Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 22nd January, 2026
+
W.P.(C) 16297/2025 & CM APPL. 66681/2025
M/S MEEVER INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED
THROUGH DIRECTOR-OPERATIONS,
MR. VENKATA SESHAVATARAM KARUMURI
14TH FLOOR, 1403-C, MANJEERA TRINITY CORPORATE
JNTU – HITECH CITY ROAD, KUKATPALLY,
HYDERABAD, TELANGANA, INDIA – 500072
.....PETITIONER
Through:
Mr. Shashi Mathews, Mr.
Abhishek Boob, Ms. Sunidhi,
Ms. Lopamudra Mahapatra,
Advocates
Versus
1.
UNION OF INDIA
THROUGH SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF STEEL
UDHYOG BHAVAN
NEW DELHI – 110107
.....RESPONDENT NO. 1
2.
BUREAU OF INDIAN STANDARDS
THROUGH DIRECTOR GENERAL
MINISTRY OF CONSUMER AFFAIRS FOOD & PUBLIC
DISTRIBUTION
MANAK BHAVAN, 9
BAHADUR SHAH ZAFAR MARG
NEW DELHI – 110002
.....RESPONDENT NO. 2
3.
PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (PORT)
KOLKATA CUSTOMS, CUSTOM HOUSE
15/1 STRAND ROAD
KOLKATA-700001
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
.....RESPONDENT NO. 3
4.
CHIEF COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS
CUSTOMS HOUSE SEA PORT
CHENNAI – 600001
.....RESPONDENT NO. 4
5.
DIRECTORATE GENERAL OF FOREIGN TRADE
THROUGH DIRECTOR GENERAL
VANIJYA BHAWAN, ‘A’ WING
16 AKBAR ROAD
NEW DELHI – 110011
.....RESPONDENT NO. 5
6.
UNION OF INDIA
THROUGH SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF FINANCE
NORTH BLOCK
NEW DELHI – 110001
.....RESPONDENT NO. 6
Through:
Mr. Siddhartha Shankar Ray,
CGSC with Mr. Debashish
Mishra (GP), Mr. Virugayala
Rakesh Reddy, Ms. Sonali
Modi, Mr. Mukul Dev,
Advocates for Respondents no.
1 and 6/Union of India
Dr.
Subhash
C.
Gupta,
Advocate for Respondent no.
2/BIS
Mr. Akash Verma, Standing
Counsel for CBIC, Mr. Teevra
Mishra, Mrs. Aanchal Uppal,
Advocates for Respondent no.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY DIGPAUL
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE, J.
1.
Heard.
2.
The petitioner, a private limited company incorporated under
the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013, is engaged in the import
of steel products.
3.
The detention of the import consignment of steel sheet piles by
the respondents no. 3 and 4, on account of rejection of the No
Objection Certificate (NOC), by respondent no. 1, the petitioner has
approached this Court with following prayers:“a.
Issue a Writ of certiorari, or a Writ in the
nature of certiorari, or any other appropriate Writ,
Order or directions, quashing the Impugned Circular,
dated 20.10.2023 (Annexure P/2, at Pg. 105); and / or
b.
Issue a Writ of certiorari, or a Writ in the
nature of certiorari, or any other appropriate Writ,
Order or directions, quashing the Impugned NOC
Rejections passed by the Respondent No. 1 (Annexure
P/1, at Pg. 98-104) on multiple occasions in respect of
the Subject Goods; and / or
c.
Issue a Writ of mandamus, or a Writ in the
nature of mandamus, or any other appropriate Writ,
Order or directions to the Respondent No. 3 and 4 to
release the Subject Goods currently under detention by
the said Respondents, at Kolkata and Chennai,
respectively, without insistence on the requirement of
an NOC / Clarification from Respondent No. 1; and /
or
d.
Issue a Writ of mandamus, or a Writ in the
nature of mandamus, or any other appropriate Writ,
Order or directions to the Respondent No. 1 to issue a
NOC / Clarification with respect to the Subject Goods
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
currently under detention by the said Respondents, at
Kolkata and Chennai, respectively; and / or
e.
Issue a Writ of mandamus, or a Writ in the
nature of mandamus, or any other appropriate Writ,
Order or directions to the Respondent No. 1 to extend
a benefit identical to the one-time NOC / Clarification,
as granted to other similarly placed importers as the
Petitioner; and / or
f.
Issue a Writ of certiorari, or a Writ in the
nature of certiorari, or any other appropriate Writ,
Order or directions, quashing the Impugned Show
Cause Notice, dated 11.09.2025 (Annexure P/44, at
Pg. 463-472), issued by the Respondent No. 3;
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of
accordingly. A copy of this Judgment be uploaded on
the website of this Court.”
4.
The respondents, in terms of order of this Court dated 28th
October, 2025, have placed on record a short affidavit in reply.
5.
On 10th January, 2026, a preliminary objection was raised by
the respondents on the maintainability of the petition on the ground:a. The petitioner has approached this Court against the show cause
notice and as such, he has right to appear before the authority
who has issued a show cause notice through a reply and get the
show cause notice adjudicated.
b. The Court at Delhi lacks territorial jurisdiction as non-release of
the petitioner’s goods has been effected by Kolkata Custom
Commissioner, who has issued them show cause notice, who is
respondent no. 3 to the present petition.
6.
Learned counsel for the respondents has specifically urged that
the petitioner–company itself is located within the jurisdiction of the
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
Telangana High Court at Hyderabad. According to him, the
respondent no. 3, who has issued the Show Cause Notice, and the
goods detained by respondents no. 3 and 4 are situated at Kolkata and
Chennai respectively, both of which are outside the territorial
jurisdiction of this Court. The counsel for respondents would further
urge that the only part of cause of action which the petitioner is
pleading for bringing the cause within the jurisdiction of this Court is
the challenge to the circular dated 20th October, 2023 issued by the
respondent no. 1, as also the rejection of NOC by respondent no. 1.
7.
According to him, the liability arising out of specific nature of
business carried out by the petitioner – company arises either within
the territory of Chennai or Kolkata, and in such an eventuality, just
because the circular was issued by the respondent no. 1, who is
situated at Delhi, will not by itself confer territorial jurisdiction.
According to him, the rejection of the NOC was through electronic
mode, and simply because the authority located at Delhi rejected the
NOC, that itself will also not confer jurisdiction upon the Court at
Delhi. The learned counsel would urge that the rejection of the NOC
is in relation to the business activity of the petitioner and the goods
which are detained at Chennai and Kolkata.
8.
Drawing support from the judgments of the Apex Court in the
matters of Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India And
Another reported in (2004) 6 SCC 254, as also, State of Goa v.
Summit Online Trade Solutions Pvt. Ltd. reported in (2023) 7 SCC
791, it is urged that the petition is liable to be dismissed for want of
territorial jurisdiction.
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
9.
As against the above, learned counsel for the petitioner would
urge that this Court has territorial jurisdiction over the issue, having
regard to the scheme of Article 226(2) of the Constitution of India
read with Section 20(c) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
(hereinafter referred to as ‘CPC’). According to him, not only the
circular was issued by the respondent no. 1 at Delhi, but also, the
decision to reject the NOC was taken at Delhi. He would seek to
connect the decision in the form of the Circular and the rejection of
NOC to the detention of the goods at Chennai and Kolkata, so as to
urge that a part of the cause of action has arisen at Delhi.
10.
As such, he would claim the petition is very much
maintainable.
11.
At the outset, we are required to have regard to the statutory
provisions viz. Article 226(2) of the Constitution of India, which reads
thus:
“226. (2) The power conferred by clause (1) to issue
directions, orders or writs to any Government, authority or
person may also be exercised by any High Court exercising
jurisdiction in relation to the territories within which the
cause of action, wholly or in part, arises for the exercise of
such power, notwithstanding that the seat of such
Government or authority or the residence of such person is
not within those territories.”
12.
Similarly, Section 20(c) of the CPC deals with the place where
the cause of action arises, which is reproduced as under:“20. Other suits to be instituted where defendants reside or
cause of action arises.—Subject to the limitations aforesaid,
every suit shall be instituted in a court within the local limits
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
of whose jurisdiction—
(a)-(b)***
(c) the cause of action, wholly or in part, arises.”
13.
Even if the CPC in stricto sensu is not applied to the
proceedings of the present petition, however, in the matter of Kusum
Ingots & Alloys Ltd. (supra), the Apex Court has made following
observations:
“9. Although in view of Section 141 of the Code of Civil
Procedure the provisions thereof would not apply to writ
proceedings, the phraseology used in Section 20(c) of the
Code of Civil Procedure and clause (2) of Article 226, being
in pari materia, the decisions of this Court rendered on
interpretation of Section 20(c) CPC shall apply to the writ
proceedings also. Before proceeding to discuss the matter
further it may be pointed out that the entire bundle of facts
pleaded need not constitute a cause of action as what is
necessary to be proved before the petitioner can obtain a
decree is the material facts. The expression material facts is
also known as integral facts.
10. Keeping in view the expressions used in clause (2) of
Article 226 of the Constitution of India, indisputably even if a
small fraction of cause of action accrues within the
jurisdiction of the Court, the Court will have jurisdiction in
the matter.”
14.
In the light of aforesaid provisions and the constitutional rights,
the issue regarding the cause of action has been tested by the Apex
Court. The following observations from the aforesaid judgment are
worth referring to, which reads thus:
“Cause of action
6. Cause of action implies a right to sue. The material facts
which are imperative for the suitor to allege and prove
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
constitute the cause of action. Cause of action is not defined
in any statute. It has, however, been judicially interpreted
inter alia to mean that every fact which would be necessary
for the plaintiff to prove, if traversed, in order to support his
right to the judgment of the Court. Negatively put, it would
mean that everything which, if not proved, gives the defendant
an immediate right to judgment, would be part of cause of
action. Its importance is beyond any doubt. For every action,
there has to be a cause of action, if not, the plaint or the writ
petition, as the case may be, shall be rejected summarily.”
15.
The Apex Court is of the view that the cause of action, in
relation to the remedy sought, depends entirely on the ground set forth
in the plaint upon which the petitioner requests the Court to decide the
issue. For the purpose of deciding the issue, whether the Court has a
territorial jurisdiction to entertain a writ petition, the Court is required
to take into account the averments made in the petition, without going
into the truth of such averments at that stage.
16.
The petitioner, to establish that the cause of action has arisen
within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court, has relied on the
challenges in the petition to:a. The circular dated 20th October, 2023 issued by the respondent
no. 1; and
b. The rejection of the prayer for issuance of an NOC.
17.
We are required to deal with the first issue as to whether a
circular issued by the respondent no. 1/Union of India at Delhi can
confer territorial jurisdiction on this Court. An identical issue came up
for consideration before the Apex Court in the matters of Nasiruddin
v. STAT [(1975) 2 SCC 671] and U.P. Rashtriya Chini Mill Adhikari
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
Parishad v. State of U.P. [(1995) 4 SCC 738], wherein the Apex
Court while dealing with the similar issue has made following
observations.
24. Learned counsel for the appellant in support of his
argument would contend that the situs of framing law or rule
would give jurisdiction to the Delhi High Court and in
support of the said contention relied upon the decisions of
this Court in Nasiruddin v. STAT [(1975) 2 SCC 671 : AIR
1976 SC 331] and U.P. Rashtriya Chini Mill Adhikari
Parishad v. State of U.P. [(1995) 4 SCC 738] So far as the
decision of this Court in Nasiruddin v. STAT [(1975) 2 SCC
671 : AIR 1976 SC 331] is concerned, it is not an authority
for the proposition that the situs of legislature of a State or
the authority in power to make subordinate legislation or
issue a notification would confer power or jurisdiction on the
High Court or a Bench of the High Court to entertain a
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution. In fact this
Court while construing the provisions of the United Provinces
High Courts (Amalgamation) Order, 1948 stated the law
thus: (SCC p. 683, para 37)
“37. The conclusion as well as the reasoning of the
High Court is incorrect. It is unsound because the
expression ‘cause of action’ in an application under
Article 226 would be as the expression is understood
and if the cause of action arose because of the
appellate order or the revisional order which came to
be passed at Lucknow then Lucknow would have
jurisdiction though the original order was passed at a
place outside the areas in Oudh. It may be that the
original order was in favour of the person applying for
a writ. In such case an adverse appellate order might
be the cause of action. The expression ‘cause of
action’ is well known. If the cause of action arises
wholly or in part at a place within the specified Oudh
areas, the Lucknow Bench will have jurisdiction. If the
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
cause of action arises wholly within the specified Oudh
areas, it is indisputable that the Lucknow Bench would
have exclusive jurisdiction in such a matter. If the
cause of action arises in part within the specified areas
in Oudh it would be open to the litigant who is the
dominus litis to have his forum conveniens. The
litigant has the right to go to a court where part of his
cause of action arises. In such cases, it is incorrect to
say that the litigant chooses any particular court. The
choice is by reason of the jurisdiction of the court
being attracted by part of cause of action arising
within the jurisdiction of the court. Similarly, if the
cause of action can be said to have arisen part within
specified areas in Oudh and part outside the specified
Oudh areas, the litigant will have the choice to
institute proceedings either at Allahabad or Lucknow.
The court will find out in each case whether the
jurisdiction of the court is rightly attracted by the
alleged cause of action.”
18.
Similarly, in para 26 of the said judgment in Kusum Ingots
(Supra), the following observations were made by the Apex Court:26. The view taken by this Court in U.P. Rashtriya Chini Mill
Adhikari Parishad [(1995) 4 SCC 738] that the situs of issue
of an order or notification by the Government would come
within the meaning of the expression “cases arising” in
clause 14 of the (Amalgamation) Order is not a correct view
of law for the reason hereafter stated and to that extent the
said decision is overruled. In fact, a legislation, it is trite, is
not confined to a statute enacted by Parliament or the
legislature of a State, which would include delegated
legislation and subordinate legislation or an executive order
made by the Union of India, State or any other statutory
authority. In a case where the field is not covered by any
statutory rule, executive instructions issued in this behalf
shall also come within the purview thereof. Situs of office of
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
Parliament, legislature of a State or authorities empowered to
make subordinate legislation would not by itself constitute
any cause of action or cases arising. In other words, framing
of a statute, statutory rule or issue of an executive order or
instruction would not confer jurisdiction upon a court only
because of the situs of the office of the maker thereof.
19.
Apart from the above, in the matter of Union of India v. Adani
Exports, the Apex Court has held that in order to confer the
jurisdiction on the High Court to entertain a writ petition, it is
necessary for the petitioner to disclose “integral facts” pleaded in
support of the cause of action to empower the Court to decide the
dispute.
20.
The issue regarding the constitutionality of Parliamentary
legislation fell for consideration and the Apex Court in the matter of
Kusum Ingots & Alloys Ltd. (supra), have passed following
observations which reads thus:“……
19. Passing of a legislation by itself in our opinion does
not confer any such right to file a writ petition unless a
cause of action arises therefor.
20. A distinction between a legislation and executive
action should be borne in mind while determining the
said question.
21. A parliamentary legislation when it receives the
assent of the President of India and is published in the
Official Gazette, unless specifically excluded, will apply
to the entire territory of India. If passing of a legislation
gives rise to a cause of action, a writ petition questioning
the constitutionality thereof can be filed in any High
Court of the country. It is not so done because a cause of
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
action will arise only when the provisions of the Act or
some of them which were implemented shall give rise to
civil or evil consequences to the petitioner. A writ court,
it is well settled, would not determine a constitutional
question in a vacuum.”
21.
In the backdrop of the aforesaid observations, the mere fact that
the circular under challenge was issued at Delhi will not, by itself,
confer territorial jurisdiction upon this Court to entertain a petition in
relation to the petitioner and the actions of the respondents no. 3 and 4
in detaining the goods at Chennai and Kolkata.
22.
The issue regarding the rejection of the NOC was related to the
business activities carried out by the petitioner either at Chennai or
Kolkata. That being so, the integral facts pleaded in the petition, in
our opinion, does not constitute a cause of action empowering the
Court at Delhi to entertain the petition.
23.
We are equally supported by the judgment of Apex Court in the
matter of State of Goa v. Summit Online Trade Solutions Pvt. Ltd.,
(supra), particularly paragraphs 18, 19, 20 and 21, which reads thus:“18. Here, tax has been levied by the Government of Goa in
respect of a business that the petitioning company is carrying
on within the territory of Goa. Such tax is payable by the
petitioning company not in respect of carrying on of any
business in the territory of Sikkim. Hence, merely because the
petitioning company has its office in Gangtok, Sikkim, the
same by itself does not form an integral part of the cause of
action authorising the petitioning company to move the High
Court. We hold so in view of the decision of this Court in
National Textile Corpn. Ltd. v. Haribox Swalram [National
Textile Corpn. Ltd. v. Haribox Swalram, (2004) 9 SCC 786] .
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
The immediate civil or evil consequence, if at all, arising
from the impugned notification is that the petitioning
company has to pay tax @ 14% to the Government of Goa.
The liability arises for the specific nature of business carried
on by the petitioning company within the territory of Goa.
The pleadings do not reflect that any adverse consequence of
the impugned notification has been felt within the jurisdiction
of the High Court. At this stage, we are not concerned with
the differential duty as envisaged in Schedule II (@ 6%) visà-vis Schedule IV (@ 14%) of the impugned notification. That
is a matter having a bearing on the merits of the litigation.
19. The long and short of the matter is that the petitioning
company has to bear the liability of paying tax @ 14% levied
by the Government of Goa for selling lottery tickets in the
State of Goa under Schedule IV of the impugned notification.
It does not bear out from the petition memo how the
impugned notification levying tax for carrying on business in
the State of Goa subjects the petitioning company to a legal
wrong within the territory of Sikkim for the writ petition to be
entertained by the High Court.
20. In our opinion, the High Court ought not to have
dismissed the applications of the appellant without
considering the petition memo which has no semblance of a
case having been made out as to how part of cause of action
arose within the territorial limits of the High Court or without
any pleading as to how any right has been affected within the
territory of Sikkim.
21. Even otherwise, the High Court was not justified in
dismissing the interim applications. Assuming that a slender
part of the cause of action did arise within the State of Sikkim,
the concept of forum conveniens ought to have been
considered by the High Court. As held by this Court in Kusum
Ingots & Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India [Kusum Ingots &
Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India, (2004) 6 SCC 254] and Ambica
Industries v. CCE [Ambica Industries v. CCE, (2007) 6 SCC
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
769] , even if a small part of the cause of action arises within
the territorial jurisdiction of a High Court, the same by itself
could not have been a determinative factor compelling the
High Court to keep the writ petitions alive against the
appellant to decide the matter qua the impugned notification,
on merit.”
24.
The Apex Court in the matter of State of Goa (supra), has held
in categorical terms that even if a small part of cause of action arises
within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Court, the same by itself,
could not have been a determinative factor compelling the High Court
to keep the writ petition alive.
25.
From the aforesaid observations, it is apparent that no sufficient
cause of action has arisen within the territorial jurisdiction of this
Court to allow and entertain the petition.
26.
That being so, the writ petition stands dismissed.
27.
Pending application stands disposed of.
28.
Copy of this judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
(JUDGE)
AJAY DIGPAUL
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 22, 2026/pr/st
Signed By:AKASH
YADAV
15:58:24
W.P.(C) 16297/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review