The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
951. Heard the learned advocates for the respective parties and perused the materials placed. Record reveals that the petitioner entered appearance in the suit for eviction and filed the written statement on August 30, 2018 and the written statement was accepted subject to payment of cost. Issues were framed on April 10, 2026 and the P.W. 1 was examined on June 3, 2026 and his cross-examination was closed on June 16, 2026. Thereafter the instant application under Order VIII Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure was filed on July 16, 2026. Mr. Mukherjee, learned senior advocate appearing for the petitioner, in course of his argument, laid special emphasis on the case made out by the petitioner as stated in paragraph of the proposed additional written statement. After going through the paragraph 2 of the proposed additional written statement this Court finds that the petitioner after narrating the incidents that took place in the last week of November, stated that the defendant-officials could find out the letter dated January 8, 2019 which was sent to the plaintiff. Mr. Mukherjee submits that for the purpose of bringing on record the foundational fact for tendering the said letter in evidence, the statements made in paragraph of the proposed additional written statement is necessary. He further submits that the said fact is necessary for the purpose of deciding the real controversies…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
D/L- 23
C.O. 3257 of 2026
22/09/2026
M/s. MCS Share Transfer Agen Ltd.
Vs.
Debabrata Gupta
Ct. No.- 6
Aritra
Mr. S.P. Mukherjee, Sr. Adv.,
Mr. Shuvajit Bose
….for the petitioner
Mr. Rajdeep Bhattacharya
Mr. Kaustav Seal
….for the opposite party
This application under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India is at the instance of the defendant and is directed
against an order dated August 12, 2026 passed by the
learned Civil Judge (Sr. Div.), 8th Court at Alipore.
By the order impugned the application under Order
VIII Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure stood rejected.
The opposite party filed a suit for eviction and mesne
profit against the petitioner herein.
After the cross-
examination of the P.W.1 was closed, petitioner filed an
application praying for leave to file an additional written
statement. The leave as sought for by the petitioner stood
rejected by the impugned order.
Being aggrieved, the defendant has approached this
Court.
Mr. Mukherjee, learned senior advocate appearing for
the petitioner submits that the petitioner sought to
incorporate the fact of issuance of a notice dated January
8, 2019 which was not readily available with the petitioner
by way of a subsequent pleading. He submits that for such
reason the leave could not be sought for prior to the
commencement of trial.
He submits that by way of
subsequent pleading the petitioner did not make any case
which may be said to be contradictory or mutually
destructive with the original written statement.
He
submits that the learned trial judge without considering
the explanation given by the petitioner in the application
praying for leave to file the subsequent pleading rejected
the same.
In support of his contention that an application under
Order VIII Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure is
maintainable in the facts of the instant case, Mr.
Mukherjee placed reliance upon a decision of the Hon’ble
Madras High Court in the case of P. Saraswathi vs. C.
Subramaniam, reported at 2013 (3) MWN (Civil) 770 and
the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Baldev Singh & Ors. vs. Manohar Singh & Anr., reported at
(2006) 6 SCC 498.
Mr. Bhattacharya, learned advocate appearing for the
opposite party submits that since the trial has commenced
the petitioner has taken the route of Order VIII Rule 9 of
the Code of Civil Procedure in order to bypass the proviso
to Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
He
submits that the case which the petitioner is now seeking
to make out by way of subsequent pleading is mutually
destructive with the case made out by the petitioner in the
application dated February 28, 2019 which stood rejected
by an order dated January 13, 2026.
In support of his contention that leave was rightly
refused, M. Bhattacharya placed reliance upon a decision
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Mondira
Ghosh vs. Chaitali Ghosh, reported at 2026 SCC Online SC
951.
Heard the learned advocates for the respective parties
and perused the materials placed.
Record reveals that the petitioner entered appearance
in the suit for eviction and filed the written statement on
August 30, 2018 and the written statement was accepted
subject to payment of cost. Issues were framed on April
10, 2026 and the P.W. 1 was examined on June 3, 2026
and his cross-examination was closed on June 16, 2026.
Thereafter the instant application under Order VIII Rule 9
of the Code of Civil Procedure was filed on July 16, 2026.
Mr. Mukherjee, learned senior advocate appearing for
the petitioner, in course of his argument, laid special
emphasis on the case made out by the petitioner as stated
in
paragraph
of
the
proposed
additional
written
statement.
After going through the paragraph 2 of the proposed
additional written statement this Court finds that the
petitioner after narrating the incidents that took place in
the
last
week
of November,
stated
that
the
defendant-officials could find out the letter dated January
8, 2019 which was sent to the plaintiff.
Mr. Mukherjee submits that for the purpose of
bringing on record the foundational fact for tendering the
said letter in evidence, the statements made in paragraph
of
the
proposed
additional
written
statement
is
necessary.
He further submits that the said fact is
necessary
for
the
purpose
of
deciding
the
real
controversies between the parties in the suit.
At this stage, it would be relevant to took note of the
fact that the petitioner filed a petition on February 28,
2019 and in paragraph 4 thereof it was stated that the
possession
of
the
tenanted
premises
are
with
the
defendant as on that date i.e. as on February 28, 2019.
The learned
trial judge
rightly noted that the
petitioner sought to take a contradictory stand by way of
filing the additional written statement to incorporate the
fact that the petitioner left the suit property on January 8,
2019.
Proviso to Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil
Procedure curtails the discretion of the Court to allow an
application for amendment after the commencement of
trial unless the party applying for amendment of pleading
satisfies the court that he was prevented by sufficient
cause
for
not
filing
the
application
prior
to
the
commencement of trial.
Mr. Mukherjee, learned senior advocate appearing for
the petitioner could not satisfy this Court as to why the
facts which the petitioner sought to incorporate by way of
additional written statement could not have been sought
to be incorporated by filing an application under Order VI
Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
To the mind of this Court the step taken by the
petitioner by filing an application under Order VIII Rule 9
of the Code is only to bypass the proviso to Order VI rule
17 of the Code of Civil Procedure as the instant application
has been filed after the evidence of P.W.1 stood closed.
At this stage, it would be relevant to take note of the
decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Mondira Ghosh (supra) wherein the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in more or less identical fact situation held that the
ploy was adopted to get over the hurdle raised by the
proviso to Order VI Rule 17 of the Code.
The Hon’ble
Supreme Court held thus:“12. Further, the very filing of such an
application by the defendant, having failed to
seek amendment of her written statement at the
appropriate stage and after the trial in the suit
had already commenced, was clearly an abuse of
process. As noted by the learned Judge himself,
this ploy was adopted to get over the hurdle
raised by the proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 CPC,
which would not have permitted the defendant to
seek amendment of her written statement.”
That apart, Order VIII Rule 9 does not confer any
absolute
right
upon
a
party
to
file
any
pleading
subsequent to the written statement. A party seeking to
file subsequent pleading has to first apply for leave of the
court except in the circumstances wherein a party is
exempted from obtaining leave of the court as specifically
stated in the Order VIII Rule 9 of the Code.
After going through the application praying for leave
to file the additional written statement this Court finds
that the only reason stated in the said application is that
during search of the documents in the Office the notice
dated January 8, 2019 could be detected.
The said explanation, to the mind of this Court,
cannot be a sufficient ground for the Court to exercise its
discretion in favour of filing the subsequent pleading after
commencement of trial.
In Baldev Singh (supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that “commencement of trial” as used in proviso to
Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure must be
understood in the limited sense as meaning the final
hearing of the suit, examination of witnesses, filing of
documents and addressing of arguments. In the fact and
circumstances of the said reported case, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court after noting that the parties were yet to file
their documents was of the view that the proviso to Order
VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure could not have
been rejected.
The said decision is not an authority for the
proposition as to whether a litigant can be allowed to
bypass the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil
Procedure in the garb of filing subsequent pleading under
Order VIII Rule 9 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
In P. Saraswathi (supra) the Hon’ble Madras High
Court held that Order VIII Rule 9 of the Code of Civil
Procedure gives a wide discretion to the court to receive
the written statement or the additional written statement
and
the
rigid
principle
applicable
in
the
case
of
amendment of plaint under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code
of Civil Procedure cannot be applied in the case of
receiving additional written statement under Order VIII
Rule 9 of the Code as there is no restriction with regard to
the
receiving
of
additional
commencement of trial.
written
statement
after
In view of the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Mondira Ghosh (supra), the
decision in
the case of P. Saraswathi (supra) cannot be
said to be a binding precedent upon this Court.
The learned trial judge assigned cogent reasons for
rejecting the application praying for leave to file the
additional written statement. For such reason this Court
is not inclined to interfere with the order impugned.
Accordingly, CO 3257 of 2026 stands dismissed.
There will be no order as to costs.
All parties shall act on the server copy of this order
duly downloaded from the official website of this Court.
(Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review