Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 04th February 2026
+
RFA(COMM) 470/2025 & CM APPL. 50484/2025
1. M/S MAPELE ENGINEERS INDIA
2. MR. BIDYUT CHATTOPADHYAY
PARTNER, M/S MAPELE ENGINEERS INDIA
BOTH AT:
306, 3rd FLOOR, PINNACLE TOWER,
A42/6, SECTOR-62, NOIDA, U.P-201301
.....APPELLANT
Through:
Mr. Rakesh Kumar, Mr. Ankit
Kumar, Mr. Aman Kumar,
Advs.
Versus
M/S REGENT ENGINEERS PVT. LTD.
SHOP NO.l, 1997, FIRST FLOOR, SONA BAZAR,
BHAGIRATH PALACE, DELHI-110006
.....RESPONDENT
Through:
Mr. Anil Kumar Hajelay and
Mr. Anant Kumar Hajelay,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY DIGPAUL
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE, J.
1.
This appeal has been filed by the original defendants under
Section 13(1) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 read with Section
96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
“CPC”).
2.
The learned Commercial Court, vide judgment dated 17th May,
2025, while appreciating the contentions of the respondent–plaintiff
qua the scheme under the provisions of Order XIII-A of the CPC,
decreed the suit.
3.
The facts necessary for deciding the present appeal are,
respondent–plaintiff who is engaged in the business of trading electrical
goods, entered into a transaction with the present appellant-original
defendant no. 1, a partnership firm, and defendant no. 2, its partner,
based on the quotation dated 24th May, 2022.
4.
The said quotation was in relation to supply of “OBO
Bettermann’ Brand material for ‘Lightening Protection System’ for one
of the plaintiff’s worksite, namely, Amrita Hospital at Faridabad.
5.
Accordingly, a Letter of Intent for material worth Rs.5,00,000/-
was sent through e-mail on 1st June, 2022 by the appellants–original
defendants to the respondent–plaintiff. Vide e-mail dated 2nd July,
2022, the appellants–original defendants instructed the respondent–
plaintiff to supply the material in different lots/batches. Pursuant to the
instructions of the appellants herein, the respondent–original plaintiff
supplied the first lot of material against Invoice No. TI-2217 dated 15th
July, 2022 at a cost of Rs.4,50,113/-, which amount was payable by
29th August, 2022, failing which interest at the rate of 18% per annum
was agreed to be paid by the appellants–original defendants. The
appellants–original
defendants
accordingly
made
payment
of
Rs.1,50,113/- till 29th August, 2022; however, failed to pay the balance
amount of Rs.3,00,000/-.
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
6.
Such default on the part of the appellants–original defendants in
making payment of Rs.3,00,000/- prompted the respondent–plaintiff to
issue a notice dated 1st June, 2024, demanding payment of the aforesaid
amount along with interest.
7.
The mediation taken recourse to, since failed, the suit came to be
initiated for recovering a sum of Rs.4,26,101/-, which includes
principal amount of Rs.3,00,000/-; Rs.1,15,101/- towards interest from
29th August, 2022 till 15th October, 2022 and Rs.11,000/- as fee for
Legal Notice. Pendente lite interest was sought to be recovered @ 18%
per annum from the date of filing of the suit till its realization.
8.
The suit was contested by the appellants–original defendants by
filing a written statement, wherein the defence set up was that the
material supplied by the respondent–plaintiff was not as per the agreed
terms and suffered from quality issues. It was further contended that the
supply of material was delayed by the respondent–plaintiff, which
caused financial loss to the appellants–original defendants, and
consequently.
9.
On merits, it is urged that the claim of the respondent-plaintiff
was denied in its entirety.
10.
The respective parties including that of the plaintiff filed
documents which are in the form of exchange of communication viz.
communication dated 30th March, 2024 sent by the appellants to the
respondent, wherein a request for grant of additional time for
arrangement of payment was made. The defence that was set up by the
appellants was based on three issues- (a) the material that was supplied
was defective; (b) there was delay in supplying the material and (c) the
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
requisite consideration towards the material supplied was paid.
11.
Based on the aforesaid documents which are in the form of e-
mails, the respondent-plaintiff initiated proceedings under Order XIIIA Rule 1 of the CPC for drawing summary judgment.
12.
The said application was based on the dues being not disputed by
the respondent to the extent of one claimed in the suit.
13.
The said claim, made by way of an application, was disputed by
the present appellants–original defendants by filing a reply. It was
contended therein that the following documents, pertaining to the
exchange of communications between the parties, were either admitted
or that the contents thereof were not admitted, viz.:
Sl.No.
E-mail dated
Sent by
Admitted/Contents
not
mail
not
admitted.
1.
Mail
dated ------------
Admitted
12.05.2022
2.
Mail
24.05.2022
3.
Mail
01.06.2022
4.
Mail
02.07.2022
dated Respondent to Mail received but
Appellant
dated Appellant
contents denied
to Admitted
Respondent
dated Appellant
to Admitted
Respondent
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
5.
Mail
30.03.2024
14.
dated Appellant
Respondent
to Contents of mail not
admitted.
Based on the aforesaid, the learned Commercial Court proceeded
to evaluate the claim of the present appellants. The learned Commercial
Court noted that the claim was denied by the appellants mainly on three
counts, as referred to hereinabove. The learned Commercial Court
further observed that once it is admitted that an e-mail was issued on
30th March, 2024 by the present appellants, the question of denying its
contents does not arise, particularly as the appellants themselves claim
that the entire payment towards the supply of material has been made.
15.
The appellants have failed to demonstrate any payment made by
them, but for the payment received by the respondent–plaintiff as
disclosed in the plaint.
16.
Apart from the above, the contention of the appellants that the
material was defective and was supplied at a belated stage are
concerned, there is not an iota of evidence brought on record through
the reply filed by the appellants to demonstrate that at the appropriate
stage, they had lodged any protest on the basis of such conduct.
17.
That being so, the learned Commercial Court proceeded to pass
the summary judgment exercising summary powers under Order XIIIA Rule 6 of CPC and as such, the present appeal.
18.
Amongst others, the contentions are that the appellants should
have been given opportunity of proving their claim that the liability was
not admitted by him pursuant to the alleged e-mail dated 30th March,
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
2024 by framing the issues and permitting it to adduce evidence. His
further contentions are that there exists another transaction in relation
to which the contents of e-mail dated 30th March, 2024 can be referred
to and as such, same can be explained only by adducing evidence.
19.
As such, it is claimed by learned counsel for the appellants that
the very requirement for exercising powers for delivering summary
judgment as contemplated under Order XIII-A Rule 1 of CPC is not
made out and that being so, the appeal needs to be allowed.
20.
We have heard the contentions.
21.
The issue sought to be canvassed is required to be dealt with
under the scheme of Order XIII-A of the CPC, which deals with the
summary judgment. The procedure prescribed under the said Order is
specifically framed for deciding suits without recording evidence.
22.
One of the objects is to have the decisions in a commercial suits
decided expeditiously, which otherwise is prescribed under the aims
and objects of the Commercial Court Act, 2015.
23.
The procedure provided under the aforesaid Order XIII-A for
summary judgment may be invoked at the instance of either the plaintiff
or the defendant, however, such recourse has to be taken thereunder
after the summons have been served on the defendant or before the
issues in respect of the suit claim are framed.
24.
Under Rule 3 of Order XIII-A, it is open to the Court to deliver
a summary judgment against the plaintiff or the defendant on a claim,
if the plaintiff has no real prospect of succeeding in the claim or the
defendant has no real prospect of successfully defending the claim.
25.
The Court can also deliver the summary judgment if there are
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
compelling reasons as to why the claim should not be disposed of
without recording the evidence.
26.
The application for summary judgment which is to be moved in
accordance with the procedure under Sub-rule 1 of Rule 4 of the Order
XIII-A contemplates that such application must contain or satisfy the
requirement under the clause (a) to (f) thereunder.
27.
Before deciding the application for summary judgment, it is
mandatory for the learned Commercial Court to grant opportunity of
hearing to the other side and the time to grant such opportunity
including that of reply to the application is prescribed to be 30 days’
notice.
28.
The other side to the application for summary judgment is
required to disclose its contents to the application in addressing the
points set out in clause (a) to (f) of Sub-rule 3 of Rule 4 of Order XIIIA.
29.
The said Order further empowers the Court to pass a conditional
order or decide the application in terms of the Rule 6 of Order XIII-A.
30.
Under the provisions of Order VI Rule 1 of the CPC, “pleadings”
are defined to mean a plaint or a written statement. Further, under Rule
2 of Order VI material facts are required to be pleaded and not the
evidence.
31.
A plaint, which is required to contain pleadings, shall contain the
particulars as provided under Order VII Rule 1.
32.
Order VIII of the CPC deals with written statements. Rule 3A
thereof was incorporated and brought into effect from 23rd October
2015, which reads as under:
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
“[3A. Denial by the defendant in suits before the Commercial
Division of the High Court or the Commercial Court.— (1)
Denial shall be in the manner provided in sub-rules (2), (3),
(4) and (5) of this Rule.
(2) The defendant in his written statement shall state which of
the allegations in the particulars of plaint he denies, which
allegations he is unable to admit or deny, but which he
requires the plaintiff to prove, and which allegations he
admits.
(3) Where the defendant denies an allegation of fact in a plaint,
he must state his reasons for doing so and if he intends to put
forward a different version of events from that given by the
plaintiff, he must state his own version.
(4) If the defendant disputes the jurisdiction of the Court he
must state the reasons for doing so, and if he is able, give his
own statement as to which Court ought to have jurisdiction.
(5) If the defendant disputes the plaintiff’s valuation of the suit,
he must state his reasons for doing so, and if he is able, give
his own statement of the value of the suit.]”
33.
The aforesaid Rule provides that the denial of a claim by the
defendant in a suit before the Commercial Court should be in
accordance therewith. Sub-rule (1) of Rule 3A contemplates the denial
to be in the manner provided under sub-rules (2), (3), (4), and (5) of this
Rule.
34.
Sub-rule (2) of Rule 3A provides that the defendant, in the
written statement, is required to state which of the allegations in the
particulars of the plaint he denies and which he is unable to deny or
admit. He is equally required to state which of the allegations he wants
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
the plaintiff to prove and which allegations he admits.
35.
Sub-rule (3) of Rule 3A provides for the conduct of the defendant
in cases where he denies the allegations of fact in the plaint. In such
circumstances, he is required to state his reasons for doing so and he is
equally required to state his different version, if any, of the events from
that pleaded by the plaintiff. He is required to mention his own version.
36.
Order XI prescribes the procedure for disclosure, discovery, and
inspection of documents in suits before the Commercial Division of the
High Court or a learned Commercial Court.
37.
Rule 4 thereunder provides for admission or denial of
documents. Rule 4 reads thus:“4. Admission and denial of documents. — (1) Each party
shall submit a statement of admissions or denials of all
documents disclosed and of which inspection has been
completed, within fifteen days of the completion of
inspection or any later date as fixed by the Court.
(2) The statement of admissions and denials shall set out
explicitly, whether such party was admitting or denying:—
(a) correctness of contents of a document; (b) existence of
a document;
(c) execution of a document;
(d) issuance or receipt of a document;
(e) custody of a document.
Explanation.––A statement of admission or denial of the
existence of a document made in accordance
with sub-rule (2) (b) shall include the admission or denial
of the contents of a document.
(3) Each party shall set out reasons for denying a document
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
under any of the above grounds and bare and unsupported
denials shall not be deemed to be denials of a document and
proof of such documents may then be dispensed with at the
discretion of the Court.
(4) Any party may however submit bare denials for third
party documents of which the party denying does not have
any personal knowledge of, and to which the party denying
is not a party to in any manner whatsoever.
(5) An Affidavit in support of the statement of admissions
and denials shall be filed confirming the correctness of the
contents of the statement.
(6) In the event that the Court holds that any party has
unduly refused to admit a document under any of the above
criteria, – costs (including exemplary costs) for deciding on
admissibility of a document may be imposed by the Court
on such party.
(7) The Court may pass orders with respect to admitted
documents including for waiver of further proof thereon or
rejection of any documents.”
38.
A perusal of sub-rule (3) of Rule 4 of Order XI further makes it
clear that the said Rule specifically casts a duty upon the parties, like
the defendant, to set out reasons for denying the documents on any of
the grounds mentioned therein.
39.
If we consider the case of the appellants-defendants, we must
have regard to the nature of the pleadings in the written statement of
the appellants.
40.
In the written statement of the appellants, paragraph 3 of the
preliminary submissions and paragraphs 5, 8, and 10 of the para-wise
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
reply read as under:
“3. It is submitted that the Defendant had approached to
the Plaintiff to supply the material of “OBO Bettermann”
brand for “Lightening Protection System” for the site
Amrita Hospital, Faridabad. It is worth noting here that the
defendant has placed the order in absolute good faith but
materials were not supplied as per the agreed terms as
having quality issues further the supplied of the said
materials was delayed which have caused immense
financial loss to the Defendant company. Thus the
Defendant Company is entitled to receive damage from the
Plaintiff account of loss suffered due to supply of inferior
company on quality and delay in the supply of the material.
Parawise Reply:
5. It is denied that material was supplied against Invoice
No.TI- 2217 dated 15.07.2022 for Rs.4,50,113/- and as per
the terms, the Plaintiff was entitled to receive interest @
18% per annum from the Defendant. It is submitted that the
Plaintiff raised the said invoice unilaterally and supplied
the materials which were not in consonance with the terms
of the Purchase Order. Moreover, the said materials were
defective.
8. It is not admitted that the Defendants have received the
legal notice, therefore, no question arise for giving the
reply to the said legal notice. However, it is submitted that
the said notice may be received by the Gate Keeper/Guard
but not communicated to the Defendants.
10. It is denied that the Defendants have been illegally and
unauthorizedly
retaining
the
aforesaid
outstanding
principal amount of Rs.3,00,000/- of the Plaintiff and as per
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
the terms and conditions mentioned on the invoice, the
Defendants are liable to pay interest @ 18% per annum
from due date of payment. It is further denied that a sum of
Rs.1,15,101/- is due on account of interest from 29.08.2022
till 15.10.2024 and a sum of Rs.11,000/- is due as fees for
service of legal notice. It is further denied that a sum of
Rs.4,26,101/- is due against the Defendants at the time of
filing of the suit. It is submitted that the Defendants are not
liable to pay any amount to the Plaintiff”
41.
From the aforesaid pleadings, if evaluated in the light of the
provisions of Order VIII referred to above, particularly Rule 3A, it can
be easily inferred that the written statement of the defendant lacks the
very basic pleadings mandated under Rule 3A of Order VIII.
42.
Not only the denial in the written statement is not in accordance
with sub-rules (2), (3), (4), and (5) of the said Rule, but such denial is
also non-specific, vague, and general in nature.
43.
Under sub-rule (2) of Rule 3A, the defendant, in his written
statement, has failed to mention as to which of the allegations in the
particulars of the plaint he denies, which allegations he is unable to
admit or deny, which allegations he requires the plaintiff to prove, and
which allegations he admits.
44.
Under sub-rule (3) of Rule 3A, the appellants were required to
state, in respect of the allegations generally denied by them, their
reasons for doing so and his version of events as different from that of
given by the plaintiff.
45.
A perusal of the written statement would reveal that a vague
statement is made by the appellants about material, that the same were
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
not supplied as per agreed terms as it had quality issues and same was
supplied at a delayed stage, which has resulted in financial loss.
46.
As mandated under sub-rules (2) and (3) of Rule 3A of Order
VIII, the appellants/original defendants have not stated which
allegations of fact in the plaint they deny and their reasons for denying
so, or their version of events, if any, different from that of the plaintiff.
47.
A similar stand appears to be taken even in the reply preferred
by the appellants to the application for summary judgment. In the said
reply, appellants appear to have relied on contents of written statement
by referring to the same.
48.
It is borne out from the record that before the issues were framed,
the respective parties had completed their pleadings. As regards the
documentary evidence, the case of the respondent–plaintiff is based on
communications in the form of e-mails, the orders issued which led to
the supply of material by the plaintiff and the acknowledgment.
49.
The said reply is carefully perused in the light of the respective
pleading in the plaint, written statement and an application moved
under Rule 4(1) of Order XIII-A by the respondent-plaintiff. Not only
the reply to the summary judgment does not discloses the material fact
but also the appellants have failed to furnish the reasons as to why the
relief sought by the plaintiff should not be granted.
50.
But for denying entire claim and conveniently disputing the
contents of mail dated 30th March, 2024, there is no reason set out by
the appellants based on either pleadings or documentary evidence to
infer that the suit is required to be decided only after recording the
evidence i.e., complete trial.
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
51.
We have already hereinbefore referred to Rule 4 of Order 11.
52.
As far as the e-mails are concerned, from the chart of documents
reproduced in paragraph 13, which is in response to the mandate under
Order XI Rule 4 regarding admission and denial of documents, we have
already noticed that existence of document is not disputed, however,
what is disputed is contents therein.
53.
It was expected of the appellants not only to explain such denial
but also to put forth their case in the written statement so also in the
reply to the application for summary judgment. It is worth to mention
here that, it is upon oral assessment of the pleadings of the rival parties,
it is for the Court to dispense with the proof of the document.
54.
The appellants have failed to conduct themselves in accordance
with the provisions of Order VIII Rule 3A as well as Order XI Rule 4.
In such an eventuality, the Commercial Court cannot be inferred to have
conducted itself contrary to the aforesaid provisions in the matter of
decreeing the suit.
55.
In the aforesaid background, what is required to be appreciated
is a summary judgment can be delivered, in case, it is noticed that the
appellants–defendants have no real prospect of successfully defending
the claim put forth by the plaintiff–respondent.
56.
The fact remains that the only explanation coming forward
during the course of hearing of present appeal from the appellants is the
aforesaid mail or the mail dated 30th March, 2024 was in relation to
some different transactions.
57.
When confronted the appellants are unable to demonstrate from
the record as to which other transaction the appellants had with the
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
defendant.
58.
Apart from above, the appellants at no point of time has
contested the claim or raised an objection or protest qua the quality or
delayed supplies allegedly made by the respondent.
59.
In such an eventuality, the learned Commercial Court, in our
opinion, was justified in proceedings against the appellants to infer that
the appellants-defendants have no real prospect of successfully
defending the claim. Such opinion has been formed by the learned
Commercial Court, having regard to the replies submitted by the
appellants under sub-Rule (3) of Rule 4 of Order XIII-A.
60.
These Two e-mails are to be appreciated in the facts of the case
viz. the e-mails dated 30th March, 2024 and 2nd July, 2022.
61.
The aforesaid e-mails categorically disclose that the appellants
acknowledged the receipt of the material and their liability to make
payment to the plaintiff. The only defence raised by the appellants of
the aforesaid two e-mails is that the first e-mail dated 2nd July, 2022 is
admitted, including its contents, whereas the contents of the e-mail
dated 30th March, 2024 are not admitted, however, receipt of said mail
was not disputed.
62.
If we consider both these mails, there is a reason to believe that
the appellants cannot, in real terms, dispute the contents of the said email, having accepted that such e-mail was issued and is in the
possession of both the parties to the suit. The contents of these mails
can be inferred to be establishing the case of the plaintiff, if are read
and appreciated in the light of other documents and rival pleadings.
63.
Though the appellants-defendants in the reply to the application
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
for summary judgment have pleaded that the contents of the material
can be proved through recording of evidence, however, if the pleadings
of the plaintiff, the pleadings in the written statement, the contents of
the emails referred above and that of plea raised in the application for
summary judgment and reply thereto, sufficiently establishes and as
rightly so inferred by the learned Commercial Court, that the
appellants-defendants had no prospect of successfully defending the
claim.
64.
In such an eventuality, we see no reason to cause interference in
appellate jurisdiction, as no infirmity could be noticed with the
judgment under challenge delivered by the Commercial Court. Rather
we are satisfied that the judgment delivered by the Commercial Court
is in tune with the provisions of the Order XIII-A of the CPC.
65.
That being so, the appeal sans merit and is, accordingly,
dismissed.
66.
Pending application also stands disposed of.
67.
Copy of the Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
(JUDGE)
AJAY DIGPAUL
(JUDGE)
FEBRUARY 4, 2026/ay/sky/sk
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
17:45:26
RFA (COMM) 470/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review