Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
!"#" $%
'() '
& &
*
&&& ++,"! $ -#.
/
*
) )
*'
&&&
'%
0 * ' &
!
%
$
)
)
"
#+ $ $ -#.
)
#
&&&&
)
)
1 & - 2 ,.
'
''
"
'(()
*
,
.
/
.
.
2 .
"
"
+#
(3'3
-
"
(333
)4'3 )4/3
"
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
(3/3
"
.
"
))23
#
.
"
.
"
(3''
,
/3 3( /3/2
'6#
,
.
.
.
.
5 .
-
-
.
.
.
.
"
*
-
.
+
''
"
"
(3'3 .
"
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
#
.
"
"
.
.
"
+
"
' /' 3 3 .
"
.
"
"
))'3
))'3
.
"
. ,
.
.
.
.
.
"
(3/3
.
:
)
.
.
'
9 "
' /' 3 3 "
(3'3
"
(3/3
;
1.1 The following documents shall constitute the contract
documents, namely:
a) This contract:
b) Tender documents as defined in the General
Instructions to tenderers:
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
c) Letter of Acceptance No.
1.2 A copy of each of the Tender Documents is annexed
hereto and the said copies have been collectively marked
Annexure&A while a copy of the Letter of Acceptance of
Tender along with annexures thereto are annexed hereto &
copies have been collectively marked as Annexure&B
xxx&xxx&xxx&xxx
4.1 Notwithstanding any other court or courts having
jurisdiction to decide the question(s) forming the subject&
matter of the reference if the same had been the subject
matter of a suit, any and all actions and proceeding arising
out of or relative to the contract (including any arbitration in
terms thereof) shall be only in the Court of Competent Civil
Jurisdiction in this behalf at Panipat. (Where this contract
has been signed on behalf of the Owner) and only the said
Court(s) shall have jurisdiction to entertain and try any such
action(s) and/or proceeding(s) to the exclusion of all other
Courts.
xxx&xxx&xxx&xxx
“Notified Claim” shall mean a claim of the
CONTRACTOR notified in accordance with the provisions of
Clause 6.6.1.0 hereof.
xxx&xxx&xxx&xxx
Subject to the provisions of Clauses 6.7.1.0.
6.7.2.0 and 9.0.2.0 hereof, any dispute arising out of a
Notified Claim of the CONTRACTOR included in the Final
Bill of the CONTRACTOR in accordance with the provisions
of Clause 6.6.3.0 hereof, and any dispute arising out of any
claim(s) of the OWNER against the CONTRACTOR shall be
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
referred to the arbitration of a Sole Arbitrator selected in
accordance with the provisions of Clause 9.0.1.1 hereof. It is
specifically agreed that the OWNER may prefer its claim(s)
against the CONTRACTOR as counter&claim(s) If a Notified
Claim of the CONTRACTOR has been referred to arbitration.
The CONTRACTOR shall not, however, be entitled to raise as
a set&off defence or counter&claim any claim which is not a
Notified Claim included in the CONTRACTOR's Final Bill in
accordance with the provisions of Clause 6.6.3.0 hereof.”
xxx&xxx&xxx&xxx
Any dispute(s) or difference(s) with respect to or
concerning or relating to any of the following matters are
hereby specifically excluded from the scope, purview and
ambit of the Arbitration Agreement embodied in Clause
9.0.1.0 with the intention that any dispute or difference with
respect to any of the said following matters and/or relating to
the Arbitrator's or Arbitral Tribunal's jurisdiction with respect
thereto shall not and cannot form the subject matter of any
reference or submission to arbitration under Clause 9.0.1.0,
and the Arbitrator or the Arbitral Tribunal shall have no
jurisdiction to entertain the same or to render any
decision with respect thereto, and such matter shall be
referred to the General Manager for decision by the
General Manager or his nominee and shall be decided by the
General Manager or his nominee, as the case may be
(whose decision shall be final and binding on the OWNER
and the CONTRACTOR) prior to the Arbitrator appointed
under Clause 9.0.1.0 proceeding with or proceeding further
with the reference, as the case may be. The said excluded
matters are:
(i) With respect to or concerning the scope or existence or
otherwise of the Arbitration Agreement;
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
(ii) Whether or not a Claim sought to be referred to
arbitration by the CONTRACTOR under Clause 9.0.1.0 is a
Notified Claim;
(iii) Whether or not a Notified Claim is included in the
CONTRACTOR's Final Bill in accordance with the
provisions of Clause 6.6.3.0 hereof.
.
.
.
-
.
.
"
.
<
"
(3/3
.
5 .
<
.
#$ #!
5 +
% & '&#()(
"
% & *+
!
,
.
5 .
"
.
5 +
1# (2 $
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
"
"
- .& &#!"
()#! /&
" &
*.
<
%$! 0
% & '&#()(
-
!
"
#$ #!
5 +
(
% & 4( /!(& + )$#!, .
"
8 .
()#! /&
5 +
"
%$! 0
% & 4( /!(& +()$#!,
"
&#$"!0 5& 6&&
5 +
#5 #!
.
!
/"!
/*
!
- .& &#!"
-
#5 #!
!%$ / *
3#&&%& ( )
&#
*
,
&* +
''
.
.
"
prima facie 1
.
"
''
prima facie 1
5 +
"
- .& &#!"
()#! /&
%$! 0
% & 7( /!(&
+ )$#!,
“110. The scope of examination under Section 11(6&A) is
confined to the existence of an arbitration agreement on the
basis of Section 7. The examination of validity of the
arbitration agreement is also limited to the requirement of
formal validity such as the requirement that the agreement
should be in writing.
111. The use of the term ‘examination’ under Section 11(6&A)
as distinguished from the use of the term ‘rule’ under Section
16 implies that the scope of enquiry under section 11(6&A) is
limited to a prima facie scrutiny of the existence of the
arbitration agreement, and does not include a contested or
laborious enquiry, which is left for the arbitral tribunal to
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
‘rule’ under Section 16. The prima facie view on existence of
the arbitration agreement taken by the referral court does
not bind either the arbitral tribunal or the court enforcing
the arbitral award.
112. The aforesaid approach serves a two&fold purpose –
firstly, it allows the referral court to weed out nonexistent
arbitration agreements, and secondly, it protects the
jurisdictional competence of the arbitral tribunal to rule on
the issue of existence of the arbitration agreement in depth.
113. Referring to the Statement of Objects and Reasons of
the Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015, it
was observed in In Re: Interplay (supra) that the High Court
and the Supreme Court at the stage of appointment of
arbitrator shall examine the existence of a prima facie
arbitration agreement and not any other issues. The relevant
observations are extracted hereinbelow:
“209. The above extract indicates that the Supreme
Court or High Court at the stage of the appointment
of an arbitrator shall “examine the existence of a
prima facie arbitration agreement and not other
issues”. These other issues not only pertain to the
validity of the arbitration agreement, but also include
any other issues which are a consequence of
unnecessary judicial interference in the arbitration
proceedings. Accordingly, the “other issues” also
include
examination
and
impounding
of
an
unstamped instrument by the referral court at the
Section 8 or Section 11 stage. The process of
examination, impounding, and dealing with an
unstamped instrument under the Stamp Act is not a
timebound process, and therefore does not align with
the stated goal of the Arbitration Act to ensure
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
expeditious
and
time&bound
appointment
of
arbitrators.[…]
(Emphasis supplied)
114. In view of the observations made by this Court in In Re:
Interplay (supra), it is clear that the scope of enquiry at the
stage of appointment of arbitrator is limited to the scrutiny
of prima facie existence of the arbitration agreement, and
nothing else. For this reason, we find it difficult to hold that
the observations made in Vidya Drolia (supra) and adopted
in NTPC v. SPML (supra) that the jurisdiction of the referral
court when dealing with the issue of “accord and
satisfaction” under Section 11 extends to weeding out ex&
facie non&arbitrable and frivolous disputes would continue
to apply despite the subsequent decision in In Re: Interplay
(supra).
115. The dispute pertaining to the “accord and satisfaction”
of claims is not one which attacks or questions the existence
of the arbitration agreement in any way. As held by us in the
preceding parts of this judgment, the arbitration agreement,
being separate and independent from the underlying
substantive contract in which it is contained, continues to
remain in existence even after the original contract stands
discharged by “accord and satisfaction”
116. The question of “accord and satisfaction”, being a
mixed question of law and fact, comes within the exclusive
jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal, if not otherwise agreed
upon between the parties. Thus, the negative effect of
competence&competence would require that the matter
falling within the exclusive domain of the arbitral tribunal,
should not be looked into by the referral court, even for a
prima facie determination, before the arbitral tribunal first
has had the opportunity of looking into it.”
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
'3
-
5 =
3#&&%& ( )
*
&#
"
#5 #!
&#$"!0 5& 6&&
!
/"!
/*
!
#5 #!
!%$
/*
& !(& + )$#!,
“120. In view of the above discussion, we formulate our
conclusions
on
this
aspect.
First,
the
separability
presumption contained in Section 16 is applicable not only
for the purpose of determining the jurisdiction of the
Arbitral Tribunal. It encapsulates the general rule on the
substantive independence of an arbitration agreement.
Second, parties to an arbitration agreement mutually intend
to confer jurisdiction on the arbitral tribunal to determine
questions as to jurisdiction as well as substantive
contractual disputes between them. The separability
presumption gives effect to this by ensuring the validity of an
arbitration agreement contained in an underlying contract,
notwithstanding the invalidity, illegality, or termination of
such contract. Third, when the parties append their
signatures
to
a
contract
containing an
arbitration
agreement, they are regarded in effect as independently
appending their signatures to the arbitration agreement. The
reason is that the parties intend to treat an arbitration
agreement contained in an underlying contract as distinct
from the other terms of the contract; and Fourth, the validity
of an arbitration agreement, in the face of the invalidity of
the underlying contract, allows the Arbitral Tribunal to
assume jurisdiction and decide on its own jurisdiction by
determining the existence and validity of the arbitration
agreement. In the process, the separability presumption
gives effect to the doctrine of competence&competence.
xxx&xxx&xxx&xxx
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
165. The legislature confined the scope of reference under
Section 11(6&A) to the examination of the existence of an
arbitration agreement. The use of the term "examination" in
itself connotes that the scope of the power is limited to a
prima facie determination. Since the Arbitration Act is a
self&contained code, the requirement of "existence" of an
arbitration agreement draws effect from section 7 of the
Arbitration Act. In Duro Felguera (supra), this Court held
that the referral courts only need to consider one aspect to
determine the existence of an arbitration agreement &
whether the underlying contract contains an arbitration
agreement which provides for arbitration pertaining to the
disputes which have arisen between the parties to the
agreement. Therefore, the scope of examination under
Section 11(6&A) should be confined to the existence of an
arbitration agreement on the basis of Section 7. Similarly,
the validity of an arbitration agreement, in view of Section 7,
should be restricted to the requirement of formal validity
such as the requirement that the agreement be in writing.
This interpretation also gives true effect to the doctrine of
competence&competence by leaving the issue of substantive
existence and validity of an arbitration agreement to be
decided by arbitral tribunal under Section 16. We
accordingly clarify the position of law laid down in Vidya
Drolia (supra) in the context of Section 8 and section 11of
the Arbitration Act.
166. The burden of proving the existence of arbitration
agreement generally lies on the party seeking to rely on such
agreement. In jurisdictions such as India, which accept the
doctrine of competence&competence, only prima facie proof
of the existence of an arbitration agreement must be
adduced
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
before the referral court. The referral court is not
the appropriate forum to conduct a minitrial by allowing the
parties to adduce the evidence in regard to the existence or
validity of an arbitration agreement. The determination of
the existence and validity of an arbitration agreement on the
basis of evidence ought to be left to the arbitral tribunal.
This position of law can also be gauged from the plain
language of the statute.”
''
$
5 +
#/2 &/ )#& '&#()( #/
"
8#!( #)/ )#& !
.
88 /& 8 #
&#' /&(
*
" &# ! '&
" &
.
''
-
The short question that falls for our consideration
is whether while exercising power under Section 11 of the
1996 Act, the Court has to confine its consideration as to the
existence of an arbitration agreement between the parties. If
so, whether it would be permissible, while exercising
jurisdiction under Section 11, to hold that some of the claims
raised are non&arbitrable or fall within excepted category.
Sub§ion (6A) of Section 11, which was inserted by Act
3 of 2016, with effect from 23.10.2015, makes it clear that
while considering an application under sub§ion (4) or
sub§ion (5) or sub§ion (6), the Supreme Court or
the High Court, as the case may be, shall, notwithstanding
any judgment, decree or order of any Court, confine to
the examination of the existence of an arbitration
agreement.
Act 33 of 2019 omitted sub§ion (6A) but the
amending Act has not been notified thus far. In consequence,
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
sub§ion (6A) of Section 11 of the 1996 Act remains in the
statute book.
The statement of objects and reasons of the 2015
amendment with reference to insertion of sub§ion (6A) in
Section 11 of the 1996 Act, reads thus:
“(iii) an application for appointment of an
Arbitrator shall be disposed of by the High
Court or the Supreme Court, as the case may
be, as expeditiously as possible and an
endeavour should be made to dispose of the
matter within a period of 60 days.
(iv) to provide that while considering any
application for appointment of Arbitrator, the
High Court or the Supreme Court shall examine
the existence of a prima facie arbitration
agreement and not other issues.”
The significance of the use of the expression “not
other issues” in the statement of objects and reasons of the
2015 amendment was noticed by a seven&Judge bench of this
Court in In Re: Interplay Between Arbitration Agreements
under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and the
Indian Stamp Act, 18995, and it was observed:
“209. The above extract indicates that the
Supreme Court or High Court at the stage of the
appointment of an Arbitrator shall ‘examine the
existence of prima facie arbitration agreement
and not other issues’. These other issues not
only pertain to the validity of the arbitration
agreement, but also include any other issues
which are a consequence of unnecessary
judicial
interference
proceedings.”
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
in
the
arbitration
Relying on the above observations made by this
Court in In Re: Interplay (supra), a three&judge bench of
this Court in “SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Krish
Spinning” observed:&
“114. ….that 2& (/ $& 8 & 9) #0 ! 2& ( !3&
8 !$$
(/#)
%&
#5 #! # ( " % &
8 $# %! 8!/ & &: ( & /&
!#5 #!
!3#&&%& * !
2&
2&
2 3 &"(& For
this reason, we find it difficult to hold that the
observations made in ‘Vidya Drolia v. Durga
Trading Corporation (supra) and adopted in
‘NTPC v. SPML Infra Limited (supra) that the
jurisdiction
of
the
referral
court
when
dealing with the issue of “accord and
satisfaction” under section 11 extends to
weeding
out
ex&facie
non&arbitrable
and
frivolous disputes would continue to apply
despite the subsequent decision in In Re:
Interplay (supra)”.
%$2!( ( )$$" &
As the above decision has been rendered by a
three&Judge bench of this Court after considering the seven&
Judge bench decision of this Court in In Re: Interplay
(supra), we are of the view that the respondent cannot profit
from certain observations made by a two&Judge bench of this
Court in Emaar (supra). In our view, therefore, the High
Court fell in error in bisecting the claim of the appellant into
two parts, one arbitrable and the other not arbitrable, when
it found arbitration agreement to be there for settlement of
disputes between the parties. The correct course for the
High Court was to leave it open to the party to raise the
issue of non&arbitrability of certain claims before the
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
arbitral tribunal, which, if raised, could be considered and
decided by it.”
'/
-
.
.
.
prima facie 1
-
.
"
.
.
prima facie
.
,
sine qua non
''
"
.
.
5 +
+()$#!,
/"!
"
- .& &#!"
&#$"!0 5& 6&&
/*
!
()#! /&
#5 #!
%$! 0
3#&&%& ( )
!%$ / *
*
.
% & 7( /!(&
&# #5 #!
& +()$#!,
!
88 /& 8 #
" &# ! '& #/2 &/ )#&7( /!(& + )$#!,
'2
"
.
#$ #!
!
&&$ 1)%!# '&#()(
!
*
.
. .
<
.
"
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
-
"
'9
"
<
.
>
A
#
-
"
2) @
"
?
>
$ -
? :3: @ ,
A
(6')43333/
((C
8B
-
.
'/
':
.
.
.
')
'4
A
.
A
'6
<
/(
'(
<
$ -
.
>
>
"
-
)
)
& &
$ 6 782
D
D
CHETAN THAKUR
2026.03.24 14:28
I attest to the accuracy and
authenticity of this order/judgment.
,
E
F E?
F E?
.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review