The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. A perusal of the material on record goes to show that, admittedly the petitioner participated in the E-Auction conducted on 23.12.2024 and deposited Earnest Money Deposit amounts of Rs.12,00,000/- for Ramagiri Site and Rs.16,00,000/- for Kadavakallu Site. The petitioner was declared as the highest bidder for Lot No.2 on 24.12.2024, and the same was confirmed by 2nd respondent on 25.12.2024 by accepting the bid amount of Rs.1,51,02,601/-. However, subsequently, by an email dated
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010601222024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3327]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY,THE NINTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K SREENIVASA REDDY
WRIT PETITION NO.31340 OF 2024
Between:
...PETITIONER
M/s. Mahadeva Enterprises
AND
The Union of India and others
...RESPONDENTS
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. CKR ASSOCIATES
Counsel for the Respondents:
1. VENNA HEMANTH KUMAR (CENTRAL GOVERNMENT
COUNSEL)
2. P ROY REDDY
The Court made the following ORDER:
The present Writ Petition has been filed seeking the
following relief.
“……to issue a Writ, Order or direction more particularly one
in the nature of WRIT Of MANDAMUS declaring the action of
2nd respondent herein in rejecting the petitioner's bid for the EAuction sale of SCRAP WIND ELECTRIC GENERATORS
(WEGs) at KADAVAKALLU (16 NOS X 250 KW = 4 MW) i.e.
SRK, J
WP No.31340 of 2024
LOT 2, issued vide Tender E-Auction No.81943, dated
16.12.2024, vide Ref.ST:DPS :eauction .07/2024-25 after
declaring the petitioner
herein as HI-Highest Bidder on
25.12.2024, without assigning
any reasons thereto, without
issuing any notice to the petitioner
herein calling for
explanation, without considering the petitioner's representation
dated 27.12.2024 and the subsequent action of 2nd respondent
herein in re-conducting the E-Auction sale of same material i.e.
SCRAP
WIND
ELECTRIC
GENERATORS
(WEGs)
at
KADAVAKALLU (16 NOS X 250 KW = 4 MW) i.e. Lot 2 vide
Tender E-Auction No.81944, scheduled to be conducted on
30.12.2024, as arbitrary, illegal, irrational, colourable exercise
of
power, besides being unconstitutional and consequently
set-aside
the E-Auction sale of same material i.e. SCRAP
WIND ELECTRIC GENERATORS (WEGs) at KADAVAKALLU
(16 NOS X 250 KW = 4 MW) i.e. Lot 2 issued vide Tender EAuction
No.81944 by directing the respondents herein to
declare the petitioner herein as highest bidder for the sale of
SCRAP WIND
ELECTRIC GENERATORS (WEGs) at
KADAVAKALLU (16 NOS X 250 KW = 4 MW) i.e. LOT 2.”
2.
Petitioner firm is doing the business of buying and selling
scrap and other materials and inter alia engaged in various civil
contractual works.
2nd respondent – BHEL (Bharat Heavy
Electricals Limited), Boiler Auxiliaries Plant (BAP) issued
E-Auction Tender Notice No.81943, dated 16.12.2024, vide
Ref:ST:DPS:e-auction:07/2024-25, for sale of scrap material i.e.,
Scrap Wind Electric Generators (WEGs) at Ramagiri (12 Nos X
250 KW = 3 MW) and Scrap Wind Electric Generators (WEGs) at
Kadavakallu (16 Nos X 250 KW = 4 MW).
The auction was
SRK, J
WP No.31340 of 2024
scheduled to be conducted on 23.12.2024. Petitioner participated
in the E-Auction held on 23.12.2024 and submitted its bid after
depositing an amount of Rs.12.00 lakhs for Ramagiri site and
Rs.16.00 Lakhs for Kadavakallu site respectively, as per the
terms and conditions of the E-Auction Notice. Petitioner became
H1-Highest bidder on 24.12.2024 only for “Scrap Wind Electric
Generators (WEGs) at Kadavakallu (16 Nos X 250 KW = 4 MW)”
i.e. Lot 2, and the same was confirmed by 2nd respondent on
25.12.2024 by accepting the bid amount of Rs.1,51,02,601/quoted by the petitioner firm. The petitioner’s bid for Lot 1 i.e.
Scrap Wind Electric Generators (WEGs) at Ramagiri (12 Nos. X
250 KW = 3 MW), was not accepted.
3.
While so, the petitioner firm received an e-mail from the E-
Auction Conductor/Admin of C1 India Private Limited i.e. 3rd
respondent herein, on behalf of 2nd respondent through a mail
ID:noreply1@c1india.com on 27.12.2024 informing that 2nd
respondent rejected the bid of the petitioner for Lot 2 i.e. Scrap
Wind Electric Generators (WEGs) at Kadavakallu (16 Nos X 250
KW = 4 MW).
Immediately, the petitioner firm submitted a
representation dated 27.12.2024 requesting 2nd respondent to
accept its bid informing that they are ready to comply with the
terms and conditions of the e-auction notice.
But, without
considering the said representation and without assigning any
reasons or affording an opportunity of hearing to the petitioner,
2nd respondent rejected the bid of the petitioner and issued fresh
Tender
Notice,
vide
E-Auction
Notice
No.81944,
dated
27.12.2024, for sale of Lot 2 i.e. Scrap Wind Electric Generators
SRK, J
WP No.31340 of 2024
(WEGs) at Kadavakallu (16 Nos X 250 KW = 4 MW) and the said
auction was scheduled to be conducted on 30.12.2024. Hence,
the petitioner is constrained to file the present Writ Petition.
4.
This Court, on 31.12.2024, while ordering notice before
admission in the Writ Petition, passed the following interim order
in IA No.1 of 2024.
“Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and
learned counsel for the respondents.
For the reasons mentioned in the accompanying
affidavit and considering the submissions made by both
the learned counsel, there shall be an interim stay of EAuction Sale of material i.e., Scrap Wind Electric
Generators (WEGs) at Kadavakallu (16 Nos. x
250KW=4MW) i.e., Lot 2 issued by the 2nd respondent
vide Tender E-Auction No.81944, if not conducted on
30.12.2024.”
5.
Counter affidavit has been filed on behalf of 2nd respondent
– BHEL along with vacate stay petition in IA No.1 of 2025, inter
alia, stating that on 31.12.2024 this Court passed stay order only
if E-Auction No.81944
was not held on the previous day i.e.,
30.12.2024. It is stated that the auction was, in fact, held on
30.12.2024 and the petitioner participated in the said auction held
on 30.12.2024. However, by concealing the fact of participating
in the auction held on 30.12.2024, petitioner obtained stay order
on 31.12.2024 by misrepresentation and concealment of material
facts.
It is stated that in compliance of the stay order, 2nd
respondent exercised abundant caution and has not put the
SRK, J
WP No.31340 of 2024
Scrap Wind Electric Generators (WEGs) at Kadavakallu (16 Nos.
x 250KW=4MW) i.e. Lot 2, for auction. It is further stated that the
scrap material of wind electric generators are erected in the open
ground and subjected to speedy deterioration of its value due to
wear and tear and there have been constant attempts for theft of
the material and 2nd respondent already lost material worth of
Rs.20.00 lakhs due to theft of material from the site.
2nd
respondent is also incurring loss towards engagement of security
personnel at site. Hence, he prays to vacate the order of stay
granted by this Court.
6.
Petitioner filed reply affidavit denying the averments made
in the counter and stating that subsequent to filing of Writ Petition,
petitioner visited the site at Kadavakallu in October, 2025 to
ascertain the existing condition of 16 Nos. Scrap Wind Electric
Generators (WEGs).
During inspection, petitioner noticed a
substantial shortage of material when compared with the
description
contained
in
the
tender
schedule.
Several
components of WEGs were found missing, damaged, dismantled
or otherwise untraceable. The site was found to be without any
proper security arrangement, fencing or surveillance, leaving the
material
exposed
to pilferage
and
deterioration
and
2nd
respondent appears to have failed to take adequate steps to
safeguard the material.
The said circumstances cast serious
doubt on the correctness of the quantity and condition of the
materials presently available at site, thereby rendering any
proposed re-auction prejudicial and contrary to public interest.
SRK, J
WP No.31340 of 2024
7.
Heard. Perused the material on record.
8.
A perusal of the material on record goes to show that,
admittedly the petitioner participated in the E-Auction conducted
on 23.12.2024 and deposited Earnest Money Deposit amounts of
Rs.12,00,000/-
for
Ramagiri
Site
and
Rs.16,00,000/-
for
Kadavakallu Site. The petitioner was declared as the highest
bidder for Lot No.2 on 24.12.2024, and the same was confirmed
by 2nd respondent on 25.12.2024 by accepting the bid amount of
Rs.1,51,02,601/-. However, subsequently, by an email dated
27.12.2024, the petitioner was informed that its bid for Lot No.2
was rejected.
9.
It is the case of the petitioner that such rejection was made
without assigning any reasons and without affording an
opportunity of hearing, despite submission of a representation on
the same day expressing readiness to comply with all terms and
conditions. Thereafter, 2nd respondent issued a fresh E-Auction
Notice dated 27.12.2024 scheduling a re-auction on 30.12.2024.
10.
A counter affidavit has been filed by 2nd respondent
contending that the petitioner participated in the subsequent
auction held on 30.12.2024 and suppressed the said fact while
obtaining an interim order from this Court on 31.12.2024. It is
stated that the interim order was conditional and not applicable,
as the auction had already been conducted.
SRK, J
WP No.31340 of 2024
11.
Having considered the submissions made on either side
and upon perusal of the material on record, this Court is of the
view that the dispute pertains to the fairness and transparency in
the tender process. While the petitioner questions the rejection of
its earlier successful bid, it is also an admitted position that
subsequent events have taken place, including conduct of
another auction.
12.
In the interest of justice, equity, and to ensure a fair and
transparent process, this Court deems it appropriate not to
adjudicate on the merits of the earlier rejection, but instead
deems it fit to direct a fresh process so as to provide equal
opportunity to all eligible participants, including the petitioner.
13.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is disposed of, with a direction
to the respondents to conduct fresh E-Auction for the sale of
“Scrap Wind Electric Generators (WEGs) at Kadavakallu (16 Nos.
x 250 KW = 4 MW)” strictly in accordance with law, ensuring
transparency and fairness in the process, and by affording equal
opportunity to all eligible bidders, including the petitioner. It is
open for the petitioner to participate in the auction. There shall be
no order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, the miscellaneous petitions, if any,
pending in this Writ Petition shall stand closed.
________________________
K. SREENIVASA REDDY, J.
Date:09.02.2026
Nsr
SRK, J
WP No.31340 of 2024
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE K. SREENIVASA REDDY
Writ Petition No.31340 of 2024
Date:09.02.2026
Nsr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review