Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT HYDERABAD
MONDAY , THE TWENTY THIRD DAY OF SEPTEMBER
TWO THOUSAND AND THIRTEEN
:PRESENT:
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE P. NAVEEN RAO
WP .NO:27385, 27882, 28092 of 2009, 28652 of 2011 and 125 of 2012
WP .NO:27385 of 2009
Between:
1 M/s.Laxmi S.T. Mining and Leasing labour Contractor Cooperative
Society
Limited, having its office at D.No.2/150-92, Taraka Rama
nagar,Chemmumiyapet, Kadapa Mandal, and District, represented by
its
President Mr.V.Jayaram
2 Mr.B. Gangaiah S/o.Sri Gangulaiah, R/o.Taraka Rama Nagar,
Chemmumiyapet, Kadapa Mandal and District
3 Mr.V.Krishnaiah S/o.Sri Changaiah, R/o.Taraka Rama Nagar,
Chemmumiyapet, Kadapa Mandal
..... Petitioners
AND
1 The Divisional Forest officer, Kothagudem Khammam District
2 The Assistant Director, Mines and Geology, Kothagudem Khammam
District
3 The Mandal Revenue officer, Garla Mandal Khammam District
.....Respondents
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying
that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed herein,the High Court
may be pleased to grant an order, direction or writ, more so in the nature of
writ of mandmaus declaring the impugned proceedings of the first
respondent bearing No.4202/2009/A5(i) dated 30.11.2009 as illegal,
arbitrary, highhanded and violative of Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution of
India and consequently set aside the same and further direct the first
respondent not to interfere with the mining activity of the first petitioner
society under the lease granted to it, over the land of about 55 acres of land
in survey No.57 and 58 of Pocharam village, Garla Mandal, Khammam
District.
The petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the
Petition and the affidavit filed herein and upon hearing the arguments of SRI
B. Naryana. Reddy Advocate for the Petitioner, GP for Forest for
Respondent No.1, GP for Mines & Geology for Respondent No.2 and of
GP for Revenue for Respondent No.3.
WP .NO: 27882 of 2009
Between:
M/s. Viswabharathi Mining Corporation Garla, Garla PO and Mandal,
Khammam District, A.P. Rep. by its Managing Partner Mr. S.V. Shiva
Reddy
S/o. Shanker Reddy, 42 yrs
..... Petitioner
AND
1 The Government of Andhra Pradesh Forest Department, Secretariat,
Hyderabad Rep. by its Secretary
2 The Government of Andhra Pradesh Revenue Department, Secretariat,
Hyderabad, Rep. by its Secretary
3 The District Collector Khammam District.
4 The Divisional Forest Officer Kothagudem, Khammam District.
5 The Assistant Director of Mines and Geology Kothagudem,
Khammam District.
6 The Assistant Director, Survey and Land Records Khammam District.
7 The Tahsildar, Garla Mandal, Khammam District.
.....Respondents
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying
that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed herein, the High Court
may be pleased to issue a writ order or direction more particularly one in
the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring order of the 4th respondent dt. 3011-2009 in Rc No. 3916/2009/A6 restraining the Petitioner from conducting
mining operations over an extent of 123.076 Hectares in Sy.No. 76 of
Seripuram Village, Garla Mandal, Khammam District despite the petitioner
holding the lease under lease deed dt. 12-5-2009 executed by the 5th
respondent to conduct mining of barytes mineral for a period of 20 years as
arbitrary illegal, unjust violative of principles of natural justice violative of the
Fundamental Rights guaranteed to the petitioner under Articles 14,19 and
21 of the Constitution of India and consequently set aside the same and
direct the respondents to permit the petitioner to conduct mining operations
and transport the barites.
The petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the
Petition and the affidavit filed herein and upon hearing the arguments of SRI
N. MOHAN KRISHNA, Advocate for the Petitioner, GP for Forest for
Respondent No.1 & 4 GP for Revenue for Respondent No.2,3,6,7 and of
GP for Mines & Geology for Respondent No.5.
WP .NO: 28092 of 2009
Between:
1. M/s. The Pocharam Tribal Mining Cooperative Society Limited Having its
office at Kotya Naik Thanda Village, Pocharam (post), Garla Mandal,
Khammam District, represented by its Chairman Mr. Bhukya Badru.
2. Bhukya Kishan, S/o. Bhukya Venkataiah, R/o. Ho. 5-70, Kotya Naik
Thanda
Village, Pocharam (post), Garla Mandal, Khammam District.
3. Jatotu Kotya, S/o. Jajotu Dasru, R/o. Ho. 5-88/1, Kotya Naik Thanda
Village,
Pocharam (post), Garla Mandal, Khammam District.
..... Petitioners
AND
1 The Divisional Forest Officer Kothagudem,Khammam Dist
2 The Assistant Director Mine& Gelogy Kothagudem,Khammam Dist
3 The Mandal Revenue Officer Garla(M), Khammam Dist
.....Respondents
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying
that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed herein, the High Court
may be pleased to grant an order, direction or writ, more so in the nature of
writ of mandamus, declaring the impugned proceedings of the first
respondent bearing No.4203/2009/A5 (ii) dated 30.11.2009 as illegal,
arbitrary, highhanded and violative of Article 14 and 21 of the Constitution of
India and consequently set aside the same and further direct the first
respondent not to interfere with the mining activity of the first petitioner
society under the lease granted to it, over the land of about 55 acre of land
in Survey No.57 and 58 of Pocharam Village, Garla Mandal, Khammam
District.
The petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the
Petition and the affidavit filed in support thereof and upon hearing the
arguments of SRI B. NARAYANA REDDY, Advocate for the Petitioners,
GP for Forest for Respondent No.1, GP for Mines and Geology for
Respondent No.2 and of GP for Revenue for Respondent No.3. .
WP .NO: 28652 of 2011
Between:
M/s. Sri Kanaka Durga Tribal Labour Contract Mutually Aided Co-operative
Society, (Regd.No. AMC/KMM/DCO/687/2007) Garla Village and Mandal,
Khammam District, rep. by its President & Authorized Signatory Paltya
Moni
..... Petitioners
AND
1 The Government of Andhra Pradesh, Forest Department, rep. by its
Secretary, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2 The Government of Andhra Pradesh, Revenue Department, rep. by its
Secretary, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
3 The District Collector, Khammam District.
4 The Conservator of Forests / Divisional Forest Officer, Kothagudem,
Khammam District.
5 The Assistant Director of Mines & Geology, Kothagudem, Khammam
District.
6 The Assistant Director, Survey & Land Records,
Khammam
7 The Tahsildar, Garla Mandal, Khammam District.
.....Respondents
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying
that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed herein, the High Court
may be pleased to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in
the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the 4th respondent
and his subordinates in interfering with the leasehold rights of the petitioner
and further passing order dated 27.05.2011 in Rc.No.4205/2009/A5,
directing the petitioner not to conduct mining activity at Sy.No.58,
admeasuring Ac.102.00 of Pocharam Village, Garla Mandal, Khammam
District and treating the said land as forest land, as arbitrary, illegal, unjust,
violative of principles of natural justice, violative of the Fundamental Rights
guaranteed to the petitioner under Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution
of India and consequently set aside the same and direct the respondents to
permit the petitioner to conduct mining operations and transport the barytes
and dolomites as per the lease deed dated 11.01.2010.
The petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the
Petition and the affidavit filed herein and upon hearing the arguments of SRI
C.V. R. RUDRA PRASAD, Advocate for the Petitioner, GP for Forest for
Respondent Nos.1 & 4, GP for Revenue for Respondent Nos.3,6,7and of
GP for Mines & Geology for Respondent No.5, the Court made the
following.
WP .NO: 125 of 2012
Between:
M/s. Indian Barytes & Chemical Ltd Rep by its Director, S.V. Shiva Reddy,
S/o. Shanker Reddy, Regd Office at 3/433, Rajareddy Street, Kadapa
R/o. Villa No. 23, Aditya Fortueiew, Puppalguda, Hyderabad 89
..... Petitioner
AND
1 The Government of Andhra Pradesh Rep by its Secretary, Forest
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad
2 The Government of Andhra Pradesh Rep by its Secretary, Revenue
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
3 The District Collector, Khammam District
4 The Divisional Forest Officer, Kothagudem, Khammam District
5 The Assistant Director of Mines and Geology, Kothagudem, Khammam
District
6 The Assistant Director, Survey and Land Records, Khammam
7 The Tahsildar, Garla Mandal, Khammam District
.....Respondents
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying
that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed herein, the High Court
may be pleased to issue an appropriate writ order or direction more
particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring the action of
the 4th respondent in restraining the petitioner from conducting mining
activities in an extent of 121.41 hectares in Sy.No. 76/1 situate at Siripuram
Village, Garla Mandal, Khammam District despite the lease granted by the
Government of Andhra Pradesh as arbitrary, illegal, violative of principles of
natural justice, discriminatory, violative of Fundamentl Rights guaranteed to
the petitioner under Article 14 and 19 of the Constitution of India and
consequently direct the respondents to permit the petitioner to conduct
mining operations in the area leased out to the petitioner and not to interfere
with its lawful business.
The petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the
Petition and the affidavit filed herein and upon hearing the arguments of SRI
C.V.R. RUDRA PRASAD, Advocate for the Petitioner, GP for Forest for
Respondent Nos.1 & 4, GP for Revenue for Respondent Nos.2, 3, 6 & 7
and of GP for Mines for Respondent Nos.5 and the Court made the
following.
ORDER:
These writ petitions are instituted by the petitioners,
aggrieved by separate notices issued on different dates by the
4th respondent-Divisional Forest Officer, Kothagudem, restraining
the petitioners from conducting mining operations, on the ground
that the land in which the mining operations were taken up by the
petitioners is a protected forest area known as Garla Reserve
Forest in Khammam District.
All the petitioners were granted
lease at various points of time to undertake mining of barites
mineral. In so far as the petitioner in W.P.No.27882 of 2009,
originally the lease was granted by the Government of Andhra
Pradesh vide G.O.Ms.No.15, dated 03.01.1962, in the name of
one Sri G.Rama Rao and in the year 1965 the same was
transferred in the name of the petitioner and the lease was
extended from time to time.
The petitioners seriously dispute the stand of the Forest
Department that the area, which was granted to them for
conducting mining operations, is a reserved forest area. The
petitioners placed reliance on internal correspondence within the
Government in support of their contention that the area in which
they are undertaking mining is not a reserved forest area.
By order dated 19.03.2010 & 08.04.2010, this Court issued
directions to undertake survey operations, but no proper survey
was conducted and the dispute remained unresolved.
The then Nizam Government issued Gazette Notification
No.218 dated 17.08.1951, notifying the area in question as
protected forest area.
The notification only prescribed the
boundaries. Referring to the said notification, the learned Senior
Counsel for the petitioners submits that it is necessary to identify
the forest land by referring to the boundaries mentioned in the
said notification and then identify whether the area where mining
operations are conducted is within the protected forest area
covered by the said notification and such exercise can be done
effectively only by Survey of India.
In pursuance to earlier debate on the issue, learned
Additional Advocate General requested the Government to offer
its view on conducting survey of forest land by Survey of India.
The learned Additional Advocate General produced letter
addressed by the Prl. Chief Conservator of Forests (Head of
Forest
Force),
Government
of
Andhra
Pradesh,
bearing
R.C.No.14075/2010-F2, dated 22.07.2013, agreeing in principle to
conduct survey by Survey of India for demarcation of boundaries
in Garla reserved forest.
I am of the view that conducting of proper survey is
necessary for identifying the area covered by the notification
dated 17.08.1951 which would ensure protection of reserve forest
and avoidance of future controversy instead of leaving to the
whims of local officers of various departments of Government
and for proper adjudication in all these writ petitions.
Therefore, a direction is issued to Survey of India to
undertake survey of the Garla reserve forest area in accordance
with the boundaries specified in notification No.218 of 17.08.1951
to identify the area covered by the said notification with particular
reference to the area where mining operations are undertaken by
the petitioners in Seripuram Village, Khammam District. The Prl.
Chief Conservator of Forests shall coordinate with the Survey of
India for undertaking the said survey on behalf of the State
Government. The petitioners and Government of A.P. shall bear
the expenditure for undertaking the said survey operations in
equal proportion.
The Prl.Chief Conservator of Forests shall
immediately nominate one of the senior IFS officers to coordinate with Survey of India and petitioners and participate in
survey operations. Similarly, petitioners shall also nominate a
person who shall co-ordinate with Government Official nominated
and the Survey of India officials.
The Prl. Chief Conservator of
Forests shall make available all relevant documents and record
to Survey of India. Survey of India shall undertake the survey
with the modern equipment as available to identify the exact area
of reserved forest as per the said notification with particular
reference to the area where mining operations are undertaken by
the petitioners. This exercise shall be completed and report be
filed in this Court within three months from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order.
The Officer nominated by the Prl. Chief Conservator of
Forests shall estimate costs of such survey in consultation with
the Director, Survey of India, Hyderabad, and intimate the same
to the petitioners.
On receipt of such information, petitioners
shall deposit their contribution within a week thereof.
The Survey of India shall inform the representatives of the
petitioners as well as the Prl.Chief Conservator of Forests the
date/dates when survey operations are proposed to be taken up
and the survey shall be conducted in their presence.
The Registry shall communicate a copy of this order to the
Director, Survey of India, Ramanthapur, Hyderabad.
Post all the Writ Petitions on 30.12.2013.
Sd/- P.V.K. SATYANARAYANA
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
For ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
To
1. The Directior, Survey of India, Ramanthapur, Hyderabad (Special
Messenger)
2 The Divisional Forest officer, Kothagudem Khammam District
3 The Assistant Director, Mines and Geology, Kothagudem Khammam
District
4 The Mandal Revenue officer, Garla Mandal Khammam District
5 The Secretary, Forest Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh
Secretariat, Hyderabad.
6 The Secretary, Revenue Department, Government of Andhra Pradesh,
Secretariat, Hyderabad.
7 The District Collector Khammam District.
9. The Principal Chief Conservator of Forest, State if A.P., Hyderabad.
10 The Tahsildar, Garla Mandal Khammam District.
11 The Assistant Director, Survey and Land Records Khammam District.
12 The Conservator of Forests / Divisional Forest Officer, Kothagudem,
Khammam District.
13. The Director, Survey of India, Ramanthapur, Hyderabad
(1 to 9 by RPAD)
14. Two CC to GP for Revenue, High Court of A.P., Hyderabad (OUT)
15. Two CC to GP for Forest, High Court of A.P>, Hyderabad (OUT)
16. Two CC to GP for Mines & Geology, High Court of A.P>, Hyderabad
(OUT)
17. One CC to SRI V.R. REDDY KOVVURI, Advocate (OPUC)
18 One CC to SRI N. MOHAN KRISHNA, Advocate (OPUC)
19. One CC to SRI B. NARAYANA REDDY, Advocate (OPUC)
20. One CC to SRI C.V.R. RUDRA PRASAD, Advocate (OPUC)
21. One CC to Sri R. Raghunandan, Advocate (OPUC
22 One spare copy.
Note: Para =7 of the order dated 23-9-2013 in WP Nos.27385, 27382,
28092 of 2009, 28652 of 2011 and 125 of 2012 is corrected as per the
order of the Court dated 4-2-2014 made in WPMP No.38870 of 2013 in
WP No.27882 of 2009 and WP No.46763 of 2013 in WP No.27385 of
2009, substitute this amended order in place of the previous order
which was already dispatched on 1.10.2013.
Sd/- K. BHASKARA RAO
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
HIGH COURT
PNRJ
ORDER
DATED: 23-09-2013
AMENDED ORDER DATED 4-02-2014
WP .NO:27385, 27882, 28092 of 2009,
28652 of 2011 and 125 of 2012
POST ALL THE WRIT PETITIONS ON 30-12-2013
DRAFTED: TVR
DATED: 27-09-2013
HIGH COURT
PNRJ
ORDER
DATED: 23-09-2013
WP .NO:27385, 27882, 28092 of 2009,
28652 of 2011 and 125 of 2012
POST ALL THE WRIT PETITIONS ON 30-12-2013
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review