Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT TAX No. - 4103 of 2026
M/S Laxmi Narayan Gupta
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
State Of U.P And 3 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s)
Counsel for Respondent(s)
:
:
Nishant Mishra, Prerna Surolia
C.S.C.
Court No. - 39
HON'BLE SAUMITRA DAYAL SINGH, J.
HON'BLE SWARUPAMA CHATURVEDI, J.
1. Heard Sri Nishant Mishra, learned counsel for the petitioner, Sri Ankur
Agarwal, learned Senior Standing Counsel for the revenue and perused
the record.
2. The present writ petition has been filed to challenge the order dated
30.06.2026 passed by respondent no.2 under Section 74 of the SGST Act,
2017 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') read with Section 8 of the Goods
and Services Tax (Compensation to States) Act, 2017 for F.Y. 2021-22.
3. Present is the second leg of litigation. Petitioner has challenged the
Adjudication Order dated 30.06.2026 passed in compliance to the order
dated 02.04.2026 passed by this Court in M/s Laxmi Narayan Gupta vs.
State of U.P. and 2 others, 2026:AHC:70540-DB. At that stage,
violation of Section 75(7) of the Act was alleged with respect to the first
set of Adjudication Orders dated 26.12.2025. The writ petition was
disposed of with the following observations:
"7. The present writ petition is accordingly disposed of on the following terms :
(i) The impugned adjudication orders dated 26.12.2025 and 05.01.2026 are set aside.
(ii) The petitioner may file its final reply to the show-cause notice dated 05.08.2025 within
a period of two weeks from today.
(iii) If the petitioner wants to claim an opportunity to cross-examine any witness or to be
supplied documents relied upon etc., the petitioner may necessarily make such application
alongwith reply. Such application, if filed may be dealt with and decided before fixing any
date for final hearing.
WTAX No. 4103 of 2026
(iv) Thereafter, the adjudicating authority may fix and communicate the petitioner the date
for personal hearing with at lease 15 days advance notice.
(iv) The adjudicating authority may then pass appropriate reasoned order within a further
period of one month such that the proceedings may be concluded on or before
30.06.2026."
4. Thereafter, on 10.04.2026 respondent No.4 issued a fresh show cause
notice to the petitioner rectifying the error noticed in the first leg of
litigation. The petitioner responded to the same vide reply dated
17.04.2026 and prayed for cross-examination of the two panch witnesses
as also the officer of the SIB, who had conducted the search. On
08.05.2026, respondent No.4 issued intimation to the petitioner to crossexamine all the witnesses, as prayed. On 15.05.2026, the two panch
witnesses were cross-examined. According to the petitioner, they denied
filling up of the panchnama details in their presence. It has also been
suggested that the said witnesses indicated that they had signed on blank
papers. Thereafter, on 29.05.2026, the SIB report was first furnished to
the petitioner. It disclosed that respondent No.4 was himself involved in
the conduct of search. Therefore, on the request of the petitioner, the
proceedings were transferred to respondent No.2 vide order dated
12.06.2026 passed by the Additional Commissioner.
5. Consequently, respondent No.2 issued reminder notice on 16.06.2026.
On 19.06.2026, the petitioner moved another application seeking crossexamination of respondent Nos.3 and 4. Without passing any order on
that application, the final Adjudication Order has been passed on
30.06.2026 containing observations that respondent Nos.3 and 4 have
been granted immunity under Section 157 of the UPGST Act, 2017.
Therefore, they were not cross-examined.
6. Submission is, the order of the Court dated 02.04.2026 has yet not been
complied. The proceedings suffer from violation of essential requirements
of natural justice, being cross-examination of respondent Nos.3 and 4,
wrongly denied.
7. Second and more materially, it has been submitted that the panch
witnesses have clearly denied the preparation of the panchnama in their
WTAX No. 4103 of 2026
presence. Therefore, the contents of the panchnama have not been
proven. Unless respondent Nos.3 and 4 had been produced for crossexamination, the adjudicating authority could not have relied on the
panchnama. To that extent, the reasoning of the adjudicating authority
denying opportunity to the petitioner to cross-examine respondent Nos.3
and 4, is wholly unsustainable in law.
8. To the extent, such defects exist, it has been further submitted, no
useful purpose may be served in relegating the petitioner to the forum of
alternative remedy as the proceedings suffer from incurable defect.
9. On the other hand, learned Senior Standing Counsel would submit, to
the extent, it was necessary, cross-examination has been allowed. The
panch witnesses have not specifically or consistently denied preparation
of the panchnama in their presence. Referring to the extract of the
statement at page Nos.81 and 82 of the writ petition, it has been submitted
that Sri Shivam Sahu first stated that he signed a blank document. He then
stated that he did not remember if the paper that he signed had already
been written upon or not. Only thereafter, to another question, if the paper
that he signed was blank or written upon, he stated, it was blank.
Similarly, Sri Naresh Kumar, the other panch witness specifically stated,
on being called upon, he reached the place where the panchnama was
being prepared. It clearly indicated that the panchnama was prepared in
the presence of the panch witnesses.
10. Seen in that light, it has been further submitted, the cross-examination
of respondent Nos.3 and 4, who had performed official duties was not
required. Even if the reasoning given by the adjudicating authority may
not be sustainable as no statutory immunity to such officers, to be crossexamined, yet, it is not the mandate of law that all officers performing
official duties must necessarily be cross-examined to establish the
contents of the documents. Referring to paragraph No.8 of the writ
petition, it has been submitted that the preparation of the panchnama is
duly admitted to the petitioner even, at this stage. For ready reference,
contents of paragraph No.8 of the writ petition are quoted below:
"8. That the petitioner categorically submits that the partner of the firm Smt. Nidhi Gupta
and her son Shri Abhimanyu Gupta, who were present during the course of search
WTAX No. 4103 of 2026
proceedings, were asked to sign the Panchnama and other documents, which were then
signed by them without readingthe contents. Thus, the petitioner was not aware of the fact
that panchnama records recovery of sheets loose of papers and diaries/register/notebook
from the premises of the petitioner and also that the same was seized vide seizure order
dated 01.03.2024, as copies of both the documents was not provided to the petitioner."
11. In such circumstances, it has been strenuously urged by learned
Senior Standing Counsel that adequate remedy of appeal is available to
the petitioner. All issues being pressed and all other issues involving
merits may be tested in such proceedings.
12. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having perused the
record, while learned counsel for the petitioner may be right in his
submission that mere production of a document may not lead to its proof,
and to that extent, he has placed reliance on a decision of the Supreme
Court in Bareilly Electricity Supply Co. Ltd. vs. Workmen and others,
(1971) 2 SCC 617, that alone may not be enough to decide the present
issue, in the limited context, whether the writ remedy, would be the most
appropriate remedy available to the petitioner?
13. The defect as noticed in the first leg of proceedings, being violation of
Section 75(7) of the Act, no longer exists. As to the further direction
issued to pass a fresh order after making available to the petitioner all
documents being relied against and after making available due
opportunity of cross-examination, it is noted that insofar as copies of
documents are concerned, those have been made available to him. The
narration of dates made above clearly indicates that the authorities have
acted in a manner, which may appear to indicate that efforts have been
made to comply with the order. As to the exact compliance, opportunity
to cross-examine the two panch witnesses has been granted. What
conclusions may be drawn on the strength of these statements made,
including the cross-examination statements, on the basis of those
statements may involve a merit evaluation. That is possible to be done in
the appeal proceedings, as well.
14. At present, for the foregoing reasons, we are consciously not making
any observation with respect to the conclusions that may have been drawn
WTAX No. 4103 of 2026
on the strength of the cross-examination statement of the two panch
witnesses. We leave that issue open, at this stage. As to the crossexamination of the two revenue officers, it is undisputed to the petitioner
that the cross-examination of those officers has been sought only for
reason of preparation of the panchnama. By way of document, the
panchnama is seen to exist. Not only its copy has been handed over to the
petitioner, but both panch witnesses may have stated that they have
affixed their signatures on certain documents that came to be described as
the panchnama. Whether such document had been filled up or had not
been filled up or prepared before the panch witnesses signed the
document is not to be commented, at this stage.
15. While we accept the contention of learned counsel for the petitioner,
that the reasoning offered by the adjudicating authority to decline
opportunity of cross-examination of respondent Nos.3 and 4 is
unsustainable, at the same time, it cannot be said by way of a corollarytherefore, that opportunity must necessarily have been granted by the
adjudicating authority. Which witness is to be cross-examined, is an issue
to be dealt with by the adjudicating authority on its own facts in each
case.
16. However, as we have already observed that denial of such opportunity
for a wrong reason may not lead to the opposite conclusion that such
opportunity must necessarily have been granted, we are also mindful that
the petitioner is not remediless in that regard. In the appeal proceedings
that may be instituted against the adjudication order, it may remain with
the petitioner to raise that issue. If considered proper, the appeal authority
may itself allow for cross-examination of the witnesses of the respondent
Nos.3 and 4 or call for appropriate report from the adjudicating authority
on that count after providing for necessary measures regarding crossexamination.
17. Further submission that the prayer for cross-examination had been
earlier granted by respondent No.4 but later that has been denied, may
also not be seen as right that had already vested in the petitioner,
inasmuch as that would remain an interlocutory order, that may have been
subject to further proceedings.
WTAX No. 4103 of 2026
18. Thus, without making any observation either on the merits and/or on
the requirement of cross-examination of respondent Nos.3 and 4, but
leaving that issue completely open to be canvassed by the petitioner on its
own strength, before the appeal authority, we dispose of the present writ
petition with the observation, subject to the petitioner filing an appeal
within a period of four weeks from today, the same may be entertained
and decided on its own merits without raising any objection as to
limitation.
(Swarupama Chaturvedi,J.) (Saumitra Dayal Singh,J.)
October 8, 2026
Anurag/-
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review