Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.17267 of 2025
Reserved on:17.09.2026
Date of Decision: 29.09.2026
Date of uploading: 30.09.2026
_______________________________________________________
M/s K.M. Distillery Pvt. Ltd.
…….Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors.
… Respondents
_______________________________________________________
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1 Yes.
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Arvind Sharma, Senior Advocate with
Ms. Kiran Sharma and Mr. Digvijay Singh
Thakur, Advocates.
For the Respondents: Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General with Mr.
Rajan Kahol, Mr. Vishal Panwar, Additional
Advocates General with Mr. Ravi Chauhan &
Mr. Anish Banshtu, Deputy Advocates
General.
____________________________________________________
Sandeep Sharma, Judge:
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with order dated
14.07.2025
passed
by
the
Financial
Commissioner
(Excise),
Himachal Pradesh (Annexure P-10), in exercise of powers under
Section 29 of the Himachal Pradesh Excise Act, 2011 (hereinafter
referred to as the 'Act'), for alleged breach of Sections 29(b) and (c)
of the Act, whereby BWH-2, L-13C, L-15 and L-16 licences issued in
1Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
favour of the petitioner came to be cancelled, petitioner, which is a
company registered in the name and style of M/s K.M. Distillery
Private Limited, having its manufacturing unit at Plot No. 25, Sector-5,
Parwanoo, District Solan, has approached this Court in the instant
proceedings filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
praying therein for the following reliefs:
“a. That a writ in the nature of mandamus may very kindly be issued
thereby quashing and setting aside order dated 14.07.2025
(Annexure P-8).
b. That a writ in the nature of mandamus may very kindly be issued
thereby directing respondents to renew the licence in Form BWH-2
of the petitioner for the year 2025-26 and also restore L-13C, L-15
and L-16 licences of the petitioner.”
2.
Quintessential facts relevant for adjudication of the case
at hand, as emerge from the pleadings adduced on record by the
respective
parties,
are
that
the
petitioner-company
named
hereinabove was granted/issued licence, duly renewed till 2024-2025,
in Form BWH-2 for running a bottling plant and also three other
subsidiary licences in Form L-13C, L-15 and L-16, by respondent
Nos.
2 and
3,
respectively, in their
capacity
as
Financial
Commissioner (Excise) and Collector (Excise), respectively, for
manufacture and sale of bottled country liquor. After expiry of the
aforesaid period, petitioner had also applied to the competent
authorities for renewal of the aforesaid licences for the year 20252026 after paying the required fee for each licence.
3.
On 02.06.2025, a team constituted under the orders of
respondent No. 2, comprising of seven officers of the Excise and
Taxation Department under the chairmanship of Mr. Ujjwal Singh
Rana, Additional Commissioner, State Taxes and Excise, allegedly on
the basis of some credible information, at 11:45 AM, carried out a
surprise inspection at the licensed premises owned by the petitioner
situated at Plot No. 25, Sector-5, Parwanoo and found the following
quantities of holograms (for sealing) and holograms (for track and
trace system) in the presence of Mr. Madan Lal and Mr. Jeetan
Kumar:
“a. Hologram (for sale in Haryana) Qts & Nips (total=48272)
b. Track and Trace Hologram/stickers (total=42,387)
c. Track and Trace Hologram/Stickers mentioning Frost
Falcon Distillery (total=11640)
d.
Label
750 ml/Falcon
Santra for sale
in Haryana
Sr.890800080045 (total 670).”
4.
Besides above, raiding team, after having reached the
office of the Assistant State Taxes and Excise Officer in charge
(hereinafter “ASTEO”), directed him to open the 'REVENUE LOCK' of
the bottling hall and allegedly found the following quantities of
spirit/liquor in various vats and other irregularities:
“1.
Quantity of ENA stored in SSV-II was found less by
9354.4 BLS, whereas, as per entry made in D-14, there
should be 11,635.8 BL of ENA in SSV-II.
2. While measuring blending quantity, it was detected that
quantity of Himachal Orange blend of country liquor (Batch
No. 33 dated 25.3.2025) was found less by 149.02 BLS
and quantity entered in D-14 register was 1468.0 BLS and
it was found 1319.00 BLS.
3. During the process of inspection, the team allegedly found
that 64 BLS less quantity of Himachal Orange blend of CL
(Batch No. 34 dated 26.3.2025) was present in BV-2.
4. The team allegedly detected quantity of liquor in BV-5
measuring 29,729 BLS; however, allegedly such quantity
was not entered in the statutory register, i.e. D-14.
5. CCTV installed for keeping strict vigil on day-to-day
operation of bottling plant were found to be inoperative.
6. Allegedly, the team detected an empty pint of Race7
Whisky (for sale in Haryana), which was labelled showing
the manufacturing unit M/s Frost Falcon Distillery Limited,
Village Jorhi, District Sonipat, Haryana, on conveyor belt
No. 2.”
5.
As per inspection report, Mr. Birbal Prakash, ASTEO in
charge posted at the bottling plant, was present and, besides him,
several other labourers/employees were present in the factory
premises. The inspection team also found the following shortcomings
on the part of the above-named Assistant State Taxes and Excise
Officer deployed by the Excise and Taxation Department in the
bottling plant of the petitioner:
Sr.
No.
Type
of Name
spirit/blend
of
VAT
1.
2.
ENA
Blend
Himachal
Orange
B.
No.33
Blend
Himachal
Orange
B.
No. 34
Coloured
liquid
substance
3.
4.
6.
SSV-2
BV-1
Dip in Physical Stock
cm
stock (in as per
BLS)
record
(in BLS)
32.8
2281.4
11635.8
29.4
1319.0
1468.02
Difference,
if any (in
BLS)
(-)9354.4
(-)49.02
BV-2
249.0
11171
11235
(-)64
BV-5
293.0
20729
(+)20729
Copy of the inspection report is placed on record as
Annexure P-2. Inspection team also recorded the statements of
persons namely Jeetan Kumar and Pura Ram with regard to alleged
transportation of liquor from M/s K.M. Distillery Private Limited on
28.04.2025. In the afore backdrop and on the basis of the inspection
report submitted by the inspection team of the Excise and Taxation
Department, a notice under Section 29(b) and (c) of the Act came to
be issued by respondent No. 1 to the petitioner, wherein, besides the
irregularities mentioned in the inspection report, it was also alleged
that as per statement of Mr. Pura Ram Sharma, who claimed himself
to be an employee, petitioner-company illegally exported 800 cases of
country liquor through a truck for sale in Haryana on 28.04.2025. It
was also stated in the notice that an FIR No. 63 dated 03.06.2025
under Section 173 of BNSS, 2023, had been registered at Police
Station Parwanoo under Sections 318(4), 336(3) and 340(2) of BNS,
2023 and Section 39(2)(a) of the Himachal Pradesh Excise Act, 2011.
Through aforesaid notice, petitioner came to be directed to show
cause as to why action be not taken against it (Annexure P-3).
7.
Petitioner submitted reply to the notice (Annexure P-5),
raising therein the following points:
I. Inspection conducted in the absence of the Directors of the
Company.
II. Conduct of inspection team is doubtful as premises were
sealed by revenue lock and no production was undertaken
since 1.4.2025.
III. No electricity consumption for the period from 1.4.2025 to
2.6.2025.
IV. Shri Pura Ram Sharma was not present on 28.04.2025 in
the factory premises as he was attending the marriage of his
nephew (Bhanja) in Rajasthan.
V. Alleged material recovered from factory premises was
implanted.
VI. Jeetan Kumar and Madan Lal are not employees of the
petitioner and they have sworn affidavits that no recovery was
made in their presence.
VII. So far as non-working of CCTV installed in the premises is
concerned, the factory was not in production since 31.3.2025
and access to cameras was with the officials of the Excise and
Taxation Department.”
8.
Along with the aforesaid reply, petitioner also submitted
certain documents, i.e.:
a) Extract of Attendance Register from November 2024 till
April 2025.
b) Electricity bills.
c) Affidavit of Madan Lal.
d) Affidavit of Jeetan Kumar.
e) Marriage card and photographs of the marriage of the son
of sister (nephew) of Shri Puru Ram Sharma in Rajasthan.”
9.
Excise Department, through Collector, filed rejoinder to
the reply filed by the petitioner (Annexure P-6) and Deputy
Commissioner, State Taxes and Excise, also filed rebuttal to the reply
(Annexure P-7).
10.
In nutshell, it came to be submitted at the behest of the
petitioner that the inspection team responsible for conducting
raid/inspection on 02.06.2025 was not a legally constituted team as
per State notification dated 26.04.2025. Petitioner-company also set
up a case that petitioner unit was not in operation since 01.04.2025 as
the unit was locked with revenue seal/paper seal issued by Financial
Commissioner/Commissioner (Excise) on 31.03.2026 and the said
revenue seal/paper seal was found intact on 02.06.2025 by the
inspecting/raiding
team.
Petitioner
also
submitted
that
false
evidence/witnesses had been planted by the inspecting/raiding team.
To substantiate its aforesaid plea, it came to be submitted at the
behest of the petitioner-company that persons namely Pura Ram,
Jeetan Kumar and Madan Lal, employees of M/s K.M. Distillery, have
not supported the case of the respondents and filed their affidavits
that nothing was recovered in their presence. Petitioner also
submitted that Jeetan Kumar and Madan Lal are not the employees of
petitioner M/s K.M. Distillery. Besides above, petitioner also attempted
to set up a defence that Pura Ram was not at Parwanoo on
28.04.2025 when the allegation of 800 cases of liquor being
transported for sale in Haryana was made. While producing on record
extracts of the attendance register and salary register of the
petitioner, petitioner-company also set up a case that Jeetan Kumar
and Madan Lal are not employees nor working in the petitioner unit.
11.
Besides above, petitioner also set up a case that the
alleged head of inspection, i.e. Additional Commissioner, State Taxes
and Excise, posted at headquarters, was neither Collector (Excise)
nor he had been authorized by the Collector to carry out inspection.
While referring to Rule 9.12 of Punjab Distillery Rules as applicable to
the State of Himachal Pradesh as well as applicable to the bottling
plants by virtue of Rules 43 and 55 of H.P. Bonded Warehouse Rules,
1987, petitioner submitted that inspection can be carried out by the
Collector himself or by an officer authorized by the Collector, but since
Additional Commissioner, State Taxes and Excise,
was not
authorized by the Collector, the raid, if any, conducted by the
aforesaid authority is vitiated.
12.
Financial Commissioner, having taken note of the
aforesaid defence/reply filed by the petitioner, proceeded to pass
impugned order dated 14.07.2025 (Annexure P-10), wherein he
rejected all the contentions raised at the behest of petitioner-company
and ordered cancellation of licences held by the petitioner in Form
BWH-2, L-13C, L-15 and L-16. In afore background, petitioner has
approached this Court in the instant proceedings, praying therein for
the reliefs, as have been reproduced hereinabove.
13.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and gone
through the records of the case.
14.
Precisely, the grouse of the petitioner, as has been
highlighted in the grounds of petition and further canvassed by Mr.
Arvind Sharma, learned Senior Counsel, duly assisted by Ms. Kiran
Sharma, learned counsel representing the petitioner, is that Financial
Commissioner (Excise), Himachal Pradesh, while passing impugned
order, failed to take note of submissions/contentions recorded in the
reply to the show cause notice submitted by the petitioner. Since Mr.
Sharma, learned Senior Counsel, has made submissions with regard
to the grounds raised in the reply to the show-cause notice, which
have already been noted in the earlier part of the judgment, this Court
sees no necessity to take note of the same again for the sake of
brevity. However, one ground/submission urged by Mr. Arvind
Sharma,
learned
Senior
Counsel,
in
addition
to
the
submissions/contentions raised through reply to show cause notice,
as stated hereinabove, is that Financial Commissioner/Commissioner,
while passing impugned order, has not acted in a fair manner. He
submitted that since inspecting/raiding team was constituted by
aforesaid authority on 31.05.2025 (Annexure R-2/1) and after receipt
of report of inspecting team, notice was also sent by aforesaid
authority (Annexure P-3), there was no occasion, if any, for the afore
authority to adjudicate the dispute. In nutshell, he submitted that
Commissioner (Excise) could not be a judge of his own cause and as
such, order impugned in the instant proceedings, being passed by the
aforesaid authority, is not sustainable in the eye of law.
15.
To the contrary, Mr. Anup Rattan, learned Advocate
General, duly assisted by Mr. Rajan Kahol, learned Additional
Advocate General, while supporting the impugned order passed by
Financial Commissioner (Excise), submitted that there is no illegality
or infirmity in the same and as such, no interference is called for.
While making this Court peruse the impugned order passed by
Financial Commissioner, Mr. Anup Rattan, learned Advocate General,
attempted to persuade this Court to agree with his contention that all
the defences/contentions raised by the petitioner were duly met by the
aforesaid authority and there is no reason to interfere with the
impugned order.
16.
Since petitioner herein has specifically raised an issue
with regard to non-adherence of Notification dated 26.04.2025 issued
by Government of Himachal Pradesh, Department of State Taxes and
Excise, with regard to constitution of inspection team, this Court finds
it apt to deal with the aforesaid issue at the first instance.
17.
Mr. Arvind Sharma, learned Senior Counsel representing
the petitioner, submitted that committee so constituted vide order
dated 31.05.2025 (Annexure R-2/5) was not in accordance with the
mandate of the Himachal Pradesh Excise Act, 2011 and the
notification issued thereunder.
18.
Before ascertaining the correctness of the aforesaid
submission made at the behest of the petitioner, it would be apt to
take note of certain relevant provisions of Himachal Pradesh Excise
Act, 2011, as interpreted in judgment rendered in CWP No.16382 of
2025, titled as M/s Tiloksons Brewery & Distillery, Kala Amb,
District Sirmour, H.P. Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors.:
“5. Financial Commissioner and Collector.(1) The State Government may, by notification, appoint an
Excise and Taxation Commissioner who shall exercise all the
powers of Financial Commissioner, and subject to the control
of the State Government, the general superintendence and
administration of all matters relating to excise shall vest in
him.
(2) The State Government may, by notification, appoint as many
Collectors as it may deem fit, to discharge in any specified area the
functions of the Collector under this Act and the Collector shall,
subject to the control of the Financial Commissioner, control all
other Excise Officers within his jurisdiction.
(3) The jurisdiction of the Financial Commissioner shall extend
to the whole State and the jurisdiction of Collectors shall
extend to the areas of the State in which they are for the time
being employed.
6.
Other classes of Excise Officers and their powers and
jurisdiction.(1) There shall be such other classes of Excise Officers as the
State Government may, by notification, declare and it may
appoint as many persons as it deems fit to be the Excise
Officers of these classes.
(2) The State Government may, by notification, invest in any
person, not being an Excise Officer, with powers to perform all
or any of the functions of an Excise Officer, under this Act,
and such person shall in the exercise of these functions be
deemed to be an Excise Officer.
(3) The State Government shall, by notification, declare the
powers to be exercised under this Act by the Excise Officer of
each class.
(4) The jurisdiction of the Excise Officers shall, unless the
State Government otherwise directs, extend to the districts in
which they are for the time being employed.
7.
Persons appointed under this Act to be public
servants.- All persons appointed under this Act shall be
deemed to be public servants within the meaning of section 21
of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
8.
Power to enter and inspect.- Any Excise Officer, not
below such rank as the State Government may, by notification
specify,(a) enter and inspect, at any time by day or by night, any place
in
which
any
licensed
manufacturer
carries
on
the
manufacture of or stores any liquor;
(b) enter and inspect, at any time, any place in which any
liquor is kept for sale by any person holding a license under
this Act;
(c) examine any accounts and registers, test, measure or
weigh any materials, stills, utensils, implements, apparatus or
testing instruments or liquor found in that place;
(d) seize any accounts, register, measure, weights or testing
instruments which he has reason to believe to be false or
incorrect; and
(e) seize any liquor which he has reasons to believe to be
unaccounted for in the accounts and registers maintained by
the licensee.
9. Power to investigate.(1) The State Government may, by notification, invest any
Excise Officer, with power to investigate any offence
punishable under this Act, committed within the limits of the
area in which the officer exercises jurisdiction.
(2) Every officer so empowered may within those limits
exercise the same powers in respect of such investigation as
an officer-in-charge of a police station may exercise in a
cognizable case under the provisions of Chapter XII of the
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
10.
Powers of Excise Officer to search, seize etc.-
(1) Whenever any Excise Officer not below such rank as the
State Government may, by notification, specify has reason to
believe that an offence punishable under this Act, has been, is
being, or is likely to be, committed by any person, in any
place, and that a search warrant cannot be obtained without
affording the offender an opportunity of escape or of
concealing evidence of the offence, he may, at any time, by
day or night, enter and search such place.
(2) Any Excise Officer specified in sub-section (1) may seize
anything found in such place which he has reason to believe
to be liable to confiscation under this Act, and may detain and
search and, if he thinks proper, arrest any person found in
such place whom he has reason to believe to be guilty of such
offence as aforesaid.”
Section 6 of the Himachal Pradesh Excise Act, 2011 was
amended as under by the Himachal Pradesh Excise
(Amendment) Act, 2024:- “6. Other classes of Excise Officers
and their powers and jurisdiction. – (1) There shall be the
following
classes
of
officers
within
their
respective
jurisdictions:(i) an officer not below the rank of Assistant State Taxes and
Excise Officer in the State Taxes and Excise Department;
(ii) Executive Magistrate not below the rank of Tehsildar; and
(iii) Police Officer not below the rank of Assistant SubInspector
in the Police Department.
(2) The aforesaid Excise Officers shall exercise the powers to
enter, inspect, investigate, search and seize and obtain
information under sections 8, 9, 10, 12 and 54 of this Act.
(3) The State Government shall, by notification appoint Police
Officer or Official, on secondment basis from the Himachal
Pradesh Police, for carrying out the purposes of this Act.”
In exercise of powers conferred by Section 8 of the H.P.
Excise Act, following notification was issued by the State on
26.04.2025 (Annexure P-17):-
“GOVERNMENT
OF
HIMACHAL
PRADESH
DEPARTMENT OF STATE TAXES & EXCISE
File
No.
EXN-F(1)-3/2024
Dated
Shimla-171002,
26th April, 2025
In supersession of Notification No. EXN-F(4)-1/2009-loose
dated 22nd July, 2013 and in exercise of the powers conferred
by Section 8 of the Himachal Pradesh Excise Act, 2011, the
Governor of Himachal Pradesh is pleased to notify that the
power under Section 8 of the ibid Act shall be exercised by the
Officers
defined
under
Section
6(1)(ii)
who
shall
be
accompanied by an Officer of the Department of State Taxes
& Excise not below the rank of Assistant State Taxes & Excise
Officer having jurisdiction and by a Police Officer defined
under Section 6(1)(iii) not below the rank of Deputy
Superintendent of Police having jurisdiction.
Sd/Principal Secretary (ST&E) to the
Government of Himachal Pradesh”
“4(i)(b) Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner submitted
that inspection under Section 8 of the Excise Act is to be
conducted
in
accordance
with
the
Notification
dated
26.04.2025. Power under Section 8 is to be exercised by the
Officer
defined
under
Section
6(1)(ii)
who
is
to
be
accompanied by:
(i) an Officer of the Department of State Taxes & Excise not
below the rank of Assistant State Taxes & Excise Officer
having jurisdiction; and
(ii) a Police Officer defined under Section 6(1)(iii) not below
the
rank
of
Deputy
Superintendent
of
Police
having
jurisdiction.”
19.
Mr. Sharma,
learned Senior Advocate, vehemently
argued that use of expression 'shall be accompanied' in the
notification suggests that presence of accompanying officer is
intended to form part of the procedural framework governing such
inspection. He submitted that inspection was carried out under
Section 8 of the Excise Act, but absence of police officer in inspection
would vitiate the inspection as constitution of team was not in
consonance with the notification. While referring to judgment passed
by Privy Council in case titled Nazir Ahmad v. King Emperor, AIR
1936 PC 253, Mr. Sharma submitted that principle therein is being
consistently followed till date that where a power has been given to do
a certain thing in a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or
not at all. He submitted that since team was not constituted strictly in
terms of aforesaid provisions of law, raid conducted by inspection
team constituted in terms of order dated 31.05.2025, being not in
consonance with mandatory provisions of the Act as amended in the
year 2024 and notification issued thereunder, is bad in the eye of law,
as a result thereof, all the consequential action thereafter cannot
sustain.
20.
To the contrary, Mr. Anup Rattan, learned Advocate
General submitted that surprise inspection was covered under
Section 10 and not under Section 8 of the Act and as such, presence
of police officer was not essential during inspection. He submitted that
as per Section 8, any Excise Officer (of the rank specified by State
Government by a notification) can conduct inspection. He submitted
that Section 10 also empowers the specified Excise Officer to conduct
inspection. While referring to amended Section 6, Mr. Rattan
submitted that apart from Assistant State Taxes and Excise Officer in
the Department, the Executive Magistrate not below the rank of
Tehsildar and police officer not below the rank of Assistant Sub
Inspector have been authorized and empowered to enter, inspect,
investigate, search, seize and obtain information under Sections 8, 9,
10, 12 and 54 of the Excise Act. He also referred to notification dated
26.04.2025 to state that power under Section 6(1)(ii) of the Act shall
be exercised by an officer, who shall be accompanied by an officer of
the Department of State Taxes and Excise not below the rank of
Assistant State Taxes and Excise Officer and a police officer under
Section 6(1)(iii) not below the rank of Deputy Superintendent of
Police.
21.
Bare reading of aforesaid provisions, though may lead to
an interpretation that under Sections 8 and 10 of the Excise Act, any
Excise Officer can inspect the premises and Executive Magistrate not
below the rank of Tehsildar under Section 6(1)(ii), as also the police
officer not below the rank of Assistant Sub Inspector under Section
6(1)(iii), are also Excise Officers, but officer falling under Section 6(ii),
i.e. Tehsildar (or higher in rank to him), would not be able to exercise
powers under Sections 8 and 10 by himself; rather, he will necessarily
have to be accompanied by an officer not below the rank of Deputy
Superintendent of Police and by an Assistant State Taxes and Excise
Officer.
22.
This Court is in full agreement with Mr. Arvind Sharma,
learned Senior Counsel representing the petitioner, that aforesaid
interpretation would defeat the logic behind amendment of Section 6
and also object intended to be achieved by notification dated
26.04.2025, i.e. inclusivity of all wings during inspection in order to
accord some protection to the licence holder to safeguard his interest.
In case Assistant Sub Inspector of Police and Tehsildar are permitted
to inspect the premises on their own, very purpose of issuing
notification dated 26.04.2025 would be defeated.
23.
Coordinate Bench of this Court in case M/s Tiloksons
Brewery & Distillery, Kala Amb, District Sirmour (supra), had an
occasion to deal with similar issue, wherein aforesaid Court, after
having taken note of aforesaid provisions of law vis-à-vis issue
involved therein, which is similar to the issue involved in the case at
hand, held as under:“Harmonious interpretation of provisions therefore would lead
to logical conclusion that power under Section 8 of the Excise
Act can be exercised by the Executive Magistrate of First
Class who is to be accompanied by an Excise Officer and a
Police Officer as specified by the State Government. The
team constituted by the respondents for inspecting petitioner’s
premises did not have Executive Magistrate of First Class.
Apparently, this team did not even have Police Officer of the
rank specified in the Excise Act & the Notification. The
inspection report prepared by respondent No. 3 though
mentions participation of a ‘Special Investigation Cell’ of
District Police but does not give names of specific Police
Officers or their ranks. The inspection report furnished by
respondent No. 4 does not even state about association of
any Police Officer during inspection. The reply filed by the
respondents does not dispute inspection having been carried
out under Section 8 of the Excise Act or the requirement of
associating Executive Officer as also the Police Officer during
inspection but tries to downplay it by pleading that procedural
lapses would not vitiate the inspection. It has to be held that
constitution of the team that inspected the premises was not in
consonance with the Act & the applicable Notification.”
24.
In the case at hand, it is not in dispute, rather stands
admitted in the reply filed by the respondents that inspection was
carried out under Section 8 of the Excise Act, but vide notification
dated 26.04.2025, His Excellency the Governor of Himachal Pradesh
notified that power under Section 8 of the Act shall be exercised by
officers defined under Section 6(1)(ii), who shall be accompanied by
an officer of the Department of State Taxes and Excise not below the
rank of Assistant State Taxes and Excise Officer having jurisdiction
and by a police officer defined under Section 6(1)(iii) not below the
rank of Deputy Superintendent of Police having jurisdiction.
25.
In the case at hand, Commissioner, State Taxes and
Excise, Himachal Pradesh, vide office order dated 31.05.2025
(Annexure R-2/5), accorded authorization to conduct search with
respect to unauthorized activity/manufacturing stated to have been
carried out in M/s K.M. Distillery Private Limited, petitioner herein,
under H.P. Excise Act and constituted team as under:
“1) Sh. Ujjal Singh Rana, Additional CST&E (IT, EIU and
Enforcement)
2. Sh. Aman Sophat, ACSTE O/o JCSTE (CZ) Una
3. Sh. Anurag Garg, ACSTE Ghumarwin
4. Sh. Manoj Sehgal, STEO O/o JCSTE (CZ) Una
5. Sh. Rupinder Singh, STEO ΒΒΝ.
6. Sh. C.M. Lath, STEO Nalagarh
7. Sh. Nitin, STEO Nadaun
8. Sh. Dhian Singh, ASTEO O/o JCSTE (SZ) Parwanoo
9. Sh. Suraj, ASTEO MPB Baddi.”
26.
Though vide office order dated 31.05.2025, Additional
Commissioner, State Taxes and Excise, as well as other officers of
State Taxes and Excise Department, came to be included, but
admittedly no police officer defined under Section 6(1)(ii) not below
the rank of Deputy Superintendent of Police having jurisdiction ever
came to be associated. Since inspection team was not in terms of
mandatory provisions of Himachal Pradesh Excise Act as amended in
the year 2025 and notification issued thereunder, entire inspection
conducted by team constituted vide order dated 31.05.2025 is
vitiated. Though it came to be argued at the behest of respondentState that procedural lapses would not vitiate the inspection, but this
Court, while holding that constitution of team that inspected premises
was not in consonance with the Act and applicable notification, has no
hesitation to conclude that the very object intended to be achieved by
notification dated 26.04.2025, i.e. with regard to inclusion of all wings
during inspection in order to accord some protection to licence holder,
would be defeated in case constitution of committee is not in
accordance with Act and Rules. The very purpose and object of
including officers other than those of Excise Department is to ensure
fairness during raid/inspection. Since in the case at hand, inspection
team did not have a police officer of the rank specified in the Excise
Act and notification, coupled with the fact that inspection report
furnished by respondent No. 2 does not even state about association
of any police officer during inspection, raid/inspection carried out in
the premises of petitioner on 02.06.2025 cannot be said to be in
accordance with law.
27.
Deviation from law in constitution of committee that
inspected petitioner's premises compels this Court to arrive at a
conclusion of declaring entire inspection to be vitiated or, in other
words, the very foundation of issuing notice to petitioner and order
passed thereupon illegal.
28.
Having carefully perused afore judgment passed by the
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court, this Court finds merit in the
contention of Mr. Anup Rattan, learned Advocate General, submitted
that Coordinate Bench of this Court, while passing judgment in M/s
Tiloksons Brewery & Distillery, Kala Amb, District Sirmour
(supra), had not set aside the report of inspection committee on the
ground that its constitution was not in accordance with law, rather the
same came to be set aside on some other ground. Careful perusal of
judgment passed by Coordinate Bench of this Court in M/s Tiloksons
Brewery & Distillery, Kala Amb, District Sirmour (supra), suggests
that though aforesaid Court arrived at a definite finding that
constitution of committee that inspected premises was not in
consonance with mandatory provisions of Act as amended in the year
2024 and notification issued thereunder, but yet proceeded to quash
impugned order passed by Commissioner, State Taxes and Excisecum-Financial Commissioner, cancelling petitioner's licence in Form
D-2 and L-1, on the ground that impugned order passed by
Commissioner, State Taxes and Excise, cancelling petitioner's
licence, does not at all reflect either application of independent mind
or that order was passed after following proper procedure.
29.
Since Coordinate Bench of this Court, in peculiar facts
and circumstances, had not proceeded to quash entire inspection
proceedings, but if judgment rendered by it is read in its entirety, it
clearly suggests that committee, which had inspected petitioner's
premises, was not found to be constituted in terms of mandate of Act
as well as notification, but instead of setting aside impugned order in
that case on the aforesaid ground, matter was remanded back to
Commissioner to decide the same afresh, taking into consideration
observations made in that judgment.
30.
However, in the instant case, this Court is of the definite
view that constitution of committee, which inspected petitioner's
premises, was not in accordance with law, coupled with the fact that
very purpose and object of providing provision of law under Act with
regard to constitution of committee as well as notification dated
26.04.2025, wherein Section 6 came to be amended, is/was to ensure
that, to eliminate the element of bias and injustice, officers of other
departments are also included in raiding team. Since provisions
contained in the Act, as has been discussed hereinabove, clearly
mandate inclusion of officer of other department in raiding team, it
cannot be said that non-inclusion, if any, of officer not below the rank
of Deputy Superintendent of Police is a procedural lapse, which can
be ignored; rather, the same being a material defect in constitution of
team, which admittedly is constituted in violation of Section 6, entire
inspection proceedings conducted by aforesaid committee need to be
quashed and set aside.
31.
Though
during
proceedings
of
the
case,
other
submissions/arguments also came to be raised at the behest of
petitioner, as have been recorded in the earlier part of judgment, but
since, for the discussion made hereinabove, this Court is of the
definite view that respondent deviated from law while constituting
committee that inspected petitioner's premises, as a consequence
thereof, entire inspection carried out by aforesaid committee is vitiated
and, as such, consequential actions subsequently taken pursuant to
aforesaid report submitted by team are of no consequence and,
hence, this Court finds no necessity to deal with other grounds and
same are left open.
32.
Consequently, in view of the detailed discussion made
hereinabove as well as the law taken into consideration, this Court
finds merit in the present petition and, accordingly, the same is
allowed. Impugned order dated 14.07.2025 (Annexure P-8) is
quashed and set aside, with a direction to the respondents to renew
the licence in Form BWH-2 in favour of the petitioner for the year
2026-27 and to restore the L-13C, L-15 and L-16 licences of the
petitioner subject to fulfilment of all the conditions by the petitioner.
Petition stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms along
with pending application(s), if any. Mr. Arvind Shama, learned Senior
Counsel, submits that his client has deposited licence fee for the year
2025-26, but since the licence was not renewed for that year, the
license fee deposited for 2025-26 may be adjusted towards licence
fee for the year 2026-27. Accordingly, it is ordered that licence fee, if
any, deposited by the petitioner shall be adjusted towards licence for
the financial year 2026-27.
p
(Sandeep Sharma),
Judge
September 29, 2026
(Sunil)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review