Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 28th April, 2026
Date of Decision 08th July, 2026
Uploaded on 09th July, 2026
+
W.P.(C) 3734/2013, CM APPL. 15403/2018
M/S INDRAPRASHTA GAS LIMITED
Through:
.....Petitioner
Ms.Raavi Birbal, Adv.
versus
ABDUL HAFEEZ KHAN
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Krishna Dev Pandey, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
JUDGMENT
SHAIL JAIN, J.
1.
The present writ petition under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India has been instituted by M/s Indraprastha Gas
Limited (hereinafter referred to as “the Petitioner” or “IGL”),
assailing the Award dated 19.02.2011 passed by the learned Presiding
Officer, Labour Court No. XII, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi in
Industrial Dispute No. 263/2008 .
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
2.
The present petition arises out of an industrial dispute
concerning
the
alleged
termination
of
services
of
the
respondent/workman, Sh. Abdul Hafeez Khan. The dispute came to be
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 1 of 23
referred for adjudication by the Secretary (Labour), Government of
NCT of Delhi, vide Reference Order No. F.24(126)/03/Lab./3782-86
dated 03.06.2003 under Sections 10(1)(c) and 12(5) of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947. The terms of the said reference read as follows:
"Whether the services of Sh. Abdul Hafeez Khan s/o
Sh. Abdul Hamid have been terminated by the
management illegally and / or unjustifiably and if so to
what sum of money as monetary relief along with
consequential benefits in terms of existing laws/ Govt.
Notifications and to what other relief is he entitled and
what directions are necessary in this respect.?"
3.
Pursuant to the aforesaid reference, the respondent-workman
filed a Statement of Claim before the Labour Court. The case set up by
the workman was that he had been working as a Technician at a CNG
station situated at NH-24, Gazipur, Delhi, and that his services came to
be discontinued on 20.08.2002. It was his case that the said
termination was illegal and unjustified and entitled him to
reinstatement with consequential benefits.
4.
The petitioner/management entered appearance and contested
the claim by filing its Written Statement. Besides raising a preliminary
objection regarding the maintainability of the reference, it denied the
existence of any employer-employee relationship with the respondent
and asserted that the respondent had been engaged through an
independent contractor.
5.
On the basis of the pleadings and material placed before it, the
Labour Court framed the following issues:
i) As per terms of reference;
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 2 of 23
ii) Whether there is no relationship of employer and
employee between the parties?
iii)Relief.
6.
Upon conclusion of evidence and hearing of the parties, the
Labour Court passed the impugned Award dated 19.02.2011 , whereby
the reference was answered in favour of the respondent-workman and
he was directed to be reinstated with consequential reliefs.
7.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid Award, the petitioner/management
has instituted the present writ petition seeking judicial review thereof
under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER
8.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner assails
the impugned Award on the ground that the Labour Court erred in
holding that an employer-employee relationship existed between the
petitioner-management and the respondent-workman. It is submitted
that the respondent failed to produce any documentary evidence
establishing his direct employment with the petitioner and,
consequently, failed to discharge the initial burden cast upon him in
law. According to the petitioner, the Labour Court nevertheless
proceeded to hold that an employer-employee relationship stood
established despite expressly recording that the respondent had not
produced any document demonstrating that he was an employee of the
petitioner-management.
9.
Learned counsel submits that the respondent was never
employed by the petitioner but had been engaged through an
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 3 of 23
independent contractor, namely M/s Mahajan Enterprises. In support
of the said defence, reliance is placed upon the operating agreement,
the registration certificate obtained under the Contract Labour
(Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1970, the contractor's wage records,
Provident Fund records, Employees' State Insurance records and the
petitioner's recruitment policy. It is submitted that the petitioner was a
registered principal employer under the Contract Labour (Regulation
and Abolition) Act, 1970 and that the contractor possessed a valid
licence thereunder. According to the petitioner, the Labour Court
failed to appreciate the aforesaid documentary evidence in its proper
perspective.
10.
It is further submitted that the issue concerning the status of
similarly situated Driver Salesmen and Technicians engaged at the
petitioner's CNG stations had earlier been considered by the Industrial
Tribunal in I.D. No. 99/2003 instituted by Vyapar Thatha Udyog
Karamchari Sangh on behalf of 216 workmen, including the
respondent herein. By Award dated 20.12.2011, the Industrial Tribunal
held that such workmen were employees of the respective contractors
and not of the petitioner-management. Learned counsel submits that
the said Award was upheld by this Court in Vinay Sharma & Ors. v.
Indraprastha Gas Ltd. & Anr. [W.P.(C) No. 6657/2012]. and that the
reasoning adopted therein supports the petitioner's challenge to the
impugned Award.
11.
Reliance is also placed upon the decision of this Court in M/s
Indraprastha Gas Ltd. v. Ambrish Kumar [WP.(C) 3743/2013,] ,
wherein, in the context of a similar dispute involving the petitioner-
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 4 of 23
management, this Court reiterated that the burden of establishing an
employer-employee relationship rests upon the workman and that the
mere performance of duties at the premises of the principal employer
does not, by itself, establish direct employment. Learned counsel
submits that the impugned Award is inconsistent with the principles
recognised in the aforesaid decisions.
12.
Learned counsel further places reliance upon the decisions of
the Supreme Court in Balwant Rai Saluja v. Air India Ltd., 2014 (3)
LLN 568 (SC) ; National Aluminium Co. Ltd. v. Ananta Kishore
Rout, (2014) 6 SCC 756; General Manager (OSD), Bengal Nagpur
Cotton Mills v. Bharat Lal & Anr , (2011) 1 SCC 635; and S.C.
Chandra & Ors v. State of Jharkhand & Ors, (2007) 8 SCC 279 to
contend that the existence of an employer-employee relationship is to
be determined with reference to recognized indicia such as the power
of appointment, payment of wages, disciplinary control, supervision
and the right to terminate service. It is submitted that none of these
indicia stood established.
13.
Without prejudice to the aforesaid submissions, learned counsel
contends that the Labour Court recorded a finding regarding
completion of 240 days of continuous service without independently
examining the evidence on record. It is submitted that the burden of
proving completion of 240 days rested upon the respondent-workman
and that no cogent documentary material was produced by him in
support thereof. Reliance is placed upon the decision of the Supreme
Court in Range Forest Officer v. S.T. Hadimani, (2002) 3 SCC 25.
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 5 of 23
14.
It is further contended that the Labour Court erroneously
inferred the existence of an employer-employee relationship merely
because the respondent discharged his duties at the petitioner's CNG
station. According to the petitioner, such reasoning overlooks the
settled distinction between a principal employer and the employee of a
contractor. It is submitted that, in the absence of a direct employeremployee relationship, the question of illegal termination by the
petitioner did not arise.
15.
Lastly, learned counsel reiterates the objection regarding
jurisdiction and submits that the appropriate Government in relation to
the petitioner was the Central Government and not the Government of
NCT of Delhi. It is, therefore, contended that the reference itself was
without jurisdiction and that the impugned Award is liable to be set
aside on this ground as well.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT
16.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent/workman supports the impugned Award and submits that it
does not suffer from any illegality, perversity or jurisdictional
infirmity warranting interference in exercise of the writ jurisdiction of
this Court. It is contended that the Labour Court, upon due
appreciation of the pleadings, oral and documentary evidence, rightly
concluded that the respondent was an employee of the petitionermanagement and that the termination of his services was illegal and
unjustified.
17.
Learned counsel submits that the respondent had been working
as a Technician with the petitioner since 23.06.2001 and was drawing
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 6 of 23
monthly wages of Rs. 5,160/-. It is contended that, despite rendering
continuous service, the respondent was not extended statutory benefits
such as an appointment letter, ESI facilities and overtime benefits.
According to the respondent, when he demanded such benefits and
sought regularisation of his services, his services were terminated on
20.08.2002 without compliance with the provisions of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947. It is submitted that the respondent thereafter
approached the Labour Authorities, issued a demand notice and
participated in conciliation proceedings, which ultimately culminated
in the present reference.
18.
Learned counsel further submits that the petitioner's plea that
the respondent had been engaged through an independent contractor
was rightly rejected by the Labour Court. It is contended that the name
of the alleged contractor was not disclosed in the written statement and
that the operating agreement relied upon by the petitioner pertained to
a period subsequent to the respondent's alleged termination. It is,
therefore, submitted that the said agreement did not establish the
existence of any contractor arrangement during the relevant period. It
is further submitted that the petitioner neither produced the attendance
registers, wage registers and other primary employment records
despite requests made before the Labour Court, nor examined any
representative of the alleged contractor.
19.
It is further contended that the operational records produced by
the respondent, coupled with the admitted position that he had been
discharging duties at the petitioner's CNG station, sufficiently
established the respondent's employment with the petitioner-
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 7 of 23
management. Learned counsel submits that the petitioner also failed to
place on record any reply to the respondent's demand notice, which
lends support to the respondent's case.
20.
On the question of jurisdiction, learned counsel submits that the
reference made by the Government of NCT of Delhi was validly made
and that the Labour Court rightly rejected the petitioner's objection in
that regard.
21.
It is lastly submitted that the findings recorded by the Labour
Court are findings of fact based upon appreciation of the evidence on
record and do not warrant interference in exercise of the supervisory
jurisdiction of this Court under Articles 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India. The present writ petition is, accordingly, liable
to be dismissed.
ISSUES FOR CONSIDERATION
22.
The principal question that arises for consideration is whether
the impugned Award dated 19.02.2011 passed by the Labour Court
suffers from any illegality, perversity or error of law warranting
interference by this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Articles
226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
23.
The Court has heard counsel for the parties and perused the
material placed on record.
24.
At the outset, it is necessary to reiterate the limited scope of
judicial review exercised by this Court under Articles 226 and 227 of
the Constitution of India. The jurisdiction is supervisory and not
appellate in nature. This Court does not sit as a Court of appeal over
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 8 of 23
the findings recorded by the Labour Court, nor does it re-appreciate
the evidence merely because another view on the same material may
also be possible. Interference is warranted only where the impugned
Award suffers from jurisdictional error, perversity, is based on no
evidence,
ignores
material
evidence,
or
proceeds
upon
a
misapplication of settled legal principles. Where the findings are
founded upon a proper appreciation of the evidence and represent a
plausible view, they ordinarily do not warrant interference in exercise
of writ jurisdiction. This principle stands authoritatively settled in
Syed Yakoob v. K.S. Radhakrishnan, AIR 1964 SC 477. The same
principle has been reiterated by the Supreme Court in Workmen of
Nilgiri Coop. Mkt. Society Ltd. v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2004) 3 SCC
514, wherein it was observed that the question whether an employeremployee relationship exists is essentially one of fact and ordinarily
does not warrant interference in exercise of writ jurisdiction unless the
finding is manifestly erroneous or perverse. It is in the aforesaid legal
backdrop that the challenge to the impugned Award falls for
consideration.
25.
A perusal of the impugned Award shows that the Labour Court
answered the reference in favour of the respondent-workman. The
Labour Court held that an employer-employee relationship existed
between the petitioner/management and the respondent/workman,
rejected the petitioner's defence that the respondent had been engaged
through an independent contractor, namely M/s Mahajan Enterprises,
and concluded that the respondent had completed more than 240 days
of continuous service. On that basis, it held that the respondent's
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 9 of 23
termination was illegal and unjustified for non-compliance with the
provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act.
26.
Consequently, the Labour Court directed reinstatement of the
respondent/workman with continuity of service, albeit without back
wages, and also awarded compensation. The operative portion of the
impugned Award reads as under:
"Taking a collective assessment of the facts of the case
and my findings above and in the pursuits of objects of
justice the management no.1 is directed to reinstate the
workman with continuity of service without back wages
from the date of his termination. Since, no one can
survive without any livelihood so it can be presumed that
during the period of his termination workman might have
been working somewhere else. Further management no.1
is also directed to pay Rs.45,000/- as compensation to the
workman since he has fought a long battle for about 8
years. The compensation will be paid within three months
from the date of its enforceability i.e. from the
notification of Award, failing which workman shall be
entitled to recover the amount of compensation with
interest @ 9% per annum from the date of award."
27.
The Labour Court further recorded that Management No.2 had
already been deleted from the array of parties vide order dated
07.01.2010, there being no concern of the said management with the
dispute in question.
28.
The petitioner has also questioned the competence of the
Government of NCT of Delhi to make the present reference,
contending that the appropriate Government was the Central
Government within the meaning of Section 2(a) of the Industrial
Disputes Act, 1947. The Labour Court rejected this objection and held
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 10 of 23
the reference to be competent. Since the present petition can be
disposed of on the substantive findings recorded hereinafter, it is
neither necessary nor appropriate to examine the correctness of that
finding.
29.
The principal issue which falls for consideration is whether the
finding recorded by the Labour Court regarding the existence of an
employer-employee relationship between the petitioner/management
and the respondent/workman can be sustained in law. The
determination of this issue is governed by the settled legal principles
relating to the burden of proving the existence of an employeremployee relationship where such relationship is itself in dispute.
30.
In Workmen of Nilgiri Coop. Mkt. Society Ltd. v. State of
Tamil Nadu, (2004) 3 SCC 514, the Supreme Court observed as
under:
“Burden of proof
47. It is a well-settled principle of law that the person
who sets up a plea of existence of relationship of
employer and employee, the burden would be upon him.
48. In N.C. John v. Secy., Thodupuzha Taluk Shop and
Commercial Establishment Workers' Union [1973 Lab IC
398 : (1973) 1 LLJ 366 (Ker)] the Kerala High Court
held: (LAB IC p. 402, para 9) The burden of proof being
on the workmen to establish the employer employee
relationship an adverse inference cannot be drawn
against the employer that if he were to produce books of
accounts they would have proved employer-employee
relationship.
49. In Swapan Das Gupta v. First Labour Court of W.B.
[1976 Lab IC 202 (Cal)] it has been held: (LAB IC para
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 11 of 23
10) Where a person asserts that he was a workman of the
company and it is denied by the company, it is for him to
prove the fact. It is not for the company to prove that he
was not an employee of the company but of some other
person.
50. The question whether the relationship between the
parties is one of employer and employee is a pure
question of fact and ordinarily the High Court while
exercising its power of judicial review shall not interfere
therewith unless the finding is manifestly or obviously
erroneous or perverse.
[ Emphasis Supplied ]
The aforesaid principle also stands reinforced by the decision of this
Court in Chhathoo Lal v. Management of Goramal Hariram Ltd.,
W.P.(C.) No. 14191/2004, wherein it was held that the issue of the
employer-employee relationship goes to the very root of the Labour
Court's jurisdiction and is incidental to a reference alleging illegal
termination. Unless the workman first establishes that he was an
employee of the management against whom relief is claimed, no
question of illegal termination by that management can arise.
31.
The aforesaid decisions, read together, lay down the principles
governing the present case. They make it clear that the existence of an
employer-employee relationship is not determined merely by the place
where the work is performed, but by considerations such as the power
of appointment, payment of wages, maintenance of service records,
disciplinary and administrative control, supervision, and the authority
to terminate service. It is in the light of these considerations that the
evidence in the present case falls to be examined. The initial burden of
establishing the existence of a direct employer-employee relationship
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 12 of 23
rests upon the workman who asserts it, since the existence of such
relationship constitutes the foundational fact on which both his claim
and the Labour Court's jurisdiction to adjudicate a reference alleging
illegal termination depend. That burden is neither discharged nor
displaced by the management's failure to produce relevant records, for
an adverse inference arising from such non-production may, at best,
lend support to a case otherwise established but cannot be invoked to
create one where none exists. Equally, the adjudicatory forum must
first determine whether the workman has discharged that burden
before examining the sufficiency of the management's defence, for the
sufficiency or otherwise of the management's defence cannot
determine whether the workman has proved his own case. To proceed
otherwise would invert the legally prescribed order of enquiry.
32.
Tested on the touchstone of the aforesaid principles, the first
question
that
falls
for
consideration
is
whether
the
respondent/workman succeeded in establishing the existence of a
direct
employer-employee
relationship
with
the
petitioner/management.
33.
The respondent's case throughout has been that he was directly
appointed by the petitioner/management and was never engaged
through any contractor. The evidence led by the respondent must,
therefore, be examined to determine whether that assertion stands
established.
34.
In support of his case, the respondent examined himself by way
of affidavit and relied upon certain operational records maintained at
the petitioner's CNG station. In his cross-examination, however, he
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 13 of 23
admitted that no appointment letter had ever been issued to him by the
petitioner, no pay slip had been issued in his favour, and no order of
termination had been served upon him. He was further unable to
produce any Provident Fund record, Employees' State Insurance
record or any other document showing that his wages were paid by the
petitioner, that the petitioner maintained his service records, or that it
exercised disciplinary or administrative control over him.
35.
The operational records relied upon by the respondent, namely
the control room shift log books, technician deployment sheets, duty
rosters and the Diwali gift distribution list, are likewise silent as to
who engaged him, who paid his wages, who maintained his service
records or who exercised disciplinary or administrative control over
him. It is further material that the respondent's name is recorded
inconsistently across these documents, appearing as "Hafeez Khan" in
one register, "Hafiz Khan" in another and "Abdul Khan" in a third.
These inconsistencies materially detract from the evidentiary value of
the documents relied upon by the respondent.
36.
The respondent also sought to establish his direct recruitment by
placing reliance upon a newspaper advertisement allegedly issued by
the petitioner. The Labour Court rejected the contention on the ground
that the newspaper advertisement relied upon by the respondent was
published nearly four years after his alleged termination and, therefore,
could not substantiate his plea of direct recruitment. That finding is
borne out from the record and calls for no interference.
37.
Viewed cumulatively, neither the respondent's affidavit nor the
documentary material relied upon establishes that the respondent was
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 14 of 23
appointed by the petitioner, paid wages by it, or that the petitioner
maintained the respondent's service records or exercised disciplinary
or administrative control. The evidence led by the respondent is,
therefore, insufficient to establish the existence of a direct
employer-employee relationship with the petitioner, and the initial
burden of proving such relationship remains undischarged.
38.
The enquiry, however, could not conclude there. Despite the
respondent having failed to establish the foundational facts necessary
to prove direct employment, the Labour Court nevertheless recorded a
finding in Workman/Respondent’s favour. It therefore becomes
necessary to examine the reasoning which led the Labour Court to that
conclusion.
39.
The Labour Court thereafter proceeded to examine the
petitioner's defence. The petitioner's consistent stand, from the
conciliation proceedings through its Written Statement and the
evidence of MW-1, was that the respondent had never been directly
employed by the petitioner but had been engaged through an
independent contractor named as M/s Mahajan Enterprises, under an
operating agreement. According to the petitioner, the contractor was
responsible for payment of the respondent's wages, maintenance of his
attendance and statutory records, and compliance with the applicable
labour laws. In support of this defence, the petitioner relied upon the
operating agreement (Ex. MW1/1), the contractor's registration
certificate under the Contract Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act,
1970 (Ex. MW1/2), the contractor's wage records (Ex. MW1/3), the
contractor's Provident Fund and Employees' State Insurance records
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 15 of 23
(Ex. MW1/4), and the petitioner's recruitment policy (Ex. MW1/5).
The Labour Court rejected this defence, observing that the contractor's
identity had not been disclosed in the Written Statement and surfaced
only during the petitioner's evidence, that no witness from M/s
Mahajan Enterprises had been examined, and that the operating
agreement itself came into force only after the respondent's alleged
termination and, therefore, could not establish the existence of a
contractor arrangement during the relevant period. The Labour Court
cannot be faulted for declining to treat the operating agreement as
proof of a contractor arrangement during the relevant period, since a
document stated to have become operative only in April 2004 could
not establish such an arrangement nearly two years earlier. Likewise,
the delayed disclosure of the contractor's identity was a circumstance
legitimately bearing upon the credibility of the petitioner's defence.
Those conclusions are borne out by the record, and this Court finds no
infirmity in that part of the Labour Court's reasoning.
40.
The enquiry, however, did not conclude with those findings.
The rejection of the petitioner's contractor defence merely negatived
its plea that the respondent had been engaged through M/s Mahajan
Enterprises; it neither established that the respondent was directly
employed by the petitioner nor relieved the respondent of the burden
of proving such relationship. The decisive question that still required
determination was whether the evidence on record independently
established the respondent's claim of direct employment. That enquiry
necessarily required consideration of all the material evidence bearing
upon that issue. In particular, the contractor's wage records, Provident
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 16 of 23
Fund records and Employees' State Insurance records (Ex. MW1/3 and
Ex. MW1/4) bore directly upon the identity of the employer by
indicating the entity responsible for payment of wages and
maintenance of statutory employment records. Their relevance did not
depend upon the operating agreement alone. Yet, while rejecting the
operating agreement, the Labour Court did not independently examine
those documents, although they formed part of the petitioner's
evidence in their own right. Whatever evidentiary weight they
ultimately merited, they constituted material evidence on the issue and
required independent evaluation. The omission to consider them
renders the appreciation of the evidence incomplete.
41.
The Labour Court also relied upon certain additional
circumstances in support of its conclusion. Their evidentiary
significance, however, falls to be examined independently.
42.
The first circumstance relied upon by the Labour Court was the
admitted fact that the respondent discharged duties at the petitioner's
CNG station. That fact established no more than the respondent's
presence at the petitioner's establishment. It did not answer the distinct
question whether the respondent was directly employed by the
petitioner or engaged under some other arrangement. In the absence of
evidence identifying the legal basis of the respondent's engagement,
that fact, by itself, could not establish a direct employer-employee
relationship.The second circumstance was the petitioner's failure to
reply to the respondent's demand notice dated 02.09.2002. Such
silence could, at best, lend support to a case otherwise established; it
could not relieve the respondent of the obligation to prove the
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 17 of 23
relationship asserted. Nor was such silence inconsistent with the
petitioner's case that the respondent had been engaged through an
independent contractor. The third circumstance related to the
petitioner's non-production of attendance and wage registers. On this
aspect, however, the Labour Court itself held that such non-production
was "remote for the purpose to arrive at the conclusion that
attendance register and wages register could have contained the name
of the workman" and consequently declined to draw any adverse
inference against the petitioner. Having so held, it was not open to the
Labour Court to treat the absence of those records as a circumstance
reinforcing the respondent's case.
43.
Accordingly, this Court finds that none of these circumstances,
whether considered individually or collectively, supplied the
independent evidentiary foundation necessary to establish the
existence of a direct employer-employee relationship between the
petitioner and the respondent. The respondent's deployment at the
petitioner's CNG station established only that duties were performed at
the petitioner's establishment; it did not identify the legal basis of the
engagement. The petitioner's silence in response to the demand notice
did not establish the relationship asserted by the respondent. Equally,
once the Labour Court itself had held that the petitioner's nonproduction of attendance and wage registers did not justify the
drawing of an adverse inference, the absence of those records could
not thereafter be relied upon to reinforce the respondent's case. None
of these circumstances established the essential facts necessary to
prove that the petitioner had directly appointed the respondent, paid
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 18 of 23
the respondent's wages, maintained the respondent's service records, or
exercised disciplinary or administrative control over the respondent.
Their cumulative consideration, therefore, could not cure the absence
of affirmative evidence establishing the direct employer-employee
relationship asserted by the respondent.
44.
The cumulative effect of the foregoing discussion brings into
focus the infirmity in the reasoning adopted in the impugned Award.
The Labour Court rightly held that the operating agreement relied
upon by the petitioner with M/s Mahajan Enterprises, pertaining to a
period subsequent to the respondent's alleged termination, did not
establish the existence of a contractor arrangement during the relevant
period. It also rightly treated the delayed disclosure of the contractor's
identity as a circumstance bearing upon the credibility of the
petitioner's defence and found that the respondent had failed to
produce documentary evidence establishing direct employment with
the petitioner. Those findings are borne out by the record, and this
Court finds no infirmity in that part of the Labour Court's reasoning.
On an independent appraisal of the evidence, this Court also finds that
the material relied upon by the respondent is insufficient to establish
the direct employer-employee relationship asserted, with the result that
the respondent's initial burden of proof remained undischarged.
45.
The error in the impugned Award arises thereafter. Although the
Labour Court had itself found and this Court has, for the reasons
already recorded, independently confirmed that the respondent's
evidence was insufficient to establish the relationship asserted by him,
it nevertheless proceeded to infer a "probable/proximate nexus"
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 19 of 23
between the respondent and the petitioner from the rejection of the
petitioner's contractor defence and the surrounding circumstances. The
Award discloses no reasoning explaining how the conclusion
regarding the existence of a direct employer-employee relationship
follows from the very findings that the respondent had failed to
produce documentary evidence establishing such relationship. The
circumstances relied upon by the Labour Court may explain why the
petitioner's contractor defence was not accepted; they do not, without
more, constitute affirmative proof that the respondent was directly
employed by the petitioner. In substance, therefore, the Award treats
the rejection of the petitioner's defence as supplying the proof which
the respondent himself failed to produce, thereby impermissibly
inverting the settled burden of proof .The finding that a direct
employer-employee relationship existed between the petitioner and the
respondent, therefore, cannot be sustained. This conclusion also
accords with the view taken by this Court in Vinay Sharma & Ors. v.
Indraprastha Gas Ltd. & Anr. ( Supra ) and M/s Indraprastha Gas
Ltd. v. Ambrish Kumar,( supra ) wherein, on comparable facts, it was
held that operational records, by themselves, do not establish the
existence of a direct employer-employee relationship. Those decisions
turned on their own facts and are referred to only to indicate that the
conclusion reached in the present case is consistent with the principles
applied therein.
46.
This is not a case of this Court substituting one plausible view
of the evidence for another. The interference arises because the
impugned Award proceeds upon a misapplication of the settled burden
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 20 of 23
of proof and omits to consider material evidence bearing directly upon
the identity of the employer, thereby attracting the well-settled
parameters governing interference under Articles 226 and 227 noticed
at the outset.
47.
In view of the finding returned herein that the respondent failed
to establish the existence of an employer-employee relationship with
the petitioner-management, the question whether he had completed
240 days of continuous service would not ordinarily arise for
consideration, the protection under Sections 25-B and 25-F of the
Industrial Disputes Act being contingent upon the existence of such
relationship. The Labour Court has, however, independently recorded
a finding that the respondent had completed more than 240 days of
continuous service and founded the relief granted thereon. The
correctness of that finding, therefore, also falls for consideration.
48.
The legal position is well settled. In Range Forest Officer v.
S.T. Hadimani, (2002) 3 SCC 25, reiterated in Surendranagar
District Panchayat v. Jethabhai Pitamberbhai, (2005) 8 SCC 450,
the Supreme Court has held that the burden lies upon the workman to
establish, by cogent evidence, completion of 240 days of continuous
service during the twelve months preceding the alleged termination.
The Labour Court was, therefore, required to examine the evidence
relating to continuous service independently and record reasons
demonstrating how the statutory requirement stood satisfied.
49.
On examining the impugned Award, this Court finds that no
such independent exercise has been undertaken. While recording that
the respondent had completed more than 240 days of continuous
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 21 of 23
service, the Labour Court neither identifies the evidence on which that
finding rests nor records any independent reasons demonstrating how
the requirement of Section 25-B of the Industrial Disputes Act stood
fulfilled. Instead, the finding appears to have followed as a natural
consequence of the Labour Court's conclusion regarding the existence
of an employer-employee relationship rather than from an independent
appraisal of the evidence relating to continuous service.
50.
This Court is, therefore, unable to sustain the finding regarding
completion of 240 days of continuous service. Once the finding
regarding the existence of an employer-employee relationship has
been found to be unsustainable, the consequential finding regarding
completion of 240 days of continuous service, unsupported as it is by
any independent evaluation of the evidence, also cannot be sustained.
The finding returned by the Labour Court in that regard is,
accordingly, set aside.
51.
This Court has also considered whether the matter should be
remanded to the Labour Court for fresh adjudication. The error
identified herein is not merely one of inadequate discussion, but of a
fundamental misapplication of the settled principles governing the
burden of proof. The industrial dispute arises from an alleged
termination in the year 2002, the reference was made in 2003, and the
impugned Award was rendered in 2011. More than two decades have
since elapsed. In these circumstances, and the respondent having failed
to establish the foundational facts necessary to prove a direct
employer-employee relationship, no useful purpose would be served
by remanding the matter for a fresh consideration of the same
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 22 of 23
evidence. The interests of justice are, therefore, better served by finally
determining the issue.
52.
For all the aforesaid reasons, the impugned Award warrants
interference in exercise of this Court's supervisory jurisdiction under
Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
CONCLUSION
53.
In view of the conclusions recorded on the merits, it is
unnecessary to record any final finding on the objection raised by the
petitioner regarding the competence of the Government of NCT of
Delhi to make the present reference.
54.
Accordingly, the Award dated 19.02.2011 passed by the
Presiding Officer, Labour Court No. XII, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi
in Industrial Dispute No. 263/2008 is hereby set aside.
55.
The writ petition is, accordingly, allowed.
56.
There shall be no order as to costs, and all pending applications,
if any, also stand disposed of.
SHAIL JAIN, J
JULY 8, 2026
RM
Signed By:KAPIL
KUMAR
10:30:26
W.P.(C) 3734/2013
Pag e 23 of 23
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review