Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~2, 3
* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 06.08.2026
#
+
CNR No. DLHC012633872017
W.P.(C) 4906/2017, CM APPL. 21263/2017, CM APPL.
21291/201 and CM APPL. 46480/2017
M/S INDIAN PRINTING WORKS
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Rajesh Kumar Gautam,
Ms. Likivi K. Jakhalu, and
Ms. Ayal Akram, Advocates
versus
RATAN KASHYAP
Through:
#
+
.....Respondent
Mr. J. M. Kalia and
Mr.Dhruv Kalia, Advocates
CNR No. DLHC011093242018
W.P.(C) 5196/2018
RATAN KASHYAP
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. J. M. Kalia and
Mr.Dhruv Kalia, Advocates
versus
M/S INDIAN PRINTING WORKS
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Rajesh Kumar Gautam,
Ms. Likivi K. Jakhalu, and
Ms. Ayal Akram, Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
The present cross-writ petitions are being disposed of vide
this common judgment, as they arise out of the same impugned
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:50:02
W.P.(C) 4906/2017 & W.P.(C) 5196/2018
award dated 07.04.2017 passed by the learned Presiding Officer,
Labour Court-XVII, Karkardooma Courts in LIR No. 4545/16 (Old
I.D. No. 109/13).
W.P.(C) No. 4906/2017 has been preferred by M/s Indian
Printing Works (hereinafter the “management”), whereas W.P.(C)
No. 5196/2018 has been preferred by Ratan Kashyap (hereinafter
the “workman”).
2.
The dispute before the Labour Court arose from the claim of
the workman that he had joined the management on 22.04.2008 as a
Helper at its unit at C-52, Okhla Phase-II, Delhi and was
subsequently transferred to its unit at E-4, Rani Jhansi Road,
Jhandewalan, Delhi. It was his case that he had taken leave from
18.12.2012 to 20.12.2012 and, thereafter, reported for duty on
21.12.2012. According to him, he was called by the management
and asked to explain his absence, whereafter he was not permitted to
resume his duties.
3.
The workman issued a demand notice dated 22.12.2012 to the
management, and the dispute was eventually referred to the Labour
Court in terms of the following reference:
“Whether the services of workman Sh. Ratan Kashyap have been
terminated illegally and unjustifiably by the management and
what relief is he entitled to and what directions are necessary in
this respect?”
4.
The stand of the management, on the other hand, was that the
workman had joined as a Helper on 17.04.2008, that his last drawn
salary was Rs.7,254/- per month, and that he was a habitual
absentee. It was submitted that he had remained absent without
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:50:02
W.P.(C) 4906/2017 & W.P.(C) 5196/2018
information on 05.12.2012, 06.12.2012, and thereafter from
18.12.2012 to 20.12.2012. According to the management, when the
workman reported for duty on 21.12.2012, he was asked to explain
his absence, whereafter he himself stopped attending duties. The
management specifically denied having terminated his services and
maintained that the workman was repeatedly asked to resume his
duties, including before the Conciliation Officer as well as before
the Labour Court.
5.
The Labour Court framed the following issues on 12.03.2015:
“1. Whether the workman was absenting from duties w.e.f.
18.12.2012 without any intimation and sanction of leave?
OPM.
2. As per the terms of reference.”
6.
In support of his case, the workman examined himself as
WW-1 and relied upon, inter alia, his election identity card, his ESI
cards, the demand notice dated 22.12.2012, the complaint before the
Labour Commissioner, the proceedings before the Assistant Labour
Commissioner, and the order of reference. He also examined Sh.
Radha Kant, a co-worker, as WW-2.
The management examined its partner, Sh. Sudesh Pal
Kumar, as MW-1 and relied upon, inter alia, an apology letter dated
28.06.2012, a leave application dated 07.12.2012 marked as Ex.
MW1/2, and another leave application marked as Ex. MW1/3.
7.
The Labour Court noted that the workman had not produced
any leave application to substantiate his assertion of having
informed the management in advance regarding his leave from
18.12.2012 to 20.12.2012. Conversely, Ex. MW1/3 was an undated
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:50:02
W.P.(C) 4906/2017 & W.P.(C) 5196/2018
leave application seeking leave only for 19.12.2012 and 20.12.2012.
The Labour Court also noted that while MW-1 had deposed that
several letters had been issued to the workman asking him to rejoin
duties, not a single such letter, memo, or notice was placed on
record. At the same time, the Labour Court noted that an offer
allowing the workman to rejoin duties had been made before the
Court itself, which he declined on the ground that he was willing to
rejoin only if back wages were paid.
8.
The Labour Court ultimately held that once the workman had
submitted Ex. MW1/3 regarding his absence on 19.12.2012 and
20.12.2012, the matter ought to have ended with an explanation or,
at most, some punishment such as a warning. It concluded that the
management had instead taken the drastic step of refusing to permit
him to resume duties. Accordingly, both issues were decided in
favour of the workman and against the management.
9.
On the question of relief, the Labour Court noted that even an
illegal termination would not automatically result in reinstatement
with full back wages. Further, it was observed that the claimant had
not averred in his statement of claim that he had remained
unemployed since the date of termination, nor was the same borne
out by his testimony. The Labour Court further noted that the
workman had acquired experience of about 4 years and 8 months
while working as a Helper and Inkman, and observed that if he had
approached another business establishment, he would have been
able to obtain employment of equal status and salary. Consequently,
reinstatement was ruled out, and a lump-sum compensation of
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:50:02
W.P.(C) 4906/2017 & W.P.(C) 5196/2018
Rs.1,20,000/- was awarded, payable within 1 month from the date
of publication of the award, failing which the amount was to carry
interest @ 9% per annum from the date of the award till realization.
10.
Learned
counsel for
the management
has
primarily
challenged the finding of the Labour Court that the management had
refused to permit the workman to resume duties and, consequently,
illegally terminated his services. It is contended that the workman
took
an
inconsistent
stand
before
the
Assistant
Labour
Commissioner and the Labour Court, inasmuch as his complaint
dated 31.12.2012 did not allege termination or of being refused
permission to join duties. It is further submitted that the
management had consistently maintained that the workman had not
been terminated and had offered him an opportunity to resume duty,
including vide reply dated 04.03.2013 and a letter issued in May
2013, which the workman admitted having received but did not act
upon. Learned counsel has also contended that the allegations
regarding the non-extension of statutory benefits were not proved
and that the testimony of WW-2 did not support the workman’s
version regarding the alleged police incident.
11.
Per contra, learned counsel for the workman submits that
although the Labour Court correctly decided both issues in favour of
the workman, it erred in denying reinstatement and awarding only
Rs.1,20,000/- as lump-sum compensation.
12.
I have heard the learned counsels for the parties and perused
the material placed on record.
13.
Before examining the rival contentions, it is necessary to bear
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:50:02
W.P.(C) 4906/2017 & W.P.(C) 5196/2018
in mind the limited scope of interference available to this Court in
proceedings under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
The jurisdiction exercised by this Court over an award passed by a
Labour Court is supervisory and not appellate. This Court does not
ordinarily reappreciate the evidence or substitute its own view for
that of the adjudicating authority merely because another view may
be possible. Interference is warranted only where the finding is
without jurisdiction, perverse, or suffers from a patent error of law
or a violation of the principles of natural justice. Reference in this
regard may be made to Syed Yakoob Vs. K.S. Radhakrishnan1. The
said principle was reiterated by the Supreme Court in International
Airport Authority of India Vs. International Air Cargo Workers
Union2. This Court has also considered the scope of interference in
writ proceedings in Ritz Theatre Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Ramesh Chandra3.
14.
The learned counsel for the management has relied heavily
upon the fact that the workman, in his initial complaint dated
31.12.2012, did not expressly state that his services had been
terminated. However, this circumstance, by itself, cannot be viewed
in isolation from the subsequent proceedings, including the issuance
of the demand notice and the filing of the statement of claim.
15.
The Labour Court had before it the evidence that the
workman reported for duty on 21.12.2012, that MW-1 admitted that
the workman had worked from about 9:00 a.m. to 11:00 a.m. and
that he was thereafter asked to explain his absence. The Labour
1963 SCC OnLine SC 24.
(2009) 13 SCC 374
2024 SCC OnLine Del 3633
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:50:02
W.P.(C) 4906/2017 & W.P.(C) 5196/2018
Court also considered Ex. MW1/3 and came to the conclusion that
the workman had, at least for 19.12.2012 and 20.12.2012, submitted
an application regarding leave. Upon consideration of the evidence,
it concluded that the management ought not to have refused work to
the workman once an explanation for his absence had been
provided.
16.
The question before the Labour Court was not merely
whether the workman had remained absent, but whether the conduct
of the management on 21.12.2012 amounted to a termination of the
workman’s services. The Labour Court answered that question in
favour of the workman after considering the evidence led by both
sides. The contention that the management had repeatedly offered
the workman an opportunity to rejoin duty does not, in itself,
demonstrate perversity in the award. The fact that the workman
declined the subsequent offers is a circumstance which could
certainly be taken into account while moulding the relief, but it does
not, by itself, efface the finding already returned regarding the
circumstances in which he was prevented from continuing his duties
on 21.12.2012.
17.
The Labour Court noted that the management had alleged
irregular attendance and other instances of misconduct, but that no
domestic enquiry had been conducted. The Labour Court considered
the principle laid down in The Workmen of Firestone Tyre &
Rubber Co. of India (P) Ltd. Vs. The Management & Ors.4
concerning the proof of misconduct before the adjudicating forum
AIR 1973 SC 1227
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:50:02
W.P.(C) 4906/2017 & W.P.(C) 5196/2018
where no domestic enquiry has been held. In any event, the ultimate
finding of the Labour Court was not based merely upon the alleged
misconduct, but upon its conclusion that the management had
refused to permit the workman to resume duties.
18.
The contention based on the testimony of WW-2 is also not
convincing. The management is seeking a reappreciation of the
testimony of the said witness to contend that he did not support the
workman’s version regarding the police incident. However, even
assuming that WW-2 did not fully support every aspect of the
workman’s case, the finding regarding termination was not founded
exclusively upon the alleged assault or the calling of the police. The
Labour Court considered the workman’s attendance, the leave
application, his reporting for duty on 21.12.2012, the evidence of
MW-1, and the subsequent offer of before arriving at its conclusion.
Unless the findings are shown to be wholly unsupported by
evidence or so unreasonable that they can be characterised as
perverse, this Court would not substitute its own appreciation of
evidence for that of the Labour Court. Consequently, the
management’s challenge to the award on the premise that no
termination had taken place cannot be sustained.
19.
The principal grievance of the workman is that the Labour
Court erred in observing that there was no pleading or evidence
regarding his unemployment and, on that basis, ruled out
reinstatement. The Labour Court, however, was considering the
question of appropriate relief after having found the termination to
be illegal. The grant of reinstatement with back wages is not an
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:50:02
W.P.(C) 4906/2017 & W.P.(C) 5196/2018
automatic consequence of every finding of illegal termination. The
Labour Court is required to mould the relief having regard to the
facts and circumstances of each case. While denying reinstatement,
the Labour Court did not rely solely upon the absence of a specific
averment of unemployment. It also took into consideration the
workman’s length of service, his experience as a Helper and
Inkman, and the circumstances in which the dispute had arisen. It
further took note of the fact that an offer to resume duty had been
made before the Court, which the workman had declined unless
back wages were paid. These were relevant circumstances while
considering the appropriate relief. The question before this Court is
whether the decision of the Labour Court to award compensation in
lieu of reinstatement suffers from such perversity or illegality as
would warrant interference in writ jurisdiction. In this regard, the
legal position is well settled that reinstatement is not an inevitable or
automatic consequence of a finding of illegal termination. The
Labour Court itself considered several decisions detailing the
Court’s discretion to mould relief, including Nehru Yuva Kendra
Sangathan Vs. Union of India & Ors.5, Municipal Council, Sujanpur
Vs. Surinder Kumar6, Talwara Cooperative Credit & Service
Society Ltd. Vs. Sushil Kumar7, and Jagbir Singh Vs. Haryana State
Agriculture Marketing Board8. The said decisions recognise that the
Labour Court is required to balance the circumstances of each case
while deciding whether reinstatement, back wages, or monetary
2000 IV AD (Delhi) 709
2006 LLR 662
(2008) 9 SCC 486
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:50:02
W.P.(C) 4906/2017 & W.P.(C) 5196/2018
compensation would be appropriate. The issue of reinstatement and
the quantum and nature of monetary relief remain matters requiring
consideration in the facts of each case.
20.
The contention that the amount of Rs.1,20,000/- is inadequate
essentially invites this Court to undertake a fresh assessment of the
appropriate quantum of compensation. The mere fact that another
amount may also be considered reasonable cannot furnish a ground
for interference under Articles 226/227, particularly when the
Labour Court exercised its jurisdiction to mould the relief and has
assigned cogent reasons for declining reinstatement. The same
principle applies to the management’s challenge to the award of
compensation. Once the finding of illegal termination is held to be a
factual finding within the jurisdiction of the Labour Court and
supported by the evidence considered by it, the award of
consequential monetary relief cannot be interfered with lightly.
21.
Accordingly, this Court finds that neither of the two petitions
discloses any ground warranting interference with the impugned
award. Entertaining either challenge would fall outside the limited
scope of this Court’s supervisory jurisdiction in the facts of the
present case.
22.
Consequently, the impugned award is upheld, and the present
cross-writ petitions are dismissed.
23.
It is further noted that, pursuant to the interim order dated
31.05.2017 passed in W.P.(C) No. 4906/2017, the management was
directed to deposit a sum of Rs.1,20,000/- in the form of an FDR
(2009) 15 SCC 327
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:50:02
W.P.(C) 4906/2017 & W.P.(C) 5196/2018
with the Registrar General of this Court, subject to which the
operation of the impugned award was stayed. In view of the
dismissal of both writ petitions, the interim order dated 31.05.2017
shall stand vacated.
24.
The amount of Rs.1,20,000/- deposited with the Registrar
General of this Court pursuant to the aforesaid interim order, along
with the interest accrued thereon, shall be released by the Registry
in favour of the workman, Ratan Kashyap, in terms of the impugned
award.
25.
The pending applications also stand disposed of as
infructuous.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
AUGUST 06, 2026
kb/nb
corrected and released on 18.08.2026
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:50:02
W.P.(C) 4906/2017 & W.P.(C) 5196/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review