Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on: 07.09.2026
Date of Decision: 18.09.2026
Date of Uploading: 18.09.2026
#
CNR No. DLHC010462782024
+
CM(M) 3094/2024 & CM APPL. 43964/2024
M/S HOLISTICC CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. L. B. Rai, Mr. Satvik Rai
and Mr. Kartik Rai, Advs.
versus
M/S FLORITECH BUILDCON PVT LTD
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Rishi Sood, Adv.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY DIGPAUL
JUDGMENT
%
1.
Through the present petition, the petitioner/defendant no. 1 is
impugning the order dated 08.07.2024 in CS (COMM) No. 88/2021 titled
“M/s Floritech Buildcon v. M/s Holistic Constructions Pvt. Ltd. And Ors.”
passed by the learned District Judge (Commercial -01) (South) Saket Courts,
New Delhi1 whereby the learned Trial Court dismissed the application moved
by the petitioner under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
19082.
2.
The facts, shorn of unnecessary detail, as necessary for disposal of the
Hereinafter „Trial Court‟
Signed By:ANKITA CM(M)
RAI
3094/2024
17:19:17
present petition are that the respondent/plaintiff purportedly supplied Kota
stone, Granite, and Sandstone to the petitioner, for which the due payment is
alleged to not have been tendered.
3.
Seeking to recover the due amount, the respondent served a legal notice
dated 17.03.2020 to the petitioner and on 29.08.2020, the respondent filed an
application for pre-litigation mediation before the South District Legal
Services Authority whereby a Non- Starter Report vide reference no. 187
/08/Med/South/DLSA/2020/1133-1134 was issued.
4.
Pursuant thereto, in 2021 the respondent instituted the underlying suit
seeking recovery of Rs. 17,42,216/- with pendente lite and future interest
computed from the date of notice i.e., 17.03.2020 till its realization @ 24%
per annum, along with cost of the suit.
5.
After the issuance of summons, on 26.07.2021 the petitioner placed its
written statement on record, whereby it was categorically stated that there is
no amount payable by the petitioner to the respondent.
6.
During the pendency of the proceedings, the respondent preferred an
application under Order VII Rule 14 (3) read with Section 151 of the CPC,
but the same was not pressed. Another application under Order XI Rule 1 of
the CPC was moved on behalf of the respondent seeking to place on record
additional documents which came to be allowed by the learned Trial Court
vide order dated 23.02.2023.
7.
At the next date of hearing, the learned counsel for the respondent
raised certain objections qua the written statement filed by the petitioner. It
was submitted that the written statement was not accompanied with the
statement of truth, any Board Resolution that authorised Mr. Thakur Ratish
Mahesh to represent the petitioner etc.. In view thereof, the learned Trial
Hereinafter „CPC‟
Signed By:ANKITA CM(M)
RAI
3094/2024
17:19:17
Court vide the order dated 17.05.2023, granted the petitioner an adjournment
to rectify the said errors subject to cost of Rs. 10,000/-.
8.
Consequently, the petitioner rectified the errors and placed the
necessary documents on record while citing inadvertence for failure to file the
same initially. Meanwhile, the respondent moved an application under Order
XIII A read with Section 151 of the CPC seeking summary judgment. The
petitioner duly responded to the said application and moved an additional
application under Order VII Rule 11 read with Section 151 of the CPC.
9.
After hearing the parties and perusing the record, the learned Trial
Court vide order dated 19.01.2024 dismissed the application of the petitioner
under Order VII Rule 11 read with Section 151 of the CPC and listed the
matter for arguments on the application of the respondent under Order XIII A
read with Section 151 of the CPC.
10.
Simultaneously, on 05.02.2024 the petitioner moved an application
under Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC seeking to include the fact that the
petitioner issued only three purchase orders whereas the respondent filed
invoices for a value exceeding the cumulative amount of such purchase
orders.
11.
The learned Trial Court vide the impugned order dated 08.07.2024
dismissed both the application of the petitioner under Order VI Rule 17 of the
CPC as the well as the application of the respondent seeking summary
judgment under Order XIII A read with Section 151 of the CPC.
12.
Through the impugned order the learned Trial Court also framed issues
namely, “(1) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of the suit amount,
as claimed? OPP” and “(2) Relief” and put up the matter for Plaintiff‟s
evidence on 05.08.2024 and for Defendant‟s evidence on 20.08.2024. The
observations made by the learned Trial Court while dismissing the application
Signed By:ANKITA CM(M)
RAI
3094/2024
17:19:17
of the petitioner read thus:
“3. Invoices and purchase orders referred in the application seeking
amendment are pertaining to year 2016. Query was made to Ld.
Counsel for defendant as to how these facts came to the notice
lateron when the invoices or the purchase orders are bearing the
date of year 2016. It is submitted by Ld. Counsel for defendant that
when the documents were being scrutinized, then this fact was
noted.
4. Ld. Counsel for defendant has also placed reliance upon Rajesh
Kumar Aggarwal & Ors. Vs. K.K. Modi and Others (2006) 4
Supreme Court Cases 385, wherein it was noted that the object of
rule is that the courts should try the merits of the case that come
before them and should, consequently, allow all amendment that
may be necessary for determining the real question in controversy
between the parties provided it does not cause injustice or
prejudice to the other side.
5. In the said judgment, it was also noted that such amendment
should be necessary for the purpose of determining the real
question in controversy between the parties. However, no
application for amendment should be allowed after the trial has
commenced, unless the court comes to the conclusion that in spite
of the due dilligence, the party could not have raised the matter for
which amendment is sought before the commencement of the trial.
6. In the instant matter, defendant has categorically denied
about the existence of purchase orders and the invoices and
also denied the same in the Affidavit of Admission/Denial of
documents. By way of amendment application, defendant now
seeks to alter the said defence, which is not permissible under
application under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC. Besides that, the
amendment sought is not based upon any new facts which were not
in knowledge of the defendant earlier. Application accordingly
stands dismissed.”
13.
Aggrieved by the dismissal of its application seeking amendment, the
petitioner herein approached this Court through the present petition. This
Court vide order dated 02.08.2024 declined to stay the underlying proceedings
but directed the learned Trial Court to not dispose of the matter finally.
14.
Thereafter, the Plaintiff‟s evidence stood concluded on 30.04.2025, the
Defendant‟s evidence stood concluded on 13.08.2025 and the matter is now
Signed By:ANKITA CM(M)
RAI
3094/2024
17:19:17
standing at the stage of final arguments.
15.
Mr. L.B. Rai, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, submits
that when the subject application was filed, neither the trial had commenced
nor had any evidence been tendered and therefore, no prejudice would have
been caused to the respondent had the application been allowed. It is further
submitted that the petitioner did not seek to introduce new facts, fill lacunae,
or delay the proceedings and that the proposed amendment was essential to
crystallize the core issue pertaining to the exact number of purchase orders
issued.
16.
To fortify his contentions, Mr. Rai places reliance on the decision of
the Hon‟ble Apex Court in Rajesh Kumar Aggarwal v. K.K. Modi3 to
contend that all amendments which are necessary to determine the real
question in controversy between the parties, should be allowed, provided that
no prejudice is caused to the opposite party. Additional reliance is placed on
the decision of this Court in Time Warner Entertainment Co., LP. v. A.K.
Das4 to contend that amendments can be permitted notwithstanding delay and
laches, if the same is necessary to do complete justice.
17.
Per Contra, Mr. Rishi Sood, the learned counsel for the respondent
submits that the petitioner having categorically denied any transactions,
purchase orders, and invoices in its written statement as well as in its affidavit
of admission/denial, cannot now turn around to admit the purchase orders and
introduce a contradictory defence. It is further submitted that the subject
amendment application of the petitioner is bereft of any reasonable cause to
explain as to why the defence sought to be introduced through the application
was omitted at the time of filing the initial written statement.
(2006) 4 SCC 385
2002 SCC OnLine Del 1421
Signed By:ANKITA CM(M)
RAI
3094/2024
17:19:17
18.
Heard. Perused the record.
19.
The primary grievance of the petitioner is that the learned Trial Court
adopted a hyper-technical approach in dismissing its application under Order
VI Rule 17 of the CPC, as that the proposed amendment was essential to
adjudicate the real controversy between the parties and the trial not yet
commenced.
20.
A bare perusal of the original written statement dated 26.07.2021,
specifically of paragraphs 4, 5, and 6, demonstrates that the petitioner
unequivocally denied any payment due to the respondent and receipt of any
tax invoices. Further perusal of the petitioner‟s affidavit of admission/denial
of documents makes it clear that the petitioner denied the existence of any
purchase orders as well. Relevant paragraphs of the written statement are
reproduced hereunder for ready reference:
“4. That the contents of Para No.4 of the Plaint are wrong and
denied. It is denied that the Plaintiff has completed delivery of the
order of items which are allegedly placed by the Plaintiff upon
Defendant. Rest of the contents of para under reply are wrong and
denied.
5.That the contents of Para No.5 of the Plaint are wrong and
denied. It is denied that Plaintiff has ever issued Tax invoices to the
Defendant and the same was not cleared by the Defendant. It is
submitted that no amount is payable by the Defendant to the
Plaintiff, so there is no question of issuing Tax invoices by the
Plaintiff upon Defendant. Rest of the contents of para under reply
are wrong and denied.
6. That the contents of Para No.6 of the Plaint are wrong and
denied. It is denied that the amount of Rs. 17,42,216/- (Rupees
Seventeen Lakhs Forty Two Thousand Two Hundred and Sixteen
only) is due and payable by Defendant to Plaintiff. Since no
amount is payable by Defendant, so there is no question of issuing
any Tax invoices by Plaintiff upon Defendant. Rest of the contents
of para under reply are wrong and denied.”
Signed By:ANKITA CM(M)
RAI
3094/2024
17:19:17
21.
However, by way of the proposed amendment, the petitioner sought to
incorporate one more paragraph, as paragraph 18, in the written statement to
plead that it had, in fact, issued three purchase orders totalling Rs.43,36,162/-,
two dated 21.12.2015 and one dated 27.01.2016. On this foundation, the
petitioner sought to contend that there was no occasion for the respondent to
issue invoices upon the petitioner for Rs. 76,20,362/-. An excerpt from the
proposed amendment reads thus:
“That the defendants have issued only three purchase orders to the
plaintiff being two purchase orders dated 21.12.2015 and third
purchase order dated 27.01.2016 total for Rs. 43,36,162/-. The
details of purchase orders are as under:XXXXXX
The Plaintiffs have filed invoices on record for Rs. 76,20,362/-.
Since purchase orders are issued only for Rs. 43,36,162/ so there is
no occasion for the plaintiff to issue invoices upon defendant for
Rs. 76,20,362/-.”
22.
It is thus evident that by way of the proposed amendment, the petitioner
did not elaborate upon or clarify an existing stand taken in its written
statement, but rather, sought to completely retract its categorical denial of
purchase orders and tax invoices made via the original written statement and
affidavit of admission/denial, in an attempt to set up a new factual case.
23.
Furthermore, the only justification proffered by the petitioner for
seeking the proposed amendment after a delay of three years is that the
purchase orders came to its knowledge only at a later stage. This explanation
is wholly unconvincing as firstly, it is not reasonable for a corporate entity to
remain oblivious to its own purchase orders at the time of drafting its written
statement and secondly, inadvertence in verifying one‟s own records cannot
be considered by the Court to grant the relief of amendment. The explanation
mentioned by the petitioner in the subject application dated 05.02.2024 is
reproduced hereunder for ready reference:
Signed By:ANKITA CM(M)
RAI
3094/2024
17:19:17
“2. That the defendants have filed their written statement but some
very relevant facts has come to the knowledge of the defendants
recently which defendants wants to incorporate in their written
statement by way of amendment.”
24.
It is no longer res integra that a party cannot alter and amend its
pleadings to the effect of resiling from its original stance. While a party is
permitted to take alternate pleas, such pleas cannot be mutually destructive of
each other. At this juncture, it is pertinent to emphasize upon the principle
laid down by the Hon‟ble Apex Court in Gautam Sarup v. Leela Jetly5 which
reads as follows:
“28. What, therefore, emerges from the discussions made
hereinbefore is that a categorical admission cannot be resiled from
but, in a given case, it may be explained or clarified. Offering
explanation in regard to an admission or explaining away the same,
however, would depend upon the nature and character thereof. It
may be that a defendant is entitled to take an alternative plea. Such
alternative pleas, however, cannot be mutually destructive of each
other.”
25.
It is settled that courts must adopt a liberal approach while considering
an application for amendment; however, such liberty is not absolute. The
grant of an amendment is discretionary and cannot be claimed as a matter of
right or entitlement. Consequently, the petitioner herein cannot seek
indulgence to introduce an amendment that is essentially an afterthought,
seeking to resile from a stance previously taken.
26.
Importantly, reliance placed by learned counsel for the petitioner on
Rajesh Kumar Aggarwal (supra) and Time Warner Entertainment Co., LP.
(supra) is misplaced and does not advance its case. In the former case, the
amendment was necessary owing to subsequent events which arose during the
pendency of the suit and resulted in a mere alteration of the relief claimed.
(2008) 7 SCC 85
Signed By:ANKITA CM(M)
RAI
3094/2024
17:19:17
Whereas, in the latter case, amendment was sought due to a subsequent
development and was necessary for proper adjudication of the dispute and
was hence permitted notwithstanding the delay and laches. Contrarily, the
petitioner herein seeks to introduce a defence that is mutually destructive of
its original stance, by relying upon its own purchase orders dating back to
2016, which were available to the petitioner even before the institution of the
suit.
27.
During the course of arguments, the learned counsel for the petitioner
placed further reliance on Dinesh Goyal v. Suman Agarwal (Bindal)6 to
make out a case for allowance of its amendment application. This decision,
like the aforementioned decisions, is distinguishable from the present case. In
the said case, the Hon‟ble Apex Court permitted amendment in a partition
suit, observing that determination of the question of will was necessary to
adjudicate the inter se dispute between the parties. However, in the present
case, the petitioner is not seeking to challenge a document set up by the
opposite side but is rather attempting to resile from its own denial.
28.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the view that the
learned Trial Court rightly dismissed the application of the petitioner under
Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC, as the petitioner cannot be permitted to resile
from its own denial, and introduce a mutually destructive defence. The
impugned order dated 08.07.2024 suffers from no jurisdictional infirmity,
perversity, or patent illegality warranting interference under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India. Accordingly, the petition, being devoid of merit, is
dismissed along with the pending applications, if any.
29.
It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the
merits of the rival claims.
Signed By:ANKITA CM(M)
RAI
3094/2024
17:19:17
30.
The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.
AJAY DIGPAUL, J.
SEPTEMBER 18, 2026/gs/as
2024 SCC OnLine SC 2615
Signed By:ANKITA CM(M)
RAI
3094/2024
17:19:17
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review