Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
Date of decision: 30th September, 2026
Uploaded on: 5th October, 2026
CNR No. DLHC010474192026
+
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
M/S HAYAGREV CIVIL ENGINEERING PVT LTD. .....Appellant
Through: Mr. Anirudh Wadhwa, Mr. Raghav
Wadhwa, Ms. Anjali Jain, Mr.
Siddharth
Jain,
Advs.
(M:
9465351015)
versus
NBCC (INDIA) LIMITED & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Gudipati G. Kashyap, Mr.
Ranvijay Gohain, Mr. Nishant Pandit
and Mr. Deepak, Advs.
CORAM:
JUSTICE PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUSTICE DINESH BHATT
Prathiba M. Singh, J. (Oral)
1.
This hearing has been done through hybrid mode.
CM APPL.68301/2026 (for exemption)
2.
Allowed, subject to all just exceptions. Application is disposed of.
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
3.
The present appeal has been filed by the Appellant under Order XLIII
Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter, ‘CPC’) read with
Section 13(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, inter alia, assailing the
impugned order dated 20th August, 2026 passed by the ld. Single Judge in
I.A. No. 14495/2026 in CS (COMM) No. 331/2024 titled ‘Hayagreve Civil
Engineering Private Ltd. v. NBCC India Ltd.’
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
17:33:28
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
4.
The brief background of the present case is that, a suit being CS
(COMM) No. 331/2024 was filed by the Appellant against the RespondentNBCC (India) Limited seeking various reliefs, including recovery of a sum of
of Rs.6,59,13,849/- against the Respondent.
5.
The recovery of the aforesaid amount was in respect of certain works,
which were executed by the Appellant for the Respondent in the project called
the Construction of Cooling Tower (NDCT) including Raft Foundation,
Basin, Columns & Shell etc. all complete Civil Site Works for BHEL/GSECL
at 1x800 MW Wanakbori Super Critical TPP Unit-8, District- Kheda
(Gujarat).
6.
In the said suit, an application under Order XXXIX Rule 10 of CPC
was filed by the Appellant seeking directions to the Respondent to deposit the
admitted amount to the tune of Rs. 4,00,17,407/-, before the Court. The said
application was disposed of by the ld. Single Judge, vide order dated 26th
November, 2025.
7.
Vide the said order, the ld. Single Judge, after considering paragraph 12
of the written statement filed by the Respondent, had directed as under:
“1. The plaintiff has filed the instant application seeking
directions to the defendant to deposit Rs. 4,00,17,407/before this Court.
2. In paragraph no. 12 of the written statement,
following position has been taken by the defendant.
“12. Thus, the balance payable amount of
Rs.4,00,17,407/- to the plaintiff with respect
to project “Construction of Cooling Tower
(NDCT) including Raft Foundation, Basin,
Columns & Shell etc. all complete Civil Site
Works for BHEL/GSECL at 1x800 MW
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
17:33:28
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
Wanakbori Super Critical TPP Unit-8,
District-Kheda (Gujarat)”, was transferred
from NDCT works, Wanakbori to NDCT
works, Yadadri under Clause 26 of the
contract entered into between the plaintiff and
the defendant. That Clause 26 of the contract
states thus:
“26.0 WITHHOLDING AND LIEN IN
RESPECT OF SUMS DUE FROM
CONTRACTOR
26.1 Whenever any claim or claims for
payment of a sum of money arises out of or
under the contract or against the contractor,
NBCC shall be entitled to withhold and also
have a lien to retain such sum or sums in
whole or in part from the security, if any,
deposited by the contractor and for the
purpose aforesaid, NBCC shall be entitled to
withhold the security deposit, if any, furnished
as the case may be and also have a lien over
the same pending finalization or adjudication
of any such claim. In the event of the security
being insufficient to cover the claimed amount
or amounts or if no security has been taken
from the contractor, NBCC shall be entitled
to withhold and have a lien to retain to the
extent of such claimed amount or amounts
referred to above from any sum or sums found
payable or which may at any time there after
become payable to the contractor under the
same contract or any other contract pending
finalization of adjudication of any such claim.
26.2 It is an agreed term of the contract that
the sum of money or moneys so Withheld or
retained under the lien referred to above by
the Engineer-in- Charge or NBCC will be
kept withheld or retained as such by the
Engineer in-Charge or NBCC till the claim
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
17:33:28
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
arising out of or under the contract is
determined by the competent court and that
the contractor will have no claim for interest
or damages whatsoever on any account in
respect of such withholding or retention
under the lien referred to above and duly
notified as such to the contractor. For the
purpose of this clause, where the contractor is
a partnership firm or a limited company, the
Engineer-in-Charge or the NBCC shall be
entitled to withhold and also have a lien to
retain towards such claimed amount or
amounts in whole or in part from any sum
found payable to any partner/limited
company, as the case may be in his individual
capacity or otherwise. NBCC shall have the
right to cause an audit and technical
examination of the works and the final bills of
the contractor including all supporting
vouchers, abstract, etc, to be made after
payment of the final bill and if as a result of
such audit and technical examination any sum
is found to have been overpaid in respect of
any work done by the contractor under the
contract or any work claimed to have been
done by him under the contract and found not
to have been executed, the contractor shall be
liable to refund the amount of over-payment
and it shall be lawful for NBCC to recover the
same from him in the manner prescribed in
sub-clause 26.1 of this clause or in any other
manner legally permissible; and if it is found
that the contractor was paid less than what
was due to him under the contract in respect
of any work executed by him under it, the
amount of such under payment shall be
duly paid by NBCC to the contractor, without
any interest thereon whatsoever.
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
17:33:28
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
26.3 LIEN IN RESPECT OF CLAIMS IN
OTHER CONTRACTS
Any sum of money due and payable to the
contractor (including the security deposit
returnable to him) under the contract may be
withheld or retained by way of lien by the
Engineer-in-Charge or by NBCC against any
claim of the Engineer-in-Charge or NBCC in
respect of payment of a sum of money arising
out of or under any other contract made by the
contractor with the Engineer-in-Charge or
the NBCC. It is an agreed term of the contract
that the sum of money so withheld or retained
under this clause by the Engineer-in-Charge
or the NBCC will be kept withheld or retained
as such by the Engineer-in-Charge or the
NBCC or till his claim arising out of the same
contract is or any other contract is either
mutually settled or determined by the
competent court, as the case may be, and that
the contractor shall have no claim for interest
or damages whatsoever on this account or on
any other ground in respect of any sum of
money withheld or retained under this clause
and duly notified as such to the contractor.”
Further, because of slow progress of work by
plaintiff, since client (BHEL) has withdrawn
the project “Construction of NDCT” to
plaintiff at Yadadri, Telangana vide LOA No
–
NBCC/ED(CPG)/2021/726
dated
05.03.2021 for an amount of Rs.98.75
Crores” from the defendant and since the
entire work of CT#1,3 & 5 is being executed
through other agency at the risk & cost of
Defendant (NBCC), the plaintiff is liable to
compensate the defendant for the said actual
loss, which can be calculated only after
completion of the said works. However, it is
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
17:33:28
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
pertinent to mention that the defendant has
also challenged the termination by BHEL
before the Administrative Mechanism for
Resolution of CPSEs Disputes (AMRCD), a
forum established to resolve the disputes
between two Government entities. It is
clarified that the dispute before AMRCD is
pending and has not been finalized yet. The
defendant company reserves its right to
quantify the said and claim the same from the
plaintiff, which the defendant is liable to be
compensated, as per relevant Contractual
clause agreed between the parties. It is
clarified that a clear picture with regard to
the dues recoverable from the plaintiff would
be possible once the pending dispute between
Defendant and BHEL before AMRCD is
finalized. Hence, as per the relevant
contractual clauses the amount of plaintiff is
rightly withheld by the defendant and the
instant suit filed by the plaintiff is
premature.”
3. Under these circumstances, it is directed that without
prejudice to the rights and contentions, the aforesaid
amount be deposited before the Registrar General of
this Court within a period of six months from today, who
shall keep the same in an interest bearing FDR.”
8.
Pursuant to the order dated 26th November, 2025, the amount was
deposited by the Respondent before this Court.
9.
Thereafter, the Appellant preferred an application under Section 151 of
CPC, seeking withdrawal of the deposited amount.
10.
However, the said withdrawal was opposed by the Respondent, stating
that the said deposit was an interim deposit and not an admitted amount. Vide
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
17:33:28
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
order dated 20th August, 2026 passed by the ld. Single Judge, the said
application was disposed of in the following terms:
“2. Pursuant thereto, an amount of Rs.4,00,17,407/was deposited by the defendant. The defendant claims a
contractual lien over the said amount, citing a separate,
unresolved dispute under another project.
3. Learned counsel for the plaintiff submits that there is
no linkage between the deposited amount and the
dispute sought to be raised by the defendant in respect
of the other project. The same is, however, refuted by
the learned counsel for the defendant.
4. The present application seeks that the plaintiff be
permitted to withdraw the amount deposited by the
defendant pursuant to the aforesaid order dated
26.11.2025.
5. The defendant has admitted in its written statement
that the amount owed to the plaintiff under the contract,
which is the subject matter of the present suit, is to the
tune of Rs.4,00,17,407/-.
6. Considering the circumstances, the plaintiff is
permitted to withdraw the said amount, subject to
furnishing an unconditional bank guarantee to the
satisfaction of the Registrar of this Court for an
equivalent amount, as also an undertaking agreeing to
abide by orders passed by this Court for restitution of
the said amount, if so required in future.
7. It is directed accordingly.”
11.
In terms thereof, the Court had permitted the Appellant to withdraw the
admitted amount to the tune of Rs.4,00,17,407/-, subject to furnishing of
unconditional bank guarantee to the satisfaction of the Registrar General of
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
17:33:28
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
this Court, for an equivalent amount as also to furnish an undertaking agreeing
to abide by the orders passed by this Court for restitution of the said amount,
if required.
12.
Aggrieved by the said order, the Appellant has preferred the present
appeal.
13.
The submission on behalf of the ld. Counsel for the Appellant is that
for the amount of Rs.4,00,17,407/-, there cannot be any lien by the
Respondent, in respect of a separate project, which is known as Yadadri
project.
14.
On the other hand, ld. Counsel for the Respondent relies upon clause
26.3 in the Yadadri project contract to argue that the lien in respect of claims
in other contracts can also be maintained by the Respondent.
15.
Further, it is also submitted by ld. Counsel for the Appellant that
unconditional withdrawal of the amount ought to have been permitted, as the
same is deposited, pursuant to the admission made by the Respondent.
16.
On the other hand, ld. Counsel for the Respondent relies upon clause
26.3 in the Yadadri project contract to argue that Respondent can retain the
amount.
17.
The Court has heard ld. Counsel for the parties. At the outset, a query
has been put to ld. Counsel for the Appellant, as to how the present appeal is
maintainable, as the same is challenging an order passed in an application
under Section 151 of CPC. The said order is a discretionary order permitting
the conditional withdrawal of the deposited amount.
18.
In response, ld. Counsel Mr. Jain submits that the order has been passed
in furtherance of the order passed in application under Order XXXIX Rule 10
of CPC.
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
17:33:28
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
19.
In the opinion of this Court, the application under Order XXXIX Rule
10 of CPC was disposed of directing the deposit of the amount before the
Registrar General of this Court and further direction was made that the same
would be kept in an interest bearing FDR.
20.
Order XXXIX Rule 10 of CPC is primarily meant to safeguard and
secure the interest of the Appellant-Plaintiff, subject to satisfying the
conditions set out in the said provision. The said application was disposed of
vide order dated 26th November, 2025.
21.
The impugned order dated 20th August, 2026, was passed in respect of
the application filed by the Appellant under Section 151 of CPC , seeking
withdrawal of the deposited amount, pursuant to order dated 26th November,
2025. While disposing of the application under Section 151 of CPC, the Court
exercised discretion and permitted withdrawal of the amount, subject to
certain conditions.
22.
In the opinion of this Court, such an order does not fall within any of
the clauses of Order XLIII Rule 1 of CPC, and is not an appealable order.
23.
In fact, the Supreme Court in Keshardeo Chamria v. Radha Kissen
Chamria, (1952) 2 SCC 329 has held that an order passed under Section 151
of CPC is not appealable under Order XLIII Rule 1 of CPC. The relevant
portion of the said decision is as under:
“[…]18. It was not contended and could not be seriously
urged, that an order under Section 151 simpliciter is
appealable. Under the Code of Civil Procedure certain
specific orders mentioned in Section 104 and Order 43
Rule 1, only are appealable and no appeal lies from any
other orders (vide Section 105 CPC). An order made
under Section 151 is not included in the category of
appealable orders.”
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
17:33:28
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
24.
Further, Section 13(1A) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 permits
an appeal only against orders enumerated in Order XLIII Rule 1 of CPC. The
impugned order dated 20th August, 2026 does not fall within the category of
appealable orders under Order XLIII Rule 1 of CPC. Consequently, the
present appeal is not maintainable.
25.
Thus, without going into the merits of the matter, the present appeal is
held as being not maintainable and the same is, accordingly, dismissed.
PRATHIBA M. SINGH
JUDGE
DINESH BHATT
JUDGE
SEPTEMBER 30, 2026/dk/sm
Digitally Signed
By:DHIRENDER KUMAR
17:33:28
FAO(OS) (COMM) 272/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review