The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. Consequt:ntly, the miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed. Rs. Ps Costs Quarrtified by Hon'ble Court (That the Petitioner herein and Counsel for the oetitioner are d irected to pay costs of ii.s 1,00.000/- (Rupees one Lakh only) in favour of the ResPondents. 1,00,000-00 iFo,ooo-oo SD/.P. PONNA KRISHNA //TRUE COPY// \/ To, Sri. GVK Gautami Power Llmrted Sy No.43 ,,['OO' plot no.43,54,57 and 58, 4th f loor Mahaveer Radiance, Pillar number 1708 ,MA dhapur, Hyderabad, Telangana, lndia 500081 Represented by it's Director Mr. Sunil Kumar saraf The Chairman and Managing Director, Southern Power Distribution Company of Andhra Pradesh, Limited, besides Srinivasa Kalyana Mandapam, Tiruchanur Road, Tirupathi - 517501 (hereinafter referred to as APSPDCL) 3 The Chairman and Managing Director, Eastern Power Distribution Company of Andhra Pradesh, Limited, P&T Colony, Seethammadhara, Vishakhapatnam - 530020 (hereinafter referred to as APEPDCL) 4 The Chairman and Managing Director, Southern Power Distribution Company ofTelangana Ltd., 6-1-50, Vidyut Saudha, Khairatabad, Hyderabad E The Chairman and Managing Director, Northern Power Distribution Company '1-1-503 and 504, of Telangana Limited, Having its registered Office at H. No. Opp NIT Petrol Pump. Chaitanyapuri, Hanamkonda, Warangal - 506 004 (hereinafter referred to as TSNPDCL) 6 The Chairman and Managing Director, Tel…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3300 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENry SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION NO : 19268 OF 2016
Between:
M/s. GVK Gautami Power Limited, Sy. No.43 and 44, plot no 43,54,57 and 58'
4th floor Mahaveer Radiance, Pillar number 1708, Madhapur, Hyderabad,
Telangana, lndia 500081 Represented by it's Director Mr' Sunil Kumar Saraf
Address of Petitioner no.1 is amended as per C.O.dt.15'09'2025 in lA
No.1/2025.
...PETITIONER
AND
Southern Power Distribution company of Andhra Pradesh, Limited, besides
Srinivasa Kalyana Mandapam, Tiruchanur Road, Tirupathi - 517501
Represented by its chairman and Managing Director, (hereinafter referred to
as APSPDCL)
J
EasternPowerDistributionCompanyofAndhraPradesh,Limited,P&T
Colony, Seethammadhara, Vishakhapatnam - 530020 Represented by its
Chairman and Managing Director, (hereinafter referred to as APEPDCL)
Southern Power Distribution Company of Telangana Ltd, 6-1-50, Vidyut
Saudha, Khairatabad, Hyderabad Represented by its Chairman and
Managrng Director,
E
b
Northern Power Distribution Company of Telangana Limited, Having its
registered Office at H. No. '1-'1-503 and 504, Opp NIT Petrol Pump'
Chiaitanyapuri, Hanamkonda, Warangal - 506 004 Represented by its
Chairmjn and Managing Director, (hereinafter referred to as TSNPDCL)
Telangana State Transmission Corporation Ltd, (TSTRANSCO) Vidyut
Saudh]a, Khairatabad, Hyderabad. Represented by its Chairman and
Managing Director,
Transmission corporation of Andhra Pradesh(APTRANSCO), Vidyut saudha,
Khairatabad, Hyderabad. Represented by its Chairman and Managing
Director,
T,AndhraPradeshPowerCoordinationCommittee(APPCC),VidyutSaudha,
Khairatabad, Hyderabad Represented by its Chairman and Managing
Director,
B Telangana State Power Coordination Committee' Vidyut Suadha'
and
Khairatabad, Hyderabad (TSPCC) Represented by its Chairman
Managing Director,
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Arltcle 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
pleased
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
to issue a writ. direction oT order especially in the nature of a writ of mandamus
'l
of.
declaring that the inaction of the Respondents to 4 in reimbursing the amount
to the
Rs.24,28,91 ,324t- i e.ihe Minimum Alternate Tax (MAT) paid by the Petitioner
lncome tax Department for the financial years 2009-10 and 2010-l1 and the interest
occurred on the amounts paid towards MAT, in accordance with the order
passed by
the then Andhra Pradesh Electricity Regulatory commission on 12-8-2013 in
o P.No.2.1 ol 2013 which has been upheld by the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity
and the Hon,ble supreme court on 24-11-2015 in civil Appeal No.3006 of 2015 and
requested by the Petitioner to he paid by letter dated 31-12-2015 as being illegal,
arbitrary, unlawful and violative of the order passed by the Hon',ble supreme court
and, consequen y, directing the Respondents to make payment of the amount
directed to be paid in the order dated 21-8-2013 passed by the then Andhra Pradesh
Electricity Regulatory Commission in O.P No.21 of 2013
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2016 {w PMP. NO: 23628 0F 2016
Petition under section '15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased direct the
Respondents to secure 50 % of the amount payable by way of a bank guarantee and
to pay the remaining 50% amount with immediate effect.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI AVINASH DESAI SR. COUNSEL ASSISTED BY
SRI CH. PUSHYAM KIRAN
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1,2,6&7: SRI VIKRAM POOSARLA SR.
COUNSEL ASSISTED BY SRI MALIPEDDI ABHINAY REDDY, SC FOR APSPDCL
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.3,5&8: SRI N.SREEDHAR REDDY, SC FOR TS
TRANSCO
Counsel for the Respondent No.4: SRI A.CHANDRA SHAKER, SC FOR
TSNPDCL
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR THE STATE OF
TELAI{GANA
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NAGESH BHEEMAPAKA
WRIT PETITION No. 19268 OF 2016
09.06.2026
Between:
M/s CIVK Gautami Power Limited
Petitioner
And
Southern Pou'er Disl.ribution Co. of AP Ltd
& othcrs
.. .. Respondents
ORPER:
Heard Sri Avinash Desai, learned Senior Counsel
assisted b1 Sri Ch. Pushyam Kiran, learned. counsel for
petitioner, Sri N. Sreedhar Reddy, learned Standing Counsel on
behall of Responclents 3, 5 and 8, Sri Vikram Poosarla, learned
Scnior Counsel assisted by Sri M. Abhinay Reddy learned
counsel on behalf of Rcspondents 1, 2, 6 ar'd 7 and Sri A.
Chandra Shaker, learned Standing Counsel on behalf of
Respondent No.4.
2.
Petitioner is a Company incorporated under the
Companies Acr, engaged in the business of generation and sale
of electrical energ.. It is stated, on 31.03. 1997, petitioner and
ersr',t'hile A.P. State Electricity Board (ApSEB) have entered into
a Por"t.er Purchase Agreement (ppA). After unbundling of A. p.
State Electricity Board, pursuant to Electricity Reforms Act, AP
TRANSCO (the 6trr Respondent) succeeded to the contractual
rights and obligations of APSEB. As per PPA, respondents are
bound to reimburse all taxes levied on the income of petitioner,
which, according to petitioner, includes M'A'T paid during
subsistence of P.P.A.
It is further stated, as the 66 respondent did not
reimburse the M.A.T paid by petitioner, the latter was
2.1.
constrained to approach the AP Electricity Regulatory
Commission (APERC) by filing O.P. No' 2l of 2073' The said
Commission, by Order dated, 12.8.2013, allowed the claim and
directed respondents to reimburse the M'A T' payments made
by petitioner along with interest, in terms of P'P'A' As against
the same, the 6fr respondent preferred Appeal before the
Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (APIEL) uide Appeal No' 15 of
2014 which was dismissed. Against the same, Respondents frled
C.A. No. 30O6 of 2015 before the Hon'ble Supreme Court which
alsostooddismissedon24.ll.20l5'Itistherefore,contended
by learned Senior Counsel that in view of the order of A'P'E'R C'
dt.12.08.2013 becoming final, on account of dismissal of C A'
No. 30O6 of 2O15 by the Hon'ble Supreme Court' the order of
the A.P.E.R.C. shall be complied with by Respondents by
reimbursing M.A.T. payment along with interest
J
2.2.
It is lurther stated that pending the above Writ
Petition, Insoh,cncv proceedings were initiated against petitioner
by Edelu'eiss Asset Reconstruction Company uide C.P. (L.8.) No.
391l7 IHBD 12022 belore National Company Law Tribunal
(NCLT). The NCLT admitted the petition and ordered initiation of
Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process against petitioner
herein.'lhe Resolution PIan submitted by R.S.P.L. was approved
by N.C.L.T. on 06.011.2025 and R.S.P.L. acquired petitioner
herein. therefore, I.A. No. I of 2025 was filed seeking permission
of this Court to amend the cause title thereby substituting the
new managemenl to represent petitioner. The said I.A. was
allowcd on 15.O9.2O25. It is argued by learned Senior Counsel
that in view of the facts stated above, petitioner is entitled for
reimbursemt:nt of M.A.T. amounts paid by them along with
interest in tune with the orders passed by A.P.E.R.C. as
affirmed by Hon'ble Supreme Court and as respondents have
not complied n,ith thc said directions, this Writ Petition is filed.
3.
Learned Standing Counsel for Respondents 3, 5 &
8, Sri N. Sreedhar Reddlr filed a detailed counter and has taken
a prcliminary objection that this Writ Petition is filed for
execlltion of thc order of A.P.E.R.C., hence, it is not
maintninable under Article 226 of the Constitution. It is
contended, petitioncr is a gas-based power generation project
located in Peddapuram of East Godavari District'
in the State of
13'03' 1997 by
Andhra Pradesh. P.P.A. was entered into on
with A.P.S.E.B, pursuant to which' petitioner started
petitioner
itscommercialoperationsandsuppliedgeneratedpowerfrom
petitioner
15.06.2009 onwards till 1O'02'2013' Thereafter'
became defunct in view of lack of supply
of gas to it and there
were no commercia-I operations from 1O'O2'2O13
It is stated'
P.P.A. was valid for 15 years w'e f
15'6 2009 (date of
commission) and as per clauses of P'P'A '
AP DISCOMs used to
issue open Letter of Credit (L'C ) with validity
time to time. The Letter of Credit was issued
of one year' from
for Rs 18'82 crores
on 16.12.2012, vaJid' up to 15 12'2013' with maximum
drawl
limitofRs.go.33Crorespermonthi.e.dependinguponthe
is stated that due to
preceding year's average monthly bills It
scarcity of gas, petitioner could not generate
power and achieve
the normal Plant Load Factor (P'L'F') of
8O% of its capacity' but
however, petitioner was generating bills
at the normal P'L F' of
80%o,eventhoughitwasnotproducingpowertothesaid
capacity. It is stated that petitioner achieved
only 13'35% of
P L'F' from
P.L.F. from lO.l2'2O12 to 1O'01'2013 arrd '44o/o
plant was shut
10.01.2013 to 1O.O2'2O13 and thereafter' the
downduetolackofrawmateriali.e.gas.Therefore'thecapacity
were restricted
charges claimed by the generator/ petitioner
only to actual generatecl enerS' and accordingly'
payments were
made
3. 1.
hled O.P.
lt is stated that aggrieved by the same' petitioner
with I A No' 1 of
No. E of 20 lil before A P'E R C' along
20 13 for interim order' The
sairl I A was dismissed by
A.P.E.R.C as against u'hich petitioner frled
Appeal No' 101 and
l02of20l3beforeAPTEL.TheAPTELwaspleasedtodisposeof
the appeals bv order dated 28'05'2O 13' directing
dispose of the main petition expeditiously'
three months. In the meantime, due to
the APERC to
i'e' within a period of
bifurcation of composite
State o[ Andhra Pradesh into State of Telangana
and residuary
State ol Andhra Pradesh, and formation
of separate Electricity
Regulatory Commissions in each of the
States' O P No' 8 of
201 3 was transferred from A'P E
R C' to C E'R'C' (Central
there was no
Electricity Regulatory Commission)' Even though
was sti1l
actlvity trom lL O2'2O13 onwards' petitioner
generalion
raising its invotces on the erstwhiie DISCOMs
based on its 80%
P.L.F-. As the DISCOMs did not admit
the said invoices'
petilioner presented the same before State
Bank of Hyderabad'
Gunfoundry Branch, Hyderabad and encashed
the Letter of
Credit issued b1' DISCOMS
3.'2.
It is s@ted, AP DISCOMs filed OS No' 444 of 2O13
along r,"'ith Interlocutory Applications before the City
Civii Court'
Hyderabad for grant of injunction restraining the generator/
petitioner from invoking the Letter of Credit and also against
Bank directing not to honour the illegal claims made by
petitioner. The City Civil Court dismissed the I'As' as against
which DISCOMs hled C.M'A' No 865 of 2O13 before this Court'
which also stood dismissed. The DISCOMs frled a complaint
before the Banking Ombudsman against the Banker for
releasing the Letter of Credit' The Ombudsman' by its
dated 3O.5.2016, informed that the Banker has acted as
Ietter
per the
terms of the L'C. and the matter has been treated as sufhciently
dealtandclosed.Petitioner,takingadvantageofavailabilityof
Letter of Credit has encashed to a tune of Rs' 276'24 crores
different spells from 13.03.2013 to 17 '12 2013 during
the PY
2Ol2-13 arrd.2OL3-14.It is stated that apart from the amount
Rs. 276.24 crores, petitioner is also iiable to
at
of
pay true up arrears
of Rs. 74.33 crores as per the terms of P P'A'
3.3.
It is stated that AP DISCOMs have fiied O'P' No 12
of 2016 before A.P.E.R.C. seeking refund of Rs' 350'57 crores
i.e. towards principal amount of LC encashed' true
up arrears
and Rs. 86.73 crores towards interest accrued till
10 3'2016
of the
and future interest @ lSyo per annum till realization
No' 21 of 2013
amount. In the meantime, petitioner filed O'P
before A.P.E.R.C. for reimbursement of M'A'T
and A'P E'R'C'
allowed the said clarm The order
affirmed by APTEL bv the Hon'ble
in O P No 12 of 2016 was
Supreme Court in C'A' No'
3006 ot 2015. lt is further stated that
O P No 12 of 2016 hled
Central EiectricitY
b1, AP DISCOMS was transferred to
tune with the
Commission on 19.01.2019 in
Regulatory
directions of this Court in Writ Petition
No . 15848 of 2015 and
batch rvherein the Division Bench of
A.P.E.R.C. ar-rd T.G.E'R C' to transfer
this Court directed
ai1 the pending cases on
the subject matter to C E R C' for adjudication
in view of
bifurcation of composite State of Andhra
Pradesh into State of
Telangana and residuary State of Andhra
Pradesh'
g.4
Learned Standing Counsel contends
O.P. filed by DISCOMs for recovery
that as the
of amounts' illegaily
encashed by petitioner, is pending adjudication
before C'E'R C
u,hich has no\ r mounted to Rs 1109'38
crores (as on
30.09.2025), even if MAT' charges
to be refunded,
are
respondents themselves need to recover
more than Rs' 1 100
of amount by way
crores from petitioner' Detailed computation
with the counter affidavit' It
of a statement was enclosed along
that this Court in a
is contended bv learned Standing Counsel
the forum' for
u'rit petition filed under Article 226' is not
execution of order passed by the subordinate
tribunals' more so
bv A.P.tr.R.C. It is also contended that accepting w'ithout
conceding that a
Writ Petition under Article 226 is
maintainable,thisCourtlacssterritorialjurisdictiontoentertain
the present Writ Petition as all the issues involved pertain to the
State of Andhra Pradesh. It is also further contended that in
view of N.C.L.T. approving the Corporate Insolvency Resolution
Process (C.I.R.P.) submitted by M/s Radha Smelters arld others'
by treating the petitioner as an ongoing concern' even if
Respondents succeed before C.E R'C, they would not be able to
recover any amount in view of clean-slate principle' It is further
contended that Resolution Applicants i e' Radha Smelters and
Vasavi Realty have submitted the plan which has been approved
by N.C.L.T. treating petitioner as an ongoing concern' which is
nothing but a legal fraud played on N'C'L'T' by petitioner' It is
further contended that petitioner became defunct arrd there was
no power generation from ll 'O2 '2013 onwards and the
Company was not in operation due to lack of raw material for
more than 12 years, therefore, N'C'L'T' approving the
Resolution Plan and treating petitioner as an ongoing concern
is
a fraud played on N.C.L.T. The Company which has purchased
petitioner have done so only for the purpose of landed property
of petitioner, the value of which has raised multi-fo1d and
make prolits by sale of land in real estate' Even as on date'
to
I
there is no gas to be supplied to petitioner industry for its
revival
3.5
It is contended that I.B.C. Act has been enacted by
an Act of Parliament for revival of sick industries by new
cntrepreneurs / comp:rn ies / investors so that industrial activity
would go on. therebv industrial growth and employment could
be achieved which g'ould benefit the economy of the country'
But fraud is played by the present management of the petitioner
only to get many incentives under I'B' Code and therefore
pral'ed to dismiss the n'rit petition.
4.
Sri Vikram Poosarla, learned Senior Advocate
appearing for Shri M.Abhinay Reddy, learned counsel for
Reslrondents 1, 2, 6 and 7 has, apart from raising the
prelirninary objection on maintainability of the writ petition'
concurred and sailed with the arguments of learned Standing
Counsel for Respondents 3, 5 and 8 and further added that
powt:r under Art. 226 of Constitution is discretionary in nature
and the High Court shall exercise self-imposed restraints
especially when there is an efhcacious alternative remedy to the
parly approaching the Court. He further contended that Writ
Pctition undcr Article cannot be filed solely for implementation
of Commission's order dated 12 08.2013 and it is left open to
pctitioner to approach the Commission itself for execution of
such an order. He further contended that this Court does not
have territorial jurisdiction to agitate the present Writ Petition
and it is the High Court in the State of Andhra Pradesh where
the entire cause of action has arisen, which is competent to
a judicate the issue and further contends that the project of the
petitioner is situated in Peddapuram in Kakinada District,
which is within the territorial limits of High Court of Andhra
Pradesh. Power Purchase Agreement was executed with
respondent authorities operating in Andhra Pradesh State ald
all transactions and cause of action in relation to the project
have arisen w.ithin the State of Andhra Pradesh' Moreover, the
order which is now sought to be executed is also passed by
A.P.E.R.C. In view of all these issues, it is contended that this
Court does not have jurisdiction to entertain the uT it petition'
5.
Learned Senior Counsel for petitioner has replied to
the arguments of respondents by stating that petitioner has no
other forum to approach but this Court under Article 226' He
states that there is no power with A.P.E.R.C for execution of an
order and the powers under Sections 142 and 146 of Electricity
Act are restricted to punish defaulters for non-compliance of the
orders passed by A.P'E'R'C and therefore' there are
of petitioner'
executable remedies for actual recovery of dues
no
Hence, it is contended, the Writ Petition is
maintainable'
Learnecl Senior Counsel further states that writ petition was
filed in 2O t6 and '"r.as pending for the last 9 years and
respondents have never raised any question as to
maintainability of Writ Pctition for all these years; therefore,
they cannot be permitted to raise the said plea at this stage.
Learned Senior Counsel relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Durgd Enterprlses htt. Ltd. u. Prtnclpal
Secretary, GotErflment of U,P,I and in Dr. Bal Kisltan
Agarwal as State oJ It.P.2. It is contended that the order of
A.P.E.R.C. was confirmed by APTEL; thereafter by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court; tht:refore, as per the judgment of Calcutta High
Coorl Bibekanandrr Mondal u. Stdte of West Bengals, an act
done in w'rllful disobcdience of Court order is not only contempt
but also an illegal and invalid act; therefore, this Court, under
hrLicle 226 of the Constitution of India has got very wide power
to rcmedl. injustice wherever it is found.
6.
This Court has given anxious consideration to the
arguments. The prayer sought for by petitioner, seeking a
drrercLion to Respondents 1to 4 to reimburse the Minimum
Altcrnatt: Tax (MAT) amount paid by petitioner to Income Tax
Departme nt
for
FY
2009- 10
and
20lO-11
i.e.
Rs- 24,28,9 1,324 l- along with interest accrued thereon. in
' zoo+ 1ts1 scc 665
' to9s1 t scc 614
' 2002 S(:C Online Oalcutta 571
accordance with the order dated l2.a.2ol3 passed by the then
A.P. Electricity Regulatory Commission in O.P. No. 21 of 2013,
as upheld by APTEL and Hon'bie Supreme Court, is in the
nature of execution of an order passed by the A.P. Electricity
Regulatory Commission.
.
The point for consideration is whether this Court, in
exercise of its extraordinary jurisdiction under Art. 226 of
Constitution of India, can execute an order passed by A.P.
Electricity Regulatory Commission in O.P. No. 21 of 2O13
dated 12.08.2013.
8.
This Court is convinced with the contention/
arguments of learned counsel for respondents that this Court
does not have territorial jurisdiction to entertain the Writ
Petition in view of the fact that petitioner project is located in
Peddapuram of Kakinada District (Andhra Pradesh State) which
is in the territorial limits of High Court of Andhra Pradesh. This
Court is also convinced with the contention of Respondents that
Power Purchase Agreement was executed with the authorities
operating in the State of Andhra Pradesh and that all the
transactions and cause of action in relation to the project have
arisen within the State of Andhra Pradesh, and also what is now
sought to be executed in this Writ Petition is an order passed by
A.P. Electricity Regulatory Commission. Therefore, it is to be
held that this Court does not have territorial jurisdiction to
entertain the Writ Petition.
9.
Secondly, petitioner approached this Court under
Artrcle 226 of Constitution for execution of the order, by
converting the sard proceedings into recovery/ execution
proceedings, therefore, Writ of Mandamus, in the opinion of this
Court, does not lie to entertain the prayer sought by petitioner.
As rightly contended by learned counsel for Respondents,
petitioner has got an efficacious remedy to approach the AP
Elecrricily Rcgulatory Commission itself, as Electricity Act, 20O3
is a Code in itsclf. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Maharashtra
State Electricitg Distribution Compang Ltd. u. Maharashtra
Electricitg Regulatory Commissiona and in S.Bhcrg at Kumar
us Gouentment oJ Andhra Pradeshs held that the Reguiatory
Commission constituted under the statute like Electricity Act
have all the trappings of the Court and are substitute for civii
court and such bodies have the power to execute their own
orders. Therefcrre bypassing the said forum and invoking the
writ jurisdiction of this Court is legally impermissible.
10.
Yer another ground for refusing the prayer sought
by petitioner is, pendcncy of O.P. No. 12 of 20O6 on the file of
Central Electricitl' Regulatory Commission wherein respondents
'
1zo zz1 +
scc 6s7
' 2000 scc online AP 565
have sought for refund of certain amounts which were, in the
opinion of respondents, illegally encashed by petitioner and
even if petitioner is entitled for refund of Minimum Alternate Tax
(MAT), Respondents, in the event of their succeeding before
C.E.R.C., would not be able to recover the said amount, in view
of I.B.C. proceedings concluded before the N C.L'T. which have
overriding effect over the Electricity laws.
This Court is also not inclined to accept the
11.
contention of petitioner that in view of long pendency of the Writ
Petition before this Court, for nine years, Respondents cannot
seek to dismiss the Writ Petition on the ground of availability of
alternative remedy.
{n,view of the facts and circumstances of this case,
12.
this Court is of the opinion that it lacks territorial jurisdiction at
the first instance and that execution of the order passed by a
subordinate tribunal cannot be ordered in proceedings under
writ jurisdiction. This Court is also satished that the Electricity
Act empowers petitioner to seek the said remedy before A'P'
Electricity Regulatory Commission. Hence, this Court does not
find any merits to entertain the Writ Petition.
Accordingly, the Writ Petition is dismissed with
3.
costs of Rs. 1,oO,OoO/- (Rupees one lac only) to be paid to
respondents.
-/
l5
14.
This Court awestruck to note that respondents,
whose case is pending before the CERC, have not
made a claim
with regard to the said amount before the NCLT where
proceedings of petitioner under I.B.C. are pending.
They have
not even made an Application before the Insolvency
Resolution
Professional regarding their claim which is pending
before the
CERC].
15.
'I'he Chairman and Managing Director,
Pradesh and Tclangana TRANSCO Departments
DISCOMS are therefore, directed to probe
Andhra
and all the
into the issue as to
who is responsible for not making the claim, which
act resulted
in heaq- loss the public exchequer.
16.
Consequt:ntly, the miscellaneous petitions pending,
if any, shall stand closed.
MEMORANDUM OF COSTS
Rs.
Ps
Costs Quarrtified by Hon'ble Court (That
the Petitioner herein and Counsel for the
oetitioner are d irected to pay costs of
ii.s 1,00.000/- (Rupees one Lakh only) in
favour of the ResPondents.
1,00,000-00
iFo,ooo-oo
TOTAL
SD/.P. PONNA KRISHNA
A ISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
\/
To,
SECTION OFFICER
Sri. GVK Gautami Power Llmrted Sy No.43 ,,['OO' plot no.43,54,57 and 58,
4th f loor Mahaveer Radiance, Pillar number 1708 ,MA dhapur, Hyderabad,
Telangana, lndia 500081 Represented by it's Director Mr. Sunil Kumar saraf
The Chairman and Managing Director, Southern Power Distribution Company
of Andhra Pradesh, Limited, besides Srinivasa Kalyana Mandapam,
Tiruchanur Road, Tirupathi - 517501 (hereinafter referred to as APSPDCL)
3 The Chairman and Managing Director, Eastern Power Distribution Company
of Andhra Pradesh, Limited, P&T Colony, Seethammadhara, Vishakhapatnam
- 530020 (hereinafter referred to as APEPDCL)
4 The Chairman and Managing Director, Southern Power Distribution Company
ofTelangana Ltd., 6-1-50, Vidyut Saudha, Khairatabad, Hyderabad
E
The Chairman and Managing Director, Northern Power Distribution Company
'1-1-503 and 504,
of Telangana Limited, Having its registered Office at H. No.
Opp NIT Petrol Pump. Chaitanyapuri, Hanamkonda, Warangal - 506 004
(hereinafter referred to as TSNPDCL)
6 The Chairman and Managing Director, Telangana State Transmission
Corporation Ltd, (TSTRANSCO) Vidyut Saudha' Khairatabad, Hyderabad
7 The Chairman and Managing Director, Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh(APTRANSCO), Vidyut Saudha, Khairatabad, Hyderabad'
8 The Chairman and Managing Director, Andhra Pradesh Power Coordination
Committee (APPCC), Vidyut Saudha, Khairatabad' Hyderabad.
o The Chairman and Managing Director,Telangana State Power Coordination
Committee, Vidyut Suadha, Khairatabad, Hyderabad (TSPCC).
'10 One CC to SRI PUSHYAM KIRAN, Advocate [OPUC]
11 One CC to SRI MALIPEDDI ABHINAY REDDY, SC FOR APSPDCL [OPUC]
12 One CC to SRI N.SREEDHAR REDDY, SC FOR TRANSCO [OPUC]
IJ One CC to SRI A.CHANDRA SHAKER, SC FOR TSNPDCL [OPUC]
14 Two CD Copies
l
PMK
BS
.fu
HIGH COURT
DATED: 09/06/2026
ORDER
1Yl
WP.No.19268 of 2016
'
S14 rF
t- t
c.
lo
1 5 JU[l 2026
1'J
I
\..
1 it
:-; /,'!
n,./,''
'" -_./
)
I
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
p{
re\aLu
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review