Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
Reserved On
: 08/10/2026
Pronounced On : 14/10/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 7085 of 2025
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA
and
HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI
Sd/-
Sd/=============================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
✔
No
=============================================
M/S GUJARAT CO-OPERATIVE MILK MARKETING FEDERATION LIMITED
Versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
=============================================
Appearance:
MR AMAL PARESH DAVE(8961) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1
MR PARESH M DAVE(260) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1
MS HETVI H SANCHETI(5618) for the Respondent(s) No. 1,2,3
=============================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA
and
HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA)
1.
Rule. Learned Senior Standing Counsel Ms.Hetvi H.
Sancheti, waives service of notice of Rule on behalf of the
respondent – authorities.
2.
The present writ petition has been filed seeking the
following relief : “16. (A)
That Your Lordships may be pleased to issue a
Writ of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order or
direction, quashing and setting aside Order in Original
No.74/CGST/(AhmedabadSouth)/ADC/PBM/24-25
dated
01.01.2025 (Annexure-”F”) passed by the Additional
Commissioner of CGST, Ahmedabad South Commissionerate
(Respondent No.2 herein) with all consequential reliefs and
benefits to the petitioner;”
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
BRIEF FACTS :-
3.
The petitioner- Federation is a farmers’ Co-operative
Society
engaged
in
marketing
various
dairy
products
manufactured by milk co-operatives in the State of Gujarat.
The Federation comprises various milk co-operatives in the
State of Gujarat and is popularly known as “Amul”. Its
objective is to ensure remunerative returns to farmers and
agriculturists who are members of and constituents of the milk
co-operatives. The Federation also aims to serve the interests
of
consumers
by
providing
quality
products
for
their
consumption.
4.
The petitioner Federation’s Head Office (hereinafter
referred to as the “HO”) is situated at Anand. Since its
formation and registration as an apex co-operative society, the
HO of the Federation has been situated at Anand. All corporate
activities of the Federation are undertaken, managed and
supervised from its HO at Anand.
5.
The Federation has a dairy known as “Amulfed Dairy”
situated at Village Bhat in Gandhinagar District. Apart from
Amulfed Dairy, there are 21 other District-level Co-operative
Societies of farmers and agriculturists in the State of Gujarat,
which operate milk plants i.e. dairies, in various districts of the
State.
6.
The petitioner Federation holds a Goods and Services Tax
(GST) registration as an Input Service Distributor (ISD) for its
HO at Anand. It also holds a common GST registration covering
all its branches and depots in the State of Gujarat.
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
7.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
Being the apex body responsible for the sale, supply and
distribution of milk and milk products, the Federation incurs
various corporate expenses through its HO at Anand. Such
corporate
expenses
include
advertisement
and
publicity
expenses, IT infrastructure expenses, IBM annual maintenance
service expenses, SAP annual maintenance and audit charges,
legal fees, litigation expenses and other similar expenses. The
Federation incurs these expenses for services utilised by the
Federation itself as well as by its branches situated at various
locations.
8.
The dispute in the present writ petition pertains to the
period from July 2017 to March 2019, during which the
petitioner incurred the aforesaid corporate expenses without
allocating the same to its branch offices and depots by
adopting the method of cross-charging.
9.
The details of the corporate expenditure incurred by the
Federation are duly recorded in its books of account, including
the relevant ledgers and balance sheets maintained at its HO
at Anand.
10.
It appears that the third respondent initiated an inquiry
against the Federation in respect of the corporate expenditure
incurred by it, on the ground that the petitioner Federation had
not allocated the expenditure to its branches by way of crosscharges. The respondent authorities proceeded on the premise
that the expenditure incurred and paid by the HO at Anand
was liable to GST, inasmuch as the branch offices to which the
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
HO provided such services were treated as distinct persons in
terms of Section 25(4) of the Central Goods and Services Tax
Act, 2017 (hereinafter referred to as the “CGST Act”).
11.
The respondent authorities further alleged that the
salaries paid to employees working at the HO were attributable
to the supply of services by such employees to the distinct
persons, namely, the branch offices of the Federation.
Accordingly,
the
authorities
contended
that
the
salary
expenditure incurred in respect of the employees at the HO
was also liable to GST as consideration for services provided by
the HO to its branches.
12.
Consequently, a show-cause-cum-demand notice dated
31.08.2022 was issued by the respondent authorities, calling
upon the petitioner to show cause as to why GST should not be
demanded on common expenditure incurred towards services
such as advertisement, publicity, insurance and other similar
expenses, as well as on the salaries paid to employees at the
HO, in proportion to the turnover of the branches situated
within the State of Gujarat.
13.
The respondent authorities invoked Section 74 of the
CGST Act on the allegation that the petitioner had failed to
disclose the common expenditure and had not undertaken
cross-charging.
14.
The
petitioner
accordingly
filed
its
reply
dated
13.09.2022, explaining the nature and functioning of the
services provided by the HO to its branches and depots.
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
15.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
During the adjudication proceedings, the Central Board of
Indirect
Taxes
and
Customs
(CBIC)
issued
Circular
No.
199/11/2023-GST dated 17.07.2023, clarifying the taxability of
services provided by one office of an organisation to another
office of the same organisation.
16.
Thereafter, a further Circular No.210/4/2024-GST dated
26.06.2024 was issued by the CBIC, providing additional
clarification regarding the valuation of services between
related persons, including cases where the recipient is eligible
for full input tax credit (ITC). The clarification provides that, in
cases where the recipient is eligible for full ITC, the value of
the supply may be deemed to be ‘Nil’ where the invoice has
not been issued by the related entity.
17.
During the adjudication proceedings, the petitioner relied
upon the aforesaid circulars and brought them to the attention
of the adjudicating authority. However, by the impugned
Order-in-Original
dated
Commissioner
CGST
of
01.01.2025,
confirmed
a
the
demand
Additional
of
IGST
aggregating to Rs.43,43,12,441/- against the petitioner under
Section 74 of the CGST Act, along with applicable interest and
penalty.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER : -
18.
Learned advocate Mr.Dave, appearing for the petitioner,
at the outset, has referred to the decision of the Delhi High
Court in the case of M/s. Metal One Corporation India Private
Limited and others Vs. Union of India & Ors., 2024 (10) TMI
1534 (Delhi High Court). He has submitted that the Delhi High
Court, while dealing with identical issue and considering the
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
Circulars dated 17.07.2023 and 26.06.2024, has quashed and
set aside the demand notices issued by the GST authorities. It
is
submitted that the aforesaid judgment of the Delhi High
Court, rendered on similar issues, support the case of the
petitioner and, accordingly, the impugned notices as well as
the Order-in-Original are required to be quashed and set aside.
19.
It is further submitted that the entire case of the Revenue
is misconceived. The petitioner has been subjected to penalty
proceedings by invoking Section 74 of the CGST Act on the
premise that the HO of the Federation was required to
undertake cross-charging. If the case of the Revenue is that
the internally generated services were required to be supplied
by the Head Office to its branch offices, the demand for tax
ought to have been raised against the Head Office. It is
submitted that the reverse charge mechanism is not applicable
to such internally generated services provided by the Head
Office to the branch offices. In the present case, the demand
has not been confirmed under the reverse charge mechanism
either.
20.
It is further submitted that the respondent authorities
have failed to appreciate that the proceedings have been
initiated against the Ahmedabad branch office of the petitioner
by treating it as the principal place of business, whereas the
HO of the petitioner is admittedly situated at Anand. Since no
corporate
expenditure
was
incurred
and
paid
by
the
Ahmedabad branch office, there was no question of the said
branch office being required to undertake cross-charging.
21.
It is submitted that the Revenue has proceeded on an
erroneous understanding of the provision of Section 25(4) of
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
the CGST Act by treating the HO and the branch offices as
distinct persons. It is contended that no separate GST
registration has been obtained by the branch offices in the
State of Gujarat and, therefore, the demand of tax raised
against the petitioner by treating the HO and the branch
offices as distinct persons is misconceived.
22.
It is further submitted that, in accounting practice, cross-
charging is often adopted by an organization to ascertain the
performance of its various profit centres. For this purpose,
common expenses are proportionately allocated to different
profit centres, namely, the branches and depots of the
organisation, to facilitate an assessment of the performance of
each
business
unit.
However,
cross-charging
is
not
a
mandatory requirement under any law for the time being in
force and is followed by an organization primarily for its
internal accounting purposes rather than to fulfil any statutory
obligation. The petitioner has admittedly not allocated the
common expenditure proportionately to its branches and
depots for the period from July 2017 to March 2019. It is
contended that no statutory provision mandates the petitioner
to adopt a cross-charging mechanism in the facts of the
present case.
23.
It is further submitted that, in the present case, separate
GST registrations have not been obtained for the branch
offices of the petitioner. It is, therefore, contended that Section
25(4) of the CGST Act is not applicable in the manner sought to
be invoked by the respondent authorities and that the Head
Office and the branch offices cannot be treated as distinct
persons for the purpose of the impugned demand.
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
24.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
It is also submitted that the CBIC has clarified that, where
the HO has not issued a tax invoice to a branch office in
respect of services provided by the Head Office to such branch
office, the value of such services may be deemed to be ‘Nil’. In
view of the said clarification, it is contended that the value of
the internally generated services in the present case is also
required to be treated as ‘Nil’, since the petitioner has not
issued any tax invoice from its Head Office to its branches and
depots. Accordingly, the tax liability in respect of such services
would be ‘Nil’, as the value of the services, including their open
market value under Rule 28 of the Central Goods and Services
Tax Rules, 2017 (for short, “CGST Rules”), is deemed to be
‘Nil’.
25.
Finally, it is contended that the invocation of Section 74
of the CGST Act is wholly illegal and without jurisdiction, as the
petitioner has not committed any fraud, wilful misstatement or
suppression of facts with the intent to evade payment of tax.
All payments made towards common expenditure at the
petitioner’s HO, as well as the salaries paid to employees
working at the HO, have been duly and fully accounted for in
the books of account, ledgers and balance sheets maintained
by the petitioner. There has been no suppression of facts or
wilful misstatement in respect of the expenditure incurred and
paid at the HO level. It is, therefore, contended that the
invocation of Section 74 of the CGST Act in the present case is
without jurisdiction.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE REVENUE :-
26.
Opposing the reliefs sought in the present writ petition,
learned Senior Standing Counsel Ms.Sancheti has submitted
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
that the writ petition may not be entertained, as the petitioner
has deliberately refrained from allocating expenses to its
branch offices by adopting the cross-charging mechanism, with
a fraudulent intent to evade payment of GST.
27.
It is submitted that the petitioner has itself accepted the
legal position, as, with effect from 01.04.2019, it started
allocating expenses to its branch offices, treating such
allocation as a supply to a distinct person and discharging the
applicable tax on the expenses or services shared with the
branch offices.
28.
It is further submitted that, under the erstwhile Central
Excise and Service Tax regime, the concept of a “distinct
person” and the mechanism of cross-charging were not
recognized.
However,
with
effect
from
01.07.2017,
the
relevant provisions became applicable to all Head Offices
providing common services to their branch offices or incurring
expenditure at the Head Office for services utilized by such
branch offices.
29.
It is submitted that the judgment rendered by the Delhi
High Court is not applicable to the facts of the present case. In
this regard, learned Senior Standing Counsel has submitted
that the adjudicating authority has already dealt with the CBIC
Circulars dated 17.07.2023 and 26.06.2024 in paragraph No.20
of the impugned order. The adjudicating authority has
categorically observed that the clarifications contained in the
said circulars would apply only where the recipient branch
office or depot is eligible for full input tax credit (ITC) in respect
of the relevant supply.
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
30.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
It is further submitted that the petitioner has raised a
factually incorrect contention. The petitioner has applied for
and obtained separate GST registrations for its branch offices
situated outside the State of Gujarat. The supply of services
between distinct persons has been treated as a taxable supply
under Section 7 of the CGST Act and detailed reasons in
support thereof have been recorded in the impugned order. It
is submitted that the adjudicating authority has assigned valid
reasons for holding that the aforesaid circulars are not
applicable to the petitioner. The petitioner is, therefore,
incorrect in contending that the reasons recorded by the
adjudicating authority are merely jurisdictional in nature.
31.
It is further submitted that the valuation of the services
and the allocation of expenditure amongst the branch offices
have been undertaken in accordance with the valuation rules
prescribed under Rules 28, 30 and 31 of the CGST Rules. It is
also submitted that the IGST paid by the petitioner on crosscharged expenses would be available as Input Tax Credit (ITC)
to the recipient branch offices on the strength of tax invoices
issued by the HO under Section 31 of the CGST Act. However,
in the present case, the petitioner has retained the entire ITC
at the HO level, even though the services procured have also
been utilised by and have benefited the branch offices. The
benefit of such ITC has not been passed on to the branch
offices. It is contended that the petitioner appears to have
deliberately adopted this course of action, as the tax liability at
the
HO
level
would
be
substantially
higher
corresponding tax liability at the branch-office level.
than
the
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
32.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
Finally, it is submitted that the extended period of
limitation under Section 74 of the CGST Act, has been precisely
invoked against the petitioner. The petitioner did not inform
the Department at any point of time that it was not discharging
IGST on a cross-charge basis in respect of services utilized by
its branch offices situated outside the State of Gujarat, which
were treated as distinct persons under the provisions of the
CGST Act, 2017.
ANALYSIS AND OPINION : 33.
Having heard the learned advocates appearing for the
respective parties, the undisputed facts emerging from the
pleadings and the record are as under:
34.
The petitioner is a Marketing Federation comprising
various milk co-operatives in the State of Gujarat and is
popularly known as “Amul”. Its activities extend across the
country. The petitioner Federation has its Head Office at
Anand, from where all its corporate activities are undertaken,
managed and supervised.
35.
The petitioner Federation holds a GST registration as an
Input Service Distributor (ISD) for its Head Office at Anand. It
also holds a two GST registration within the State of Gujarat
under Section 25 of the CGST Act, 2017. However, for outside
the State it has distinct GST registration numbers across India.
36.
The Federation, being the apex body, incurs various
corporate expenses, including advertisement and publicity
expenses, IT infrastructure expenses, annual maintenance
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
service expenses, legal fees, litigation expenses and salaries
paid to its employees, amongst other expenses.
37.
The respondent authority initiated an inquiry against the
Federation on the ground that it had failed to discharge its tax
liability by adopting the method of cross-charging in respect of
the aforesaid corporate expenditure. It is not in dispute that
the petitioner Federation has duly recorded the details of all
such expenditure in its books of account, ledgers and balance
sheets maintained at its Head Office at Anand.
38.
The respondent authorities proceeded on the premise
that the branch offices to which the HO provided such services
were distinct persons by virtue of Section 25(4) of the CGST
Act, and that the services in question were utilized by the
branches
and
depots.
Consequently,
demand
notice
dated
31.08.2022
a
was
show-cause-cumissued
by
the
respondent authorities. By invoking Section 74 of the CGST
Act, the authorities alleged that the petitioner had deliberately
and fraudulently failed to disclose the common expenditure
and had not undertaken cross-charging. Accordingly, the
extended period of limitation was invoked for initiating
proceedings under Section 74 of the CGST Act, 2017. The
period of dispute is for the period from July,2017 to March,
2019.
39.
The proceedings ultimately culminated in the impugned
order-in-original dated 01.01.2025, whereby a demand of IGST
aggregating to Rs.43,43,12,441/- was confirmed against the
petitioner under Section 74 of the CGST Act, along with
interest and penalty. The adjudicating authority held that the
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
Federation operated its HO at Anand and incurred expenditure
towards various common services for the functioning of its
corporate office, the benefits of which also accrued to other
distinct units of the Federation. It was further held that, under
the GST law, the supply of such services by the corporate
office to its distinct units was liable to tax at the value
determined in accordance with the applicable valuation rules.
40. Thus, the respondents have passed the impugned order by
alleging that the petitioner-Federation has not paid the GST by
not adopting the methodology of allocating the expenses by
way of cross-charging to their branches, depots.
FACET OF CROSS-CHARGING BETWEEN HO AND BO AS DISTINCT
PERSONS AND GST LIABILITY :-
41. For examining the status of the petitioner-Federation and
its branches and depots across the country as “distinct
persons”, the provisions of Section 25 of the CGST Act needs
to be examined. The same reads as under:
“SECTION 25 : Procedure for registration
(1) Every person who is liable to be registered under section 22 or
section 24 shall apply for registration in every such State or
Union territory in which he is so liable within thirty days from the
date on which he becomes liable to registration, in such manner
and subject to such conditions as may be prescribed:
(2) xxxxxxxxxx
(4) A person who has obtained or is required to obtain more than
one registration, whether in one State or Union territory or more
than one State or Union territory shall, in respect of each such
registration, be treated as distinct persons for the purposes of this
Act.
(5) Where a person who has obtained or is required to obtain
registration in a State or Union territory in respect of an
establishment, has an establishment in another State or Union
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
territory, then such establishments shall be treated
establishments of distinct persons for the purposes of this Act.”
42.
as
Thus, the petitioner-Federation and its Branches/Depots
having different GST registration across India will fall within the
ambit of “distinct person”, as envisaged under Section 25(4) &
(5) of the CGST Act. The CGST Act consolidates the taxation of
goods and services into a unified framework, designating the
"supply of goods or services" between taxable persons as the
core taxable event. While Section 7 of the CGST Act,
establishes that a valid "supply" fundamentally requires
consideration, the statute carves out critical exceptions to this
rule.
Schedule
I
to
the
CGST
Act
delineates
specific
transactions that fall within the ambit of supply even in the
absence of consideration. Specifically, Entry 2 of Schedule I
covers the "Supply of goods or services or both between
related persons or between distinct persons as specified in
Section 25 of the CGST Act, when made in the course or
furtherance of business." Rule 28 of the CGST Rules, further
further prescribes valuation for supplies of goods and services
between distinct persons. Thus, the taxability of transactions
between a head office and its branches is governed by these
provisions. In other words, by virtue of these provisions,
transactions between "distinct persons" are pulled squarely
into the net of GST. The CGST Act does not define ‘CrossCharge’. However, the working of Sections 25(4) and 24(5) of
the CGST Act and Rule 28 of the CGST Rules read with Entry 2
of Schedule I, the invoicing of supply of goods and services on
the
transactions
between
HO
and
BO
establishes
the
mechanism of “cross-charging”, which is premised on its
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
respective GST registration for different branches/depots.
Hence, any services or support shared between these distinct
persons will constitute a supply under Schedule I. However, if
HO and its branches/depots operate under a single GST
registration, they will remain outside the scope of “distinct
person”, and exempt from cross-charging.
ASPECT OF VALUATION OF SERVICES :-
43.
During the course of adjudication process, the CBIC
issued circular dated 17.07.2023 and 26.06.2024 clarifying the
valuation of services between related persons, including cases
where the recipient is eligible for full ITC. The petitioner relied
upon such circulars before the adjudicating authority, but its
impact was in vain. It is not in dispute that the petitioner has
not issued any tax invoices from its Head Office to its branches
and depots in respect of the services in question. The
petitioner contends that, in such circumstances, the value of
the
services
is
required
to
be
treated
as
‘Nil’
and,
consequently, no tax liability arises.
44.
At this stage, we may refer to Circular No. 199/11/2023-
GST dated 17.07.2023 issued by the Central Board of Indirect
Taxes and Customs (CBIC), which clarifies as under:
“The value of supply of services made ay by a registered person to
a distinct is person needs to be determined as per to rule 28 of
CGST Rules, read with sub-section (4) of section 15 of CGST Act. As
per clause (a) of rule 28, the value of supply of goods or services or
both between distinct persons shall be the open market value of
such supply. The second proviso to rule 28 of CGST Rules provides
that where the recipient is eligible for full input tax credit, the of
value declared in the invoice shall be in deemed to be the open
market value of the goods or services. Accordingly, in respect of
supply of services by HO to BOs, the value of the said supply of
services declared in the invoice by HO shall be deemed to be open
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
market on value of such services, if the recipient BO is eligible for
full input tax credit. Accordingly, in cases where full input all tax
credit is available to a BO, the value declared on the invoice by HO
to the said BO in respect of a supply of services shall be deemed to
be the open market value of such services, of irrespective of the
fact whether cost of to any particular component of such services,
like employee cost etc., has been included or not in the value of the
services in the invoice.
Further, in such cases where full input tax credit is available to the
recipient, if HO has not issued a tax invoice to the BO in respect of
any particular services being rendered by HO to the said BO, the
value of such services may be deemed to be declared as ‘Nil’ by HO
to BO, and may be deemed as open market value in terms of
second proviso to rule 28 of CGST Rules.”
45.
The
CBIC
issued
further
clarificatory
Circular
No.210/4/2024-GST dated 26.06.2024, stating that if no invoice
was issued to the BO by the HO then the value of service may
be deemed to be declared as ‘Nil’ by HO to BO, and may be
deemed as open market value in terms of second proviso to
Rule 28(1) of CGST Rules.
46. The Delhi High Court in the case of
Metal One
Corporation India Pvt. Ltd. (supra), while considering the
aforesaid Circular and the provisions of Rule 28 of the CGST
Rules, has held thus:
“ 14. In the facts of the present writ petitions, it is conceded that no
invoices were generated. In view of the above and in light of the
explicit terms of the Circular, the value of the service rendered would
have to be treated as 'Nil'. This would lead one to the inescapable
conclusion of no perceivable or plausible tax liability possibly being
created. Consequently, we are of the considered opinion that the
proceedings initiated in terms of the impugned SCNs' and their
continuance would be futile and impractical. The impugned SCNs are
essentially rendered impotent and would serve no practical purpose.”
47.
Thus, the recitals of the Circular dated 17.07.2023 and
26.06.2024, are self-explanatory, which is considered by Delhi
High Court. Since it is not disputed by the Respondents that
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
the HO of the petitioner has not issued any tax invoices to its
branches and depots in respect of the services in question, the
value of such services is required to be treated as ‘Nil’ in terms
of Rule 28 of the CGST Rules, and consequently, no tax liability
arises in the present case. Albeit the adjudicating authority has
cursorily referred to the Circulars, but has not dealt with the
issue of taxable value of services in context of non-issuance of
tax invoices to its branches and depots, and the clarification
issued by the CBIC vide Circulars has been brushed aside by
recording that “ the tax payer has not made out a case that
100% ITC involved on the invoice was to be passed on to only
one branch office or depot as the fill services mentioned in that
particular invoice was supplied to that particular branch office
or depot.” Hence, the impugned order suffers non-application
of mind on the effect of payment of GST taking the taxable
value of service as ‘Nil’, since no invoice has been issued by
the Federation.
48.
The respondent authorities, therefore, cannot determine
the value of the services on a proportionate basis merely on
the ground that the petitioner did not adopt the cross-charging
mechanism to determine the value of the common expenditure
by allocating the same in proportion to the turnover of its
various branches and depots.
49.
The adjudicating authority has also failed to appreciate
that the services rendered by the HO to its branches constitute
input services and that the credit of the tax paid on such
services would be admissible under Section 16(1) of the CGST
Act. Any tax paid by the petitioner's HO on such internally
generated services would be available as ITC to the respective
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
branches and depots, in accordance with the clarification
contained in the circular dated 17.07.2023.
INVOCATION OF SECTION 74 OF THE CGST ACT :-
50.
We may now consider the impugned order passed under
Section 74 of the CGST Act. The extended period of five years
is invoked as envisaged under Section 74 by the respondents
on the basis of DGGI investigation. It is alleged that without
such investigation, the facts relating to tax evasion would not
have been known, hence it can be said that the petitionerFederation has deliberately suppressed the facts with the
intent to evade payment of GST. Except these observations,
there is nothing recorded by the respondents either in the
show cause notice or in the order in original, in order to satisfy
the ingredients of Section 74 of the CGST Act against a tax
payer as the intent to evade of tax must involve fraud, wilful
misstatement or suppression of facts. The Supreme Court in a
recent decision in a case of Tata Steel Ltd. Vs. Union of India,
2026 (189) taxmann.com 520 (SC) has held thus:
“11. At the outset we have to notice that the proceedings under
Section 73/74 can be initiated only on the satisfaction of the
Assessing Officer. Even if observations/objections are made on audit,
the Assessing Officer should enter his satisfaction before a notice is
issued. Insofar as a notice under Section 74, the satisfaction should
be not only of mismatch of ITC and short payment of tax having
occurred, as is alleged in this case, the Officer should be satisfied
that either fraud/wilful misrepresentation/suppression had led to such
mismatch or short payment of tax.
12. We are unable to countenance the argument of the learned ASG
that Explanation 2 to Section 74 applies, since even according to him
it stood omitted with effect from 01.11.2024. Equally fallacious is the
argument that the proceedings were initiated prior to the expiry of
limitation under Section 73. The limitation under Section 73 (10) is
also to issue the order under Section 73 (9) and not to issue a notice
and sub-section (2) of Section 73 provides for a notice, at least three
months before the time limit under Section 73 (10).
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
13. The fact that the Department had taken up the objections on
audit with the Public Accounts Committee itself indicates that there
was no satisfaction at the end of the Department, meaning the
Assessing Officer; as to the mismatch or the short fall of payment of
tax having occurred, not to say anything about the suppression
alleged. Further, but for a bland statement of availing of ITC for the
three years 'without documentary evidence and suppress the facts'
(sic), the SCN did not contain any foundational facts to validate such
allegation of suppression.
14. It is not mere lip service to the provisions that is intended when
an extended limitation period is provided for recovering an excess
benefit availed, short payment or excess refund, from the assessee,
especially
when
the
allegation
is
of
fraud/wilful
misrepresentation/suppression. The foundational facts which led to
the inference arrived at of fraud/wilful misrepresentation/
suppression should be evident from the notice itself. The mere
employment of such words will not indicate an application of mind,
upon which alone the satisfaction can be arrived at. The words are
not to be mechanically recited in the notice to enable recovery
outside the normal limitation provided under the statute.”
51.
Thus, the Supreme Court has asserted that when Section
74 of the CGST Act provides an extended limitation period to
recover short payments, excess benefits, or erroneous refunds
based on allegations of fraud, wilful misrepresentation, or
suppression, it demands more than mere lip service. The
foundational facts supporting these serious inferences must be
clearly demarcated within the notice itself. Mere recitals of
these statutory terms mechanically do not demonstrate a
genuine application of mind which is a strict prerequisite for
invoking the extended period. The tax authority cannot use
these words as a routine formula just to bypass the normal
limitation period. In the present case, the adjudicating
authority has mechanically invoked Section 74 of the CGST Act
without recording any specific finding establishing that the
petitioner resorted to fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression
of facts with the intent to evade payment of tax by avoiding
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
the cross-charging methodology. The mere exhuming of
information by DGGI, without forming any opinion establishing
the core vices on such information cannot attract the rigors of
Section 74 of the CGST Act.
52.
Before invoking the stringent provisions of Section 74 of
the CGST Act, the adjudicating authority ought to have
appreciated that even if the petitioner had adopted the
method of cross-charging, the tax liability on such services
could have been discharged by utilising the ITC of the tax paid
to the actual service providers at the petitioner's Head Office,
The tax so paid on the cross-charged services would, in turn,
have been available as ITC to the respective branches and
depots, which also hold GST registrations. The situation would,
therefore, have been revenue-neutral. In such circumstances,
the question of suppression of facts, wilful misstatement or
fraud with the intent to evade payment of tax does not arise
merely because the petitioner did not adopt the cross-charging
mechanism. It is also pertinent to note that the jurisdictional
GST
authorities
were
aware
of
the
functioning
of
the
Federation, as the expenditure in question was duly recorded
in
the
books
of
account,
ledgers
and
balance
sheets
maintained at the petitioner's Head Office at Anand.
53.
Thus, mere allegation that the petitioner failed to adopt
cross-charging in respect of internally generated services
provided by the Head Office to its branch offices cannot ipso
facto lead to the conclusion that the petitioner wilfully or
fraudulently evaded payment of tax or suppressed material
facts
with
such
intent.
The
adjudicating
authority
has,
C/SCA/7085/2025
(GJHC240329302025)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 14/10/2026
therefore, failed to establish the essential ingredients for
invoking Section 74 of the CGST Act, reflecting a clear nonapplication of mind.
54.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the writ petition
succeeds and is accordingly allowed. The Order-in-Original
No.74/CGST/
(Ahmedabad
South)/ADC/PBM/24-25
dated
01.01.2025 passed by the Additional Commissioner of CGST,
Ahmedabad, is hereby quashed and set aside. Rule is made
absolute accordingly.
Sd/(A. S. SUPEHIA, J)
Sd/(VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI,J)
MAHESH/Supp.Board-01/01
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review