Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:9627
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CMPMO No. : 7 of 2026
Reserved on : 17.03.2026
Decided on
: 31.03.2026
M/s Escorts Kubota Ltd.
…Petitioner
Versus
Devinder Kumar
…Respondent
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner
: Mr. Arvind Sharma, Advocate.
For the respondent
: Mr. Ajay Sharma, Senior Advocate
with Mr. Tarun Brakta, Advocate.
Virender Singh, Judge
Petitioner, M/s Escorts Kubota Limited, has filed
the present petition, under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India, against the order dated 26.11.2025, passed by learned
Civil Judge, Barsar (hereinafter referred to as the trial Court),
in CMA Nos.623 & 624 of 2025 in Civil Suit No.237 of 2015,
titled as Devinder Kumar versus M/s Escorts Construction
Equipments Ltd.
Whether Reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? Yes.
2.
2026:HHC:9627
By way of the order dated 26.11.2025, the learned
trial Court has allowed the application for setting aside the
exparte order passed against the petitioner M/s Escorts Kubota
Limited, by putting the condition upon the petitioner to
deposit rupees nine lacs with the learned trial court.
3.
Parties to the lis are hereinafter referred to, in the
same manner, in which, they were referred to by the learned
trial Court.
4.
Brief facts, leading to filing the present petition
before this Court, may be summed up as under:
4.1.
PlaintiffDevinder Kumar (respondent herein) has
filed a suit for recovery of Rs.5,00,000/, on account of damages
accrued to him on account of deficiency of services and torts,
along with interest @11% per annum till its realization,
against the defendant (petitioner herein), before the learned
trial Court.
4.2.
When the notices, in the suit, could not be served,
by way of ordinary process, then on 19.11.2019, an application,
under Order 5 Rule 20 CPC, was allowed and the notices of the
suit were ordered to be published against the defendant in the
2026:HHC:9627
newspaper ‘Amar Ujala’ for 28.12.2019.
Thus, the notices
were duly published and despite publication of the notices, the
defendant has failed to put appearance.
Consequently, the
defendant was proceeded against exparte.
4.3.
Thereafter,
the
defendant
had
moved
an
application under Order 9 rule 7 CPC, for recalling the order
dated 24.05.2022, passed by the learned trial Court, by virtue
of which, the defendant was ordered to be proceeded against
exparte.
4.4.
The application has been filed on the ground that
the defendant has no office at Plot No.F77/C, Road No.I, D
VKI, Area Jaipur (Rajasthan). According to the defendant, its
registered office is at 15/5, Mathura Road, Faridabad–121003,
Haryana and the name of the Company earlier was M/s
Escorts Limited, which was now changed to Escort Kubota
Limited.
4.5.
The defendant came to know about the pendency
of the suit only on 20.09.2025, when they had received a
summons from the learned trial Court to produce the record.
Thereafter, they had moved the application.
2026:HHC:9627
The said
application has been contested by plaintiffDevinder Kumar.
4.6.
Since, the application, under Order 9 Rule 7 CPC,
was moved, after the prescribed period of limitation, as such,
the defendant has also filed application, under Section 5 of the
Limitation for condonation of delay.
4.7.
Both the applications were allowed by the learned
trial Court, vide order dated 26.11.2025 and the exparte order
dated 24.05.2022, was recalled, by putting the following
conditions:
“1.
The defendant shall pay costs of `5,000/ to the
plaintiff to compensate for the expenses incurred
towards publication and examination of witnesses.
2.
The defendant shall bear the process fee and diet
money of any witness who may be required to be
recalled for crossexamination. In case he fails to
do so for any witness, it shall be presumed that
defendant does not wish to crossexamine said
witness and admits their testimony.
3.
The defendant shall ensure the presence of
plaintiff’s witness No.7 (Dealing Head/Manager of
the defendant Company) along with the relevant
record, as and when directed by the Court.
4.
The defendant company shall deposit a sum of
`9,00,000/ (Rupees Nine Lakh only) with the
Court as security for the possible decreetal amount
2026:HHC:9627
and interest, if any, that may be adjudged in
favour of the plaintiff.
5.
5.
Compliance of all the aforesaid conditions shall be
made on or before the next date of hearing, which
stands fixed for the filing of the written statement.
Only one opportunity shall be afforded for the
same.
6.
Shamsher Singh, who has filed the present
applications on behalf of the defendant company,
is recognized as its authorized representative for
the purposes of contesting this suit, subject to the
filing of a formal authorization letter/resolution
issued by the company on or before the next date of
hearing.
7.
In case of failure to comply with any of the above
conditions, the defendant shall be liable to adverse
orders, including forfeiture of the right to file the
written statement or to participate further in the
proceedings.”
Feeling aggrieved from the said order, the present
petition has been filed, mainly on the ground that the
condition imposed by the learned trial Court, directing the
defendant to deposit a sum of Rs.9,00,000/, as a precondition,
for setting aside the exparte order is arbitrary, unreasonable
and without any legal justification, as such, the same is not
permissible under the law.
6.
According to the defendant, the learned trial Court
has fallen into error by imposing the condition to deposit a
2026:HHC:9627
sum of Rs.9,00,000/, as a precondition, to recall the order, by
virtue of which, the defendant was proceeded against exparte.
7.
The findings have further been assailed on the
ground that while deciding the application, under Order 9
Rule 7 CPC, learned trial Court has passed the order qua
deposit of Rs.9,00,000/, which could only be passed, under the
provisions of order 38 Rule 5 CPC, that too, on fulfillment of
the statutory provisions.
8.
On the basis of the above facts, Shri Arvind
Sharma, Advocate, appearing for the petitionerdefendant has
prayed that the said condition may kindly be set aside and the
defendant may kindly be permitted to join the proceedings.
9.
The prayer, so made, in the petition, has been
opposed by Mr. Ajay Sharma, learned Senior Advocate
assisted by Mr. Tarun Brakta, Advocate, on the ground that
despite publication of the notice, when, the defendant had
failed to put appearance, the defendant was ordered to be
proceeded against exparte. The present petition, according to
the learned Senior Counsel, is nothing, but, tactics to delay the
proceedings, as reasonable order directing the defendant to
deposit
Rs.9,00,000/
2026:HHC:9627
has
been
passed
by
specifically
mentioning that this amount would be as security for the
possible decree, which may be passed against the defendant.
As such, it has been prayed that the order passed by the
learned trial Court on 26.11.2025, does not require any
interference by this Court, that too, under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
10.
The factual position, in the present case, is not in
dispute.
Defendant, despite publication of notice, in the
newspaper, has not bothered to put appearance, as such, the
defendant was proceeded against exparte. Subsequently, the
defendant had filed application, under Order 9 Rule 7 CPC,
which was allowed vide order, dated 26.11.2025, under
challenge, before this Court.
11.
In the application, under Order 9 Rule 7 CPC, a
stand has been taken that the defendant was not aware about
the pendency of the suit, nor, was aware about the fact that
the defendant was proceeded against exparte, vide order dated
24.05.2022.
12.
2026:HHC:9627
While deciding the said application, the learned
trial Court had also imposed the cost of Rs.5,000/ and in
addition to this, Rs.9,00,000/ were ordered to be deposited.
The learned trial Court was within its jurisdiction to impose a
cost, for recalling the exparte order, to permit the defendant to
join the proceedings.
13.
This Court is of the view that the learned trial
Court has considered the entire facts and circumstances, as to
how, the case remained on board for about four years for
service of defendant, and when proceeded against exparte,
thereafter, the application, under Order 9 Rule 7 CPC has
been filed. The learned trial Court, in para 52 of the order,
has given the reasoning for directing the deposit of a sum of
Rs.9,00,000/.
14.
Learned counsel appearing for the defendant could
not satisfy the judicial conscience of this Court, as to how the
order passed by the learned trial Court to deposit a sum of
Rs.9,00,000/, can be said to be without any jurisdiction, as,
while deciding the application, under Order 9 Rule 7 CPC, the
learned trial Court is at liberty to impose conditions, however,
2026:HHC:9627
considering the fact that the suit was filed for recovery of
Rs.5,00,000/ only, as such, the condition to deposit a sum of
Rs.9,00,000/ as security, is liable to be modified, by directing
the defendant to deposit a sum of Rs.5,00,000/.
Ordered
accordingly.
15.
The learned trial Court is directed to invest the
said amount, in the shape of FDR and the same shall not be
disbursed to anyone till the final disposal of the suit.
16.
With these observations, the present petition is
disposed of. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall
also stand disposed of.
March 31, 2026( ps )
( Virender Singh )
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review