The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. Accordingly, WA No.42 of 2022 is dismissed.
19. MC (WA) No.23 of 2022 is disposed of.
20. There will, however, be no order as to costs. (W. Diengdoh) Judge (Sanjib Banerjee) Chief Justice Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.02
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No.42/2022 with
MC (WA) No.23/2022
Date of order: 15.12.2022
M/s Dharani Geotech Engineers & anr Vs. State of Meghalaya & ors
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Appellants
: Mr. K. Saha, Adv with
Mr. M. Prasad, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. A. Kumar, Advocate-General with
Mr. S. Sahay, GA
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, GA
Ms. S. Laloo, GA
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The appeal is directed against a judgment and order of November
15, 2022 by which the appellants’ writ petition has been rejected.
2.
The grievance that the appellants carried to the writ court was that
the bid of the first appellant for a project for the repair and upliftment of
the Umiam dam had been wrongfully rejected.
3.
Two principal grounds have been canvassed in this appeal: that
even the respondent employer and the bid evaluation committee set up by
the employer were satisfied that the first appellant met the eligibility
criteria for its financial bid to be considered; and, that that the initial
satisfaction of the bid evaluation committee was modified upon obtaining
the opinion from a Central government organisation which had no
business to interfere in the matter.
4.
The dispute is confined to the extent of the work experience of
the first appellant herein. The documents furnished in connection with
inviting bids for the project indicated the experience necessary for a
contractor to be eligible for consideration. Clause 4.2(b) of the
qualification criteria in the technical part of the notice inviting bids
stipulated as follows:
“For the above and any other contracts substantially completed
and under implementation as prime contractor, joint venture
member, or sub-contractor between 1st January 2010 and
application submission deadline, a minimum construction
experience in the following key activities successfully completed:
1. Drilling: 10,000 Rmt
2. Grouting: 1130 MT
3. Concrete works: 880 Cum”
5.
As a part of the bid documents submitted by the first appellant, it
relied on an agreement between itself and APC Drilling and Construction
Private Limited executed in or about May, 2020. In essence, such deed
indicated that APC Drilling and Construction Private Limited had been
awarded a contract by NTPC Limited for the consolidation grouting of
rock mass below and around the flip bucket area at NTPC Koldam HPES.
For such purpose, APC Drilling entered into the said agreement with the
first appellant herein where the first appellant herein was described as an
associate. However, the extent of the first appellant’s association in the
project appears to have been restricted to only the grouting work involved
as the words “for grouting works” invariably accompanied in parenthesis
whenever the first appellant herein was described as an associate of APC
Drilling in the relevant agreement. Both in the recital and in the primary
clauses 1 and 2 of the relevant agreement, the first appellant was referred
to as “associate (for grouting works)”.
6.
Since the work at the NTPC site also involved drilling work and
since the first appellant herein was associated with the project and
undertook the work awarded by NTPC to APC Drilling, it relied on the
said agreement and other documents pertaining to receipt of payments,
labour license and the like in support of its assertion in its bid documents
that it had the requisite work experience, inter alia, in terms of clause
4.2(b) of the qualification criteria as indicated in the technical part of the
notice inviting bids.
7.
It appears that the bid evaluation committee of the employer
found the documents submitted by the first appellant herein to indicate
the first appellant’s eligibility to be considered for appointment as a
contractor for the Umiam project. However, despite the apparent
satisfaction of the bid evaluation committee as to the bid responsiveness
of the first appellant herein, the employer chose to consult the Central
Project Management Unit under the Ministry of Jal Shakti of the Union
to obtain a second opinion.
8.
In response to the employer’s query in such regard, CPMU made
an independent assessment of the bid documents submitted by the first
appellant and was of the opinion that since the first appellant herein had
been associated with the NTPC work at Koldam only for grouting
purposes, it did not meet the requisite experience on account of drilling
work as called for in the bid documents. The State as the employer,
accepted the view of CPMU and, by the impugned notice dated October
20, 2022, communicated its rejection of the bid to the first appellant
herein on the ground that the bid was non-responsive and the first
appellant technically not qualified. The exact reason furnished by the
employer in such regard is quoted:
“With reference to the above, it may be informed that the
Technical Evaluation Committee and CPMU have evaluated the
bids for the above mentioned work and have declared the bid
submitted by you as non-responsive and technically not
qualified due to the reason indicated below:ECQ 4.2(b) Key Activities: (1) i.e. executed drilling quantities.
As per the documents submitted for the Work “Consolidation
Grouting of Rock Mass Below and Around flip bucket are of
NTPC Koldam HPES”, it has been found that M/s Dharani
Geotech Engineers was an associate in the quoted project, and had
carried out works pertaining to Grouting. The deed of joint
undertaking executed by the parties for the above quoted project
also states that the associate was engaged to carry out grouting
works. Hence, the documents indicates that the drilling activities
have been carried out by the Main Contractor i.e. M/s APC
Drilling and Construction Pvt. Ltd. Therefore, not qualified under
EQC 4.2(b).”
9.
The first appellant immediately responded to the notice of
rejection by issuing a letter on October 23, 2022, inter alia, asserting that
notwithstanding APC Drilling being the superior contractor in respect of
the NTPC project, the entire work had been done by the first appellant
herein and even payments in respect thereof had been released to the first
appellant. To boot, the first appellant called upon the State to verify from
NTPC as to the nature of the work undertaken and completed by the first
appellant in the NTPC project. A detailed email also followed from the
first appellant along with other papers apparently seeking to assert that
the first appellant had the requisite experience in drilling.
10.
Though several judgments were referred to before the Single
Bench, primarily on the extent of court interference in matters pertaining
to contracts and acceptance or rejection of bids, since the State has been
hardly called upon in the present case, the authorities have not been
referred to in course of the present appeal.
11.
Two primary questions appear to have been framed by the Single
Bench in assessing the matter: whether the involvement of CPMU was
illegal or arbitrary; and, whether the first appellant herein had
demonstrated that it met the eligibility criteria to be considered for the
relevant project. Indeed, these were the only questions which were
relevant in the context of the first appellant’s challenge to the notice of
rejection of October 20, 2022.
12.
As to the first ground, it appears to be a complete non-starter. The
matter may have been different if the employer had accepted the bid
evaluation committee’s satisfaction and communicated the same to the
bidder and thereafter purported to change its mind on the basis of any
opinion obtained from a third party. However, such was not the case.
When an employer seeks to assess the technical expertise of a bidder in a
crucial infrastructure project, the employer, particularly a government
employer, is well within its rights to consult persons or organisations that
it deems to be experts in the relevant field. Surely, the Central Project
Management Unit of the Ministry of Jal Shakti could have been deemed
to be an expert considering the nature of the work involved in the present
project. Thus, there cannot be any grievance on the part of the first
appellant herein in the State as employer in the present case having
consulted CPMU or having obtained a second opinion from such body.
13.
The next part of the first issue is the more important aspect.
Whether or not an employer has conducted an assessment on its own,
when a second opinion is sought and obtained and the employer accepts
such second opinion upon its application of mind, the employer cannot
be faulted therefor. This was not a case of a busy-body seeking to
intervene and try to change the employer’s opinion as to the bid
responsiveness of the first appellant herein. It was only an endeavour on
the part of the employer to ensure that the assessment was correct. The
employer’s reference of the matter to an expert body and the employer’s
subsequent acceptance of the expert opinion in such regard must,
necessarily, be seen in such light.
14.
The fact that CPMU may have been mentioned in the contract as
a consultant has no bearing on the issue. Indeed, CPMU need not have
been mentioned in the contract at all. CPMU was considered by the
employer in this case to be an expert in the matter of assessing the
technical qualification of the bidders apparently found suitable. It was not
as if the employer referred only the case of the first appellant bidder to
CPMU. The reference pertained to such bids that had been apparently
found to be responsive and CPMU’s opinion also covered both the bids.
15.
It is the other issue which has arisen which is of paramount
importance. It is elementary that when some eligibility criteria are
specified and a bid is made in pursuance thereof, the bid should be
complete in itself to indicate how the eligibility criteria were met. The
bidder has to cover all parameters pertaining to eligibility in the bid
documents itself and after submission of bid, generally, no further
material can be submitted to improve the bid or to demonstrate the
qualifications of the bidder. In certain cases, particularly in complex
engineering projects, clarifications are sought after receiving the
technical bid and the correspondence exchanged in such regard are also
considered to be a part of the bid since they precede the actual assessment
of the bid.
16.
In the present case, certain clarifications were sought by the
employer from the first appellant herein. However, such queries pertained
to the status of the first appellant in the NTPC project as an associate of
APC Drilling. Though the initial letter of the employer in such regard
referred to clause 4.2 of the eligibility criteria under the technical part of
the bid documents, no clarification was sought as to whether the first
appellant had the requisite experience of completing 10,000 Rmt of
drilling work. Since the question was not asked, nothing was furnished
on behalf of the first appellant in response to the queries raised by the
employer to indicate that it had the requisite experience in respect of
drilling.
17.
Since the writ court found that the bid submitted by the first
appellant did not completely indicate the eligibility of the first appellant
qua drilling and the writ court also, quite appropriately, found that there
was nothing arbitrary or illegal in the employer in the present case
consulting CPMU before accepting or rejecting the technical bid of the
first appellant herein, the order impugned does not call for any
interference.
18.
Accordingly, WA No.42 of 2022 is dismissed.
19.
MC (WA) No.23 of 2022 is disposed of.
20.
There will, however, be no order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
15.12.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review