Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3301 ]
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI'JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITION NO: 31232 OF 2024
Between:
M/s. Deccan Chronicle Holdings Ltd, No. 36, Sarojini Devi Road, Secunderabad.
Represented by its Chief Financial and H.R head, Mr. Baratam Anil Kumar.
...PETITIONER
AND
The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner -ll Employees P.F.,
Organization, Regional Office l, Bhavishyanidhi Bhavan, Barkatpura,
Hyderabad.
The Central Government lndustrial Tribunal, Cum Labour Court., Manorajan
Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad.
...RESPONOENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an order, direction or writ particularly one in the nature of a
certiorari, to call for the records relating to the order passed by the 2 nd
respondent, i.e. Central Government lndustrial Tribunal, Hyderabad, in lA No 1
and 2 ol 2024 in EPF Appeal No.33 ot 2024 daled 27-O9-2024 and lo quash and
set aside the said order to the extent of imposing the condition of pre-deposit 30
percent of the ordered amount, as lhe same is illegal, arbitrary and without
jurisdiction and in vialation of the provisions to the Employees Provident Fund
and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 and grant such other relief or relief s as
this Honorable Court deems fit and proper in the circumstances of the case.
lA NO: 1 Ot= 2024
Petit on under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend ttre operation of the condition ordered by the Central Government
lndustrial Tribunal, Hyderabad in lA No 1 and 2 of 2024 in EPF Appeal No 33 of
2O24 daled 27 -09-2024 to the extent of imposing the Condition of pre- deposit of
30% of lhe ordered amount, in the interest and justice and equity.
lA NO: 1 01:2025
Between:
The Regiorral Provident Fund Commissioner -ll Employees P.F., Organization,
Regional Office l, Bhavishyanidhi Bhavan, Barkatpura, Hyderabad.
...PETITIONER
AND
'1. M/s. Deccan Chronicle Holdings Ltd, No. 36, Sarojini Devi Road,
Secunderabad. Represented by its Chief Financial and H.R head, Mr.
Baratam Anil Kumar.
2. The ()entral Government lndustrial Tribunal, Cum Labour Court., Manoraian
Complex, Nampally, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
' Petiticn under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavil filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased To
Vacate the interim order of stay passed in lA1l2O24 in WP3123212024 dl.8-11-
2024 and extended from time to time and by the latest o'det d1.20-2-2025 and
pass such other in the interests of justice.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI C.NTRANJAN RAO
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 : MS.T.BALA JAYASREE (SC FOR EPFO)
Counsel for the Respondent No.2 : SRIG.VENKATES1{WARLU,
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA I{ARTHIK
WRIT PETITION No.3L232 OF 20.24
Dated 9tu Januarv. 2O26
Between:
M/s. Deccan Chronicle
Petitioner
AND
The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner-ll,
Employee Provident Fund Organization
Regional Office [, Bhavishyanidhi Bhawan,
Barkatpura, Hyderabad & another
Respondents
ORDER:
This Writ Petition is filed seeking the following relief:
.u.... to issue a writ, order or direction more in the nature of a
certiorari, to Call for the records relating to the order passed by the lna
Respondent i.e. Central Government Industrial Tribunal, Hyderabad in
IA No 1 and 2 of 2024 in EPF Appeal No 33 of 2024 dated 27-09-2024
and to quash and set aside the said order to the extent of imposing the
condition of pre- deposit 30% of the ordered amount, as illegal as the
same is against to the provisions to the Employees Provident Fund &
Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 and is in violation of the settled legal
principles and consequent set-aside the same and grant such other
relief or reliefs as this Honble Court deems fit and proper in the
circumstances of the case."
r
PK, J
wp_3t232_2O24
2l
Brief facts of the case are that petitioner is a company
registerel under the companies Act engaged in the business of
publishi.g newspaper under the name and style of Deccan
chronick: and is covered under the EpF Act with code No.Ap/
and has been remitting the EpF contributions regularly. However,
the first respondent has passed an order dated rg.oz.2024 under
section ',7-c of the EpF Act directing the petitioner to pay an
amount of Rs.5,93,o6,724/- on the ground that barance pF
contributions have to be paid on gross wages without any reference
to salary timit in view of the provisions contained in para go
Scheme (Special provisions in the case
of
of EpF
Newspaper
establishrnents and newspaper employees). Aggrieved by the
said
order, petitioner has filed an appeal before respondent No.2 vide
EPF Appeal No.33 of 2024 wherein the Tribunal vide order
27 .09.2024 in IA Nos. 1 and 2 of 2024 has ordered
dated
the petitioner to
deposit 3cto/o of the amount directed to be paid in the order passed
under section 7-c of the EpF Act, as a pre-condition for granting
the stay. Aggrieved by the said condition of pre-deposit, the
petitioner:.s before this Court.
PK, J
wP_31232_2024
3)
Heard Mr. C.Niaranjan Rao, learned counsel for the
petitioner, Smt. T.Bala Jayasree, learned Standing Counsel,
appearing for respondent No.1, and Sri G.Venkateshwarlu, learned
Standing Counsel, appearing for respondent No..2.
4l
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that due to
phenomenal growth of electronic media since 1990s followed by
wide spread mobile apps from 2OOO, the business of petitioner has
drastically reduced. In view of the accumulated financial losses
which effected the newspaper industry, the Company could not pay
the loans to various linancial institutions within the stipulated
time. Therefore, the Canara Bank, Prime Corporate Branch,
Secunderbad, has filed an application before the National Company
Law Tribunal, Hyderabad, under Section 7 of Insolvency and
Bankruptcy Code, 2OL6. After hearing the parties, the Tribunal
passed an order dated L9.O7 .2OL7 in CP No. 18 / 4l /7 /HDB /20t7
admitting the appeal and public announcement was also made
about the initiation of Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process as
prescribed under section 15 (1) and (2) of the Insolvency and
Barrkruptcy Code, 2016. Further, as per the orders of the
Tribunal, a Resolution Professional was appointed. [n the
PK, J
wp_31232_2024
meantime, the ajfairs of the petitioner company were being
monitored by the Manasng Committee/Super-rzisory Committee in
terms ol' the interim order dated o5.12.2ol9 passed by the
Tribunal in company Appeal (AT) (Ins.) No.982 of 2019. Learned
counsel has contended that in view of the covid-l9 pandemic, the
financial position of the petitioner Company was further affected.
Yet, within the limitations of the challenges of the cash flow, the
supervis<1ry committee assisted by erstwhile Resolution
Professiorral is making all efforts to keep the company as a going
concern imd preserve its values and employment of many people
directly and indirectly is depending on the company. As such, the
income generation of the petitioner Company has fallen short of
flow and therefore it could
not remit the monthly provident
"""i,
fund contributions from April, 2017 onwards within time.
Therefore, respondent No.1 has initiated proceedings under Section
7A (1) (b) of the EPF Act for the period from April, 2olr to october,
2019. Further, without considering the objections raised by the
petitioner, an order dated 26.11.2020 has been passed under
Section 7-A of the EPF Act determining the pF dues payable by the
petitioner as Rs.14,86,08,946/- for the above said period. Despite
,,
/
e=€
i'
,,
PK, J
wp_31232_2024
the financial constraints, the petitioner has paid the total due
amount by taking few instalments and the same was also accepted
by respondent No.l without any protest and the Company is
regularly paying its current PF Contributions/dues well within
time. Learned counsel has contended that basing on the incorrect
representation dated 23.06.2023 made by the employees of the
petitioner to respondent No.1 for higher pension as well as higher
contributions without any salary limit, respondent No.1 has issued
the show cause notice dated 29.08.2023, to which, the petitioner
has submitted its reply on 05.09.2023 requesting to drop the said
notice as the petitioner Company is under the proceedings of
Resolution Plan in full and that it has been complying the
provisions of EPF Act since last 67 years. Further, during the
inquiry proceedings, the petitioner made written submissions on
27.03.2024, 18.04.2024, 24.05.2024 and O2.O7.2024 to
respondent No.l. But, without considering the legal and factual
issues raised by the petitioner, respondent No.l passed the order
dated 19.07.2024 under Section 7-C of the EPF Act directing the
petitioner to remit an amount of Rs.5,93,06,7741- which the
petitioner is not at all liable to pay and the sarne is challenged by
!E6
PK,
J *!
wp_3t232_2O24
the petitioner before respondent No.2 vide
Appeal No.33 of 2024.
In the said appeal, petitioner had arso fired
I.A.Nos.1 and 2 of 2o24
seeking to waive the condition of pre-deposit
of the o::der dated rg.oz.2024 wherern
and grant suspension
respo+dent No.2 passed the
impugnr:d order to deposit 300/0 of the
amount determined in the
order derted rg.or.2024. Learned counser
has further contended
that while deciding the appeals fired under
sectio n z_r of the EpF
Act, the Tribunar can impose the pre-condition
the said appeals are fired against the orders
of deposit, only if
passed under Section
7-A of the EpF Act and the said condition
as specified under
Section 7-o of the EpF Act is not applicabre.
contended that the order passed by the
Therefore, it is
Tribunal is liabre to be set
aside to the extent of ordering to pay
3oyo of the determined
amount tmder section z-c of the Ep Act. Reliance
has been placed
on the decision of the Hon'rcle Supreme court
in shiu Hqrbq.t
Researcht Loboratory a. Assistcrnt provident
Fund.
commissionefl and the order dated passed
Judicature at Bombay in w.p.No.3659 of
t 2016 Labour Law
Reporter 55
)
by the High court of
2011, dated 20.06.20Lr.
PK, J
wp_31232*2024
5)
Per contra, the learned Standing Counsel appearing for the
respondents has submitted that the petitioner establishment is
covered under the provisions of EPF & MP Act, L952 with Code
No.AP/HYDIL76 and the schemes framed under the said Act are
applicable to the Establishments are Employees' Provident Funds
Scheme, L952, Employees' Pension Scheme, 1995, and the
Employees' Deposit Linked Insurance Scheme, L976. While so,
respondent No.1 has issued summons on 19. 12.2023 to the parties
for initiation of inquiry under Section 7C of the EPF Act. After
a{fording reasonable opportunities, the Inquiry Officer has passed
the order dated 26.11.2020. Learned Standing Counsel has
contended that the employer is liable to remit the contribution at
l2%o as per Section 6 without restricting the basic wages to the
wage ceiling for newspaper employees in the establishment which
is a newspaper establishment for the period of inquiry. When the
statute becomes applicable on the establishment, the employer is
duty bound to comply the provisions of the Statute without waiting
either for the inspections or assessments under Section T A or 7C of
the EPF Act as the principle of estoppel will not operate in case of
statutory default. Further, Section 6 of the Act fixes statutory
PK, J
wp.3t232_2024
liability on the petitioner to pay the contributions as per the
provision:s of the Statute. It is further contended that the grounds
urged by the petitioner of financial distress or the initiation of CIRP
cannot vitiate the enquiry under Section TC of the EpF Act and
such pro<:eedings shall not foreclose the authority under the EpF
Act from assessing the dues. It is further contended that Section
7-o of thr: EPF Act requires the condition of pre-deposit of TSo/o of
the amouet assessed for entertaining the appeal. However, without
giving any opportunity to the petitioner, the Tribunal i.e.
respondent No.2 has passed the impugned order reducing the
quantum of pre-deposit. The financial diffrculties cannot be
allowed to be a ground to seek waiver for delayed remittances of pF
contributicns. Further, the judgment relied by the petitioner is not
applicable to the present case inasmuch as the inquiry conducted
under se<:tion 7c of the EPF Act is continuation of the inquiry
under Section 7A of the EPF Act. Therefore, the learned Standing
counsel prayed to dismiss the writ petition. Reliance has been
placed on Express Pnblicatlons (Madurai) Ltd us. union oJ
^l
PK, J
wp_31232_2024
Indla2 and M/s. Shlz Gouindaraja Mill.s a. Reglonal Prouldent
Ittnd Commissionef .
6)
This Court has taken note of the submissions made by
respective parties and perused the material on record-
7l
A perusal of the record discloses that admittedly respondent
No.1 has passed the order dated 19.07.2024 under Section 7-C of
the Employees'Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act,
1952, and ordered the petitioner to pay an amount of
Rs.5,93,06,7741- towards escaped amount. Aggrieved by the said
order, petitioner has preferred EPF Appeal No.33/2O2a under
Section 7-l of the EPF Act before respondent No.2 along with IA
Nos.l and 2 of 2024 wherein respondent No.2 has passed the order
dated 27.09.2024 and stayed the operation of the impugned order
dated 19.07.2024 subject to remittance of 3O% of the amount
determined under Section 7-C of the EPF Act, within a period of six
weeks thereof. The said condition of pre-deposit is under challenge
before this Court.
2 AIR 2004 SC 1950
3 2024 Supreme (Online) (Mad) 78881
l0
PK, J
wp-31232.2024
8) At the juncture, this Court deems it apt to refer Section 7-O
as well as Section 7-C of the EPF Act, which read as under:
7-O. Deposit of amount due, on fillng of appeal.- No appeal by the
employr:r shall be entertained by a Tribunal unless he has deposited
with it :ievengr-five per cent. of the amount due from him as determined
by an olficer referred to in Section 7A:
Provi,led that the Tribunal may, for reasons to be recorded in writing,
waive or reduce the amount to be deposited under this section.
7C. De,termination of escaped amount.- Where an order determining
the amount due from an employer under section 7 A or section 7E} has
been passed and if the officer who passed the order(a) has reason to believe that by reason of the ornission or failure on
the parl of the employer to make any document or report available, or to
disclose, fully and truly, all material facts necessary for determining the
correct amount due from the employer, €u1y amount so due from such
employr:r for any period has escaped his notice;
. (b) hrrs, in consequence of information in his profession, reason to
believe that any amount to be determined under section 7 A or section
78 has escaped from his determination for any period notwithstanding
that the re has been no omission or failure as mentioned in clause (a) on
the parl of the employer,
he may within a period of five years from the date of communication of
the ordr:r passed under section 7A or section 78, re-open the case and
pass appropriate orders re-determining the amount due from the
employr:r in accordance with the provisions of this Act.
Provi,led that no order re-determining the amount due from the
employr:r shall be passed under this section unless the employer is
given a reasonable opportunity of representing his case."
lt
^l
lt
PK, J
wp_31232_2024
9)
From the above, it is clear that an order under Section 7C of
the EPF Act would be passed in respect of the amor:.nts escaped by
the employer even after determination of the amounts under
Section 7A or 78 of the EPF Act. Therefore, the order passed under
Section 7C of the EPF Act has to be treated as in continuation of
I
the orders passed under Section 7 A or 78 of the EPF Act.
10) Insofar as the judgments relied by the learned counsel for the
petitioner are concerned, Section 7C of the EPF Act was not dea-lt
with in the said judgments. Hence, they are of no avail to the
petitioner in the present case.
11) For the afore-mentioned reasons, this Court does not Iind any
error' in the order passed by respondent No.2 directing the
petitioner to pre-deposit the amount. However, having regard to
the fact that the relief is interim in nature and as the petitioner is
questioning the liability in paying the escaped amount, this Court
deems it appropriate to reduce the quantum of pre-deposit from
sooh to 2o%o, to balance the equities. Further, the Tribunal shall
expedite the hearing of the appeal.
/
/
n
t2
PK, J
wp-3t232_2024
l2l with above directions, the writ petition is disposed of.
Mi:scellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall stand closed.
No costs.
SD/- AHMED ABDULLA KHAN
ANT REGISTRAR
/ffRUE COPY//
CTION OFFICER
To,
1. The llegional Provident Fund Commissioner -ll Employees P.F.,
Organization, Regional Office l, Bhavishyanidhi Bhavan, Barkatpura,
Hyde,rabad.
2. The (lentral Government lndustrial Tribunal, Cum Labour Court., Manorajan
Comlrlex, Nampally, Hyderabad.
3. One CC to SRI C.NIRANJAN RAO, Advocate. [OPUC]
4. One CC to MS.T.BALA JAYASREE (SC FOR EPFO). [OPUC]
5. One CC to SRI G.VENKATESHWARLU (SC FOR CENTRAL GOVT). IOPUCI
6. Two 3D Copies.
BSK
. GJP
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:09/01 12026
THE S
t
o
ORDEFI
?
1 I
WP.No,31232 ot 2024
DISPOS}ING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
)
Ll,
*
I'lll R 7ttlfr
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review