Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supp.List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
CRP. No. 2 of 2022
Date of Order :11.02.2022
M/s. BSC-C AND CJV
Vs.
The Chief Engineer (PWD)
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. U. Hazarika, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. R. Prakash, Adv.
Mr. L. Khyriem, Adv.
Ms. G. Mohan, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Mr. S. Sahay, GA
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, GA.
Ms. R. Colney, GA.
i)
:
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
Yes/No
in press:
______________________________________________________________
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Matter is taken up via Video Conferencing.
2.
The instant petition before this Court under Article 227 has been filed
seeking to set aside and quash orders dated 29-10-2021, 17-11-2021 and 10-122021 passed by the learned Commercial Court, Shillong in Commercial Case.
No. 13/2021 initiated by respondents under Section 34 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996. The petitioner is aggrieved by the exercise of jurisdiction
by the learned Commercial Court in assuming jurisdiction by allegedly ignoring
the provisions of Section 34 and 36 of the Act; and in passing the impugned
orders which have deprived the petitioner from the fruits of the award. The main
contention of the petitioner is that while an application under Section 33 was
pending before the Arbitral Tribunal, the respondents filed an application under
Section 34 before the learned Commercial Court which was taken up for
consideration and orders were passed thereon, which according to the petitioner
are illegal and without jurisdiction.
3.
The factual background leading to the present dispute is that the petitioner
was awarded a contract for 2 laning of Shillong - Nongstoin section of NH 44 E
and Nongstoin- Rongjeng-Tura Road in the State of Meghalaya under Phase-A
of SARDP-NE-NH 44-E and SR-MG-PWD-2010-11-172, and an agreement to
this effect, was executed between the petitioner and the respondents on 21-022011. The initial contract price was fixed at Rs. 1303 crores, but subsequently,
due to variations and increase in the scope of work, the contract price was revised
by the respondent through various Revised Cost Estimates and the contract price
thereafter stood at Rs. 2406.06 crores.
4.
That during the execution of the project, certain disputes arose between
the parties and after extension of time, the project was completed on 31-12-2017,
after a delay of 45(forty-five) months. To resolve the disputes, the dispute
resolution clause was invoked by the petitioner and thereafter, an Arbitral
Tribunal was constituted and came into reference on 10-04-2019. In the
proceedings before the Arbitral Tribunal, the petitioner then filed an application
under Section 31(6) seeking an interim award on a part of the dispute and for the
remainder of the dispute, a statement of claims was filed on 31-05-2019. Vide
order dated 27-07-2021, the Arbitral Tribunal awarded 75 crores to the
petitioner, on a finding that there was overwhelming material on record, to
justify the said entitlement for an interim award as prayed for.
5.
Thereafter, it appears that on 16-08-2021, the petitioner filed an
application under Section 33(1)(a) and 33(4) of the Act seeking correction of the
interim award as well as for an additional award towards the claims which
though claimed, did not form part of the interim award. To this application, it
also appears, that the respondent filed a reply on 13-09-2021. On 28-10-2021
when the matter was fixed for arguments, an adjournment was taken by the
respondent and the matter stood deferred to 08-11-2021 and on this date, the
petitioner was served with an application under Section 34 filed by the
respondent before the learned Commercial Court, along with a copy of an order
dated 29.10.2021, granting an unconditional stay of the award dated 27-07-2021.
6.
The proceeding before the learned Commercial Court then resulted in
further orders being passed dated 17-11-2021, which slightly modified the stay
order dated 29-10-2021 and 10-12-2021, wherein the learned Commercial Court
passed orders for the continuance of the interim order staying the award. The
petitioner in these proceedings had also sought for dismissal of the Section 34
application and for vacation of the stay order dated 29-10-2021. In the meantime,
the Arbitral Tribunal vide order dated 21-12-2021, dismissed the application
filed by the petitioner under Section 33 of the Act. Being aggrieved with the
interim orders dated 29-10-2021, 17-11-2021 and 10-12-2021, passed by the
learned Commercial Court, this revision application is before this Court.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
8.
Mr. U. Hazarika, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. R. Prakash,
learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the learned Commercial Court has
wrongfully assumed jurisdiction in express breach of the provisions of Section
34(3) of the Act and passed interim orders which have interfered with the arbitral
proceedings and the award. The learned Senior counsel submits that Section 5
of the Act prohibits any other judicial authority from intervening in such matters
except if provided so. He further submits that the scheme of the Act provides for
a rendition of an interim award under Section 31(6) read with Section 2(c) of the
Act and also provides for its correction by a petition under Section 33, within
30(thirty) days of the passing of the award. Learned Senior counsel with
reference to Section 34(3), submits that the right to challenge the award when an
application under Section 33 is pending, would commence from the date of the
disposal of the Section 33 application within a period of 3(three) months. The
language of Section 34(3) he contends, refers to the disposal of the request under
Section 33 which would be the trigger date for a challenge to the award, and in
this case, he submits, the right to challenge the award would accrue to the
respondent only after the disposal of the application under Section 33 which in
this case was on 21-12-2021. In support of his submissions, learned Senior
counsel has placed reliance on the following decisions.
(i)
Prakash Atlanta v. National Highway Authority of India (2016)
SCC Online Del 743.
(ii)
Ved Prakash Mithal v. Union of India (2018) SCC Online SC
3181.
(iii)
9.
P.Radha Bai v. P. Ashok Kumar (2019) 13 SCC 445.
The learned Senior counsel submits that the initiation of the proceedings
before the learned Commercial Court under Section 34 during the pendency of
the Section 33 application, which the respondent had participated in before the
Arbitral Tribunal, has therefore resulted in parallel proceedings. Coming to the
orders of the learned Commercial Court, the learned Senior counsel submits that
the initial order dated 29-10-2021, granting a stay of the award overlooked the
fact that the Section 33 application was pending and further, the stay was granted
without adverting to the provisions of Section 36(2) and (3). Regarding the
orders dated 17-11-2021 and 10-12-2021, the learned Senior counsel submits
that despite the non-maintainability of the Section 34 application, the learned
Commercial Court chose to continue the interim order of stay of the award while
permitting the Section 33 proceedings to continue. The resultant fact of these
illegal proceedings, he contends, is that the petitioner’s right to seek fulfillment
of the award has been frustrated.
10.
In reply to these submissions made by the learned counsel for the
petitioner, the learned Advocate General has first raised the question of
maintainability of the instant application under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India. The main contention of the learned Advocate General, is that Section 5
of the Arbitration Act bars judicial interference in arbitration proceedings except
as prescribed under the Act, and that it is settled law that the Arbitration Act is
a self-contained code. Section 37 of the Act he submits, has enumerated the
categories from where appeal would lie, to the exclusion of any other ground
and the impugned orders not falling under any of the enumerated categories of
Section 37 are therefore not appealable orders. The learned Advocate General
submits that the present petition seeks to secure indirectly the right of appeal
which is not available under the Act. On another limb of argument, the learned
Advocate General submits that Section 8 of the Commercial Courts Act has
placed a bar on the entertaining of a civil revision or petition, against
interlocutory orders of the Commercial Courts including on jurisdictional issues,
and that Section 8 itself further prescribes that an appeal will be subject to
Section 13 (1)(3) which in turn is subject to Section 37 of the Arbitration Act.
As such, he contends that Section 8 of the Commercial Courts Act read with
Sections 5 and 37 of the Arbitration Act bars the instant petition.
11.
In support of these two arguments, learned Advocate General has cited the
following judgments: (i)
NTPC vs. MePDCL 2021 SCC Online Megh 134 (Para 31, 36, 37,
38)
(ii)
BGS SGS SOMA JV v. NHPC, (2020) 4 SCC 234 (Para 12-20)
(iii)
Fuerst Day Lawson Ltd. V. Jindal Exports Ltd. (2011) 8 SCC 333
(Paras 89-91)
(iv)
Chintels India Ltd v Bhayana Builders 2021 SCC Online SC 80
(Para 29)
(v)
Black Diamond Track Parts Private Limited v. Black Diamond
Motors Private Limited (Para 29, 30)
12.
The learned Advocate General on the invocation of Article 227 of the
Constitution by the petitioner, submits that the scope of interference under
Article 227 is extremely limited and the invocation of such jurisdiction is subject
to the existence of exceptional situations such as; inherent or patent lack of
jurisdiction, malafides or fraud. He contends that none of the prescribed
conditions for invoking the extra-ordinary jurisdiction of this Court has been
made out and that the petitioner has not made a single averment in the pleadings,
either before this Court, or before the learned Commercial Court, that the
Learned Commercial Court inherently or patently lacks jurisdiction. He further
submits that the stand that the petitioner has taken, that the Section 34 application
was pre-mature, is in itself an admission that it is not a case of inherent or patent
lack of jurisdiction but rather at best, a case of error within the jurisdiction of the
learned Commercial Court. The learned AG in this context has placed the
following judgments: (i)
Deep Industries Ltd. v. ONGC, (2020) 15 SCC 706 (Para 22
onwards)
(ii)
Bhaven Construction vs. Executive Engineer 2021 Online SC 8
(Para 10-12, 16-17, 22-23, 27)
(iii)
Navayuga Engineering Company vs. Bangalore Metro Rail
Corporation Limited 2021 SCC Online SC 469 (Para 4)
13.
It is further submitted that the judicial trend is heavily weighted in favour
of rejection of such attempts, and that the Supreme Court and various other
Courts have consistently by several judgments, rejected efforts of parties to
circumvent the arbitration framework under the Act, by recourse to proceedings
under Article 227. To buttress this argument that Article 227 cannot be invoked
to frustrate the intent and purpose of the Arbitration Act, the learned Advocate
General, has cited the following cases, wherein petitions under Article 227
against Section 34 interim orders were dismissed; namely :(i)
Ambience Project vs. Neeraj Bindal 2021 SCC Online Del 4023
(Para 16)
(ii)
Surender Kumar Singhal v. Arun Kumar Bhalotia, 2021 SCC
Online Del 3708 (Para 25 (viii)]
(iii)
Ashok Kumar Puri and Another vs. S. Suncon Realtors Pvt. Ltd.
and Another 2021 SCC Online Del 5220 (Para 8&9)
14.
The learned Advocate General then argues that the petitioner has already
submitted to the jurisdiction of the Commercial Court, inasmuch as, Misc.
applications being Misc. Case 23 and 24 of 2021, containing objections had been
filed by the petitioner and the same were considered and decided by the
Commercial Court itself. He submits that the petitioner, having submitted to the
jurisdiction of the Commercial Court, cannot now challenge it in collateral
proceedings; and the Commercial Court having the jurisdiction to decide a
challenge to an arbitral award, the only controversy that remained was whether
this jurisdiction could be exercised during pendency of a Section 33 application
under the Act. It is further submitted by the learned AG that the petitioner having
contested the passing of the impugned order of ad-interim stay on merits, has
chosen to pursue a remedy under the Arbitration Act, and as such is required to
abide by the said Act itself and having availed the opportunity before the learned
Commercial Court, no collateral challenge can lie. The learned AG further
contends that the order dated 29-10-2021 was modified vide order dated 17-112021, on the specific consent and request of the petitioner, which therefore
estops the petitioner from resorting to other remedy instead of the procedure
prescribed under the Arbitration Act.
15.
On the other aspect as to whether a Section 34 application will be
maintainable during the pendency of an application under Section 33 before the
Arbitral Tribunal, the learned AG contends that an award is a final determination
of the issues referred to arbitration and that the award is enforceable as a decree,
where the rights and liabilities of the parties, on issues raised or claimed therein,
stand determined on the basis of the said award. An arbitral award, he contends
includes an interim award and therefore the award though passed at an interim
stage, the respondent is entitled to seek remedy against the same under Section
34. The learned AG then submits that no bar exists in Section 33 and 34, which
prohibits the challenge to an arbitral award pending a clarification application
under Section 33, and as such the Section 34 application cannot be said to be
pre-mature. It is further argued that the petitioner’s reliance on 34(3) of the
Arbitration Act is mis-placed, inasmuch as, Section 34 (3) provides an extended
period of limitation to challenge the award which was subject to an application
of correction and it cannot be said that it has created a bar to challenge an award
already passed. As such, he submits there is no statutory bar for preferring a
Section 34 application during the pendency of a petition under Section 33.
16.
The learned AG further submits that not challenging the award within the
(3) three month’s period therefore, could have exposed the respondent to the risk
of expiration of the limitation period to challenge the award under Section 34.
In this regard, he submits that the Supreme Court in the case of State of
Arunachal Pradesh v. Damini Construction (2007) 10 SCC 742, refused to
condone the period expired on a frivolous Section 33 application in computing
the limitation for challenging the arbitral award under Section 34.
17.
In concluding his submissions, the learned Advocate General submits that,
as it stands today the Arbitral Tribunal had already rejected the Section 33
application of the petitioner, therefore, the undisputed fact is that the award dated
27-07-2021 has neither been corrected nor modified, and the respondent having
statutory right to challenge the same has already done so. As such, he contends
the present petition is infructuous in view of the dismissal of the Section 33
application and further the petition being not maintainable under Article 227, the
same is liable to be dismissed and that parties are to seek and pursue the remedies
within the four corners of the Arbitration Act.
18.
Mr. U. Hazarika, learned Senior counsel on behalf of the petitioner in
response to the respondent’s arguments, firstly submits that the language of
Section 34 (3) is very clear that there is only a three month period available to a
party to challenge an award, one after passing of the award, and the other after
disposal of Section 33 proceedings, and as such, in a situation even if the first
application of section 34 is validly filed, it would necessarily become infructuous
as the same has been filed after the initiation of Section 33 proceedings, as in the
present case and therefore the Section 34 application is void. Learned Senior
counsel then submits that the right to sue, accrues only when the cause of action
arises and in the instant case the right to sue accrued to the respondent only on
the disposal of the Section 33 application on 21-12-2021. This, the learned
Senior counsel submits, is in consonance with the judgment of the Supreme
Court in the case of V.P. Mithal (Supra) that disposal within the meaning of
Section 34 (3) can be either allowing or dismissing the Section 33 application.
19.
On the challenge to maintainability of the application under Article 227
of the Constitution, the learned Senior counsel submits that there being no
sanction under Section 34(3) to filing a petition when an application under
Section 33 is pending, the respondent having done so, is violative of the
provisions of the Arbitration Act, and the learned Commercial Court lacked
inherent jurisdiction to entertain such a petition. The learned Senior counsel
submits that therefore, there being no remedy under the Arbitration Act, the only
efficacious alternative available to the petitioner, is an application under Article
227 of the Constitution, which has empowered High Courts with supervisory
jurisdiction over Courts and Tribunals to keep them within the metes and bounds
of their jurisdiction and authority. Learned Senior counsel submits that the
judgment cited by the respondents in this context, deals with cases where the
jurisdiction under Article 227 has been invoked in respect of the orders passed
in validly instituted petitions under the Arbitration Act, unlike the present case
where the learned Commercial Court patently lacked jurisdiction. The learned
Sr. counsel while rounding of his response, has placed reliance on the case of
State of Gujarat vs. Union of India (2018) Online Guj 1515 to highlight the
parameters of interference under Article 227, in the context of Section 8 of the
Commercial Courts Act.
20.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties, noted the submissions and
considered the materials before the Court. Shorn of other details and facts, the
core questions that have arisen for determination before this Court is first, the
maintainability of an application under Article 227 against the orders of the
Commercial Court and secondly, whether a Section 34 application should be
entertained, while a Section 33 application is pending disposal before an Arbitral
Tribunal.
21.
On the first question, there is no quarrel that the Arbitration Act is a self-
contained code wherein the procedure has been prescribed and appealable orders
categorically laid out in Section 37. Further, the stipulation of Section 5 cannot
be ignored as also the other provisions. The Commercial Court’s Act in this
regard, has also vide Section 8 cast a bar against Revision application or Petitions
against an interlocutory order of a Commercial Court including an order on the
issue of jurisdiction and further has prescribed by Section 13, the manner and
procedure of appeal and provided that only those orders that are enumerated
under Order 43 of the Code of Civil Procedure and Section 37 of the Arbitration
Act are appealable. In this backdrop, the facts of the instant case have to be
examined from the standpoint of the statutory policy and the judicial
pronouncements that have been rendered by the Supreme Court and other High
Courts.
22.
As submitted by the respondent with the support of the cited cases, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Deep Industries Ltd (Supra) has held that,
though petitions under Article 227 can be filed, the High Court must be
extremely circumspect in interfering and that interference be restricted to orders
that are passed lacking inherent jurisdiction. Further, it is observed in the same
judgment that if petitions were to be filed under Articles 226/227 of the
Constitution against orders passed in appeals under Section 37, the entire arbitral
process would be derailed, while at the same time it is also observed that Article
227 is a constitutional provision which remains untouched by the non obstante
clause of Section 5 of the Act, the same however, should be exercised with
extreme care. The Supreme Court in Bhavan Constructions (Supra) in the same
vein, has held that discretion under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution cannot
be exercised to allow judicial interference beyond procedure established under
the Arbitration Act and that the exercise of such powers is not permissible except
in exceptionally rare circumstances, where one party is left remediless under the
statute, or a clear bad faith shown by one of the parties. It is also further noted
that the same judicial position as laid down in Deep Industries Ltd (Supra) is
reiterated in the case of Navayuga Engineering Company (Supra).
23.
It is correct that the judicial trend is heavily weighted in favour of rejection
of applications under Articles 226/227 as in most cases, recourse is taken to the
same by parties to stall or circumvent the proceedings under the Arbitration Act.
It is also correct that in commercial matters, time is the essence and legislation,
such as the Commercial Courts Act and amendments to the Arbitration Act have
been enacted to limit and circumscribe circumstances that lead to delay in the
disposal of such matters by way of appeals or revisions which do not meet the
rigors of the Arbitration Act and Commercial Courts Act. This however, does
not in any manner effect the supervisory jurisdiction of the High Courts under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India, against orders interim or otherwise,
passed by the Commercial Courts, but the exercise of such jurisdiction must be
used sparingly to correct patent errors which would keep the Subordinate Courts
within their bounds of their authority and jurisdiction. In this context, the
observations made by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Surya Dev Rai vs.
Ram Chander Rai (2003) 6SCC 675 will be of valuable assistance in the
consideration of the manner in which powers under Article 227 are to be
exercised by the High Court. Para 39 which is relevant is reproduced herein
below:
“39.
Though we have tried to lay down broad
principles and working rules, the fact remains that the
parameters for exercise of jurisdiction under Articles 226 or
227 of the Constitution cannot be tied down in a strait-jacket
formula or rigid rules. Not less than often, the High Court
would be faced with a dilemma. If it intervenes in pending
proceedings there is bound to be delay in termination of
proceedings. If it does not intervene, the error of the moment
may earn immunity from correction. The facts and
circumstances of a given case may make it more appropriate
for the High Court to exercise self-restraint and not to
intervene because the error of jurisdiction though committed
is yet capable of being taken care of and corrected at a later
stage and the wrong done, if any, would be set right and
rights and equities adjusted in appeal or revision preferred
at the conclusion of the proceedings. But there may be cases
where “a stitch in time would save nine”. At the end, we may
sum up by saying that the power is there but the exercise is
discretionary which will be governed solely by the dictates of
judicial conscience enriched by judicial experience and
practical wisdom of the judge.”
24.
As such, what emerges from the judgments that have been placed and
from the extract quoted above, is that the power of supervisory jurisdiction is to
be exercised sparingly and only in cases where failure of justice has been
occasioned and unless the error in the proceedings is corrected, the same would
result in a wrong that would remain uncorrected, or result in prolonging the lis.
Exercise of supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 in such matters therefore,
should not result in prolonging the case or cause multiplicity of proceedings but
its use should be limited to exceptionally rare situations or circumstances and
should be in aid of the adoption and adherence to a procedure established by law
by the Subordinate Courts.
25.
Coming to the legality and validity of the impugned orders as also the
procedure adopted, the short point is on the purport of Section 34(3) and the
filing of a petition under Section 34, when an application under Section 33 is
pending. Section 34(3) for the sake of convenience is quoted herein below:
“34(3)
An application for setting aside may not be
made after three months have elapsed from the date on which
the party making that application had received the arbitral
award or, if a request had been made under section 33, from
the date on which that request had been disposed of by the
arbitral tribunal:
Provided that if the Court is satisfied that the
applicant was prevented by sufficient cause from making the
application within the said period of three months it may
entertain the application within a further period of thirty
days, but not thereafter.”
26.
A perusal of this provision reflects the prescription of limitation on
applications on the passing of an award. It has been argued by the respondents
that pendency of the application under Section 33, would not preclude the right
of a party to make an application after receipt of the arbitral award, interim or
otherwise, and that to come within the limitation period the Section 34
application had been filed. In this context, as to whether this proposition as
advanced by the respondents is a correct position in law, the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of P.Radha Bai & Ors. v. P. Ashok Kumar
& Anr. (2019) 13 SCC 445 wherein the scheme of limitation for challenging
the arbitral award has been explained is relevant and at para 32.1and 36.3 it has
been held as follows:
“32.1
Section 34 is the only remedy for challenging an
award passed under Part I of the Arbitration Act. Section 34(3) is
a limitation provision, which is inbuilt into the remedy provision.
One does not have to look at the Limitation Act or any other
provision for identifying the limitation period for challenging an
award passed under Part I of the Arbitration Act.
36.3 Third, Section 34(3) reflects the principle of unbreakability.
Dr. Peter Binder in International Commercial Arbitration and
Conciliation in UNCITRAL Model Law Jurisdictions, 2nd Edn.,
observed:
“An application for setting aside an award can
only be made during the three months following the
date on which the party making the application has
received the award. Only if a party has made a request
for correction or interpretation of the award under
Article 33 does the time-limit of three months begin
after the tribunal has disposed of the request. This
exception from the three-month time-limit was subject
to criticism in the working group due to fears that it
could be used as a delaying tactics. However,
although “an unbreakable time-limit for applications
for setting aside” was sought as being desirable for
the sake of “certainty and expediency” the prevailing
view was that the words ought to be retained “since
they presented the reasonable consequence of Article
33”. According to this “unbreakability” of time-limit
and true to the “certainty and expediency” of the
arbitral awards, any grounds for setting aside the
award that emerge after the three-month time-limit
has expired cannot be raised”.
(emphasis supplied)
27.
In the case of Ved Prakash Mithal and Sons vs. Union of India (2018)
SCC Online 3181, the Hon’ble Supreme Court on the same question has held
that the period mentioned in Section 34(3) would start running from the day
Section 33 application is disposed of and application of Section 34 within the
said limit could be said to be within time, and further that disposal of the
application can be either by allowing it or dismissing it. Relevant paragraphs
from 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 is reproduced herein below:
“5. The respondent preferred an appeal before the High
Court, whereby the learned Single Judge of the High Court,
by his judgment dated 10.07.2017, reversed the order of the
Additional District Judge stating that as the Section
33 application had been disposed of only on 14.12.2015, the
period mentioned in Section 34(3) would start running only
from then, in which case, the Section 34 application could be
said to be within time.
6.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners
before us has argued that the expression “disposed” which
is mentioned in Section 34(3) would have to be read in
consonance with and in harmony with Section 33. So read,
this would only mean where some positive step has, in fact,
taken place under Section 33 and the Award is either
corrected or modified. This could not possibly refer to an
Award which is not ultimately corrected or modified and the
application under Section 33 is merely dismissed. For this,
he relies upon the judgment of a Single Judge of the Bombay
High Court in the case of Amit Suryakant Lunavat v. Kotak
Securities, Mumbai reported in 2010 (6) Mh.L.J. 764. The
learned Single Judge held:
“13. There is no justification, as contended, to accept
the submission in view of the mandate of section 34
and considering the scheme and purpose of
the Arbitration Act that because the application
under section 33 of the Act was filed and it was
rejected subsequently, therefore, the limitation period
commenced afresh from the date of such decision of
the award. In my view, it is contemplated only on a
situation where the Arbitrator corrects or interprets
and/or add or decide to add any additional claims and
modified the award as only in such cases the original
award looses its originality and therefore an
application for setting aside the award needs to be
filed within three months from the date of receipt of
such corrected or modified award. Therefore, the
party who received the award after deciding the
application under section 34(3) of the Act, may get the
benefit of fresh commencement of limitation from the
receipt of the modified and/or corrected award and
not otherwise.”
7.
We are of the view that the judgment of the Bombay
High Court does not reflect the correct position in law.
Section 34(3) specifically speaks of the date on which a
request under Section 33 has been “disposed of” by the
Arbitral Tribunal.
8.
We are also of the view that a “disposal” of the
application can be either by allowing it or dismissing it. On
this short ground, in our opinion, the learned Single Judge
of the Delhi High Court is correct in law.
9.
The Special
dismissed.”
28.
Leave
Petition
is,
accordingly,
In the instant case, the petitioner had filed an application under Section 33
(1) (a) and 33(4) on 16.08.2021, after the passing of the interim award by the
Arbitral Tribunal on 27-07-2021, seeking corrections as well as for an additional
award. To this application, a reply was also filed by the respondents on
30.09.2021, who however, during pendency of the Section 33 applications,
moved the Commercial Court under Section 34 against the interim award, which
resulted in the impugned orders being passed. Taking into account the scheme
of the Act especially Section 34(3) read together with Section 5 and in the light
of the decisions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, it can be safely concluded that
the Section 34 application filed by the respondents before the learned
Commercial Court could not in common prudence be filed, during the pendency
of a Section 33 application especially when the respondents were participating
in the said proceedings, as the statute provides for a period of three months after
the disposal of the application for parties to challenge the award under Section
34. The language of Section 34(3) therefore refers to the disposal of request
under Section 33 as being the trigger date for a challenge to the award. Whether
the application under Section 33 was dismissed or changes made to the award
would be immaterial, as a plain reading of this provision reflects that the three
months limitation period would run from the date of disposal of the Section 33
application. It is to be noted also that the contention of the respondent that the
case of State of Arunachal Pradesh v. Damini Construction
(Supra) is
applicable in the instant case cannot be accepted as in the said case, after the
period of limitation under Section 34(3) of the Act expired, the appellant then
wrote a letter to the arbitrator for review of the award and also sought
clarification which is not the situation in this instant case wherein the Section 33
application was pending before the Arbitral Tribunal.
29.
This being the position, though Section 33 and section 34 are independent
provisions, the learned Commercial Court had erred in exercising its jurisdiction
in entertaining a Section 34 application at that stage, after the respondent had
disclosed before the Commercial Court that a section 33 application was pending
before the Arbitral Tribunal. In the impugned order dated 17-11-2021 passed in
Commercial Misc. Case No. 24/2021, the learned Commercial Court itself had
recorded and observed that as on that date, an application under Section 33 was
pending before the Arbitral Tribunal for adjudication, but however, though
allowing the Section 33 proceedings to be disposed of by the Arbitral Tribunal,
had extended the stay of the interim award, which had been granted vide the first
impugned order dated 29-10-2021. This in the considered view of this court, has
allowed for a piquant situation to unfold, inasmuch as, parallel proceedings were
allowed to continue. Though Section 34(3) of the Act prescribes only the
limitation period, the scheme and purpose of the Act, in the opinion of this Court,
has provided for certainty and expediency of the time limit allowed for
challenging the award as couched in the words of Section 34(3), that clearly
provides a time limit of three months after disposal of a petition under Section
33 and certainly does not envisage such a situation where parallel proceedings
are permitted.
30.
In the totality of the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case, and
after due consideration, especially on the aspect of invocation of Article 227 in
such matters, this Court is constrained to observe that a limited interference is
called for to correct the procedure adopted by the Commercial Court to bring the
matter on the right track, by the exercise of powers of supervisory jurisdiction
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
31.
Accordingly, the impugned orders dated 29-10-2021, 17-11-2021 and 10-
12-2021 as far as they relate to the stay of the interim arbitral award dated 2707-2021 are hereby set aside. As the Section 33 application has since been
rejected by the Arbitral Tribunal, the Section 34 application filed by the
respondents, shall be now taken up afresh (de novo) by the Commercial Court
for consideration by affording opportunity to the petitioner before any other
orders are passed thereon.
32.
With the above directions, the petition stands partially allowed and
accordingly stands disposed of.
33.
Parties directed to appear before the learned Commercial Court on 7 th
March 2022 for resumption of the proceedings.
34.
Parties to bear their own costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
11.02.2022
“Samantha-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review