Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
132521
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE THIRD DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
WRIT PETITION NO: 35379 OF 2025
Between
M/s. BPR lnfrastructure Pvt Ltd., Rep by its Managing Director, Sri Baddam
Prabhakar Reddy S/o. Baddam Narayana Aged about-72 years, OccBusiness, R/o. Plot No.348/A, MLA Colony, Road No.12, Banjara Hills,
Hyderabad-34.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, rep by its Special Chief Secretary(FAC) For the
youth Advancement, Tourism, and Culture Department of Telangana. At
Secretariat, Hyderabad
2. Telangana State Tourism Development Corporation Ltd, Rep by its Managing
Director Having its office at Tourism House No.3-5891,Himayatnager
Hyderabad- 29
3. The State of Telangna, Rep by its Principal Secretary for Finance
Department, At Secretariat, Hyderabad.
4. The Superintending Engineer, TSTDC Ltd, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue writ of Mandamus
l.Declare the inaction of the Respondents in not releasing certified amounts for
works executed under Agreement. No.05/SE/SB/TSTDC/AgnU2023-24, dated
27.04.2023 as arbitrary, illegal, and violative of Articles 14, 19(1)(g), and 300-4 of
the Constitution of lndia
Consequently direct the Respondents to release the certified 1st Part bill of
Rs.2,79,09,175.00/-Gross, dated 19.12.2023,2nd Part bill of Rs.1,58,49,968.00/-
:i:,tir
"ri.rffii.'
Gross, dakrd 27.03.2024, 3rd Part bill of Rs.17,68,421.00/-Gross, dated 01.or.2o2s,
Total- 4,5!;,27,564.001- (Rupees Four Crore Fifty Five Lakhs, Twenty Seven
Thousand and Five hundred and Sixty Eight Only) with 24 % interest per annum
from the defaulUdue date to till actual date of payment.
l.A. NO: 1OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
Respondents, especially 2,3 and 4 to forthwith release the certlfied and admitted
amounts of 1st Part bill of Rs.2,79,09,175.00/-Gross, dated 19.12.2023, 2nd Part bill
of Rs.1,58,49,968.00/-Gross, dated 27.03.2024, 3rd Part bill of Rs.17,68,421.001Gross, dakld 01 .07.2025 ,Total: 4,55,27,564.001- (Rupees Four Crore Fifty Five
Lakhs, Twr:nty Seven Thousand and Five hundred and Sixty Eight only) under
Agreement No.0S/SE/SB/ TSTDC/Agmt12o23-24, dated 27.o4.2023, pending
disposal of lhe writ petition.
l.A. NO: 2 (rF 2025
Petiticn under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit file,l in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the
respondentr; to forthwith release the admitted and certified bill amount of
Rs.4,42,61,,2011- (Rupees Four Crores Forty Two Lakhs Sixty One Thousand Two
Hundred attd One only) pursuant to Token No.2600703570 in respect of the
completed rvorks executed under Agreement No.0S/SE/SB/ TSTDC lAgmtl2O23-24,
dated 27.04.2023, pending disposal of the writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: Ms. G.SREE CHANDRA REP.
M/s. HYDERABAD LAW FIRM
counsel for the Respondent No.l: AGP FoR GENERAL ADMIN|STRATION
Counselforthe Respondent No.2 & 4: SRI P.VENKATESHWAR RAO,
SC FOR TSTDC
Gounsel for the Respondent No.3: AGP FOR FINANCE
The Court rnade the following: ORDER
o
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA
DATE: O3.O3.2026
Between :
M/s. BPR Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.
Rep. by its Managing Director
Petitioner
And
The State of Telangana,
Tourism Department,
Hyderabad & 3 others
"'i
ResPondents
'RDER:
Heard Ms. G. Sree Chandra, learned counsel
appearing on behalf of the petitioner, learned Assistant
Government Pleader for
General Administration,
appearing on behalf of Respondent No.1,
sri P. venkateshwar Rao, learned standing counsel
appearing on behalf of Respondent Nos.2 and 4 and
learned Assistant Government pleader for Finance
appearing on behatf of Respondent No.3.
2.
praver as under:
,,,*,i
SN,J
wP 35319 2025
"...to issue Writ of Mandamus, declare the inaction of the
respondents in not releasing certified amounts for works
executed under Agreement No.05/SE/SB/TSTDC/Ag m tl 2023 -24,
daled 27.04.2023 as arbitrary, illegal, and violative of Articles
1a, 19(1Xg) and 300-A of the Constitution of India, consequently
dirr:61 166 Respondents to release the certified l.t part bill of
Rs.2,79,O9,175.00/- Gross, dated 19.12.2O23, 2"d part biil of
Rs.1,58,49,968.00/- Gross, dated 27.03.2024,3'd & Final bill of
Rs.l7,68,42t/- Gross, dated ol.o7.2o25, Totat
Rs.4,55,27,564.00 (Rupees Four Crore Fifty Five Lakhs, Twenty
Seven Thousand and Five Hundred and Sixty Eight only), with
24(/o interest per annum from the default/due date to till actual
date of payment and pass such other order..."
3.
The case of the petitioner, in brief, is that the petitioner
had ent.ered into an agreement dated 27.04.2023 with the
Telangana State Tourism Development Corporation for the
construction of a budget hotel at Manyamkonda, Mahabubnagar
District, pursuant to a tender process in which the petitioner
emergecl as the lowest bidder. Despite initial site encumbrances,
the petitioner completed the work to the satisfaction of the
authorities, and the bills were duly measured, certified, and
approved for payment. The certified amounts include the lst part
bill date,l 19.12.2023, the 2nd part bill dated 27.03.2024, and
the 3rd and final bill dated 01.07 .2025, aggregating to
Rs.4,55,27,564/-. However, the respondents failed to release the
admitted dues without any legal justification. Aggrieved by the
SN,J
wP 35379 2025
r-)
same, the petitioner had approached this Court by filing the
present Writ Petition.
4.
PERUSED THE RECORD:-
(A)
State of Uttar Pradesh and others reoorted in (2019) 16
SCC 794 passed by the Two Judoe Bench of the Aoex
Court in Civil Aopeal No.251O of 2019 (Arisino out of SLP
(C) No.29505 of 2014), is extracted hereunder:
"...It is clear, therefore, from the aforesaid
order dated 22.03.20L4 that there is no dispute as to
the amount that has to be paid to the appellant.
Despite this, when the appellant knocked at the
doors of the High Court in a writ petition being Writ
Civil No.25126 of 2014, the impugned judgment
dated 02.05.2014 dismissed the writ petition stating
that disputed questions of fact arise and that the
amount due arises out of contract. We are afraid
the Hioh Court was wholly incorrect inasmuch
as there was no disouted ouestion of fact. On
well settled that where the State - behaves
I
Corooration of India Ltd. and Others' (2OO4 (3)
scc 553)I.
SN,J
wP_35379_2025
This being the case and the work having been
completed long back in 2009, we direct the Uttar
Pradesh Jal Nigam to make the necessary payment
within a period of four weeks from today. Given the
long period of delay, interest at the rate of 6 per cent
per annum may also be awarded.
The appeal stands disposed of accordingly."
(B) The Apex Coult in the iudqment reported in
observed as under:
*39. A Bench of two learned Judges of this
Court in Shrilekha Vidyarthi (Kumari) v. State of
U.P.4 observed that there exists "an obvious
difference" between contracts concerning private
parties to those which have State as a party. The
primary difference being that the State while
exercising its powers and discharging its functions
"acts indubitably, os is expected of it, for public aood
and in public interest". The said factor singularly is
sufficient to bring into any transaction the minimal
requirements of public law, to which the State is a
party. The fact that a dispute falls into the
contractual realm does not relieve the State of its
obligation to comply with the requirements of Article
L4.
40. Fufther the Court in Shrilekha Vidyarthi
case4 had observed that: (SCC p.237, para 24)
"24. The State cannot be attributed the split
personality of Dr.Jekyll and Mr. Hyde in the
contractual field so as to impress on it all the
characteristics of the State at the threshold while
SN.J
wP_35379 2025
r-\
making a contract requiring it to fulfil the obligation
of Article t4 of the Constitution and thereafter
permitting it to cast off its garb of State to adorn the
new robe of a private body during the subsistence of
the contract enabling it to act arbitrarily subject only
to the contractual obligations and remedies flowing
from it. It is really the nature of its personality as
Sfate which is significant and must characterize all
its actions, in whatever field, and-not'the nature of
function, contractual or otherwise, which is decisive
of the nature of scrutiny permitted for examining the
validity of its act. The requirement of Article 14
being the duty to act fairly, justly and reasonably,
there is nothing which militates against the concept
of requiring the State always to so act, even in
contractual matters. There is a basic difference
between the acts of the State which must invariably
be in public interest and those of a private individual,
engaged in similar activities, being primarily for
personal gain, which may or may not promote public
interest. Viewed in this matter, in which we find no
conceptual difficulty or anachronism, we find no
reason why the requirement of Atticle 74 should not
extend even in the sphere of contractual matters for
regulating the conduct of the State activity."
(c)
hereunder:
when there is nonof dacisions held
oavment of the undisouted bills' the same is
violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India. The counsel for the
petitioner rightly placed reliance on the decision of
\
SN,J
wP 35379 2025
the Apex Court in Surya Constructions Vs. State of
Utter Pradesh and others, following the judgment in
ABL International Ltd. Vs. Export Credit Guarantee
Corporation of India Ltd. Cited supra. In view of the
Apex Court judgment, the contention of the learned
Government Pleader that the writ petition is not
maintainable before this Court could not be
countenanced. The bills of the petitioner dated
13.3.2019 are admitted by the respondents and
forurarded for payment after due measurements and
obtaining quality control and the Vigilance report.
Hence, the authorities are estopped from stating that
the bills are submitted without executing the works.
On the mere ground of pendency of Vigilance report,
payment cannot be stopped. Accordinoly. there
shall be a direction to the respondents to pav
the bill a mount of Rs.8,O8.8 l- to the
oetitioner withan a oeraod of six weeks from the
date of receipt of copv of this order."
The relev nL Dortion of the
(E))
iudqment
g!g!9g[16.O3.2021 oassed by the Hioh Court of Andhra
Pradesh in Mutvala Veeravenkata Satvanaravana vs. The
State o f Andhra Pradesh reoo rted in 2021 SCCO :nline AP
t4to, i n Dartic ular oaraoraDh os.8 and f. is
hereunder:
"8. The provisions of the Act make it clear that
it is a welfare legislation meant to create
employmenfleradicate unemployment in rural areas
and in the process to create durable assets for rural
India. Thus, it is clear that a public element is
involved in these works with State participation and
funding. The "States" presence is therefore all
pervasive in this scheme. The law on the
interpretation of welfare legislation is also very clear.
As held in number of cases including K.H.Nazar v.
SN,J
wP 353 79 2025
Mathew K Jacob case by the Supreme Court of India
"Judges ought to be concerned with the colour,
content and the context of such statutes". Therefore,
in view of the settled law and keeping in mind the
purpose for which the legislation is enacted, this
Court has to hold that there is a public element
involved in this and that it is not a pure case of the
State entering into a commercial contract.
9. Aoart frgm this when State or State
instrumentalities act in an arbitrary manner or
fail to act within time the Writ Court does have
iurisdiction to entertain the matter. Even the
case law cited by the learned counsel for the
petitioner suppotts this to an extent. Besides this
Court notices that there is no method/mode for
settlement of disputes provided for. Section 23 of the
Act and Rule 14 of Schedule-I for example provide
for constant monitoring of the works/books to be
maintained etc. Despite this, there is no strict denial
of the exact quantum of work executed."
(E)
The
relev
ooltio
of
iudo
ent
dated 22.03.2022 passed by the Hiqh coult of Andhra
Practesh in W.P.No.2511 of 2O22, in particular paraoraph
Nos.23 and 24, is extracted hereunder:
"23r The Hioh Court of Andhra Pradesh in
J. Devendra Reddv v Kakativa UniversiW and
another reoorted in 2O15 (3) ALD 97' held that
withholding of the amount pavable to the
oetitioner for the contract works, constitutes
patent arbitrariness on the oart of the
resoondents and directed the resoondents to
oav 2O15 the amount due to the oetitioner
atonq with interest @ 12olo per annum'
241 The Hioh Court of Andhra Pradesh in
S. Srinivas vs. State of Andhra Pradesh and
\-
i
t(
SN,J
wP 35379 2025
others reported in 2021 (sLALT 267, held that
the oetitioner is entitled for the interest @ 12olo
p.a., from the date of exoiry of one month from
the date of submission of bill to till the date of
payment."
(lF) The relevant portion of the iudoment
@tctL21.04.2o25 oassed bv this court in w.p.tto.t17+c of
2025-!!r oarticular oaraqraph No.5, is extracted hereunder:
nq reoard to e submissions of both
the learned counsel, this Court deems it
aoorooriate to dispose of the Writ petition bv
directinq the resoondent authorities to release
It
the admitted bill amount of Rs.1,16.51.734.OO,
due to the petitioner as expeditiouslv as
oossible, oreferablv within a oeriod of six (Gl
weeks from the date of receipt of a copv of the
order. No costs."
(G) The .eler"nt oortion of the o.der of this Cgr"t
da.l!€dJ!3.1o.2023 oassed under similar circumstances in
$LP.N.9.12555 of 2o23 in particular oaraqraoh Nos.12 and
13, is extracted hereunder:
'12. In the light of the pteadings and
arguments referred to above, it is clear that there is
no dispute with regard to amounts payable under Bill
Nos.34, 35 and 36. It has been held bv the
Hon'ble Supreme Court from time to time that
writ iurisdiction oer se cannot be denied merety
because the dispute arose out of a commercial
contract as held in Surva Constructions, case
(Supra 1)- ABL fnternational Limited,s case
(Supra 2) and Century Soinning and
Manufacturino Company Limited,s case (Supra
1l
SN,J
wP_35379_2025
3). In Surva Constructions'case (Supra 1), the
Hon'ble Supreme Court oranted relief to the
oetitioner therein takino note of the fact that
bills payable to the petitigner were undisputed.
In the instant case, the oetitioner stands on a
better footinq as the bills of the oetitioner are
not only admitted but also certified. As observed
above, in the present case there is no dispute as
such between the parties. The o'nly'issue is with
regard to release of payment under Bill Nos.34, 35
and 36 by the respondents - State. No explanation is
forthcoming from the respondents as to why the
amounts covered by Bill Nos.34, 35 and 36 cannot
be released. According to the respondents, Bill
Nos.34, 35 and 36 are pending for want of budgetary
clearance. On the face of it, action of the
respondents is arbitrary, unreasonable and unjust
and the same cannot be countenanced.
13. The contention of the learned
Additional Advocate General that
the
petitioners have to aooroach civil Court even
for oavment of admitted bills runs contrarv to
the settled leqal orooosition. This Court would
also look into the public interest involved. The
project, as informed by the learned counsel on either
side, is an ongoing project and the bills worth of
hundreds of crores are kept pending for no reason
and there is every possibility of non-release of
payment impacting the ongoing project and the
same would not be in public interest. Even for this
reason, this Court holds that the petitioner has made
out a case warranting interference in writ
jurisdiction. Further, as there is inordinate delay in
release of payments covered by the subject bills by
the respondents to the petitioner without any
justification, in the opinion of this Court, the
respondents are liable to pay penal interest.
However, as against the claim of 18o/o per annum
sought by the petitioner, this Court holds that the
respondents are liable to pay penal interest at 9o/o
per annum."
-
il
I
i
SN,J
wP 35379 2025
5. The learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner submits that the subject issue in the present
writ petition is squarely covered by the order of this Court
dated 01.12.2025 passed in W.p.No.304O4 of 2O2S and
hence the petitioner is entifled for the grant of relief as
extended to the petitioner in W.p.No.3O4O4 of 2O25 dated
o1.12.:!,O25
6.
The I earned sta ndinq cou nsel aooe arinq on be half of
the resoondents does not disoute the said submission
made b v the learned counse I appearino on be half of the
oetitioner.
7. Taki nq into nsiderat lon:a) Tfre aforesaid facts and circumstances of the case,
b) The submissions made by the learned counset
appearing on behalf of the petitioner and learned
Standinrg Counsel appearing on behalf of respondent
Nos.2 and 4,
c) The observations in the judgments referred to and
extracted above and enlisted below:
(i) (2o1e) 16 SCC 7s4,
(ii) (2023) 8 SCC 240.
(iii) MANU/AP I 07 21 I 2022,
(iv) 2021 ScCOnline Ap 1410,
SNJ
wP 35379 2025
(v) The judgment dated 22.03.2022 passed by the
High Court of Andhra Pradesh in W.P.No.2511 of
2022,
(vi) The judgment dated 21.A4.2fJ25 passed by this
Court in W.P.No.l!744 ol 2O25,
(vii) The order dated 03.10.2023 passed by this
Court in W.P.No.12655 ol 2O23,
The writ petition is disposed of, directing the
respondents herein to consider the request of the
petitioner for release of the certified and admitted bill
amount of Rs.4r55r27F64l- (Rupees Four Crore Fifty Five
Lakhs, Twenty Seven Thousand and Five Hundred and
Sixty Four only) to the petitioner for the works executed
under Agreement No.O5/SE/SB/TSTDC/Agmtl2023-24
dated 27.0,4.2023 in accordance to law, as per petitioner's
legal entitlement, duly taking into consideration the
observation of the Apex Court and other Courts in the
judgments (referred to and extracted above), within a
period of four (O4) weeks from the date of receipt of a
copy of this order. There shall be no order as to costs.
Miscellaneous petitions,
if anV, _99I9[_g illlU L
Petition, shall stand closed.
Sd/-M. NAGAMANI
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
\
To,
1. The Special Chief Secretary(FAC) For the youth Advancement, Tourism, and
Culture Department of Telangana. At Secretariat, Hyderabad, State of
Telangana.
2. The Managing Director, Telangana State Tourism Development Corporation
Ltd, Having its office at Tourism House No.3-5891, Himayatnager Hyderabad29
3. The Principal Secretary for Finance Department, At Secretariat, Hyderabad,
State of T
\
4. The Superintending Engineer, TSTDC Ltd., Hyderabad
5. One CC;to Ms. HYDERABAD LAW FIRM, AdVOCAtC TOPUC]
6. One CC; to SRI P.VENKATESHWAR RAO, SC FOR TSTDC [OPUC]
7. Two CC)s to GP FOR GENERAL ADMINISTRATION, High Court for the State
of Telarrgana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
8. Two COs to GP FOR FINANCE, High Court for the State of Telangana at
Hyderalrad [OUT]
9. Two CEt Copies
BSR/DAN
,
I
HIGH C:OURT
DATED: 0310312026
I
I
t( oR
oo
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOIJT COSTS
\
$
S 14
21APR
ORDER.
WP.No.35379 of 2025
-IHE
*
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review