Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.( C) No.7398 of 2026
M/s Binod Construction a partnership firm and a registered MSME
having its office at Industrial Estate Kokar, P.O Ranchi GPO, PS
Sadar, District Ranchi 834001 through one of its partners namely
Shri Vikash Kumar aged about 53 years son of Late Binod Kishore
Prasad residing at 876/N, Subhash Chowk, Jatra Tand Bazar, PO
Kokar PS Sadar and Dist. Ranchi
...
Petitioner
Versus
1. Union of India through Ministry of Railways having its offices at Rail
Bhawan, 1, Raisina Road, Rajpath Area, Central Secretariat, PO &
PS Central Secretariat, New Delhi, 110001, India
2. Divisional Railway Manager South Eastern Railways Ranchi
Division having its offices at DRM Office Ranchi, Hatia, PO & PS
Hatia, Dist. Ranchi
3. Senior Divisional Electrical Engineer (TRD), Ranchi having its
offices at DRM Office Ranchi, Hatia, PO & PS Hatia, Dist. Ranchi
4. Praveen Meena Sr. Divisional Electrical Engineer (TRD), Ranchi
having its offices at DRM Office Ranchi, Hatia, PO & PS Hatia,
Dist. Ranchi
...
Respondents
--------CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ PRASAD
--------For the Petitioner
Mr. Amit Kumar Das, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Sahay Gaurav Piyush, Advocate
For the Respondents Mr. Kumar Vaibhav, CGC
Mr. Parth Jalan AC to CGC
--------03/Dated: 30.09.2026
1.
Heard Mr Amit Kumar Das, Sr. Advocate, appearing for the
petitioner, with Mr Sahay Gaurav Piyush, and Mr Kumar Vaibhav,
CGC, appearing for respondents 1 to 3, with Mr Parth Jalan. No
notice is required for the 4th respondent.
2.
Rule. The Rule is made returnable immediately with the
consent of the learned counsel for the parties.
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
3.
Petitioner
challenges
communication
dated
27.08.2026
(Annexure-14) by which 1st to 4th respondents have terminated the
contract with the petitioner, ordered the forfeiture of performance
security deposit and further, debarred the petitioner from
participation in bid for executing any work being rendered by the
Ranchi Division for a period of two years from the date of issue of
the impugned communication dated 27.08.2026.
4.
Mr Das submitted that the termination of the contract and the
invocation of the performance guarantee was ex facie arbitrary and
unreasonable. He submitted that the petitioner’s response to the
show-cause notice was not even considered before the impugned
communication was issued.
5.
Without prejudice, Mr Das submitted that the order of
blacklisting/debarment is an ex facie violation of the principles of
natural justice and fair play. He further submitted that the showcause notice dated 17.08.2026, which preceded the impugned
communication, neither expressly nor by implication refers to any
proposed action of black-listing. He relied on several decisions of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court and of this Court including the decision
in UMC Technologies Pvt. Ltd. Vrs. Food Corporation of India
& Anr. (2021) 2 SCC 551, to contend that a blacklisting/debarment
order without due compliance with principles of natural justice and
fair play warrants interference because this is one of the harshest
orders that can be made against the contractor.
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
6.
Mr. Kumar Vaibhav submits that despite grant of several
opportunities, the quality of services provided by the petitioner did
not improve. He submitted that a show-cause notice was issued
and after finding that the cause shown was unsatisfactory and
further, the petitioner took no serious steps to make good its
apparent defects, a decision was taken to terminate the contract
and invoke the performance guarantee. He submitted that this
decision was entirely consistent with Clause 7.4 of the general
conditions
of
contract,
and
that
no
arbitrariness
or
unreasonableness was involved in the decision-making process.
7.
Insofar as blacklisting/debarment is concerned, Mr Kumar
Vaibhav submitted that reference to the proposed action of
blacklisting/debarment need not always be express but can also be
implied from the surrounding circumstances as held in the case of
Gorkha Security Services Vrs. Government (NCT of Delhi) &
Ors., (2014) 9 SCC 105. He pointed out that, under Clause 4.11.8
of the contract, blacklisting/debarment for a period of two years is a
consequence only of rescission of the contract. He submitted that,
in
such
circumstances,
it
was
more
than
implied
that
debarment/blacklisting was on the anvil if the petitioner failed to
show sufficient cause.
8.
The rival contentions now call for our determination.
9.
Insofar as rescission of the contract and invocation of
performance guarantee is concerned, we are satisfied that any
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
evaluation of the rival contentions on this issue would involve
adjudication into seriously disputed questions of fact.
10.
The petitioner has asserted valid compliance with the
contractual terms. The respondents seriously dispute compliances.
They point to several letters in which shortcomings and defects
were pointed out to the petitioner, and the petitioner was called
upon to rectify them. At this stage, based on the material on record,
it would neither be appropriate nor be possible for this Court,
exercising its summary jurisdiction, to adjudicate upon such highly
disputed questions of fact.
11.
At least Prima- facie, we cannot accept that the termination
was ex facie in violation of principles of natural justice. This is
because a due show-cause notice was issued to the petitioner, and
the impugned order notes that the petitioner took no steps to
improve the quality of services and that the deployment of staff
violated the contractual provisions and the Labour Laws. The order
also notes that the petitioner did not even submit the duty roster.
12.
Thus, the contention that the petitioner’s reply was not
considered at all cannot be accepted. The absence of a formal line
stating that the decision maker considered the reply and found it
unsatisfactory is a mere matter of semantics. The authority
terminating the contract is not acting in some judicial or quasijudicial capacity requiring writing of elaborate orders.
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
13.
Therefore, we decline the invitation to adjudicate upon the
issue of termination of the contract or the invocation of the
performance guarantee on the ground that such adjudication would
involve highly disputed questions of fact.
14.
However, we clarify that, since we have not adjudicated upon
such dispute, our refusal to grant the petitioner any relief on this
score should not be construed as this Court's rejection of relief. The
petitioner may, if so advised, resort to any appropriate alternate
remedy, including a civil suit, to seek redress on the issue of
termination of the contract and the invocation of the performance
guarantee. This Court has left the contentions of all parties on this
issue open, as it has not decided them in this matter. Any
observations in this judgment and order are made only in the
context of deciding the issue of appropriate remedy; therefore, they
should not influence the courts or the authorities if approached to
decide the issue of termination and invocation of the performance
guarantee.
15.
As to the issue of debarment for two years, this Court can
investigate it, particularly because the challenge to this part of the
impugned communication is not to the merits of the decision but to
the decision-making process itself. The petitioner has contended
that the decision regarding debarment violated principles of natural
justice because the show-cause notice preceding the debarment
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
neither expressly nor by implication suggested any proposal for
debarment.
16.
Admittedly, the notice in this case makes no express
reference to debarment. It also makes no specific reference to
Clause 4.11.8 of the Contract. In any event, Mr Kumar Vaibhav’s
contention that debarment is only a consequence of rescission of
the contract can itself be said to be debatable, given the decisions
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court that one of the harshest actions,
debarment or blacklisting, cannot be resorted to merely because it
is established that the contractor may have breached the
contractual terms.
17.
In any event, the law is fairly settled that the show-cause
notice is required to be issued before any order of blacklisting or
debarment is made. It must, expressly or by implication, suggest
that such action is being proposed. The Hon’ble Supreme Court
has explained that blacklisting is one of the harshest actions
against a contractor and has also compared it to civil death. In
several decisions, including UMC Technologies Pvt. Ltd. (Supra),
the Hon'ble Supreme Court has underscored the importance of
issuing a particularised show-cause notice so the noticee can show
cause as to why such action should not be initiated against it.
18.
In the above regard, reference can usefully be made to the
contents of paragraphs 13 to 21 of the decision rendered by the
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
Supreme Court in UMC Technologies (Supra) which are
transcribed below for the convenience of reference:“13. At the outset, it must be noted that it is the first
principle of civilised jurisprudence that a person against
whom any action is sought to be taken or whose right or
interests are being affected should be given a reasonable
opportunity to defend himself. The basic principle of
natural justice is that before adjudication starts, the
authority concerned should give to the affected party a
notice of the case against him so that he can defend
himself. Such notice should be adequate and the grounds
necessitating action and the penalty/action proposed
should be mentioned specifically and unambiguously. An
order travelling beyond the bounds of notice is impermissible
and without jurisdiction to that extent. This Court in Nasir
Ahmad v. Custodian General, Evacuee Property has held that it
is essential for the notice to specify the particular grounds on
the basis of which an action is proposed to be taken so as to
enable the noticee to answer the case against him. If these
conditions are not satisfied, the person cannot be said to have
been granted any reasonable opportunity of being heard.
14. Specifically, in the context of blacklisting of a
person or an entity by the state or a state corporation, the
requirement of a valid, particularized and unambiguous
show cause notice is particularly crucial due to the severe
consequences of blacklisting and the stigmatization that
accrues to the person/entity being blacklisted. Here, it may
be gainful to describe the concept of blacklisting and the
graveness of the consequences occasioned by it.
Blacklisting has the effect of denying a person or an entity
the privileged opportunity of entering into government
contracts. This privilege arises because it is the State who
is the counterparty in government contracts and as such,
every eligible person is to be afforded an equal opportunity
to participate in such contracts, without arbitrariness and
discrimination. Not only does blacklisting take away this
privilege, it also tarnishes the blacklisted person’s
reputation and brings the person’s character into question.
Blacklisting also has long-lasting civil consequences for
the future business prospects of the blacklisted person.
15. In the present case as well, the appellant has submitted
that serious prejudice has been caused to it due to the
Corporation’s order of blacklisting as several other government
corporations have now terminated their contracts with the
appellant and/or prevented the appellant from participating in
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
future tenders even though the impugned blacklisting order
was, in fact, limited to the Corporation’s Madhya Pradesh
regional office. This domino effect, which can effectively
lead to the civil death of a person, shows that the
consequences of blacklisting travel far beyond the
dealings of the blacklisted person with one particular
government corporation and in view thereof, this Court has
consistently prescribed strict adherence to principles of
natural justice whenever an entity is sought to be
blacklisted.
16. The severity of the effects of blacklisting and the resultant
need for strict observance of the principles of natural justice
before passing an order of blacklisting were highlighted by this
Court in Erusian Equipment & Chemicals Ltd. v. State of West
Bengal in the following terms:
“12. …The order of blacklisting has the effect of
depriving a person of equality of opportunity in the matter of
public contract. A person who is on the approved list is
unable to enter into advantageous relations with the
Government because of the order of blacklisting. A person
who has been dealing with the Government in the matter of
sale and purchase of materials has a legitimate interest or
expectation. When the State acts to the prejudice of a
person it has to be supported by legality.
15. …The blacklisting order involves civil consequences.
It casts a slur. It creates a barrier between the persons
blacklisted and the Government in the matter of
transactions. The black lists are “instruments of coercion”.
20. Blacklisting has the effect of preventing a person from
the privilege and advantage of entering into lawful
relationship with the Government for purposes of gains. The
fact that a disability is created by the order of blacklisting
indicates that the relevant authority is to have an objective
satisfaction. Fundamentals of fair play require that the
person concerned should be given an opportunity to
represent his case before he is put on the blacklist.”
17. Similarly, this Court in Raghunath Thakur v. State of
Bihar struck down an order of blacklisting for future contracts
on the ground of non-observance of the principles of natural
justice. The relevant extract of the judgement in that case is as
follows:
“4. … It is an implied principle of the rule of law that any
order having civil consequences should be passed only after
following the principles of natural justice. It has to be realised
that blacklisting any person in respect of business ventures has
civil consequence for the future business of the person
concerned in any event. Even if the rules do not express so, it is
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
an elementary principle of natural justice that parties affected
by any order should have right of being heard and making
representations against the order.”
18. This Court in Gorkha Security Services v. Government
(NCT of Delhi) has described blacklisting as being equivalent to
the civil death of a person because blacklisting is stigmatic in
nature and debars a person from participating in government
tenders thereby precluding him from the award of government
contracts. It has been held thus:
“16. It is a common case of the parties that the blacklisting
has to be preceded by a show-cause notice. Law in this
regard is firmly grounded and does not even demand much
amplification. The necessity of compliance with the
principles of natural justice by giving the opportunity to the
person against whom action of blacklisting is sought to be
taken has a valid and solid rationale behind it. With
blacklisting, many civil and/or evil consequences follow. It is
described as “civil death” of a person who is foisted with the
order of blacklisting. Such an order is stigmatic in nature
and debars such a person from participating in government
tenders which means precluding him from the award of
government contracts.”
19. In light of the above decisions, it is clear that a prior show
cause notice granting a reasonable opportunity of being heard
is an essential element of all administrative decision-making
and particularly so in decisions pertaining to blacklisting which
entail grave consequences for the entity being blacklisted. In
these cases, furnishing of a valid show cause notice is critical
and a failure to do so would be fatal to any order of blacklisting
pursuant thereto.
20. In the present case, the factum of service of the show
cause notice dated 10.04.2018 by the Corporation upon the
appellant is not in dispute. Rather, what Shri Banerji has argued
on behalf of the appellant is that the contents of the said show
cause notice were not such that the appellant could have
anticipated that an order of blacklisting was being contemplated
by the Corporation. Gorkha Security Services is a case where
this Court had to decide whether the action of blacklisting could
have been taken without specifically proposing/contemplating
such an action in the show-cause notice. For this purpose, this
Court laid down the below guidelines as to the contents of a
show cause notice pursuant to which adverse action such as
blacklisting may be adopted:
“Contents of the show-cause notice
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
21.
The central issue, however, pertains to the
requirement of stating the action which is proposed to be
taken. The fundamental purpose behind the serving of
show-cause notice is to make the noticee understand the
precise case set up against him which he has to meet. This
would require the statement of imputations detailing out the
alleged breaches and defaults he has committed, so that he
gets an opportunity to rebut the same. Another
requirement, according to us, is the nature of action
which is proposed to be taken for such a breach. That
should also be stated so that the noticee is able to
point out that proposed action is not warranted in the
given case, even if the defaults/breaches complained of
are not satisfactorily explained. When it comes to
blacklisting, this requirement becomes all the more
imperative, having regard to the fact that it is harshest
possible action.
22.
The High Court has simply stated that the purpose
of show-cause notice is primarily to enable the noticee to
meet the grounds on which the action is proposed against
him. No doubt, the High Court is justified to this extent.
However, it is equally important to mention as to what
would be the consequence if the noticee does not
satisfactorily meet the grounds on which an action is
proposed. To put it otherwise, we are of the opinion
that in order to fulfil the requirements of principles of
natural justice, a show-cause notice should meet the
following two requirements viz:
(i)The material/grounds to be stated which
according to the department necessitates an action;
(ii)Particular
penalty/action
which
is
proposed to be taken. It is this second
requirement which the High Court has failed to
omit.
We may hasten to add that even if it is not specifically
mentioned in the show-cause notice but it can clearly
and safely be discerned from the reading thereof, that
would be sufficient to meet this requirement.”
21. Thus, from the above discussion, a clear legal position
emerges that for a show cause notice to constitute the
valid basis of a blacklisting order, such notice must spell
out clearly, or its contents be such that it can be clearly
inferred therefrom, that there is intention on the part of the
issuer of the notice to blacklist the noticee. Such a clear
notice is essential for ensuring that the person against
whom the penalty of blacklisting is intended to be
imposed, has an adequate, informed and meaningful
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
opportunity to
blacklisting.”
19.
show
cause
against
his
possible
In this case, we are satisfied that the show-cause notice
which preceded the impugned communication made neither any
express reference nor any implied reference to the proposal for
blacklisting/debarment. The notice makes no specific reference to
Clause 4.11.8 of the Contract. Simply stating that punitive action will
be taken in accordance with law or contractual provisions is not
sufficient. Even a simple reference to contractual provisions would not
suffice. On the short ground, the impugned communication, to the
extent it bars the petitioner from participating in the bid for executing
any work tendered by the Ranchi Division, is quashed and set aside.
However, it is clarified that such quashing shall not preclude the
respondents from issuing a fresh show-cause notice to the petitioner
and disposing of it in accordance with law.
20.
This petition is therefore, partly allowed. The challenge to the
termination of the contract and invocation of performance guarantee is
rejected, leaving it open to the petitioner to avail of alternate
remedies, but the impugned communication, to the extent it debars or
blacklists the petitioner, is hereby quashed and set aside. Again,
liberty is granted to the respondents to issue a fresh show-cause
notice and dispose it of in accordance with law on the issue of
blacklisting/debarment.
21.
The rule is made partly absolute in the above terms without
any order for costs.
( 2026:JHHC:29501-DB )
22.
IAs, if any, do not survive and are disposed of.
(M.S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Manoj Prasad, J.)
September 30, 2026
Pramanik/Anjali
Uploaded on 06.10.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review