Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 18TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL
WRIT PETITION NO. 37394 OF 2009 (GM-ST/RN)
BETWEEN:
M/S.BHORUKA POWER CORPORATION LTD.,
V FLOOR, HITANANDA II
NO.48, LAVELLE ROAD
BANGALORE - 560 001
REP BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR
SRI S CHANDRASEKHAR
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. M.M. SWAMY.,ADVOCATE)
AND:
Digitally
signed by
SUMA B N
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REP BY ITS CHIEF SECRETARY LAW AND
PARLIAMENTARY AFFAIRS
VIDHANA SOUDHA
BANGALORE-560 001.
2.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REP BY ITS SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
VIDHANA SOUDHA,
BANGALORE-560 001.
3.
THE DISTRICT REGISTRAR AND
DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF STAMPS,
MINI VIDHANA SOUDHA
STATION ROAD, GULBARGA.
4.
THE KARNATAKA POWER CORPORATION LIMITED
-2HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
SHAKTHI BHAVAN, NO.82, RACE COURSE ROAD,
BANGALORE-560 001
REP BY ITS CHAIRMAN/MANAGING DIRECTOR.
5.
KRISHNA BHAGYA JALA NIGAMA LIMITED
KHANAPUR - 585319
SHAHPUR TALUK,
GULBARGA DISTRCT,
REP BY ITS CHAIRMAN/MANAGING DIRECTOR.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. ASHOK N NAYAK FOR R4.,ADVOCATE FOR R4
SRI. SRINIVAS KUMAR M., HCGP FOR RESPONDENT)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226
AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO
DECLARING THAT ARTICLE 30(d) OF THE SCHEDULE TO THE
KARNATAKA
STAMP
ACT,
AS
UNCONSTITUTIONAL,
IRRATIONAL AND CONSEQUENTLY NOT APPLICABLE TO THE
LEASE DEEDS EXECUTED BETWEEN THE PETITIONER AND THE
R4 & 5 FOR SETTING UP MINI HYDEL PROJECTS VIDE ANX-B &
B1 AND ETC.
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE M.G.S. KAMAL
-3HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
ORAL ORDER
1.
Petitioner
being
aggrieved
by
the
orders
dated
06.10.2009, passed by the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal
as per Annexure-P and the order dated 22.08.2000
passed by the respondent No.3-District Registrar as per
Annexure-K. In terms of which, petitioner is called upon
to
pay
stamp
duty
and
penalty
in
a
sum
of
Rs.3,47,30,000/- and corresponding registration fee of
Rs.69,46,000/- aggregating in a sum of Rs.4,16,76,000/is before this Court seeking following reliefs:
" a) Issue a writ of Declaration or any other writ, order or
direction Declaring that Article 30(d) of the Schedule to the
Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 as unconstitutional, irrational
and consequently not applicable to the Lease Deeds
executed between the petitioner and the Respondents No.4
& 5 for setting up mini hydel projects vide Annexure - 'B' &
'B1';
b) Issue a writ or order or direction in the nature of certiorari
and quash the order dated 06.10.2009 passed in Appeal
No's.508/2008, 520 to 528/2000 made by the Hon'ble
Karnataka Appellate Tribunal at Bangalore vide Annexure 'P';
c) Issue a writ or order or direction in the nature of certiorari
and quash the order dated 22.08.2000 in File No.DRG:46A7/99-2000/3580 issued under Section 46A of the Karnataka
Stamp Act, 1957 and 80A of the Indian Registration Act,
1908 made by the respondent No.3 vide Annexure - 'K';
d) Further be pleased to grant any other relief or reliefs that
this Hon'ble Court deems fit under the circumstances and
facts of the case in the interest of justice and equity."
-4HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
2.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that
originally the relief was sought seeking declaration,
declaring Article 30(d) of the Schedule to the Karnataka
Stamp Act, 1957 (for brevity "the Act, 1957") as
unconstitutional,
irrational
and
consequently
not
applicable to the lease deeds (Annexures-B and B1)
executed between the petitioner and respondent Nos.4
and 5 for setting up of mini-hydel project. That the said
provision has been deleted, effect from 01.04.1999.
Therefore, petitioner would not press relief in this regard.
3.
He further submits that however, the effect of the
provision in respect of the lease which are executed
during the currency of the said provision still prevails. It
is in furtherance to that the respondent-Stamp Authority
is insisting the petitioner to pay the stamp duty as
contemplated under the said deleted provision.
Hence,
he submits that the petitioner is entitled to be heard on
the remaining prayers.
4.
Brief facts of the case are;
-5HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
4.1
That the petitioner had entered into an agreement dated
10.05.1993 with the respondent-State which had floated
a scheme for setting up of Mini Hydel Plant. In terms of
the said agreement, petitioner was permitted to set up a
plant at
Shahapur Branch Canal, Gulbarga District. The
agreement
produced
at
Annexure-A
contemplate
petitioner to effect modification or improvement to the
Shahapur Branch Canal, Gulabarga District at its own
cost.
4.2
In furtherance to the said agreement, a lease agreement
dated 28.02.1997 came to be executed for a period of 40
years. One of the clauses in the lease agreement is that
on the expiry of the said lease term the petitioner herein
is required to hand over the project site along with the
improvements effected thereof. The agreement clause 8
(iii) also provides for payment of stamp duty at '4' times
the amount of value of average annual rent reserved
(4000/-). It is in the background of this agreement and
the
clauses
contained,
the
respondent-Authorities
appears to have invoked Article 30(d) of the Schedule to
-6HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
the Act, 1957, as it existed calling upon the petitioner to
pay the stamp duty, registration fee and the penalty
thereon aggregating a sum of Rs.3,47,30,000/-, which
has resulted in petitioner preferring the present petition.
4.3
It appears petitioner had preferred an appeal against the
determination
of
Stamp
Duty
before
the
Appellate
Tribunal, which has resulted in dismissal confirming the
order passed by the respondent-authorities. However,
since the constitutional validity of Article 30(d) of the
Schedule to the Act, 1957 was raised in this petition, this
Court had permitted the petitioner to maintain the
petition. Hence, the petition seeking the above reliefs.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner taking this Court
through the records submitted that the demand raised by
the respondent-Authorities as per notices produced at
Annexures-C and D, is based on speculative facts without
determination of the actual improvements, which have
been effected and completed even as contemplated under
the said deleted provision. He submits that there is no
basis for respondent-Authorities to demand astronomical
-7HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
payment of stamp duty in a sum of Rs.3,47,30,000/-,
with registration fee and penalty thereon. He submits that
the agreements of this nature will have to be considered
taking into overall project intricacies which requires
periodical upgradation, depreciation and it is not a onetime affair. Therefore, he submits that if the respondentauthorities are directed to consider the representation
made by the petitioner, the purpose of the petition would
be served.
6.
Learned HCGP, on the other hand submits that if a
representation is made afresh by the petitioner the same
will be considered taking into the factual aspects as exist
at the project site.
7.
Heard and perused the records.
8.
Article 30(d) of the Schedule to the Act, 1957, before its
deletion read as under:
-8HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
"(d)
9.
Where the lessee undertakes to effect
improvements in the leased property and
agreed to make over the same to the
lessor at the time of termination of lease
The same duty as
conveyance (No.20) for
value
of
the
improvement
contemplated
to
be
made by the lessee as
set forth in the deed in
addition to the duty
chargeable under subclause (a) or (b) or (c),
as the case may be.''
Perusal of the language employed in the aforesaid article
indicate that if in the event lessee undertakes to effect
improvement in the leased property, and further agreed
to make over the same to the lessor at the time of
termination of lease, stamp duty equal to the stamp duty
payable on conveyance under Article 20, valued on the
improvement contemplated to be made by the lessee as
set-forth in the deed in addition to the duty chargeable be
paid.
10.
The improvement to be effected on the demised property
is a variable factor. Unless the agreement specifically
provides the stipulation with regard to time, distance and
the form of improvement to be affected, it is always
subject to the determination of the improvement made at
-9HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
the time when the provisions of Article 30(d) of the
Schedule to the Act, 1957 are invoked.
11.
No doubt, the agreement at Annexure-A and the lease
agreement at Annexures-B and C indicate petitioner as a
lessee having agreed to effect modification, improvement
and has further agreed to hand over the same to the
State Government after expiry of 40 years, it is however
not
clear
as
to
the
extent
of
modification
and
improvement and the cost of such improvement to be
made.
It could be depending on various factors, which
the respondent-Authorities, as rightly pointed by learned
counsel for the petitioner, seem to have lost sight of.
Payment of stamp duty is a factor requiring determination
of the fact existing on the date of incidence of imposition
of stamp duty. The Appellate Authority has also not
adverted to this aspect of the matter.
12.
Needless to state, utilization of immovable property would
also include factor of depreciation, which is recognized
even while determining the payment of stamp duty.
Admittedly, the lease agreements seem to have been
- 10 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
entered
into
notifications
during
have
the
year
1997,
been
issued
on
the
impugned
01.04.1998.
The
impugned notices though have called upon the petitioner
to pay the deficit stamp duty, do not indicate the basis on
which the said stamp duty is sought to be paid. The
common
order
dated
22.08.2000,
passed
by
the
respondent No.3-District Registrar under Section 46A of
the Act, 1957 as per Annexure-K, indicate that during the
course of the audit, the lease agreement subject matter
of the petition were verified and found that the value of
the improvement contemplated by the lessee over the
project was about Rs.34.73 Crores.
13.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that to arrive
at the project cost at Rs.34.73 Crores in the purported
audit conducted by the respondent-Authority, petitioner
was not given any opportunity and the said determination
is unilateral. Consequently, imposition of deficit stamp
duty, is unsustainable.
14.
The Appellate Tribunal in its order dated 10.06.2009 in
Appeal
No.508/2000,
520/2000
and
528/2000,
has
- 11 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
proceeded
to
confirm
the
order
passed
by
the
respondent-authorities, apparently on the premise of
petitioner
allegedly
not
furnishing
the
details
of
expenditure/cost of improvement made by it.
15.
From reading of the order passed by the Appellate
Tribunal, it is clear that both the respondent No.3- District
Registrar
as
well
as
the
Appellate
Tribunal
have
proceeded to call upon the petitioner to pay the deficit
stamp duty on the basis of the contents of the lease
agreement without actually adverting to the factum of
improvement, cost and expenditure actually incurred by
the petitioner and the nature of improvement to be
carried out. Imposition of stamp duty and duty penalty
has financial consequences and the same cannot be done
without specific ascertainment and determination of the
liability.
16.
This Court, in the light of the submissions made by the
learned counsel for the petitioner and learned HCGP and
also for the reasons recorded above is of the considered
view that the petitioner be reserved a liberty to make a
- 12 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
fresh representation to the respondent No.3-District
Registrar,
who
shall
consider
the
matter
afresh.
Accordingly, following:
ORDER
(i) Petition is partly allowed.
(ii) Impugned order dated 22.08.2000 passed by the
respondent No.3-District Registrar as per Annexure-K and
the order dated 06.10.2009 passed by the Karnataka
Appellate
Tribunal
as per
Annexure-P are
hereby
quashed.
(iii) Matter is remitted to the respondent No.3District Registrar.
(iv) Petitioner shall make a fresh representation
within 30 days from the date of receipt of certified
copy of this order.
(v) Petitioner shall furnish details of the expenditure
or costs incurred with the specific details of the
improvement/modification carried out along with the
representation.
(vi) The respondent No.3-District Registrar shall
assess the cost/expenses incurred and the extent of
- 13 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:44220
WP No. 37394 of 2009
CNR: KAHC010803862009
improvement, if any made and if required, the
respondent No.3-District Registrar shall visit the spot
to ascertain the factum of improvement carried out
and thereafter pass appropriate order with an outer
limit of six months thereafter.
(vii) Needless to state, since the respondent No.4Karntaka Power Corporation Ltd., stated to have
made a requisition to the State Government to
exempt payment of stamp duty in the light of the
transaction
being
Government
made
agencies,
in
the
between
the
two
respondent-Stamp
Authorities are at liberty to consider the same in
accordance with law, if so permissible.
Sd/
(M.G.S. KAMAL)
JUDGE
RL/- List No.: 1 Sl No.: 16
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review