Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 12TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.M. POONACHA
COMMERCIAL APPEAL NO. 618 OF 2025
BETWEEN:
1.
M/S BHAGYALAKSHMI HOMES LLP
REGISTERED OFFICE AT:
GOLDEN HOUSE 80 FEET ROAD
#581/A, "KML ARCADE", 1ST FLOOR
8TH BLOCK, KORAMANGALA
BENGALURU - 560 095
REPRESENTED BY G.S. RUDRESH
AUTHORISED SIGNATORY
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI VENKATESH R BHAGAT, ADVOCATE)
Digitally signed
by PRABHAKAR
SWETHA
KRISHNAN
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
AND:
1.
SMT. SULEKHA VERMA
W/O AKASH MATHUR
MAJOR
2.
SRI AKASH MATHUR
S/O LALITH MOHAN LAL MATHUR
MAJOR
BOTH EARLIER RESIDING AT J-1102
PURVA VENEZIA APARTMENTS
NEAR MOTHER DAIRY
YELAHANKA NEW TOWN
BANGALORE - 560 064.
-2NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
PRESENTLY AT B1-101
SSN RAJ ETTERNIA
SILVER COUNTY ROAD, HARALUR
BENGALURU - 560 068
3.
M/S. GOLDEN GATE PROPERTIES LTD.,
(A PUBLIC LIMITED COMPANY
INCORPORATED UNDER
THE PROVISIONS OF
THE COMPANIES ACT, 1956)
HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT:
NO.820, 80 FEET ROAD
8TH BLOCK, KORAMANGALA
BENGALURU - 560 095
REPRESENTED BY
RATISH KUMAR MOORTHY
AUTHORISED SIGNATORY
4.
SRI RATHISH KUMAR MOORTHY
C/O. SRI GOLDEN HOUSE
80 FEET ROAD, No. 581/A,
"KML ARCADE" 1ST FLOOR
8TH BLOCK, KORAMANGALA
BENGALURU - 560 095.
5.
SRI HARSHA
GOLDEN HOUSE 80 FEET ROAD
#581/A, "KML ARCADE"
1ST FLOOR, 8TH BLOCK
KORAMANGALA
BENGALURU - 560 095
6.
SRI GIRIRAJU
GOLDEN HOUSE 80 FEET ROAD
No.581/A, "KML ARCADE"
1ST FLOOR, 8TH BLOCK
-3NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
KORAMANGALA
BENGALURU - 560 095
7.
360 REALTORS LLP
No.1184, 1ST FLOOR,
5TH MAIN ROAD
SECTOR 7, HSR LAYOUT
BENGALURU, KARNATAKA - 560 102
BY ITS AUTHORISED
REPRESENTATIVE
SAURABH SINGH
ALSO AT JK GOLF VIEW
1ST FLOOR, NO.267
KORAMANGALA,
INNER RING ROAD
AMAR JYOTHI LAYOUT, DOMLUR
NEAR EGL BUSINESS PARK
BENGALURU - 560 071
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. AKSHATHA P, ADVOCATE FOR R-1 & 2)
THIS COMMERCIAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION
13(1)(A) OF COMMERCIAL COURT ACT, 2015 PRAYING TO SET
ASIDE THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 06.09.2025 PASSED IN
COM.O.S NO.685/2024 BY THE LXXXIX ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND
SESSIONS JUDGE, AT BENGALURU CITY (CCH-90) ON I.A.NO.4 AND
TO ALLOW I.A.NO.4 FILED UNDER SEC.8 OF THE ARBITRATION AND
CONCILIATION ACT, 1996, TO RELEGATE THE PARTIES TO
ARBITRATION IN TUNE WITH THE ARBITRATION CLAUSE & ETC.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
-4NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C.M. POONACHA
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. VIBHU BAKHRU, CHIEF JUSTICE)
1.
The appellant has filed the present appeal under Section
37(1)(a) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 [A&C Act],
impugning an order dated 06.09.2025 passed by the learned
LXXXIX Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru
[Commercial
Court],
dismissing
I.A.No.4
in
Com.
O.S.No.685/2024.
2.
The appellant had filed the said application under Section 8 of
the A&C Act, inter alia, praying that the parties be referred to
arbitration.
3.
The appellant's application was rejected, inter alia, on the
ground that it had not filed its written statement within the prescribed
time and that its right to file the same had closed. The learned
Commercial Court also found that some of the parties to the suit
were not signatories to the arbitration agreement relied on by the
appellant.
-5NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
4.
Respondent Nos.1 and 2 [the plaintiffs] had filed the
aforementioned suit, inter alia, seeking a decree for a sum of
`53,93,279/- (Rupees fifty three lakhs ninety three thousand two
hundred and seventy nine only). The appellant was arrayed as
defendant No.1 in the suit. Additionally, five other parties were
arrayed as defendant Nos.2 to 6. Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 shall be
referred to as the plaintiffs, and the parties arrayed as the
defendants shall be referred to as such.
5.
The plaintiffs claim that defendants Nos. 1 to 5 were Real
Estate Builders and Developers, introduced to the plaintiffs by
defendant No. 6. They claim they were induced to invest in the
project named 'Golden Ira, ' being developed by defendant No. 1
(appellant).
6.
The plaintiffs claim that they have invested a total sum of
`49,50,000/- in the said project, which was being developed at
Raghunathapura Village, Kasaba Hobli, Doddaballapura Taluk,
Bengaluru Rural District. They claim that the defendants assured
them that the amount they invested would be doubled by the end of
three years. The plaintiffs claim that they entered into three separate
agreements with respect to respective residential plots in the
-6NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
project, being an agreement dated 19.08.2016 in respect of Plot
No.511; an agreement dated 19.11.2016 in respect of Plot No.490;
and an agreement dated 16.08.2017 in respect of Plot No.385. The
plaintiffs state that they issued a legal notice dated 12.06.2023, and
thereafter, negotiations were held between the parties, but the
dispute could not be resolved.
7.
The
suit
Com.O.S.No.685/2024
was
registered
on
27.04.2024, and the summons was directed to be issued to the
defendants on 27.04.2024, returnable on 14.06.2024. The order
sheet indicates that the summons to defendant No.2 (M/s.Golden
Gate Properties Limited) was served. However, the summons to
defendant No.1 and two other defendants remained unserved.
Accordingly, on 14.06.2024, the learned Commercial Court directed
the issuance of fresh summons to the said defendants, and the suit
was listed for hearing on 20.07.2024. Since the plaintiffs had not
taken the necessary steps, the learned Commercial Court passed
an order dated 20.07.2024 directing the re-issue of the suit
summons to unserved defendants (defendant Nos. 1, 3 to 6) by
Registered Post Acknowledgement Due (RPAD) returnable on
24.08.2024.
-7NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
8.
The said summons was served, and defendant No.1 was
represented by his advocate on 24.08.2024. The learned counsel
appearing for defendant No.1 submitted that he had not received
the plaint documents. Accordingly, the learned Commercial Court
directed that the documents be furnished to defendant No. 1 and relisted the suit on 30.08.2024. The suit could not be taken up on the
said date as the learned Judge was on training and accordingly, the
suit was directed to be listed on 13.09.2024. On 13.09.2024, the
learned Commercial Court considered the plaintiffs' application and
directed the plaintiffs to furnish a draft, process fee and to mention
the name of the newspaper for substituted service to defendant
Nos.3 to 6, and the suit was thereafter listed on 23.10.2024.
9.
On 23.10.2024, the plaintiffs did not appear before the
learned Commercial Court, and there was no representation on their
behalf; the suit was adjourned to 13.11.2024. On 13.11.2024, the
Court noted that the learned counsel for the plaintiffs had not
furnished the proper process fee and accordingly directed the
plaintiffs to take the necessary steps. The matter was thereafter
listed on 19.11.2024, and the Court directed the issuance of
-8NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
summons to defendant Nos. 3 to 6 through publication in
newspapers and adjourned the proceedings to 18.12.2024.
10.
On 18.12.2024, the learned counsel appearing for defendant
No.1 sought time to file a written statement, and the Court directed
that the matter be called later in the day. The matter was taken up
later in the day at 03.00 p.m. However, defendant No.1 remained
unrepresented. Defendant No.1 neither filed the written statement
nor filed an application seeking additional time to do so. The learned
Commercial Court noted the same and proceeded on the basis that
the written statement "is taken as not filed", and the suit was listed
for plaintiffs' evidence on 17.01.2025.
11.
On 17.01.2025, the learned counsel for the plaintiffs, as well
as defendant No.1, were present. The learned counsel for the
plaintiffs furnished their respective affidavits of the plaintiffs [PW1
and PW2] in lieu of examination in chief. Some of the documents
produced by them were exhibited, and the matter was adjourned to
21.01.2025 for the recording of further evidence of the plaintiffs who
were examined as PW1 and PW2.
-9NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
12.
The plaintiffs (PW1 and PW2) were further examined on
21.01.2025. However, none was present on behalf of defendant
No.1, and the matter was adjourned to 20.02.2025 for crossexamination of PW1 and PW2.
13.
It is clear from the order sheet that defendant No.2 was
proceeded ex parte, and the right of defendant No.1 to file the
written statement was closed.
14.
On 20.02.2025, defendant No.2 filed I.A.No.2 under Order IX
Rule 7 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 [CPC], seeking to set
aside the order whereby defendant No.2 had been proceeded ex
parte. Defendant No.1 also filed two applications: I.A.No.3 under
Section 151 of the CPC to recall the order dated 18.12.2024,
whereby its right to file a written statement was closed, and I.A.No.4
under Section 8 of the A&C Act, praying that the parties be referred
to Arbitration.
15.
Defendant No.1 claims that it was not served with the
summons as it had not received the documents till 17.01.2025 and
therefore, its right to file an application under Section 8 of the A&C
Act could not be closed. It is not disputed that defendant No.1 had
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
received the summons and had also appeared through counsel
before the Commercial Court on 24.08.2024.
On that date, the
learned counsel had made a grievance that he had not received the
documents. However, the suit was listed again on 30.08.2024.
Thereafter, the learned counsel had appeared before the learned
Commercial Court on 13.09.2024, 23.10.2024, 13.11.2024 and
19.11.2024, but did not raise any grievance regarding non-receipt of
the documents. Defendant No.1 was also represented through his
counsel on 18.12.2024. When the suit was called, he had sought
time to file a written statement. Even at that stage earlier that day,
he had not raised any objection that he had not received any
documents. The suit was again taken up later in the day at 03.00
p.m., but defendant No.1 was not represented, and his right to file
the written statement was closed.
16.
It is relevant to extract Sub-section (1) of Section 8 of the A&C
Act, which reads as follows:
"8. Power to refer parties to arbitration where there is
an arbitration agreement.—(1) A judicial authority,
before which an action is brought in a matter which is the
subject of an arbitration agreement shall, if a party to the
arbitration agreement or any person claiming through or
under him, so applies not later than the date of submitting
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
his first statement on the substance of the dispute, then,
notwithstanding any judgment, decree or order of the
Supreme Court or any Court, refer the parties to
arbitration unless it finds that prima facie no valid
arbitration agreement exists."
17.
It is clear from the plain language of Sub-section (1) of
Section 8 of the A&C Act that an application under Section 8 can be
made not later than the date of submitting his first statement on the
substance of the dispute. In the present case, the right to furnish the
written statement was closed on 18.12.2024. Therefore, the right of
defendant No.1 to file an application under Section 8 stood
extinguished as well.
18.
In SPML Infra Ltd. V. Trisquare Switchgears (P) Ltd.:2022
SCC online DEL 1914, the Division Bench of the Delhi High Court
(of which one of us was a member) had considered the question as
to the right of a party to file an application under Section 8 of the
A&C Act after the time for filing the written statement had expired.
The Court had held as under:
17. Although Section 8 of the A&C Act (as in force prior to
23.10.2015) did not prescribe any time period within which a
party must apply under Section 8 of the A&C Act as explained
in Booz Allen and Hamilton Inc. v. SBI Home Finance Ltd.,
the scheme of the A&C Act and the provisions of Section 8 of
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
the A&C Act clearly indicate that the application under that
section “should be made at the earliest”.
18. It is clear from the scheme of the that once the
proceedings before the court or judicial authority progress
beyond the initial stage, it would no longer be permissible for
a party to then turn around and seek recourse to arbitration. A
mere delay in making an application under Section 8 of the
A&C Act may not be fatal to a party’s right; but once the
proceedings have progressed beyond the stage of completion
of pleadings, such an application would not lie. This is
because at that stage, the parties are sufficiently invested in
the said proceedings, and it would not be permissible for any
party to turn around and apply under Section 8 of the A&C
Act.
19. If a party’s right to file a statement of defence is
closed, the same would also result in its rights accruing in
favour of the other party. Clearly, at this stage, it would not be
permissible for a party to apply under Section 8 of the A&C
Act even though he has not expressly evinced any intention to
contest the proceedings. It is implicit in the expression “not
later than submitting the first statement of substance of the
dispute” that the application under Section 8 of the A&C Act
can be made at the stage when it is open for a party to submit
such a statement. It, obviously, follows that once such a stage
is crossed, the right of the party to apply under Section 8(1) of
the A&C Act would also stand closed. The scheme of Section
8 of the A&C Act does not contemplate unraveling concluded
proceedings. Once the right of a party to file the written
statement of defence is closed, the proceedings in a suit
progress beyond the stage of completion of pleadings. It is
not open for the defendant to now seek a reference to
arbitration. Although Section 8 of the A&C Act (as in force
prior to 23.10.2015) did not specify any time limit, it did
indicate the stage of the proceedings at which a party could
apply, that is, before filing of the first statement on the
substance of the dispute. This clearly implies a stage at which
such a statement could be filed and not thereafter.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
20. If the contention advanced by the appellant is
accepted, it would imply an application under Section 8 of the
A&C Act can be allowed to be filed at any stage of the
proceedings; even after the evidence is tendered and
witnesses have been cross-examined or for that matter just
before the matter is fixed for pronouncement of the decision.
Clearly, this is not in conformity with the scheme of Section 8
of the A&C Act.
21. The Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act,
2015 [Act 3 of 2016] amended the A&C Act significantly. By
virtue of the said Act, Sub-section (1) of Section 8 of the A&C
Act was substituted and a proviso was introduced to Subsection (2) of Section 8 with retrospective effect from
23.10.2015. Section 8 of the A&C Act, as in force with effect
from 23.10.2015, reads as under:
“8. Power to refer parties to arbitration where there is
an arbitration agreement-(1) A judicial authority,
before which an action is brought in a matter which is
the subject of an arbitration agreement shall, if a
party to the arbitration agreement or any person
claiming through or under him, so applies not later
than the date of submitting his first statement on the
substance of the dispute, then notwithstanding any
judgment, decree or order of the Supreme Court or
any Court, refer the parties to arbitration unless it
finds that prima facie no valid arbitration agreement
exists.
(2) The application referred to in sub section (1) shall
not be entertained unless it is accompanied by the
original arbitration agreement or a duly certified copy
thereof:
Provided that where the original arbitration
agreement or a certified copy thereof is not available
with the party applying for reference to arbitration
under sub-section (1), and the said agreement or
certified copy is retained by the other party to that
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
agreement, then, the party so applying shall file such
application along with a copy of the arbitration
agreement and a petition praying the Court to call
upon the other party to produce the original
arbitration agreement or its duly certified copy before
that Court.”
22. The change in the language of Section 8(1) of the
A&C Act is material. Whereas prior to the 2015 Amendment,
Sub-section (1) of Section 8 of the A&C Act used the
expression “not later than when submitting his first statement
on the substance of the dispute”. Sub-section (1) of Section 8,
as substituted, uses the expression “not later than the date of
submitting his first statement on the substance of the dispute”.
The legislative intent to introduce the words “not later than the
date of” clearly stipulates a framework of time within which an
application under Section 8(1) of the A&C Act can be made.
23. This amendment to Section 8 of the A&C Act,
cannot be considered in isolation. It is material to note that the
Parliament had also enacted the Commercial Courts Act,
2015 (Act 4 of 2016), which came into force on the same date
as the Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015,
that is, with effect from 23.10.2015. By virtue of Section 16 of
the said Act, certain provisions of the CPC were amended in
their application to any suit in respect of a commercial dispute
of the specified value. The said provisions, inter alia, also
included amendment to Order 8 Rule 1 and Order 8 Rule 10
of the CPC. The proviso to Order 8 Rule 1 of the CPC was
substituted, which expressly provided that if the defendant
failed to file a written statement within the prescribed period of
thirty days, the court could, for reasons to be recorded in
writing, extend further time to file the written statement.
However, such extended time could not be later than 120
days from the date of service of summons. Further, the
proviso to Order 8 Rule 10 of the CPC was introduced, which
expressly provided that no court would make an order to
extend the time provided under Order 8 Rule 1 of the CPC for
filing of the written statement. Thus, the Parliament has
curtailed the outer time limit of filing of a written statement in a
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
commercial suit to 120 days after receipt of summons. The
said amendment is obviously to ensure expeditious
adjudication of commercial disputes.
24. Arbitration is an alternate dispute resolution mechanism to
provide for an expeditious adjudication of disputes. By virtue
of the Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act, 2015,
certain other provisions were also introduced in the A&C Act
to provide for time limits for making the arbitral award. Section
29-A of the A&C Act was introduced, which specifically
provide that an arbitral award would be made within a period
of twelve months from the date the arbitral tribunal enters
upon reference. One of the objects of the A&C Act is to
provide for an expeditious resolution of disputes in a time
bound manner. In BSNL v. Nortel Networks India Private
Limited the Supreme Court had observed that the A&C Act
“has been amended twice over in 2015 and 2019, to provide
for further time limits to ensure that the arbitration
proceedings are conducted and concluded expeditiously”.
25. As stated above, a written statement would also fall within
the sweep of expression “statement on the substance of the
dispute” as used in Section 8(1) of the A&C Act. The
introduction of the expression “the date of” in the context of
the suit would necessarily have to be co-related with the time
available or granted for filing of a written statement. The
legislative intent of introducing the expression “the date of”,
when read with the contemporaneous amendments to Order
8 Rule 1 of the CPC by virtue of the Commercial Courts Act,
2015, is quite clear; it is to introduce the precise time frame
within which an application under Section 8(1) of the A&C Act
could be filed.
26. Resultantly, if a party fails to file an application under
Section 8(1) of the A&C Act for referring the parties to
arbitration within the time available or granted for filing the
first statement on the substance of the dispute (which would
include a written statement in the context of a suit), the party
would forfeit its right to apply under Section 8(1) of the A&C
Act.
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
27. This Court is unable to accept that there is any infirmity in
the decision of the learned Commercial Court. This Court is
unable to concur with the decision of the Single Judge of this
Court in Hughes Communications India Ltd. and Ors. v. Union
of India that Section 8 of the A&C Act cannot be read to mean
that an application under Section 8(1) of the A&C Act would
not lie after the right to file the written statement has been
closed. We, accordingly, over-rule the said decision.
19.
In the present case, since the right of defendant No.1 to file its
written statement stood closed, it was not entitled to file an
application under Section 8 of the A&C Act.
20.
The learned counsel for the appellant earnestly contended
that the time period to file a written statement had not expired. He
submitted that the limitation for filing the written statement would
commence upon receipt of the complete documents along with the
plaint. The learned counsel also refers to the decision of the
Supreme Court in Nahar Enterprises v. Hyderabad Allwyn
Limited and another:2007(9) SCC 466, in support of his
contention.
21.
The decision in the case of Nahar Enterprises (supra) is of
little assistance to the appellant. In that case, the appellant claimed
that the summons were served on 14.10.1988, but were not
accompanied by a copy of the plaint. He had immediately sent a
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
telegram on 17.10.1988 and also a letter to the Court, but had not
received any response. It is material to note that the Court, without
issuing any further summons, fixed a date for the defendant's
appearance and proceeded to adjourn the matter. On the date of
the hearing fixed, the defendant was absent, and another date was
fixed for an ex parte hearing and on that date, the suit was decreed.
22.
In the aforesaid context, the Supreme Court faulted the trial
Court for not appreciating how the defendant could file his written
statement in the absence of a copy of the plaint and other
documents. Additionally, the Supreme Court held that the trial court
erred by failing to consider that the summons was served on the
defendant after the date fixed for his appearance, and therefore it
was obligatory to fix another date for his appearance.
23.
There is no cavil that, under Order V, Rule 2 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 [CPC], every summons must be accompanied
by a copy of the plaint. In the present case, there is no dispute that
defendant No.1 was served with the summons. It is not the
appellant's case that the summons was not accompanied by the
plaint. It, however, states that it had not received the documents
required to accompany the plaint. However, we note that, apart from
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
raising the issue on 24.08.2024, defendant No.1 had not raised any
such objection thereafter and had participated in the proceedings.
During the course of proceedings on 18.12.2024, defendant No.1's
counsel sought time to file the written statement, and the matter was
held over. However, he neither filed any application seeking an
extension of time nor appeared when the matter was called up
again. The suit was thereafter listed on 17.01.2025. On this
occasion as well, defendant No.1 was represented. However, the
counsel had not sought any time to file the written statement, the
right to which had already closed.
24.
The plaintiffs examined themselves as PW1 and PW2, and
tendered their affidavits in lieu of their examination-in-chief, which
was accepted. The proceedings were adjourned to 21.01.2025 for
further
proceedings.
The
learned
counsel
relies
on
an
acknowledgement recorded on the order sheet indicating that
counsel had received the documents. However, it is apparent that
the documents supplied were those marked as exhibits.
25.
As noted earlier, the matter had been listed before the
Commercial Court on four (4) prior occasions after 24.08.2024, the
date on which defendant No.1 stated that he had not received the
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
documents, and no grievance on the ground of non-receipt of the
documents had been raised. The counsel for defendant No.1 had
participated
in
the
proceedings
unreservedly,
including
on
17.01.2025. On this date as well, no objections had been raised on
behalf of defendant No.1. Thus, counsel for defendant No.1 had
participated in the proceedings on 17.01.2025, when PW1 and PW2
had been examined.
26.
PW1 and PW2 were further examined on 21.01.2025. None
was present on behalf of defendant No.1 on 21.01.2025. However,
no objections have been raised on his behalf earlier. The matter
was thereafter adjourned for cross-examination of PW1 and PW2 to
20.02.2025.
At that stage, defendant Nos.1 and 2 had filed the
application.
27.
It is also material to note that defendant Nos.1 and 2 are
represented by the same counsel. The record indicates that the
summons was served on defendant No.2, which is at the same
address as that of defendant No.1. Defendant No.2 had been
proceeded ex parte on 14.06.2024.
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
28.
It is also relevant to note that defendant No.1 (appellant) had
filed the application under Section 8 of the A&C Act on 20.02.2025,
which was granted thirty days after defendant No.1 claims to have
received the documents. Thus, the said application was clearly
beyond the period prescribed for filing the written statement.
SSCG
Contracts
(India)
(P)
Ltd.
v.
K.S.
In
Chamankar
Infrastructure (P) Ltd., (2019) 12 SCC 210, the Supreme Court
had observed as under:
“The Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and
Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015 came
into force on 23-10-2015 bringing in their wake certain
amendments to the Code of Civil Procedure. In Order 5 Rule
1, sub-rule (1), for the second proviso, the following proviso
was substituted:
“Provided further that where the defendant fails to file the
written statement within the said period of thirty days, he shall
be allowed to file the written statement on such other day, as
may be specified by the court, for reasons to be recorded in
writing and on payment of such costs as the court deems fit,
but which shall not be later than one hundred twenty days
from the date of service of summons and on expiry of one
hundred and twenty days from the date of service of
summons, the defendant shall forfeit the right to file the
written statement and the court shall not allow the written
statement to be taken on record.”
Equally, in Order 8 Rule 1, a new proviso was substituted as
follows:
“Provided that where the defendant fails to file the written
statement within the said period of thirty days, he shall be
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
allowed to file the written statement on such other day, as
may be specified by the court, for reasons to be recorded in
writing and on payment of such costs as the court deems fit,
but which shall not be later than one hundred and twenty days
from the date of service of summons and on expiry of one
hundred and twenty days from the date of service of
summons, the defendant shall forfeit the right to file the
written statement and the court shall not allow the written
statement to be taken on record.”
This was re-emphasised by re-inserting yet another proviso in
Order 8 Rule 10 CPC, which reads as under:
“10. Procedure when party fails to present written statement
called for by court.—Where any party from whom a written
statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9 fails to present
the same within the time permitted or fixed by the court, as
the case may be, the court shall pronounce judgment against
him, or make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit
and on the pronouncement of such judgment a decree shall
be drawn up:
Provided further that no court shall make an order to extend
the time provided under Rule 1 of this Order for filing of the
written statement.”
A perusal of these provisions would show that ordinarily a
written statement is to be filed within a period of 30 days.
However, grace period of a further 90 days is granted which
the Court may employ for reasons to be recorded in writing
and payment of such costs as it deems fit to allow such
written statement to come on record. What is of great
importance is the fact that beyond 120 days from the date of
service of summons, the defendant shall forfeit the right to file
the written statement and the Court shall not allow the written
statement to be taken on record. This is further buttressed by
the proviso in Order 8 Rule 10 also adding that the court has
no further power to extend the time beyond this period of 120
days.”
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
29.
As explained by the court, the written statement was required
to be filed within a period of thirty days. However, the court may
grant an additional ninety days, subject to recording reasons in
writing and payment of costs as it deems fit. In the present case,
more than 120 days had elapsed after the summons was served.
Even according to the appellant, the application was beyond the
period of thirty days prescribed for filing the appeal.
30.
The learned counsel appearing for defendant No.1 had
sought documents on 24.01.2024. The learned Commercial Court
had directed that the same be furnished to him and relisted the suit
on 30.08.2024.
No grievance was made by defendant No.1
thereafter.
31.
The application under Section 8 was filed nearly seven
months thereafter.
32.
Thus the application under Section 8 of the A&C Act was filed
much after the time for filing the same had expired.
33.
We are unable to accept the given facts and circumstances
that the summons was not served on defendant No.1. We find no
fault with the decision of the learned Commercial Court.
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC:2021-DB
COMAP No. 618 of 2025
HC-KAR
34.
In our view, it is not open to the defendant No.1 to raise any
objections regarding non-receipt of documents, having participated
in the proceedings without raising any objections on several
occasions. It is not disputed that the plaintiffs had served a legal
notice prior to filing the suit, and the defendants were also invited to
pre-institutional negotiations. In the given facts, the contention that
defendant No.1 had not received the documents cannot be
accepted and must be rejected.
35.
In view of the above, the appeal is dismissed.
Sd/(VIBHU BAKHRU)
CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/(C.M. POONACHA)
JUDGE
KPS/KMV
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 8
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review