Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THEHIGH COURTOF DELHIAT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 07.08.2026
%
#
CNR No. DLHC011476822018
+
W.P.(C) 8877/2018
M/S BALVANTRAY MEHTA VIDYA BHAWAN ANGURIDEVI
SHERSINGH MEMORIAL ACADEMY
Through:
.....Petitioner
Dr.Meenakshi Kalra, Ms.Sakshi
Gupta, Ms.Anjali C., Mr.Kamal,
Mr.Mayank, Ms. Vrinda, and Mr.S.N.
Kalra, Advocates
versus
SMT. LEELAWATI
Through:
.....Respondent
None
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
The
present
writ
petition
has
been
preferred
by
the
petitioner/management challenging the award dated 05.05.2018 passed by the
learned Presiding Officer, Labour Court-V, Dwarka Courts in New ID No.
4718/16, whereby monetary compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- was awarded to
the respondent/workwoman while denying her claim for reinstatement.
2.
The dispute was referred to the Labour Court in terms of the following
reference:
“Whether Smt. Leelawati W/o Sh. Gopal Chand absented from her duties
unauthrorisedly (sic) or her services have been terminated illegally and/or
unjustifiably by the management and if so, to what sum of money as
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
12:26:59
W.P.(C) 8877/2018
monetary relief along with other consequential benefits in terms of existing
laws/Govt. Notifications and to what other relief is she entitled and what
directions are necessary in this respect?”
3.
Briefly stated, the workwoman claimed before the Labour Court that
she was working on a permanent post of „Aaya‟ with the management school
w.e.f. January 2010, and her last drawn wages were Rs.6,000/- per month.
She alleged that on 01.07.2010, the management issued an offer of
appointment stating that she would be appointed on a purely contractual basis,
and thereafter issued similar contractual offers from time to time without
serving notice under Section 9A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947
(hereinafter the “ID Act”) to alter her status from a permanent employee. She
asserted that this device of contractual employment was a sham mechanism
used to deny her regular service benefits. The workwoman further asserted
that upon demanding full wages of Rs.6,000/- for April and May 2011, as
against the sum of Rs.3,000/- actually paid to her, her services were illegally
terminated on 13.05.2011 in violation of Sections 25F, 25G, and 25H of the
ID Act, despite having rendered continuous service for over 240 days as
contemplated under Section 25B of the ID Act.
4.
The management contested the claim by stating that the workwoman
was appointed purely on a contractual basis against a temporary post. It was
submitted that after her initial engagement as a trainee from 13.01.2010 to
31.03.2010, she was re-engaged contractually from 01.07.2010 to
31.03.2011. Upon notice, she re-applied on 15.02.2011, leading to an
extension from 01.04.2011 to 13.05.2011. The management maintained that
her contractual engagement naturally expired on 13.05.2011 and that she
never re-applied thereafter. It was further submitted that during the final
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
12:26:59
W.P.(C) 8877/2018
tenure, the workwoman had remained on unauthorized leave for 10 days in
April 2011 and 6 days in May 2011.
5.
In the aforesaid backdrop, the following issues were framed by the
Labour Court:
“1. Whether the workman was appointed on contractual basis against a
temporary post of Aaya? OPM
2. If issue no.1 is decided in favour of the workman, whether his services
were illegally and/or unjustifiably terminated by the management?
OPW
3. Relief.”
6.
The Labour Court decided issue no. 1 against the management, holding
that the workwoman had completed 288 days of continuous service under
Section 25B of the ID Act and thus fell within the definition of a “workman”
under Section 2(s) of the ID Act. Qua issue no. 2, the Labour Court held that
the workwoman‟s termination without complying with Section 25F of the ID
Act was illegal. As for relief under issue no. 3, while denying reinstatement,
the Labour Court awarded monetary compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- to the
workwoman. Aggrieved by the award, the management has preferred the
present writ petition.
7.
A
perusal
of
the
proceedings
reveals
that
while
the
respondent/workwoman was initially represented through counsel upon
service of notice, none has appeared on her behalf for the past several years.
In view of her continued non-appearance, vide order dated 06.03.2023, this
Court had directed that Court notice be issued to the learned counsel for the
respondent. The Office Noting reflects that since no address for the learned
counsel was available on record, the Court Notice was issued directly to the
workwoman at her recorded address. The same was duly served. However,
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
12:26:59
W.P.(C) 8877/2018
despite repeated service, none has appeared on her behalf. Accordingly, this
Court proceeds to consider the matter on merits.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner/management contends that the
Labour Court erred in holding that the workwoman had completed 240 days
of continuous service, ignoring the periodic breaks in her contractual
engagements as well as her unauthorized absences of 10 days in April 2011
and 6 days in May 2011.
9.
I have heard the learned counsel for the petitioner/management and
examined the record.
10.
Before proceeding further, this Court takes note of the limited scope of
writ jurisdiction in exercise of powers conferred under Articles 226/227 of the
Constitution of India. It is well settled that the challenge is not in the nature of
an appeal, but to see if the order has been passed without jurisdiction, is
perverse, or does not follow the principles of natural justice (Ref: Syed
Yakoob Vs. K.S. Radhakrishnan1). The said principle was reiterated by the
Supreme Court in International Airport Authority of India Vs. International
Air Cargo Workers Union2. This Court has also considered the scope of writ
jurisdiction in Ritz Theatre Private Limited Vs. Ramesh Chandra3.
11.
A perusal of the record reveals that while considering issue no. 1, the
Labour Court calculated the period of service rendered by the workwoman
between 01.07.2010 to 13.05.2011 and, even after excluding the period of
alleged unauthorized absence of 16 days (10 days in April 2011 and 6 days in
May 2011), the total days worked in the 12 calendar months preceding her
termination came to 288 days, thereby satisfying the requirement of
1963 SCC OnLine SC 24
(2009) 13 SCC 374
2024 SCC OnLine Del 3633
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
12:26:59
W.P.(C) 8877/2018
continuous service as contemplated under Section 25B of the ID Act. This
Court in Delhi Cantonment Board Vs. CGIT & Ors.4 has held that the ID Act
makes no distinction between a permanent employee and a temporary
employee, whether a probationer, casual, daily wager or ad hoc employee,
and as long as a person is employed to do manual, unskilled, skilled,
technical, operational, clerical or supervisory work for hire or reward, they
would fall within the definition of “workman” under Section 2(s) of the ID
Act and be entitled to its protection, and where such workman has put in 240
days of service, compliance with Section 25F is a condition precedent to
termination, failing which such termination would be illegal.
12.
Furthermore, the Labour Court observed that the management failed to
prove that the post of „Aaya‟ was temporary, as a school requires such
services on a continuous basis. Taking note of the admission that the
management itself called upon the workwoman to re-apply whenever her
contract period was nearing completion, the Labour Court rightly considered
the contract to be a mere device to avoid statutory obligations.
13.
Insofar as issue no. 2 is concerned, once the workwoman was held to be
a “workman” under Section 2(s) of the ID Act who had completed continuous
service of 240 days, her separation from service without adhering to the
statutory requirements of Section 25F of the ID Act inevitably rendered the
termination illegal.
14.
Turning to the relief granted under issue no. 3, the Labour Court
declined reinstatement, and instead awarded monetary compensation of
Rs.1,00,000/-.A gainful reference may be made to Jagbir Singh Vs. Haryana
2006 SCC OnLine Del 97
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
12:26:59
W.P.(C) 8877/2018
State Agriculture Mktg. Board5, wherein the Supreme Court clarified that
reinstatement with back wages is not automatic, and in appropriate cases,
compensation may be granted instead, observing as under:
“7. It is true that the earlier view of this Court articulated in many
decisions reflected the legal position that if the termination of an employee
was found to be illegal, the relief of reinstatement with full back wages
would ordinarily follow. However, in recent past, there has been a shift in
the legal position and in a long line of cases, this Court has consistently
taken the view that relief by way of reinstatement with back wages is not
automatic and may be wholly inappropriate in a given fact situation even
though the termination of an employee is in contravention of the prescribed
procedure. Compensation instead of reinstatement has been held to meet
the ends of justice.”
15.
Similarly, the Supreme Court in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited Vs.
Bhurumal6 observed that in cases where termination is found to be illegal due
to procedural defects, compensation in place of reinstatement may be
appropriate:
“33. It is clear from the reading of the aforesaid judgments that the
ordinary principle of grant of reinstatement with full back wages, when the
termination is found to be illegal is not applied mechanically in all cases.
While that may be a position where services of a regular/permanent
workman are terminated illegally and/or mala fide and/or by way of
victimisation, unfair labour practice, etc. However, when it comes to the
case of termination of a daily-wage worker and where the termination is
found illegal because of a procedural defect, namely, in violation of Section
25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act, this Court is consistent in taking the
view that in such cases reinstatement with back wages is not automatic and
instead the workman should be given monetary compensation which will
meet the ends of justice. Rationale for shifting in this direction is obvious.
34. The reasons for denying the relief of reinstatement in such cases
are obvious. It is trite law that when the termination is found to be illegal
because of non-payment of retrenchment compensation and notice pay as
mandatorily required under Section 25-F of the Industrial Disputes Act,
even after reinstatement, it is always open to the management to terminate
the services of that employee by paying him the retrenchment
compensation. Since such a workman was working on daily-wage basis and
(2009) 15 SCC 327
(2014) 7 SCC 177
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
12:26:59
W.P.(C) 8877/2018
even after he is reinstated, he has no right to seek regularisation [see State
of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3) [(2006) 4 SCC 1: 2006 SCC (L&S) 753] ].
Thus when he cannot claim regularisation and he has no right to continue
even as a daily-wage worker, no useful purpose is going to be served in
reinstating such a workman and he can be given monetary compensation by
the Court itself inasmuch as if he is terminated again after reinstatement, he
would receive monetary compensation only in the form of retrenchment
compensation and notice pay. In such a situation, giving the relief of
reinstatement, that too after a long gap, would not serve any purpose.
35. We would, however, like to add a caveat here. There may be
cases where termination of a daily-wage worker is found to be illegal on the
ground that it was resorted to as unfair labour practice or in violation of the
principle of last come first go viz. while retrenching such a worker daily
wage juniors to him were retained. There may also be a situation that
persons junior to him were regularised under some policy but the workman
concerned terminated. In such circumstances, the terminated worker should
not be denied reinstatement unless there are some other weighty reasons for
adopting the course of grant of compensation instead of reinstatement. In
such cases, reinstatement should be the rule and only in exceptional cases
for the reasons stated to be in writing, such a relief can be denied.”
16.
In the present case, the events relate back to 2010-2011, and a
considerable period of time has elapsed since the termination of the
workwoman‟s services. Taking into account the length of service rendered
and the nature of duties, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
quantum of compensation determined by the Labour Court is just, fair, and
reasonable, and cannot be termed as perverse or arbitrary so as to warrant
interference under writ jurisdiction.
17.
Accordingly, the present writ petition is dismissed. The amount of
Rs.1,00,000/- deposited with the Registrar General of this Court pursuant to
the order dated 08.07.2019, along with any interest accrued thereon, shall be
released to the respondent/workwoman.
18.
The Registry is directed to communicate a copy of this order forthwith
to the respondent/workwoman at her recorded address as well as to the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
12:26:59
W.P.(C) 8877/2018
counsel who had previously entered appearance on her behalf in the present
proceedings, by way of written communication.
(MANOJ KUMAR OHRI)
JUDGE
AUGUST 7, 2026
nb
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
12:26:59
W.P.(C) 8877/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review