Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 348e ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY,THE NINETEENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION N O: 13504 OF 2009
Between:
M/s. Balaji lndustrial and Agricultural castings, 1 6 I DA, -Balanagar, -Hyderabad
- 500 037, ;p. bt itr Frrtndr, M. Bhuranesh-wari, Wo' M' Sreekanth'
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The Government of lndia, Ministry of. Finance AND Company,,,tfiil'j,l
Oepa rtment of n"r"r, re, i +' H rdco Vishala B u ld ng !:ry,L9,'-61|,I
(Review)
Cama place,-itew-OeNilt 10066, rep. by itsJoint Secretary
Hydeiatiad - M Division'
2. The Assistant Commissioneitf Ceniral Excise, Zi,
Aditya Towers, Sri Sai
Hyderabad: iV Cormissionerale, Faoi Notlg ?nd
i
i
Eia"G Ob Bowenpally, Secunderabad - 500 011'
...RESPONDENTS
in the
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that
may be
circumstances stated in the affidavit fited therewith, the High Court
writ of
pleased to issue appropriate writ, order or direction more particularly a
passed bythe 1st
Mandamus declaring the order No. 137l09-CX dt.03.06.2009
the provisions
respondent as arbitrary, iltegal, without jurisdiction and ultra vires
of
of central Excise Act and Rules and violation of Article 14 0f the constitution
lndia and to set aside the same
l.A. NO: I OF 2009(WPMP. NO: 17546 OF 2009)
stated
Petition under s,ection 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
be pleased to
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition' the High Court may
1"t respondent
suspend the order No. 137/09-CX dt. 03.06.2009 passed by the
lA NO: I OF 2019
Between:
The A:;sistant Commissioner of Central Excise, Hyderabad - M Division,
Hyderabad - lV Commissionerate, Plot Nos.16 and 21, Aditya Towers, Sri Sai
Eiclave, Old Bowenpally, Secunderabad - 500 011.
(Presently
Office of the Commissioner of Central Tax, Medcha! GST
'
CommiCsionerate, H.No. 11464918 M Lakdikapul, Hyderabad 4)
....PETITIONER
2Nd RESPONDENT
AND
1.
M/s. Balaji lndustrial and Agricultural Castings, 16 lDA, Balanagar, Hyderabad
- 500 037, rep. by its Partner, M. Bhuvaneshwari, Wo. M. Sreekanth.
...RESPONDENT/UI'RIT PETITIONER
The Ciovernment of lndia, Ministry of Finance AND Company, {fairs,
Deparlment of Revenue, 14 Hudco Vishala Building B-Wing,_6th Floor, Bhikaji
Caha Place, New Delhi-110066, rep. by its Joint Secretary (Review)
...RESPONDENT/I
St
RCSPONDENT
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
vacate the stay granted vide order dt. 16/9/2009 in WPMP NO. 17546/2009 lN
WP No. 13504/2009
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRl. MOHD. ANWAR AL! REP
M/s. MOHAN VINOD & ASSOCIATES
Counsel for the Respondents Ms. PRAVALIKA GOUD FOR
SRI DOMINIC FERNANDES
(senior standing counsel for CBIC)
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TETANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABTE SRI IUSTI ESU D DAL/A CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION
o-135O4 of 2OO9
DATE OF ORDER: 19.01.2026
Between :
M/s. Balaji Industrial and Agricultural Castings,
16 IDA, Balanaga6 Hyderabad - 500 037,
Rep. by its partner M, Bhuvaneshwari,
Wo. M.Sreekanth.
...Petitioner
AND
The Government of India,
Ministry of Finance & Company Affairs,
Department of Revenue,
14, Hudco Vishala Building,
B-Wing,6th Floor, Bhikaji Cama Place,
New Delhi - 110066,
Rep. by its Joint Secretary (Review) and 1 other.
... Respondents
ORDER: (per the Honk gi lustic€ P.Sam Koshy)
Heard Mr. Mohd. Anwar Ali, learned counsel representing
M/s. Mohan Vinod Associates for the petitioner; and Ms. Pravalika
Goud, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Mr' Dominic
Page ?- of 7
Fernander;, learned Senior Standing Counsel for CBIC for
respondent No.2.
2.
The instant writ petition has been filed by the petitioner
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India assailing the Order
No.137l0'9-CX, dated 03.06.2009, passed by respondent No.1.
3.
Vldr: the said impugned order, respondent No.1 / Revisional
Authority has affirmed the Order-in-Appeal No.1212007(H-IV)(D),
dated 29.08.2007, passed by the Commissioner of Customs &
Central E:<cise (Appeals).
4.
The point for consideration is 'whether the petitioner would
be entitl:d for rebate of duty for the exports made to other
countries other than Nepal and Bhutan in terms of the notification
No. 19/2004-CE (NT), dated 05.09.2006?'
5.
The: respondent Nc.2 / Assessing Officer, at the first instance,
vide order dated 18.09.2006 had accepted the contention of the
petitioner so far as treating the export made by the petitioner to be
one which would be accessible to rebate as per the notification
No.19/2C,04-CE (NT), dated 06.09.2006. The order passed by the
Assessing Officer was subjected to challenge before the
Commissioner of Customs & Central Excise (Appeals) by way of
Order-in-Appeal No.1212007(H-IVXD). The Commissioner of
Customs & Central Excise (Appeals) found that the petitioner, in
fact, had exported certain equipments from India to Zambia and
had received certain job work for digging of bore wells' The
equipments exported werg also in connection with the
accomplishments of job work given to the petitioner'
6.
The petitioner claimed for refund vlde application dated
10.04.2006 and the same was processed by the Assessing Officer
by issuing a notice on 05.07.2006. The petitioner replied to the
said notice on 19.O7.2006. Thereafte[ considering the submissions
put forth on either side, the Assessing Officer vrde order dated
18.09.2006 allowed the claim of the petitioner, which was set aside
by the Commissioner of Customs & Central Excise (Appeals)'
7.
The grounds for setting aside the order dated 18'09'2006'
was that the notification No.19/2004-CE (NT) itself very specifically
mentionedthattherebatewouldbeeligibleonlyforthose
exporters who meet the conditions, limitatioris, and procedures
...J,,
-.,/
specified in the said notification. The notification had categorically
spelt out certain conditions and limitations and also laid down the
procedun:s under which such rebate would be claimed. The
commissioner of customs & central Excise (Appeals) found that
the petitioner was not in a position to meet the conditions and
limitations at the first instance and also has not complied with the
procedures spelt out in notification No.19/2004-cE (NT). Thus,
allowing the appeal of the Revenue, the commissioner of customs
& central Excise (Appeals) set aside the order-in-original
No.32l2006-07-R.
8- It vuas this order which has been subjected to chailenge by
the petiti()ner before the Revisional Authority by way of a revision.
The Revisional Authority also finding force in the conclusion arrived
at by the commissioner of customs & central Excise (Appeals)
found that the petitioner, in fact, has not followed the provisions of
notificaticn No.tg/2oo4-cE (NT). Further, the Revisional Authority
found that there were certain discrepancies in the claim raised by
the petiti(\nar
a(
-\
*\s
Page 5 ot 7
9.
Some of the essential features which are reflected from the
order passed by the Commissioner of Customs & Central Excise
(Appeals) as also by the Revisional Authority are that with the so-
called export being made by the petitioner, there was no foreign
exchange that was earned by the petitioner from the sale of those
equipments or by the Government of India indirectly. Secondly, the
duty for the vehicle on which the bore well equipments were fixed
were in fact not manufactured by the petitioner, but were
manufactured by M/s. Ashok Leyland, who had paid the duty.
Therefore, the rebate for the said vehicle could not had been
claimed by the petitioner who was only the manufacturer of bore
well equipments which was installed on the vehicle purchased from
M/s. Ashok Leyland. Likewise, it was also the finding of the two
authorities that the exporter had also not filed any ARE-1 and the
procedure prescribed so far as selling of the goods of which export
was made, the examination of those goods and places of dispatch
was also not carried out in terms of the requirements spelt out in
notification No.19/20O4-CE (NT). Another irnportant aspect which
was found by the two authorities was that the entire export was
made by the petitioner for carrying out job work that they had got
fl
in Zambia and after the job work; the entire equipments were reimported back to Zambia. Therefore, since the goods that were
exported 'were at the time of export itself shown as goods to be reimportabl,-. by itself would establish that since it was of reimportabl,: basis, the country as such was not earning any foreign
exchange from the so-called export made by the petitioner
entailing lrim for rebate as notified yrde notification No.19/2004-CE
(NT).
10. Sinr:e the Commissioner of Customs & Central Excise
(Appeals) as also the Revisional Authority have given a concurrent
finding so far as the petitioner having not fulfilled the conditions
and limitations and also having not complied with the procedures
laid down in the notification No.19/2004-CE (NT), the petitioner
was required to establish by way of specific proof of having met the
conditionr; and also having fulfilled the procedures laid down in the
notificatic,n No.19/2004-CE (NT). However, perusal of the writ
petition and upon hearing the contentions put forth by the learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner, we were not taken through the
proof if any available with the petitioner so far as having met the
condition:; and limitations and also having complied with the
procedures spelt out in notification No.19/2004-CE (NT)' In the
absence of any specific material strong enough to hold that the
findings arrived at by the two forums i.e. Revisional Authority as
also by the Commissioner of Customs & Central Excise (Appeals) to
be an incorrect finding of fact, we do not find any strong case made
outbythepetitionertoholdthatthetwoorderstobeeitherbadin
law or factuallY incorrect.
11. The instant writ petition therefore being devoid of merit'
deserves to be and is accordingly, dismissed' The question of law
stands decided in favour of the Revenue and against the petitioner
holding that the petitioner is not entitled for any rebate of duty for
the exports made to other countries other than Nepal and Bhutan
in terms of the notification No.19/2004-CE (NT), dated 05'09'2006'
L2. As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending if any' shall
stand ctosed. However, there shail be no order "r
TrllihorANt swAmy
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
,,TRUE COPYII
SECTION OFFICER
To,
& AS-S^OCIATES' Advocate TOPUCI
. One CC to M/s. MOHAN VINOD
FEflilnru*oEslie"ioisiandins couhselfor CBIC)
2. One CC to SRt. DOMIN|L
loPUcl
3. Two CD Copies
BM
BS
@t-
gonrwn
t qi.lilt li
mDm
,J
i
*
WP.No.13504 of 2009
DISMISSING THE WRIT
r(
f..'t-
I Fi8
o
*
o
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review