Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P. (T) No. 3208 of 2026
(with I.A. No. 7483 of 2026)
M/s Arvind Construction, represented through its proprietor Arvind
Kumar Gupta, aged about 47 years, son of Shri Ghanshyam Lal Gupta,
resident of 1A, VIP Apartment, Dimna Main Road, Opposite Vishal
Megamart, P.O.- Mango, P.S.-Mango, Jamshedpur, District- East
Singhbhum, Jharkhand.
……..
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand through the Secretary, Water Resources
Development Department, officiating at Nepal House, P.O.:Doranda, P.S.:- Doranda, Dist:-Ranchi, Jharkhand.
2. The Principal Secretary, Water Resources Development Department,
officiating at Nepal House, P.O.:- Doranda, P.S.:- Doranda, Dist:Ranchi, Jharkhand.
3. The Engineer-in-Chief, Water Resources Development Department,
officiating at Nepal House, P.O.:- Doranda, P.S.:- Doranda, Dist:Ranchi, Jharkhand.
4. The Chief-Engineer, officiating at Swarnrekha Bhawan Adityapur,
P.O- Adityapur, P.S- Adityapur, Dist-Saraikella-Kharsawan
Jharkhand.
5. The Executive Engineer, Minor Distribution No.-03, officiating at
Mango, P.O- Mango, P.S- Mango, Dist- East-Singhbhum,
Jharkhand.
6. Mr. Ram Nivas Prasad, aged not known, S/o not known, ChiefEngineer, Chandil Complex, Adityapur Jamshedpur, Swarnrekha
Bhawan Adityapur, P.O- Adityapur, P.S-Adityapur, Dist- SaraikellaKharsawan.
……….
Respondents
AND
W.P. (T) No. 3133 of 2026
(with I.A. No. 7482 of 2026)
M/s Arvind Construction, represented through its proprietor Arvind
Kumar Gupta, aged about 47 years, son of Shri Ghanshyam Lal Gupta,
resident of 1A, VIP Apartment, Dimna Main Road, Opposite Vishal
Megamart, P.O.- Mango, P.S.-Mango, Jamshedpur, District- East
Singhbhum, Jharkhand.
……..
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand through the Secretary, Water Resources
Development Department, officiating at Nepal House, P.O.:Doranda, P.S.:- Doranda, Dist:-Ranchi, Jharkhand.
2. The Principal Secretary, Water Resources Development
Department, officiating at Nepal House, P.O.:- Doranda, P.S.:Doranda, Dist:-Ranchi, Jharkhand.
3. The Engineer-in-Chief, Water Resources Development
Department, officiating at Nepal House, P.O.:- Doranda, P.S.:Doranda, Dist:-Ranchi, Jharkhand.
4. The Chief-Engineer, officiating at Swarnrekha Bhawan
Adityapur, P.O- Adityapur, P.S- Adityapur, Dist-SaraikellaKharsawan Jharkhand.
5. The Executive Engineer, Minor Distribution No.-03, officiating
at Mango, P.O- Mango, P.S- Mango, Dist- East-Singhbhum,
Jharkhand.
……….
Respondents
--------CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
--------For the Petitioners:
Mr Varun Praphakar, Advocate
(in both cases)
For the State:
Mr Vibhor Mayank, A.C. to A.G.
(in both cases)
--------04/Dated: 24.06.2026
1.
Heard Mr Varun Praphakar, the learned counsel for the petitioners,
and Mr Vibhor Mayank, the learned A.C. to A.G. appearing for the
respondents-State.
2.
The learned counsel for the petitioners craves leave to withdraw
the petitions.
3.
We grant the petitioners leave and dispose of both the writ
petitions and the Interlocutory Applications therein.
4.
However, though we have disposed of the writ petitions, we note
what we have observed in paragraphs 5, 6 and 7 of our order dated
12.05.2026 :“5. However, we direct that the affidavit should be filed by
the
Secretary
(Water
Resources
Development
Department) without delegating this task to any other
officer. Assuming that the affidavit will refer to the
alleged mistake in issuing the NIT in the wrong format,
the affidavit must, in clear terms, explain who was
responsible for such mistake.
6.
The above explanation is necessary to be furnished in
the Secretary's affidavit because issuing tenders and
publishing them in newspapers costs the tax-payer a lot
of money. Besides, in this case, we noted that the
reason for cancellation of the tender was also not
readily supplied to the petitioner or other tenderers,
thereby forcing them to approach the Court, for which
again, the petitioner must have incurred expenses. The
mistake, is a cause for utilizing valuable judicial time.
Therefore, the Secretary, must, in the affidavit, disclose
clearly the officer/officers responsible for the alleged
mistake and state whether any steps would be taken to
recover the loss caused to the State exchequer on
account of such mistake. The affidavit must also
indicate whether there is any proposal to fix
responsibility on such officers and make suitable
entries in their confidential rolls.
7.
The Secretary, must file the affidavit before 12th June,
2026 without seeking any further extensions.”
5.
In our order, we had directed the Secretary to enquire into the
matter. Still, we are surprised that the Secretary delegated this duty
to a committee that has now prepared a report that commits
nothing and was perhaps constituted only to frustrate or delay the
faithful compliance with the Court’s directions.
6.
Even the Secretary, in his affidavit filed before us on 22nd of June
2026, has rightly found the report unsustainable. The affidavit
states that a committee was constituted, comprising the Executive
Engineer, the Superintending Engineer and the Chief Engineer, to
determine which Officer/Officers were responsible for the
mistaken publication of the tender in the correct form. We had also
directed the Secretary to file an affidavit on whether there is any
proposal to fix responsibility on such officer/officers and make
suitable entries in their confidential rolls.
7.
The Committee, we are sorry to say, has only filed a report stating
that there was a mistake in the publication of the Tender Notice.
This was well known. This was, in fact, the State’s contention.
Therefore, we wonder why such a committee was necessary to
determine the obvious. The committee, constituted by the
Secretary, either to delay the matter or to evade responsibility, was
clearly required to ascertain which Officer/Officers were
responsible for the alleged mistake. The Secretary was directed to
inform the Court whether any steps would be taken to recover the
loss caused to the State exchequer on account of such mistake from
such Officer/Officers, and further, whether there would be any
proposal to make suitable entries in their confidential rolls.
8.
From the report filed before us, we are sorry to say that we get the
impression that this Committee, comprising the Executive
Engineer, Superintending Engineer, and Chief Engineer, appears to
be only interested in protecting the fellow Officer/Officers
responsible for the mistake.
9.
The Secretary, we are surprised, has again remanded the matter to
this very Committee, which has clearly evinced an interest in not
determining which persons were responsible for the mistake. It is
rather difficult to accept that this Court’s order or the Secretary’s
order lacked any clarity. The committee’s mandate was quite clear.
They are senior officials holding responsible positions. Therefore,
on their own, they should have determined where the fault lay and
recovered the loss caused to the State exchequer from the errant
officials.
10. The Secretary and the Committee official must always remember
that they are dealing with public funds. They are the trustees of the
public funds collected from taxpayers in this country. Therefore, if,
on account of a gross mistake, the State Exchequer is put to a loss,
there is a duty to at least enquire into such mistakes, determine
which Officer/Officers are responsible for them, and, if necessary,
recover the amount from the responsible officers. There is also a
duty to make an entry in the confidential rolls of the responsible
Officer/Officers so that a sense of responsibility is instilled and
they improve in future. Protecting errant officials at any cost is not
as important as protecting the State’s interests or the public
interest.
11. The Executive Engineer, the Superintending Engineer and the
Chief Engineer have indulged in an exercise to cover up the truth
by pretending that they did not understand the Court’s order or that
they did not understand the order by which they were constituted
and under which they were required to function. The entire idea
seems to be to create a bureaucratic logjam so that the Court’s
orders are, if possible, frustrated or at least not complied with in
letter and spirit. Since even the Secretary has not bothered to
deprecate all this but merely remanded this matter to the very same
committee, we deprecate this attitude of all concerned.
12. The Secretary is now directed to himself enquire into the matter up
by 08.07.2026 and determine which Officer/Officers are
responsible for the mistake. The Secretary may take the assistance
of the Committee. However, if the Secretary receives no assistance
from the members of the Committee, we will have to consider
whether the mistake should be attributed to the Secretary himself,
and whether the members of the Committee and the amounts spent
on issuing such a mistaken advertisement should be recovered
from them. Once a mistake is apparent and admitted, we refuse to
accept that the persons who committed it cannot be identified. In
fact, such determination must be a matter of record. Any attempt to
protect errant officials is a serious matter, and those found to
extend such protection must also be held accountable.
13. The Secretary should also consider whether any members of the
committee were themselves responsible for the mistake and have,
therefore, filed such a report without any application of mind.
14. At one stage, we were considering placing this order in the
confidential records of the Secretary and the committee members.
However, at least one opportunity is due to the officials to make
serious amends.
15. Although we are disposing of these petitions, we direct the
Secretary to file a compliance affidavit in this Court by
10.07.2026, without seeking any extension. Now that there is [in
fact, there never was] a dispute about the publication of an
incorrect notice causing loss to the State exchequer, the names of
those responsible for this mistake must be disclosed, and action for
recovery must be initiated.
16. List the matter for orders/compliance on the 13th of July 2026.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
June 24, 2026
N.A.F.R.
Manoj/Sharda/Cp.2
Uploaded on 29.06.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review