Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: 27.03.2026
FAO 389/2016 & CM APPL. 29552/2016
+
M/S AMBALA PATIALA TRANSPORT CO
.....Appellant
Through: Ms.Ekta Choudhary, Ms.Rushali
Sikand and Mr.Ankur Anand,
Advocates
versus
PRATAP SINGH
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr.R.K.Nain with Mr.Chandan
Prajapati, Mr.Daksh Nain and
Mr.Karan Sharma, Advocates
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
The appellant, being the employer, has preferred the present appeal
assailing the impugned award dated 21.05.2015 passed by the learned
Commissioner under Employee's Compensation Act, 1923 (hereinafter
referred to as the „EC Act‟), whereby the claim for death compensation was
allowed. The employer was directed to pay a sum of Rs.3,94,120/- along
with 12% simple interest from the date of the accident till its realization. The
impugned award came to passed in the context of claim seeking the death
compensation by the parents of one, Balbir Singh (hereafter referred to as
the „deceased‟).
2.
It was claimed that the deceased was employed as a driver on the
vehicle bearing No. HR-55-2008, owned by the employer, and that he died
out of and during the course of his employment. It was averred that the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:34:39
FAO 389/2016
Pg. 1 of 7
deceased, on the instructions of his employer, who was in the transport
business, undertook an occupational trip from Delhi to Kolkata after getting
the vehicle loaded with cycle parts. He was the only driver on the truck.
When he reached Aligarh, the engine of the said vehicle broke down. The
deceased, who was already under work pressure, fell ill. The vehicle
remained parked on the roadside, and despite all efforts, the engine could
not be repaired. The employer, however, neither bothered nor came to the
rescue of the deceased. The deceased remained lying in the vehicle for
about 13 days, and it was a mechanic who informed about the ill health to
the brother of the deceased i.e., Jeet Singh, who was also employed as a
driver, albeit with a different owner, and was on the way from Delhi to
Kolkata. He reached the spot, took the deceased, and admitted to Burdwan
Medical College & Hospital for treatment on 05.03.2006 where he expired
during the treatment on 20.03.2006. The death was attributed to the
employment. It was further claimed that the last drawn wages of the
deceased was Rs.4,500/- per month, along with Rs.100/- per day as food
allowance. The deceased was aged about 35 years.
3.
Apparently, the first claim application filed by the claimant came to
be dismissed on 16.09.2009. The order records that the employer had
claimed that the vehicle in question did not belong to him and as such claim
was dismissed with liberty to file the same on getting details of the real
owner of the vehicle. The second claim application was thereafter filed on
the same set of facts.
however, this time the truck number was not
mentioned. Further, the claim application was accompanied by the medical
documents of the Burdwan Medical College & Hospital indicating the date
of admission as 05.03.2006 as well as the death certificate dated 20.3.2006,
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:34:39
FAO 389/2016
Pg. 2 of 7
where cause of death has been found as „encephalopathy‟.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellant contended that the employer not
only denied the ownership of the vehicle but also denied that the deceased
was ever employed as a driver with it. It is also contended that the claim
that the deceased remained lying 13 days in truck at Aligarh, and instead of
taking him to a nearby hospital, was taken to Burdwan Medical College and
Hospital in West Bengal, is improbable and ought not to have been believed
by the learned Commissioner.
5.
Mr
Chandan
Prajapati,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondent/claimant, on the other hand, contends that the claimants being
the parents of the deceased, were not aware of the complete registration
number of the truck in question and, therefore, could provide only an
incomplete number. Further, the claimants have examined the brother of the
deceased, the mechanic who had come to repair the vehicle, as well as
another driver who had seen the deceased with the truck.
6.
A perusal of the written statement as well as the evidence filed on its
behalf would show that employer has admitted to be in the transport
business on Delhi-Kolkata circuit. The employer further claimed that it
initially purchased two trucks, however, the same was sold within one year.
At the time of incident in question, the employer was not owning any trucks,
and its business was being carried by hiring trucks from third parties. It was
also claimed that the deceased was never employed with them.
7.
In this view of the matter, mere denial of the ownership of the truck in
question would not absolve the employer from its liability. Insofar as the
deceased being employed with the employer is concerned, the claimants
have examined three witnesses. The first being Jeet Singh, brother of the
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:34:39
FAO 389/2016
Pg. 3 of 7
deceased who stated that, like the deceased, he was also a driver. The
deceased was employed with M/s Ambala Patiala Transport Co., which was
owned by Raj Babu. Under the instructions of the employer, the deceased
was driving a loaded truck to Kolkata when the vehicle broke down near
Aligarh. On coming to know of the serious condition of his brother, he
reached the spot and got the deceased admitted in Burdwan Medical College
and Hospital. In cross-examination, he clarified that he was informed by
one, Lalit Kumar Khanna. He also clarified that, at that time, his brother was
unconscious and had suffered mosquito bites. The second witness examined
being Lalit Kumar Khanna, the mechanic who had come to repair the
vehicle admitted that he had informed the brother of the deceased about his
medical condition. The third witness i.e., Ramesh Kumar stated that he was
employed as a second driver on a truck belonging to one Parvinder Singh.
He further stated that the deceased was employed with the employer on the
truck in question and under the directions from his employer, the deceased
had undertaken occupational trip from Delhi to Kolkata. In crossexamination, he categorically stated that he had also reached the spot and
saw the condition of the deceased and had accompanied the brother of the
deceased.
8.
In light of the aforesaid evidence, the learned Commissioner returned
a finding that the witnesses Lalit Kumar Khanna and Ramesh Kumar were
independent persons, and their testimony along with the medical certificate,
post-mortem report of the deceased proved that the deceased had died during
the course of his employment. The cause of death was also found to be
relatable to occupational hazard. In „Param Pal Singh through Father vs.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:34:39
FAO 389/2016
Pg. 4 of 7
National Insurance Company and Another’1, the Supreme Court while
interpreting the expression „personal injury‟ under Section 3 of the
Workmen‟s Compensation Act, 1923 held that there has to be causal
connection between the employment and death.
Relevant extract is as
under:
“29. Applying the various principles laid down in the above decisions to
the facts of this case, we can validly conclude that there was causal
connection to the death of the deceased with that of his employment as a
truck driver. We cannot lose sight of the fact that a 45-year-old driver
meets with his unexpected death, may be due to heart failure while driving
the vehicle from Delhi to a distant place called Nimiaghat near Jharkhand
which is about 1152 km away from Delhi, would have definitely undergone
grave strain and stress due to such long distance driving. The deceased
being a professional heavy vehicle driver when undertakes the job of such
driving as his regular avocation it can be safely held that such constant
driving of heavy vehicle, being dependent solely upon his physical and
mental resources and endurance, there was every reason to assume that
the vocation of driving was a material contributory factor if not the sole
cause that accelerated his unexpected death to occur which in all fairness
should be held to be an untoward mishap in his lifespan. Such an
“untoward mishap” can therefore be reasonably described as an
“accident” as having been caused solely attributable to the nature of
employment indulged in with his employer which was in the course of such
employer’s trade or business.”
9.
The Supreme Court, in „Mackinnon Mackenzie & Co. (P) Ltd. v.
Ibrahim Mahmmed Issak‟2, held that for a claim to fall within the ambit of
the Act, the injury must arise both out of and in the course of employment.
While “in the course of employment” mean in the course of the work which
the workman is employed to do and which is incidental to it. The words
“arising out of employment” are understood to mean that, during the course
of employment, the injury has resulted from some risk incidental to the
duties of the service, which, unless engaged in such duty owing to the
(2013) 3 SCC 409
(1969) 2 SCC 607
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:34:39
FAO 389/2016
Pg. 5 of 7
master, it is reasonable to believe the workman would not otherwise have
suffered. In other words, there must be a causal relationship between the
accident and the employment. To put it differently, if the accident had
occurred on account of a risk which is an incident of the employment, the
claim for consideration must succeed, unless, of course, the workman has
exposed himself to an added peril by his own imprudent act. Although the
burden lies on the claimant, the nexus may be inferred from proved facts,
provided it is not based on mere conjecture.
10.
In the present case, the evidence on record establishes that the
deceased had undertaken a work-related journey from Delhi to Kolkata as a
driver and fell ill when the vehicle broke down en route, thereby satisfying
the requirement that the incident occurred in the course of employment.
Further, the material on record, including the testimony of witnesses and the
medical documents, indicates that the deceased remained unattended during
the course of such employment and his condition deteriorated due to factors
incidental thereto, thereby establishing a causal nexus between the
employment and the death. The evidence on record as well as the postmortem report sufficiently establishes such connection, which this Court has
no doubt, took place „arising out of and in the course of employment‟.
11.
This Court is conscious of the fact that the present is a challenge
under Section 30 of the EC Act, and in light of the aforesaid decisions, the
findings of fact recorded by the employer, the impugned order requires no
interference. Accordingly, the challenge fails.
12.
At the filing of the appeal, the employer was directed to deposit 50%
of the awarded amount, which should be released to the claimant. The
employer is directed to also pay remaining amount within two weeks from
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:34:39
FAO 389/2016
Pg. 6 of 7
today.
13.
The appeal is dismissed in the aforesaid terms.
14.
The pending application shall also stand closed.
MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
(JUDGE)
MARCH 27, 2026/pmc
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:34:39
FAO 389/2016
Pg. 7 of 7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review