Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
Reserved On
: 07/01/2026
Pronounced On : 23/01/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11025 of 2025
With
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11029 of 2025
With
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11030 of 2025
With
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11033 of 2025
With
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11034 of 2025
With
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11035 of 2025
With
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 11043 of 2025
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA
Sd/-
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRANAV TRIVEDI
Sd/-
================================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
a
================================================================
M/S ALSTOM TRANSPORT INDIA LIMITED THROUGH ITS AUTHORISED
SIGNATORY SHAH DIPTEJ HARSHADKUMAR
Versus
ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER, CGST AND
CENTRAL EXCISE (APPEALS) & ORS.
================================================================
Appearance:
MR. SUJIT GHOSH, SENIOR ADVOCATE WITH MS. MANNAT WARAICH,
MS. ANSHIKA AGARWAL, MR. SHREY BHATT WITH MR. ADITYA J
PANDYA, Advocates for the Petitioner(s) No. 1
PARAM V SHAH(9473) for the Respondent(s) No. 1,2,3,4
================================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRANAV TRIVEDI
COMMON CAV JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA)
(1)
The present group of petitions involves a common
question of law and, therefore, they have been
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
heard together and are being decided analogously
by this common judgment.
FACTS:
(2)
Special Civil Application No.11025 of 2025 is
taken as a lead matter.
(3)
The captioned writ petitions are filed by the
the
petitioner
- Alstom
Transport
India
Ltd.
(ATIL), seeking quashing and setting aside the
Orders-in-Appeal
dated
08.01.2025
passed
by
respondent No.1-Additional Commissioner, CGST &
Central Excise (Appeals), Vadodara, passed under
Section 107(11) of the Central Goods and Service
Tax,
(hereinafter
CGST, Act, 2017”)
referred
to
as
“the
allowing the appeal filed by
respondent No.2 - Assistant Commissioner, CGST &
Central Excise, Division-V, Vadodara-II, against
the
Refund
Sanction
Orders
dated
28.02.2024
passed by respondent No.3, Deputy Commissioner,
CGST & Central Excise, Division-V, Vadodara-II,
in FORM RFD-06.
(4)
The
identity
of
the
petitioner
-
Company
emanates from the order dated 10.08.2023, passed
by
the
National
dissolving
three
Company
Law
Tribunal
entities
-
(i)
(NCLT)
Alstom
Rail
Transportation India Pvt. Ltd. (ARTIPL), (ii)
Alstom Manufacturing India Pvt. Ltd. (AMIPL),
and (iii) Alstom System India Pvt. Ltd. (ASIPL),
C/SCA/11025/2025
and
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
sanctioning
their
amalgamation
into
the
petitioner. The certified copy of the said order
was
issued
on
28.08.2023
and
was
thereafter
filed with the Registrar of Companies (RoC) on
22.09.2023.
(5)
In
terms
of
the
Scheme
of
Amalgamation,
the
entire business of the three dissolved entities,
including, inter alia, all assets, liabilities,
rights,
title,
interests,
obligations,
and
immovable properties, one of them being ARTIPL,
stood
transferred
to
and
vested
in
the
petitioner upon the Scheme coming into effect
from the appointed date. As per the Scheme, the
“effective
date”
was
the
date
on
which
the
certified copy of the NCLT order was last filed
with the Registrar of Companies, which, in the
present case, is 22.09.2023.
(6)
The aforesaid arrangement and development were
duly intimated by ARTIPL to the Superintendent,
Range-II, Division-V, Vadodara-II, vide letter
dated 10.10.2023 i.e. within two weeks from the
effective date.
(7)
The erstwhile ARTIPL, having exported goods in
April
2023,
filed
an
application
dated
04.01.2024 seeking refund of unutilized Input
Tax Credit (ITC) in terms of Section 16 of the
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
Integrated
Goods
and
Services
Tax
Act,
(IGST Act, 2017) read with Section 54(3) of the
CGST Act, 2017.
(8)
It appears that on 20.10.2023, FORM GST ITC-02
was filed by erstwhile ARTIPL Ltd. in terms of
Section 18(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 read with
Rule 41 of the Central Goods and Service Tax
Rules,
(hereinafter
referred
to
as
“the
CGST Rules, 2017”) for transfer of part amount
of unutilized ITC of Rs.192,87,53,211/- out of
total
available
unutilized
Rs.242,02,00,000/-.
However,
the
ITC
of
amount
in
question of Rs.49,14,00,000/- remained in the
Electronic Credit Ledger of ARTIPL, and was not
sought to be transferred. Thereafter, it appears
that from 04.01.2024 to 28.02.2024, the ARTIPL
filed
various
refund
claim
(month-wise)
for
different amounts totaling to unutilized ITC of
Rs.49,14,00,000/-.
Adjudication
took
place
at
various levels in respect of aforesaid various
refund applications.
(9)
Accordingly,
a
show
cause
notice
dated
22.02.2024 was issued to the ARTIPL, and upon
submission of objections on 28.02.2024, a Refund
Sanction Order came to be passed in favour of
ARTIPL,
and
the
refund
Rs.2,56,75,437/- has been encashed.
amount
of
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
(10) Subsequently,
on
29.07.2024,
respondent
No.4
reviewed the Refund Order under Section 107(2)
of the CGST Act, 2017, and passed an Order-inReview
Order
on
29.07.2024,
directing
the
Respondent no.3, to file an appeal in FORM GST
APL-03
for
the
period
from
01.04.2023
to
30.04.2023.
(11) Accordingly, respondent No.3 preferred an appeal
against the ARTIPL, which came to be allowed
vide order dated 08.01.2025 setting aside the
order granting refund, which has giving a cause
to file the captioned writ petitions.
(12) It
appears
that,
during
the
aforesaid
proceedings of refund, a show cause notice dated
07.11.2024 was issued to the ARTIPL proposing
cancellation of its GST registration. The said
show cause notice was adjudicated by an order
dated 29.11.2024, whereby the GST registration
of the ARTIPL came to be cancelled. In the said
order,
it was
specifically
provided
that
the
effective date of cancellation of registration
would be 29.11.2024.
(13) Thus, from a perusal of the aforementioned key
dates, it can be noticed that even though the
ARTIPL was dissolved and amalgamated into the
petitioner
vide
order
of
the
NCLT
dated
10.08.2023, certified copy of which was filed
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
with the RoC on 22.09.2023, and intimation of
which
was
given
to
the
respondents
on
10.10.2023, until 29.11.2024 the ARTIPL existed
as a registered person under the GST and was
recognized so by the respondent authorities.
SUBMISSIONS MADE ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER:
(14) Learned Senior Advocate Mr.Ghosh has made the
following submissions :
(15) All the proceedings were initiated in the name
of the ARTIPL all throughout. However, on and
from
29.11.2024
cancellation
of
i.e.
the
the
date
registration,
of
the
the
ARTIPL
cannot be said to exist for the purpose of the
GST Laws.
(16) Reference is made to Clause 8.1 of the Scheme of
Amalgamation,
and
is
contended
that
the
Transferee Company is obliged to bear both the
burdens and benefits of all legal, taxation, and
other
claims
or
investigations
of
whatsoever
nature pertaining to the transferor companies.
He
has
also
referred
to
the
contents
of
Paragraph No.13 of the NCLT order, which records
that any claim against the Transferor Companies
in respect of direct and indirect taxes shall be
settled
by
the
Transferee
Company,
hence
accordingly, in terms of the NCLT order and the
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
undertakings furnished thereunder, in respect of
the
GST
proceedings
Transferor
Company
Transferee
Company
initiated
i.e.
against
the
ARTIPL,
the
petitioner,
is
the
i.e.
the
obligated to prosecute and / or defend the same.
(17) It is contended that once the GST registration
of the ARTIPL stood cancelled, the ARTIPL cannot
be said to have had any legal existence, either
under the Company Law or under the GST law, so
as to be capable of instituting or prosecuting
any legal proceedings.
(18) A
refund,
largesse,
accordance
governing
being
can
in
be
with
the
the
nature
claimed
the
same.
of
only
the
State
in
statutory
Under
a
strict
framework
GST
regime,
persons effecting zero-rated supplies constitute
one of the categories entitled to claim refund.
In terms of Section 16(1) of the IGST Act, 2017,
“zero-rated supply” includes exports of goods
and services. Section 16(3) of the IGST Act,
is
the
provision
which
creates
the
statutory right to claim refund of unutilized
input tax credit in respect of exports of goods
and services. However, the claim for refund must
be made in accordance with Section 54 of the
CGST
Act,
and
is
subject
to
such
conditions, safeguards, and procedures as may be
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
prescribed. Reference is made to Section 54(3)
of the CGST Act, 2017, which further imposes
restrictions,
inter
alia,
that
refund
of
unutilized ITC shall not be admissible where the
export of goods is subject to export duty, or
where
the
claimant
has
availed
drawback
in
respect of such goods. Thus, it is submitted
that
the
statutory
and
substantive
right
to
claim refund flows from Section 16(3) of the
IGST Act, 2017, and a fundamental precondition
for the accrual of such right is that the zerorated
supply
must
be
made
by
a
registered
person. Section 16(3) clearly postulates that,
on the date of making the zero-rated supply, the
claimant
of
the
refund
must
be
a
registered
person.
(19) It is contended that in the present case, the
ARTIPL
had
April
2023,
neither
effected
at
exports
which
undergone
point
in
the
month
of
in
time
it
had
nor
had
its
amalgamation
registration been cancelled. It had, therefore,
fulfilled all the substantive preconditions for
claiming refund of unutilized ITC. Consequently,
upon
effecting
enforceable
such
right
to
exports,
claim
a
refund
vested
and
accrued
in
favour of the ARTIPL under Section 16(3) of the
IGST Act, 2017.
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
(20) With regard to the Legislative policy underlying
special treatment to exports by grant of refunds
(particularly refund of unutilized ITC) and its
relevance to the present case, it is contended
that such refunds of unutilized ITC are denied
to exporters, and the embedded input taxes would
either inflate the cost of the exported product
or would have to be absorbed by the exporter,
both of which would defeat the underlying policy
objective.
(21) Reliance is placed on Paragraphs No.29 and 30 of
the
decision
of
this
Court
in
the
case
of
Macrowagon Retail Pvt. Ltd. and Anr. vs. Union
of India and Ors., 2025 S.C.C. OnLine Guj. 3644
and decision of the Supreme Court in the case of
Union of India and Ors. vs. VKC Footsteps India
Pvt.
Ltd.,
(2022)
S.C.C.
603,
and
on
the
judgment rendered by the learned Single Judge of
the Karnataka High Court in the case of Tonbo
Imaging India Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India and
Ors., 2023 (73) GSTL 200 (Kar.).
(22) While placing reliance on the decision of the
Supreme
Court
in
the
case
of
Government
of
Kerala and Anr. vs. Mother Superior, (2021) 5
S.C.C. 602 it is contended that any ambiguity in
the interpretation of such beneficial provisions
must enure to the benefit of the taxpayer.
C/SCA/11025/2025
(23) The
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
respondents
alleging
that
have
there
denied
is
the
violation
refund
of
by
Section
18(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule 41 of
the CGST Rules, 2017 inasmuch as, out of the
total
unutilized
ITC,
it
retained
a
sum
of
Rs.49.14 crore, which was thereafter sought to
be utilized for claiming refund. It is contended
that it is manifest from the reason assigned
that the respondents are neither disputing the
fulfillment of the substantive conditions for
eligibility to avail the ITC and to claim refund
of unutilized ITC in respect of exports effected
by the ARTIPL, nor is there any dispute with
regard to the factual position that the ARTIPL
qualifies
as
an
exporter
and
had
in
fact
effected exports, since there is no finding in
the impugned appellate order alleging violation
of
Section
16(3)
of
the
IGST
Act,
or
Section 54(3) of the CGST Act, 2017.
(24) It
is
the
contended
adopted
by
the
that
the
respondents
on
interpretation
the
aforesaid
provisions is wholly misconceived since Section
18(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 is a permissive
provision
and
not
mandatory
which
enables
a
registered person to transfer unutilized ITC to
the transferee in the event of amalgamation, and
the said provision does not mandate that the
Transferor Company must transfer its unutilized
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
ITC, nor does it contain any stipulation that,
if such transfer is effected, the entire quantum
of
unutilized
ITC
must
necessarily
be
transferred.
(25) It is submitted that the expression “transfer of
the
entire
unutilized
ITC”
is
conspicuously
absent both in Section 18(3) of the CGST Act,
2017 as well as in Rule 41 of the CGST Rules,
2017. Hence, in such circumstances, to read into
Section
18(3)
of
the
CGST
Act,
a
requirement of compulsory transfer of the entire
unutilized
ITC
would
amount
to
judicial
legislation, which is impermissible in law in
view
of
settled
interpretation.
In
principles
this
regard,
of
statutory
reliance
is
placed on the decision of the Supreme Court in
the case of Padmasundara Rao & Ors. vs. State of
T.N. & Ors., (2002) 3 S.C.C. 533.
(26) In a situation where a transferor chooses not to
transfer any part of its unutilized ITC to the
transferee company pursuant to an amalgamation,
there exists no provision under the CGST Act,
2017 which empowers the authorities to compel
such transfer or to take any punitive action for
non-transfer,
both
the
which
decision
itself,
to
demonstrates
transfer
ITC
and
that
the
quantum of ITC to be transferred lie entirely
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
within the domain of the transferor, and the
Revenue has no role to play in this regard.
(27) That a fair reading of Section 18(3) of the CGST
Act, 2017 read with Rule 41 of the CGST Rules,
indicates
that
the
respondents
such
transfer,
regulatory
role
in
prescribe
the
form,
provide
have
no
except
to
access
to
the
portal, and require furnishing of a Chartered
Accountant’s
certificate.
Rule
of
41(3)
the
Significantly,
CGST
Rules,
under
2017,
the
acceptance of the transfer is to be given by the
transferee and not by the Department.
(28) Thus,
it
is
submitted
that,
in
these
circumstances, Section 18(3) of the CGST Act,
2017 read with Rule 41 of the CGST Rules, 2017
is
nothing
provision,
but
a
permissive
which
is
directory
and
in
enabling
nature
and
devoid of any mandatory character. Substantial
compliance with such a permissive and directory
provision is sufficient.
the
decision
in
the
Reliance is placed on
case
of
Administrator
Municipal Committee Charkhi Dadari & Anr. vs.
Ramji Lal Bagla & Ors. (1995) 5 S.C.C. 272.
While placing reliance on the decision of Hari
Vishnu Kamath vs. Syed Ahmad Ishaque & Ors.,
(1954) 2 S.C.C. 881 (Constitution Bench), it is
submitted that it is well established that an
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
enactment in form mandatory might in substance
be
directory,
and
that
the
use
of
the
word
“shall” does not conclude the matter and the
practical bearing of the distinction between a
provision which is mandatory and one which is
directory
is
that
while
the
former
must
be
strictly observed, in the case of the latter it
is sufficient that it is substantially complied
with.
(29) In so far as violation of Rule 41 of the CGST
Rules, 2017 is concerned, the submission of the
petitioner is that even the said Rule does not
mandate that the entire unutilized credit needs
to
be
transferred
in
the
case
of
an
amalgamation. No doubt, in the case of demerger,
a
certain
restrictive
covenant
has
been
incorporated by providing that the ITC shall be
apportioned in the ratio of value of assets of
the
new
unit,
however,
even
this
restrictive
covenant has no application in the present case,
since the present case is a case of amalgamation
and
not
a
demerger.
It
is
contended
that
wherever the legislature wanted to use the word
“entire”, it has done so, as can be discerned
from perusal of Explanation to Rule 41(1) of the
CGST Rules, 2017 where the phrase “entire asset
of business” has been used. If the intention of
the
Legislature
was
to
require
a
Transferor
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
Company
to
transfer
its
entire
unutilized
credit, then nothing stopped the Legislature in
incorporating
the
word
“transfer
of
entire
unutilized credit” in Rule 41(1) of the CGST
Rules, 2017 or Section 18(3) of the CGST Act,
2017.
(30) While dealing with the objections raised by the
revenue, for the alleged violation of Section
87(2) of the CGST Act, 2017, it is contended
that in so far as Section 87(2) of the CGST Act,
is
concerned,
the
contemplates
that
order,
registration
the
from
said
the
date
provision
of
the
NCLT
certificate
of
the
amalgamating company is liable to be cancelled.
However, since the power and responsibility to
cancel registration is statutorily vested in the
respondent Department and not in the petitioner,
the
provision
transferor
does
must
not
mandate
necessarily
that
apply
the
for
cancellation of registration prior to or upon
the effective date of the NCLT order. Hence, no
such
obligation
can
be
foisted
upon
the
transferor in the present case, and that apart,
considering
the
fact
Department
was
duly
amalgamation
as
early
that
the
intimated
as
on
respondentof
10.10.2023,
the
the
authorities ought to have initiated proceedings
for cancellation of registration forthwith under
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
Section 29 of the CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule
22 of the CGST Rules, 2017, which empowers the
proper officer to cancel registration suo motu,
even with retrospective effect.
(31) It is submitted that even when the respondent
authorities eventually exercised such power by
issuing show cause notice dated 07.11.2024 and
passing the cancellation order dated 29.11.2024,
they
consciously
registration
only
chose
to
prospectively
cancel
i.e.
the
w.e.f.
29.11.2024, and not retrospectively. In these
circumstances, the petitioner cannot be accused
of having violated Section 87(2) of the CGST
Act, 2017. In any event, unlike Section 29(4) of
the CGST Act, 2017, which provides for deemed
cancellation
of
registration
in
certain
circumstances, Section 87(2), read with Sections
29(1) and 29(2) of the CGST Act, 2017, does not
contemplate any deemed cancellation in cases of
amalgamation. On the contrary, Section 29 of the
CGST
Act,
2017,
in
its
makes
it
clear
that
opening
part
cancellation
is
itself,
to
be
effected by the proper officer either on his own
motion
or
upon
an
application
filed
by
the
registered person. The respondent authorities,
if aggrieved by the prospective nature of the
cancellation or believed the same to be legally
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
untenable,
they
ought
to
have
challenged
the
cancellation order in appeal. Having failed to
do
so,
the
said
order
has
attained
finality
inter se between the parties.
(32) In
the
alternative,
it
is
contended
that
without prejudice to the above, and in order to
safeguard
the
vested
right
to
refund
which
accrued to the ARTIPL and now stands vested in
the petitioner by virtue of amalgamation, it is
submitted
that
even
if
this
Court
is
not
inclined to accept the methodology adopted in
the present case, this Court may be pleased to
mould
the
relief
by
directing
the
respondent
authorities to permit the petitioner to file a
fresh refund application manually and to process
the same notionally, without raising objections
relating to non-compliance of Section 16(3) of
the
IGST
Act,
in
the
hands
of
the
petitioner,portal-related technical impediments,
or
limitation.
already
In
disbursed
such
may
an
be
event,
the
amount
directed
not
to
be
recovered, and while passing the fresh refund
order, the amount earlier paid may be adjusted.
Such an approach would be both equitable and
consistent with the purpose of the law governing
the zero-rated supplies.
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS:
(33) Learned Senior Standing Counsel Mr.Param Shah
has made the following submissions.
(34) It is a settled principle of law that a taxing
statute must be construed strictly on the basis
of what is expressly provided therein, and that
neither
any
addition
or
subtraction,
nor
any
presumption or assumption, can be made beyond
the clear language of the statute. In support of
the said submission, the respondents have placed
reliance upon the judgment of the Supreme Court
in the case of Chief Commissioner of Central
Goods
and
Service
Tax
&
Ors.
vs.
M/s.Safari
Retreats Private Limited & Ors., 2024 INSC 756,
wherein
the
Supreme
Court
has
succinctly
reiterated the settled principles governing the
interpretation of taxing statutes.
(35) Reference is made to the provisions of Sections
18 and 87 of the CGST Act, 2017 read with Rule
41 of the CGST Rules, 2017, and it is submitted
that a conjoint and harmonious reading of the
said provisions leaves no manner of doubt that,
in
the
event
of
amalgamation,
the
unutilized
Input Tax Credit of the erstwhile company can be
transferred to the transferee company only by
filing
Form
GST
ITC-02
prescribed manner.
electronically
in
the
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
(36) There exists no statutory provision enabling the
transferee company to seek encashment of such
unutilized ITC in any form, including by way of
a refund application. Furthermore, there is also
no provision permitting partial transfer of the
unutilized ITC of the transferor company in the
case of amalgamation. In the present case, the
ARTIPL, by acting contrary to law and on its own
volition, filed Form ITC-02 for only a part of
the ITC and thereafter proceeded to file refund
applications
for
the
remaining
amount,
which
course of action is wholly impermissible in law.
(37) It
is
further
submitted
ARTIPL,
despite
having
that
ceased
the
to
erstwhile
exist
with
effect from 22.09.2023, addressed an intimation
letter dated 10.10.2023 stating that it was in
the process of undertaking all compliance under
the GST Law. This clearly demonstrates that it
was the obligation of the transferor company to
apply for cancellation of its GST registration
on
account
of amalgamation.
However,
no
such
application was ever made, and the said company
continued to file returns until 06.02.2025.
(38) Even after the lapse of more than one year from
the
effective
date
of
amalgamation,
no
application for cancellation of GST registration
was filed, which could very well have been done
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
by the officers of the Transferee Company i.e.
the petitioner. The respondent Department was,
therefore,
notice
constrained
dated
culminated
in
to issue
07.11.2024,
the
a show
which
cancellation
cause
ultimately
order
dated
29.11.2024.
(39) From
the
conduct
of
the
petitioner,
it
is
manifest that the application for cancellation
of registration was deliberately not filed with
a mala fide intention to encash the unutilized
ITC
by
way
of
refund
applications,
which
is
otherwise impermissible under the statute. The
petitioner, therefore, cannot be permitted to
take advantage of its own wrong.
ANALYSIS AND OPINION
The facts established from the pleadings
(40) The following events emerge from the facts and
pleadings:
a)
The
order
of
amalgamation
other
the
NCLT
approving
of
the
erstwhile
entities
into
ATIL
vide
of
NCLT
order
scheme
ARTIPL
and
order
of
two
dated
10.08.2023.
b)
Certified
copy
issued
on
28.08.2023.
c)
The RoC Certification
22.09.2023.
of
the
ATIL
is
dated
C/SCA/11025/2025
d)
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
ATIL filed FORM GST REG-1 under Rule 8 of the
CGST Rules, 2017 on 10.05.2023 in anticipation
of the NCLT order.
e)
It
was
registered
w.e.f
certificate issued on
f)
25.5.2023
vide
21.12.2025.
Intimation by ARTIPL of amalgamation on 10.10.23
to authorized officer.
g)
Show-cause
notice
for
cancellation
of
registration of the ARTIPL issued on 07.11.2024.
h)
The
ARTIPL
registration
cancelled
w.e.f
29.11.2024 from the said date.
[
i)
Amount of Rs.192.88 Cr. was claimed through FORM
GST
ITC-02
by
the
ARTIPL
on
20.10.2023
of
unutilized ITC.
j)
Refund Sanctioned Order FORM GST RFD-06 passed
on 28.02.2024 of Rs.2,56,75,437/- of granting
the ITC in favour of the ARTIPL.
[[
k)
Order dated 08.01.2025 passed in Appeal under
Section 107(11) of the CGST Act, 2017 cancelling
the refund sanction order dated 28.02.2024.
ISSUE OF REGISTRATION OF THE PETITIONER-ATIL AND
ERSTWHILE ARTIPL ON AMALGAMATION :
(41) Keeping in mind the aforementioned dates, registration / cancellation of respective ARTIPL and
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
AITL respectively and in order to appreciate the
rival contentions, it will be necessary to have
a closer look to the statutory provisions of
CGST ACT, 2017 and Rules, which are as below:
“SECTION 22 : Persons liable for registration
(1) Every supplier shall be liable to be registered
under this Act in the State or Union territory, other
than special category States, from where he makes a
taxable supply of goods or services or both, if his
aggregate turnover in a financial year exceeds twenty
lakh rupees:
Provided that where such person makes taxable supplies
of goods or services or both from any of the special
category States, he shall be liable to be registered
if his aggregate turnover in a financial year exceeds
ten lakh rupees.
[PROVIDED FURTHER that the Government may, at the
request of a special category State and on the
recommendations of the Council, enhance the aggregate
turnover referred to in the first proviso from ten
lakh rupees to such amount, not exceeding twenty lakh
rupees and subject to such conditions and limitations,
as may be so notified:]
[PROVIDED FURTHER that the Government may, at the
request of a State and on the recommendations of the
Council, enhance the aggregate turnover from twenty
lakh rupees to such amount not exceeding forty lakh
rupees in case of supplier who is engaged exclusively
in the supply of goods, subject to such conditions and
limitations, as may be notified.
Explanation : For the purposes of this sub-section, a
person shall be considered to be engaged exclusively
in the supply of goods even if he is engaged in exempt
supply of services provided by way of extending
deposits,
loans
or
advances
insofar
as
the
consideration is represented by way of interest or
discount.]
(2) Every person who, on the day immediately preceding
the appointed day, is registered or holds a licence
under an existing law, shall be liable to be
C/SCA/11025/2025
registered under
appointed day.
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
this
Act
with
effect
from
the
(3) Where a business carried on by a taxable person
registered under this Act is transferred, whether on
account of succession or otherwise, to another person
as a going concern, the transferee or the successor,
as the case may be, shall be liable to be registered
with effect from the date of such transfer or
succession.
(4) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-sections
(1) and (3), in a case of transfer pursuant to
sanction
of
a
scheme
or
an
arrangement
for
amalgamation or, as the case may be, demerger of two
or more companies pursuant to an order of a High
Court, Tribunal or otherwise, the transferee shall be
liable to be registered, with effect from the date on
which the Registrar of Companies issues a certificate
of incorporation giving effect to such order of the
High Court or Tribunal.
Explanation : For the purposes of this section, (i) the expression "aggregate turnover" shall include
all supplies made by the taxable person, whether on
his own account or made on behalf of all his
principals;
(ii) the supply of goods, after completion of jobwork,
by a registered jobworker shall be treated as the
supply of goods by the principal referred to in
section 143, and the value of such goods shall not be
included in the aggregate turnover of the registered
jobworker;
(iii) the expression "special category States" shall
mean the States as specified in sub-clause (g) of
clause (4) of article 279A of the Constitution [except
the State of Jammu and Kashmir] [and States of
Arunachal Pradesh, Assam, Himachal Pradesh, Meghalaya,
Sikkim and Uttarakhand].
SECTION 25 : Procedure for registration
(1) Every person who is liable to be registered under
section 22 or section 24 shall apply for registration
in every such State or Union territory in which he is
so liable within thirty days from the date on which he
becomes liable to registration, in such manner and
subject to such conditions as may be prescribed:
xxx xxx xxx
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
(8) Where a person who is liable to be registered under
this Act fails to obtain registration, the proper officer
may, without prejudice to any action which may be taken
under this Act or under any other law for the time being
in force, proceed to register such person in such manner
as may be prescribed.”
(42) As per the provisions of Section 22(1) of the
CGST Act, 2017, every supplier is liable to be
registered
under
the
Act.
Sub-section
(4)
to
Section 22 of the CGST Act, 2017 starts with a
non-obstante clause and mandates that “in a case
of transfer pursuant to sanction of a scheme or
an arrangement for amalgamation or, as the case
may
be,
demerger
of
two
or
more
companies
pursuant to an order of a High Court, Tribunal
or otherwise, the transferee shall be liable to
be
registered,
which
the
with
effect
Registrar
of
from
the
Companies
date
on
issues
a
certificate of incorporation giving effect to
such order of the High Court or Tribunal.” Thus,
as per Section 22(4) of the CGST Act, 2017, the
petitioner-ATIL was required to register itself
from
the
date
on
certificate
of
22.09.2023,
within
which
the
RoC
incorporation,
a
period
of
issues
which
is
days
as
prescribed under Section 25 of the CGST Act,
2017.
ATIL
“liable
to
will
be
fall
within
registered”
provisions.
the
found
in
expression
both
the
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
(43) However,
it
appears
application
for
that
getting
the
ATIL
itself
filed
the
registered
on
10.05.2023, prior to the order dated 10.08.2023
in
anticipation,
registered
and
thereafter
retrospectively
25.05.2023
by
issuing
it
w.e.f.
the
was
from
certificate
on
21.12.2025, whereas the RoC certificate is dated
22.09.2023. Thus, the filing of the application
by
the
ATIL
before
acquiring
its
statutory
identity itself was de hors the provision of
Section 25 of the CGST Act, 2017, since the ATIL
became liable to be registered only after the
order
passed
by
the
NCLT
and
issuance
of
certificate by the RoC.
(44) Sub-section (8) to Section 25 of the CGST Act,
2017 confers suo motu powers to the authorized
officer
to
register
such
person,
who
becomes
liable to be registered under the Act, but fails
to do so, without prejudice to any action which
may be taken under the Act. The consequence of
not registering is prescribed in Section 122(xi)
of
the
CGST
Act,
2017,
which
is
payment
of
penalty of ten thousand.
(45) Now, for examining the facet of cancellation of
transferor
-
ARTIPL,
the
relevant
provisions
which are to be kept in mind are Section 29 of
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
the CGST Act, 2017, and Rules 20 and 22 of the
CGST Rules, 2017. The same are as under:
“SECTION
:
registration :
Cancellation
"or
suspension"
of
(1) The proper officer may, either on his own motion
or on an application filed by the registered person or
by his legal heirs, in case of death of such person,
cancel the registration, in such manner and within
such period as may be prescribed, having regard to the
circumstances where,
(a) the business has been discontinued, transferred
fully
for
any
reason
including
death
of
the
proprietor, amalgamated with other legal entity,
demerged or otherwise disposed of; or
(b) there is any change in the constitution of the
business; or
(c) the taxable person, other than the person
registered under sub-section (3) of section 25, is no
longer liable to be registered under section 22 or
section 24.
"Provided that during pendency of the proceedings
relating to cancellation of registration filed by the
registered person, the registration may be suspended
for such period and in such manner as may be
prescribed.";
(2) The proper officer may cancel the registration of
a person from such date, including any retrospective
date, as he may deem fit, where,
(a)
a
registered
person
has
contravened
such
provisions of the Act or the rules made thereunder as
may be prescribed; or
(b) a person paying tax under section 10 has not
furnished returns for three consecutive tax periods;
or
(c) any registered person, other than a person
specified in clause (b), has not furnished returns for
a continuous period of six months; or
(d) any person who has taken voluntary registration
under sub-section (3) of section 25 has not commenced
C/SCA/11025/2025
business
within
registration; or
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
six
months
from
the
date
of
(e) registration has been obtained by means of fraud,
wilful misstatement or suppression of facts:
Provided that the proper officer shall not cancel the
registration without giving the person an opportunity
of being heard.
"Provided
further
that
during
pendency
of
the
proceedings relating to cancellation of registration,
the proper officer may suspend the registration for
such period and in such manner as may be prescribed.".
(3) The cancellation of registration under this
section shall not affect the liability of the person
to pay tax and other dues under this Act or to
discharge any obligation under this Act or the rules
made thereunder for any period prior to the date of
cancellation whether or not such tax and other dues
are
determined
before
or
after
the
date
of
cancellation.
(4) The cancellation of registration under the State
Goods and Services Tax Act or the Union Territory
Goods and Services Tax Act, as the case may be, shall
be deemed to be a cancellation of registration under
this Act.
RULE 20 : Application for cancellation of registration
A registered person, other than a person to whom a
registration has been granted under rule 12 or a
person to whom a Unique Identity Number has been
granted under rule 17, seeking cancellation of his
registration under sub-section (1) of section 29 shall
electronically submit an application in FORM GST REG16, including therein the details of inputs held in
stock or inputs contained in semi-finished or finished
goods held in stock and of capital goods held in stock
on
the
date
from
which
the
cancellation
of
registration is sought, liability thereon, the details
of the payment, if any, made against such liability
and may furnish, along with the application, relevant
documents in support thereof, at the common portal
within a period of thirty days of the occurrence of
the event warranting the cancellation, either directly
or through a Facilitation Centre notified by the
Commissioner:
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
RULE 22 : Cancellation of registration
(1) Where the proper officer has reasons to believe
that the registration of a person is liable to be
cancelled under section 29, he shall issue a notice to
such person in FORM GST REG-17, requiring him to show
cause, within a period of seven working days from the
date of the service of such notice, as to why his
registration shall not be cancelled.”
(46) Section 29 of the CGST Act, 2017 empowers the
proper officer to cancel the registration on his
own motion or on an application filed by the
registered person for various reasons prescribed
therein. One of the reason assigned in Clause(a)
of sub-section (1) to Section 20 of the CGST
Act, 2017 is the discontinuation of business due
to
amalgamation,
which
is
applicable
in
the
instant case. In this context, Rule 20 of the
CGST
Rules,
requires
filing
of
an
application for cancellation of registration in
FORM GST REG-16 “within a period of thirty days
of the occurrence of the event warranting the
cancellation”.
Instructions
FORM-GST
for
filing
Cancellation.
The
provides
“The
that
REG-16
of
Application
instruction
new
contains
entity
in
for
explicitly
which
the
applicant proposes to amalgamate itself shall
register
with
the
tax
authority
before
submission of the application for cancellation.
This application shall be made only after the
new
entity
will
only
is registered”. Thus,
operate
on
the
FORM
REG-16
eventuality
of
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
registration of the new entity i.e. the ATIL.
Thus, if the provisions of Section 29(1)(a) of
the CGST Act, 2017 are read with Rule 20 of the
CGST
Rules,
2017,
the
event
warranting
the
cancellation in the instant case would be the
amalgamation of transferor-ARTIPL and ATIL, vide
order of NCLT dated 10.08.2023, and as per the
Scheme the effective date is 22.09.2023, which
is the filing of the certified copy of the order
of NCLT before the RoC. Thus, the ARTIPL was
supposed to file the GST REG-16 for cancellation
of its registration within a period of 30 days
in FORM GST-REG-16 from 22.09.2023, as per the
provision of Section 29(1) of the CGST Act, 2017
read with Rule 20 of the CGST Rules, 2017, after
the registration of ATIL, which it did choose to
do so, but chose to apply for refund of part of
amount
of
unutilized
apprehension
that
its
authorized
officer
ITC,
probably
communication
informing
to
about
on
the
the
amalgamation vide communication dated 10.10.2023
would
satisfy
the
requirements
of
statutory
provision of Section 29 of the CGST Act, 2017
read with Rule 20 of the CGST Act, 2017.
(47) Thereafter, a show cause notice dated 07.11.2024
was issued for cancellation of registration to
ARTIPL
by
the
Superintendent
by
citing
the
provision of Section 29(1)(a) of the CGST Act,
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
2017. From the contents of FORM GST REG-19, it
appears
that
in
response
to
the
show
cause
notice, the erstwhile - ATIPL, vide letter dated
19.11.2024,
informed
the
specifically
that
ARTIPL
the
authority
has
stating
amalgamated
into the ATIL and it would like to contest the
proposed cancellation, and sought 30 days time
and the refund application was under process.
Thereafter,
it
appears
that
after
affording
personal hearing to the representatives of the
petitioner, the Superintendent passed an order
FORM GST REG-19 dated 29.11.2024, cancelling the
registration of the ARTIPL, making it effective
from the even date. Thus, the GST registration
of ARTIPL was cancelled w.e.f. 29.11.2024.
(48) The
petitioner
has
attempted
to
take
shelter
under the expression used in Section 29(1) of
the CGST Act, 2017 assigning power to proper
officer to take suo motu action of cancellation
of
registration
intimated
the
of
the
ARTIPL
since
Jurisdictional
it
Officer
had
vide
communication dated 10.10.2023 about the details
of
amalgamation
and
the
effective
date
of
22.09.2023. It is pertinent to note that in this
communication
the
transferor
-
ARTIPL
has
categorically made the following statement:
“Kindly
consider
this
letter
as
an
intimation
regarding the NCLT sanctioned amalgamation and to
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
inform your goodselves that the transferor company
ARTIPL having GSTIN 24AAACA5584C1Z1 falling under the
jurisdiction of your goodselves is in the process of
undertaking and ensuring the fulfillment of all
relevant compliances and procedures applicable under
GST laws accordingly.”
Thus,
the
transferor-ARTIPL
had
given
an
assurance to the Jurisdictional Officer that it
is in the process of undertaking and ensuring
the
fulfillment of all relevant compliance and
procedures applicable under the GST laws, which
indubitably include the compliance of statutory
provisions
relating
to
cancellation
of
registration. In wake of the specific assurance
given by the ARTIPL, the Jurisdictional Officer
was not required to exercise his power suo motu.
However, if such officer had the knowledge or
was aware of the details of amalgamation, its
effective date, the date of certificate of the
RoC issued in the name of new entity, he / she
on having knowledge of such details was required
to form an opinion relating to cancellation of
registration under Rule 22 of the CGST Rules,
2017. Rule 22 starts with the sentence “Where
the proper officer has reasons to believe that
the registration of a person is liable to be
cancelled”. Thus, if the authorized officer is
having
the
requisite
information
relating
to
amalgamation, which he had in the instant case,
such information can supply/satisfy the reasons
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
qualifying him to believe that the registration
is liable to be cancelled, hence he / she is
required to issue notice to such person in FORM
GST REG-17 calling upon to show cause about the
cancellation of registration within seven days.
(49) It is also contended on behalf of the petitioner
that it was always open for the Jurisdictional
Officer
to
cancel
retrospectively,
the
as
registration
per
the
of ARTIPL
provisions
of
Section 29(2) of the CGST Act, 2017 i.e. from
the effective date of 22.09.2023, however, since
the registration is cancelled prospectively from
29.11.2024, the ARTIPL can be said to be in
existence. We do not subscribe to the submission
of retrospective cancellation of the ARTIPL on
reading of the provision of sub-section (2) of
Section 29 of the CGST Act, 2017. Sub-section
(2)
thereof
cancel
the
empowers
the
registration
proper
officer
from
such
to
date,
including any retrospective date as he may deem
fit
in
clauses
those
(a)
circumstances
to
(e)
such
as
as mentioned
from
contravention
of
provisions of the Act, commission of fraud etc,
since the sub-section (2) of Section 29 of the
CGST Act, 2017 ends with the word “where” which
prescribe the eventuality of clauses
prescribed
from (a) to (e), which is not the case of the
petitioner.
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
(50) At this stage, it would be apposite to refer to
Section 87 of the CGST Act, 2017, which reads
thus:
“SECTION 87 : Liability in case of amalgamation or
merger of companies :
(1) When two or more companies are amalgamated or
merged in pursuance of an order of court or of
Tribunal or otherwise and the order is to take effect
from a date earlier to the date of the order and any
two or more of such companies have supplied or
received any goods or services or both to or from each
other during the period commencing on the date from
which the order takes effect till the date of the
order, then such transactions of supply and receipt
shall be included in the turnover of supply or receipt
of the respective companies and they shall be liable
to pay tax accordingly.
(2) Notwithstanding anything contained in the said
order, for the purposes of this Act, the said two or
more companies shall be treated as distinct companies
for the period up to the date of the said order and
the registration certificates of the said companies
shall be cancelled with effect from the date of the
said order.”
(51) Section 87 of the CGST Act, 2017 prescribes the
liability in case of amalgamation or merger of
companies. For the purpose of registration of
effect of amalgamation on the registration of
the ARTIPL, the provision of sub-section (2) to
section
of
the
CGST
Act,
bears
relevance. Sub-section (2) to section 87 of the
CGST Act, 2017 begins with non-obstante clause
and
also
has
an
added
expression
“for
the
purpose of this Act”. Non-obstante clause has
been inserted with reference to the “said order”
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
which is in context with sub-section (1), which
again is in context with the order passed by the
Court or Tribunal sanctioning amalgamation or
merger. Sub-section(2) directs that two or more
companies
are
to
be
treated
as
“distinct
companies” for the period up to the date of the
said order and the registration certificates of
the
said
companies
shall
be
cancelled
with
effect from “the date of the said order”. Thus,
the statutory provision of sub-section (2) to
Section 87 of the CGST Act, 2017 overrides the
intention of treating two or more companies as
distinct companies for the purpose of the Act,
and
the
registration
certificate
of
such
companies is required to be cancelled from the
“date
of
the
order”
passed
by
the
Court
or
Tribunal sanctioning amalgamation or merger of
the companies.
(52) In the present case, the registration of ARTIPL
has been cancelled on 29.11.2024, which again
does not reconcile with the provision of Section
87(2) of the CGST Act, 2017. In the instant
case, the NCLT dissolved ‘three’ entities (1)
Alstom Rail Transportation India Pvt. Ltd., (2)
Alstom Manufacturing India Pvt. Ltd., and (3)
Alstom System India Pvt. Ltd. and amalgamated
into the petitioner - ATIL. Thus, the identity
of transferor - ARTIPL as distinct company will
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
exist till the date of order of NCLT, and its
registration is required to be cancelled with
effect
from
the
date
of
order
of
NCLT
i.e.
10.08.2023.
ILLEGALITY/IRREGULARITY NOTICED FROM THE FACTS OF
REGISTRATION AND CANCELLATION OF REGISTRATION OF
ATIL & ARTIPL RESPECTIVELY
a)
Non-filing of application by erstwhile ARTIPL
seeking cancellation of its registration despite
having lost its identity w.e.f. 10.08.2023 under
Rule 20 of the CGST Rules, 2017 within a period
of 30 days from the date of passing of the NCLT
order or receipt of certified copy or from the
issuance of certificate by RoC.
b)
Cancellation of registration on 29.11.2024 of
ARTIPL before the registration of ATIL. (vide
order
dated
21.12.2025
w.e.f
25.05.2023)
in
violation of instructions in FORM REG-16.
c)
Action of the Jurisdictional Officer in ignoring
the communication dated 10.10.2023 written by
erstwhile ARTIPL, and not initiating proceedings
under Rule 22 of the CGST Rules, 2017.
d)
Issuance
07.11.2024
of
to
the
show
ARTIPL
cause
after
one
notice
year
dated
by
the
Jurisdictional Officer.
e)
Cancellation of registration of erstwhile ARTIPL
on and w.e.f. 29.11.2024, instead of date of
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
order of NCLT or from the date of issuance of
certificate by RoC.
f)
Filing of FORM GST-REG-1 under Rule 8(5) of the
CGST
Rules,
registration
on
by
transferee-ATIL
10.05.2023
before
for
the
its
order
passed by NCLT on 10.08.2023, and issuance of
its incorporation by RoC on 22.09.2023 resulting
into violation of provisions of Section 25.
[
g)
Failure to take steps for registration of ATIL
as
per
the
provision
of
sub-section
(8)
of
section 25 of the CGST Act, 2017 despite having
known
the
status
of
ATIL
and
ARTIPL
vide
communication dated 10.10.2023. No steps taken
under Section 122(xi) of the CGST Act, 2017.
h)
Conferral of the GST Registration of transfereeATIL
retrospectively
w.e.f.
25.05.2023
vide
certificate issued on 21.12.2025 in violation of
Section
22(4)
of
the
CGST
Act,
on
an
application filed before the effective date of
22.09.2023.
i)
Thus, on an overall appreciation of facts, it is
evident that both the transferor - ARTIPL and
transferee - ATIL have violated the statutory
provisions.
The
provisions
registration
of
the
ATIL
and
registration
by
the
erstwhile
regulating
cancellation
-
ARTIPL
of
after
amalgamation, are blatantly disregarded, by both
C/SCA/11025/2025
the
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
entities
officers,
and
also
by
the
respondent
and
rather
it
is
noticed
the
Jurisdictional
Officer
has
facilitated
the
irregularity. If the aforementioned dates are
closely analyzed both ARTIL and ATIL would be
existing and their entities will be recognized
after the order passed by the NCLT and issuance
of RoC despite failure to act as per the Act and
Rules. The GST registration of the transferee ATIL is from 25.05.2023, (before the order of
NCLT),
and
the
cancellation
of
transferor
-
ARTIPL is from 29.11.2024. Thus, ARTIPL, though
lost
its
identity
22.09.2023
after
continued
the
to
effective
retain
date
it
till
29.11.2024, simultaneously with the existence of
identity of ATIL w.e.f. 25.05.2023, and claimed
refund of unutilized ITC lying in the electronic
ledger. It is true that there is no provision in
the GST Act which enables the cancellation of
the
registration
by
deeming
same
is
on
the
reliant
fiction,
statutory
but
the
provisions,
which are required to be followed scrupulously,
more particularly in case of amalgamation. The
respective entities cannot be allowed to carry
out
business
effective
date,
function
except
simultaneously
after
to
it
the
extent
is
permissible within the contours governing the
relevant provisions of the Act and Rules.
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
ASPECT OF CLAIM OF UNUTILIZED ITC LYING IN ECL
(53) In
the
instant
case,
the
relevant
provisions
governing the transfer and refund of the ITC are
Sections 54 and 18 of the CGST Act, 2017 and
Rule 41 of the CGST Rules, 2017, which are as
follows:
“SECTION 54 : Refund of tax
(1) Any person claiming refund of any tax and
interest, if any, paid on such tax or any other amount
paid by him, may make an application before the expiry
of two years from the relevant date in such form and
manner as may be prescribed:
Provided that a registered person, claiming refund of
any balance in the electronic cash ledger in
accordance with the provisions of sub-section (6) of
section 49, may claim such refund in the return
furnished under section 39 in such manner as may be
prescribed.
xxx xxx xxx
(3) Subject to the provisions of sub-section (10), a
registered person may claim refund of any unutilised
input tax credit at the end of any tax period:
Provided that no refund of unutilised input tax credit
shall be allowed in cases other than
(i) zero rated supplies made without payment of tax;
(ii) where the credit has accumulated on account of
rate of tax on inputs being higher than the rate of
tax on output supplies (other than nil rated or fully
exempt supplies), except supplies of goods or services
or both as may be notified by the Government on the
recommendations of the Council:
Provided further that no refund of unutilised input
tax credit shall be allowed in cases where the goods
exported out of India are subjected to export duty:
Provided also that no refund of input tax credit shall
be allowed, if the supplier of goods or services or
both avails of drawback in respect of central tax or
claims refund of the integrated tax paid on such
supplies.
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
SECTION 18 : Availability
circumstances :
of
credit
in
special
(1) Subject to such conditions and restrictions as may
be prescribed
(a) a person who has applied for registration under
this Act within thirty days from the date on which he
becomes liable to registration and has been granted
such registration shall be entitled to take credit of
input tax in respect of inputs held in stock and
inputs contained in semi-finished or finished goods
held in stock on the day immediately preceding the
date from which he becomes liable to pay tax under the
provisions of this Act;
(b) a person who takes registration under sub-section
(3) of section 25 shall be entitled to take credit of
input tax in respect of inputs held in stock and
inputs contained in semi-finished or finished goods
held in stock on the day immediately preceding the
date of grant of registration;
(c) where any registered person ceases to pay tax
under section 10, he shall be entitled to take credit
of input tax in respect of inputs held in stock,
inputs contained in semi-finished or finished goods
held in stock and on capital goods on the day
immediately preceding the date from which he becomes
liable to pay tax under section 9:
Provided that the credit on capital goods shall be
reduced
by
such
percentage
points
as
may
be
prescribed;
(d) where an exempt supply of goods or services or
both by a registered person becomes a taxable supply,
such person shall be entitled to take credit of input
tax in respect of inputs held in stock and inputs
contained in semi-finished or finished goods held in
stock relatable to such exempt supply and on capital
goods exclusively used for such exempt supply on the
day immediately preceding the date from which such
supply becomes taxable:
Provided that the credit on capital goods shall be
reduced
by
such
percentage
points
as
may
be
prescribed.
(2) A registered person shall not be entitled to take
input tax credit under sub-section (1) in respect of
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
any supply of goods or services or both to him after
the expiry of one year from the date of issue of tax
invoice relating to such supply.
(3) Where there is a change in the constitution of a
registered
person
on
account
of
sale,
merger,
demerger, amalgamation, lease or transfer of the
business with the specific provisions for transfer of
liabilities, the said registered person shall be
allowed to transfer the input tax credit which remains
unutilised in his electronic credit ledger to such
sold,
merged,
demerged,
amalgamated,
leased
or
transferred business in such manner as may be
prescribed.
RULE 41 : Transfer of credit on sale,
amalgamation, lease or transfer of a business
merger,
(1) A registered person shall, in the event of sale,
merger, de-merger, amalgamation, lease or transfer or
change in the ownership of business for any reason,
furnish the details of sale, merger, de-merger,
amalgamation, lease or transfer of business, in FORM
GST ITC-02, electronically on the common portal along
with a request for transfer of unutilized input tax
credit lying in his electronic credit ledger to the
transferee:
Provided that in the case of demerger, the input tax
credit shall be apportioned in the ratio of the value
of assets of the new units as specified in the
demerger scheme.
(2) The transferor shall also submit a copy of a
certificate
issued
by
a
practicing
chartered
accountant or cost accountant certifying that the
sale, merger, de-merger, amalgamation, lease or
transfer of business has been done with a specific
provision for the transfer of liabilities.
(3) The transferee shall, on the common portal, accept
the details so furnished by the transferor and, upon
such acceptance, the un-utilized credit specified in
FORM GST ITC-02 shall be credited to his electronic
credit ledger.
(4) The inputs and capital goods so transferred shall
be duly accounted for by the transferee in his books
of account.”
C/SCA/11025/2025
(54) The
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
petitioner
-
ATIL
is
claiming
refund
of
unutilized tax credit under Section 54(3) of the
CGST Act, 2017 for making exports falling under
zero rated supplies by erstwhile ARTIPL. As per
the provision of Section 18(3) of the CGST Act,
2017 read with Rule 41 of the CGST Rules, 2017,
the
erstwhile
ARTIPL
in
FORM
GST
ITC-02
on
20.10.2023 applied for transfer of unutilized
ITC to the tune of Rs.192,87,53,211/- out of
Rs.242,02,00,000/keeping
the
remainder
Rs.49,14,00,000/Ledger
to
of
in
erstwhile
petitioner
of
the
the
Electronic
ARTIPL.
ATIL,
amount
of
Credit
Thereafter,
the
ARTIPL filed refund application under Section
54(3)
of
the
CGST
Rs.2,56,75,437/-
Act,
on
04.01.2024
amounting
to
under
the
category of “ITC accumulated due to Exports of
Goods / Services-without payment of Tax” for a
period of 01.04.2023 to 30.04.2023, which was
allowed by the competent authority vide order
dated
28.02.2024,
which
was
subsequently
set
aside by the impugned order.
(55) With reference to the provision of Section 54(3)
of the CGST Act, 2017, assertion of the Supreme
Court in the case of Union of India vs. VKC
Footsteps
(India)
(P)
Ltd.,
(2022)
S.C.C.
603 : (2021) 93 GSTR 160, needs to be referred,
which reads thus:
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
“99. We must be cognizant of the fact that no
constitutional right is being asserted to claim a
refund, as there cannot be. Refund is a matter of a
statutory prescription. Parliament was within its
legislative authority in determining whether refunds
should be allowed of unutilised ITC tracing its origin
both to input goods and input services or, as it has
legislated,
input
goods
alone.
By
its
clear
stipulation that a refund would be admissible only
where the unutilised ITC has accumulated on account of
the rate of tax on inputs being higher than the rate
of tax on output supplies, Parliament has confined the
refund in the manner which we have described above.
While recognising an entitlement to refund, it is open
to the legislature to define the circumstances in
which a refund can be claimed. The proviso to Section
54(3) is not a condition of eligibility (as the
assessees' the counsel submitted) but a restriction
which must govern the grant of refund under Section
54(3). We, therefore, accept the submission which has
been urged by Mr N. Venkataraman, learned ASG.”
(56) Thus, the Supreme Court has held that the claim
of refund cannot be asserted as a constitutional
right, since refund is a statutory prescription.
We may at this stage refer that FORM GST-ITC-02
under Rule 41(1) of the CGST Rules, 2017 enables
the transfer of unutilized ITC in the case of
amalgamation. The condition precedent is that
the entities being acquired or transferred must
have
ledger
ITC available
from
the
combination,
in
date
lease,
its
electronic
of
merger,
or
transfer.
credit
acquisition,
Both
the
transferee and the transferor must be registered
under the GST. All pending transactions related
to the merger must be accepted, rejected, or
modified, and all liabilities of transferor’s
filed
returns
must
be
paid.
The
transfer
of
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
business
must
liabilities,
litigation,
must
be
include
the
transfer
of
including
any
unpaid
taxes,
recovery
cases.
This
transfer
or
accompanied
by
a
Chartered
or
Cost
Accountant’s certificate.
(57) Though, there is no time limit prescribed for
filing FORM GST-02, however, keeping in mind the
above
statutory
time
limits,
it
is
mandatory
that the same are observed and followed. As held
by us there is violation and disregard to the
statutory
provisions.
All
the
formalities
of
transfer of unutilized ITC are required to be
completed within the time specified in order to
avoid further complications on amalgamations of
the entities. In the instant case, the action of
registration and cancellation of registration is
at odds on with the settled legal precedent that
the amalgamating entity ceases to exist upon the
approved scheme of amalgamation.
(58) Pertinently, FORM ITC-02 requires to mention the
GSTIN
of
both
the
transferor-company
transferee-company.
In
Transferor
Company
should
registration
on
date
the
other
words,
have
of
and
a
the
valid
transfer
of
unutilized Input Tax Credit. The petitioner-ATIL
has
obtained
Registration
No.24AAJCA1167G1ZX
(for Gujarat) on 21.12.2025 w.e.f. 25.05.2023.
C/SCA/11025/2025
The
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
registration
of
ARTIPL
was
cancelled
on
29.11.2024. FORM GST ITC-2 was transferred on
20.10.2023 by the ARTIPL for unutilized credit.
All pending liabilities, interests etc., were
required
to
be
addressed
and
settled
by
the
transferor-ARTIPL during the transition period.
(59) The Supreme Court in the case of Safari Retreats
Private Limited & Ors. (supra) has prescribed
the parameters in interpretation of the taxing
statutes. They are as below:
“RULES REGARDING THE INTERPRETATION OF TAXING STATUTES
25. Regarding the interpretation of taxation statutes,
the parties have relied on several decisions. The law
laid down on this aspect is fairly well-settled. The
principles
governing
the
interpretation
of
the
taxation statutes can be summarised as follows:
a. A taxing statute must be read as it is with no
additions and no subtractions on the grounds of
legislative intendment or otherwise;
b. If the language of a taxing provision is plain, the
consequence of giving effect to it may lead to some
absurd result is not a factor to be considered when
interpreting the provisions. It is for the legislature
to step in and remove the absurdity;
c. While dealing with a taxing provision, the
principle of strict interpretation should be applied;
d. If two interpretations of a statutory provision are
possible, the Court ordinarily would interpret the
provision in favour of a taxpayer and against the
revenue;
e. In interpreting a taxing statute,
considerations are entirely out of place;
equitable
f. A taxing provision cannot be interpreted on any
presumption or assumption;
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
g. A taxing statute has to be interpreted in the light
of what is clearly expressed. The Court cannot imply
anything which is not expressed. Moreover, the Court
cannot import provisions in the statute to supply any
deficiency;
h. There is nothing unjust in the taxpayer escaping if
the letter of the law fails to catch him on account of
the legislatures failure to express itself clearly;
i. If literal interpretation is manifestly unjust,
which
produces
a
result
not
intended
by
the
legislature, only in such a case can the Court modify
the language;
j. Equity and taxation are strangers. But if
construction results in equity rather than injustice,
such construction should be preferred;
k. It is not a function of the Court in the fiscal
arena to compel the Parliament to go further and do
more;
l. When a word used in a taxing statute is to be
construed and has not been specifically defined, it
should not be interpreted in accordance with its
definition in another statute that does not deal with
a cognate subject. It should be understood in its
commercial sense. Unless defined in the statute
itself, the words and expressions in a taxing statute
have to be construed in the sense in which the persons
dealing with them understand, that is, as per the
trade understanding, commercial and technical practice
and usage.”
(60) The principles enunciated in paragraph Nos.‘a’,
‘c’, ‘e’, ‘f’ and ‘g’ will apply in the present
case. The Apex Court has cautioned that while
dealing with a taxing provision, the principle
of strict interpretation should be applied; and
in
interpreting
a
taxing
statute,
considerations
are
entirely
out
Further,
held
that
a
taxing
on
any
cannot
it
be
is
interpreted
equitable
of
place.
provision
presumption
or
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
assumption;
and
a
taxing
statute
has
to
interpreted
in
the
light
of
is
clearly
what
be
expressed, and the Court cannot imply anything
which is not expressed, and finally,
cannot
import
provisions
in
the
the Court
statute
to
supply any deficiency.
(61) In the instant case, the petitioner-ATIL, which
is
a
new
identity
wants
to
claim
refund
of
remainder / part of unutilized tax credit under
Section 54(3) of the CGST Act, 2017 for making
exports
falling
under
erstwhile ARTIPL.
the
erstwhile
20.10.2023
zero
rated
supplies
by
It is pertinent to note that
ARTIPL
in
transferred
FORM
the
ITC
GST
ITC-02
in part
on
while
keeping remainder of unutilized ITC. Thereafter,
erstwhile ARTIPL filed refund application under
Section
54(3)
04.01.2024
of
the
CGST
Act,
under
the
category
of
on
“ITC
accumulated due to Exports of Goods / Serviceswithout payment of Tax”, which was allowed by
the
competent
authority
vide
order
dated
28.02.2024. It is the case of the petitionertransferee
ATIL,
that
since
ARTIPL
has
amalgamated, the remainder of unutilized credit
of zero rated export under Section 54(3) of the
CGST Act, 2017 of goods may be allowed, as all
the rights and liability of ARTIPL are now of
ATIL.
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
(62) The fate of the writ petitions primarily hinges
on the submissions of the petitioner ATIL on
twin
grounds,
(a)
That
the
ARTIPL
was
in
existence till 29.11.2024 (date of cancellation
of
its
registration),
registered
dated
and
(b)
The
ATIL
got
w.e.f
25.03.2023
vide
21.12.2025.
It
true
that
on
entities
into
the
and
the
amalgamation
petitioner
of
–
is
three
ATIL,
the
business
certificate
adventure of ARTIPL will not seize to exist, and
it would get transferred to ATIL as per the
sanctioned
existence
scheme,
as
an
despite
entity
its
seizes
to
(ARTIPL)
exist,
but
ARTIPL while applying for transfer of unutilized
credit
FORM
GST
ITC-02
on
20.10.2023,
only
transferred it in part, and later on sought to
seek
refund.
It
is
contended
that
since
the
provision of Section 18(3) of the CGST Act, 2017
and Rule 41 of the CGST Rules, 2017, the words
“transfer” and “unutilized input tax credit”,
gives
discretion
to
electronic
credit
transferred
in
transfer
part
of
it
in
ledger,
hence
it
only
part(approx.80%)
to
the
transferee - ATIL, to be claimed as refund later
on for the remaining. We do not agree with the
interpretation
canvassed
by
the
petitioner,
since the erstwhile ARTIPL was never restricted
C/SCA/11025/2025
in
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
transferring
the
entire
unutilized
ITC
through FORM GST ITC-02. Section 18(3) of the
CGST Act, 2017 uses the line “shall be allowed
to transfer the input tax credit which remains
unutilized” and in Rule 41(1) of the CGST Rules,
2017, it is stated as “a request for transfer of
unutilized
input
tax
credit
lying
in
his
electronic credit ledger to the transferee which
remains
unutilized
ledger”,
is
fundamental
unutilized
in
his
required
to
sense,
when
ITC
relates
electronic
credit
construed
in
its
transfer
of
be
the
from
an
amalgamated
entity to new business entity. Principle ‘a’ of
the
decision
in
the
case
Safari
of
Retreats
Private Limited & Ors. (supra) does not permit
the interpretation of the statutory provision as
canvassed. It is directed by the Apex Court vide
principle ‘a’ that “A taxing statute must be
read
as
it
is
with
no
subtractions
on
the
grounds
intendment
or
additions
of
In
otherwise”.
and
no
legislative
the
cases
of
amalgamation, when a new entity is formed, and a
mechanism
is
prescribed
by
the
statute
for
transferring the unutilized ITC vide FORM GST
ITC-02
in
the
business
interest
of
the
new
entity, the intention of such enabling provision
cannot be used in a manner, which frustrates the
transfer
of
unutilized
credit
of
ITC
on
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
amalgamation as done by the transferor-ARTIPL
and as pursued by petitioner, transferee-ATIL.
(63) Principle (b) laid down by the the Apex Court in
the case of Safari Retreats Private Limited &
Ors.
decision
(supra)
directs
that
“If
the
language of a taxing provision is plain, the
consequence of giving effect to it may lead to
some
absurd
result
is
not
a
factor
to
be
considered when interpreting the provisions. It
is for the legislature to step in and remove the
absurdity;”.
Thus, the said principle squarely
applies to the facts of the instant case. The
transfer
of
partial
transferor-ARTIPL
to
absurd
After
result.
unutilized
ATIL
has
ITC
resulted
partial
by
to an
transfer
of
unutilized ITC on zero rated supply of exports
by erstwhile ARTIPL, which was accepted by ATIL;
ARTIPL applied for refund of ITC, on 04.01.2024,
after effective date of 22.09.2023. The reason
assigned
by
ARTIPL
impugned
order,
and
is
as
that
recorded
“ARTIPL
in
the
has
not
transferred the ITC of Rs.49.14 Cr. out of ITC
of Rs.242.02 Cr. to the transferee-ATIL as they
have
to
claim
the
refund
of
accumulated
ITC
which would not have been allowed to them in M/s
Altsom
Transport
assigned
statutory
by
India
ARTIPL
falls
provisions,
Ltd.”
in
since
The
line
the
reason
with
zero
the
rated
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
supply of exports was done by erstwhile ARTIPL,
and the benefits of such exports in the form of
ITC can be reaped by ATIL only in the manner as
provided
under
the
statute.
Thus,
after
the
amalgamation, erstwhile entity ARTIPL continued
filing their GSTR-3B returns and availed ITC,
albeit
its
entity
existed
till
the
effective
date as per Section 87(2) of the CGST Act, 2017.
(64) The consequences and effect of amalgamation on
the
transferor
entity
has
been
and
transferee
crystallized
Court in the case of
by
of
corporate
the
Supreme
Principal Commissioner of
Income Tax [CENTRAL]-2 vs. Mahagun Realtors (P)
Ltd., (2022) 19 S.C.C. 1, wherein the Apex Court
has held thus:
“19. Amalgamation, thus, is unlike the winding up of a
corporate entity. In the case of amalgamation, the
outer shell of the corporate entity is undoubtedly
destroyed; it ceases to exist. Yet, in every other
sense of the term, the corporate venture continues —
enfolded within the new or the existing transferee
entity. In other words, the business and the adventure
lives on but within a new corporate residence i.e. the
transferee company. It is, therefore, essential to
look beyond the mere concept of destruction of
corporate entity which brings to an end or terminates
any assessment proceedings. There are analogies in
civil law and procedure where upon amalgamation, the
cause of action or the complaint does not per se cease
— depending of course, upon the structure and
objective of enactment. Broadly, the quest of legal
systems and courts has been to locate if a successor
or representative exists in relation to the particular
cause or action, upon whom the assets might have
devolved or upon whom the liability in the event it is
adjudicated, would fall.
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
xxx
xxx xxx
31. The combined effect, therefore, of Section 394(2)
of the Companies Act, 1956, Section 2(1-A) and various
other provisions of the Income Tax Act, is that
despite amalgamation, the business, enterprise and
undertaking of the transferee or amalgamated company,
which ceases to exist, after amalgamation, is treated
as a continuing one, and any benefits, by way of carry
forward of losses (of the transferor company),
depreciation, etc., are allowed to the transferee.
Therefore, unlike a winding up, there is no end to the
enterprise, with the entity. The enterprise in the
case of amalgamation, continues.”
(65) Thus, only if the issue of registrations of
both
the
entities,
was
undertaken
as
prescribed by the statutory provisions, there
was
no
impediment
to
claim
the
refund
of
unutilized ITC by ATIL, in which the rights,
interest,
liabilities
of
ARTIPL
got
transferred.
The
and
liabilities
of
rights
ITC of ARTIPL got crystallized on the zero
rated export of goods resulting into the ITC
in
its
electronic
ledger.
Indubitably,
on
amalgamation and formation of ATIL, the only
and
exclusive
manner
to
transfer
the
unutilized ITC from its electronic ledger was
through FORM GST ITC-02, which it resorted
to, but only in substantial part, i.e, almost
80%.
The
petitioner
ATIL
was
entitled
to
claim the entire unutilized ITC of ARTIPL and
also encash it, if it was transferred
by
following the statute, since ATIL could not
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
have claimed it any manner since, it never
exported
that
the
goods.
respondent
Order-in-Appeal
Hence,
No.1,
we
do
while
dated
not
find
passing
the
08.01.2025,
has
committed any patent illegality in exercising
his power under section 107 of the CGST Act,
2017.
(66) As noticed by us, hereinabove, the action of
both
the
Officer
entities
is
and
the
Jurisdictional
pernicious
to
the
statutory
provisions,
and
this
Court
blind
to
the
illegality/irregularity
eye
cannot
turn
a
committed by them, which ultimately abetted
the
amalgamated
Doctrine of
entities.
Pari Delicto
In
view
of
the
(in equal fault),
the law aids neither party. Thus, erstwhile
ARTIPL cannot seek any benefit of refund from
the fault of the Jurisdictional Officer when
it is equally at fault. Correspondingly, at
this stage, ATIL cannot be allowed to claim
refund of unutilized credit which was lying
in the electronic ledger of ARTIPL since the
statute does not permit the course suggested
by petitioner-ATIL.
(67) Though various citations are referred to this
Court,
we
find
that
the
same
are
either
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
irrelevant or repetitive and hence, we are
dealing with few of them as under:
(68) The reliance placed in the judgement of the
Apex
Court
(supra)
since
in
by
the
provisions
the
the
case
of
petitioner
Apex
Court
was
of
exemptions
Mother
is
Superior
misconceived
dealing
with
the
contained
in
the
Kerala Building Tax Act, 1975 and the Apex
Court
in
this
regard
has
held
that
beneficiary exemptions are to be considered
in light of the object sought to be achieved
by the provision and such statute has to be
construed in accordance with such object.
(69) Reliance is also placed on the judgement of
this Court in the cases of Macrowagon Retail
Pvt. Ltd. And Anr. (supra) and VKC Footsteps
India Pvt. Ltd. (supra) as well the judgement
of the Karnataka High Court in the case of
Tonbo Imaging India Pvt. Ltd. (supra).
The
ratio laid down by the judgement in the case
of Ramji Lal Bagla and Ors. (supra) and in
the case of Hari Vishnu Kamath (supra) will
not apply in contest of the specific rules in
the
present
case,
which
prescribe
the
limitation. The Apex Court, in light of the
provisions
of
the
Representation
of
the
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
People
(Conduct
of
Elections
and
Election
Petitions) Rules, 1951. In the case of Hari
Vishnu
Kamath
(supra),
the
Apex
Court
has
held that enactment in form mandatory might
in substance to be directory and use of word
‘shall’
does
not
conclude
relevant
rule
has
been
the
matter.
interpreted
by
The
the
Apex Court with regard to rejection of the
ballet paper.
(70) Similarly in the case of Ramji Lal Bagla and
Ors.
the
(supra),
considering
the
Improvement
Act,
Apex
provisions
Court
of
while
Punjab
relating
to
Town
the
acquisition of land and while dealing with
the provisions of Section 44A of the said
Act,
has
held
that
consequences
of
statute
only
will
absence
of
resultant
non-compliance
with
the
conclusively
make
such
statute as directory notwithstanding the use
of expression “shall”. The ratio of the cited
judgements will not apply to the foregoing
issue and the statutory provisions since they
mention and use the word “shall” and also
mandate and direct to take necessary steps
within
limitation
period/time
limit
prescribed therein. Thus, none of the case
C/SCA/11025/2025
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
laws cited by the petitioner will come to its
rescue in light of the peculiar facts and the
statutory
provisions
governing
the
issue
raised in the instant writ petitions.
:: FINAL ORDER ::
(71) As
we
have
already
noticed
the
flawed
approach by the Jurisdictional Officer/s in
dealing the cancellation of registration of
the transferee - ARTIPL and the registration
of the transferor ATIL; we direct the Revenue
to
issue
instructions
appropriate
for
directions
/
following
the
scrupulously
mandate of statutory provisions while dealing
with the registrations of both the entities
in
case
of
amalgamation
in
order
to
avoid
future complication. Appropriate instructions
are
also
required
to
be
issued
for
taking
prompt steps within the time frame as soon as
the
Jurisdictional
about
the
fact
Officer
of
comes
to
know
amalgamation
of
the
entities.
(72) On
an
overall
analysis
of
the
facts,
statutory provisions and the case laws, the
writ petitions fail legal scrutiny, hence we
restrain ourselves from interfering with the
impugned
orders.
The
writ
petitions
stand
C/SCA/11025/2025
dismissed. Rule
CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 23/01/2026
discharged. No order as to
costs.
Sd/-
.
(A. S. SUPEHIA, J)
Sd/-
.
(PRANAV TRIVEDI,J)
***
Bhavesh-[PPS]* / Sr. No.1-7
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review