Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision:12th January, 2026
%
+
RFA 682/2024, CM APPL. 1271/2025 (for vacation of stay)
M/S. AGGARWAL GRANITES
S/o Sh. Ramesh Gupta
R/o B-5/333, Sector-8,
Rohini, Delhi-110085.
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Charu Bhardwaj, Advocate.
versus
MAHESH KUMAR PARWAL
S/o Late Sh. Gulab Chand Parwal
R/o B-34, First Floor, Naraina Vihar,
New Delhi-110028.
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Gaurav Kumar and Mr. Raj
Kapoor, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M E N T (oral)
RFA 682/2024
1.
Regular First Appeal under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 (hereinafter referred to as ‘CPC’) has been preferred on behalf of the
Appellant to challenge the impugned Judgment dated 06.06.2024 whereby
the decree of Possession in respect of property bearing No. E-2/A,
Mansarovar Garden, New Delhi-110015 comprising of 147 Sq. yards of
front side of ground floor and 247 Sq. Yards. of the First Floor, (hereinafter
referred to as the „Suit Property‟), has been passed against the Appellant
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
under Order 12 Rule 6 CPC, in a Civil Suit for possession.
2.
Brief facts of the Case are that the Plaintiff/Respondent filed a Suit
bearing No. CIV DJ 914/2022, titled Mahesh Kumar Parwal vs. M/s
Aggarwal Granites for Possession and Permanent Injunction in respect of
the Suit Property. According to the Plaintiff, he is the owner of property
having a Sale Deed dated 24.04.2018 executed in his favour.
3.
The Appellant/Defendant, who is the proprietor of M/s Aggarwal
Granites, was inducted as a tenant in the Suit Property by virtue of a Lease
Agreement dated 20.07.2018, for 109 months @ Rs.2,00,000/- per month
w.e.f. 01.09.2018. The rent was payable by 5th day of each calendar month.
The Appellant had also deposited Rs.4,00,000/- as security, which was
refundable at the time of vacating the property.
4.
According to the Respondent/owner, the rent was paid upto March,
2019, after which the Appellant/tenant stopped paying the rent on account of
an Agreement to Sell dated 12.12.2019 executed between the Appellant and
the Respondent herein, whereby the Plaintiff had agreed to sell the Suit
Property to the Appellant.
5.
Thereafter, a Legal Notice dated 25.11.2019 was sent to the Appellant
to claim rent/possession, which he failed to comply. Thereafter, the Suit for
Possession and Permanent Injunction was filed.
6.
The Appellant in his Written Statement/ Reply admitted that he was
inducted as a tenant vide Lease Deed dated 20.07.2018. However, he
asserted that there was an Agreement to Sell dated 12.12.2019 executed
between the Appellant and the Respondent in respect of the Suit Property
i.e. the ground floor and the first floor without terrace rights (in which the
Defendant/Appellant was already in possession as the tenant, as well as, the
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
third floor including the terrace rights) for a total consideration of
Rs.2,71,00,000/-. In terms of the Agreement to Sell, Rs.50,00,000/- were
paid by the Appellant in part performance of the Agreement vide two RTGS
transactions of Rs.25,00,000/- each dated 13.02.2019 and 14.02.2019.
7.
Further, as per the terms of the Agreement to Sell, the amount of
Rs.4,00,000/- given as a security, was also to be adjusted towards the sale
consideration. The Appellant claims that the balance sale consideration was
payable on or before 31.10.2020. The Respondent after receipt of earnest
money/part-payment and despite repeated requests never came forward to
accept the balance sale consideration and to execute the Sale Deed.
Furthermore, despite the Appellant having informed the Respondent, he
failed to present himself at the office of concerned Sub-Registrar for the
execution of the Sale Deed.
8.
However, the Respondent in order to counter the Agreement to Sell,
filed a false Complaint on 28.05.2021 consequent to which, FIR No.
20/2022 under Section 420/464/467/468/471/120B dated 06.01.2022 at
Police Station Kirti Nagar, was registered against the Appellant.
9.
The Respondent filed an Application under Order 12 Rule 6 CPC
claiming a decree of possession of Suit Property on the basis of admissions,
which was allowed vide Impugned Judgment dated 06.06.2024.
10.
Aggrieved by the Judgment, the present Appeal has been preferred on
the grounds that the factum of Agreement to Sell dated 12.12.2019 between
the parties has not been considered by the learned District Judge. By virtue
of this Agreement to Sell, the tenancy came to an end and the possession
was agreed to remain with the Appellant, till the Sale Deed was executed.
He was neither liable to pay any rent nor for eviction. The impugned Decree
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
directing him to return the possession without the return of earnest money of
Rs.50,00,000/-, is bad in law.
11.
The facts and issues in the Suit, were intermingled and intertwined
with the rights of the Appellant arising from the Agreement to Sell.
Therefore, there was no admission on the part of the Appellant and no
decree under Order XII Rule 6 CPC, could have been passed, without
leading of evidence and its appreciation thereto.
12.
It is further contended that it has not been appreciated that it is the
Respondent, who had put the Appellant in possession and therefore, he
cannot seek the recovery. Though there was an Agreement to Sell, but its
execution and payment of part consideration, has been denied by the
Respondent, which raised a triable issue and should not be decided in such a
prejudicial manner.
13.
The Respondent/Plaintiff has paid Rs. 25 Lakhs which he claims to
have returned however, the said Rs. 25 Lakhs was paid for purchase of
marble/granite. The Appellant was in the process of filing a Suit for Specific
Performance of Agreement to Sell dated 12.12.2019. In case the Suit is
decreed, the present Order would be prejudicial to the intended Suit for
Specific Performance.
14.
Insofar as the FIR is concerned wherein the Respondent has alleged
that the Agreement to Sell was a forged document, the Appellant has already
been granted Bail by the learned CMM on 08.04.2022. During the
investigations, the signatures on the Agreement to Sell to be that of the
Respondent had been verified in FSL Report. However, the Charge-Sheet in
the FIR has not been filed since more than two years.
15.
The learned District Judge erroneously relied on the documents,
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
which were submitted along with the written arguments and did not form the
basis of the pleadings.
16.
Reliance is placed on Karan Kapoor vs. Madhuri Kumar, Civil
Appeal No. 4645/2022 in SLP (C) No. 13800/2021.
17.
A prayer is, therefore, made that the impugned Order dated
06.06.2024, be set-aside.
Submissions Heard and record perused.
18.
From the pleadings as well as the Impugned Order under O12 Rule 6
CPC, it emerges that the Appellant was admittedly, inducted in the Suit
premises as a tenant in respect of property, i.e. Ground Floor and First Floor
vide Lease Deed dated 20.07.2018 at a monthly rent of Rs.2,00,000/-.
19.
The entire defence of the Appellant rests on the Agreement to Sell
dated 12.12.2019, according to which the Respondent had agreed to sell the
Suit Property and Third Floor with Terrance rights to the Appellant for
Rs.2,71,00,000/-. The Appellant had claimed that out of this sale
consideration, a sum of Rs.50,00,000/- had been paid in part performance in
two transactions of Rs.25,00,000/- each, dated 13.02.2019 and 14.02.2019.
It was further stated that Rs.4,00,000/- which were given as security at the
time of execution of the Sale Deed, was also agreed to be adjusted towards
the sale consideration. It was claimed that the entire sale consideration was
to be paid on or before 31.10.2020, after which the Sale Deed was to be
executed.
20.
The Appellant has asserted that this alleged Agreement to Sell was
entered into in respect of area measuring 147 sq. Yards of Ground Floor,
entire First Floor without roof rights and entire third floor with roof rights
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
(which was not a part of tenancy) area measuring 247 sq. Yards out of the
western portion of freehold property No.E-2A, Mansarovar Garden, Delhi.
21.
The relevant part of Agreement to Sell, including Clause 2, reads as
under:
“WHEREAS First party is the owner and in possession of
8/9th UNDIVIDED SHARE OF FRONT PORTION OF
GROUND FLOOR AREA MEASURING 147 SQ. YDS.,
ENTIRE FIRST FLOOR WITHOUT ROOF RIGHT AND
ENTIRE THIRD FLOOR WITH ROOF RIGHTS AREA
MEASURING 247 SQ. YDS. OUT OF WESTERN PORTION
OF FREEHOLD BUILT UP PROPERTY BEARING NO. E-2A, SITUATED IN THE AREA OF VILLAGE BASSAI
DARAPUR, DELHI STATE, DELHI NOW COLONY KNOWN
AS MANSOVER GARDEN, NEW DELHI- 110015 and the
proportionate freehold rights of land under the said property
WHEREIN AFTER CALLED THE PROPERTY UNDERSALE.
…
1. That the second party have already in possession of the
front portion of Ground Floor area measuring 147sq. yds. And
Entire First Floor with aggregate of 247 sq. yard. approx.
without roof rights of above said property as a tenant/ lessee
as for Lease Deed registered as document No. 8400 in Book
No. I Volume No. 23829 on pages No. 151 to 157 duly
registered on dated 20-07-2018 in the office of Sub-Registrar
SR-II, Basai, Darapur, New Delhi executed between both the
parties and it is also agreed between the both parties that on
receipt of balance payment the first party shall deliver the
vacant and physical peaceful possession of the remaining
portion of above said property under sale to the second party
and execute/sign the necessary transfer/sale document in the
office of the concerned Sub-Registrar in the name of second
part or his their Nominee without extra demand or so.
2. That the second party has not paid the monthly rent to the
first party from 1-04-2019 of the portion of above said
property which is in possession of the second party and now it
is also agreed between both the parties that the first party
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
shall demand the dues of rent of the above said property from
the second party and it is also agreed between both the parties
that the second party shall not pay the monthly rent to the first
party for the remaining period.”
22.
There are certain facts, which cannot be overlooked. Firstly, the
Appellant was in possession of front portion of ground floor admeasuring
147 sq. yards and entire first floor with an aggregate of 247 sq. Yards
without roof right, as a tenant by virtue of Lease Deed registered on
20.07.2018. However, this Agreement to Sell pertained to Ground Floor,
First Floor without roof rights and third floor with terrace rights. There is
nothing on record that the Appellant was in possession of the third floor. He
admittedly, also had no tenancy rights in respect of Third Floor.
23.
Secondly, the Contract was to be concluded and entire payment to be
made till 31.10.2020. Aside from claiming that the Appellant has paid Rs.50
lacs through two RTGS transfer in February, 2019, there is no further
averment of any kind that any payment towards alleged balance sale
consideration was ever made by the Appellant.
24.
Another significant aspect is that no Suit for Specific Performance has
been filed by the Appellant, even after the expiry of the deadline of
31.10.2020 mentioned in the Agreement to Sell, till date. Even if he had any
right of specific performance, the same already become barred by limitation.
25.
Appellant had contended that the Respondent had wrongly denied his
signatures on the Agreement to Sell and had got FIR No.20/2022 registered
against the Appellant on the allegations that the signatures on the Agreement
to Sell were forged. However, as per Status Report dated 16.10.2024, filed
by the I.O. in FIR No.0020/2022 under Sections 420/464/467/468/471/120B
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
IPC, registered at PS: Kirti Nagar, Delhi, during investigations of FIR,
signatures were sought to be verified through FSL, which gave its Report
that the signatures of the Respondent on the Agreement to Sell were genuine
and the Closure Report was intended to be filed in the FIR.
26.
Even if the best case of the Appellant is accepted that there was an
Agreement to Sell duly executed between the parties, but as noted above,
once no action has been taken under the Agreement to Sell for Specific
Performance, no rights can be claimed by the Appellant under the said
Agreement to Sell.
27.
It is mentioned in the Agreement to Sell itself that the sale
consideration was agreed to be Rs.2,17,00,000/- (which included the third
floor and terrace, which was not in the tenancy and the possession of the
Appellant). It was further stated in the Agreement to Sell that the total sale
consideration
was
Rs.2,71,00,000/-
out
of
which,
Rs.50,00,000/-
(Rs.25,00,000/- each through RTGS dated 13.02.2019 and 14.02.2019 had
been made in the Account of the Appellant).
28.
The Appellant has contended that in the FIR, the Respondent had
taken a stand in respect of Rs.50,00,000/- in FIR No. 20/2022 and it had
been alleged that Rs.50,00,000/- was a friendly loan taken by the
Respondent/Plaintiff from the Appellant out of which, he had returned
Rs.25,00,000/-. However, a contradictory stand was taken in the Suit,
wherein it was alleged by the Plaintiff/Respondent that the Appellant had
paid Rs.25,00,000/- for purchase of Marble/Granite.
29.
The Respondent explained that in February, 2019, since the Appellant
was busy in fixing the marriage of his daughter, he had transferred
Rs.50,00,000/- in the Account of M/s Golden Granites Proprietorship Firm
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
of the Plaintiff, for the purchase of marble. He has the Bills for
Rs.25,00,000/- for which the Marble was purchased. Thereafter, the
Appellant asked to cancel the Order of his client as the same was no longer
required and requested for return of his money. The Plaintiff returned
Rs.14,34,000/- on 21.02.2019 and Rs.7,66,000/- in cash, which transaction
was acknowledged by the Appellant in the WhatsApp Chat.
30.
Amount of Rs.10,00,000/- were returned through RTGS on
27.03.2019 and Rs.15,00,000/- through RTGS on 25.04.2019, a fact which
is not disputed by the Appellant. Rs. 50,00,000/- were thus, returned to the
Appellant.
31.
The Appellant asserted that there are two different averments made by
the Respondent, which can be adjudicated only after recording of evidence.
32.
While different explanation has been given by the Respondent, but it
is pertinent to refer to the Agreement to Sell wherein it was specifically
mentioned that Rs.50,00,000/- had been transferred through RTGS as part
sale consideration. Therefore, whatever be the explanations given, the same
are not tenable. It is on record that part sale consideration of Rs.50,00,000/was paid as mentioned in the Agreement to Sell. Pertinently, the Respondent
has asserted that Rs.25,00,000/- have been returned to the Appellant in
March, April 2019, a fact which has not been disputed by the Defendant.
33.
The Appellant has relied heavily on part payment of sale
consideration, to claim that he is not liable to pay the rent after the execution
of the Agreement to Sell dated 12.12.2019.
34.
It is pertinent to mention that the Appellant on 16.03.2019, he paid
Rs.4,32,000/- towards the rent for February and March, 2019. He had issued
two cheques of Rs.10,00,000/- and Rs.5,12,000/- respectively, towards the
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
rent of seven months, but both got dishonoured and a Complaint under
Section
Negotiable
Instruments
Act,
was
filed
by
the
Respondent/Appellant.
35.
The Appellant had denied having issued two cheques of
Rs.10,00,000/- and Rs.5,12,000/- respectively, towards the rent and claimed
that no such cheques were ever issued by him. It was explained that the
Plaintiff and the Defendant were in the same business i.e. trading in Granite
and various other types of stones, Marble, tiles etc, which were used in
construction
of
building
floors.
One
of
the
customers
of
the
Defendant/Appellant, had requested him to procure a huge quantity of White
Marble Slabs, which were not available with the Defendant Firm. He thus,
requested the Plaintiff, to arrange the same for the Appellant upon which, on
the asking of the Plaintiff/Respondent, the aforesaid two cheques i.e. one for
Rs.10,00,000/- and other was a blank cheque on which the amount was to be
filled for the balance amount, which may be due on account of purchase of
the Marble Slabs by the Plaintiff for the Defendant, had been handed over
to the Plaintiff/Respondent.
36.
The Plaintiff, however, could not arrange the goods as the officials of
DRI conducted a raid at his premises and the Appellant also did not try to
contact him. The two cheques, therefore, remained in the possession of the
Plaintiff. It was thus, asserted that the two cheques were not towards
payment of arrears of rent but for purchase of Marble Slabs. The cheques
have been misused and misappropriated by the Plaintiff/Respondent.
37.
It was further contended that once the Agreement to Sell dated
12.12.2019 was entered into between the parties, there was no question of
issuing the aforesaid cheques towards the rent as asserted by the Plaintiff. In
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
the Agreement to Sell dated 12.12.2019, it had been clearly mentioned that
Rs.50,00,000/- have been received by the Plaintiff, a fact which has been
concealed in the Plaint. The Plaintiff has fabricated a false story in respect of
the two cheques, which have been misused by him.
38.
Whatever may be the controversy of the amount having been paid by
the Respondent or returned by the Appellant, the core question here is that
the Agreement to Sell dated 12.12.2019 was to be executed by 31.10.2020,
which admittedly has not happened and no Suit for Specific Performance
has been filed.
39.
The question which thus arises, is whether the Appellant ceased to be
the tenant and his possession matured into that of an owner. In this regard,
reliance may be placed on Hari Gopal Manu vs. B.S. Ojha, 2016 SCC
Online Delhi 985 wherein similar facts were considered. It was held that a
mere Agreement to Sell of immovable property does not create any right in
the property save to enforce the Agreement. Even if it is found that the
Plaintiff had agreed to sell the property, which had been let out to the
Appellant/Defendant on rent, the Defendant would not get any right to
occupy the property as a purchaser.
40.
In Jiwan Das vs. Narain Das, AIR 1981 Delhi 291, it was held that no
rights enure to the agreement purchaser not even after the passing of decree
for Specific Performance till the conveyance in accordance with law is
executed. The appellant‟s right to remain in the occupation of the premises
or to retain the possession of the premises merely because of the Agreement
to Sell in his favour.
41.
In M.R. Sawhney vs. Doris Randhawa, AIR 2008 Delhi 110 (SLP No.
13820/2008) against this Judgment was dismissed on 22.10.2010 held “ex
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
facie, once a tenant always remains a tenant, unless the status changes by
contract or by operation of law.” In Abdul Hakim Mia vs. Pana Mia Miaji,
AIR 1919 Calcutta 293 (DB), it was held that where a person is inducted as
a tenant and is in possession, the character of possession cannot be altered
without the consent of Plaintiff. The principle of estoppel under Section 116
of the Indian Evidence Act, 1881, continues even after the expiration of
period of the lease and unless the tenant surrenders the possession, he is
estopped from contesting the title of the landlord.
42.
The Supreme Court of India in Sant Lal Jain vs. Avtar Singh, (1985) 2
SCC 332 held that the Defendant who is a licensee, must be deemed to be
always a licensee. It is not open to him, during the subsistence and after the
revocation of license to set up a title to the property in himself or anyone
else.
43.
In the present case, even though the parties had agreed to enter into an
Agreement to Sell, but it was subject to its performance by 31.10.2020,
which has not happened. The parties may have agreed that the rent would
not be payable till the execution of the Sale Deed, but there is not a single
averment to show that the title of the Appellant ever changed into that of an
owner.
44.
It is also pertinent to note that the Appellant has primarily relied upon
an unregistered Agreement to Sell, he cannot seek the benefit of 53A of the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882, on the basis of an unregistered Agreement to
Sell, to protect his possession.
45.
Pertinently, the learned District Judge in its Order dated 09.12.2023
had noted that the Respondent has filed Civil (Comm) Suit No. 702/2022 for
Recovery of Rs.49,56,000/- along with the interest @ 9% p.a. in regard to
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
the arrears of rent, which is still pending trial.
46.
It is also pertinent to observe that Appellant had made RTGS of
Rs.25,00,000/-, which was sought to be explained by the Respondent, as an
advance payment for supply of marble granite by the Appellant, for which a
Civil Suit has already been filed.
47.
The averments therein are that two cheques, one of Rs.10,00,000/-
and second of Rs.5,12,000/- both dated 15.12.2019, had been issued by the
Appellant towards arrear of rent, but the same on presentation, got
dishonoured. A Complaint under Section 138 NI Act was filed, though the
same was withdrawn.
48.
The learned District Judge was right in considering the admission of
the Appellant of having been inducted as tenant in the suit premises and in
rejecting the defence of Agreement to Sell as not tenable, to decree the suit
for possession.
49.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby dismissed.
Pending Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JANUARY 12, 2026
RS
RFA 682/2024
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
16:59:50
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review