Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Central Excise Ap.No.2/2021 with
MC (Central Excise Ap.) No.2/2021
Date of Order: 03.03.2022
M/s Adhunik Meghalaya Steels
Private Limited & anr
Coram:
Vs.
Union of India & ors
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. G Sharma, Adv with
Mr. R Deb Nath, Adv
Dr. N Mozika, ASG with
Ms. L. Jana, Adv
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
In view of the order proposed to be made, the facts need not be
noticed in any greater detail since the issues involved are primarily legal.
2.
The essential facts have been recorded in the previous order of
February 15, 2022, though the parties were left free to urge all grounds.
3.
The appellant-assessee procured an Arc Furnace as capital goods
for the purpose of its manufacturing unit that produces ferro silicate
components which attract excise duty. However, by reason of the location
of the manufacturing unit, the assessee is entitled to refund of the excise
duty to the extent paid. The appellant was also entitled to obtain Cenvat
credit for acquisition of capital goods used in its process of manufacture.
However, in terms of Rule 3(5) of the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2004, as such
Rule stood at the relevant time, when any capital goods had been acquired
and Cenvat credit obtained, if such capital goods were subsequently to be
sold or transferred, the Cenvat credit had to be refunded.
4.
Under the practice that was followed for the assessee to obtain the
refund of the excise duty paid, it would first adjust the quantum of excise
duty payable against any Cenvat credit in the assessee’s account; and the
balance amount of the duty would be paid in cash. A return would be filed
by the assessee at the end of each month. Upon scrutiny of the return, the
amount of excise duty paid in cash would be refunded to the assessee by the
concerned Assistant Commissioner.
5.
As regards the acquisition of any capital goods upon obtaining
Cenvat credit, at the time of sale or transfer of such capital goods, the extent
of Cenvat credit availed of had to be refunded. Rule 3(5) of the said Rules
as it stood used the expression “as such” but did not make any distinction
between capital goods that may have been acquired 10 years back and used
and capital goods which may have been acquired a day before and proposed
to be sold or transferred without being used. It is obvious that if the capital
goods had been put to use they would suffer depreciation and the usual
wear and tear and would not be worth the price at which they were acquired
at the time of the subsequent sale or transfer. The duration of use may have
a bearing on the quantum of reduction of the value of the capital goods.
However, the relevant Rule, apparently, did not expressly take such aspect
into account. At the same time to ensure that the amount to be refunded
under the Rule was rational and not arbitrary or oppressive, the Rule could
be read with reference to the expression “as such”. That would imply that if
the capital goods acquired were in the same state as at the time of
acquisition, a complete refund of the Cenvat credit would have to be made.
As a corollary, it would follow that if the capital goods were not in the state
in which it had been acquired – upon such capital goods being put to use –
the entirety of the Cenvat credit may not have to be refunded. The Rule,
however, made no express distinction as to the quantum of refund of
Cenvat credit that had to be made for no use or for little use or for
exhaustive use of the capital goods.
6.
This anomaly in Rule 3(5) of the said Rules was addressed by a
2007 amendment that made a distinction and gave a rebate of two and half
percent of the Cenvat credit obtained for every quarter of use of the capital
goods. Thus, if the capital goods had been used for a period of 10 years,
only a nominal amount of the Cenvat credit obtained would be liable to be
refunded; whereas, if the capital goods were not used at all and proposed to
be sold in the same quarter in which they were acquired, the entirety of the
Cenvat credit obtained would have to be refunded.
7.
Indeed, there is also a provision in the said Rules that when the
capital goods are reduced to scrap, it is only the duty on the transaction
which has to be paid and not a refund on the entirety of the Cenvat credit
obtained at the time of the acquisition of the capital goods.
8.
In the present case, upon the assessee using the Arc Furnace for a
considerable period of time, it desired to replace the same or, at any rate, to
sell or transfer the same; whereupon the assessee was required to refund in
cash the entire quantum of Cenvat credit that it had obtained at the time of
the acquisition of the Arc Furnace. There is no dispute that such refund was
made in cash. However, according to the Department, the assessee acted in
a mischievous manner by incorporating the amount of Cenvat credit
refunded in respect of the Arc Furnace in its return at the end of the month.
The Department claims that the Assistant Commissioner, in his mistaken
belief that the money that had been paid and indicated in the return was in
connection with the duty on the manufactured goods of the assessee,
refunded back the Cenvat credit obtained in respect of the Arc Furnace. A
few months down the line, the alleged mistake was noticed and a showcause notice was issued to the assessee as to why the amount should not be
refunded by the assessee. For such purpose, Section 11A of the Central
Excise Act, 1944 was pressed into service to demand the refund apparently
erroneously made.
9.
To complete the narration, the refund was extracted and the
assessee’s entreaties right up to the Tribunal fell on deaf ears. It is the order
of the Tribunal upholding the entitlement of the Department to obtain the
refund of the relevant amount of about Rs.1.58 crore that is the subjectmatter of the present challenge.
10.
Of the several grounds urged by the assessee, three are of some
relevance. According to the assessee, there was no attempt on its behalf to
mislead the Assistant Commissioner or induce the Assistant Commissioner
to believe that the amount paid in cash on account of the refund of the
Cenvat credit obtained for the Arc Furnace was duty paid for its
manufactured products. The appellant next says that Section 11A of the said
Act could not have been invoked as the concerned Assistant Commissioner
is deemed to have applied his mind before arriving at a decision to refund
the amount to the assessee. The assessee asserts that in such a scenario, an
appeal could be carried by the Department against the order of refund made
by the Assistant Commissioner, but Section 11A of the Act, as it then
stood, could not have been invoked.
11.
The further point made by the assessee is that even if Section 11A
of the Act had been invoked by the Department, the Tribunal erred in
reading the amended Section 11A of the Act to assess the matter, though it
is the undisputed position that the unamended Section 11A of the Act was
applicable to the present case. Though some structural changes were made
to Section 11A by bringing in some of the conditions indicated by way of a
proviso to the substantive part of such provision, the material change that
was effected by way of the subsequent amendment to Section 11A of the
Act was in the introduction of the expansive expression “for any reason”.
12.
The assessee contends that since the expression “for any reason”
did not find any place in Section 11A of the Act that ought to have been
applied to the present case, it is evident that the Tribunal took irrelevant
considerations into account and the decision-making process itself was
awry.
13.
The second principal ground pressed by the assessee is that
notwithstanding the Rule 3(5) having been amended in the year 2007 and
the demand for refund of the Cenvat credit on account of capital goods
having been raised on the assessee earlier, the Tribunal at various places
and some High Courts have taken a view that the benefit given under
amended Rule 3(5) of the said Rules for depreciation of the capital goods
would, in effect, have retrospective operation. For such purpose, the
assessee relies on a judgment of the Principal Bench of the Tribunal
reported at 2013 (298) ELT 541 which accepted a view expressed by the
Madras High Court in a decision reported at 2011 (264) ELT 367.
14.
Amendments to enactments or rules or instructions sometimes
bring about an altered situation or, at times, may be clarificatory in nature.
When an amendment is clarificatory, then such amendment has to be read
into the provision sought to be amended as if it was included therein from
the inception of such provision. In the present case, despite the use of the
expression “as such” in original Rule 3(5) of the said Rules of 2004, no
remission was given as to the quantum of refund of the Cenvat credit earlier
availed of by taking into account the tenure of use of the capital goods.
Plainly, it was irrational. The usual wear and tear of any goods would
diminish its value, as the rule of depreciation instructs, upon its use over a
period of time. In such a scenario, Rule 3(5) of the said Rules of 2004 could
have been seen to have been arbitrary in not making a distinction between
the quantum of Cenvat credit that ought to be refunded by an assessee who
intended to sell any capital goods for which Cenvat credit which had been
obtained, within a short time of the acquisition of capital goods or after long
years of use thereof. The distinction was brought about and the remission,
so to say, was provided in the amended Rule 3(5) of the said Rules in 2007.
15.
On facts similar to the present case, the Madras High Court
upheld the view taken by the Tribunal in interpreting the benefit conferred
by the amendment to Rule 3(5) to have retrospective operation even if the
demand for the refund of the Cenvat credit obtained for the capital goods
had been raised prior to the amendment of 2007.
16.
The third and the most important ground urged by the appellant is
that in view of the exemption that the appellant is entitled to by reason of
the location of its manufacturing facility, the assessee ought not to have
been required to make any refund of the Cenvat credit obtained at the time
of purchase of the Arc Furnace. The assessee asserts that since the excise
duty paid by it is refunded by the Department and the Cenvat credit
obtained for acquisition of the Arc Furnace was adjusted, like currency,
against the excise duty payable on the manufactured goods; the assessee
being required to disgorge the Cenvat credit obtained, amounts to the
equivalent exemption that it was otherwise entitled to being denied to it.
17.
In other words, what the assessee says is that if it was liable in a
month to pay Rs.100 on account of the excise duty it would be entitled to
get refund of such amount of Rs.100 the next month and so on. However, if
the assessee had adjusted the Cenvat credit obtained for the capital goods
against a part of the excise duty payable for its manufactured goods, then
the appellant would have paid only the amount by which the duty exceeded
the Cenvat credit in cash to be entitled to receive the refund of such cash
only. In this case, when the appellant had used the Cenvat credit for
acquiring the Arc Furnace and had adjusted the same against excise duty
payable for its manufactured goods and paid the balance amount in cash
after adjusting the credit, the quantum of credit which the assessee had
obtained is lost forever to the assessee. What the assessee suggests is that
the Cenvat credit given for acquisition of capital goods to a manufacturer,
who is otherwise exempted from paying excise duty on its manufactured
products, is revenue neutral. There is considerable force in such contention
that when a manufacturer is entitled to refund of the entire excise duty, the
refund to the Department of any adjusted Cenvat credit availed of would
again have to be refunded by the Department by virtue of the exemption to
which the assessee is entitled to.
18.
The third aspect – the most important ground – urged on behalf of
the assessee goes to the root of the matter does not appear to have been
considered by the Tribunal in the impugned judgment and order dated
January 16, 2020.
19.
The Department, fairly, accepts that the matter may require fresh
consideration. Accordingly, the judgment and order of the Tribunal dated
January 16, 2020 is set aside. The order of the adjudicating authority that
was carried to the Tribunal is also set aside.
20.
However, without the remanding the matter to the Tribunal, it is
deemed fit and proper to remand the matter to the previous level, the
adjudicating authority, for the entire gamut of the matter to be considered
afresh in accordance with law. It is hoped that the appropriate adjudicating
authority would render its decision within a period of four months of the
receipt of a copy of this order. It is also hoped that the adjudicating
authority shall afford a personal hearing to the assessee or the assessee’s
representative. It will be open to the parties to challenge the order of the
adjudicating authority before the Tribunal in accordance with law.
21.
Central Excise Appeal No.2 of 2021 and MC (Central Excise Ap.)
No.2/2021 are disposed of without any order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
03.03.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review