Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 23.09.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 01.10.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 01.10.2026
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010414842025
W.P.(C) 9406/2025 & CM APPL. 39693/2025
M/S A.G. ENTERPRISES
......Petitioner
Through: Mr. Bimal Jain, Mr. Anurag
Jain and Ms. Ishika Agarwal,
Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ANOTHER
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Harpreet Sing, Mr. Iqbal
Singh Bedi, Ms. Suhani
Mathur, Mr. Mudit Grover, Mr
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Mr. Akshay
Saxena,
Ms.
Animika
Bharadwaj, Advs
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE BHARAT PARASHAR
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
1.
Through the present Petition, the Petitioner seeks quashing of
the Demand-cum-Show Cause Notice dated 06.06.2024, the summary
whereof was uploaded on 02.08.2024, as well as the Order-in-Original
dated 12.02.2025 passed in the adjudication proceedings, whereby the
Petitioner has been held liable for reversal/recovery of Input Tax
Credit [hereinafter referred to as “ITC”], along with applicable interest
and penalty under the provisions of the CGST Act and the
corresponding provisions of the Delhi Goods and Services Tax Act,
2017 [hereinafter referred to as “DGST Act”].
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
2.
The issue which arises for consideration in the present Petition
is whether this Court, in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226
of the Constitution of India, ought to interfere with the adjudication
proceedings culminating in the Order-in-Original passed under
Section 74 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
[hereinafter referred to as “CGST Act”], on the grounds that the
proceedings were allegedly initiated in breach of Section 6(2)(b) of
the CGST Act, in disregard of earlier proceedings undertaken by the
State Goods and Services Tax authorities, without affording an
effective opportunity of hearing, and by allegedly travelling beyond
the allegations contained in the Show Cause Notice.
FACTUAL MATRIX:
3.
In order to appreciate the controversy involved in the present
Petition, the relevant facts, in brief, are required to be noticed.
4.
The Petitioner is a proprietorship concern engaged in the
business of retail and wholesale trading of machines, screws,
scaffolding, shuttering and propping equipment. The proceedings in
question emanate from an investigation initially undertaken in respect
of
M/s
Pramod
Traders/Bheem
Traders,
bearing
GSTIN
09BIUPP9328M1Z2.
5.
The record of the Impugned Adjudication Order shows that a
communication dated 06.12.2021 was received from the office of the
Assistant
Commissioner,
CGST,
Firozabad,
regarding
the
investigation into the activities of the aforesaid entity. It was reported
that the said entity was issuing invoices without corresponding actual
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
supply of goods and was also not complying with its statutory filing
and tax payment obligations.
6.
During the course of the aforesaid investigation, it was noticed
that
M/s
ASA
Nand
Nathu
Ram,
bearing
GSTIN
07ABDPB4654M1ZM, had availed ITC of Rs.7,48,600/- from M/s
Pramod Traders/Bheem Traders. Consequently, an inspection of the
principal place of business of M/s ASA Nand Nathu Ram was
conducted on 18.01.2022 under Section 67(1) of the CGST Act.
7.
The Impugned Order records that the premises of M/s ASA
Nand Nathu Ram were found to be existent and operational and that
its proprietor, Mr. Sunil Kumar Bajaj, was present at the premises. It
further records that a summons dated 18.01.2022 was served upon him
and that his statement was thereafter recorded under Section 70 of the
CGST Act.
8.
During the course of the investigation, the mobile phone of Mr.
Sunil Kumar Bajaj was also examined and certain WhatsApp
conversations were stated to have been found therein. The Impugned
Order records that the mobile phone was voluntarily surrendered for
further investigation. It is further recorded that Mr. Sunil Kumar
Bajaj, in his statement recorded under Section 70 of the CGST Act,
stated that ITC had been availed on the basis of “goods-less invoices”
provided by one Mr. Udey.
9.
The investigation thereafter proceeded to verify the suppliers of
M/s ASA Nand Nathu Ram. The Impugned Order records that twelve
(12) suppliers falling within the jurisdiction of CGST Delhi North and
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
CGST Delhi East were verified and were found to be bogus/nonexistent.
10.
Nand
On the basis of the investigation, it was alleged that M/s ASA
Nathu
Ram
had
availed
fake
ITC
amounting
to
Rs.11,95,83,886/-. It was further alleged that the said entity had issued
tax invoices without actual supply of goods and had thereby passed on
inadmissible ITC amounting to Rs.12,08,75,617/- to 618 beneficiary
firms, companies and entities.
11.
Out of the aforesaid beneficiaries, 228 entities, falling within
the jurisdiction of CGST Delhi North, were stated to have availed ITC
amounting to Rs.10,30,79,845/-, while the remaining 390 beneficiary
entities, falling within the jurisdiction of other CGST/SGST
Commissionerates, were stated to have availed ITC amounting to
Rs.1,77,95,772/-.
12.
The case of the Department, as reflected in the Impugned
Order, is that the aforesaid transactions were undertaken without any
genuine supply or receipt of goods or services and that the recipient
entities had availed and utilised inadmissible ITC on the strength of
invoices without actual receipt of the corresponding goods.
13.
During the investigation, summonses were issued to the
recipient entities falling within the jurisdiction of CGST Delhi North.
The Impugned Order records that some of the recipient entities
deposited amounts towards reversal of ITC, interest and penalty.
Insofar as the Petitioner is concerned, the Table forming part of the
Impugned Show Cause Notice records the alleged ITC liability of M/s
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
A.G. Enterprises at Rs.47,93,104/-, along with applicable interest and
penalty. The record further reflects a deposit of Rs.5,00,000/- by the
Petitioner through DRC-03 dated 20.10.2022.
14.
A Demand-cum-Show Cause Notice bearing No.22/2024-25
was thereafter issued by the Additional Commissioner (Anti-Evasion),
CGST Delhi North Commissionerate. The Impugned Adjudication
Order records that the proceedings were initiated under Section 74 of
the CGST Act read with the corresponding provisions of the DGST
Act and the IGST Act.
15.
The allegations against the recipient entities, including the
Petitioner, were essentially that they had availed and utilised ITC on
the strength of invoices without actual receipt of goods or services and
had thereby contravened the provisions of Section 16 of the CGST
Act. The Show Cause Notice proposed recovery of the allegedly
inadmissible ITC along with interest under Section 50 and penalty
under Section 74 of the CGST Act.
16.
The Petitioner had, prior thereto, also been subjected to
proceedings before the State GST authorities. In respect of financial
year 2017-18, a notice dated 23.09.2023 was issued under Section 73
of the CGST/DGST Act alleging wrongful availment of ITC from M/s
ASA Nand Nathu Ram. The Petitioner submitted its reply dated
21.11.2023. According to the Petitioner, the said proceedings
culminated
in
an
order
dated
13.12.2023
whereby
the
allegation/demand was dropped.
17.
In respect of financial year 2018-19, another notice dated
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
20.12.2023 was issued by the State GST authorities in respect of ITC
allegedly availed from M/s ASA Nand Nathu Ram, M/s N.S. Traders
and M/s Bala Ji Traders. The Petitioner submitted its reply dated
06.01.2024. The allegations concerning M/s N.S. Traders and M/s
Bala Ji Traders were dropped, whereas the demand concerning M/s
ASA Nand Nathu Ram was confirmed by order dated 29.04.2024. The
Petitioner states that proceedings challenging the said order are
pending before this Court.
18.
In respect of financial year 2019-20, the State GST authorities
issued a further notice dated 29.05.2024 under Section 73 in respect of
several suppliers, including M/s ASA Nand Nathu Ram. The
Petitioner states that the allegations in respect of the other suppliers
were dropped, whereas the demand concerning M/s ASA Nand Nathu
Ram was confirmed by order dated 29.08.2024. According to the
Petitioner, the said order was based substantially upon the
communication of the Deputy Commissioner, Anti-Evasion.
19.
The Petitioner further refers to proceedings undertaken by the
State GST authorities for financial year 2020-21, in which a notice
dated 22.11.2024 was issued in respect of, inter alia, M/s ASA Nand
Nathu Ram. The Petitioner states that the said proceedings
subsequently culminated in an order dated 27.02.2025.
20.
In the meantime, the Central GST proceedings proceeded on the
basis of the Demand-cum-Show Cause Notice dated 06.06.2024, the
summary of which was uploaded on the GST portal on 02.08.2024.
The Petitioner submitted a response to the pre-notice intimation/DRCSignature Not Verified
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
01A on 28.05.2024, raising, inter alia, an objection regarding the
earlier proceedings undertaken by the State GST authorities and
asserting that the conditions for availment of ITC under Section 16
had been fulfilled.
21.
The Petitioner also raised objections regarding the nature of the
evidence relied upon by the Department and sought an opportunity to
cross-examine the persons whose statements were relied upon. The
Petitioner also referred to the proceedings undertaken against other
taxpayers and requested that the proposed demand not be confirmed
without considering the material placed on record.
22.
Thereafter, the adjudication proceedings culminated in the
Impugned Order-in-Original. The order records the allegations
contained in the Show Cause Notice and proceeds to examine the
alleged availment and utilisation of ITC by the recipient entities. In
paragraph 8 of the Impugned Order, the adjudicating authority has
recorded the “Record of the Personal Hearing”. It has been stated that
personal hearing opportunities were granted to the concerned Noticees
and that some Noticees appeared and made oral as well as written
submissions, which were considered. In respect of the remaining
Noticees, the adjudicating authority records that neither the Noticees
nor their authorised representatives appeared and that the matter was
accordingly proceeded with ex parte.
23.
The adjudicating authority thereafter examined the allegations
concerning the receipt of goods and the availment and utilisation of
ITC. In paragraph 12 of the Impugned Order, specific reference has
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
been made to Section 16(2)(b) of the CGST Act and it has been held
that the recipient entities had not received the goods physically and
had instead received goods-less invoices.
24.
The adjudicating authority further proceeded to examine the
applicability of Section 74(1) of the CGST Act. In paragraph 14, it has
been held that the alleged availment and utilisation of ITC without
actual receipt of goods was by reason of fraud, wilful misstatement or
suppression of facts, and that the ingredients for invocation of Section
74(1) stood satisfied. In paragraph 15, the adjudicating authority dealt
with the liability towards interest under Section 50 of the CGST Act.
Thereafter, the order proceeds to deal with the penal consequences
arising from the alleged availment and utilisation of inadmissible ITC.
25.
Ultimately, by the Impugned Order, the demand of inadmissible
ITC was confirmed against the recipient entities, including the
Petitioner, along with applicable interest under Section 50 and penalty
under Section 74(1). The amounts already deposited by the respective
Noticees were ordered to be appropriated against their respective
liabilities.
26.
The Petitioner has approached this Court assailing the aforesaid
order.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES:
27.
Contentions on behalf of the Petitioner:
27.1. It was submitted that the impugned proceedings are without
jurisdiction in view of Section 6(2)(b) of the CGST Act. It is
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
contended that the State GST authorities had already initiated
proceedings in respect of the same ITC allegedly availed from M/s
ASA Nand Nathu Ram and, therefore, the Central GST authorities
could not have initiated another proceeding concerning the same
subject matter.
27.2. It was further submitted that the proceedings before the State
GST authorities had, in respect of certain financial years, already
culminated in orders. Particular emphasis is placed upon the order
dated 13.12.2023 for financial year 2017-18, whereby the allegation
concerning the ITC availed from M/s ASA Nand Nathu Ram is stated
to have been dropped. Reliance is also placed upon the subsequent
orders passed by the State GST authorities in respect of financial years
2018-19 and 2019-20.
27.3. It was next submitted that the Impugned Order could not have
confirmed the demand on a ground different from that contained in the
Show Cause Notice. According to the Petitioner, the Show Cause
Notice proceeded on the allegation of non-receipt of goods and
alleged contravention of Section 16(2)(b), whereas the order is stated
to have proceeded on the premise that the supplier had not discharged
the tax liability to the Government, thereby attracting Section
16(2)(c).
27.4. It was submitted that the Petitioner had specifically requested
an opportunity of personal hearing and had sought time to submit a
detailed response. According to the Petitioner, the Impugned Order
was nevertheless passed without granting an effective opportunity of
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
hearing.
27.5. It was further contended that the reply furnished by the
Petitioner to the DRC-01A was not duly considered. The Petitioner
also challenges the clubbing of different financial years in one
proceeding and contends that such clubbing defeats the statutory
scheme governing limitation and adjudication. Reliance has also been
placed upon Section 75(4) of the CGST Act and the principles of
natural justice.
27.6. The Petitioner has also relied upon the judgment of this Court in
Amit Gupta v. Union of India1, in support of the submission that
Section 6(2)(b) of the CGST Act is intended to prevent parallel
proceedings by different GST authorities in respect of the same
subject matter.
27.7. The Petitioner has further relied upon various decisions
concerning the requirement of a personal hearing, the impermissibility
of confirming a demand on grounds travelling beyond the Show Cause
Notice, the consideration of replies furnished by the assessee and the
consequences of clubbing different periods in a single proceeding.
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
28.
This Court has carefully considered the submissions advanced
on behalf of the parties and perused the material on record.
29.
At the outset, it is necessary to notice that the Petitioner seeks to
invoke the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court against an Order-in1
2023 SCC OnLine Del 6664
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
Original whereby a demand towards allegedly inadmissible ITC,
together with interest and penalty, has been adjudicated under Section
74 of the CGST Act.
30.
The statutory scheme provides a remedy of appeal against an
adjudication order of this nature. The question, therefore, is whether
the objections raised by the Petitioner constitute circumstances
warranting exercise of the extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226
of the Constitution, notwithstanding the availability of the statutory
appellate remedy.
31.
The Petitioner has principally founded its challenge upon
Section 6(2)(b) of the CGST Act and the alleged violation of
principles of natural justice. These objections, no doubt, require
consideration. However, the mere description of an objection as one of
“jurisdiction” or “natural justice” does not, by itself, require this Court
to exercise its writ jurisdiction in every case. The Court is required to
examine the substance of the objection and the nature of the
adjudication which is under challenge.
32.
In the present case, the challenge under Section 6(2)(b)
proceeds on the premise that the proceedings initiated by the State
GST authorities and the proceedings initiated by the Central GST
authorities necessarily concern the same subject matter merely
because both proceedings involve ITC allegedly availed from M/s
ASA Nand Nathu Ram.
33.
The expression “same subject matter” occurring in Section
6(2)(b) is of central significance. The statutory provision does not
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
prohibit every subsequent proceeding merely because the same
assessee has earlier been subjected to proceedings by another GST
authority. The bar operates where the subsequent proceedings are in
respect of the same subject matter.
34.
The question whether two proceedings concern the same
subject matter cannot, therefore, be determined merely by identifying
a common supplier or by observing that the proceedings relate to ITC.
The relevant proceedings have to be examined with reference to the
tax period, the particular transactions and invoices involved, the
precise ITC forming the subject matter of the demand, the allegations
made in the respective notices and the liability which each authority
has sought to determine.
35.
The Supreme Court, while considering the scope of Section
6(2)(b) of the CGST Act in M/s Armour Security (India) Ltd. v.
Commissioner, CGST Delhi East Commissionerate2, has explained
that the statutory bar is attracted where proceedings are initiated on
the same subject matter. The Court has also explained the significance
of the issuance of a Show Cause Notice as the formal initiation of
proceedings and has emphasised that the subject matter has to be
identified with reference to the particular tax liability, deficiency or
obligation arising from the alleged contravention.
36.
Applying the aforesaid principle, the mere fact that the State
proceedings and the Central proceedings refer to M/s ASA Nand
Nathu Ram does not, by itself, establish that the entirety of the
2025 INSC 982
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
proceedings initiated by the Central authorities is barred under Section
6(2)(b).
37.
The State proceedings referred to by the Petitioner were
initiated separately for different financial years. The proceedings for
financial year 2017-18 were initiated by notice dated 23.09.2023; the
proceedings for financial year 2018-19 by notice dated 20.12.2023;
and the proceedings for financial year 2019-20 by notice dated
29.05.2024. The Central Show Cause Notice, on the other hand, was
dated 06.06.2024, the summary whereof was uploaded on 02.08.2024.
38.
The chronology itself demonstrates that the question of
applicability of Section 6(2)(b) cannot be answered merely by stating
that the State authorities had at some earlier stage initiated
proceedings. The relevant question is whether, on the date of initiation
of the Central proceedings, the liability which was sought to be
determined against the Petitioner in those proceedings had already
become the subject matter of proceedings initiated by the State
authorities.
39.
In respect of financial year 2017-18, the Petitioner relies upon
the order dated 13.12.2023 whereby, according to the Petitioner, the
demand relating to M/s ASA Nand Nathu Ram was dropped. In
respect of financial year 2018-19, the proceedings culminated in an
order dated 29.04.2024 whereby the demand relating to M/s ASA
Nand Nathu Ram was stated to have been confirmed. In respect of
financial year 2019-20, the State proceedings were initiated by notice
dated 29.05.2024 and, according to the Petitioner, culminated in an
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
order dated 29.08.2024.
40.
The aforesaid chronology, at the very least, demonstrates that
the question whether the liability adjudicated upon by the Central
authorities was precisely the same liability which had already been
subjected to proceedings by the State authorities involves an
examination of the respective Show Cause Notices, the tax periods,
the invoices and the precise ITC amounts involved therein.
41.
Such an exercise is essentially factual in nature. It is also
relevant that the Central proceedings were initiated under Section 74
of the CGST Act on the allegation that ITC had been availed and
utilised on the strength of invoices without actual receipt of goods or
services and that such availment was accompanied by fraud, wilful
misstatement or suppression of facts.
42.
The State proceedings, as placed before this Court, were
initiated under Section 73 of the CGST Act. The fact that a proceeding
is under Section 73 while another is under Section 74 is not, by itself,
conclusive for determining the question of “same subject matter”. At
the same time, the difference in the statutory provision invoked is a
relevant circumstance while examining the precise nature of the
liability sought to be determined in each proceeding.
43.
The Court, therefore, cannot accept the submission that the
mere commonality of the supplier, namely M/s ASA Nand Nathu
Ram, is sufficient to establish that the Central proceedings are wholly
barred by Section 6(2)(b).
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
44.
More importantly, the challenge to the Impugned Order is not
confined to the question of jurisdiction under Section 6(2)(b). The
Petitioner seeks adjudication by this Court on the correctness of the
findings concerning actual receipt of goods, the admissibility of ITC,
the applicability of Section 74, the evidence relied upon by the
Department, the consideration of the reply, the requirement of
personal hearing and the computation of the liability.
45.
These are matters which are ordinarily required to be examined
in the statutory appellate proceedings. The appellate authority is
competent to examine the complete adjudication record and determine
whether the demand confirmed against the Petitioner is supported by
the material on record and whether the statutory requirements for
invocation of Section 74 have been satisfied.
46.
The contention that the Impugned Order has travelled beyond
the Show Cause Notice also does not, on a reading of the Impugned
Order placed before this Court, warrant interference at this stage.
47.
The principal allegation recorded in the Impugned Order is that
the recipient entities had availed ITC on the strength of invoices
without actual receipt of goods. In paragraph 12 of the Impugned
Order, specific reliance has been placed upon Section 16(2)(b) of the
CGST Act and the finding is that the recipient entities had not
physically received the goods and had instead received goods-less
invoices.
48.
It is true that the Petitioner alleges that the Impugned Order has
also proceeded on the basis of non-payment of tax by the supplier and
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
thereby invoked Section 16(2)(c). However, the Impugned Order, as
placed before us, does not rest exclusively upon such a finding. The
finding regarding non-receipt of goods and availment of ITC on
goods-less invoices constitutes an independent basis expressly
recorded in paragraph 12 of the order.
49.
Likewise, the invocation of Section 74(1) is based upon the
adjudicating authority's conclusion that the alleged availment and
utilisation of ITC without actual receipt of goods was accompanied by
fraud, wilful misstatement or suppression of facts. Thus, the challenge
that the entire demand has been confirmed on a wholly new and
unrelated factual foundation is not borne out, at least on the face of the
Impugned Order.
50.
Whether the aforesaid findings are factually and legally
sustainable, whether the material relied upon establishes actual nonreceipt of goods, and whether the ingredients necessary for invoking
Section 74 are satisfied are matters which can appropriately be
considered in the statutory appellate proceedings.
51.
The next contention concerns the alleged denial of personal
hearing.
52.
Section 75(4) of the CGST Act contemplates grant of an
opportunity of hearing where a request is received in writing from the
person chargeable with tax or where an adverse decision is
contemplated against such person.
53.
In the present case, the Impugned Order specifically contains a
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
section dealing with the record of personal hearing. It records that
personal hearing opportunities were granted to the Noticees and that
some of them appeared and made oral as well as written submissions,
which were considered. It further records that the remaining Noticees
did not appear either personally or through their authorised
representatives and that the matter was thereafter proceeded with ex
parte.
54.
The Petitioner disputes the effectiveness of the opportunity so
afforded and submits that its request for time and personal hearing
was not duly considered. This contention would require examination
of the notices issued for personal hearing, their mode of service, the
dates fixed, the response of the Petitioner thereto and the complete
adjudication record.
55.
Significantly, the Impugned Order does record the grant of
opportunities of personal hearing. There is also an apparent
chronological inconsistency in paragraph 8.1 of the Impugned Order,
where one of the dates of hearing is recorded as 23.12.2025, although
the order is stated to have been passed on 12.02.2025. Such an
inconsistency cannot, by itself, establish that no hearing opportunity
was granted. At the highest, it calls for verification of the underlying
adjudication record.
56.
In these circumstances, particularly when the Impugned Order
records that opportunities of personal hearing were granted, we are not
inclined to set aside the adjudication proceedings in exercise of Article
226 merely on the basis of the aforesaid apparent date discrepancy.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
57.
The Petitioner has also contended that its reply to the DRC-01A
dated 28.05.2024 was not considered.
58.
The Impugned Order records in paragraph 7 that replies filed by
the Noticees were considered. The adjudicating authority has
thereafter dealt with the allegations concerning the availment of ITC,
receipt of goods, the statements recorded during investigation, the
applicability of Section 16, the invocation of Section 74 and the
liability towards interest and penalty.
59.
The question whether the Petitioner’s individual submissions,
including the objection regarding the earlier State GST proceedings,
were adequately appreciated is again a matter which can be examined
by the appellate authority on the basis of the complete record.
60.
The writ jurisdiction is not ordinarily intended to substitute the
statutory appellate examination of the merits of an adjudication order,
particularly where the order has been passed after issuance of a Show
Cause Notice and the adjudicating authority has recorded its reasons.
61.
The Petitioner has also questioned the clubbing of different
financial years in the impugned proceedings and contends that the
same affects limitation.
62.
The objection concerning limitation is necessarily dependent
upon the identification of the particular tax periods and the precise
transactions forming the subject matter of the demand. The Impugned
Order records the period covered by the proceedings and the basis on
which the Department invoked Section 74. Whether the statutory
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
requirements for invoking the extended period contemplated under
Section 74 were satisfied in respect of the particular liability of the
Petitioner is a matter which can be examined by the appellate
authority on the basis of the complete Show Cause Notice and the
adjudication record.
63.
The mere fact that the proceedings concern more than one
financial year does not, by itself, render the proceedings void. The
material question would be whether the demand pertaining to each
relevant period has been separately identifiable, whether the statutory
period of limitation is satisfied and whether the conditions for
invoking Section 74 are fulfilled. These are matters capable of
examination in appeal.
64.
The Petitioner has placed reliance upon the orders passed by the
State GST authorities, particularly the order dated 13.12.2023 in
respect of financial year 2017-18.
65.
The fact that an earlier State proceeding in respect of a
particular period may have culminated in an order does assume
relevance
while
considering
Section
6(2)(b).
However,
the
consequence of that order cannot be determined in isolation from the
precise allegations, tax period, ITC amount and transactions involved
in the Central proceedings.
66.
As noticed hereinabove, the statutory bar under Section 6(2)(b)
is attracted where proceedings are initiated on the same subject matter.
The mere fact that the Petitioner had earlier faced proceedings
concerning ITC allegedly availed from the same supplier does not,
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
without identification of the precise liability, establish that the entire
Central proceeding is rendered without jurisdiction.
67.
The Petitioner is, therefore, not precluded from raising the
aforesaid objection before the statutory appellate authority. On the
contrary, the appellate authority would be in a better position to
examine the complete record of the State proceedings along with the
Central Show Cause Notice and determine whether, to the extent of
any particular liability, the statutory bar under Section 6(2)(b) is
attracted.
68.
The present case is also distinguishable from a situation where a
subsequent authority is shown, on the face of the record, to have
initiated proceedings in respect of an identical liability which was
already the subject matter of a pending proceeding before another
competent GST authority. Here, the Petitioner has placed before us
proceedings pertaining to different financial years, involving different
notices and different stages of adjudication. The exact identity of the
liabilities has not been established merely by reference to the common
supplier.
69.
It is also relevant that the proceedings for financial year 2020-
21, referred to by the Petitioner, were initiated by notice dated
22.11.2024, whereas the Central Show Cause Notice was dated
06.06.2024. Thus, the subsequent initiation of State proceedings for
that financial year cannot, in any event, invalidate the earlier Central
initiation.
70.
Likewise, the State order stated to have been passed on
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
27.02.2025 in respect of financial year 2020-21 was passed after the
Central Order-in-Original dated 12.02.2025. Such subsequent
adjudication cannot retrospectively render the Central proceedings
without jurisdiction.
71.
This Court is conscious of the fact that the Petitioner’s principal
grievance is founded upon the statutory bar contained in Section
6(2)(b). A jurisdictional objection of this nature is undoubtedly
capable of being examined in writ jurisdiction in an appropriate case.
However, the present case involves determination of the precise
identity of the tax liability forming the subject matter of the respective
State
and
Central
proceedings.
That
determination
requires
examination of the respective notices, replies, orders and underlying
transaction-wise material.
72.
The existence of an efficacious statutory appellate remedy
assumes significance in such circumstances. The Petitioner has not
demonstrated, on the material placed before this Court, a case where
the Central proceedings are ex facie wholly without jurisdiction or
where the Impugned Order is liable to be set aside solely on account
of an undisputed violation of natural justice.
73.
The challenge based upon Section 6(2)(b), therefore, cannot be
accepted merely on the basis of the broad assertion that the same
supplier was involved in the earlier State proceedings. The statutory
provision requires identity of the subject matter and not merely
identity of an assessee, supplier or broad factual background.
74.
Similarly, the challenge on the ground that the Impugned Order
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
travels beyond the Show Cause Notice is not established on the face of
the record. The finding regarding non-receipt of goods and availment
of ITC on goods-less invoices, which forms a substantial basis of the
Impugned Order, is expressly recorded with reference to Section
16(2)(b).
75.
The allegations concerning fraud, wilful misstatement and
suppression of facts are relevant to the invocation of Section 74 and
do not, by themselves, constitute a new and unrelated demand.
Whether the material relied upon by the adjudicating authority is
sufficient to establish those ingredients is a matter for the appellate
forum.
76.
The Petitioner’s objections concerning the evidentiary value of
the statements recorded during investigation and its request for crossexamination also involve examination of the evidentiary record. The
Petitioner would be entitled to urge all such grounds before the
competent appellate authority in accordance with law.
77.
The Court is also unable to accept the submission that the mere
assertion of violation of natural justice warrants setting aside the
Impugned Order when the order itself records that opportunities of
personal hearing were granted. The Petitioner may demonstrate before
the appellate authority, on the basis of the underlying record, that the
opportunity was illusory or that its request for hearing was not
properly dealt with. At this stage, however, the material placed before
this Court does not justify bypassing the statutory remedy.
78.
The Petitioner’s reliance upon the judgments concerning
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
personal hearing, consideration of replies and the scope of an
adjudicating authority’s jurisdiction does not alter the aforesaid
conclusion.
Those
principles
are
undoubtedly
applicable
to
adjudication under the CGST Act. The question before us, however, is
whether the present record establishes such a fundamental breach as
would warrant interference under Article 226 notwithstanding the
statutory remedy. In the facts of the present case, the same has not
been established.
79.
There is yet another aspect which merits notice. The Petitioner
seeks, in substance, adjudication by this Court of the correctness of
the demand of Rs.47,93,104/-, the entitlement to ITC, the factual
question of receipt of goods, the evidentiary value of statements and
investigation material, the applicability of Section 74, the computation
of interest and the consequential penalty.
80.
Such an exercise would require this Court to enter into disputed
questions arising from the investigation and adjudication record. The
statutory appellate mechanism is specifically designed to undertake
such examination. There is no justification for this Court to assume
the role of the appellate authority in the present proceedings.
81.
This Court is, therefore, of the view that the Petitioner has not
made out a case warranting interference with the Impugned Order-inOriginal in exercise of the extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226
of the Constitution of India.
82.
The challenge to the Demand-cum-Show Cause Notice also
cannot survive independently once the adjudication proceedings have
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
culminated in a reasoned Order-in-Original. The Petitioner has an
efficacious remedy against the adjudication order and can urge therein
all grounds relating to jurisdiction, Section 6(2)(b), limitation, the
alleged discrepancy between the Show Cause Notice and the order,
natural justice, consideration of its replies, evidentiary material and
computation of liability.
83.
It is clarified that this Court has not adjudicated upon the
ultimate correctness of the demand raised against the Petitioner. In
particular, this Court has not expressed any final opinion on the
question whether, in respect of any particular financial year or
particular transaction, the proceedings initiated by the Central
authorities are barred by Section 6(2)(b). That question is left open for
consideration by the competent appellate authority on the basis of the
complete record.
84.
Likewise, no final opinion is being expressed on the Petitioner’s
contention regarding the admissibility of ITC, actual receipt of goods,
applicability of Section 16(2)(b) or Section 16(2)(c), invocation of
Section 74, limitation, interest or penalty.
85.
The observations made herein are confined to the question
whether the present case warrants exercise of writ jurisdiction against
the Impugned Order in view of the statutory appellate remedy
available to the Petitioner.
CONCLUSION:
86.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the present Writ Petition is
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
dismissed.
87.
The Petitioner shall be at liberty to avail the statutory remedy
available to it against the Impugned Order-in-Original, in accordance
with law. All contentions available to the Petitioner, including those
relating to Section 6(2)(b) of the CGST Act, the earlier proceedings
before the State GST authorities, limitation, natural justice, the alleged
variance between the Show Cause Notice and the Impugned Order,
admissibility of ITC, interest and penalty, are left open for
consideration by the Competent Authority in accordance with law.
88.
It is clarified that the dismissal of the present Writ Petition shall
not be construed as an expression of opinion on the merits of the
aforesaid contentions. The Competent Statutory Authority shall
consider the same independently and in accordance with the
applicable provisions of law.
89.
The pending application also stands closed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
BHARAT PARASHAR, J.
OCTOBER 01, 2026
jai/pal
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
10:53:25
W.P.(C) 9406/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review