Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC013759572018
+
W.P.(C) 12251/2018 & CM APPL. 47475/2018
M. P. SINGH
.....Petitioner
Through:
Dr. Surat Singh, Mr. Aadarsh Teotia,
Mr. Keshar Tanwar, Advocates.
versus
FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA AND ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Manoj, Ms. Aparna Sinha,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
ORDER
12.08.2026
%
1.
The Petitioner was prematurely retired from the service of the Food
Corporation of India1 on 5th July, 2002. More than two decades later, the
legality of that decision continues to occupy the parties and the Court. The
immediate challenge in the present petition, however, is to a communication
dated 21st June, 2018, by which FCI rejected a legal notice issued by the
Petitioner and stated that his case had already been reviewed and decided in
2004.
2.
The impugned 2018 communication was the latest step in a dispute
that had begun with the retirement order of 5 th July, 2002. Its effect cannot
be understood without looking at what happened in the intervening years,
“FCI”
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
particularly the representations made by the Petitioner, the decisions taken
by FCI and the earlier proceedings before this Court.
The record
3.
The Petitioner joined FCI in 1969 and rose through the ranks to the
post of Assistant Manager (Quality Control). By an order dated 10th October,
2001, passed in disciplinary proceedings, he was reduced to the lower time
scale of Technical Assistant Grade I2 for a period of three years.
4.
Regulation 22(2) of the Food Corporation of India (Staff)
Regulations, 1971 authorises premature retirement in the following terms:
“The appropriate authority shall, if it is of the opinion that it is in the
interest of the Corporation to do so, have the absolute right to retire a Cat.
I, II, III & IV employee after he has attained the age of 50 years by giving
him a notice of not less than 3 months in writing or 3 months pay and
allowances in lieu of such notice.”
5.
Regulation 22(5) identifies the competent authority, in relation to an
employee, as the authority competent to terminate the services of an
employee of equivalent rank under Regulation 19(1).
A Zonal Committee met on 24th June, 2002 to review the cases of
6.
Category II officers who had crossed the age of 50 years. The minutes
expressly describe the exercise as a review of “Cat. II officers”. They record
that the Committee considered 64 Assistant Managers (QC) and five
Assistant Managers (Depot), of whom 19 were found unfit for retention.
7.
One part of those minutes assumes significance. The Committee
noticed that M.L. Chauhan had already been reverted by the disciplinary
authority to TA I. It therefore recorded:
“During review it was observed that Sh. M.L. Chauhan was reverted by the
“TA I”
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
disciplinary authority as TA.I, therefore, Committee was of the view that his
case may be reviewed by Regional Office, Punjab.”
8.
The Petitioner had also been reduced to TA I before the Committee
met. His case was nevertheless considered in the Category II exercise.
Acting upon the recommendation of the Committee, the Zonal Manager
(North) passed the order dated 5th July, 2002 retiring him with immediate
effect under Regulation 22(2).
9.
The Petitioner challenged the decision administratively. He submitted
representations, including one dated 12th August, 2002, and also approached
this Court in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 6455/2002. On 4th August, 2003, the
writ petition was disposed of after FCI stated that a decision on the
representation was awaited. FCI was directed to decide it within two
months. The Court did not examine the validity of the retirement order.
10.
Meanwhile, the Petitioner had also addressed an appeal dated 22 nd
January, 2003 to FCI Headquarters. On 16th September, 2003, the Executive
Director at Headquarters examined the record and noticed the manner in
which M.L. Chauhan had been dealt with. The communication records that
the Petitioner had likewise been reverted to TA I before his case was
considered by the Committee and states:
“The records revealed that the case of Sh. M.P. Singh is also identical
because he had been reverted vide order dated 10/12-10-2001 to the post of
TA.I whereas the Committee has decided his case on 24.02.2002. Obviously,
this case also should have been reviewed by the Regional Office,
Punjab/Haryana.”
11.
The Zonal Office/Regional Office was accordingly asked to undertake
a fresh review and intimate its outcome.
12.
A further communication dated 15th October, 2003 from the Zonal
Office to the Senior Regional Manager, Punjab, records that, since the
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
Petitioner had been reverted to TA I, his case “should have been reviewed
by a committee of officers at R.O. level under Chairmanship of S.R.M.,
Punjab being Category III official”. It then explains how the Petitioner came
to be included in the Zonal review. His reversion from Assistant Manager to
TA I had not been reflected in the vigilance profile forwarded by the
Regional Office on 4th May, 2002. The Regional Office was asked to explain
the omission.
13.
FCI’s
own
contemporaneous
correspondence,
therefore,
acknowledged an anomaly in the original review process.
14.
The matter did not end there. A Committee chaired by the Managing
Director subsequently considered the representations of five officers,
including the Petitioner. The consequential memorandum dated 12th January,
2004 records:
“…the Committee, who in turn after going through all the relevant records
observed that all these officials have not made any new points. The
Committee observed that the action taken by Zonal Manager (North) in
exercise of powers conferred in 22(2) of the Food Corporation of India
(Staff) Regulations, 1971 is in order and rejected his representation.”
15.
The memorandum does not refer to the communication dated 16 th
September, 2003. It does not discuss the subsequent letter dated 15 th
October, 2003, the omission in the vigilance profile, or why the course
adopted for M.L. Chauhan need not be followed in the Petitioner’s case. The
Court, therefore, is unable to accept, without qualification, FCI’s submission
that the memorandum dated 12th January, 2004 demonstrably constituted
compliance with every aspect of the direction dated 16th September, 2003.
16.
That conclusion, however, does not decide this petition. On 23rd
February, 2004, the Petitioner filed an appeal/review before the Chairman,
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
FCI. It was expressly directed both against the retirement order dated 5 th
July, 2002 and the rejection communicated on 12th January, 2004. More
importantly, the Petitioner then raised in clear terms the very objection on
which the present petition rests. After referring to his reduction to TA I, he
stated that the Zonal Manager was not the appropriate authority and that the
Senior Regional Manager was competent to review a Category III employee.
The same appeal also questioned the amount paid in lieu of three months’
notice.
17.
By February 2004, therefore, the Petitioner was fully aware of the
factual and legal foundation of the case now advanced before this Court. The
objection was not latent or subsequently discovered. It had been identified,
articulated and made the basis of a claim for reinstatement.
18.
The Petitioner thereafter instituted W.P.(C) 19704/2004 challenging
the retirement order and the memorandum dated 12th January, 2004. That
petition was dismissed in default on 5th February, 2015. FCI has placed the
subsequent orders on record. The attempts to restore the proceeding
ultimately failed. On 18th July, 2017, this Court declined further restoration,
observing that the applications did not inspire confidence and that the
petition had been prosecuted “very casually”. A review petition was also
dismissed on 11th September, 2017.
19.
A few months later, the Petitioner issued a legal notice dated 21st
December, 2017, once again asserting that the direction dated 16 th
September, 2003 had remained unimplemented. Headquarters forwarded the
notice to the Executive Director (North) on 18 th January, 2018. The relevant
part reads:
“However, it appears that requisite action in the matter as per cited Hqrs.,
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
letter dated 16.09.2003 has not been taken by ZO(N) till date…”
20.
The expression used is “it appears”. Read as a whole, the
communication was prompted by the allegation contained in the Petitioner’s
legal notice and sought action upon it. It cannot fairly be treated as an
admission by FCI Headquarters that no review whatsoever had taken place
after 2003. At the same time, the communication does show that, even in
2018, the administrative record had not yielded a ready answer to the
question whether the particular direction of 16 th September, 2003 had been
acted upon.
21.
When no response came, the Petitioner filed W.P.(C) 5800/2018. On
28th May, 2018, this Court directed FCI to “positively respond” to the legal
notice within four weeks and convey its fate so that the Petitioner could
avail such remedies “as available in law, if need be”. The petition was
disposed of without examination of the underlying service dispute.
22.
FCI then passed the order dated 21st June, 2018. It referred to the
review conducted under the chairmanship of the Managing Director, the
Petitioner’s disciplinary record and ACRs, and stated that under the FCI
Delegation of Powers a higher authority could exercise powers delegated to
an authority below it. It consequently held that the review by the Zonal
Manager was tenable and rejected the legal notice.
23.
The Delegation of Powers relied upon in that order has not been
placed before this Court. The competence objection therefore need not be
decided at this stage, for the reasons which follow.
The rival positions
24.
Counsel appearing for the Petitioner submits that the fresh review
directed on 16th September, 2003 has never taken place. The distinction
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
between the review of his representation dated 12th August, 2002 and the
later direction for a fresh review is emphasised. Reliance is also placed upon
M.L. Chauhan’s case and the communication dated 15th October, 2003 to
contend that FCI itself accepted that the Petitioner’s reversion to TA I had
not been reflected in the vigilance profile and that his case ought to have
been considered at Regional Office level. The communication dated 18 th
January, 2018 is relied upon as confirmation that the exercise remained
incomplete.
25.
Counsel for FCI submits that the Petitioner, through successive
proceedings, seeks to unsettle an order of 2002. His case was reviewed by a
Committee chaired by the Managing Director and rejected on 12 th January,
2004. He thereafter challenged the matter in W.P.(C) 19704/2004 but
allowed that proceeding to be dismissed. A legal notice issued in 2017 and
the order passed upon it in 2018, it is argued, cannot furnish a fresh cause of
action. On merits, FCI relies upon the Petitioner’s disciplinary history and
ACRs and maintains that there was sufficient material for his premature
retirement.
Analysis
26.
The record presents two distinct questions. First, whether the original
review process suffered from a procedural infirmity, having regard to the
Petitioner’s reversion to TA I before the Zonal Committee considered his
case. Secondly, assuming such an infirmity arose, whether the Petitioner can
now reopen that issue through a challenge to the communication dated 21 st
June, 2018.
27.
On the first, the Petitioner’s grievance cannot simply be dismissed as
fanciful. He had been reduced to TA I before the Zonal Committee met.
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
That Committee was constituted to review Category II officers. It treated
M.L. Chauhan differently for precisely the reason that Chauhan had been
reverted to TA I. Headquarters thereafter described the Petitioner’s case as
“identical” in that respect and stated that it should have been reviewed by
the Regional Office. The Zonal Office then acknowledged that the
Petitioner’s reversion had not been reflected in the vigilance profile placed
before the Committee.
28.
The record thus discloses a substantial question regarding the original
process. But that question was neither unknown nor unavailable to the
Petitioner.
29.
He expressly raised it in his appeal/review dated 23rd February, 2004
and thereafter challenged the retirement order and the decision dated 12 th
January, 2004 in W.P.(C) 19704/2004.
30.
Once that proceeding was dismissed and restoration failed, the
challenge to the original decision, including the objection to the level of
review, stood abandoned.
31.
The Petitioner could not thereafter revive the same dispute merely by
reiterating the grievance in a legal notice and treating FCI’s response thereto
as giving rise to a fresh cause of action. The letter dated 18 th January, 2018
and the impugned communication dated 21st June, 2018 have to be viewed
against that procedural history. Neither communication reopened the
original proceedings or conferred upon the Petitioner a fresh right to
challenge the retirement order.
32.
The law on this aspect is settled. In C. Jacob v. Director of Geology
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
and Mining,3 the Supreme Court cautioned against permitting a stale service
dispute to acquire an appearance of freshness through a subsequent
representation and an order passed upon it. Consideration and rejection of
such a representation do not revive the original cause of action.
33.
Union of India v. M.K. Sarkar,4 carried the principle further. Delay
and laches are to be examined with reference to the original cause of action.
A direction by a Court to consider a representation, without adjudicating the
merits, and an order subsequently passed in compliance with that direction,
do not extend time or erase the delay.
34.
The same rule was reiterated in State of Uttaranchal v. Shiv Charan
Singh Bhandari.5 Repeated representations do not arrest the passage of
time, and an administrative decision taken pursuant to a judicial direction to
consider a stale claim does not give that claim a new life.
35.
Those principles fit this case closely. The order dated 28 th May, 2018
did not reopen the Petitioner’s retirement. It required only a response to his
legal notice. The words chosen by the Court are themselves instructive. The
Petitioner was left to pursue such remedies “as available in law”. The
direction preserved a remedy if one existed. It did not create one which had
ceased to remain available on account of the earlier course of proceedings.
36.
Likewise, the order dated 21st June, 2018 was not a fresh substantive
determination of the Petitioner’s service rights. The relief now sought cannot
be granted without reopening the retirement order and the events of 2003
and 2004. The form of the prayer cannot alter the substance of the
controversy.
(2008) 10 SCC 115
(2010) 2 SCC 59
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
Nor does the alleged deficiency in the memorandum dated 12 th
37.
January, 2004 alter the position. The Petitioner was aware of that grievance
in 2004, pursued it before this Court, and cannot now reopen it through a
later representation and response.
38.
The Court would not place the matter on the technical footing of res
judicata. W.P.(C) 19704/2004 was not decided on its merits. The
impediment is different. The Petitioner had already invoked the jurisdiction
of this Court in respect of the same retirement order, allowed that
proceeding to be dismissed, failed in restoration and review, and then
attempted to revive the same controversy through a legal notice. A stale
service dispute does not acquire a fresh life under Article 226 merely
because it is raised again through a later representation or proceeding.
39.
There is also a concern regarding disclosure. The petition does not set
out with sufficient candour the complete course and fate of W.P.(C)
19704/2004, including the failed restoration and review proceedings. Those
facts were material to the exercise of discretionary jurisdiction under Article
226.
40.
In Auroville Foundation v. Natasha Storey,6 the Supreme Court
reiterated that a party invoking Article 226 must disclose material facts and
earlier proceedings bearing on the relief sought. Successive proceedings for
substantially the same relief, without candid disclosure of the earlier
litigation, may legitimately be viewed as an abuse of process.
41.
The petition is, however, not being dismissed on suppression alone.
The correspondence of September and October 2003 did raise a procedural
(2013) 12 SCC 179
2025 INSC 348
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
concern, and FCI’s letter dated 18th January, 2018 added to the uncertainty.
But that does not alter the decisive fact: the grievance was known, asserted
and brought to Court in 2004. It cannot be revived in the present
proceedings through a later legal notice and response.
42.
The contention founded on parity with M.L. Chauhan requires closer
examination. The record establishes that both officers had been reverted to
TA I before the review and that FCI Headquarters treated their cases as
identical for the purpose of deciding the level at which the review ought to
occur. It does not establish that their service records, disciplinary histories or
ACRs were identical. Nor has the final decision of the Regional Office in
Chauhan’s case been placed on record. The Petitioner can therefore draw
support from Chauhan’s case on the question of procedure; he cannot claim,
on this material, an automatic entitlement to the same ultimate result.
43.
The remaining challenge to the retirement order does not take the
matter further. In Baikuntha Nath Das v. Chief District Medical Officer,
Baripada,7 the Supreme Court held that compulsory retirement in public
interest is not a punishment, carries no stigma, and that the principles of
natural justice have no place in the context of an order of compulsory
retirement. Judicial review remains available where the decision is mala
fide, rests on no evidence, or is so arbitrary that no reasonable person could
have formed the requisite opinion on the material before it.
44.
The Petitioner’s submission that the retirement is invalid merely
because no show cause notice or hearing preceded it cannot therefore be
accepted.
45.
Nor is this a case in which the record before the reviewing authorities
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
was wholly devoid of material. The Committee which examined the
Petitioner’s case in December 2003 had before it several disciplinary
penalties and the ACRs for 1994, 1995 and 1996. Those ACRs described his
performance as “FAIR” and repeatedly referred to the need for scrutiny on
account of his involvement in vigilance cases. Whether that material was
sufficient to warrant retirement was primarily for the competent authority.
This Court cannot undertake a fresh appraisal of the service record as an
appellate forum.
46.
The separate grievance concerning the amount of three months’ pay
does not require adjudication at this distance of time. It was specifically
raised in the Petitioner’s original appeal and again in the appeal/review
dated 23rd February, 2004. It stands on the same footing as the other
objections to the order of 5th July, 2002 and cannot acquire a fresh cause of
action through the proceedings of 2018.
47.
One final clarification is necessary. Since the Delegation of Powers
relied upon by FCI has not been produced, the Court expresses no opinion
on FCI’s contention that the Zonal Manager was competent to act. The
petition fails not on acceptance of that contention, but because the
competence objection was known, raised and carried to Court in 2004, and
cannot now be reopened through the 2018 response to a legal notice.
Conclusion
48.
The position can thus be stated concisely. The record does disclose an
arguable irregularity in the manner in which the Petitioner’s case was
originally placed before the Zonal Committee in 2002. FCI itself noticed
that irregularity in 2003. But the Petitioner was aware of the point, raised it
(1992) 2 SCC 299
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
before the Corporation, and carried his challenge to this Court in 2004. The
later failure to prosecute that proceeding cannot be repaired by a
representation made in 2017. The letter dated 18th January, 2018, the
direction of this Court dated 28th May, 2018, and FCI’s consequential order
dated 21st June, 2018 neither effaced the intervening history nor revived the
original cause of action.
49.
The petition is accordingly dismissed. All pending applications stand
disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
AUGUST 12, 2026/ab
W.P.(C) 12251/2018
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 17/08/2026 at 12:14:00
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review