The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
24. 04.2025 [1] Mr. S. Lokhendro, learned counsel, appears for the petitioner; Mr. A. Golly, learned counsel, appears for respondent Nos.1 to 6 and Mr. S. Kaminikumar, learned CGC, appears for respondent 8 & 10. [2] The present revision petition has been filed against the dismissal order dated 04.05.2016 passed by the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Imphal West-I in Judl. Misc. No.140 of 2015. [3] According to the petitioner, she has received the suit land through a registered gift deed bearing No.1277 of 2012 dated 06.06.2012 from her elder brother namely Moirangthem Tombi Singh and hence, the petitioner has filed instant Judl. Misc. Case No.140 of 2015 on the file of the Civil Judge(Junior Division), Imphal West-I to implead the applicant as party in the aforesaid suit. According to her, she is necessary party in the aforesaid suit as the gift deed has been executed in favour of the applicant and therefore, no prejudice will be cause to the respondents. [4] Mr. A. Golly, learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos. 1 to 6 has strongly objected by stating that the first defendant is a party in the aforesaid suit namely Shri Oinam Hemanta Singh and Civil Judge(Junior Division), Imphal West-I has granted injunction order on 11.02.2005 in Judl. Misc. case No.45 of 2005 by restraining the defendant No.1 his men and privies from committing any act to change the nature of the suit land …
58. From a conspectus of all the aforesaid judgments, touching upon the present aspect, broadly, the following would emerge: i. First, for the purpose of impleading a transferee pendente lite, the facts and circumstances should be gone into and basing on the necessary facts, the Court can permit such a party to come on record, either under Order I Rule 10 CPC or under Order XXII Rule 10 CPC, as a general principle; Page 34 of 35 ii. Secondly, a transferee pendente lite is not entitled to come on record as a matter of right; iii. Thirdly, there is no absolute rule that such a transferee pendente lite, with the leave of the Court should, in all cases, be allowed to come on record as a party; iv. Fourthly, the impleadment of a transferee pendente lite would depend upon the nature of the suit and appreciation of the material available on record; v. Fifthly, where a transferee pendente lite does not ask for leave to come on record, that would obviously be at his peril, and the suit may be improperly conducted by the plaintiff on record; vi. Sixthly, merely because such transferee pendente lite does not come on record, the concept of him (transferee pendente lite) not being bound by the judgment does not arise and consequently he would be bound by the result of the litigation, though he remains unrepresented; vii. Seventhly, the sale transaction pendente lite is hit by the provisions of …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
JOHN
JOHN TELEN KOM
2025.04.30
TELEN KOM Date:
11:29:31 +05'30'
Item No.6
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
CRP(C.R.P. Art.227)No.31 of 2016
Smt. Moirangthem Ningol Thounaojam ongbi Pusparani
Devi, aged about 56 years W/o Dr. Th. Naranbabu Singh
resident of Kangla Sangomshang Imphal East District
Manipur At present residing at Doctor’s Colony, Quarter No.
Type V/22 Regional Institute of Medical Sciences Lamphel,
Imphal West District PO & PS Lamphel, Manipur.
Petitioner
Vs.
Km. Yurembam Inakhunbi Devi aged about 43 years D/o late
Y. Chandrahas Singh resident of Thangmeiband Lourungpurel
Leikai PO & PS Lamphel, District Imphal West, Manipur & 9
Ors.
Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. D. KRISHNAKUMAR
ORDER
(Oral)
24.04.2025
[1]
Mr. S. Lokhendro, learned counsel, appears for the petitioner;
Mr. A. Golly, learned counsel, appears for respondent Nos.1 to 6 and Mr. S.
Kaminikumar, learned CGC, appears for respondent 8 & 10.
[2]
The present revision petition has been filed against the dismissal
order dated 04.05.2016 passed by the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Imphal
West-I in Judl. Misc. No.140 of 2015.
[3]
According to the petitioner, she has received the suit land
through a registered gift deed bearing No.1277 of 2012 dated 06.06.2012 from
her elder brother namely Moirangthem Tombi Singh and hence, the petitioner
has filed instant Judl. Misc. Case No.140 of 2015 on the file of the Civil
Judge(Junior Division), Imphal West-I to implead the applicant as party in the
aforesaid suit. According to her, she is necessary party in the aforesaid suit
as the gift deed has been executed in favour of the applicant and therefore,
no prejudice will be cause to the respondents.
[4]
Mr. A. Golly, learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos. 1 to
6 has strongly objected by stating that the first defendant is a party in the
aforesaid suit namely Shri Oinam Hemanta Singh and Civil Judge(Junior
Division), Imphal West-I has granted injunction order on 11.02.2005 in Judl.
Misc. case No.45 of 2005 by restraining the defendant No.1 his men and
privies from committing any act to change the nature of the suit land and also
to alienate the suit land or any part thereof to any-body.
[5]
According to the learned counsel appearing for the respondent
Nos. 1 to 6, the aforesaid injunction has been in force and the first defendant
has executed the sale deed in favour of the petitioner vide Regd. Deed of Sale
being No.995 of 2009 dated 22.04.2009 and subsequently, Shri Moirangthem
Tombi Singh, the aforesaid brother has executed the Gift deed in favour of the
petitioner herein.
[6]
According to the learned counsel of respondent Nos. 1 to 6, the
aforesaid contention raised by the petitioner has been duly considered and it
has been rightly discussed by the Civil Judge(Junior Division), Imphal West-I
and detailed order has been passed under Section 52 of Transfer of Property
Act. Ordinarily, a pendent lite purchaser’s application for impleadment is
normally be allowed or considered liberally the reason being there is chances
of the transferor having no more interest in the property may not properly
defend the suit or may even collude with the plaintiff against the transferee.
But on the facts of the case is concerned, injunction has already been granted
by the learned trial court restraining the defendant No.1 committing any act to
change the nature of the suit land and also to alienate the suit land or any part
thereof to any-body. According to learned counsel appearing for respondent
Nos.1 to 6, the aforesaid injunction order has been disobeyed by the
defendant No.1 and executed the sale deed in favour of the petitioner’s
brother. Therefore, the trial court has rightly rejected the said application.
Further, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents has relied upon
the judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in (1995) 6 SCC 50, in
the case of Surjit Singh & Ors. Vs. Harbans Singh & Ors. the relevant para 4
is reproduced as follow:
“4. As said before, the assignment is by means of a registered deed. The
assignment had taken place after the passing of the preliminary decree
in which Pritam Singh has been allotted 1/3rd share. His right to property
to that extent stood established. A decree relating to immovable property
worth more than hundred rupees, if being assigned, was required to be
registered. That has instantly been done. It is per se property, for it
relates to the immovable property involved in the suit. It clearly and
squarely fell within the ambit of the restraint order. In sum, it did not make
any appreciable difference whether property per se had been alienated
or a decree pertaining to that property. In defiance of the restraint order,
the alienation/assignment was made. If we were to let it go as such, it
would defeat the ends of justice and the prevalent public policy. When
the Court intends a particular state of affairs to exist while it is in seisin
of a lis, that state of affairs is not only required to be maintained, but it is
presumed to exist till the Courts orders otherwise. The Court, in these
circumstances has the duty, as also the right, to treat the
alienation/assignment as having not taken place at all for tis purposes.
Once that is so, Pritam Singh and his assignees, respondents herein,
cannot claim to be impleaded as parties on the basis of assignment.
Therefore, the assignees-respondents could not have been impleaded
by the trial court as parties to the suit, in disobedience of its orders. The
principles of lis pendens are altogether on a different footing. We do not
propose to examine their involvement presently. All what is emphasized
is that the signees in the present facts and circumstances had no cause
to be impleaded as parties to the suit. On that basis, there was no cause
for going into the question of interpretation of paragraphs 13 & 14 of the
settlement deed. The path treaded by the courts below was, in our view,
out of their bounds. Unhesitatingly, we upset all the three orders of the
courts below and reject the application of the assignees of rimpleadment
under order 22 Rule 10 CPC.”
Further, the learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos.1-6
has relied upon the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of H.
Anjanappa & Ors. Vs. A. Prabhakar & Ors passed in Civil Appeal Nos. 11801181 of 2025 and the relevant paras 57 & 58 are reproduced hereunder as:
“57. Having regard to the fact that the Respondent Nos. 1 and 2
respectively purchased the suit property during the pendency of the suit
instituted for specific performance and that too, while the injunction
against the original owner (transferor) was operating, the Respondent
Nos. 1 and 2 respectively could not be said to have even made out any
good case for grant of leave to appeal.
58. From a conspectus of all the aforesaid judgments, touching upon the
present aspect, broadly, the following would emerge:
i. First, for the purpose of impleading a transferee pendente lite, the facts
and circumstances should be gone into and basing on the necessary
facts, the Court can permit such a party to come on record, either under
Order I Rule 10 CPC or under Order XXII Rule 10 CPC, as a general
principle; Page 34 of 35
ii. Secondly, a transferee pendente lite is not entitled to come on record
as a matter of right; iii. Thirdly, there is no absolute rule that such a
transferee pendente lite, with the leave of the Court should, in all cases,
be allowed to come on record as a party;
iv. Fourthly, the impleadment of a transferee pendente lite would depend
upon the nature of the suit and appreciation of the material available on
record;
v. Fifthly, where a transferee pendente lite does not ask for leave to
come on record, that would obviously be at his peril, and the suit may be
improperly conducted by the plaintiff on record;
vi. Sixthly, merely because such transferee pendente lite does not come
on record, the concept of him (transferee pendente lite) not being bound
by the judgment does not arise and consequently he would be bound by
the result of the litigation, though he remains unrepresented;
vii. Seventhly, the sale transaction pendente lite is hit by the provisions
of Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act; and,
viii. Eighthly, a transferee pendente lite, being an assignee of interest in
the property, as envisaged under Order XXII Rule 10 CPC, can seek
leave of the Court to come record on his own or at the instance of either
party to the suit.”
[7]
Considering the aforesaid judgement of the decisions of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court and the facts and circumstances of the case where
the applicant’s brother has executed Gift Deed on 06.06.2012 in favour of the
petitioner. The said execution of Gift Deed by the petitioner’s brother is at the
time when the injunction order is in force and considering Section 52 of the
Transfer of Property Act, the trial court has rightly came to the conclusion that
the applicant cannot be added as a party defendant in the suit.
[8]
Considering the facts of the case and on perusal of the order
passed by the learned trial court, this Court does not required for any
interference with the said order of the trial Court and consequently, the present
Civil Revision petition is dismissed.
[9]
It is made clear that since the said suit is of the year 2005, the
learned Civil Judge Junior Division, Imphal West-I is directed to dispose of
the said suit as early as possibly within a period of 6(six) months from the date
of receipt of a copy of this order.
CHIEF JUSTICE
John Kom
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review