The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. As rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the petitioners, this is a typical case where there had been blatant violation of the prescribed procedures of law in dealing with the appeal preferred by the petitioners. No doubt, the above course adopted by the authorities concerned had caused prejudice to the petitioners since they lost their opportunity to challenge the findings of the Food Analyst, and also to have the food sample analysed at the Referral Food Laboratory at the appropriate time. That being so, the prayer in this petition to quash the prosecution proceedings against the petitioners, is well founded. In the result, the petition stands allowed. The proceedings against the petitioners/accused Nos.1 and 2 in C.C.No.113/2019 on 2025:KER:30886 the files of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Haripad are hereby quashed. (SD/-) G. GIRISH, JUDGE jsr 2025:KER:30886 ANNEXURE-I TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT DATED 20.3.2018 OF ANNEXURE -II TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE DATED 17.3.2018 OF THE 3RD RESPONDENT ANNEXURE - III TRUE COPY OF THE APPEAL MEMORANDUM SUBMITTED ANNEXURE - IV TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE AND FOOD ANALYST'S REPORT DATED 14.11.2017 AND 6.11.2017 ANNEXURE - V TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 2.7.2018 THIS HON'BLE COURT THIS HON'BLE IN W.P.(C) NO. 18288/2018 ANNEXURE - VI UNDER SEC. 4295) OF THE FSS ACT IN CC NO.113/2019 BEFORE THE JUDICIAL FIRST CLASS
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE G.GIRISH
THURSDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 20TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.MC NO. 6650 OF 2019
AGAINST CC NO.113 OF 2019 OF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE OF FIRST
CLASS- I, HARIPAD
PETITIONERS/1ST AND 2ND ACCUSED:
M K RAMACHANDRAN
AGED 50 YEARS
S/O KUNJU PILLAI, RESIDING AT MOONAMKUTTYCHIRAYIL,
NAGIARKULANGARA, HAIPAD - 690 513 ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT
SATHEESH KUMAR
AGED 48 YEARS
S/O. S.A. SUBRAMONIAN, KULANGARA TRADERS, KARAZHMA
CHANTHAI, CHENNITHAI - 690 105, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT
BY ADV R.RAJASEKHARAN PILLAI
RESPONDENTS/STATE AND 2ND RESPONDENT:
THE STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY THE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF
KERALA
FOOD SAFETY OFFICER
HARIPAD, ALAPPUZHA DISTRICT
THE NAME OF THE 2ND RESPONDENT OCCURRING IN CRL.M.C IS
DELETED AS PER ORDER DATED 12/03/2020 IN
CRL.M.A.NO.2/2019 IN CRL.M.C.NO.6650/2019
BY SRI.GRASHIOUS KURIAKOSE, ADDL.DIRECTOR GENERAL OF
PROSECUTION
THIS CRIMINAL MISC. CASE HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
08.04.2025, THE COURT ON 10.04.2025 PASSED THE FOLLOWING:
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
ORDER
The petitioners are the accused in C.C.No.113/2019 on the
files of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Haripad, a case which
arose out of a complaint filed by the Food Safety Officer, Haripad
Circle under section 42(5) of the Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006
(hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’).
In the present petition filed
under Section 482 Cr.P.C, the petitioners seek to quash the
proceedings in the said case.
2.
The complainant had purchased 2 Kgs of Coriander from
the shop conducted by the first petitioner as licensee in Building
No.337 situated in Ward No.17 at Nangiarkulangara in Chingoli
Panchayat. The second petitioner is the warrantor who sold the above
food item to the first petitioner. The aforesaid food item was found to
have been unsafe under Section 3.1.(zz).(ix) of the Act since it
contained dead and living insects in the analysis conducted by the
Food Analyst.
The second part of the sample was not sent to the
Referral Food Laboratory since there was no such request in the
appeal filed by the petitioners. In view of the above violation detected
by the Food Safety Officer, he preferred a complaint before the
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
learned Magistrate on 12.04.2019. The learned Magistrate took the
complaint to files and issued summons to the petitioners to answer
the charge under Section 26(1)(2)(i) read with Section 59(i) of the
Act.
3.
In the present petition, the petitioners would contend that
the prosecution launched against them is prima facie unsustainable
since the complaint does not bring out the offence alleged against
them. It is further contended that there is infraction of the mandatory
procedural requirements of the Act and the Rules framed thereunder,
and hence the prosecution against them is liable to be quashed.
4.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners and the
learned Public Prosecutor representing the State of Kerala.
5.
It is pointed out by the learned counsel for the petitioners
that there had been flagrant violation of the requirement of Section
42(2) of the Act to analyse the food sample and to send the report
mentioning the method of sampling and analysis within 14 days to the
designated officer with a copy to the Commissioner of Food Safety.
Thus, it is argued that the non-compliance of the aforesaid provision
of law would vitiate the prosecution initiated against the petitioners.
Per contra, the learned Additional Director General of Prosecution
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
would submit that the time limit prescribed in the aforesaid Section is
having no consequence if the Food Analyst had informed the
Designated Officer and the Commissioner of Food Safety giving
reasons for the failure to analyse the food sample within the aforesaid
period and specifying the time to be taken for analysis in accordance
with the proviso to Section 46(3) of the Act.
By adverting to a
statement submitted by the Food Analyst on 31.01.2018 mentioning
that the analysis report of the 11 food samples described in the table
thereunder could not be sent due to incompletion of the analysis of
the sample within the stipulated time, the learned Additional Director
General of Prosecution submitted that the requirement of the proviso
to Section 46(3) of the Act is fulfilled since the food sample involved
in this case is shown as item No.4 in that table. Thus, it is argued
that the failure of the Food Analyst to send the analysis report within
14 days of the receipt of the sample cannot be taken as a reason to
assail the prosecution in the present case. The argument advanced
by the learned Additional Director General of Prosecution in the above
regard has to be accepted since it is seen that there is substantial
compliance of the requirements of the proviso to Section 46(3) of the
Act, and hence the failure of the Food Analyst to complete the
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
analysis of food within 14 days and to send the report to the
Designated Officer and the Commissioner of Food Safety, cannot be
taken as a ground to quash the prosecution initiated against the
petitioners.
6.
The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that
there had been complete non-compliance of the relevant provisions of
law by the authorities concerned in dealing with the appeal filed by
the petitioners, and hence the prosecution initiated against them is
apparently vitiated due to the serious prejudice caused to the
petitioners.
Referring
to
Annexure-III
copy
of
the
Appeal
Memorandum, the learned counsel for the petitioners pointed out that
the appeal against the report of the Food Analyst was preferred by
the petitioners on 19.04.2018, but the authorities concerned slept
over it.
It is further contended by the learned counsel for the
petitioners that even after the order passed by this Court in W.P.(C)
No.18288/2018 on 02.07.2018 directing the Assistant Commissioner of
Food Safety to take up, consider and pass orders on the appeal with
notice to the petitioners within a period of two months from the date
of receipt of a copy of the above judgment, the authorities concerned
did not take any action. It is thus argued that the complaint preferred
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
by the Food Safety Officer contains the false representation in
paragraph No.6 that the accused did not prefer appeal under section
46(4) of the Act and therefore the second part of the sample was not
sent to the Referral Food Laboratory for analysis.
7.
By
referring
to
the
case
file
maintained
by
the
complainant, the learned Additional Director General of Prosecution
submitted that the appeal filed by the petitioners was considered by
the Assistant Commissioner of Food Safety, Alappuzha in compliance
with the direction of this Court in W.P.(C) No.18288/2018 after giving
notice to the petitioners, but the petitioners did not care to appear
before the said authority. Accordingly, the Appellate Authority is said
to have decided the appeal against the petitioners as per the order
passed on 26.10.2019.
Thus, according to the learned Additional
Director General of Prosecution, there had been no infraction of the
relevant provisions of law pertaining to the disposal of the appeal
preferred by the persons aggrieved by the findings of Food Analyst.
8.
On going through the records of the case, it is seen that
there had been apparent laxity on the part of the authorities
concerned in dealing with the appeal filed by the petitioners against
the findings of the Food Analyst. As already stated above,
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
Annexure-III would reveal that the petitioners preferred appeal
against the findings of the Food Analyst on 19.04.2018. Since the
aforesaid appeal was not considered or disposed of by the Appellate
Authority, this Court directed the Assistant Commissioner of Food
Safety, Alappuzha, in W.P.(C) No.18288/2018, to take up, consider and
pass orders in the statutory appeal filed by the petitioners within a
period of two months from the date of receipt of a copy of that
judgment dated 02.07.2018.
Instead of complying with the aforesaid
direction of this Court, the prosecution is seen to have been launched
against the petitioners on 12.04.2019. It is after six months from the
launch of the prosecution as above that the Designated Officer felt it
necessary to comply with the direction of this Court in the aforesaid
writ petition to consider the appeal preferred by the petitioners.
Accordingly, a notice is seen to have been issued to the petitioners on
14.10.2019
directing
them
to
appear
before
the
Assistant
Commissioner of Food Safety and the Designated Officer, Alappuzha at
11:30 a.m on 21.10.2019 for a hearing. On 26.10.2019, the Assistant
Commissioner of Food Safety and Designated Officer, Alappuzha
passed the order rejecting the appeal, noting the absence of
petitioners, and also stating the reason that the one and only remedy
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
prescribed under the law is to challenge the findings of the Food
Analyst through an appellate analysis, which was not availed by the
food business operator, and hence the appeal preferred by the
petitioners cannot be entertained.
9.
At the outset, it has to be stated that the way in which the
Appellate Authority dealt with the appeal preferred by the petitioners
was in flagrant violation of the established principles of law. The fact
that the authorities concerned paid no heed to the order passed by
this Court in W.P.(C) No.18288/2018 on 02.07.2018 for more than one
year, discloses their recalcitrant and callous attitude in following rule
of law. There is absolutely no explanation offered by the authorities
concerned for their contemptuous act of ignoring the directions of this
Court in the judgment dated 02.07.2018 in W.P.(C) No.18288/2018 to
take up, consider and pass orders in the appeal within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of a copy of that judgment. The fact
that the authorities concerned ventured to launch prosecution against
the petitioners on 12.04.2019 by misrepresenting that the accused did
not prefer appeal, can only expose the contumacious conduct on the
part of the department officials. The course adopted by the authorities
concerned, deciding to consider the appeal filed by the petitioners
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
after six months from the institution of the complaint against them is
like putting the horse behind the cart. Needless to say that the basic
canons of law to be followed in dealing with the prosecution of cases
of this nature had been flown to winds by the authorities concerned.
Thus, it has to be stated that the above conduct adopted by the
department would vitiate the prosecution initiated against the
petitioners.
10.
The reasoning in the order passed by the Assistant
Commissioner of Food Safety and the Designated Officer on
26.10.2019 in the appeal filed by the petitioners to reject the appeal,
is not in consonance with the relevant provisions of law. The Appellate
Authority had found fault with the petitioners for incorporating the
relief sought for in the appeal memorandum, praying to reject the
findings of the Analyst and exonerate the appellants by setting aside
the aforesaid findings. According to the Appellate Authority, the one
and only remedy which the petitioners could seek in an appeal filed
under Section 46(4) of the Act and Rule 2.4.6 of the Food Safety and
Standards Rules was to challenge the findings of the Food Analyst by
requesting the analysis of the other sample at the Referral Food
Laboratory. The above view of the Appellate Authority is not in
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
consonance with the aforesaid provisions of law. Sub Section (4) of
Section 46 of the Act reads as follows:
“46. Functions of Food Analyst
(1)
xxx
xxx
(4) An appeal against the report of Food Analyst shall lie
before the Designated Officer who shall, if he so decides,
refer the matter to the referral food laboratory as notified by
the Food Authority for opinion.”
11.
It is clear from the aforesaid provision of law that the
question of referring the matter to the Referral Food Laboratory is
only one of the options of the Designated Officer if he felt the above
course to be followed. So also, it is clear from the wordings in Rule
2.4.6 of the Food Safety and Standards Rules that the sending of one
part of the sample to the Referral Food Laboratory depends upon the
decision of the Designated Officer in the above regard. The aforesaid
provisions of law do not forbid the Designated Officer from
considering the other challenges raised by the petitioners against the
violation of the procedural requirements of law by the Food Analyst.
Therefore, the Designated Officer cannot say the excuse that he did
not consider the appeal preferred by the petitioners since there was
no prayer in it to send the alternate sample to the Referral Food
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
Laboratory.
2025:KER:30886
That apart, even in the absence of any prayer in that
regard, the Designated Officer could have opted for sending the
available sample to the Referral Food Laboratory after following the
requisite procedures. Thus, it has to be concluded that the reasons
stated by the Designated Officer/Appellate Authority in the order
dated 26.10.2019 for rejecting the appeal preferred by the petitioners,
can only be taken as an attempt to cover up their failure to take
prompt action in the appeal filed by the petitioners.
12.
As rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the
petitioners, this is a typical case where there had been blatant
violation of the prescribed procedures of law in dealing with the
appeal preferred by the petitioners.
No doubt, the above course
adopted by the authorities concerned had caused prejudice to the
petitioners since they lost their opportunity to challenge the findings
of the Food Analyst, and also to have the food sample analysed at the
Referral Food Laboratory at the appropriate time. That being so, the
prayer in this petition to quash the prosecution proceedings against
the petitioners, is well founded.
In the result, the petition stands allowed. The proceedings
against the petitioners/accused Nos.1 and 2 in C.C.No.113/2019 on
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
the files of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Haripad are
hereby quashed.
(SD/-)
G. GIRISH, JUDGE
jsr
Crl.M.C.No.6650/2019
2025:KER:30886
APPENDIX OF CRL.MC 6650/2019
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
ANNEXURE-I
TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT DATED 20.3.2018 OF
THE FOOD ANALYST
ANNEXURE -II
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE DATED 17.3.2018 OF
THE 3RD RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE - III
TRUE COPY OF THE APPEAL MEMORANDUM SUBMITTED
BY THE PETITIONERS BEFORE THE ASST.
COMMISSIONER FOOD SAFETY RESPONDENT
ANNEXURE - IV
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE AND FOOD ANALYST'S
REPORT DATED 14.11.2017 AND 6.11.2017
ANNEXURE - V
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 2.7.2018 THIS
HON'BLE COURT THIS HON'BLE IN W.P.(C) NO.
18288/2018
ANNEXURE - VI
TRUE COPY OF THE PRIVATE COMPLAINT FILED
UNDER SEC. 4295) OF THE FSS ACT IN CC
NO.113/2019 BEFORE THE JUDICIAL FIRST CLASS
MAGISTRATE COURT HARIPAD
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review