Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 21ST DAY OF JULY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP SINGH YERUR
MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.9186 OF 2025 (CPC)
BETWEEN:
1.
M.K MURUGAPPA GOWDA
S/O LATE KAPPANNA
AGED ABOUT 80 YEARS,
R/AT JYOTHINAGARA,
NEAR K.E.B QUARTERS,
SIRA TOWN,
TUMKURU DISTRICT,
REP.BY HIS POWER OF ATTORNEY HOLDER
DR.PRASAD.
S/O M.K.MURUGAPPA GOWDA
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
R/AT NEAR TUMKURU TOWN PLANNING AUTHORITY
HANUMANTHAPURA
TUMKUR TOWN, TUMKURU
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. K B S MANIAN.,ADVOCATE)
Digitally
signed by
VINUTHA M
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
AND:
1. M/S THE REMCO (BHEL) EMPLOYEES HOUSE
BUILDING CO OPERATIVE SOCIETY
NO.560, 1ST FLOOR,
52ND CROSS, 3RD BLOCK
RAJAJINAGAR
BENGALURU 560 010.
REP. BY ITS SECRETARY.
2.
R. VIMALA
W/O BALARAMA. C
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS,
R/AT NO.9/11, 35TH CROSS,
PURNA PRAGNA LAYOUT,
-2HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
BENGALURU 560 061.
3.
THE COMMISSIONER
BRUHAT BENGALURU MAHANAGARA PALIKE
J.C ROAD,
BENGALURU
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.SHARATH S GOWDA .,ADVOCATE FOR R-2;
NOTICE TO R-1 IS DISPENSED WITH V.O.D 21.07.2026)
THIS MFA IS FILED U/O.43 RULE 1(r) OF THE CPC,
AGAINST THE ORDER DT. 18.09.2025 PASSED ON I.A NO.1
IN O.S.NO. 5232/2022
ON THE FILE OF THE X ADDITIONAL
CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BENGALURU (CCH-26),
REJECTING IA NO. 1 FILED U/O.39 RULE 1 AND 2 OF CPC.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP SINGH YERUR
ORAL JUDGMENT
This appeal is preferred by the appellant who is the
plaintiff in O. S. No. 5232 of 2022 being aggrieved by the
order dated 18.09.2025 passed on IA No. 1 under OrderXXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of CPC.
(i) Brief facts of the case
2. The appellant filed a suit in O.S No. 5232/2022
against the respondent, seeking the following reliefs.
-3HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
"i) To restrain the 2nd Defendant, her heirs, legal
representatives, assigns, etc from interfering with
the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit
schedule site of the Plaintiff, by granting decree of
permanent injunction and,
ii) Direct the 3rd Defendant to effect the katha of
the schedule site in the name of the Plaintiff by
granting an order of mandatory injunction and also
grant such other reliefs as this Hon'ble Court deems
fit to grant under the circumstances of the above
case with costs in the interest of justice and equity."
2.1 It is the case of the appellant that Remco BHEL
House Building Co-operative Society ('the Society' for
short) had formed a residential layout over several acres
of land in Pattanagare village during 1984-1985 for the
benefit of its employees. The society had acquired the
lands by virtue of acquisition initiated by the BDA.
Accordingly, an allotment letter dated 31.01.1992 was
issued and subsequently, a registered sale deed executed
on 13.05.1995 in favour of its allottee - Sujatha Ratnakar.
2.2 It is a further case of the appellant that
acquisition
proceedings
were
challenged
by
certain
-4HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
landowners before this Court and this Court struck down
the acquisition of the lands. Pursuant to the acquisition
proceedings being struck down, Society preferred an
appeal before the Hon'ble Apex Court, which came to be
dismissed
and the Society was directed to restore the
possession of the land to the landowners. However, by
that time the residential layout was fully formed and
several employees had already constructed their houses.
The private negotiations and fact that the residential
layout was already formed was not before the Hon'ble
Apex Court.
2.3 It is further pleaded that subsequent to the
judgment
of
the
Hon'ble
Apex
Court
affirming
the
quashing of the acquisition proceeding, the Society had
entered
into
private
negotiations
with
land
owners,
additional compensation was paid and a declaration cum
ratification deeds were executed in the year 2000 to
regularise the transaction.
-5HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
2.4 It is also pleaded that the layout came under the
jurisdiction of BBMP in the year 2007 and khatas were
transferred and registered in the names of allottees. The
khatas
were
unilaterally
cancelled
by
the
respondent/defendant no.3/BBMP, consequent to which
Writ petitions were filed in W.P. Nos.14665-675/2012,
which were allowed setting aside the order of cancellation
of the khata, vide order dated 13.02.2013.
2.5 The appellant/plaintiff claim that predecessorsin-title were always in possession and enjoyment of the
suit schedule property and they had paid upto date taxes.
The encumbrance certificates, tax paid receipts and khata
certificates
are
all
standing
in
the
name
of
the
predecessors in title since 1995. On the contrary, there
are
no
revenue
records
reflecting
the
names
of
defendants, who claim to have allegedly purchased the
land from the land owners.
-6HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
2.6 The appellant/plaintiff filed a
suit against the
defendants seeking the reliefs hereinabove mentioned.
Along with the plaint, he filed an application under OrderXXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of CPC to restrain the defendant no.
2 from interfering with his peaceful possession and
enjoyment of the suit schedule property during the
pendency of the suit.
3.
The
defendants
appeared
and
filed
their
statement of objections. Defendant no. 2 denied the claim
of the plaintiff and took up the plea that when the land
acquisition was quashed, the possession was re-delivered
by the society in favour of the landowners, which was
confirmed by defendant no. 1 through its letter dated
09.10.2002 addressed to the State Government. Insofar
as the agreement said to be entered between the
defendant no.1 and land owners is concerned, it is
contended by the defendant no.2 that it is a fabricated
document and it is an unregistered document, which do
-7HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
not convey any right, title and interest in favour of
defendant no.1.
3.1 Further, it was pleaded by defendant no. 2 that
she has purchased the suit schedule property from one
Mirle Varadraj and it is her contention that original land
owners have sold the land measuring 2 acres 17 guntas in
Sy.no.17/2 under a registered sale deed dated 27.12.2004
in favour of one Karishanayya and said Karishanayya
executed a GPA on 30.05.2009, which was coupled with
interest and subsequent thereof, the GPA was ratified on
19.03.2020, empowering the power of attorney holder to
sell the property. On the basis of said power of attorney,
one Mirle Varadraj has formed the lay out, executed sale
deed dated 05.10.2020 in respect of Site no.23 in
Sy.No.17/2 measuring 40 feet x 60 feet in favour of
defendant no. 2 and hence the defendant no. 2 is a
bonafide purchaser who has already obtained the licence
-8HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
and
sanction
plan
and
also
entered
into
a
joint
development agreement dated 18.04.2022.
3.2 On these grounds, she sought for rejection of the
application.
4. The said application - IA No. 1 was heard by the
learned trial judge and upon consideration of the materials
and submissions made therein, the trial Court did not find
favour with the plaintiff to grant an interim order of
injunction and agreed with the defendant no. 2 and hence
passed an order rejecting the application - I.A. No.1 filed
under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of CPC. It is this order
that is questioned before this court in this appeal.
(ii) Contentions of learned counsel for
appellant/plaintiff
5. It is the vehement contention of learned counsel Sri K.B.S. Manian appearing for the appellant/plaintiff that
the impugned order passed by the trial Court is illegal,
perverse and arbitrary and the same does not stand the
-9HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
test of reasonability and the principles governing the grant
of temporary injunction.
5.1 Learned counsel further contends that the trial
Court has committed a serious perversity in relying upon
the orders passed by this Court in RFA No.1743/2013 and
R.P. No. 228/2011 dated 14.12.2023 and rejecting the
application on the basis of the orders passed in the said
matters. It is contended by learned counsel that the
appellant/plaintiff was not a party to the said litigation.
Further, the said order is subject matter of challenge
before the Hon'ble Apex Court in SLP(C) No. 017735017736/2024.
5.2 Learned counsel further contends that the trial
Court got carried away with certain observations of this
Court in the above mentioned RFA proceedings, all of
which are irrelevant in terms of Section 42 of the Evidence
Act and therefore on this ground also the impugned order
suffers from legal infirmity and perversity.
- 10 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
5.3 It is further contended by learned counsel for
appellant/plaintiff that trial Court has erred in concluding
that the re-delivery of possession was confirmed by the
first defendant. On the contrary, it is a contention of the
1st defendant that in terms of the declaration-cumratification deed executed on 10.11.2000, the landowners
post the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court upholding
the judgment of this Court quashing
the acquisition
proceedings, had entered into private negotiations with
landowners
and
had
entered
into
declaration-cum-
ratification deed dated 10.11.2000. The impugned order
fails to refer to the material documents produced by the
appellant before the trial Court.
5.4 Learned counsel for appellant/plaintiff further
contends that it is the specific case of the 1st defendant
that the communication addressed to the Special Land
Acquisition Officer of having re-delivered possession was
in the light of declaration-cum-ratification deed, in terms
- 11 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
of which, for the purposes of complying with the order of
the Supreme Court quashing the acquisition proceedings,
nominal possession on paper was handed over, whereas in
terms of the agreement as recorded in the declarationcum-ratification deed, the possession physically continued
to remain with the Society and the allottees.
5.5 Learned counsel further contends that the trial
court committed perversity in failing to appreciate that the
residential layout was formed by the defendant no. 1 as
early as 1990 and that several employees/ allottees had
already constructed their homes and consequently, the
irresistible conclusion is that the residential layout was
formed and is in physical possession of the society and its
allottees.
5.6 It is further contended that the trial Court failed
to
appreciate
the
order
dated
13.2.2013
in
W.P.
No.21920/2010, wherein this Court recorded the fact that
Supreme Court upheld the setting aside of the acquisition
- 12 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
and
that
the
landowners
had
entered
into
private
transactions with the Society and in terms of declarationcum-ratification deed dated 10.11.2000 had confirmed
the formation of the residential layout by the society and
had confirmed the sale deeds executed by the Society in
favour of its allotttees. All these orders have been ignored
by the trial Court while passing the impugned order.
5.7 It is further contended that the trial Court has
selectively chosen order passed in RFA No.1743/2013
dated 14.12.2023 and has dismissed the application,
which is illegal and perverse.
5.8 It is also contended by learned counsel that the
trial Court has also rejected the application for the reason
that the agreement to sell dated 29.12.1991 produced by
the plaintiff is not a registered document and the trial
Court has misdirected itself in refusing to consider the
agreement dated 29.12.1991, in as much as for the
purposes of proving possession, the agreement to sell
- 13 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
dated 29.12.1991 is admissible in evidence. The trial Court
has committed an error in coming to a finding with regard
to the agreement being not valid, which is a matter of trial
and cannot be decided at the interlocutory stage.
5.9 It is further contended by learned counsel that
the appellant/plaintiff had filed the application seeking
protection and preservation of the property and possession
of the suit schedule property on the ground of lawful
settled legal possession and the suit being for bare
injunction, by granting an interim temporary injunction,
the suit property could have been protected and the status
quo could have been maintained till the decision of the
main suit.
5.10
It is also contended that the trial Court has
committed serious error by not looking into the khata
which was transferred in the name of the appellant/
plaintiff, whereas the respondent/ defendant no. 2 does
not have any khata.
- 14 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
5.11 The trial Court has also committed a serious
illegality in relying upon the sale deed dated 27.12.2004
executed in favour of one Karishanayya in suppression of
the declaration-cum-ratification deed and so also the
subsequent transfer on 05.10.2020 in favour of the 2nd
defendant. Infact, the sale deed on the basis of which the
defendant's claim right is dated 5.10.2020, which is 25
years after the judgment of the Apex Court in the year
1995. It is also contended by learned counsel that the
appellant has produced documents to show that he has
been in possession of the suit schedule property since
1991 and the defendant no.2 has come into picture only
on 05.10.2020.
5.12 The Trial Court conveniently ignored all these
relevant and crucial factual aspects and refused to grant
the order of injunction for protection of the property and
preservation of the property in the nature as it is before
the parties could go to trial.
- 15 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
5.13 Learned counsel further contends that the very
fundamental principles of grant of temporary injunction
have not been followed by the learned trial judge. As the
suit property is a vacant site, the appellant/plaintiff claims
right over the property having purchased the same by way
of registered document and having put in possession and
if the defendant no. 2 alters the nature of the suit
property, then the plaintiff would be put to irreparable
injury, hardship and therefore, prima facie case having
been made out, the balance of convenience tilts in his
favour.
5.14 It is also contended by learned counsel that in
another parallel proceedings in O.S. No. 4495/24 filed by
the respondent no. 2 herein against the appellant/plaintiff,
the respondent no. 2 has undertaken that she would not
put up construction in the very same suit schedule
property. But despite having given such undertaking and a
Court passing an order not to put up construction, the
- 16 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
construction
activities
have
been
completed
by
the
respondent no. 2 in total disregard to the orders passed in
the said suit O.S. No. 4495/2024.
5.15 On these grounds, learned counsel for appellant
seeks to allow the appeal and set aside the impugned
order passed by the learned trial judge.
5.16 Learned counsel for the appellant relies upon
the following judgment in support of his case:
1) Wander Ltd. and another -vs- Antox India P. Ltd. 1990 (Supp) SCC 727
2) Meharwal Khewaji Trust (Regd) Faridkot -vs- Baldev
Dass - (2004)8 SCC 488
(iii) Contentions of learned counsel for respondent
no.2/defendant no.2
6. Per contra learned counsel appearing for the
respondent no. 2/defendant no.2 vehemently contends
that there is absolutely no illegality or perversity in the
impugned order passed by the trial Court, muchless calling
- 17 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
for interference at the hands of this Court. It is further
contention of learned counsel that the suit itself is not
maintainable before the trial Court, muchless this appeal
for the reason that the respondent no. 2 has already put
up construction in the suit schedule property on the basis
of a registered sale deed in her favour. It is contended by
learned counsel that the original landowners had sold the
suit land measuring 2 acres 17 guntas in Sy. No. 17/2
under registered sale deed dated 27.12.2004 in favour of
one Karishanayya, who
had executed a GPA
dated
30.5.2009 in favour of Mirle Varadraj. On the basis of the
said GPA, Mirle Varadraj has formed the lay-out and
executed the sale deed in respect of Site No.23 in
Sy.No.17/2 measuring 40 feet x 60 feet in favour of
respondent no. 2 and therefore respondent no.2 is a
bonafide purchaser and is in possession and enjoyment of
the suit schedule property. It is further contended that
respondent no. 2 has obtained a sanctioned license plan
and has also entered into a joint development agreement
- 18 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
dated 18.04.2022. Therefore, the application filed by the
appellant/plaintiff cannot be allowed and hence sought for
dismissal of the same.
6.1 It is further contention of learned counsel that
the very suit is filed for bare injunction and the respondent
no. 2 has filed his detailed written statement and
objections taking a plea that she is the absolute owner by
way of a registered sale deed and is in possession and
enjoyment of the suit schedule property and carrying out
developmental activities. It is also the contention of
learned counsel that even as on date of filing of the suit,
respondent no. 2 was in possession and had already dug a
trench for putting up pillars for construction in the suit
schedule property. Therefore, when the respondent no. 2
took up such a plea in the written statement and in the
objection to the application - I.A. No.1 that she is the
absolute owner of the suit schedule property, claiming a
right over the suit schedule property, the suit for bare
- 19 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
injunction is not maintainable. Once the cloud is raised
and a title is set up, the suit for bare injunction would not
be maintainable and the plaintiff ought to have converted
the suit for other reliefs suitably.
6.2 It is also the contention of learned counsel that
the plaintiff has averred in the plaint that the defendant
no. 2 claims right over the property in question, having
purchased the same from its previous owner, which itself
casts a cloud over the title of the plaintiff and therefore
when the plaintiff himself has made such an averment in
the plaint, he could not have filed the suit for bare
injunction as contemplated in the judgment of the Hon'ble
Apex Court in the case of Anathulla Sudhakar -vs- P.
Buchi Reddy. 1
6.3 The counsel further contends that in a suit for
bare injunction when an application is filed, the onus is
upon the plaintiff to come before the Court to show that
(2008) 4 SCC 594
- 20 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
he is the absolute owner and in possession of the suit
schedule property as on date of filing of the suit. In the
present case on hand, the plaintiff himself is not sure with
regard to his ownership and in his own pleadings in the
plaint has categorically stated that the respondent no. 2 is
claiming right over the suit schedule property by way of
registered
sale
deed.
Therefore,
under
such
circumstances, the plaintiff himself is not sure and clear
with regard to his right over the suit schedule property
and neither has he produced any material to show his
possession and enjoyment over the suit schedule property
except stating that he is an absolute owner having
purchased the same in pursuance to an agreement of sale
entered into by the Society with the landowners and
thereafter, he having purchased the property by way of a
registered sale deed from the allottee to whom the Society
sold the land.
- 21 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
6.4 On these grounds, he seeks dismissal of the
appeal and consequently, to sustain the impugned order
passed by the learned trial Judge as the same does not
call for interference, as there is no perversity or illegality.
6.5 Learned counsel for respondent No.2 relies upon
the following judgments in support of his case:
i)
Sanjay Paliwal and another vs. Bharat
Heavy
Electricals
Executive
Director
Ltd.
through
reported
in
its
LiveLaw (SC) 54;
ii)
M.Haroonal
N.Palagulla
Rasheed
&
Ors.
vs.
[Special
Rajlaxmi
Leave
to
Appeal (C) No.990/2023; and
iii)
Basi Reddy Jayarami Reddy and others vs.
G.Vasundara Lakshmi and others [MFA
No.6156/2019 and connected matters]
(iv) Consideration
7. Having heard learned counsel for the appellant
and learned counsel for respondent No.2, apparently it is
seen that there is no dispute to the fact that both the
- 22 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
plaintiff and defendant No.2 have registered sale deeds in
their respective names and are claiming right over the suit
schedule property by way of the said registered sale deeds
and so also both are claiming possession and enjoyment of
the suit schedule property. The fact remains that the suit
is filed for bare injunction by the plaintiff. It is also a fact
that the plaintiff himself has pleaded in the plaint with
regard to defendant No.2 claiming right over the suit
schedule property by way of a registered sale deed and is
making attempts to put up some illegal construction in the
suit schedule property. Therefore, he filed an applicationI.A.No.1 under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2.
8. It is also not in dispute with regard to the fact that
the acquisition proceedings were quashed by this Court,
which was subsequently challenged before the Hon'ble
Apex Court and the same came to be dismissed upholding
the quashing of the acquisition proceedings and thereby,
- 23 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
the properties were ordered to be returned to the original
landowners.
9. Apparently, what is required to be seen by the
trial Court while deciding the application under Order
XXXIX Rule 1 and 2 is three essential requirements of
prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable
hardship that would be caused more to which party?
10. In the present case on hand, it is also submitted
that respondent No.2-defendant No.2 has already put up
construction in the suit schedule property. It is also
brought to the notice of this Court that respondent No.2
had filed a suit in O.S.No.4495/2024, wherein an order
was passed by the trial Court directing her not to put up
construction as she was plaintiff in the said suit. But
despite the said order, she has violated the said order and
continued construction in the property of the said suit,
which is claimed to be the very same property in the
present suit. But the suit schedule in both these cases are
- 24 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
different as per the schedules mentioned in the respective
suits.
11.
During
the
course
of
argument,
certain
photographs have also been placed before this Court to
show that as on date of filing of the suit, the suit schedule
property was a vacant land and there were some trenches
put in for the construction of the pillars and the same has
been put up by respondent No.2. But over a period of
time,
the
construction
has
been
carried
out
and
completed.
12. Apparently, on the basis of these documents
produced and the submissions of learned counsel for both
parties, what can be decided by this Court is, even as on
date of filing of the suit, plaintiff was unable to produce
any document to show that he was in possession of the
property except with regard to sale deed and the Katha
documents, whereas defendant No.2 also had a registered
sale deed and claimed to be in possession of the suit
- 25 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
schedule property by way of registered document. But
what is relevant to see is that defendant No.2 in his
written statement categorically took up the plea that she is
the absolute owner of the suit schedule property by way of
a registered document and she has been put in possession
and also she has entered into Joint Developmental
Agreement (JDA) with a third party. If that being the case,
the scenario of a bare injunction suit takes a different turn
altogether to consider an application under Order XXXIX
Rule 1 and 2 with regard to the title as possession follows
title.
13. The trial Court is required to exercise its
discretionary relief by applying its judicial mind while
considering the application under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and
2. It is no more res integra that the trial Court at the stage
of deciding the application under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and
2 need not venture into conducting a mini trial as to who
would be successful and whose document is reliable and
- 26 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
whose document is not reliable. What is to be seen by the
trial
Court
is,
requirements
as
i.e.,
stated
prima
earlier,
facie
three
case,
essential
balance
of
convenience and irreparable hardship that would be
caused to the party more?
14. In the facts and circumstances of the present
case,
when
the
plaintiff
himself
has
admitted
that
defendant No.2 is relying upon a registered sale deed and
claiming title and is making attempts to put up trench in
the suit schedule property, photographs having been
shown to that effect, the construction activity having
already commenced as the same having given to the third
party by way of a JDA, the Court will have to see who has
made
out
a
prima
facie
case
and
the
balance
of
convenience tilts in which of the party and so also the
hardship.
15. On an overall view of all these documents,
submissions and materials placed on record, the trial Court
- 27 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
was of the opinion that the plaintiff was unable to make
out a prima facie case for grant of a temporary injunction
and more so for the reason that it is a discretionary and
equitable relief so also balance of convenience did not
weigh more in favour of the plaintiff and the hardship
would not be caused to the plaintiff if an order of
injunction is rejected and accordingly, dismissed the
application.
16. It is again no more res integra for this Court, in
view of the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the
case of Wander Ltd. and anr. v. Antox India P. Ltd.,
which is subsequently reiterated in the judgment of the
Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Ramakant Ambalal
Choksi v. Harish Ambalal Choksi2 that the Appellate
Court while dealing with an application under Order XXXIX
Rule 1 and 2 either granted or rejected by the trial Court,
cannot impose its own opinion if it comes to a different
(2024) 11 SCC 351
- 28 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
opinion than what is expressed by the trial Court as the
trial Court is exercising a discretionary relief deciding the
application
on
the
basis
of
these
three
essential
requirements. Therefore, I do not find any good ground or
cogent
reason
to
differ
from
the
opinion
and
the
discretionary power exercised by the trial Court to come to
a different opinion than what is already arrived at by the
trial Court. This Court also does not find any perversity or
illegality committed by the trial Court in dismissing the
application-I.A.No.1 under Order XXXIX Rule 1 and 2.
17. Though learned counsel for respondent No.2 has
made several claims with regard to the suit being not
maintainable, this Court refrains itself from delving into
the merits of the matter as that is not the subject matter
to be considered for deciding the application on hand.
18.
Under
the
circumstances,
in
view
of
the
discussions made herein above and the judgments relied
upon by both the parties and the powers of the Appellate
- 29 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:37519
MFA No. 9186 of 2025
CNR: KAHC010797092025
Court to deal with the application under Order XXXIX Rule
1 and 2, I do not find sufficient good ground or cogent
reason to interfere with the order passed by the learned
trial judge.
19. Accordingly, I pass the following:
ORDER
i)
This appeal is dismissed.
ii)
It is made clear that this Court has not
expressed any opinion on the merits of
the matter.
Ordered accordingly.
Sd/(PRADEEP SINGH YERUR)
JUDGE
pages 1 to 19 .. GSS
20 to end ..VM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 31
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review