Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34841
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE THIRTIETH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
wRl T PETITION NO: 26716 OF 2013
Between:
1. M. Javakrishna (Died as per Petitioner Nos. 2 to 5), S/o. Late Jangaiah @
Jaoarinadham. Aoed about 59 Years, Ri/o H.No.3-5-8071118' Flal No.301'
Yo-usuf Block, Hyd-erguda, Hyderabad.
2. Smt. M. Sujatha, W/o. Late M. Jayakrishna, Aged about-S4years, Occ. Home
maker, FUir. H.No. 16-1 1-1 611i111511 Plot No. 219, Sripuram Colony,
Malakpet, Hyderabad.
3. Smt.V. Swiva Nandini, Wo. V. Pavan Kumar, Aged about 38 years' Occ.
Home mak6r, Rl/o. H.No. 16-11-161111115/1 Plot No. 219, Sripuram Co lony,
Malakpet, Hyderabad.
4. Ms. M. Manasa Sri, D/o. Late M. Jayakrishna, Aged aboul 36 years, Occ.
Home maker, Ri,/o. H.No. 16-11-16111i115/1 Plot No. 2'19, Sripuram Colony,
Malakpet,Hyderabad.
5. Mr. M. Murali Sai, S/o. Late M. Jayakrishna, Aged about 33years, Oct..Pvt.
Employee, Ri/o. H.No. 16-11-161111115/1 Plot No. 219, Sripuram Colony,
Malakpet, Hyderabad.
Petitioner Nos. 2 to 5 are brought on record as LRs of the deceased
Petitioner No.l as per C.O.dt. 10.01.2024 in lA No. 112023.
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. Revenue Divisional Officer, Hyderabad Division, Exhibition Grounds Road,
Hyderabad.
2. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Nampally Mandal, Hyderabad.
3. State of Andhra Pradesh, Rep. by its Principal Secretary Revenue
Department Secretariat, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ of Certiorari or any other appropriate Writ, Order or
Orders, Direction or Directions to quash the order of the '1"t Respondent dated
10.9.2013 in Oase No. 8/2990/2013 whereby the confirmed the order of the 2nd
Respondent clated 15.2.2006 in E12261190 by declaring the same as illegal,
arbitrary, malafide and unconstitutional.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2013(WPMP. NO: 33057 OF 2013)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavil. filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the 6,roceedings ofthe 1st Respondent in Case No. 8/2990/2013 dated
10.9.2013 wlrereby he confirmed the order of the 2nd Respondent dated
15.2.2OO0 in E:.12261190, pending disposal of the Writ petition.
IANO:1OF2 019
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the 2nd respondent and his subordinates not to interfere with the peaceful
possession a nd enjoyment of the petitioner in respect of the property in
Sy.Nos.17, tll and 19 (TS Nos.9,8 & 7 respectively) situated at Thotaguda
Revenue Village, Nampally Mandal, Hyderabad, pending disposal of the Writ
Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI VEDULA SRINIVAS, Sr. COUNSEL, REP.
SMT VEDULA CHITRALEKHA
Counsel for the Respondents: GP FOR REVENUE
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
IIIRIT PETITION No -26716 0F 2()13
DATE: 3O.O1.2O26
BETWEEN:
M.Jayakrishna and 4 others.
....Petitioners
AND
Revenue Divisional Offtcer,
Hyderabad and 2 others.
...Respondents
ORDER
The present writ Petition is frled assailing the order dated
10.09.2013 passed by respondent No.1 - Revenue Divisional Officer,
Hyderabad in case No.B/299O12A13, rvhereb-v the appeal preferred
by the originat petitioner (deceased) under Section 6 of the Andhra
Pradesh Land Encroachmerrt Act, 1905 (fbr short, '1905 Act',) was
dismissed by confirming the order dated 15.02.2006 in Proceedings
No.El226lll99o passed by respondent No.2 - Mandal Revenue
Officer, Nampalty. By the said order, the original petitioner was
directed to be evicted from the iands in Sy.Nos.17, lB, 19 situated at
Thotaguda Revenue Village, Nampaliy Mandal, Hyderabad'
2.Duringthependencyofthewritpetition'theoriginalpetitioner
expired on 09'O8 '2023' Consequently' his legal
M.Jaya<rishna
representlltivesi.e.,petitionerNos.2to5werebroughtonrecorduide
order datt:d 1O-01 -2024 passed in I'A'No' l of
3.
2023'
Hezrrd Sri Vedula Srinivas' learned Senior Counsel
represenlingSmt.VedulaChitralekha,learnedcounselforthe
petitionet.sand'thelearnedGovernmentPleaderforRevenue
appearing for the respondents and perused the
material on record'
Factual matrix (in brief)
4.Thecaseoftheoriginalpetitioneristhatthesubjectlandwas
grandmother'
originall'y owned and possessed by his paternal
Smt.MaliMuthamma,fromaperiodpriortoindependence.Uponher
been
the petitioner succeeded to the said property and has
demise,
and
in continuous, peaceful and uninterrupted possession
enjoymt:nt thereof, cultivating the land and regularly
placed reliance on
revenu€:. In support of his claim, the petitioner
various revenue records, incruding
paying land
pahanies, Ryotwari Passbooks,
of the petitioner as
and To'nm Survey Records, which reflect the name
well as that of his predecessor-in-title'
5.
'l'he respondents treated the subject land as Government land'
contendingthatitformspartoftheMusiriverbed,andclassifredthe
. ..1
^\,
i
I
same as "Sarkarilr(harij Khata". Proceeding on such classification,
the respondent No.2 has passed order dated rs.o2.2oo6 initiating
eviction proceedings against the petitioner under the 1905 Act.
6-
Aggrieved by the said order, the petitioner preferred appeal
under section 6 of the 1905 Act before the respondent No.I. The said
appeal was dismissed by order dated 10.09.2013, confirming the
eviction proceedings passed by respondent No.2.
7.
challenging tlle aforesaid appellate order dated 10.09.2013
i.e., the consequential eviction proceedings, the petitioner filed the
present writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution.
Submissions on behalf of the petitioners
8.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioners made the following
submissions:
i. That the petitioners have been in continuous, peaceful and
uninterrupted possession of the subject land since prior to
1954, as evidenced by Pahani patrikas (19S4-S5), Ryotwari
Passbooks, and rown survey Register entries. The name of
Mali Muthamma was recorded in the revenue records, and
subsequent mutation in the petitioner's name was lawful.
ii. That the long-standing possession coupled with payment of
land revenue and recognition in revenue records, raises a
I
\
prosumption of title in favour of the petitioners. The
rer;pond.ents have failed to establish any better title so as to
di:;place such PresumPtion.
iii. That the classif,rcation of the land as part of the Musi riverbed
is arbitrary and unsupported by record. Town Survey Records
contradict such claim, and the land has been in continuous
agricultural and lawful use for decades, without submergence
or obstruction to water flow.
iv. Ttrat the appellate order of respondent No' 1 - Revenue
Divisional officer is non-speaking and mechanical,
d<:monstrating total non-application of
mind. Relevant
d.ocumentary evidence and binding judicial precedents were
ignored, rendering the order unsustainable'
v. Tl-rat the writ petition is maintainable notwithstanding
a,iailability of alternative remedY, aS the impugned orders are
without jurisdiction, contrary to settled law, and raise pure
qrestions of law concerning interpretation and evidentiary
vitlue of revenue records-
vi. That reliance placed on R.ChandeaanapPa o. State of
B]arnqtaka,I wherein t].e Hon'ble Supreme Court held that
long and uninterrupted possession raises a presumption of
r (1995) tr*Scrc 309
ru/
title and the Division Bench judgment of this court in
W.P.No.3232 of 2006 in support of his claim.
vii. That there is no evidence of encroachment by the petitioner.
Possession flows from lawful inheritance and recorded rights.
In the absence of proof of unauthorized occupation;
proceedings under the 19o5 Act, are wholly misconceived.
Submissions of the respondents
9.
Learned Assistant Government pleader for Revenue made the
following submissions:
That t]:e subject land is classified as "sarkari" in the Sethwar
and as "Billa Dhakala" (unassessed waste). It fails within the
retaining wall of the Musi River and forms part of the riverbed.
consequently, the land vests in the state under Section 24 of
the Andhra Pradesh (Telangana Area) Land Revenue Act, 1317
Fasli.
ii. That the petitioner's grandmother was not a pattadar but was
merely recorded as a "shivajiamadar" (encroacher), indicating
unauthorized occupation. payment of land revenue or
existence of revenue entries does not confer title, particularly
in respect of Government land.
iii. That the town Survey operations conducted under the Andhra
prz.desh Survey ancl Boundaries Act, L923, attained finality
up,rn publication in the Gazette, wherein the subject land was
recordedaSGovernmentland.Thepetitionerorhis
pr<:decessor did not raise any objection at the relevant stage
and is, therefore, estopped from disputing the classification.
iv. That the eviction proceedings under the 1905 Act, were
initiated strictly in accordance with law, after issuance of due
notice and affording opportunity of hearing' The appellate
or,ler passed by the Revenue Divisional officer is legal, proper
and does not warrant interference'
v. TtLat the petitioner has an efficacious statutory remedy of
reyision under Section 12 af the 19O5 Act, in addition to the
remedy of instituting a civil suit. In view thereof, the present
w::it petition is not maintainable'
vi. That the subject land forms part of the riverbed of the Musi
ri.uer. Any occupation or construction thereon is illegal and
p()ses serious environmental and public safety risks, including
obstruction to natural water flow and increased flood
vrrlnerability.
*
//"'
W
vii. That in W.P.No.68O of 2OL2, the petitioner had furnished an
undertaking before ttris Court not to change the nature of the
subject land. It is alleged that the petitioner violated the said
undertaking by continuing unauthorized use and alteration of
the [and, disentitling him to any equitable relief under Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
10. I have taken note of the respective contentions urged by both
the learned counsel and perused the material on record.
Analysis and findings
11. It is pertinent to note that the present writ petition raises
substantial questions touching upon the jurisdiction and legality of
the proceedings initiated under the 19O5 Act. The impugned orders
are assailed on the grounds of violation of principles of natural
justice, non-application of mind, and misreading of material revenue
records. It is well settled law that where the action of statutory
authorities is exrfizcie arbitrary, without jurisdiction, or in breach of
natural justice, this Court can exercise its extraordinary jurisdiction
under Article 226 of tl:re Constitution of India. Hence, the objection
raised by the respondents regarding the availability of an alternative
remedy is devoid of merits and is accordingly rejected.
L2. The Hon,ble Supreme court in Mandal Reaenue offtcer a.
Goundla Venkaiahz while reiterating the view taken in Goaernment
of Andht.a Pradesh u. Thummo;la Krishna Rao3 has held that the
proceedir.gs under the 19o5 Act are summary in nature and. can be
invoked only when tl.e land is admittedly Government land and the
occupati<rn is prima facie unauthorized. Where serious disputes
relating r-o title and long-standing possession arise, the authorities
under th: 1905 Act lack jurisdiction to adjudicate such issues. In the
present ()ase, the very foundation for invoking the provisions of the
1905 Act is absent, as the petitioners' possession is supported by
revenue records spanning several decades
13. The petitioners have placed on record a series of revenue
d.ocumetrts clating back to 1954-55, which initially show the name of
Mali M-:thamma and, thereafter, that of the petitioner- These
records, including entries in Pahanis, Rycitwari Passbooks, and the
Town siurvey Register, although disputed by the respondents,
establish a prima facie case of lawful possession, if not title. The
responc.ents' reliance on the Sethwar and the classilication of the
land as "Billa Dhakala" cannot be treated as conclusive, particularly
when subsequent revenue records demonstrate cOntinUOUS
' 1zo to; :r scc 461
3 (1982) 2 SCC 134
possession by the petitioner's family along with regular pa5rment of
revenue
14. Though revenue records do not by themselves confer title, they
carry a statutory presumption of possession and enjoyment, which
gains significance when such entries remain unchallenged over a
long period. when coupled with long, continuous and uninterrupted
possession, they constitute strong evidence of lawful entitlement,
unless rebutted by the state by establishing a superior title. In the
present case, the respondents have failed to place any material to
show that the land was ever assigned, allotted, or declared as
Government property prior to the petitioner's family coming into
possession. A bare and antiquated sethwar classification, in the
absence of supporting contemporaneous evidence, cannot prevail
over decades of recognized and recorded possession.
15. on perusal of the record, it indicates that the respondents,
assertion that the land forms part of the Musi riverbed is not
supported by any contemporary survey or expert report. The Town
Survey records, in fact, show the land as dry and under occupation.
The land does not fall within the active flood zorte, nor is there any
finding that the petitioner's occupation has caused environmental
harm or obstructed the natural flow of water. The respond.ents, vague
l0
reference to the "Musi riverbed" appears to be a belated
and
unfoundr:d justification for eviction'
16. It Ls also to be noted that the appellate order passed by the
RDO is <:ryptic and fails to consider the documents and precedents
placed before it by the petitioner. [t merely reiterates the findings of
the MRC without any independent analysis- Such omission amounts
to a violation of principles of natural justice and renders the order
legally untenable. In this regard, the impugned orders suffer from
non-application of mind.
L7. In W.P.No .3232 0f 2006, this court did not hold that the land
was Go\/ernment property; it merely directed the petitioner to avail
the statutory remedy of appeal, which he duly did. similarly, the
observa.:ions in w.P.No.680 0f 2012 were made in the context
of an
undertaking given by the petitioner regarding temporary structures
and did not constitute a determination of title'
18. The petitioner and his legal heirs have been in uninterrupted
possession of land for over seven decacles, having built their lives
around it. An attempt by the State to evict them after such prolonged
period, without compelling evidence of superior tifle, is inequitable
and corttrary to the principles of substantive justice'
I
ti
g
19. In view of the foregoing discussion, this court is satisfied that
$
i
a
the petitioners have established a strong pima facie case of lawful
?
i
i
possession, supported by revenue records. The respondents have
l
;
I
failed to prove that the land in question is "Government land,,or that
the petitioner constitutes an "encroacher" within the meaning of the
1905 Act. The impugned orders dated rs.o2.2oo6 and 10.09.2013
are arbitrary, legally unsustainable and violative of the petitioner,s
i
;
i
rights under Article 3O0A of the Constitution of India.
t
I
20- Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed and the impugned
i
a
i
orders dated 15.02.2006 and 10.09.2013 are hereby set aside. The
respondents are directed not to' interfere with the petitioners,
peaceful possession and enjoyment of the subject land except by due
process of law and in accordance with a competent adjudication by a
civil Court. There shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall
stand closed.
That Rure Nisi has made Absotute as above witness
The Hon'ble SRI APARESH KUMAR Strue n, ifre Cfiief Justiie on
tf,is Friday,
'si;:
the Thirtieth Day of January, Two Thousand ;"d
ilF;t
//TRUE COPY//
SD/.P. PONNA
SISTANT
A
CTION OFFICER
To,
Revenue Divisional Officer, Hyderabad
Ihe
Road,
Hyderabad.
Exhibition Grounds
2. The Mandal Revenue officer, Nampaily Mandar, Hyderabad.
3' The Principal Secretary, Revenue Department Secretariat, Hyderabad, State
of Telangana.
4. one cc to SI\rr VEDULA CHTTRALEKHA, Advocate topucl
i
5 Two cc;s to GP FOR REVENUE, High court for the State of Telangana at
Hyderatrad [OUT]
6. Two CD CoPies
/
BSR
Bsw
HIGH COUR
DATED: 3 l 10112026
ORDER
WP.No.26716 of 2013
(
o
(,
le fE8
*
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION ,
ITHOUT COSTS
q .dd
\+
r fl-,-t
s
o
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review