Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
LAIRENMAYU
M INDRAJEET
SINGH
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
LAIRENMAYUM
INDRAJEET SINGH
Date: 2023.06.15
13:21:35 +05'30'
AT IMPHAL
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Lungningam Gangmei, now aged about 55 years, by occupation business,
S/o Poushonglung Gangmei, resident of Thengjang Village, P.O. & P.S.
Loktak Project, District – Churachandpur, Manipur – 795124.
……. Petitioner/s
– Versus –
Shougrakpam Purnima Singh, by occupation Govt. employee, S/o late Sh.
Tomba Singh, resident of Bishnupur Makha Leikai, Ward No.6, P.O. & P.S.
Bishnupur, District – Bishnupur, Manipur.
On his death on 20-12-2019, represented by his Legal Representatives,
namely :1.
Shougrakpam Ongbi Abemma Devi, aged about 57 years, W/o late
Shougrakpam Purnima Singh, resident of Bishnupur Makha Leikai, Ward
No.6, P.O. & P.S. Bishnupur, District – Bishnupur, Manipur – 795126.
2.
Shougrakpam Lomit Singh, aged about 28 years, S/o late Shougrakpam
Purnima Singh, resident of Bishnupur Makha Leikai, Ward No.6, P.O. & P.S.
Bishnupur, District – Bishnupur, Manipur – 795126.
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 1
3.
Shougrakpam Dhakeshwor Singh, aged about 23 years, S/o late
Shougrakpam Purnima Singh, resident of Bishnupur Makha Leikai, Ward
No.6, P.O. & P.S. Bishnupur, District – Bishnupur, Manipur – 795126.
…. Respondent/s
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioner/s
:
Mr. S. Sachindra, Advocate
Mr. K. Kopham, Advocate
For the Respondent/s
:
Mr. RK Milan, Advocate
Date of Hearing
:
18.04.2023
Date of Judgment & Order :
13.06.2023.
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
The question of law involved in the present petition is whether legal
heirs of a deceased defendant, who are brought on record at the stage of the
hearing of the suit, be permitted to file additional written statement within the
meaning of Order 22 Rule 4(2) of CPC in addition to the written statement already
filed by the deceased defendant.
[2]
By way of the present Revision Petition under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, the petitioner/plaintiff has approached this Court challenging
the correctness of the impugned order dated 13.12.2022 passed by the Ld. Civil
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 2
Judge, Sr. Division, Bishnupur in Judl. Misc. Case No.272 of 2022 [Ref:- Original
(Money) Suit No.2 of 2014]. By the impugned order, the trial Court allowed the
application of the newly impleaded legal heirs of the deceased sole defendant to file
additional written statement even at the stage of hearing.
[3]
The brief fact of the present case is that the petitioner/plaintiff,
Lungningam Gangmei filed Original (Money) Suit No.2 of 2014 under Order XXXVII
of CPC in the Court of the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Bishnupur against the
original sole defendant, late Shougrakpam Purnima Singh (husband of respondent
No.1 and father of respondent Nos.2 and 3 herein) for recovering a sum of
Rs.20,40,000/- (Rupees twenty lakh and forty thousand) from the defendant with
interest @ 6% per annum on the decretal amount from the date of decree till
realization of the decretal amount.
[3.1]
On 01.11.2013, the defendant approached the petitioner/plaintiff and
requested for a loan of Rs.15,00,000/- (Rupees fifteen lakhs) as he was in urgent
need of the same to invest in his Amway Business and would repay the loan with
interest @ 4% per month on or before 31.07.2014 without fail. Being a friend, the
petitioner/plaintiff paid the sum of Rs.15,00,000/- (Rupees fifteen lakhs) to the
defendant on 01.11.2013. The defendant executed a money receipt dated
01.11.2013 (Annexure-A/1) in favour of the petitioner/plaintiff in presence of
witnesses. On 22.01.2014, the defendant also executed a promissory note
(Annexure-A/2) for a sum of Rs.15,00,000/- (Rupees fifteen lakhs) in favour of the
plaintiff/petitioner to be repaid with interest @ 4% per month w.e.f. 01.11.2013.
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 3
The defendant also executed a loan agreement dated 22.01.2014 (Annexure-A/3)
for borrowing a sum of Rs.15,00,000/- (Rupees fifteen lakhs) from the
petitioner/plaintiff with an interest @4% per month w.e.f. 01.11.2013 and to be
repaid on or before 31.07.2014 without fail. The defendant also agreed to execute
a mortgage in favour of the petitioner/plaintiff of his homestead land under patta
No.253 (old), 352/798 (new) covered by dag No.1214/1537 measuring an area of
0.12 acre situated at Bishnupur Ward No.6 within Village No.38 - Bishnupur Kha. If
the defendant failed to return the amount within the stipulated time, the
petitioner/plaintiff would be at liberty to enter into possession of the homestead
land. The original defendant filed written statement to the money suit inter-alia
denying the fact that he never approached the petitioner/plaintiff for a loan of
Rs.15,00,000/- (Rupees fifteen lakhs) with an interest @ 4% per month. It is also
averred that the petitioner/plaintiff did not have a valid license under Section 6 of
the Bombay Money Lenders Act to do money lending business with interest. The
defendant also denied the execution of the money receipt, promissory note and
loan agreement in favour of the petitioner/plaintiff in presence of 2(two) witnesses.
However, the defendant admitted that he signed on some blank stamp papers and
blank papers with revenue stamp. It was prayed that the suit be dismissed.
[3.2]
On
13.05.2015,
the
trial
Court
framed
five
issues.
The
petitioner/plaintiff produced four witnesses including himself and the defendant
examined himself as witness on close evidence. Five issues framed by the trial
Court are reproduced as:
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 4
I S S U E S
13 – 05 – 2015
1.
Whether the Defendants borrowed/Loan a sum of Rs. 15,00,000/-
(Rupees fifteen Lakhs) from the plaintiff by executing Promissory Note, Money
received and Loan agreement or not?
2.
Whether the Plaintiffs is a money lender or not if so he has a valid
license? And whether the suit can not be proceeded U/s 10 of Bombay Money
Lender Act?
[3.3]
3.
Whether the documents are manufactured or not?
4.
Cause of action?
5.
Reliefs?
Before final hearing of the suit, the defendant filed an application
being Judl. Misc.Case No.167 of 2017 in the trial Court to decide issue Nos. 2 and 3
as preliminary issues. The application was dismissed on 29.05.2017 on the basis of
res-judicata as the trial Court had already held in order dated 20.10.2016 in Judl.
Misc.Case No.312 of 2016 that the petitioner/plaintiff was not a money lender and
the said order, i.e. order dated 20.10.2016 attained finality. Subsequently, this
Court also dismissed the petition being CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.27 of 2017 filed by
the defendant herein challenging the order dated 29.05.2017 passed by the Ld.
Civil Judge, Senior Division, Bishnupur in Judl. Misc. Case No.167 of 2017 [Ref:O(M)S No.2 of 2014] and directed the Ld. Civil Judge, Senior Division to proceed
with the case further.
[3.4]
During pendency of the suit at the stage of argument, the defendant
died on 20.12.2019 leaving behind the present respondents as legal representatives
and they were brought on record as legal representatives of the deceased
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 5
defendant vide order dated 16.06.2022. Thereafter, the present respondents who
are the LRs of the deceased defendant filed an application being Judl. Misc. Case
No.272 of 2022 under the proviso of Rule 1 of Order 8 read with Section 151 CPC
to grant leave for filing additional written statement on behalf of the newly
impleaded LRs. The petitioner/plaintiff filed written objection to the application filed
by the legal representatives of the deceased defendant seeking leave to file
additional written statement inter-alia on the ground that the application is not
maintainable and additional written statement cannot be filed by the LRs of the
deceased defendant as they have no independent right, title or interest, dehors the
interest of the deceased defendant.
[3.5]
It is also stated that the deceased defendant had already filed his
written statement of defence in the suit on 25.11.2014 and led his evidence in the
proceedings of the suit and his evidence (DW hearing) was closed on 29.05.2019
and the matter was fixed for final argument on 20.06.2017 and the same was
adjourned from time to time. It is also stated that provision of Order 22 Rule 4(2)
of CPC stipulates that the party who is brought on record as legal heir of the
deceased defendant can make a defence appropriate to his character as legal
representatives of the deceased defendant who could not file written statement
under Order 8 Rule 1 or 9 of CPC. It is also pointed out that the LRs of a deceased
defendant have no right to file independent written statement of their own and
they step in the shoe of the deceased defendant. Vide impugned order dated
13.12.2022 in Judl. Misc. case No.272 of 2022, the Ld. Civil Judge, Senior Division,
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 6
Bishnupur allowed the application to file additional written statement under t he
provisions of Order 22 Rule 4(2) of CPC and relying upon the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Sumtibai & Others Vs. Paras Finance
Co.Regd. Partnership Firm Beaer (Raj.) through Mankanwar (Smt) W/O
Parasmal Chordia (Dead) & Others reported as (2007) 10 SCC 82 @ Para 8
which reads as follows:-
“8. Every party in a case has a right to file a written statement. This is in
accordance with natural justice. The Civil Procedure Code is really the rules of
natural justice which are set out in great and elaborate detail. Its purpose is
to enable both parties to get a hearing. The appellants in the present case
have already been made parties in the suit, but it would be strange if they are
not allowed to take a defence. In our opinion, Order 22 Rule 4(2) CPC cannot
be construed in the manner suggested by learned counsel for the
respondent.”
[3.6]
Being aggrieved by the impugned order, the petitioner/plaintiff filed
the Revision Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India inter-alia on the
following grounds:
A)
For that, the Ld. Trial Court, while passing the impugned order
wrongly applied the case law of Sumatibai & others Vs Paras Finance Co.
Mankanwar, (2007) 10 SCC 82, which is factually different from the present
case.
B)
For that, in the present case the original defendant, before his death,
contested the suit by filing written statement and after closing his evidence,
final hearing of the suit was fixed and he died at the argument stage.
Therefore his legal representatives cannot be permitted to set a new case or
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 7
to be allowed to file a fresh written statement in addition to the written
statement already filed by the deceased defendant before his death.
C)
For that, the Ld. Trial Court committed serious illegality and legal
infirmity by allowing the legal representatives of the deceased defendant to
file a fresh written statement at the stage of final argument of the suit.
D)
For that, it is settled law that a legal representative steps into the
shoes of the original deceased party, who died during the pendency of a
proceeding and only represents the estate of the deceased. He is to continue
the proceedings as could have done by the deceased, in whose place he is
substituted as his legal representative.
E)
For that, it is also settled law that a legal representative cannot take a
hostile stand to that of the deceased defendant. It is the rights and liabilities
of the deceased defendant which have to be considered and not those of the
legal representatives themselves. All that the legal representatives can do is to
take up the suit at the stage at which it was left when the original defendant
died and to continue it. It is not open to them to assert their individual right or
hostile title to the suit. They cannot take up a plea contrary to the one taken
up by the deceased defendant.
F)
For that, in the present case the loan agreement in question for
borrowing money by deceased defendant from the plaintiff was signed
between them only. The legal heirs or legal representatives of the deceased
defendant were not a party in the loan agreement in question. Therefore the
legal representatives of the deceased defendant have no right to file a fresh
written statement of their own at the stage of final hearing of the suit, in
addition to the written statement already filed by the deceased defendant.
G)
For that, the impugned order suffers from perversity and is otherwise
bad in law and liable to be set aside.
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 8
[4]
On 02.02.2023, this Court issued notice returnable on 02.03.2023.
The respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3 were duly served on 10.02.2023 as per the
tracking report issued by the postal department. In spite of giving opportunities,
the respondents did not file any written objection to the petition and the matter
was finally heard on 18.04.2023.
[5]
Heard Mr. S. Sachindra, learned counsel for the petitioner assisted by
Mr. K. Kopham, learned counsel and Mr. RK Milan, learned counsel for the
respondents.
[6]
Mr. S. Sachindra, learned counsel for the petitioner/plaintiff submits
that the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Sumatibai &
Others vs. Paras Finance Co. Mankanwar, (2007) 10 SCC 82 is not
applicable in the fact of the present case. In the present case, the original
defendant defended the suit by filing written statement and examined himself as
DW (defendant witness) and the matter was fixed for hearing. At that stage, the
defendant expired and the legal representatives of the deceased defendant were
brought as the respondents. It is submitted that the legal representatives cannot be
permitted to file fresh written statement in addition to the written statement
already filed by the deceased defendant. It is emphasized that LRs cannot plead
new grounds and they step into the shoes of the deceased defendant. It is also
submitted that the legal representatives of a deceased defendant cannot take a
hostile and different stand from that of the original defendant.
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 9
[6.1]
Mr. S. Sachindra, learned counsel for the petitioner/plaintiff has
distinguished the facts of the Sumtibai case (supra) from the present case. In
that case, the joint purchasers of the disputed property were not made as
defendants and only one of the joint purchasers was made as a defendant. After
expiry of the defendant, the other co-owners filed an application to file additional
written statement and the Hon’ble Court allowed the same under Order 22 Rule
4(2) of CPC as they were necessary party in the suit and they were not impleaded
earlier by the plaintiff. Mr. S. Sachindra, learned counsel for the petitioner/plaintiff
has pointed out that in the case in hand, the defendant executed a promissory
note, money receipt and loan agreement in favour of the petitioner/plaintiff for
borrowing a sum of Rs.15,00,000/- (Rupees fifteen lakhs) to be repaid with an
interest @ 4% per month. The original defendant had filed written statement and
adduced his defense witness and the matter was fixed for hearing. The
respondents who are LRs of the deceased sole respondent, have no independent
right to dispute the factum of the execution of the money receipt, promissory note
and the loan agreement dehors the plea of the deceased defendant. The
respondents just step into the shoes of the defendant and they cannot plead a
different plea from the plea already taken by the deceased defendant. The learned
counsel for the petitioner/plaintiff refers to the following case laws:
1. Babulal v. Jeshankar: AIR 1972 Cal 494
2. Smt. Dayali v. Kumari Lata: (2002) 03 RAJ CK 0089
3. NOIDA v. Pooran Singh: AIR 2004 All 218
4. Virgo Frozen Foods P. Ltd. v. SK Gandhi: (2012) 127 DRJ 339
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 10
to highlight the settled proposition of law that LRs of the deceased defendant
should stand in his shoe and cannot take a different by filing additional written
statement on their own and they should continue the suit from the stage at the
time death of the defendant.
[6.2]
Mr. S. Sachindra, learned counsel for the petitioner/plaintiff has also
pointed out that the original written statement filed by the deceased defendant and
the new additional written statement as proposed by the respondents/LRs of the
deceased defendant are almost similar and it is just a repetition. It is prayed that
the impugned order be set aside and the application seeking leave to file additional
written statement be rejected and the matter be heard on merit by the trial Court.
[7]
On the other hand, Mr. RK Milan, learned counsel for the
respondents/LRs of the sole deceased defendant submits that once the
respondents are made party, they have inherent right to file additional written
statement within the meaning of Order 22 Rule 4(2) of CPC, otherwise they would
not be able to defend the case properly and effectively. He further refers to Para 8
of the case in Sumtibai & Others reported as (2007) 10 SCC 82 (supra)
which held that newly impleaded parties ought to be allowed to file defence as
provided under Order 22 Rule 4(2) CPC.
[7.1]
Mr. RK Milan, learned counsel for the respondents further submits
that the present Revision Petition filed by the petitioner/plaintiff be dismissed being
devoid of merit and the respondents be permitted to file additional written
statement for doing complete justice in the matter.
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 11
[8]
Considered the rival submissions of the parties at bar, perused the
materials on record and the relevant case laws.
[9]
In the case of Abdul Razak v. Mangesh Rajaram Wagle: (2010)
2 SCC 432, Hon’ble Supreme Court, after discussing a catena of earlier decisions,
held that legal heirs could not plead inconsistent plea as different from that of the
deceased defendant and if LRs intended to contest the suit on their own, they
ought to implead themselves as defendants under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC to file
independent written statement. Relevant para are reproduced below:
29. In Jagdish Chander Chatterjee case 8 this Court interpreted the above
reproduced provision and held: (SCC pp. 464-65, para 10)
“10. Under sub-clause (2) of Rule 4 of Order 22 of the Civil Procedure
Code any person so made a party as a legal representative of the
deceased respondent was entitled to make any defence appropriate to
his character as legal representative of the deceased respondent. In
other words, the heirs and the legal representatives could urge all
contentions which the deceased could have urged except only those
which were personal to the deceased. Indeed this does not prevent the
legal representatives from setting up also their own independent title, in
which case there could be no objection to the court impleading them not
merely as the legal representatives of the deceased but also in their
personal capacity avoiding thereby a separate suit for a decision on the
independent title.”
30. In Bal Kishan case 9, the proposition laid down in Jagdish Chander
Chatterjee case 8 was reiterated, but its width was limited by observing that
the same would apply only to those cases where the court hearing the case
has jurisdiction to try the issues relating to independent title also. The facts
of Bal Kishan case 9 were that Respondent 1 therein filed a petition for
eviction of the tenant by alleging that the latter had sub-let the premises
without his consent. During the pendency of the petition, the tenant Musadi
Lal died. Thereupon, the appellant Bal Kishan filed an application for being
brought on record as legal representative of the deceased. The Rent
Controller allowed the application. Thereafter, the appellant filed additional
written statement asserting therein that the premises in question being
residential and commercial, the legal heir of the tenant could not be treated
as a tenant as defined under Section 2( h) of the Haryana Urban (Control of
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 12
Rent and Eviction) Act, 1973 and that possession of such legal heir of the
tenant would be that of a trespasser. He accordingly prayed for dismissal of
the eviction petition. The Rent Controller rejected the appellant’s plea and
allowed the eviction petition by holding that Musadi Lal had sub-let the
premises to Med Ram without his consent. The appeal and revision filed by
the appellant were dismissed by the appellate authority and the High Court
respectively.
31. Before this Court, the appellant relied upon the ratio of Jagdish
Chander Chatterjee case 8 and argued that he was entitled to raise an
additional plea that the eviction petition was not maintainable. While
rejecting this plea, this Court held: ( Bal Kishan case 9, SCC p. 158, para 4)
“4. But in the instant case the appellant cannot claim the benefit of the
above decision for two reasons. First, the appellant had not been
brought on record as a respondent in the eviction petition in his personal
capacity but had been brought on record only as the legal representative
of Musadi Lal. Secondly, in the circumstances of this case, even if a
prayer had been made to bring the appellant on record in his personal
capacity, the Rent Controller could not have allowed the application and
permitted him to raise the plea of independent title because such a plea
would oust the jurisdiction of the Rent Controller to try the case itself.
The observations made in Jagdish Chander Chatterjee case 8 have to be
confined to only those cases where the court hearing the case has
jurisdiction to try the issues relating to independent title also. The Rent
Controller, who had no jurisdiction to pass the decree for possession
against a trespasser could not have, therefore, impleaded the appellant
as a respondent to the petition for eviction in his independent capacity.”
32. In Vidyawati case 10 this Court considered the question whether a
person impleaded as a legal representative of the deceased defendant can
independently claim title to and interest in the property under a will. It was
contended by the appellant that claim of the original defendant and that of
the legal representative are founded on the will executed by Champawati
and the courts below were not right in refusing to permit her to file
additional written statement. While approving the view taken by the courts
below, this Court observed: (SCC p. 432, para 3)
“3. … Whether the petitioner has independent right, title and interest
dehors the claim of the first defendant is a matter to be gone into at a
later proceeding. It is true that when the petitioner was impleaded as a
party defendant, all rights under Order 22 Rule 4(2), and defences
available to the deceased defendant became available to her. In
addition, if the petitioner had any independent right, title or interest in
the property then she had to get herself impleaded in the suit as a party
defendant. … [thereafter, she could] resist the claim made by the
plaintiff or challenge the decree that may be passed in the suit.”
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 13
For taking this view, the Court relied upon the judgments in Jagdish
Chander Chatterjee case 8 and Bal Kishan case 9.
33. The judgments of Bal Kishan case 9 and Vidyawati case 10 are clearly
distinguishable. In the first case, the earlier judgment in Jagdish Chander
Chatterjee case 8, which substantially supports the appellants was
distinguished on the ground that the plea raised by the impleaded legal
representative of the tenant was inconsistent with his defence and if
accepted, the same would result in ouster of the jurisdiction of the Rent
Controller. In the second case also, the Court found that the plea raised by
the appellant, who was impleaded as legal representative of the defendant
that she had independent title under the will executed by Champawati was
not in consonance with the plea taken by the original defendant. However,
as discussed in the earlier part of the judgment, the claim made by the
appellants is in no way inconsistent with or derogatory to the defence set
up by Abdul Razak. In any case, once the additional written statement filed
by the appellants was taken on record without any objection by
Respondents 1 and 2, who also led their evidence keeping in view the
pleadings of the additional written statement, the High Court was not at all
justified in allowing the application filed for striking off the additional
written statement and that too without even adverting to Order 6 Rule 16
CPC and considering whether Respondents 1 and 2 were able to make out
a case for exercise of power by the court under that provision.
[10]
8.
(1972) 2 SCC 461
9.
(1986) 4 SCC 155
10.
(1995) 5 SCC 431
It is admitted fact that money receipt, promissory note and loan
agreement were executed between the petitioner/plaintiff and the deceased
defendant. The deceased defendant had filed written statement, adduced defence
witness and the matter was at the stage of hearing and on his death, his legal heirs
were brought on record. On perusal of the written statement filed by the deceased
defendant (Annexure-A/5) and the proposed additional written statement submitted
by the LRs of the deceased defendant (Annexure-A/8), this Court does not find any
new plea on behalf of the respondents/LRs in addition to those stated in the
original written statement. In substance, the main plea in both the written
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 14
statements are almost same to the extent denting of borrowing of Rs.15,00,000/(Rupees fifteen lakhs) by the defendant from the plaintiff/petitioner and execution
of the money receipt, promissory note and loan agreement. The additional written
statement as proposed by the respondents is filed for the sake of filing. It may also
be noted that no relief is sought against the respondents by the petitioner/plaintiff.
The fact of the present case is different from the case of Sumtibai (supra) where
the LRs were the co-owners of the suit property and hence necessary parties and
were held as entitled to file written statement as provided under Order 22 Rule 4(2)
of CPC. In the present case, filing or non-filing of additional written statement will
not make any difference in deciding the suit on merit as both have same contents.
Moreover, the respondents have no independent right and no relief is claimed in
the suit against them. This Court is of the opinion that the fact of Sumtibai
(supra) is not applicable to the fact of the present case. Filing of additional written
statement without any fruitful purpose will make unnecessary delay in the suit. LRs
have to defend the suit on the basis of plea already taken by the deceased
defendant.
[11]
Accordingly, it is held that the respondents, who are LRs of the
deceased sole defendant who had already filed written statement and contested
the suit by adducing defense witnesses, are not entitled to file additional written
statement within the meaning of Order 22 Rule 4(2) of CPC merely on the fact that
they had been brought on record as LRs of the deceased defendant and that too,
when the suit is at the stage of final hearing/argument.
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 15
[12]
As a result, the impugned order dated 13.12.2022 passed by the
Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Bishnupur in Judl. Misc. Case No.272 of 2022
allowing the respondents to file additional written statement as provided under
Order 22 Rule 4(2) of CPC is set aside and the matter is to be proceeded further
from the stage of final hearing.
[13]
With these observations and findings, the Revision Petition being
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023 is allowed. The parties are to bear their expenses.
It is clarified that this Court does not express any opinion on the merit of the case
and anything stated herein shall affect the case of the parties and the same shall
be confined to the facts required for disposal of this petition.
[14]
Send a copy of this judgment and order to the Learned Civil Judge,
Senior Division, Bishnupur for information and proceeding as per law.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
-Larson
CRP(C.R.P.Art.227) No.6 of 2023
Page 16
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review