The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. The circumstances of the instant case do not reflect any lack of bonafide. There is no doubt about the proximity of the relationship amongst the parties and it is permissible and has been permitted in almost all cases which share identical facts that compounding was allowed and there appears no reason why it should not be allowed in the instant case. Such settlements which aim to bring peace and cordiality in the family members and in the Society at large, should rather be encouraged.
11. In view of these facts and circumstances, the offence under section 323 stands compounded and the Appellant Luice @ Johny Anthony stands acquitted of the charge.
12. Consequently, in view of these developments, no useful purpose would be served by continuing with the appeal. The parties can hence demand and expect quashing of the FIR and the proceedings emanating thereafter. No reason could be there not to accept their plea in view of the developments having taken place. As such, the appeal preferred by the State, accordingly stands disposed of. Application(s), if any, also disposed of.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 11th May, 2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
+
CRL.A. 1414/2014, CRL.M.A. 11356/2026
LUICE @ JOHNY ANTHONY
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Prasanth. K., Advocate with all
the Appellants-in-person.
versus
THE STATE
Through:
+
.....Respondent
Mr. Nawal Kishore Jha, APP for State
with SI Lucy, PS Ranjit Nagar.
CRL.A. 137/2016
STATE GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Nawal Kishore Jha, APP for State
with SI Lucy, PS Ranjit Nagar.
versus
LUICE @ JOHNY ANTHONY & ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Prasanth.K., Advocate with all
the Appellants-in-person.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIMAL KUMAR YADAV
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
VIMAL KUMAR YADAV, J.
1.
Futility of fraternal fracas dawned upon the siblings / cousins but
quite late.
In the process, 16 years were consumed together with
money/stress, inconvenience, bad blood and mutual suspicion amongst the
extended family members. However, after a full round of criminal trial
Signed By:PRIYA
13:13:52
Crl.A. 1414/2014 & Crl.A.137/2016
resulting into verdict against the accused persons named in the FIR and time
spent in Appeal, the parties to a verbal dual which spilled over into a
physical fight, realized after conviction that it was nothing but a sheer
wastage of time, energy and resources etc., if it is carried forward further.
That paved the way for a settlement amongst the parties and based upon the
same, compounding of the offence was sought inasmuch as conviction was
under section 323 IPC, which is compoundable under section 319/320
Cr.P.C.
2.
It so happened that an FIR came to be registered under section 308/34
IPC at PS Ranjeet Nagar bearing registration number 173/2010 which
traversing through the trial culminated into the Impugned Judgment dated
20.09.2014 whereby learned Additional Sessions Judge-05, Tis Hazari
Courts, Delhi Convicted the Appellant herein under Section 323 IPC and
sentenced the convict through the order on sentence dated 22.09.2014 with
the following punishment:“Considering the facts and circumstances of the case in
hand, I am of the opinion that ends of justice would meet by
sentencing convict Lucie @ Johny Anthony, simple
imprisonment for a period of Six month for commission of
offence punishable U/s 323 IPC.”
3.
Two appeals were preferred, one by the accused-appellant and the
other by the State, seeking review of the Impugned Judgment in terms of
charge
framed
expecting
and
pleading
that
the
Respondent
in
Crl.A.137/2016 requires to be punished with enhanced punishment. Both the
appeals were taken together being essentially the outcome of a single
Judgment dated 20.09.2014.
4.
The brief facts required for appreciating the contentions of the rival
parties are delineated hereunder:Signature Not Verified
Signed By:PRIYA
13:13:52
Crl.A. 1414/2014 & Crl.A.137/2016
(a) On 04.09.2010 at about 10 pm, a verbal duel took place
between Smt. Rani, Morris James and Johnson James on one
side and Smt. Beena Anthony and Luice @ Johny Anthony
and Mr. Anurag on the other side. Soon it led to a free for all
and subsequently assault which led to the registration of FIR.
(b) Through the instant application i.e. Crl.MA.1356/2026,
the parties came together and sought that the offence under
section 323 IPC being compoundable, may be compounded
inasmuch as Smt. Rani, Morris James and Johnson James on
one side and Beena Anthony, Luice @ Johny Anthony and
Mr. Anurag on the other side, have voluntarily resolved and
reconciled their dispute and have all singed the ‘Settlement
Deed’ / ‘Memorandum of Understanding’ dated 09.02.2026
which has been placed on record. They have decided to live
in peace and harmony with each other and maintain cordial
family relationship. The ‘Memorandum of Understanding’
has been verified by the prosecution.
5.
Against the backdrop of aforesaid facts and circumstances, learned
counsel for the Appellant rather Counsel for the parties now with the aid of
the judgment in Mohd.Abdul Sufan Laskar & Ors. vs. State of Assam,
(2008) 9 SCC 333 whereby Hon’ble Supreme Court permitted the
compounding of offence under section 324 IPC, it is sought that this case
which is qua a lesser offence under section 323 IPC, should also be
permitted to be compounded. The relevant portion of the above mentioned
judgment is reproduced hereunder:
“11. We have heard learned counsel for the parties.
Signed By:PRIYA
13:13:52
Crl.A. 1414/2014 & Crl.A.137/2016
12. The learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the
parties have compromised the matter, entered into settlement and
an application is made to that effect praying therein that
compounding may be ordered for offences punishable under
Sections 147 and 324 IPC and an appropriate order in
accordance with law may be passed. The compromise deed is also
placed on record signed by the parties wherein it is expressly
stated that the injured Abdul Haque Laskar has voluntarily given
his consent without any force, threat, coercion, undue influence,
pressure, etc. from any quarter whatsoever for making the joint
compromise petition before this Court. A prayer is, therefore,
made by all the parties to compound the offence and acquit the
three appellants who have approached this Court.
13. “11. [Now] it is no doubt true that every crime is considered
to be an offence against the society as a whole and not only
against an individual even though an individual might have
suffered thereby. It is, therefore, the duty of the State to take
appropriate action against the offender. It is equally the duty of a
court of law administrating criminal justice to punish a criminal.
But there are offences and offences. Certain offences are very
serious in which compromise or settlement is not permissible.
Some other offences, on the other hand, are not so serious and the
law may allow the parties to settle them by entering into a
compromise. The compounding of an offence signifies that the
person against whom an offence has been committed has received
some gratification to an act as an inducement for his abstaining
from proceeding further with the case.
12. So far as the Code of Criminal Procedure is concerned,
Section 320 deals with offences which are compoundable,
either by the parties without the leave of the court or by the
parties but only with the leave of the court. Sub-section (1)
of Section 320 enumerates the offences which are
compoundable without the leave of the court, while subsection (2) of the said section specifies the offences which
are compoundable with the leave of the court. Sub-section
(9) of Section 320 declares: „No offence shall be
compounded except as provided by this section.‟ It is thus
clear that offences not referred to in sub-sections (1) and (2)
of Section 320 and not included in the table are not
compoundable. Similarly, offences punishable under laws
other than the Penal Code also cannot be compounded.”
Signed By:PRIYA
13:13:52
Crl.A. 1414/2014 & Crl.A.137/2016
14. Sub-section (8) of Section 320 of the Code expressly enacts
that where the composition of an offence under this section is
recorded by the court, it shall have effect of an acquittal of the
accused with whom the offence has been compounded.
15. Under the Code, as originally enacted in 1973, an offence
punishable under Section 324 IPC (voluntarily causing hurt by
dangerous weapons or means) was made compoundable with the
leave of the court. The said entry read as under:
“TABLE [Ed.: This table is quoted from Section 320(2) of the Criminal
Procedure Code, 1973.]
Offence
Section of the Penal Person
by
whom
Code, 1860 applicable offence
may
be
compounded
Voluntarily causing
hurt by dangerous
weapons or means.
The person to whom
hurt is caused.”
16. It is no doubt true as stated by the learned counsel for the
appellants even at the time of preliminary hearing of this matter
that by the Code of Criminal Procedure (Amendment) Act, 2005
(Act 25 of 2005) the above entry has been deleted. In other words,
an offence of voluntarily causing hurt by dangerous weapons or
means punishable under Section 324 IPC is no more
compoundable. The Amendment Act of 2005 came into force from
23-6-2006.
17. As we have already noted, according to the prosecution, the
appellants had committed the offence on 15-6-1995. In view of the
above fact, in our opinion, Act 25 of 2005 has no application to
the facts of the case. We, therefore, see no ground to refuse
permission as sought by the parties who have compromised the
offence which was compoundable under the Code as it stood in
1995. If it is so, compounding can be permitted and the accused
(the appellants) can be acquitted.
18. For the foregoing reasons, in our opinion, the appeal deserves
to be allowed and is accordingly allowed by holding that since the
matter has been compounded by compromise between the parties
Signed By:PRIYA
13:13:52
Crl.A. 1414/2014 & Crl.A.137/2016
and there is no illegality therein, such compounding can be
permitted by the Court. The appellants are, hence, entitled to
acquittal.
19. The order of conviction and sentence recorded by all courts is
hereby set aside and the appellants are ordered to be acquitted of
the charges levelled against them.”
6.
In addition to the aforesaid judgment, learned counsel for the
Appellant has also placed reliance on two more judgements i.e. Anand Jain
& Ors. vs. State (2012) SCC Online Del 612 and Rakesh vs. The State,2016
SCC OnLine 3825, and averred that in a similar set of facts and
circumstances, where the parties were only neighbours, whereas in the
instant case, they are part of the extended family, such a compounding was
allowed.
7.
Learned APP for the State on the other hand came up with the plea
that the victims Morris James and Johnson James were hit on their head with
a cricket bat, which had the potential to result into fatal injury and therefore,
it is submitted that compounding should not be permitted, especially when
an Appeal has been preferred by the Prosecution too, for enhancement of the
punishment under Section 308 IPC. On the aspect of the compounding,
learned APP for State chose not to say anything except that the
‘Memorandum of Understanding’ placed on record, has been verified and
that the parties involved are family members. However, learned APP for
State vehemently argued that penal punishment in the form of imposition of
fine/ cost be levied upon the Appellant(s), to ensure that such act should not
repeated in future.
8.
Having taking into consideration the facts as unfolded in the
preceding paras, especially the fact that the parties involved are closely
related to each other and that they have now, after so many years, realized
Signed By:PRIYA
13:13:52
Crl.A. 1414/2014 & Crl.A.137/2016
their folly and have resumed their familial relationship. The aggressor has
been forgiven by the victims, who happen to be the uncles of the aggressor.
9.
The ultimate aim of Law and Court Administration is to ensure peace
in the Society and adherence to the Laws. If the peace is otherwise achieved
by the parties then in that eventuality, the Court should not create any
impediment or a road block rather encourage it, unless it is not bonafide.
10.
The circumstances of the instant case do not reflect any lack of
bonafide. There is no doubt about the proximity of the relationship amongst
the parties and it is permissible and has been permitted in almost all cases
which share identical facts that compounding was allowed and there appears
no reason why it should not be allowed in the instant case. Such settlements
which aim to bring peace and cordiality in the family members and in the
Society at large, should rather be encouraged.
11.
In view of these facts and circumstances, the offence under section
323 stands compounded and the Appellant Luice @ Johny Anthony stands
acquitted of the charge.
12.
Consequently, in view of these developments, no useful purpose
would be served by continuing with the appeal. The parties can hence
demand and expect quashing of the FIR and the proceedings emanating
thereafter. No reason could be there not to accept their plea in view of the
developments having taken place. As such, the appeal preferred by the State,
accordingly stands disposed of. Application(s), if any, also disposed of.
13.
In view of this, both the Appeal(s) stands disposed off.
VIMAL KUMAR YADAV, J
MAY 11, 2026/bj
Signed By:PRIYA
13:13:52
Crl.A. 1414/2014 & Crl.A.137/2016
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review