Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision : 07.01.2026
W.P.(C) 19541/2025
LT. COL. RAVNEET(RETD.)
Through:
versus
.....Petitioner
Mr. Rakesh Kumar, Adv.
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Ripudaman Bhardwaj, CGSC,
Mr. Rudra Paliwal, Adv. and Major
Anish Muralidhar.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J. (ORAL)
CM APPL. 81509/2025 (Exemption)
1.
Exemption is allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
The application stands disposed of.
W.P.(C) 19541/2025 & CM APPL. 81510/2025 (Lengthy synopsis)
3.
This writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
lays a challenge to the order passed by the Armed Force Tribunal, Principal
Bench, New Delhi (Tribunal) in Original Application (OA) No.1372/2021
with the following prayers:“A. Set aside the impugned Judgment dated 29.05.2025
in Original Application No. 1372/2021 of Hon’ble
Armed Fores tribunal, Principal Bench New Delhi, and
B. Issue an appropriate order or writ in the nature of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
mandamus thereby commanding the respondent to
reinstate the petitioner and to grant her permanent
commission, in terms of judgment dated 17.02.2020 of
Hon’ble High Court in Babita Puniya Case, and/or.”
4.
The facts of this case which can be gathered from the petition are that
the petitioner was commissioned in the Indian Army through the Women
Special Entry Scheme (Officers) as on 20.03.2004 in Corps of Engineers for
a period of ten years. During her service, respondent no.1 vide notification
dated 28.10.2005 extended the validity of appointment of women officers in
the Indian Army and also the tenure of women Short Service Commission
(SSC) officers upto 14 years. The petitioner being desirous to avail this
option for grant of SSC (non-technical) applied for the same, after which the
terms of engagement were converted to 10 + 4 years under the scheme and
she was to be considered for extension of service in her 10 th year of service
i.e. 2013-14.
5.
It is the case of the petitioner that the respondent no. 1 vide letter
dated 26.09.2008 started Permanent Commissions prospectively for SSC
women officers in the JAG Branch and the Army Education Corps.
Meanwhile, this Court pronounced its judgment in the case of Babita
Puniya v. The Secretary & Anr., WP(C) No. 1597/2003 dated 12.03.2010
and a Special Leave Petition against the said judgment was preferred
seeking an interim stay. The application seeking the interim stay was not
allowed by the Supreme Court. It is for this reason that the petitioner was
expecting a permanent commission along with her male counterparts. The
reason why her case was not considered by the respondents according to the
petitioner is that they were awaiting a final decision in the civil appeal by
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court had decided the said appeal vide
judgment dated 17.02.2020 titled Secretary, Ministry of Defence v. Babita
Puniya and Ors., 2020 INSC 198.
6.
Mr. Rakesh Kumar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner argues that the petitioner is entitled to the benefit of the earlier
judgment dated 12.03.2010 and since there was no stay against the operation
of the said judgment, her male counterparts of the same branch were granted
permanent commission. He highlights the fact that she had completed
fourteen years of service and argues that substantial question of law which
need to be decided in the present petition is that whether the petition is
entitiled to be granted Permanent Commission in view of judgment in the
case of Secretary, Ministry of Defence v. Babita Puniya (supra).
7.
According to him, on 25.02.2019, SSC women officers were granted
permanent commission. However, the policy deprived all women officers
with more than 14 years of service from Permanent Commission, including
the petitioner as the said policy was prospective in nature i.e., with effect
from the date of issuance of letter, being 25.02.2019. It was thereafter that
the petitioner on 15.07.2019 sought release from service during her
provisional extension. He states that even in this scenario, the petitioner
would be entitled for consideration for the permanent commission since the
case of the petitioner would be covered by the judgment of the Supreme
Court in the case of Wg. Cdr. A. U. Tayyaba (Retd.) and Ors. v. Union of
India and Ors., Civil Appeal No. 79-82 of 2012 dated 16.11.2022; wherein
the appellants who were working in the Air Force and had sought voluntary
release from service between the years 2006 to 2009 were granted relief on
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
the ground that the respondents therein had subjected them to gender
discrimination and had gone against their legitimate expectation that in their
fifth year of service, they would also be considered at par with their male
counterparts.
8.
Mr. Ripudaman Bhardwaj, learned Central Government Standing
Counsel argues that the case of the respondents is that the issue pertaining to
the petitioner was not considered since the issue had not attained finality
inasmuch as the judgment dated 12.03.2010 was under consideration of the
Supreme Court.
9.
Mr. Bhardwaj relied on the arguments advanced before the Armed
Forces Tribunal (“AFT”) to state that after the Supreme Court rendered the
judgment on 17.02.2020, the petitioner had sent applications seeking her
reinstatement in service. She was informed vide letter dated 10.11.2020 that
her request for reinstatement in service had been duly examined by the
competent authority but the same has not been acceded to as the petitioner
was found to be ineligible. Even otherwise, the counsel for the respondents
while drawing an analogy in the case of the petitioner, states that she had
submitted an undertaking while seeking release stating that she would not
claim any benefit accruing out of the said judgment.
10.
It is the case of Mr. Bhardwaj that the petitioner vide the present
petition seeks to claim benefit of the judgment as an afterthought. In this
regard, he has relied upon the reasoning given by the Tribunal to state that
the petitioner had been commissioned for a short service after which her
period of engagement was extended to 10 + 4 years vide letter dated
20.07.2006. The petitioner and other women officers were granted extension
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
of tenure beyond 14 years through a provisional extension of service from
20.03.2018 till the final adjudication in the case of Babita Puniya (supra).
11.
According to him, during the pendency of the appeal before the
Supreme Court, the petitioner opted to seek her release out of her own
volition even when she was granted extension to continue in service but
chose not to do so citing personal grounds. He states that a voluntary
decision amounts to a conscious waiver of rights and a benefit cannot be
claimed as per the judgment in the case of Babita Puniya (supra).
12.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
record, the short question which arises for consideration is whether the
petitioner is entitled to the benefit of the judgement in the case of Babita
Puniya (supra) or not.
13.
Upon a perusal of the record it must be noted that petitioner herself
had written to the Integrated Headquarters of the Ministry of Defence
(MoD) wherein she has sought release from service while serving during the
extension period. The letter of the petitioner dated 15.07.2019 reads as
under:“1. I, WS-00861W Lt Col Ravneet was commissioned
in the Corps of EME on 20 Mar 2004 and am presently
posted with 16 Corps Zone Wksp since Jun 2019.
2. I would like to submit that I have completed 14 yrs
of service in the org and I'm presently on extn vide
IHQ of MoD (Army) letter No 05528/SSC(Women
T/NT)-23/MS-7B dt 06 Mar 2018 (copy att).
3. It is also intimated that I have two children aged 3
yrs and 10 yrs. My spouse IC-60318F Col Amit Nath is
an Ord Offr and is presently posted as Comdt, OD
Avadi. Due to organisational constraints my request
for spouse coord posting was turned down and as per
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
sector profile I have been posted to 16 Corps Zone
Wksp (Cl in Fd).
4. Due to adm and organisational constraints posed in
present duty stn (Cl ir Fd) it is difficult for me to rear
my children single handedly at this remote loc. Hence I
would like to seek release on compassionate grounds at
the earliest pl.
5. I view of the above, it's requested that my release
may pl be sanctioned at the earliest so that I can
complete all formalities connected to my release
process
6. For your kind consideration and early approval
please.”
14.
Furthermore, it is an admitted case that the petitioner‟s request for
release had been approved by the MoD vide letter dated 12.09.2019 wherein
it had been recorded as follows:“1. WS-00861W Lt Col Ravneet, EME, whose request
for release from Army during provisional extended
tenure beyond 14 years of service has been approved,
will be relieved of her duties w.e.f.. 21 Sep 2019.
2. The officer will carry a reserve liability for a period
of five years from the date of release or upto the age of
37 years whichever is earlier.
3. The officer is permitted to avail entitled balance of
leave as per policy for the year/block Terminal leave of
28 days is also entitled to the officer, which must be
availed at the end ie after completion of all types of
leave or wef the following day the officer is relieved of
her duties
4. CO/OC unit is requested to forward only one copy of
the following documents (as per the detailed
instructions enclosed) to MS-7B/MS Branch,
Integrated HQ of MoD (Army):a. Undertaking by the Officer for Reserve Liability for
a period of five years duly countersigned by the
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
CO/OC by 30 Sep 2019
b. Release Medical Board (AFMSF-18) proceedings by
30 Sep 2019
c. Part II order will be published on completion of
Terminal Leave (with struck off strength date) for
publication of release Gazette Notification.”
15.
It is also not disputed that after the petitioner had been released from
service, she requested to join back her duties and sought cancellation of the
release order vide letter dated 30.01.2020. We may refer to the contents of
the said letter below:“2 The case pertains to WS-00861W Lt Col Ravneet of
Corps of EME. The offr commissioned in the Yr 2004
has served the org for over 15 yrs. Subsequent to the
grant of provisional extn post her initial stipulated pd
of engagement of 10-04 yrs, the offr continued the
service beyond the initial contractual pd. The offr is
presently released from service wef Sep 2019 and seeks
canc of the release order based on the under
mentioned facts.
3. Facts of the case in respect of the offr are submitted
as under: (a) Yr of Commission Mar 2004, ref at para 1(a)
above
(b) Prelim terms of engagement for five yrs wef
(2004 to 2009).
(c) Extn of initial pd of engagement from five to ten
yrs under revised terms of service (wef 2004 to
2014).
(d) Screening for grant of PC/extn through No 5 SB
vide ref at Para 1(b) above.
(e) Grant of extn for four yrs after completion of
initial contractual pd in Dec 2013 vide ref at Para
1(c) above. (e)
(f) Provisional extn beyond 14 yrs of service wef
Mar 2018 vide ref at Para 1(d) above.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
(g) Application for release from service vide ref at
Para 1(e) above.
(h) Release from service in Sep 2019 vide ref at
Para 1(f) above.
4. It is kindly submitted that grant of provisional extn
to the offr on completion of mandated 14 yrs of
engagement was subject to final adjudication of the
Civil Appeal No 9367-9369/2011 vide letter at para
1(d) above. Despite being ambiguity in terms of service
and tenure engagement coupled with the impending
plea for grant of permanent commission to women in
the Army for the last one decade, the officer continued
striving for excellence in discharge of her duties.
5. However, despite contributing for over 14 yrs of
service in the org in the ibid uncertainty, perplexity
and absence of any suitable policy to the effect, the
officer was in a state of pure neglect and was being
treated like a second grade officer. As a result due to
long pendency of the issue being sub-judice and
absence of any concrete guidelines on the sub, the
officer on admn and org constraints was forced to
apply for release from service in Jul 2019 vide ref at
para 1(g) above. The same was granted vide letter at
para 1(h) above.
6. Presently in light of the recent devp and fresh
perspective under the esteem guidance of the COAS,
the org is on a path towards reforms and is making
significant strides in ensuring more inclusive envt for
women offr. The org is actively considering the process
of formulation of some concrete policy and issue of
dims charting out clear roadmap for women officer in
the Army. Thus it is humbly requested that the officer
may pl be called to join back for discharging her duties
in the org with immediate effect since the request for
release was primarily based on the grounds of non
availability of PC to EME Corps.
7. In view of the facts highlighted above, may I humbly
request the COAS to kindly consider the request for
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
revoking the release order in respect of the officer and
grant permission to resume her duties back to the
service as per the cannons of natural justice and
possible one time relief on the sub. Your kind
consideration will go a long way in securing the future
of the officer in it of self-sustenance and possible
rightful place within the org.”
16.
She had also written letters dated 05.03.2020, 24.03.2020 and
21.07.2020 wherein she had reiterated her request for reinstatement in
service and sought the revocation of her release order. However, the
competent authorities vide letter dated 10.11.2020, rejected her request by
stating as follows:
“1.
Please
refer
to
your
letter
No.
00861/RN/Pers/DO dated 30 Jan 2020.
2. Your request for reinstatement in service has been
examined with due consideration by the competent
auth but has not been accepted, being not eligible.
3. All ranks of Indian Army convey their good wishes
to you and your family.”
17.
We are of the opinion that the conclusion of the Tribunal must be
given due consideration in the facts of this case. The relevant portion of the
impugned order reads as under:“26. A perusal of the directions issued by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in its judgment in Babita Puniya
(supra) clearly indicates that, by virtue of being in
service in terms of Para 69(i)(a), and in light of the
protection extended to her by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court, the applicant would have been entitled to be
considered for the grant of Permanent Commission, or,
in the alternative, would have completed twenty years
of service, thereby becoming eligible for the grant of
service pension. However, the applicant opted to seek
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
retirement, of her own volition, even when granted
extension to continue in service and on purely personal
grounds. This voluntary decision amounted to a
conscious waiver of her right to claim the benefit of the
judgment rendered in Babita Puniya (supra). It is
evident, therefore, that the applicant herself, by
undertaking that she will not seek any benefits arising
out of the aforesaid judgment, cannot come back later
to seek the same benefits on the ground of parity.
27. We find it pertinent to place reliance on our
observations in Lt Col Aпирата Munshi & Ors v.
Union of India & Ors [OA 599/2021: AFT PB]
involving a similar factual matrix, relevant paragraphs
of which are reproduced herein as under:
48. From a detailed look at the aforesaid
directions of the judgment of Hon’ble
Supreme Court, it is well clear that by virtue
of being a petitioner before the Delhi High
Court, in line with Para 69(iii), the applicant
would have been entitled for all the benefits
granted by Para 69(i), save from the fact that
the applicant had moved the Delhi High
Court by filing the writ petition, and
secondly, who had retired during the
pendency of the case before the Hon’ble
Supreme Court.
49. However, the instant case in hand is
different from the Babita Puniya judgement
on the factual matrix, wherein the applicant
was earlier granted benefit of the aforesaid
directions in the form of reinstatement in
service, and by the time Babita Puniya would
have been decided, she would have been
considered for grant of Permanent
Commission, or alternatively, would have
completed 20 years in service, and thus,
would have been eligible for grant of service
pension, but the applicant chose to take
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
premature retirement as her voluntary
decision, that too on purely personal
grounds, waiving off her right to seek benefit
arising out of the judgment of Apex Court in
Babita Puniya (supra), and not that she
retired upon completion of her terms of
engagement.
50. With respect to the reliance placed by the
applicant on two important judgements of
Wg Cdr A U Tayyaba and Ors v. Union of
India & Ors. [2024 INSC 311] and Cdr Jaya
Kapoor (Retd.) & ors. V. Union of India &
Ors. [TA 01/2022 {W.P.(C) No.8275/2010
Delhi HC}], we find the relief granted by the
Apex Court to the appellants in Wg Cdr A U
Tayyaba (supra) and by this Tribunal to the
applicants in Cdr Jaya Kapoor (supra) is
based on different factual context.
51. While in Wg CdrAU Tayyaba (supra),
appellants retired from the service on
completion of their terms of engagement but
approached the Delhi High Court,
immediately after the judgement of Delhi
High Court dated 12.03.2010 in Babita
Puniya v. Secy, Ministry of Defence (supra)
challenging the manner of implementation by
Indian Air Force, and admittedly, when the
decision was rendered by the Supreme Court
in Secy, Ministry of Defence v. Babita
Puniya (supra) on 17.03.2020, appellants
were before the Delhi High Court. Similarly,
in the case of Cdr Jaya Kapoor (supra),
applicants had retired on completion of
terms of engagement and were before the
Delhi High Court on the date of judgement of
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Babita Puniya
(supra).
52. In the instant case, while the applicant
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
was a petitioner before the Delhi High Court
and respondent before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Babita Puniya (supra), she chose to
prematurely retire from service on personal
grounds, waiving off her rights to claim any
benefit arising out of aforesaid adjudication,
and thus, instant case is different from the
law laid down in Wg Cdr AU Tayyaba
(supra), and Cdr Jaya Kapoor (supra).
28. Therefore, in view of the aforesaid analysis, we are
of the considered view that the position adopted by this
Tribunal – that an officer who, having been eligible for
consideration for the grant of Permanent Commission,
voluntarily relinquishes such a right, cannot
subsequently claim the benefit thereof on account of a
later legal development – is legally sound and wellfounded. Such an officer, having consciously elected to
forego the entitlement, is bound by the principle of
promissory stoppels and cannot be permitted to
approbate and reprobate. We find no infirmity in the
reasoning and see no cause to take a different view.
29. Before parting, we must clearly specify that we
have extensively considered the differences in factual
context of all three OAs tagged herein, and we find that
none of the differences change our aforesaid
conclusive opinion on the material facts and
circumstances in either of the OAs.
30. Hence, the aforesaid OAs including the two tagged
OAs namely OA 1372/2021 & OA 1452/2021 fail on
merits, and thus, being dismissed as devoid of merit.”
(emphasis supplied)
18.
The Supreme Court, in Secretary, Ministry of Defence v. Babita
Puniya (supra), while affirming the decision of this Court had held as
under:
“87.3 SSC women officers who are granted PC in pursuance of
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
the above directions will be entitled to all consequential
benefits including promotion and financial benefits. However,
these benefits would be made available to those officers in
service or those who had moved the Delhi High Court by filing
the writ petitions and those who had retired during the course
of the pendency of the proceedings.”
19.
Thus, it is clear that the benefit of the judgment would be given to
those officers in service, or those who had moved this Court by filing the
writ petitions, and those who had retired during the course of pendency of
the proceedings. In Wg. Cdr. A. U. Tayyaba (supra), the appellants had
retired from service after completion of their terms of engagement, and
approached this Court immediately after the judgment in Secretary,
Ministry of Defence v. Babita Puniya (supra).
20.
However, in the present case, as held by the Tribunal, the petitioner
had, out of her own volition, sought voluntary release from service citing
personal reasons, waiving off her right to claim any benefit arising out of the
judgments. If that be so, we are in agreement with the decision of the
Tribunal that the petitioner having consciously elected to relinquish the
entitlement, cannot now claim such entitlement. Though, the learned counsel
for the petitioner has contended that the appellants had voluntarily retired
from service, no such position emerges from a perusal of the judgment.
Paragraph 21 of the judgment construes the expression „retired‟ as a release
from service, since the SSCOs were governed by a release from service
following the initial tenure of five years followed by two extensions of six
years and four years respectively.
21.
In view of the discussion above, and in the facts of this case, we are of
the view that the Tribunal was justified in dismissing the petition.
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
22.
We find no merit in the present petition and the same is liable to be
dismissed. We order so accordingly.
23.
The pending application is dismissed as having become infructuous.
V. KAMESWAR RAO, J
MANMEET PRITAM SINGH ARORA, J
JANUARY 07, 2026/sr
Signed By:PRADEEP
SHARMA
19:03:13
W.P. (C) 19541/2025
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review