Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 02nd February, 2026
+
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
LOVELESH SINGHAL,
PROPRIETOR, M/S SHIVANI OVERSEAS NO.66
3RD FLOOR, POCKET-13,
SECTOR-24, ROHINI,
DELHI-110085.
CORRESPONDENCE ADDRESS:
HOUSE NO. 88, UGF, RAJDHANI ENCLAVE
PITAM PURA, DELHI-110034.
.....PETITIONER
Through:
Mr. A.K. Babbar, Mr. Surendra
Kumar, Mr. Atul Babbar, Mr.
Bharat Kumar Tripathi & Mr.
Rahul Chauhan, Advs.
Versus
1. CENTRAL BORAD OF INDIRECT TAXES & CUSTOMS
SUBSTITUTED FOR CENTRAL BOARD OF EXCISE
& CUSTOMS,
GST POLICY WINGS, NORTH BLOCK,
NEW DELHI.
……. REPSONDENT NO.1
2. COMMISSIONER OF THE CENTRAL TAXES,
DELHI WEST, 6TH FLOOR,
GST BHAWAN, NANGAL RAY A, JANAKPURI
NEW DELHI.
……. RESPONDENT NO.2
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
3. SUPERINTENDENT/ APPRAISER/
SENIOR INTELLIGENCE OFFICER
GROUP-01, 6TH FLOOR, GST BHAWAN,
NANGAL RAY A, JANAK PURI,
NEW DELHI-110046.
…… RESPONDENT NO.3
Through:
Ms. Anushree Narain, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr. Naman
Choula and Mr. Yamit Jetley,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AJAY DIGPAUL
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE, J.
CM APPL. 6972/2026
1.
Exemption allowed, subject to all just exceptions.
2.
The application stands disposed of.
W.P.(C) 1426/2026 & CM APPL. 6973/2026
3.
The petitioner has approached this Court with following prayers:
“i) Your lordship may be pleased to issue a Writ/
Direction quashing of the impugned Circular No.
3/3/2017 dated 05.07.2017 and the impugned
summon dated 03.11.2025 issued U/s 70 of the
CGST Act.
ii) Your lordship may please to stay the operation
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
of
summon
dated
03.11.2025
issued
by
Respondent.”
4.
The facts necessary for deciding the present petition are as under:
a. In an inquiry in connection with M/s Midas Marketing Inc.,
the petitioner was served with a summon dated 03rd
November, 2025, issued under Section 70 of the Central
Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (in short, “CGST Act”),
by
Respondent
No.3/Superintendent/Appraiser/Senior
Intelligence Officer, Office of the Commissioner of Central
Taxes. The said summon was issued by the said officer based
on the circular dated 5th July, 2017, issued by the Central
Board of Excise and Customs in exercise of the powers
vested, as mentioned therein.
b. Vide said summon, petitioner was called upon to remain
present for tendering voluntary statement, production of
Bank Statement and Sales invoice and ledger in relation to
M/s Midas Marketing Inc.
c. Vide the said circular, issued by the Government of India in
exercise of the powers conferred under sub-section (91) of
Section 2 of the CGST Act; Section 20 of the Integrated
Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017; and subject to the
provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 5 of the CGST Act,
duties were assigned to the officers mentioned in column 2 of
the said circular, as regards their functions as proper officers
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
in relation to various sections of the CGST Act and the rules
made thereunder.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioner, while assailing the very
circular, submits that the circular has been issued by the respondent-Board,
thereby assigning such powers, which authority is not vested in the Board.
So as to substantiate his contention, he has invited our attention to subsection (16) of Section 2 of the CGST Act, which defines “Board”; subsection (91) of Section 2 of the CGST Act, which defines “proper officer”;
and sub-section (25) of Section 2 of the CGST Act, which defines
“Commissioner in the Board”.
6.
Drawing support from the provisions of Section 168, he urges that
even if the sub-section (2) of Section 168 of the CGST Act contemplates
that the powers specified in the said sub-section are to be exercised with
the approval of the Board, the Board, in principle, is not empowered to
assign duties to the proper officer. According to him, such powers
exclusively vest in the “Commissioner in the Board”, as defined under subsection (25) of Section 2 of the CGST Act. That being so, he would urge
that the circular itself is without the authority of law. That being so, the
officer concerned in law is not empowered to issue the show-cause
notice/impugned summons under the provisions of Section 70 of the
CGST Act.
7.
The learned counsel has also relied upon the interim orders passed
by the Rajasthan High Court in Civil Writ Petition No. 11503/2025 at
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
Jaipur in the matter of M/s. ACME Cleantech Solution Pvt. Ltd. v. Union
of India & Ors. According to him, since the issue is already under active
consideration before the Rajasthan High Court, this Court must pass a
similar order in the matter, thereby staying the consequential proceedings
initiated by the respondent pursuant to the impugned summon.
8.
The learned counsel would further urge that the summon issued to
the petitioner, based on the aforesaid circular, directed him to appear on
10th November, 2025. He would claim that the said notice was served upon
the petitioner on 11th November, 2025 and as such, on the date on which
the petitioner’s appearance was scheduled, the summon was served on a
subsequent date. As such, according to him, the respondent needs to be
directed to reconsider the date of appearance of the petitioner and the
respondent be restrained from passing any adverse order without hearing
the petitioner.
9.
As against the above, the learned counsel appearing for the
respondent submits that there is no quarrel with the rescheduling of the
date of appearance, provided in the summons. According to her, this Court,
as per the convenience of the petitioner, can direct the appearance of the
petitioner on any date and it is only subsequent thereto that the appropriate
proceedings will be taken to their logical end.
10.
According to her, if we see the provisions of Section 168, a plain
reading of the said section contemplates that sub-section (1) empowers the
Board, for achieving the purpose and uniformity in the implementation of
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
the Act, to issue such orders, instructions, or directions to the Central Tax
Officers as it may deem fit. Thereupon, such officers and all other persons
employed in the implementation of the Act are required to observe and
follow such orders, instructions, or directions.
11.
Further, she submitted that even if the impugned circular is perused,
the same is issued under the signature of the Commissioner, GST, which
presupposes that it is the Commissioner, GST, who, pursuant to the
mandate provided under sub-section (2) of Section 168, has taken the
approval of the Board and issued the circular. She would further urge that
upon perusal of the circular, even if it speaks of there being instructions to
the Principal Chief Commissioners, Chief Commissioners, Principal
Commissioners, Commissioners of Central Tax (All), and the Director
General of Systems about the powers being assigned pursuant to the
provisions referred to hereinabove, the fact remains that the Board prima
facie appears to have approved the decision of the other Commissioners.
12.
That being so, she would urge that the petition is liable to be
dismissed.
13.
In the aforesaid factual background, the relevant statutory
provisions which requires reproduction are as under:
“SECTION 2(91) OF THE CGST ACT
“proper officer" in relation to any function to be
performed under this Act, means the Commissioner
or the officer of the central tax who is assigned that
function by the Commissioner in the Board;
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
SECTION 2(16) OF THE CGST ACT
"Board" means the Central Board of Indirect
Taxes and Customs constituted under the Central
Boards of Revenue Act, 1963 (54 of 1963);
SECTION 2(25) OF THE CGST ACT
“Commissioner in the Board" means
Commissioner referred to in section 168;
the
SECTION 168 OF THE CGST ACT
Power to issue instructions or directions.(1) The Board may, if it considers it necessary or
expedient so to do for the purpose of uniformity in
the implementation of this Act, issue such orders,
instructions or directions to the central tax officers
as it may deem fit, and thereupon all such officers
and all other persons employed in the
implementation of this Act shall observe and follow
such orders, instructions or directions.
(2) The Commissioner specified in clause (91) of
section 2, sub-section (3) of section 5, clause (b) of
sub-section (9) of section 25, subsections (3) and
(4) of section 35, sub-section (1) of section 37, subsection (2) of section 38, subsection (6) of section
39, [sub-section (1) of section 44, sub-sections (4)
and (5) of section 52] 103, [sub-section (1) of
section 143, except the second proviso thereof],
sub-section (1) of section 151, clause (1) of subsection (3) of section 158 and section 167 shall
mean a Commissioner or Joint Secretary posted in
the Board and such Commissioner or Joint
Secretary shall exercise the powers specified in the
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
said sections with the approval of the Board."
14.
No doubt, the learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon sub-
section (2) of Section 168 of the CGST Act so as to substantiate his
contention that it is the Commissioner in the Board, who is required to
route the proposal and the same is required to be approved by the Board,
as provided under sub-section (2) of Section 168 of the CGST Act, in the
matter of assigning functions by the Commissioner in the Board.
15.
As far as the circular under challenge is concerned, the prima facie
reading of the same indicates that the words employed therein are that the
Board is assigning the officers mentioned in column 2 of the table to
exercise the functions as proper officers in relation to the various sections
of the CGST Act and the rules framed thereunder.
16.
The fact remains that it is not in dispute that the Commissioner is
also a part of the Board. Once it is not in dispute that the Commissioner is
part of the Board, and sub-section (2) of Section 168 contemplates that the
assignment of functions to the Central Tax Officers is upon a proposal of
the Commissioner in the Board, we see no reason to disbelieve that the
same was not under the authority of the Commissioner, which was
approved by the Board as required under sub-section (2) of Section 168
referred above.
17.
In that view of the matter, we see no reason to infer that while
issuing the circular dated 5th July, 2017, the proposal was not mooted
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
through the Commissioner in the Board, or that the same was not approved
by the Board as defined under sub-section (16) of Section 2 and subsection (25) of Section 2 of the CGST Act.
18.
In law, we have to presume that the circular is valid and the onus is
on the petitioner to discharge the burden of establishing that the circular
was issued without authority or legal approval. We are fortified in our view
by the judgment of the Apex Court in State of Tamil Nadu v. P.
Krishnamurthy, (2006) 4 SCC 517, the relevant portion of which reads as
under:
“15. There is a presumption in favour of
constitutionality or validity of a subordinate
legislation and the burden is upon him who attacks
it to show that it is invalid. It is also well
recognised that a subordinate legislation can be
challenged under any of the following grounds:
(a) Lack of legislative competence to make the
subordinate legislation.
(b) Violation of fundamental rights
guaranteed under the Constitution of India.
(c) Violation of any provision of the
Constitution of India.
(d) Failure to conform to the statute under
which it is made or exceeding the limits of
authority conferred by the enabling Act.
(e) Repugnancy to the laws of the land, that is,
any enactment.
(f) Manifest arbitrariness/unreasonableness
(to an extent where the court might well say
that the legislature never intended to give
authority to make such rules).”
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
19.
Though not specifically in context of a validity of a circular or a
notification, the Apex Court reiterated the principle of presumption in
administrative law in the matter of G.M.(Operations) S.B.I. & Anr vs
R.Periyasamy, Civil Appeal No. 10942/2014, which reads thus:“In administrative law, it is a settled principle that
the onus of proof rests upon the party alleging the
invalidity of an order. In other words, there is a
presumption that the decision or executive order is
properly and validly made, a presumption
expressed in the maxim omnia praesumuntur rite
esse acta which means 'all things are presumed to
be done in due form.”
20.
Furthermore, a reference can be made to the decision of the
Supreme Court in Ram Krishna Dalmia v. S.R. Tendolkar, 1958 SCC
OnLine SC 6, wherein it was held as under:
“18. …….We are not of opinion that they do not. It
is not for us to say on this application and we do
not in fact say or even suggest that the allegations
about the petitioners and their concerns are at all
well founded. It is sufficient for our present
purpose to say that the facts disclosed on the face
of the notification itself and the facts which have
been brought to our notice by the affidavits afford
sufficient support to the presumption of
constitutionality of the notification. There being
thus a presumption of validity in favour of the Act
and the notification, it is for the petitioners to
allege and prove beyond doubt that other persons
or companies similarly situate have been left out
and the petitioners and their companies have been
singled out for discriminatory and hostile
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
treatment. The petitioners have, in our opinion,
failed to discharge that onus…….”
21.
But for relying on the language used in the Preamble of the circular
dated 5th July, 2017, wherein the word “Board” is used in reference to
assigning the officers mentioned in column 2 as regards the functions to
be exercised as proper officers, the petitioner has neither, in clear terms,
pleaded that the proposal was to be mooted at the level of the
Commissioner in the Board, nor it is established through documents to
infer that he has discharged the burden that the circular impugned herein
was issued without authority.
22.
Rather, the learned counsel for the respondent, in our opinion, is
justified in claiming that the entire exercise in the matter of issuance of the
circular was at the behest of the Commissioner in the Board and the Board
has granted approval to it.
23.
That being so, we see no reason to cause interference in the matter
of testing the validity of the impugned circular dated 5th July, 2017 issued
by Government of India.
24.
As regards the issue dealing with the returnable date of the summons
is concerned, in view of the statement made by the learned counsel for the
respondent, we deem it appropriate to permit the petitioner to appear in
compliance with the summons dated 3rd November, 2025 before the
competent officer mentioned therein on 23rd March, 2026. The competent
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
officer shall thereafter deal with the issue in accordance with law.
25.
With above observations, we deem it appropriate to partly allow the
present writ petition to the extent of rescheduling the date, however, the
challenge to the circular fails and to that extent, the petition stands
dismissed.
26.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
NITIN WASUDEO SAMBRE
(JUDGE)
AJAY DIGPAUL
(JUDGE)
FEBRUARY 02, 2026
ab/sk
Signed By:ALKA
BOBAL
15:50:43
W.P.(C) 1426/2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review