Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
LAISHRAM
DHAKESHORI DEVI
2023.02.03 15:02:03
DHAKESHORI DEVI Date:
+05'30'
Item No. 41
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC(El.Pet.) No. 158 of 2022
Lourembam Rameshwor Meetei
…Applicant/s
Vs.
Md. Nasiruddin Khan & 4 ors.
…Respondent/s
B E F O R E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AHANTHEM BIMOL SINGH
02-02-2023
Heard Mr. N. Kumarjit, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. N. Zequeson, learned counsel appearing for the applicant and Mr.
HS Paonam, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. BR Sharma,
learned counsel appearing for the contesting respondent No.1. None
appeared for the other respondents.
[2]
The present application had been filed raising objection to
the filing of the written statement by the respondent No. 1 in the
connected El.Recr.Pet. No. 10 of 2022 and praying for rejecting the
said written statement. The main ground raised by the present applicant
is that the said written statement had been filed beyond the period of 90
days prescribed under Order VIII, Rule 1 of CPC, without seeking any
leave of this Court for condoning such delay or without giving any
explanation for the delay in filing the said written statement. According
to the learned senior counsel appearing for the applicant, the filing of
written statement beyond 90 days is not as a matter of right and unless
the respondent No. 1 in the said El.Recr.Petition filed an application
praying for condoning the delay in filing the said written statement by
explaining or by giving cogent reasons, the written statement filed by
MC(E.Pet.) No. 158 of 2022
Page 1
Item No. 41
respondent No. 1 is liable to be rejected. In this connection, learned
senior counsel had relied on the judgment rendered by the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of “Kailash – vrs.- Nanhku & ors.” reported in
(2005)4 SCC 480 wherein it has been held as under :
“42. Ordinarily, the time schedule prescribed by Order 8
Rule 1 has to be honoured. The defendant should be
vigilant. No sooner the writ of summons is served on him
he should take steps for drafting his defence and filing the
written statement on the appointed date of hearing without
waiting for the arrival of the date appointed in the
summons for his appearance in the court. The extension
of time sought for by the defendant from the court whether
within 30 days or 90 days, as the case may be, should not
be granted just as a matter of routine and merely for the
asking, more so, when the period of 90 days has expired.
The extension can be only by way of an exception and for
reasons assigned by the defendant and also recorded in
writing by the court to its satisfaction. It must be spelled
out that a departure from the time schedule prescribed by
Order 8 Rule 1 of the Code was being allowed to be made
because the circumstances were exceptional, occasioned
by reasons beyond the control of the defendant and such
extension was required in the interest of justice, and grave
injustice would be occasioned if the time was not
extended.”
“46. We sum up and briefly state our conclusions as
under:
“(i) The trial of an election petition commences from the
date of the receipt of the election petition by the court and
continues till the date of its decision. The filing of
pleadings is one stage in the trial of an election petition.
The power vesting in the High Court to adjourn the trial
from time to time (as far as practicable and without
sacrificing the expediency and interest of justice) includes
power to adjourn the hearing in an election petition,
affording opportunity to the defendant to file a written
statement. The availability of such power in the High Court
is spelled out by the provisions of the Representation of
the People Act, 1951 itself and rules made for purposes of
that Act and a resort to the provisions of CPC is not called
for.
“(ii) On the language of Section 87(1) of the Act, it is
clear that the applicability of the procedure provided for
the trial of suits to the trial of election petitions is not
MC(E.Pet.) No. 158 of 2022
Page 2
Item No. 41
attracted with all its rigidity and technicality. The rules of
procedure contained in CPC apply to the trial of election
petitions under the Act with flexibility and only as
guidelines.
“(iii) In case of conflict between the provisions of the
Representation of the People Act, 1951 and the rules
framed thereunder or the Rules framed by the High court
in exercise of the power conferred by Article 225 of the
Constitution on the one hand, and the rules of procedure
contained in CPC on the other hand, the former shall
prevail over the latter.
“(iv) The purpose of providing the time schedule for filing
the written statement under Order 8 Rule 1 CPC is to
expedite and not to scuttle the hearing. The provision spell
out a disability on the defendant. It does not impose an
embargo on the power of the court to extend the time.
Though the language of the proviso to Rule 1 Order 8
CPC is couched in negative form, it does not specify any
penal consequences flowing from the non-compliance.
The provision being in the domain of the procedural law, it
has to be held directory and not mandatory. The power of
the court to extend time for filing the written statement
beyond the time schedule provided by Order 8 Rule 1
CPC is not completely taken away.
“(v) Though Order 8 Rule 1 CPC is a part of procedural
law and hence directory, keeping in view the need for
expeditious trial of civil causes which persuaded
Parliament to enact the provision in its present form, it is
held that ordinarily the time schedule contained n the
provision is to be followed as a rule and departure
therefrom would be by way of exception. A prayer for
extension of time made by the defendant shall not be
granted just as a matter of routine and merely for the
asking, more so when the period of 90 days has expired.
Extension of time may be allowed by way of an exception,
for reasons to be assigned by the defendant and also be
placed on record in writing, howsoever briefly, by the court
on its being satisfied. Extension of time may be allowed if
it is needed to be given for circumstances which are
exceptional, occasioned by reasons beyond the control of
the defendant and grave injustice would be occasioned if
the time was not extended. Costs may be imposed and
affidavit or documents in support of the grounds pleaded
by the defendant for extension of time may be demanded,
depending on the facts and circumstances of a given
case.”
MC(E.Pet.) No. 158 of 2022
Page 3
Item No. 41
[3]
By relying on the aforesaid judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court, it has been submitted by the learned senior counsel that the
Hon’ble Apex Court has clearly held that a prayer seeking time beyond
90 days for filing written statement ought to be made in writing and that
the time schedule contained in the provision under order VIII, Rule 1 is
to be followed as a Rule and the departure therefrom will be by way of
exception. It has further been submitted that since, the respondent No.
1 did not file any application praying for condoning the delay in filing the
written statement and since the respondent No. 1 did not give any
explanation in the written statement filed by him about the delay in filing
the said written statement, the said written statement cannot be
accepted and it is liable to be rejected outright.
[4]
Mr. HS Paonam, learned senior counsel appearing for
respondent No. 1 submitted that in the judgment relied on by the
counsel for the applicant,
the Hon’ble Aplex Court had clearly
explained the object and purpose of Order VIII, Rule 1 of CPC to the
extent that the purpose of providing a time schedule for filing the written
statement under Order 8, Rule 1 of CPC is to expedite and not to
scuttle the hearing of the case and that the provisions spells out a
disability on the defendant and that it does not impose an embargo on
the power of the Court to extend the time. The learned counsel further
submitted that the respondent No. 1 had already filed his written
statement and the same is on record and that the respondent No. 1,
being the Election Petitioner, has no intention to delay hearing of the
MC(E.Pet.) No. 158 of 2022
Page 4
Item No. 41
Election Petition. The learned counsel further submitted that the
respondent No. 1 is willing and ready to pay cost for condoning the
delay in filing his written statement.
[5]
In the present case, the written statement of the
respondent No. 1 to the Election Recr. Petition No. 10 of 2022 had
already been filed and the same is found on record. As the respondent
No. 1 is the petitioner in the connected Election Pet. No. 8 of 2022, this
Court found considerable force in the submission made by Mr. HS
Paonam that the respondent No. 1/Election petitioner has no intention
to scuttle or delay the hearing of the connected Election Petitions. This
Court is also of the considered view that if the written statement of the
respondent No. 1 is rejected on the ground of delay in filing the same, a
great injustice will be caused to the respondent No. 1. In any case, this
Court can also granted time to respondent No. 1 to file a separate
application seeking leave of this Court to allow him to file the written
statement by explaining the reasons for the delay in filing the same,
however, if such recourse is taken, it will only cause further delay in the
trial of the connected election petitions.
[6]
In view of the facts and circumstances of the present case,
this Court is of the considered view that interest of justice will be served
if the respondent No. 1 is allowed to file his written statement subject to
the payment of cost of Rs. 10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand) to the
applicant through his counsel. It is made clear that the respondent No.
1 should pay the cost of Rs. 10,000/- (Rupees ten thousand) to the
MC(E.Pet.) No. 158 of 2022
Page 5
Item No. 41
applicant through his counsel within a period of 7(seven) days from
today.
[7]
With the aforesaid direction, the present application is
hereby disposed of.
JUDGE
Dhakeshori
MC(E.Pet.) No. 158 of 2022
Page 6
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review