Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 08
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
AB. No. 2 of 2022
Date of Decision: 24.02.2022
Shri Lodestar Tang
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & 2 Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. J. Shylla, Adv.
Mr. R. Gurung, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
1.
Matter is taken up via hybrid mode.
2.
Heard Mr. J. Shylla, learned counsel for the petitioner who has
submitted that the petitioner apprehending arrest in connection with Khliehriat
P.S Case No. 5(01)2022 u/s 302/34 IPC has approached this Court with an
application u/s 438 Cr.P.C, seeking grant of pre-arrest bail.
3.
According to Mr. Shylla, an FIR dated 14.01.2022 was lodged by one
Shri Md. Rafikul Ali, informing the Officer-In-Charge, Lad Rymbai Police
Outpost, East Jaintia Hills District that he is the owner of one bolero pickup
bearing registration No. AS-01-JC-3947 which was driven by his driver Shri
Bidya Dawa Dutta, had proceeded to Silchar, Assam from Guwahati on
11.01.2022 to transport some materials. He was supposed to return back on
13.01.2022. However, on 13.01.2022 the informant received a phone call
from the Lad Rymbai Police Outpost and was informed that a burnt body
suspected to be that of his driver was found from a place called Moowakhu
Dkhiah West, Khliehriat, East Jaintia Hills District. The injured was removed
to Khliehriat CHC for medical treatment, but he succumbed to his injuries that
evening itself. On 14.01.2022, the informant along with the relative of the
deceased went to Khliehriat, identified the body and has accordingly lodged
the FIR alleging that his driver was gruesomely murdered by some unknown
persons.
4.
Mr. Shylla has further submitted that the petitioner is a daily labourer
and throughout the month of January, 2022, he was busy in labour work,
constructing the house of Ribanker Tang at Mootyrshiah a village in West
Jaintia Hills District. However, the petitioner was surprised to learn that his
mother Smti. Meris Tang had received a call from some police personnel
directing her to come to Lad Rymbai Police Outpost, and on 02.02.2022 on
reaching the police outpost his family members were informed by the police
that the petitioner must surrender before the police in connection with the said
Khliehriat P.S Case No. 05(01)2022. Apprehending arrest, the petitioner has
approached the Sessions Court at Khliehriat on 07.02.2022 with an
application for anticipatory bail which was rejected, hence this application.
5.
Mr. Shylla has reiterated that the petitioner is innocent and is not at all
involved with the said Khliehriat P.S case and being a daily labourer, he was
not even in East Jaintia Hills District at the time of the alleged occurrence.
Being a permanent resident of Mootyrshiah village, if granted pre-arrest bail,
he is prepared to abide by any conditions that this Court may impose.
6.
Per contra, Mr. R. Gurung, learned GA has submitted that this Court
vide order dated 18.02.2022, had called for the case diary of Khliehriat P.S
Case No. 05(01)2022 and has also granted interim bail to the petitioner herein.
The case diary is now duly produced before this Court and the contents therein
may be allowed to be relied on by the prosecution at the hearing.
7.
Mr. Gurung has again submitted that from the materials on record, what
could be seen is that the deceased driver of the said bolero pick-up while
returning from Silchar on the night of 12.01.2022 and on reaching a certain
place near a petrol pump to take rest, suddenly about 4(four) unknown persons
knocked at the glass door of the driver’s side of the vehicle and forcibly
opened the door and abducted the occupants by taking control of the vehicle
and on reaching a certain spot in the jungle, off the highway, the deceased
driver and another person who was in the vehicle with him were immobilized
with their hands tied behind their backs. The abductors then demanded money
from them and one of the abductees managed to escape while the deceased
driver was brutally assaulted with knives and was also dosed with an
inflammable material, probably kerosene and was set on fire. He was then left
on the spot while the assailants/abductors fled from the scene. In the morning
hours of 13.01.2022, some persons found an unknown male who has received
several burnt injuries on his body lying outside one shop located at Moowakhu
Dkhiah village and on being informed, the police came and remove the person
to CHC Khliehriat for medical treatment. This person turns out to be the said
deceased driver of the informant.
8.
Mr. Gurung has again further submitted that the Investigating Agency
after thorough investigation, has apprehended some persons suspected to be
involved in the said incident and on information gathered, there is a strong
suspicion that the petitioner herein is one of the main perpetrators of the crime.
Therefore, considering the nature and gravity of the crime and the implicit
involvement of the petitioner, pre-arrest may not be granted as he is very much
required for custodial questioning. This petition therefore is devoid of merit
and the same may be dismissed.
9.
In reply, Mr. Shylla has reiterated that the name of the petitioner was
never mentioned in the FIR and at the time of the alleged incident he could
not have been present at the place of occurrence since he was in another
district. On the allegation that the name of the petitioner being involved in the
said incident surfaced during questioning of one of the accused arrested in
connection with this case, the provision of section 25 of the Evidence Act was
cited to show that confession made to a police officer cannot be proved against
a person accused of any offence. The case of Monu v. State of Haryana:
CRM-M-14613-2020(O&M) was referred to by Mr. Shylla to submit that in
a case similar to the case of the petitioner herein, the Hon’ble Punjab and
Haryana High Court vide order dated 10.06.2020, in the said case at paragraph
8 has held that the petitioner therein was not named in the FIR and the
disclosure statement made by the co-accused after one year of the alleged
offence may not be admissible in evidence against the petitioner and
accordingly anticipatory bail was granted to the petitioner therein.
10.
Another case referred to by Mr. Shylla, is the case of Prabhakar Tewari
v. State of UP and Anr: (2020)11 SCC 648, paragraphs 5 & 7 in which the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as follows: “5. We have considered the respective submissions. The facts
highlighted by the appellant are that the case involves offence under
Section 302 read with Sections 120-B/34, 147, 148 and 149 of the Penal
Code, 1860. The accused has several criminal cases pending against
him and has been named in the statement forming the basis of the FIR
on the date of occurrence itself. Two individuals, Rahul Tiwari and
Narendra Dev Upadhyay, whose statements have been recorded under
Section 161 of the 1973 Code also refer to involvement of the accused
Vikram Singh.
7. On considering the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties,
having regard to the circumstances of this case, in our opinion, there
has been no wrong or improper exercise of discretion on the part of the
High Court in granting bail to the accused. The factors outlined in
Mahipal for testing the legality of an order granting bail are absent in
the order impugned. The materials available do not justify arriving at
the conclusion that the order impugned suffers from non-application of
mind or the reason for granting bail is not borne out from a prima facie
view of the evidence on record. The offence alleged no doubt is grave
and serious and there are several criminal cases pending against the
accused. These factors by themselves cannot be the basis for refusal of
prayer for bail. The High Court has exercised its discretion in granting
bail to the accused Vikram Singh upon considering relevant materials.
No ex facie error in the order has been shown by the appellant which
would establish exercise of such discretion to be improper. We
accordingly sustain the order of the High Court granting bail. This
appeal is dismissed.”
11.
On consideration of the submissions made, this Court is mindful of the
fact that refusal or grant of bail is primarily subject to the discretionary powers
of the court, albeit by adhering to well established principles and guidelines
propounded in bail jurisprudence. The basic factor to be considered by the
courts while considering an application for grant of bail is the particular facts
and circumstances of the case which cannot be ignored while exercising such
discretionary powers.
12.
It is well settled that while considering a bail application, the nature and
gravity of the offence has to be considered, the antecedent of the applicant as
well as the fact that he or she may abscond or tamper with evidence cannot be
taken lightly under the circumstances.
13.
In the case of Monu (supra), the Court has taken into account that the
disclosure statement made by the co-accused was done only after a year of the
alleged offence. In this particular case the disclosures statement of the coaccused was done almost immediately.
14.
In the case of Prabhakar Tewari (supra), what could be understood is
that bail was granted by the Hon’ble High Court to the accused primarily on
the ground that the statement of an independent witness as regard his
complicity in the crime was recorded after 50(fifty) days from the date of
occurrence of the incident and such, statement was found unreliable and also
on the fact that the accused therein was in custody for a number of months.
Again, distinguishable from the facts of the case in hand, the petitioner was
pointedly named as one of the main perpetrators of the crime by another coperpetrator and as such, there can be no doubt that prima facie the involvement
of the petitioner cannot be ruled out, though subject to evidence at the trial
stage to prove or dis-prove the same.
15.
Be that as it may, since the matter is under investigation, this Court
deems it proper to allow the Investigating Officer to complete the
investigation even if it involves custodial questioning of the petitioner.
16.
In the light of the above observations, the petition is found to be devoid
of merit and the same is hereby dismissed.
17.
Registry is directed to send back the case diary.
18.
Petition disposed of. No cost.
19.
The interim bail granted is hereby vacated.
Judge
Meghalaya
24.02.2022
“N.Swer, Stenographer”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review