The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. 5.2022 and the same is stated at para 3 at page no.5 of the misc application. However, at page No.8 of the misc application while calculating the number of days delay, the date of applying certified copy was mistakenly mentioned as 25.4.2022 instead of 5.5.2022. Subsequently the number of days delay to be condoned was mentioned in the misc application because of the typographical mistake as 195 days instead of the correct number 205 days. The same is due to the oversight and inadvertently written and it doesn’t have much difference to the prayer for condonation. [11] Mr. M. Rarry, learned counsel for the respondents submits that the applicants have not been able to disclose the sufficient reasons for not filing the second appeal within the stipulated time. Even though the application for condonation of delay has to be dealt with sympathetic approach from the court, the applicants have to show their bonafide behaviour for failure to act promptly. Learned counsel mentions three essential conditions for condonation of delay, ie, (i) negligence on part of the applicant, (ii) inaction, and (iii) lack of bonafide. It is submitted that in the present case, the applicants are negligent in not preferring the second appeal with promptness and have been in dormant through out and any instance of bonafide on their part has not been disclosed in the application. It is pointed out a miscella…
21. 08.2023 sworn by their earlier counsel for the delay on his part in the rejoinder affidavit. It is clarified that due to oversight, the number of delay is wrongly mentioned as 195 days in place of 205 days and this ought not to affect in consideration for condonation. [15] Mr. H. Prabirkumar, learned counsel for the applicants refers the following case laws: (i) N. Balakrishnan v. M. Krishnamurthy: (1998) 7 the court and there is no presumption of deliberateness. The primary function of the court is to adjudicate the dispute between parties to advance substantive justice. Delay should not be used to transform a bad cause into a good cause. MC(RSA) NO. 4 OF 2023: L. ANILKUMAR & ORS. V. K. JAYANTA (ii) Ram Nath Sao v. Gobardhan Sao: (2002) 3 SCC 195- The expression ‘sufficient cause’ should receive a liberal construction so as to advance substantial justice, when no negligence or want of bonafide or inaction is imputable. (iii) Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. Subrata Borah Chowlek: (2010) 14 SCC 419- Liberal approach has to be adopted when no negligence can be imputed. While considering the application for condonation of delay, the courts have to strike a balance between resultant effect of the order upon the parties either way. (iv) Raheem Shah v. Govind Singh: MANU/SC/0829/2023: 2023 INSC 651- When there was a delay of only 52 days in filing the appeal and furthermore when the p…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
NON-REPORTABLE
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
MC (RSA) No.4 of 2023 with
MC (RSA) No.19 of 2023 with
MC (RSA) No.20 of 2023
1.
Lisham Anilkumar Singh, aged about
59 years, s/o (L) L.Kullachandra Singh, R/O
Wangkhei Thambalkhong, Lisham Leirak,
PO & PS Porompat, Imphal East District,
Manipur.
2.
Lisham (O) Shanti Devi, aged about 48
Years, w/o L.Binoy Singh, R/O
Wangkhei Thambalkhong, Lisham Leirak,
PO & PS Porompat, Imphal East District,
Manipur.
3.
Lisham Subhashini Devi, about 54 years,
d/o (L) L.Kullachandra Singh, R/O
Wangkhei Thambalkhong, Lisham Leirak,
PO & PS Porompat, Imphal East District,
Manipur.
4.
Lisham Lalit Singh, aged about 71 years,
s/o (L) L.Angou Singh, R/O
Wangkhei Thambalkhong, Lisham Leirak,
PO & PS Porompat, Imphal East District,
Manipur.
… Applicants
-VersusKangjam Jayanta Singh, aged about
49 years, s/o (L) K.Joykumar Singh,
R/O Wangkhei Thambalkhong,
Lisha Leirak, PO & PS Porompat,
Imphal East District, Manipur.
MC(RSA) NO. 4 OF 2023: L. ANILKUMAR & ORS. V. K. JAYANTA
… Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A.GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the applicants
::
Mr.Haobam Prabir Kumar, Advocate
For the respondent ::
Mr.M.Rarry, Advocate
Date of hearing
::
14.5.2024
Date of order
::
02.09.2024
O R D E R (CAV)
MC (RSA) No.4 of 2023
[1]
By the instant application, the applicants are praying for
condonation of 195 days (actually, 205 days) delay in filing the
accompanying Regular Second Appeal (RSA for short).
[2]
Heard Mr. H. Pabirkumar, learned counsel for the
applicants and Mr. M. Rarry, learned counsel for the respondent.
[3]
Brief facts leading to filing the application for
condonation is as follows:
[4]
The Regular Second Appeal (RSA for short) has been
filed by the present applicants before this Court for quashing/setting
aside the impugned judgment and decree dated 21.04.2022, of the
Court of District Judge, Imphal East passed in Regular Appeal No.11
of 2020.
[5]
It is stated that there has been a delay of 195 days in
preferring the RSA and the present application is being filed
explaining the delay. That the learned District Judge, Imphal East
Manipur heard the RFS No.11 of 2020 without hearing the counsel for
the applicants and reserved for judgment on 18.04.2022. On
21.04.2022 the learned District Judge, Imphal East, Manipur passed
order in the RFA No.11 of 2020 without giving any information to the
counsel for the applicants. Only on 25.4.2022 the applicants came to
know about the existence of the order dated 21.04.2022 and the
MC(RSA) NO. 4 OF 2023: L. ANILKUMAR & ORS. V. K. JAYANTA
applicants applied for certified copy of the order in RFA No.11 of 2020
on 5.5.2022. Certified copy of the judgment and order dated
21.04.2022 was obtained on 7.5.2022.
[6]
Further, it is stated that the earlier counsel for the
applicants, being one of the contesting candidates in the All Manipur
Bar Association election held on 28.5.2022, could not appear before
the Court and Ms. Nongthombam Elizabeth, Panel Lawyer, was
appointed as Legal Aid Counsel on request of the applicants to the
High Court Legal Services Committee. Thereafter, on withdrawal of
the case from the High Court Legal Services Committee, the
applicants again approached their earlier counsel for doing the
needful. Due to inability on the part of the earlier counsel, case
record/file was taken out from his custody and the applicants being
not able to find an Advocate of their choice, there was further delay.
[7]
In the second week of January, 2023, Mr. Sapam
Biswajit Meitei, Advocate was engaged and preferred the RSA on
13.02.2023.
[8]
It is prayed that if the delay is not condoned irreparable
loss and legal injury will be caused to the applicants/appellants.
[9]
In the written objection to the present application for
condonation, it is stated that the applicants have not furnished a copy
of the unnumbered RSA said to be filed along with the condonation
application and as such, the applicants cannot now be permitted to
serve a copy of the RSA after the preliminary objection as it would
amount to taking away a valuable right which has risen in favour of
the respondent and also for the reason that the respondent has
already disclosed the defense to the application based only upon the
allegations and averments made by the applicants in the condonation
application.
[10]
On rejoinder to the objection, it is stated that the
applicants applied for certified copy of the RFA No.11 of 2020 on
MC(RSA) NO. 4 OF 2023: L. ANILKUMAR & ORS. V. K. JAYANTA
5.5.2022 and the same is stated at para 3 at page no.5 of the misc
application. However, at page No.8 of the misc application while
calculating the number of days delay, the date of applying certified
copy was mistakenly mentioned as 25.4.2022 instead of 5.5.2022.
Subsequently the number of days delay to be condoned was
mentioned in the misc application because of the typographical
mistake as 195 days instead of the correct number 205 days. The
same is due to the oversight and inadvertently written and it doesn’t
have much difference to the prayer for condonation.
[11]
Mr. M. Rarry, learned counsel for the respondents
submits that the applicants have not been able to disclose the
sufficient reasons for not filing the second appeal within the stipulated
time. Even though the application for condonation of delay has to be
dealt with sympathetic approach from the court, the applicants have
to show their bonafide behaviour for failure to act promptly. Learned
counsel mentions three essential conditions for condonation of delay,
ie, (i) negligence on part of the applicant, (ii) inaction, and (iii) lack
of bonafide. It is submitted that in the present case, the applicants
are negligent in not preferring the second appeal with promptness
and have been in dormant through out and any instance of bonafide
on their part has not been disclosed in the application. It is pointed
out a miscellaneous appeal against the order of the executing court
was filed within 4/5 days by the same advocate who could not file the
appeal for 205 days. Hence, the plea of the applicants that their
earlier counsel could not file the appeal within time as he was busy in
the election of bar association, is not bonafide and is an after-thought
to attract sympathy from this court. In the whole application, there is
nothing substantive except for blaming appellate court and the
previous counsel.
[12]
Mr. M. Rarry, learned counsel for the respondent refers
to the following decisions in support of his submissions.
MC(RSA) NO. 4 OF 2023: L. ANILKUMAR & ORS. V. K. JAYANTA
(i)
Esha Bhattacharjee v. Managing Committee of
Raghunathpur Nafar Academy: (2013) 12 SCC 649Delay was not condoned due to conspicuous absence of
necessary facts.
(ii)
Shri Gainaichung Malangmei v. State of Manipur:
Order dated 04.04.2022 in MC(WA) No. 70 of 2022 of
Manipur High Court- Change of counsel to change stand
and lack of education are not grounds to condone gross delay
of 893 days.
(iii) G.
Ramegowda
v.
Special
Land
Officer,
Bangalore: (1988) 2 SCC 142 - In case of gross
negligence on the part of the party and counsel, time barred
appeal should not be entertained.
(iv) Union of India v. N. Murugesan: (2022) 2 SCC 25The conduct of the part is the most important while
considering the application for condonation of delay.
[13]
Mr. M. Rarry, learned counsel for the respondent
reiterates that the applicants have failed to show bonafide and any
sufficient cause for not enabling the prefer the appeal within
stipulated time except for blaming previous counsel and prays that
the application for condonation of delay be rejected with heavy cost.
[14]
Per contra, Mr. H. Prabirkumar, learned counsel for the
applicants/appellants submits that the accompanying appeal could
not be filed within the stipulated time due to the cogent reasons
explained in the application for condonation of delay. The delay of
205 days in preferring the second has been caused to the same
reasons as explained in the application. It is stated that the first
appeal was heard in absence of the counsel for the applicants and
they came to know about the impugned order dated 21.04.2022 in
RFA No. 11 of 2020 only on 25.04.2022 and obtained certified copy
on 07.05.2022. As Mr. N. Angouthoiba Meitei, the counsel for the
MC(RSA) NO. 4 OF 2023: L. ANILKUMAR & ORS. V. K. JAYANTA
applicants before the trial court as well as first appellate court,
advised them to approach High Court Legal Services Committee for
filing appeal as they were unable to pay litigation fees. Vide
Notification dated 21.05.2022, High Court Legal Services Committee
appointed Smt. N. Elizabeth, Panel Lawyer as legal aid counsel for the
applicants for filing the second appeal. Since the appeal was not filed
in time, vide letter dated 13.10.2022 of the Secretary, High Court
Legal Services Committee, the applicants were informed about the
withdrawal of the legal aid given to them on their request to engage
a private counsel. The applicants again approached Mr. Angouthoiba
who took some time in preparing appeal, but returned the file as he
was busy in contesting bar election. Thereafter, the present counsel
was engaged in the second week of January, 2023 and the second
appeal along with the application for condonation of delay was
promptly filed on 13.02.2023. Learned counsel submits that in the
process, a total of 205 days of delay has been caused which is nondeliberate, non-intentional and due to the reasons explained in the
application. The applicants have also filed an affidavit dated
21.08.2023 sworn by their earlier counsel for the delay on his part in
the rejoinder affidavit. It is clarified that due to oversight, the number
of delay is wrongly mentioned as 195 days in place of 205 days and
this ought not to affect in consideration for condonation.
[15]
Mr. H. Prabirkumar, learned counsel for the applicants
refers the following case laws:
(i)
N. Balakrishnan v. M. Krishnamurthy: (1998) 7
SCC 123 – Condonation of delay is a matter of discretion of
the court and there is no presumption of deliberateness. The
primary function of the court is to adjudicate the dispute
between parties to advance substantive justice. Delay should
not be used to transform a bad cause into a good cause.
MC(RSA) NO. 4 OF 2023: L. ANILKUMAR & ORS. V. K. JAYANTA
(ii)
Ram Nath Sao v. Gobardhan Sao: (2002) 3 SCC
195- The expression ‘sufficient cause’ should receive a liberal
construction so as to advance substantial justice, when no
negligence or want of bonafide or inaction is imputable.
(iii) Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. Subrata Borah
Chowlek: (2010) 14 SCC 419- Liberal approach has to be
adopted when no negligence can be imputed. While
considering the application for condonation of delay, the
courts have to strike a balance between resultant effect of
the order upon the parties either way.
(iv) Raheem
Shah
v.
Govind
Singh:
MANU/SC/0829/2023: 2023 INSC 651- When there
was a delay of only 52 days in filing the appeal and
furthermore when the parties were litigating with respect to
the right over immovable properties, the substantial rights
were to be decided between the parties. The delay could be
condoned and the appeal could have been decided on merits.
Refusing to condone the delay can result in a meritorious
matter being thrown out at the very threshold and cause of
justice being defeated.
(v)
Shalini v. Kurushetra University: (2002) 2 SCC
(vi) LP Shahi College v. Seema Mishra: (2016) 9 SCC
(vii) Rafiq v. Minshlal: AIR 1981 SC 1400
Litigants should not be made to suffer for their no fault
or fault of their counsel.
[15]
Mr. H. Prabirkumar, learned counsel for the applicants
sums up that the cogent reasons for not enabling to prefer the second
appeal have already been explained in the application. It is pointed
out that apart for the earlier conducting counsel, the legal aid counsel
MC(RSA) NO. 4 OF 2023: L. ANILKUMAR & ORS. V. K. JAYANTA
has also taken almost 5 months in preparation of the appeal and the
same was never filed. In the circumstances, the present counsel
prepared and filed the appeal and applications. It is prayed that the
delay of 205 days in filing the accompanying appeal be condoned and
the second appeal be heard on merit to do substantive justice.
[16]
Mr. M. Rarry, learned counsel for the respondent has
pointed out the decisions cited by learned counsel for the applicants
are not applicable in the facts of the present case, as they were
negligent and put blame on the previous counsel. It is prayed that
the application for condonation of delay be dismissed.
[17]
This Court has perused the materials on record, the
submissions made at bar and decisions referred to by the parties.
[18]
It is an admitted fact that there is a delay of 205 days
in preferring the second appeal. The reasons cited by the applicants/
appellants are – (i) They first approached the High Court Legal
Services Committee for legal aid and the same was granted vide
Notification dated 21.05.2022 and when the legal aid counsel could
not file the appeal, the legal aid was withdrawn on 13.10.2022
thereby adding another 5 months in the delay; (ii) The applicants
again approached their earlier counsel who also took some time and
returned the file as he was busy in contesting election of the bar
association; and (iii) The applicants engaged the present counsel in
the second week of January, 2023 and finally appeal along with the
application for condonation of delay was filed on 13.02.2023. In the
process, a delay of 205 days has been caused.
[19]
It is the specific case of the respondent that the
applicants are in gross negligent for pursing the case. On one hand,
the same earlier counsel filed misc. appeal against the order of
executing court within 4/5 days while he could not file appeal with
that speed. It is pointed out that the inability of the earlier counsel to
prepare and file appeal due to bar election cannot be sustained.
MC(RSA) NO. 4 OF 2023: L. ANILKUMAR & ORS. V. K. JAYANTA
[20]
From the record, it is seen that after getting the certified
copy of the impugned judgment on 07.05.2022, the applicants
approached for legal aid and a legal aid counsel was appointed on
21.05.2022 and after withdrawal of the legal aid on 13.10.2022, the
earlier counsel took some more time and later on returned the file.
These facts have been mentioned in the affidavit filed by the earlier
counsel. The respondent has not disputed the veracity of the affidavit.
[21]
Admittedly, in the present case, the parties are litigating
over immovable property. Even though the applicants have not been
able to disclose the day-to-day delay, however they are able to show
the circumstances under which the delay has been caused. It may be
important to keep in mind that it is duty and obligation of the courts
to decide the dispute on merit, unless the delay is so gross and
without any plausible explanation. In the case in hand, the applicants
have explained the circumstances for the delay and the respondent
will not suffer irreparable loss, if the delay is condoned and the appeal
is decided on merit.
[22]
Taking view of all the circumstances and in the interest
of justice, the delay of 205 days in filing the accompanying second
appeal is condoned subject to the payment of Rs.5000/- as cost to
the respondent. Registry is directed to number the second appeal if
the same is in order and list the same in due course on submission of
proof of payment of cost to the respondent. The application is
disposed of in terms of the above directions.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Priyojit
MC(RSA) NO. 4 OF 2023: L. ANILKUMAR & ORS. V. K. JAYANTA
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review