Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 03
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
BA. No. 55 of 2023
Smti. Lily Sitlhou
Date of Decision: 16.11.2023
State of Meghalaya & Anr.
Vs.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Ms. K. Chisa, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. J. Thabah, GA.
Mr. R. Gurung, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
This is an application under Section 439 Cr.P.C for grant of
bail in favour of Miss Neimercy Singsit, who was arrested on 04.05.2023
in connection with Nongpoh P.S. Case No. 51 (05) 2023 under Section
21(b)/29 NDPS Act.
2.
The FIR was lodged before the Officer-in-Charge, Nongpoh
Police Station on 03.05.2023. The informant is the I/C Byrnihat Police
Outpost, Ri-Bhoi District. From the body of the FIR, what could be seen
is that the informant has stated that on 02.05.2023, on receipt of
telephonic information regarding a person named Shri. Promod Chettri
who is travelling from Guwahati to Shillong and who is suspected to be
carrying some drugs consignment on the vehicle approaching the road
opposite Byrnihat Police Outpost, it was accordingly stopped for checking
after all formalities as required under the NDPS Act, was complied with.
It is further stated that 4(four) soap boxes containing substances suspected
to be heroin were seized from the said vehicle, and on being tested, the
same was confirmed to be heroin. Accordingly, the driver of the vehicle
Shri. Promod Chettri was arrested and Nongpoh P.S. Case No. 51 (05)
2023 under Section 21(b)/29 NDPS Act was registered.
3.
In course of interrogation of the arrested accused person, it was
revealed by him that the said contraband substances were handed over to
him by Miss Neimercy Singsit, who is staying somewhere near the
Airport at Guwahati. Accordingly, on the basis of such information, Miss
Neimercy Singsit was arrested in connection with the case.
4.
In due course, after completion of investigation, the
Investigating Officer had filed the charge sheet and had observed that the
accused persons, Shri Promod Chettri and Miss Neimercy Singsit have
admitted to be involved in the crime and accordingly, the Investigating
Officer has further observed that a prima facie case under Section 21(b) of
the NDPS Act is found well established against the accused person Shri.
Promod Chettri and a case under Section 29 of the NDPS Act is found
well established against the accused person Miss Neimercy Singsit and
they are sent before the competent court to stand trial.
5.
Ms. K. Chisa, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that the petitioner has now approach this Court with a prayer for grant of
bail on behalf of the accused person Miss Neimercy Singsit. She also
submits that there is no evidence against this accused person, inasmuch as,
the alleged drugs were not seized from her possession and she was also
not present in the vehicle at the time of the said seizure not being
conscious or even constructive possession of the alleged contraband
drugs. The accused person Miss Neimercy Singsit could not have been
remanded to custody on the allegation that she was arrested only on the
basis of the statement made by the co-accused Shri Promod Chettri,
further submits the learned counsel. It is also submitted that this ought to
be the basis for the arrested or eventually conviction of the accused person
in question since the confession or accusation by the co-accused cannot
implicate the accused person herein.
6.
Another limb of argument urged by the learned counsel is that
the accused is a young girl of about 20 years or so and she is already in
custody for more than 6(six) months. Therefore, having no criminal
antecedents, she may be allowed to be enlarged on bail with any
conditions that this Court may deem fit to impose, to which she will abide
by.
7.
The fact that the alleged seized contraband is of an
intermediate quantity as per the provision of Section 21 of the NDPS Act,
therefore, the rigors of Section 37 of the said Act is not applicable and as
such, this Court may be pleased to allow the prayer of the petitioner for
grant of bail. The learned counsel has also refuted the allegations made by
the prosecution that the complicity of the accused in the case is mostly
based on the seizure of the mobile phone, wherein the call details report
(CDR) would show the many conversations made between the accused
herein and the co-accused Shri. Promod Chettri. However, while filing the
charge sheet before the court, copy of which has been given to the accused
person at para 20, wherein the list of enclosures has been detailed which
ranges from serial No. (a) to (s), nothing is indicated therein about the
CDR details.
8.
Mr. J. Thabah, learned GA appearing on behalf of the State
respondent has submitted that the involvement of the accused Miss
Neimercy Singsit is well established and the fact that the seized
contraband drugs were supplied by her to the co-accused person Shri.
Promod Chettri could not be refuted since evidence of the transaction has
been found from the CDR showing all the conversations between the
accused and the co-accused. In view of this fact, it is submitted that the
petitioner has not been able to make out a case for grant of bail and the
same is liable to be rejected.
9.
This Court having heard the learned counsel for the parties and
on the basis of the materials on record including the case diary which was
produced before this Court, the fact that the accused Miss Neimercy
Singsit was arrested on her alleged involvement in a case of drug
trafficking has been detailed in the charge sheet and other documents
which are contained in the case diary. Though, it is an admitted fact that
the said contraband drugs were not seized from the possession of the
accused person, her involvement in the case can only be established
during trial when evidence is being led in this regard. From the evidence
of three witnesses, copy of whose deposition has been produced before
this Court, nothing has come out to directly link the accused person with
the alleged offence, though, all the witnesses have yet to depose before the
court which may eventually lead to either conviction or acquittal of the
accused person in question.
10.
This Court taking into consideration these aspects of the
matter, that is, the fact that the accused person was not arrested while in
possession of the said contraband drugs and also that she has no previous
record as far as her involvement in criminal cases including drug related
cases are concerned, and since the quantity seized is of an intermediate
quantity, the rigors of Section 37 of the NDPS Act not being applicable
and finally, since the charge sheet has already been filed and the case is
taken up for trial before the competent court, at this point of time, it will
not be relevant to further detain the accused person in custody.
11.
In the case of Rakesh Singh v. State of West Bengal reported
in 2021 SCC OnLine Cal 3994, the Hon’ble Calcutta High Court while
dealing with a bail application under the NDPS Act involving offences
under Section 21(b)/29 of the said Act, under the facts and circumstances
of the case, has allowed the accused person to be enlarged on bail. It
would be relevant to refer to paras 5 and 6 of the said order which reads as
follows:
“5. Certain things are clear. Firstly, there
was no recovery of contraband items from the
physical possession of the petitioner. Nothing
was recovered from the person of the petitioner
or any place over which the petitioner had
exclusive control. We are conscious that mere
non-recovery of contraband from a person’s
possession may not per se dilute the rigours of
Section 37 of the NDPS Act.
6.
However, even assuming that the
petitioner had dominion or control over the
contraband in question, admittedly intermediate
quantity (76 gms) of cocaine was seized. It was
urged on behalf of the State that the statements
of witnesses would indicate that the petitioner
was a regular purchaser of contraband items.
However, the fact remains that in the present
case only 76 gms of cocaine is involved. As
observed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case
of Sami Ullaha (Supra), where intermediate
quantity of narcotics is involved, it may not be
justified to apply the rigours of the provisions of
Section 37 of the NDPS Act relating to grant of
bail.”
12.
The case of Anjali v. State (GNCT Delhi) reported in 2023
SCC OnLine Del 6122 is also relevant for reference, wherein at paras 7
and 9 of the same, the Hon’ble Delhi High Court has observed as follows:
“7. In Rehmatullah @ Arman v. State of
Delhi, Bail Application No. 2866/2022 decided
on 24.11.2022, it was observed as under:Taking into account the factum that the
allegations against the petitioner relate to the
alleged recovery of an intermediate quantity of
Ganja, to which the parameters of Section 37
of the NDPS Act, 1985 are not applicable and
there being no previous adverse antecedents
against the applicant, the applicant is allowed
to be released on bail…
9.
In Gajender Bahadur v. The State Govt of
NCT of Delhi, Bail Application No. 3655/2022
decided on 31.01.2023, it was observed as
under:6.
These are issues which can only be
adjudicated after evidence. For the time
being, the quantity alleged to be
recovered from the applicant is at best
1170 grams of Ganja which is an
intermediate quantity. The applicant has
been in custody since 09.10.2020,
charge-sheet already has been filed and
no custodial interrogation of the
applicant is required. As regards the
other two cases against the applicant
under the NDPS Act are concerned, the
applicant has already been granted bail
by the competent Courts of jurisdiction.
The trial is not likely to conclude in near
future and the continued incarceration
of the applicant will not serve any
purpose.
7.
For the aforesaid reasons, the
applicant is directed to be released on
bail in FIR No. 473/2020 dated
07.10.2020, under Section 20 of the
NDPS Act, registered at Police StationShastri Park…
13.
In view of the observations made hereinabove, this Court is
inclined to allow this petition and to direct release of the accused person
Miss Neimercy Singsit on bail on the following conditions that:
i)
She shall not abscond or tamper with the evidence and
witnesses;
ii)
She shall not leave the jurisdiction of India without prior
permission of the court;
iii)
She shall appear before the court concerned as and when
required;
iv)
She shall bind herself on a personal bond of ₹ 50,000/(Rupees fifty thousand) only with one surety of like
amount to the satisfaction of the Trial Court.
14.
Bail Application is accordingly disposed of. No costs.
15.
Let the case diary be returned to the prosecution.
Judge
Meghalaya
16.11.2023
“D. Nary, PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review