Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:863
Serial No. 01
Supplementary 1
List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
BA. No. 49 of 2024
Date of Decision: 19.09.2024
Smti. Lily Mawii,
Niece of Shri. Khailien
Haokip
Aged about 42 years
R/o Madanrting,
Lumjingsuk Block – A,
Shillong, East Khasi Hills
District, Meghalaya-793021
:::::
Petitioner
:::::
Respondents
-Vs1.
State of Meghalaya
Represented by Ministry of
Home Government of
Meghalaya, Shillong.
2.
Superintendent of Police
East Jaintia Hills,
Meghalaya.
3.
Officer-In-Charge,
Khliehriat Police Station,
East Jaintia Hills,
Meghalaya.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Mr. R. Sharon, Adv.
2024:MLHC:863
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. K. Khan, PP. with
Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl. PP.
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Heard Mr. R. Sharon, learned counsel for the petitioner, who
has submitted that on the basis of an FIR dated 16.07.2023 lodged by
Shri, B. Bhattacharjee, MPS, Deputy Superintendent of Police (Crime),
East Jaintia Hills District, wherein the Officer-in-Charge, Khliehriat
Police Station, East Jaintia Hills District was informed of the
apprehension of two ladies who were travelling in a Tata Sumo Tourist
Vehicle No. MZ 04 A 2996, while proceeding from Silchar towards
Khliehriat, the said vehicle being intercepted at Nongsning Petrol Pump,
East Jaintia Hills District, since the occupants of the vehicle were
suspected to be carrying illegal contraband on search being made, illegal
contraband, weighing about 91.81 grams and 105.54 grams, positively
tested to be heroin was recovered from the person of two of the said
occupants of the said vehicle.
2024:MLHC:863
2.
Accordingly, the FIR was registered as Khliehriat P.S Case
No. 53(07) 23 u/s 21(b)/27/29 NDPS Act and investigation was launched.
In course of investigation, the Investigating Officer (I/O) had arrested the
two ladies present in the said Tata Sumo and on the basis of their
information, three more persons were arrested, including the uncle of the
petitioner Shri. Khailien Haokip, who was arrested on 03.08.2023 from
his rented house at Umpling, Shillong.
3.
According to the learned counsel, no case can be made out
against the accused Uncle of the petitioner since he was not apprehended
at the place of occurrence, therefore, no seizure of any alleged contraband
substance was made from his person. The statement of the accused person
in question either under Section 161 or 164 Cr.P.C. or even under Section
67 of the NDPS Act, have also not been recorded. In fact, his name
figured only in the list of the accused persons against whom the I/O has
concluded that prima facie, a well-established case under Section
21(b)/29 NDPS Act is found established, in the absence of any concrete
evidence against him.
4.
The I/O on completion of his investigation, has filed the
charge sheet, finding that prima facie, a well-established case has been
2024:MLHC:863
made out against the five accused persons named therein, and they are
directed to face trial for the offence under Section 21(b)/29 of the NDPS
Act, 1985. The stage of the case at present is that two witnesses have
been examined as prosecution witnesses. Even from the evidence of the
said two witnesses, the involvement of the accused Uncle of the petitioner
has not been mentioned, submits the learned counsel.
5.
It is also the submission of the learned counsel that no case is
made out against the accused person in question, except for the fact that
his wife is well known to the accused Lhing Hoakip since they are from
the same village and they used to communicate very often, especially in
view of the prevailing situation in the State of Manipur.
6.
The learned counsel has made an impassionate plea on behalf
of the accused person in question to say that he has four minor children
who are left without shelter as their house was destroyed by thunderstorm
and incessant rainfall and as such, if allowed to go on bail, he will comply
with any conditions as deemed fit to be imposed by this Court.
7.
Mr. K. Khan, learned P.P appearing on behalf of the State
respondents has submitted that on perusal of the case dairy (C.D), copy of
which is produced before this Court, what can be seen is that the
2024:MLHC:863
complicity of the accused Uncle of the petitioner is proved, inasmuch as,
from the statement of the co-accused, what has emerged is that the
accused Uncle of the petitioner along with his wife have been named as
the main financial supplier to facilitate the supply of the said contraband.
8.
This Court on going through the materials on record, that is,
the application in hand as well as the C.D, and on consideration of the
submission of the learned counsels on both sides, is to come to a finding
as to whether a case has been made out for grant of bail to the accused
Uncle of the petitioner.
9.
Since the charge sheet has been filed, charges were also
framed and the case is at the stage of recording of evidence of the
prosecution’s witnesses, therefore, it can be said that no further
investigation is required. On merits, the learned counsel for the petitioner
has contended that the accused Uncle of the petitioner has been
unnecessarily implicated in the case only for the reason that he and his
wife are acquaintances with two of the co-accused in the case, however,
no contraband substance was ever seized from his person, no call details
report has been produced, and that his statement under Section 161 or 164
of the Cr.P.C. or one under Section 67 of the NDPS Act was ever
2024:MLHC:863
recorded and as such, the accused Uncle of the petitioner ought to be
enlarged on bail.
10.
This Court on perusal of the C.D, have noticed that from the
statement of the accused person Smti. Ngai Rami Simte, the story that
comes out is that this accused person is a drug peddler at Shillong, who
used to receive the substance from one Lalboi, a resident of Manipur.
Lalboi in turn has informed her that he is sending a consignment of
20(twenty) boxes of the illegal contraband substance through Smti. Lhing
Haokip and Smti. Hohoi Lhanghal (two of the other co-accused). This
accused person has further stated that this transaction was done with the
financial support of the accused Uncle of the petitioner and his wife.
11.
Again, the contention of the learned counsel of the petitioner
is not correct when it was submitted that no statement of the accused
Uncle of the petitioner was ever recorded by the Investigating Office
(I/O). From the C.D, it is seen that the I/O has indeed recorded the
statement of the accused Uncle of the petitioner on 18.07.2024 at 11:05
pm, on the same day he was arrested. In his statement, he has clearly
indicated that he knows Lalboi from whom he procured the contraband
which was then sent to the co-accused Smti. Ngai Rami Simte after
2024:MLHC:863
paying her ₹ 3,00,000/- (Rupees three lakhs). This can only strengthen
the case of the prosecution to complete the chain of circumstances.
12.
Though filing of the charge sheet cannot be a bar for grant of
bail, it must not be forgotten that even though the cardinal principle of
bail jurisprudence is “bail and not jail”, facts and circumstances of a
particular case has to be taken into account to consider the nature and
gravity of the offence involved, the evidence against the person
concerned, the likelihood of his or her absconding, if enlarged on bail and
other related factors.
13.
It is on record that the accused Uncle of the petitioner is not
only involved in this single case, but has also been implicated in another
case, also under the various sections of the NDPS Act. The fact that he is
a resident of the State of Manipur, though not a bar, but in the light of his
alleged involvement in the case, there is a likelihood of him being a flight
risk. The most important aspect of the matter that has weigh heavily upon
this Court is the gravity and nature of the crime in question, that is, the
impact of the effect of drug addiction as a result of such contraband
substance being easily available in this State. The alarming situation
could not but be termed as one of a very serious nature for which in cases
2024:MLHC:863
of this kind, the court has to balance the consideration of private rights
and liberty vis-à-vis societal protection and interest.
14.
Though this Court would not come to any conclusion as to the
complicity of the accused person in question as far as the case pending
before the Trial Court is concerned, however, it is thought prudent to
allow the whole body of evidence to be produced for which the Trial
Court is competent to do so and to finally come to the findings and
conclusion as to the guilt or innocence of the said accused person in
question.
15.
Under such circumstances, this Court finds that this
application is devoid of merits and the same is hereby dismissed.
16.
Matter disposed of. No costs.
Judge
DARIKORDOR NARY
Date: 2024.09.19 20:03:18 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review