The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. The defendants were the appellants before the learned 1 st appellate court, and the learned 1st appellate court also gave a concurrent finding after formulating the point for determination as to whether the judgement and decree of the trial court suffer from any illegality or irregularity or was bad due to any defects of law and was fit to be set aside.
17. However, the learned 1st appellate court has corrected the error committed by the learned trial court so far as defendant no.4 is concerned. The appeal was dismissed with modification in the trial court’s judgment declaring 2/7th share of the plaintiffs and that the decree was against the contesting defendants no.1 to 3 and 5 to 9 and ex parte against defendant no.4. The 1st appellate court found and held the proceeding against defendant no.4 was ex parte.
18. This Court finds that the learned courts have passed the judgement based on the materials on record, which does not suffer from any illegality. The relationship of the plaintiffs with their father Thakur Sao was duly proved based on both oral and documentary evidences placed on record. No perversity has been pointed out by the learned counsel of the appellants in the matter of appreciation of evidences by the court. No question of law, much less any substantial question of law is involved in this case. This Court finds no merit in this appeal, which is accordingly dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:3030
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
S.A. No. 233 of 2023
With
I.A. No.317 of 2026
1. Lila Devi (Deleted v.o.d. 05.01.2026)
2. Ranjan, age about 54 years, son of late Perma Nand Agrawal.
3. Niraj Kumar Agrawal, age about 51 years, son of late Perma
Nand Agrawal,
4. Rina Devi, age about 49 years, daughter of late Perma Nand
Agrawal
Sl. No.1 to 4 are resident of Mohalla – Belwatikar, P.O. & P.S.
Daltonganj, District – Palamau
5. Gultan Agrawal, age about 44 years, son of late Dinesh Prasad,
Resident of Mohalla – Nai Mohalla, P.O. & P.S. Daltonganj,
District – Palamau
6. Manorma Devi, age about 74 years, wife of Late Brahmdeo
Prasad Agrawal,
7. Prabhat Kumar Agrawal, age about 53 years, Son of Late
Brahmdeo Prasad Agrawal,
Sl. No. 6 and 7 are Resident of Mohalla- Belwatikar, P.O. &
P.S.-Daltonganj, District- Palamau
8. Dipti Devi, age about 43 years, daughter of Late Brahmdeo
Prasad Agrawal, Wife of Sri Shankar Kumar Agrawal
9. Sapna Agrawal, age about 39 years, daughter of Late Brahmdeo
Prasad Agrawal, Wife of Sri Ritesh Kumar,
Sl. No. 8 and 9 are Resident of at Mission Chowck, P.O. &
P.S.-Lohardaga, District- Lohardaga.
10.Arbind Kumar Agrawal, age about 67 years, Son of Late
Jagarnath Sao,
11.Anup Agrawal, age about 56 years, Son of Late Jagarnath Sao
12.Gajendra Agrawal, age about 65 years, Son of Late Saraju
Prasad
13.Dhiraj Kumar, age about 56 years, Son of Late Saraju Prasad,
14.Anurag Kumar, age about 43 years, Son of Late Saraju Prasad,
Sl. No. 10 to 14 are Resident of Mohalla- Belwatikar, P.O. &
P.S.-Daltonganj, District- Palamau
…
…
Appellants/Appellants/Defendants
Versus
1. Sunil Kumar Prasad, Son of Late Kauleshwar Ram, Resident of
Mohalla- Belwatikar, P.O. & P.S.- Daltonganj, DistrictPalamau.
2. Smt. Usha Devi, wife of Dr. Arun Kumar and daughter of late
Kauleshwar Ram, resident of village – Ranka, P.O. & P.S. –
Ranka, District – Garhwa
…
…
Respondents/Respondents/Plaintiffs
3. Uday Agrawal, son of late Jagarnath Sao, Resident of Mohalla
– Belwatikar, P.O. & P.S. Daltonganj, District – Palamau
…
… Proforma
Respondent/Proforma
Respondents/Proforma Defendant
2026:JHHC:3030
---
CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--: Mr. S.K. Sharma, Advocate
:
--This appeal has been filed against the judgement dated
For the Appellants
For the Respondents
12/05.02.2026
05.07.2023 (decree dated 18.07.2023) passed by learned District
Judge I, Palamau at Daltonganj in Partition Appeal No.26 of 2010
affirming the judgement and decree dated 23.04.2010 (decree signed
on 12.05.2010) passed by learned Sub-judge II, Palamau at Daltonganj
in Partition Suit No.117/2004.
2.
The learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that the
appellants were the defendants in the suit and, though they filed
written statements (except defendant no. 4), they did not lead any
evidence before the court. Consequently, the court proceeded under
Order VIII Rule 10 of Code of Civil Procedure and the suit was
decreed.
3.
The learned counsel submits that the specific case of the
plaintiffs was that the entire suit property was owned by Thakur Sao,
who had a wife, namely, Moti Devi, and the defendants are the
descendants through Moti Devi. Their further case was that upon the
death of Moti Devi, Thakur Sao married Shivrani Devi in the year
1955 and the plaintiffs claimed that they are the descendants of
Thakur Sao through Shivrani Devi.
4.
The learned counsel has submitted that the suit was partly
decreed only in connection with part of the suit property to the extent
of 2.25 acres, as the plaintiffs could produce documents regarding
ownership of the property in the name of Thakur Sao only to that
extent. He submits that though the defendants did not adduce any
evidence, but as per the written statement, Shivrani Devi was not the
wife of Thakur Sao and, consequently, the plaintiffs were not born out
of a wedlock between Shivrani Devi and Thakur Sao. It was their
further case that Shivrani Devi was the wife of one Kauleshwar Ram.
He has submitted that in the written statement at paragraph 12, a
specific statement was made to prove that Shivrani Devi was the wife
2026:JHHC:3030
of Kauleshwar Ram and that she had purchased a property in the year
1957 in which the name of her husband was shown as Kauleshwar
Ram. He submits that as per the case of the plaintiffs, Thakur Sao had
died in the year 1986.
5.
The learned counsel submits that the case of the plaintiffs was
that Shivrani Devi had married Thakur Sao in the year 1955. He has
also submitted that the documents which have been considered by the
learned trial court to decree the suit are the voter list, ration Card and
school transfer certificate, which could not be said to be documents to
show that Shivrani Devi was the wife of Thakur Sao.
I.A. No.317 of 2026
6.
The learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that I.A.
No.317 of 2026 has been filed seeking to adduce additional evidence
before the 2nd appellate court by bringing on record a copy of sale
deed no.5775 dated 16.02.1957 executed by Ramchandra Ram in
favour of Smt. Shivrani Devi, wife of Kauleshwar Ram. A photocopy
of the said document has been annexed with the interlocutory
application. He submits that in ground no.11 of the memo of appeal, it
has been stated that a separate petition under Order XLI Rule 27 is to
be filed for additional evidence.
7.
During the course of hearing and upon perusal of the
interlocutory application, the learned counsel for the appellants is not
in a position to explain as to why the defendants failed to participate in
the trial and further in spite of filing appeal before the 1 st appellate
court, why no steps were taken for adducing additional evidence.
8.
In paragraph 4 of the interlocutory application, it is stated that
Brahmdeo Prasad Agrawal, who was appellant no.2 in Partition
Appeal No.26 of 2020, died on 25.06.2023 and after his death, his
legal heirs searched his box and came across sale deed no.5775 dated
16.02.1957 and thereafter they showed the document to the advocate
and ultimately the interlocutory application was filed.
9.
The learned counsel for the appellants has produced a copy of
the written statement wherein, though it is mentioned that Shivrani
2026:JHHC:3030
Kaharin had purchased certain property, but the details of such
property have not been disclosed in the written statement also.
10.
This Court is of the considered view that in the written
statement as produced by the learned counsel for the appellants during
the course of hearing, there is no specific details with regard to the
sale deed, that is, date and number mentioned in the written statement
which is sought to be adduced as additional evidence at this 2nd
appellate stage through I.A. No.317 of 2026. It is also important to
note that the plaintiffs had produced enough oral and documentary
evidence to show that they were sons of Thakur Sao and it is not in
dispute that their mother was Shivrani Devi. In the aforesaid
circumstances, no useful purpose will be served by allowing the
additional evidence. Further, there is no cogent explanation as to why
the defendants did not participate in the trial and did not adduce any
evidence, either oral or documentary.
11.
In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, I.A. No.317
of 2026 is hereby rejected.
12.
So far as the main appeal is concerned, this Court finds that the
suit was filed seeking a preliminary decree for partition claiming 2/7
share in favour of the plaintiffs with respect to the suit properties. The
learned trial court recorded that defendant nos.1 to 3 and 5 to 9 had
appeared and filed written statement on 09.03.2005, but they left
pairvi from 25.01.2006 and in the meantime the case was running for
appearance of defendant no.4, who did not appear in spite of repeated
opportunities. Repeated opportunities were granted to the defendants,
but they did not turn up, and the trial was undertaken under the
provision of Order VIII Rule 10 of Code of Civil Procedure.
Consequently, defendant nos.1 to 3 and 5 to 9 had not come before the
court to support the pleadings of their written statement.
13.
The trial court also recorded that from bare reading of the
written statement, it appeared that they denied the relationship with
the plaintiffs and also denied that the plaintiffs were members of the
joint family. The trial court framed the points for decision as follows:
2026:JHHC:3030
“1. Whether there is unity of title and unity of possession to
the suit land between the parties?
2. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get 2/7th share in the
suit property?”
14.
The learned trial court, after considering the oral and
documentary evidence, ultimately decreed the suit by holding that the
parties had unity of title and unity of possession, only to the extent of
2.25 acres of land. The court also recorded that the plaintiffs pleaded
and adduced evidence to prove that Thakur Sao had married two
wives and 1st wife was Moti Devi, who died in 1952-53 and from the
wedlock of Thakur Sao and Moti Devi five sons were born and they
are the defendants and from the second wife Smt. Shivrani Devi, the
plaintiffs were born.
15.
The trial court also referred to the documentary evidences
placed on record including the election identity card of the plaintiffs
showing that they were the sons of Thakur Sao; transfer certificate
issued by the Headmaster of Ganesh Lal Agarwal Vidyalaya,
Daltonganj dated 08.07.1976, in which Thakur Sao was mentioned as
the father of plaintiff no.1, which was marked as Exhibit 2; and the
ration card indicating that the plaintiffs were the sons of Thakur Sao.
The court further observed that there was no document on record to
disbelieve these documents establishing the relationship between the
plaintiffs and Thakur Sao. Apparently, there was no dispute that the
mother of the plaintiffs was Shivrani Devi. The trial court held that the
plaintiffs had proved that the plaintiffs and the defendants constituted
joint family and there was unity of title and unity of possession with
respect to a portion of the suit property for which documents were
produced by the plaintiffs. Ultimately, the trial court held that plaintiff
no.1 had 1/7th share, plaintiff no.2 had 1/7th share, and decreed the suit
with respect to 2.25 acres of land for which documents were produced
to show that the property belonged to Thakur Sao. The trial court held
as follows:“15. So, far the share of the plaintiffs is concerned, according to the
oral evidence of plaintiffs that title holder for the part suit land i.e. 2.25
acres. Thakur Sao died leaving behind six sons and one daughter wife
of the Thakur Sao also died. So, according to law plaintiff no.1 has
2026:JHHC:3030
1/7th share and plaintiff no.2 have also 1/7th share i.e. plaintiffs have
2/7th share. In the part land of suit land i.e. 2.25 acres. There is unity of
title and unity of possession over the part area of suit land i.e. 2.25
acres of the parties. It is joint property. There is no evidence before the
court to disbelieve the jointness of the parties. Therefore, it is ordered
that a preliminary decree of partition with respect to part land of suit
land i.e. 2.25 acres is given to the plaintiffs to the extent of 2/7th share
with contest. Plaintiffs are entitled to get further relief as to cost of the
suit.”
16.
The defendants were the appellants before the learned 1 st
appellate court, and the learned 1st appellate court also gave a
concurrent finding after formulating the point for determination as to
whether the judgement and decree of the trial court suffer from any
illegality or irregularity or was bad due to any defects of law and was
fit to be set aside.
17.
However, the learned 1st appellate court has corrected the error
committed by the learned trial court so far as defendant no.4 is
concerned. The appeal was dismissed with modification in the trial
court’s judgment declaring 2/7th share of the plaintiffs and that the
decree was against the contesting defendants no.1 to 3 and 5 to 9 and
ex parte against defendant no.4. The 1st appellate court found and held
the proceeding against defendant no.4 was ex parte.
18.
This Court finds that the learned courts have passed the
judgement based on the materials on record, which does not suffer
from any illegality. The relationship of the plaintiffs with their father
Thakur Sao was duly proved based on both oral and documentary
evidences placed on record. No perversity has been pointed out by the
learned counsel of the appellants in the matter of appreciation of
evidences by the court. No question of law, much less any substantial
question of law is involved in this case. This Court finds no merit in
this appeal, which is accordingly dismissed.
19.
Let a soft copy of this order be communicated to the court
concerned through FAX/email.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
05.02.2026
Saurav/
Uploaded on 09.02.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review