Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3301 ]
I
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
I
I
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
I
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITION NO: 30211 OF 2024
Between:
Laxmidevi Ajay, S/o Thirupathi, Age 27 years, Occ Unemployed, RJo.
H.No.18-695, Ramnagar, IVlancherial-504208, Asst. Foreman Trainee
Electrical Hall ticket: 2212285OOO1 1,
...PETITIONER
AND
The Singareni- Collieries Company Limited (SCCL), Represented by its
Chairman and Managing Director, Singareni Bhavan Red Hilis, Hyderabad
The General Manager, Personal Welfare and RC the SCCL Recruitment Cell,
Kothagudem, Bhadradri Kothagudem.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 o'f the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate Writ, Order, or Direction, particularly in the
nature of a WRIT OF MANDAMUS, declar'e that the action of the 2nd
Respondent in changing the correct options from Prelimina ry Keyl Response
sheet to Final Key/Question Paper Preview for Question Nos. 26 (Question ld
630680217894), Question No.27 (Question ld 630680217921), Question No.63
(Question ld 630680380422), Question No. 64 (Question Id 630680380429), and
Not considering objection raised for Question No. 65 (Question ld
630680389642) in the respondent company SCCL for the post of Assistant
Foreman Trainee (Electrical) examination conducted on 06. 08. 2024 pursuant to
the Notification O2l2O24 dated '15. 05. 2024 is illegal, arbitrary, discriminatory,
and in violation of Articles 14, 19, and 21 of the Constitution of lndia
consequently direct the 2nd Respondent to refer the Question Nos. Question No.
26 (Question ld 630680217894), Question No. 27 (Question ld 630680217921),
a
Question No. 63 (Question ld 630680380422), Question t',J r. 64 (Question ld
630680380429), and Question No. 65 (Question ld 6306803ti, 642)
lA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the (:i cumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the 2nd Respondent to refer the Question Nos. euest < n No. 26 (euestion
ld 630680217894), Question No.27 (Question ld 6306802 1j)211, euestion No.
63 (Question ld 630680380422), Question No. 64 (euestiorr td 630680380425\,
and Question No.65 (Question ld 630680389642) pursuar'r to the Notification
0212024 dated 15.05.2024, pending disposal of the Main Wri. retition.
lA NO: 2 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 cPC praying that in the ( i cumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
STAY the further process of selection to the extent of Assistrr rt Foreman Trainee
(Electrical) pursuant to the Notific ation o2l2024 dated 1{ .os.2oz4 until the
independent subject matter expert committee submits is report, pending
disposal of the Main Writ Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI RAMESH CHILLA
Counsel forthe Respondents: SRI P.SRI HARSHA REDDY, S C FOR SCCL
The Court made the following: ORDER
I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITON No.3O21L OF 2024
Date: 09.OL.2O26
Between :
La-xmidevi Ajay
.
Petitioner
AND
The Singareni Coliieries Company Limited,
Represented by its Chairman and Managing Director,
Singareni Bhavan Red Hills, Hyderabacl and ar'lother.
.. Respondents
ORDER:
This Writ Petition is filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India seeking to declare the action of respondent
No.2 in changing the correct options from the preliminary
ke,y/response sheet to the final key/question paper preview for
Question Nos.26 (Question l.D. No.630680217894), 27 (euestion
I.D. No.63068O277921), 63 (Question i.D. No.63068O3aO422) and,
64 (Question I.D. No.630680380429) and in not considering rhe
objection raised with respect to euestion No.65 (euestion I.D.
o
PK,J
wp 302I I 2024
No.6306803896a2) in
the examination concrt cted by the
respondent companY for the post of Assistant Fc reman Trainee
(Electrical) on 06.08.2024 pursuant to Notihcati' n No'O212024
dated l s.Os.2024, as illegal, arbitrary and vioiati"' of Articles 14'
lgand2loftheConstitutionoflndiaandtocorrlequentlydirect
respondent No.2 to refer and re-evaluate Questiolr Nos'26, 27,63,
64 trnd 65 (bearing Question I D'
Nos 130680217494'
63O68O217g2t, 630680380422, 6306BCi 80429 and
630680389642 respectively) through an irr ependent and
competent exPert committee.
2.
Heard Sri Ramesh Chilla, learned counsel f rr the petitioner
and Sri P.Sri Harsha Reddy, learned Star-rd i rg Counsel for
Singareni Coliieries Company Limited, app trring for the
respondents.
3.
The case of the petitioner is as follows:
The pclitioner belongs to the BC-A corr munity and, in
response to Employment Notification Nc ' )2 12024 dated
15.05.2024 issuecl by respondent No. 1 , invitinp applications for
the post of Assistant Foreman Trainee (Electr'< a1) comprising a
PK,J
Wp 3O2t | 2021
total of 24 posts, he applied for the said post and appeared for the
rvritten examination conducted on 06.Og.2024. Subsequentll
, the
preliminary key was made ava able on the website on 13.og.2024
and the ca-ndidates were allowed to submit objections to the same
from 13.08.2024 to tS.Og.2024 by uploading supporting
documents or material in pDF/JpEG format as attachments. The
petitioner's responses for euestion Nos.26 (euestion I.D.
No.6306802 17894), 27 (euestion I.D. No.6306802 tT92t), 63
(Questron I.D. No.6306S0380a22), and 64 (euestion I.D.
No.63068038O429) were tallying with the preliminary key, and
therefore, no objections were required to be frled in respect of
these questions. However, the petitioner raised an objectior_r in
respect of Question No.65 (euestion I.D. No.6306803896a2).
Thereafter, the final key/question paper preview. rvas made
available on 26.09.2024, wherein the petitioner noticed that thc
respondents had a,ltered the options from the preliminary ke1, lor
Question Nos.26, 27, 63 and 64, while the objection raised by the
petitioner in respect of euestion No.65 was not consrdered.
Hence, the petitioner hled the present Writ petition.
\
PK,J
wp 3021 1 2024
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner sub nits that the
petitioner sectrred B 1 marks and holds 47tn t t nk and il the
additional mar-l<s for those questions were counr( ( , the petitioner
wor..rld rank among the top candidates in the B( -A community,
thereby securir-rg one of the two posts reserved ft' that category.
Further, the petitioner raised arr objection to only r ne question, as
the remaining questions reflected correct . t s\f,rers in the
prelimir-rary ke-v and therefore did not warrant anr rbjections. It is
further submitted that in similar circumstancer; thrs Court, in
W.P. Nos.1 1810 ancl 18335 of 2O2O, uide order dr ed 03.03.202 1,
disposed of the said Writ Petitions by directing tht resltondents to
refer the dispr-rted question therein to an expert r: rmmittee u,ithin
a reasonable perlod and the said order \\rrt; subsequently
confirmed by a Division Bench of this Court uiclt: udgment dated
29.10.2021 ir.r W.A. Nos.126, 133 and 406 of 2\) )-1 . Further, in
the case of Bihar StafJ Selection Commlssion 1 Anrn Kumarl,
the Hon'ble Supreme Court laid down the lar regarding the
referral of erroneous questions to an expert comrt ttee. Therefore,
learned counsel prays this Court to direct the resl ondents to refer
L
12020) 6 SCC 362
PK,J
wp_3O2lt-2O2a
the disputed questions in the present case to an expert committee
on similar lines. ln support of his contentions, learned counsel for
the petitioner relied upon the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme
Court in Manish Ujwal and Others u, Maharishi Daganand
Sarrrstruati Uniuersitg and others 2 and Mad.hgarnam
Broadcasting Limited a. Union oJ India s and also on the
judgment ol the High Court of Delhi in Om Pro,kash Verma u,
National Testing Agencg & anothef
5.
Per contra, learned Standing Counsel appearing for the
respondents submits that the respondents issued Employment
Notilrcation No.O2/2024 dated 15.05.2O24 for hlling up vacancies
in various Executive and NCWA cadre posts, including 24
vacancies for the post of Assistant Foreman Trainee (Electrical),
T&S Grade-C (External). The petitioner herein submitted Online
Application No.SCCL0224OO|2937 for the said post and u,as
issued Call Letter No.22122a5OOOl1 to appear for the Computer
Based Test, u'hich was conducted on 06.08.2024 at various
2 (2OO5) 13 SCC 744
3 (2023) 13 SCC 401
o
w.e.1c) tto. t t sao ot 2023 and cM App No.52064 and 52065 of 2023
dated 09 .o2 .2024
.\:
PK,J
Wp 312rr 2024
-:
centers locatecl in Hyderabad, Khammam, Karimne gar. Waralgal,
Siddipet, Sathr-rpalli and Kothagudem. The preli: inary key was
displal'ed on 13.08.2024 and objections from the c rndidates were
acccpted up to 15.08.2024. Accordingly, a total cl 222 objections
were received for the post of Assistant Fttl eman Trainee
(Electrical), T&S Gracle-C (External).
(b) The entire recruitment process, inclur ing the design
and development of the softrvare application form. eceipt of online
applications and preparation of the provisional merit list, was
entrusted to M/s.Educational Consultants lndia I imited (trdCIL),
a Mini Ratna Category-l Central Public Se: or Enterprise,
Government of India. pursuant to the MoU date<l i 3.O3.2024. It is
furtl-rer submitted that alter receiving the objecticr on preliminary
ke)', M/s. EdCIL constituted a Subject E>1 ert Committee
com prising the follor'ving members to examin': the objections
received from candidates:
No
+
I
Lectu rcr
Assistant
I
Experience
Designation
Professor
l
(l vears
]
L
4 years
Highest
Qualification
Post
Graduate
DocLorate
Institution
)r vernment
'c 1 technic College,
'r lakad. Kerala.
il N,l Institute of
k .e ncc &
':l
./
PK,.J
wp 302I I 2024
Technolory,
Modinagar, Uttar
Pradesh.
Assistant
Profcssor
20 years
Doctorate
ITS Engineering
College, G reatcr
Noida, Utlar
Pradesh.
SGI Engineering
Assistant
Pro[essor
10 years
Post
Doctorate
College, affiliated to
Bikaner Technical
University, Sikar,
Ra asthan
The committee examined in detail and reviewed all
objections by referring to relevant literature, textbooks and study
materials to ensure accuracy and after making the necessarl
corrections to the preliminary key, the final key was displayed on
26.O9.2024 by specifying the questions on which objections i,r,ere
raised along with the valid reasons for the answers. Regarding the
questions in dispute, the answer keys for Question Nos.26, 27,
63, and 64 u,ere modif,led, as the committee opined that the
objections were valid and required correction. For Question No.65
(Question l.D. No.630680389642), the committee opined thar no
correction was necessary. As per the hnal key, the pelitioncr
secured 81 marks in the Computer Based Test and obtained 47th
rank in the provisiona,i merit list
I'K,J
Wp 30211_2024
(c) lt is lurther submitted that the judgrr r nts relied upon
by the petitioner pertain to the referral of dispu: d or erroneous
questions to an expert committee. Whereas, in r I e present case,
the objections raised u,ere duly referred to tl-r: subject expert
committee and fina1 kev was issued on 26.O9.2(t'.4. Further. the
selection list lor the post of Assistant Foreman Tra .nee (Electrical),
T&S Grade-C (trxternal)
\\:AS
displayed on t re vvebsite on
26.1O.2024 and candidates within the zone r,1 selection were
intimated to attend the original certihcate verific ttion scheduled
on 07.11.2024. Accordingly, the verification of oli linai certif,rcates
of the selected candidates \\ras completed .nd the entire
recruitment/ selection process for the aforesai<l post has been
concluded. Therefore, thcre are no merits in the'y'rit Petition and
the same is liable to be dismissed in limine
6.
This Court has taken note of the subrn i ;sions made by
learned counsel lor the respective parties i I d perused the
material available on record
7.
A perusal of the record discloses that the. t etitloner applied
for the post of Assistant Foreman Trainee Ole<:trical), T&S
PK,.J
Wp,.3O2l I 2024
Grade-C (External), pursuant to Employment Notification
No.O2l2024 dated 15.05.2024, he was subsequently issued Call
Letter No.2212285OOOI1 ar-rd appeared for the Computer Based
Test conducted on 06.08.2024. Tl;,e response sheets for the said
test were displayed on I3.08.2024 and the candidates were given
an opportunity to submit objections regarding the preliminary key
up to 15.08.2024. A total of 222 objections were received lor the
said post.
8.
In this regard, M/s. trdCIL, a Mini Ratna Category-l Central
Public Sector Enterprise, Gor.ernment of India, u,as entrusted lt'ith
conducting the entire recruitment process pursuant to the MoU
dated 23.O3.2024. The record discloses that after receiving the
objections from the candidates on preliminary key, it had
constituted a Subject Expert Committee to examine the objections
raised by the candidates. The Expert Committee was provided
vgith the preliminary answer key and all the objections received
from the candidates. The Committee undertook a detailed
examination and revieu, of the objections, referring to relevant
literature, textbooks and study materials to ensure accuracy.
r-
!i
\^
\l
PK,J
WD 3o2tt 2024
Based on 1ts thorough
analysis, the
n eces sary
Corr rnittee suggested
corrections to the valid objection,;
preliminary k.y. The
details of the objectiorr;
preliminary key ald the
action taken
Nos.26, 22, 63,64 and 65
rcr;cived on the
in r.( s pect of euestion
are as follows:
Answcr iD
Question ID
identified in the
ObJectio
rrl recensived
PreliInlnary Key
Firel (cy
Refcrence
'lllcclflci a- a"rt-
r
Elc( t
630680845484
5306802 t7Asa
zz I osooaozn,ytt
63068021792 I
(r)
J
,\u thor A.t. Sawhr ey
Lott on Look for tl e
rcccr)t cdition ormostA
standird edition used rn
\orrr .ourse or it.l.l oase(
(4t
change(l
',
and I
63068C j lj48i;
k"t'
(2)
lTii",;I tcv
chan
2r)O to l0O
630C),30:,.r59r
d
(.4)
Book
"I-ower EIe
Contrrters,
Apph( atrons
'Io.e
I
])csrgn" by Ned Ivlohan
M Undetand and
Wilhanr P Robbins
R^lF!.rnt Ct)afrer . Lrok
6306803804 22
a)306801482685
(31
l
kcy
changed
l
630680E +
(4)
'r;94
rn
lhe ' hdpter on "C rrrenr
Sou rr e
Inverters"
lntcflL,r Operatton a n.l
Control" Thesese.lions
t!,prcall] co(,er tfr"
prrncrplcs of crrrrent
soLlrc( rnvcr ters, their
opcrat tonal chararrer rstics
,rn(l hu\\,rh.y rnrcrdc q.irh
load
L
I
I
l
i;:0680J80429 Oartf)aO I.t SZ Z t:t
t2)
kc-v
changcd
-
In Jredrncc St-gfir
rne jrd cd,tion.
\oLr nIAhr r.lcr to ,.pes
l i99
llook
6 20
''Elecrrrc D
Conceprs
an.t
I \pplr(atrL,ns,, Ly Ga rtam
Shrof[ I).levarlr Chzrnter.
o^k llr rhe chdprer or ,.AC
630680 -t )7 t2 i)rrres
and Control
(2)
l\lerhorts' or ,Control , t
AC
Iorors_ Thescchat)re.s
I vpr.allv
,uiin,,.
"or.. for AC
.ontrol strategies
Ul llcs, lncludrng
srator
!!'1.!n t
Sp( (1fic
|
\
------,
PK,J
Wp 3021I-2024
Pates: In the 2012 edition,
You mrght refer to Pages
l
r42-t5a
l
Book: "Elcctric Machincry
Power Syslert
Fundanrentals" by Stephcn
J. Chapman Rclclant
and
Chaplcr r took rn Lhe
chaprcr
630680389642
630680 r5 i 9028
(3)
Ncr
acuon
rcqurrcd
(13O680 I519028
(3)
"MoLor
Charac(cnstics oI N1o lo rs-
These chapters t]'prc:rlh'
cover the various graphs
used (o reprcsent mol or
perforr]lance, rnclLl(llng
speed torque
charactcristics. Specrfic
pages: In the 201 I cdition,
you can rerer to pagcs 292310.
9,
Thereafter, the linal ke)' incorporating the corrections
recommended by the Expert Committee was published
on
26.09.2024. As per the hnal key, the petitioner secured 81 marks
rn the Computer Based Test and obtained 47tn rank in the
provisional merit list. Following the hnal key, the selection list for
the post of Assistant Foreman Trainee (Electrical), T&S Grade-C
(Dxternal) was displayed on the rvebsite on 26.10.2024. However,
the petitioner was not selected because of his lower merit
Subsequently, the candidates u,ithin the zone of selection were
intirnated to attend the original certif-rcate verification scheduled
on 07. 11.2024 and the entire recruitment/ selection process for
the aforesaid post has been concluded
:
L2
Pl{,J
wp 3O2l|-2O24
10. Before adverting to the settled principles id clou,n by the
1e
Hon'ble Supreme Court, this Court ltnds it necess ar_v to deal u,ith
the judgments relied upon by the learned ounsel for the
<
petitioner. The reliance placed on the judgments t I Manish Ujual
{1 supra), Madhgannam Broadcasting Lirnite c (2 supra), Om
Prakash Vertna (3 supra), as well as the orderli of this Court in
In all the said
W.P. Nos.11810 and 18335 of 2O2O, is inapposite
t le
cases, the grievance pertained either to
absence of
consideration of objections, lack of reference to i ny expert body,
or demonstrable errors apparent on the face of rl e record. In the
present case, however, the objections raised b1 the candidates
n ere admittedly referred
to a duly constituterl Subject Expert
Committee, rvhich examined all objections r'
r
h reference to
standard textbooks and study materials. Th ( answers were
modihed wherever the objections were found
o be valid and
retained where no correction was warranted.
Therefore, the
factual matrix in the present case is materially
[ferent and does
not \\,arrant interference.
t
PK,J
u.lplA2ll 2024
1. Here, this Court deems it approPriate to refer to certaln
judgments of thb Hon'ble Supreme Court laying do"vn the
the role of Expert Committees in examination and
iaw on
recruitment
matters.
L2. In Ran Vliag Singh u' State of lJttar Pradeshs ' the
Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as under:
30- The Iaw on the subiect is thercfore' quite clear and
we only propose to highlight a feu' sigruficant conclusions'
TheY are:
30.1. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governlng an
shcet or
examination permits the re evaluation ol al answer
thc
scrutiny of an answer sheet as a matter ol right' lhen
authority conducting the examination may permit il;
30.2. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governrng an
o[ an
exarnination does not permit re-evaluation or scrutiny
court
answer sheet (as distinct lrom prohibiting it) then thc
may perrr,rit re-eva,luation or scmtiny only if it is demonstrated
or by
very clearly, without any "inferential process of reasoning
process of rationa-lisation" and only in rarc or exceptional
a
cases that a materia-l error has been committccL;
30.3. The court should not at a,ll re evaluate or
scmtinise the answer sheets of a candidate it has no
' 1zo rs1 z scc asz
\
l4
PK,J
Wp 302I L 2024
expertise in the matter and academic matters ar' )est left to
acadcmics:
30.4. The courl should presume the correcl Less of the
kcv alsrvers and proceed on that assumptionl antl
30.5. In the event of a doubt, the benefrt r;) 'ould go to
the examination authority rather than to the cat didate'
(emPha s s suPPlied)
(ii)
ln tlttar Pradesh Public Sertice Commission t Rahul Singh6'
the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held as under:
"12. The law is well settled that the onus is on 1lt
ca;ldidate
to not onlJr demonstrate that the key answer is incor'-t :t but also
lhart it is:r glartng mistake which is totally appar'( :lt ald fro
inlcrential process or reasoning is required to shoq' at the key
e { rcise great
:rn swer is wrong The constitutional courts must
L
restraint in such matters ald should be reluctant trr :ntertain a
plca challenging the correctness of the key answers In Kanpur
Uniuersitg case (supra), the Court recommended a s1 : .cm of:
(l) mod.ralion:
(2) avoiding ambiguitf in the questions;
(3) prompt decisions be taken to exclude susPecle 1 qucstions
arLd no marks be assigncd to such questions'
13. As far as the present case is concerned :vcn before
publishing the first list of key ailswers the Commissior had got the
kcy answers moderated by two Expert Committees Thereafter'
6 (2o tE) 7 scc 254
r#
\l
\l
\
PK,.]
Wp 3O2lI 2024
objections were invited and a 26-member Committee was
constituted to verify the objections and after this exercise the
Committee recommended that 5 questions be deleted and in 2
questions, key answers be changed. It can be presumed that these
Committees consisted of experts in various subjccts for which the
examinees were tested. Judges cannot take on the role of experts
in academic matters. Unless, the caldidate demonstrates that the
key answers are patently wrong on the face of it, the courts cannot
enter into the academic held, weigh the pros ald cons o[ thc
arguments given by bolh sides and then comc to the cor.rclusron as
to which of the answers is better or rnore correct.
14. [n the present casc, we find that a]l thc thrce questions
needed a long process o[ reasoning and the High Court itsclf has
noticed that the stand of the Commission is also supported by
certain textbooks. When there are conflicting views, then the court
must bow down to Lhe opinion of the experLs. Judges are not
dnd cannot be expet'ts in all Jields and, therefore, theg must
exercise gredt restrdlnt and, should. not ouerstep their
jurisdiction to upset the opinion of the experts,"
(emphasis supplierl)
(iii) ln Richal v. Raj@sthan htblic Seruice CommtsstonT, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court observed that the Expert Committee,
constituted for validation of the answer key, had examined all the
objections raised by the appeliants and had provided satisfactory
clarifications. The Commission accepted the Report of the Expert
7 (2018) 8 SCC 8r
PK,J
wp,302I 1- 202a
Committee and revised the results accordingiy' I he Court held
that the recom menclations of the Expert Committe: once accepted
bl' tl-re Commissiort, are to be implemented
13. In view of the foregoing discussion, in the ill ;tant case, lt IS
evidcnt that the issues raised in respect of Quest on Nos 26, 27,
63, 64 and 65 (bearing Question I.D. Nos 130680217894,
630680380422, 630680 )'0429, aud
6306802 17921 ,
63068038964 2 rcspe ctively) were thoroughly cxarnined and
addressect b1, the Expert Committee constituted lr the purpose'
'lhe linal kc1' r'r'as published only after carelt I scrutinl and
correction by the experts, strictly in accordancc r'vitl-r the Ru1es,
regulations and procedures governing the exami;] rtion' Therefore'
this Court rs of the view that the recruitm 3 lt process was
cor-rducted foliorving all the prescribed procecl tres and under
expel't scrutin1., ensuring fairness and transpare.l ;.y'
L4. As cotrsisterltly helcl by the Hon'ble Supre r re Court in Ran
Vijag Singh's case (5 supra), Rahut Singh's case (5 supra), and
Richa!'s case (7 supra), the Courts must cx'r t:ise restraint in
interfering t,ith expert opinion in academic mr ters and should
t7
Pii,J
\\h 3021I ]024
intervene only in cases of patent, glaring or material errors, rvhich
are not present in the instant case. In view of the above
discussion, this Court is of the opinion that there are no ments ln
the Writ Petition and is liable to be dismissed
15. Accordingly, this Writ Petition stands dismissed.
16. At this juncture, learned counsel for the petitioner prays this
Court to direct the respondents to furnish the petitioner the
relevant material as to on which basis the hnal key n'as hnalized
in respect of the disputed questions.
17. Considering the above made submission. it is madc clear
that this order shall not preclude the petitioner from seeking
relevant information, if he so desires, by filing an appropriate
application before the competent authority. In such an everlt, the
same sha-ll be considered, in accordance with lari'.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shall stand ckrsed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
SD/.A.H.S. GOWRI SHANKAR
ASSISTANT BE€ISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
(9
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Chairman and Managing Director, Singareni Collieries Company
Limited(SCCL), Singareni Bhavan Red Hills, Hyderabad
2. The General Manager, Personal Welfare and RC the SCCL Recruitment Cell,
Kothagudem, Bhadradri Kothagudem.
3. On" CC to SRI RAMESH CHILLA, Advocate IOPUCI
4 One CC to SRI P.SRI HARSHA REDDY, SC FOR SCCL [OPUC]
5. Two CD Copies
{*
BSR
BS
I
I
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
I
I
DATED:0910112026
.J,
l:a iiE s rA
o
O
_t
ri)
rl
.t:
irtitlr ,.^,
ORDER
il
il
1 6 lArl 2[?6
.-1'
-a,
/.'
./
J.. ,."/
t'.'? .'.1:l'
WP.No.30211 of 2024
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION,
WITHOUT COSTS
nb
a^
a
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review