Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, AT DHARWAD
DATED THIS THE 5TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE K.S.HEMALEKHA
WRIT PETITION NO. 102329 OF 2023 (S-RES)
BETWEEN:
SRI. LAXMAN GOUDA S/O. KESHA GOUDA
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS,
OCC: PROJECT HEAD, IISC, BENGALURU,
R/O. HOSAMOTE, MAVIN KURVA,
HONNAVARA, DIST: KARWAR-581335.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. SUNIL S.DESAI, ADVOCATE)
AND:
MANJANNA
E
MANJANNA E
Location: HIGH COURT
OF KARNATAKA
DHARWAD BENCH
Date: 2026.02.16 12:54:00
+0530
1.
THE DIRECTOR
INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY (IIT),
WALMI, CAMPUS, BELUR INDUSTRIAL AREA,
NEAR HIGH COURT BENCH, PB ROAD,
DHARWAD.
2.
THE REGISTRAR
INDIAN INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY (IIT),
WALMI, CAMPUS BELUR INDUSTRIAL AREA,
NEAR HIGH COURT BENCH, PB ROAD,
DHARWAD.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. SHIVASAI M.PATIL, ADVOCATE)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO ISSUE A WRIT OF
CERTIORARI QUASHING THE IMPUGNED COMMUNICATION/ORDER
BEARING NO.ADMIN/FW/LAXMAN GOUDA/2022-23/210 DATED 17-032023 VIDE ANNEXURE-K ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT, AS
ILLEGAL, ARBITRARY AND VIOLATION OF PRINCIPAL OF NATURAL
JUSTICE, IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND EQUITY; ISSUE A WRIT
OF MANDAMUS DIRECTING THE RESPONDENTS TO CONTINUE THE
PETITIONER TO THE POST OF ASSISTANT PROFESSOR IN THE
DEPARTMENT OF CHEMISTRY, IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE AND
EQUITY AND ETC.
-2NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
THIS WRIT PETITION COMING ON FOR ORDERS THIS DAY,
ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM:
THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE K.S.HEMALEKHA
ORAL ORDER
The petitioner has called in question the legality and
validity of the communication dated 17.03.2023, issued by
respondent No.2 (Annexure-K), whereby, the offer of
appointment dated 02.11.2022 to the post of the Assistant
Professor, Grade-I, Chemistry at IIT-Dharwad has been
withdrawn, after the petitioner had already accepted the
offer, joined duty and disclosed all material facts relating to
the criminal proceedings pending against him.
Brief facts:
2. The petitioner, a highly qualified academician with
international research experience, applied pursuant to a
recruitment notification issued by the respondent-institute.
After due selection process, interview, and approval by the
competent
authority,
02.11.2022
was
an
issued
offer
in
his
of
appointment
favour.
The
dated
petitioner
-3NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
accepted the offer, resigned from his earlier employment,
joined duty on 15.02.2023 and submitted a prescribed
attestation form on 28.02.2023, wherein he truthfully
disclosed the pendency of a criminal case and his arrest and
custody arising out of a matrimonial dispute with his wife.
Despite such disclosure, without issuing a show cause
notice
or
affording
an
opportunity
of
hearing,
the
respondent issued the impugned communication (AnnexureK), withdrawing the appointment solely on the ground of
pendency of the criminal case.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
impugned action is arbitrary, disproportionate and violative
of the principles of natural justice, as no opportunity of
hearing
was
appointment.
afforded
The
prior
petitioner
to
has
withdrawal
not
of
the
suppressed
any
material fact, on the contrary he made a full and truthful
disclosure in the attestation form. The criminal case relied
upon by the respondent;
-4NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
(i)
arises
out
of
a
matrimonial
dispute
initiated by the wife,
(ii)
does not pertain to moral turpitude,
professional misconduct or corruption,
financial
fraud
or
offences
affecting
public trust and
(iii)
does not have nexus whatsoever with
the duties of an Assistant Professor.
Mere arrest, custody or pendency of a matrimonial case
cannot ipso facto render the petitioner unsuitable, especially
when he had already been selected on merit and permitted
to join. It is submitted that the respondent has misapplied
the statutory scheme and the judicial precedents governing
verification of antecedents.
4.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondent
submits that the service matters of IIT are governed by the
Institutes of Technology Act, 1961 (‘Act 1961’ for short) and
the
First
Statutes
appointments/action
must
of
IIT
conform
Dharwad
to
the
2017,
statutory
-5NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
provision. It is submitted that Section 19 of the First
Statutes governs conditions of
service, discipline and
suspension. Schedule C, clause 16(b) permits placing an
employee under suspension where a criminal case is under
investigation/trial. Clause 16(b) bars assignment of duties
to staff facing criminal investigation. It is submitted that in
the attestation, the petitioner disclosed arrest, detention
and pendency of a criminal case and, given the serious of
allegation and the statutory scheme, the Institute states
that joining was not complete until verification and hence
the offer was withdrawn on 17.03.2023 after verification.
5.
Placing reliance upon the Apex Court’s decision in
Avtar Singh Vs Union of India and Others1 (Avtar
Singh) submits that the pendency of a criminal case can
render a candidate unsuitable and the employer need not
wait for the trial outcome where suitability is affected and
that the employer's discretion in assessing the suitability
lies when serious offences are alleged.
(2016) 8 SCC 471
-6NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
6.
In this context, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that the respondents have failed to point out any
provision under the Act, 1961 or the First Statutes of IIT
Dharwad
2017,
which
authorizes
withdrawal
of
appointments solely on the ground of a criminal case. On
the contrary, Section 19 read with “Schedule C”, clause
16(a) and (b) only contemplate suspension or regulation of
duties, and not cancellation of appointment, and thus the
impugned action travels beyond the statutory framework
and is ultra vires. He submits that mere arrest or pendency
of a proceedings purely matrimonial in nature, cannot be
equated with unsuitability especially when the statutory
rules do not prescribe such consequence. He further
submits that the petitioner has truthfully disclosed all
material particulars in attestation form and once the
disclosure is honest, the respondents were required to
undertake
an
objective
assessment
of
suitability
as
mandated by law. Mechanical withdrawal of appointment
defeats the very purpose of antecedent verification. Thus
-7NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
submits that such a plea cannot substitute the statutory
compliance.
7.
This Court has carefully considered the rival
submissions and perused the material on record. The point
that arise for consideration in this Writ Petition is,
“Whether the respondents were justified in
withdrawing the petitioner's appointment solely
on the basis of pendency of a matrimonial
criminal case and is it sustainable in law under
the governing statutory rules?”
8.
The service conditions of the IIT Dharwad are
governed by the Act, 1961 and the First Statues of the
Indian Institute of Technology, Dharwad, 2017. Section 19
of the Service of Conditions reads thus:
“19. Terms and Conditions of Service of the
Employees and Determining their Seniority
(1) There shall be the following categories of
employees of the Institute –
a) Permanent Employees
b) Temporary Employees
-8NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
c) Employees on Contract
The terms and conditions of service for
each of the above categories shall be as
provided in the Schedule B.
(2) For determining the inter-se seniority of
employees of different categories for
specific
purposes
such
as
for
the
membership of authorities and bodies,
residential accommodation etc, the Board
may approve the norms and guidelines
from time to time.
(3)
The employees shall be governed by the
Conduct
Rules
as
detailed
in
the
Schedule C.”
9. Schedule C, clause 16 discipline and conduct reads
thus:
“16 Disciplinary action:
Suspension: The Director may place a member
of
the
staff
appointed
at
the
Institute
where
disciplinary
under
suspension:
(a)
a
proceeding
against him contemplated or is pending; or
-9NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
(b) where a case in respect of any
criminal offence is under investigation or trial”
10.
A conjoint reading of Act, 1961 and Section 19
read with Schedule C, clause 16(a) and (b) of the First
Statues of the Indian Institute of Technology Dharwad,
2017 makes it manifest clear that the statutory scheme
does not confer any power on the respondents to withdraw
or cancel an appointment solely on the ground of a
pendency of a criminal case.
Under the governing rules,
pendency of a criminal proceedings is recognized only
(i) as a circumstance warranting administrative regulation,
namely
(ii)
placing
withholding
the
employee
assignment
of
under
duties
suspension
during
the
investigation or trial. The Statue does not contemplate
withdrawal of appointment, cancellation of selection or
termination of service as an automatic or a consequential
measure on mere pendency of a criminal proceedings.
When the statute expressly provides for a lesser and
temporary measures, the respondents could not have
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
resorted
to
a
most
drastic
action
which
is
neither
contemplated nor sanctioned by the Rules.
11.
Further, what is important
to be noted is the
criminal case relied upon by the respondents arises out of a
matrimonial dispute initiated by the wife and does not relate
to any offence involving moral turpitude or professional
misconduct,
financial
impropriety
or
violation
of
any
statutory obligation attached to the post of Assistant
Professor. Such proceedings, by their very nature, do not
constitute a statutory disqualification under the applicable
rules or which was within the wisdom of the administration.
In the absence of any express rule enabling withdrawal of
appointment,
the
impugned
action
is
ultra
vires
the
statutory framework and cannot be sustained merely on the
basis
of
administrative
discretion
or
legal
opinion.
Accordingly, this Court holds that the respondent lacked
rule
based
appointment
authority
to
and
impugned
the
withdraw
the
petitioners’
communication
dated
17.03.2023 is therefore illegal and unsustainable in law.
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
12.
The Apex Court in Avtar Singh’s case has laid
down the guidelines and at paragraph Nos.38 has held as
under:
“38. We have noticed various decisions and
tried to explain and reconcile them as far as possible.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, we summarise
our conclusion thus:
38.1. Information given to the employer by a
candidate as to conviction, acquittal or arrest, or
pendency of a criminal case, whether before or after
entering into service must be true and there should
be no suppression or false mention of required
information.
38.2. While passing order of termination of
services or cancellation of candidature for giving false
information, the employer may take notice of special
circumstances of the case, if any, while giving such
information.
38.3. The
consideration
employer
shall
the
take
into
government
orders/instructions/rules, applicable to the employee,
at the time of taking the decision.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
38.4. In case there is suppression or false
information of involvement in a criminal case where
conviction or acquittal had already been recorded
before filling of the application/verification form and
such fact later comes to knowledge of employer, any
of the following recourses appropriate to the case
may be adopted:
38.4.1. In a case trivial in nature in which
conviction had been recorded, such as shouting
slogans at young age or for a petty offence which if
disclosed would not have rendered an incumbent
unfit for post in question, the employer may, in its
discretion, ignore such suppression of fact or false
information by condoning the lapse.
38.4.2. Where conviction has been recorded in
case which is not trivial in nature, employer may
cancel candidature or terminate services of the
employee.
38.4.3. If acquittal had already been recorded
in a case involving moral turpitude or offence of
heinous/serious nature, on technical ground and it is
not a case of clean acquittal, or benefit of reasonable
doubt has been given, the employer may consider all
relevant facts available as to antecedents, and may
take appropriate decision as to the continuance of
the employee.
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
38.5. In a case where the employee has made
declaration truthfully of a concluded criminal case,
the
employer
still
has
the
right
to
consider
antecedents, and cannot be compelled to appoint the
candidate.
38.6. In case when fact has been truthfully
declared in character verification form regarding
pendency
of
a
criminal
case
of
trivial
nature,
employer, in facts and circumstances of the case, in
its discretion, may appoint the candidate subject to
decision of such case.
38.7. In a case of deliberate suppression of
fact with respect to multiple pending cases such false
information by itself will assume significance and an
employer may pass appropriate order cancelling
candidature or terminating services as appointment
of a person against whom multiple criminal cases
were pending may not be proper.
38.8. If criminal case was pending but not
known to the candidate at the time of filling the
form, still it may have adverse impact and the
appointing
authority
would
take
decision
after
considering the seriousness of the crime.
38.9. In case the employee is confirmed in
service, holding departmental
enquiry
would
be
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
necessary
before
passing
order
of
termination/removal or dismissal on the ground of
suppression
or
submitting
false
information
in
verification form.
38.10. For determining suppression or false
information attestation/verification form has to be
specific, not vague. Only such information which was
required to be specifically mentioned has to be
disclosed. If information not asked for but is relevant
comes to knowledge of the employer the same can
be
considered
in
an
objective
manner
while
addressing the question of fitness. However, in such
cases action cannot be taken on basis of suppression
or submitting false information as to a fact which was
not even asked for
38.11. Before
a
person
is
held
guilty
of
suppressio veri or suggestio falsi, knowledge of the
fact must be attributable to him.”
13.
The High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan,
Jodhpur Bench in the case of Neeraj Kanwar Vs. State of
Rajasthan and others2 (Neeraj Kanwar), at paragraph
No.31, placing reliance upon the decision of the Avatar
Singh, stated supra has held at paragraph No.31 as under:
2025:RJ-JD:13298
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
“31. Ever otherwise, one ought to be mindful
that the youth need a reformative approach to the
indiscretions committed in heat of the moment,
which may or may not be intentional. Societal and so
should the legal perspective be, of course depending
upon
the
nature
of
delinquency,
that
youthful
indiscretions should not permanently tarnish an
individual's future. A compassionate and reformative
approach ought to be adopted when dealing with
young individuals who may have committed minor
transgressions. Young people are still in the process
of emotional and intellectual development. They
often act impulsively, sometimes making decisions
that are not well thought out. A punitive approach
that
permanently
brands
young
individuals
as
criminals for relatively minor mistakes contradicts
the principles of justice/fairness, recidivism and
reformation and reintegration into society.”
14.
The High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and
Ladakh, at Jammu, in the case of Union Territory of
Jammu and Kashmir Vs. Arsam Imtyaz Malik3 (Arsam)
has held at paragraph No.19, 20 and 21 as under:
W.P.(C)No.289/2025 CM.No.578/2025 dated 17.02.2025.
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
“19. The Apex Court in a case titled “Pawan
Kumar Vs. Union of India” reported as (2023) 12
SCC 317 held that mere suppression of material
information or furnishing of false information in a
given case does not mean that the employer can
arbitrarily
discharge/terminate
employee,
while
following the law laid down in its earlier judgment in
a case titled “Avtar Singh Vs. Union of India”
reported
as
(2016)
SCC
wherein
while
summarizing the conclusion, a three Judge Bench of
the Apex Court had laid down broad guidelines which
have
to
be
taken
note
of
by
the
appointing/competent authority in dealing with the
matters where there is suppression of material
information or disclosure of false information and
after reconciling the earlier judgments succinctly
summarized the conclusions as under:
34. No doubt about it that verification of
character and antecedents is one of the important
criteria to assess suitability and it is open to
employer to adjudge antecedents of the incumbent,
but ultimate action should be based upon objective
criteria on due consideration of all relevant aspects.
35.
Suppression
of
„material‟
information
presupposes that what is suppressed that „matters‟
not every technical or trivial matter. The employer
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
has to act on due consideration of rules/instructions
if any in exercise of powers in order to cancel
candidature
or
for
terminating
the
services
of
employee. Though a person who has suppressed the
material information cannot claim unfettered right for
appointment or continuity in service but he has a
right not to be dealt with arbitrarily and exercise of
power
has
to
be
in
reasonable
manner
with
objectivity having due regard to facts of cases.
36. What yardstick is to be applied has to
depend upon the nature of post, higher post would
involve more rigorous criteria for all services, not
only to uniformed service. For lower posts which are
not sensitive, nature of duties, impact of suppression
on suitability has to be considered by concerned
authorities considering post/nature of duties/services
and power has to be exercised on due consideration
of various aspects.
37.
The
„McCarthyism‟
is
antithesis
to
constitutional goal, chance of reformation has to be
afforded
to
young
offenders
in
suitable
cases,
interplay of reformative theory cannot be ruled out in
toto nor can be generally applied but is one of the
factors
to
be
taken
into
consideration
while
exercising the power for cancelling candidature or
discharging an employee from service.
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
20. Since the respondent, who had been
appointed as an MTS (Class IV), the question is
whether his service can be terminated on the ground
of a pendency of a criminal case. Unless a person is
held guilty by conviction in a trial held by a court, the
presumption of his innocence has to be construed as
a basic principle of criminal jurisprudence. Merely
involvement in a criminal case when the trial is still
underway is not a mirror to reflect the character and
antecedents of a person. The Apex Court in a case
titled as “State of Gujarat & Anr Vs. Suryakant
Chunilal Shah” reported as 1999(1) SCC 529 has
made following observations regarding involvement
in a criminal case on the basis of an FIR:
“The involvement of a person in criminal case
does not mean that he is „guilty‟. He is still to be
tried in court of law and the truth has to be found out
ultimately by the court where the prosecution is
ultimately conducted.”
21. Needless to mention that if a deserving
person is denied appointment then even if later on
he is acquitted by the trial court, there is very little
scope for him to get the Government employment.
The pendency of a criminal case cannot be construed
as an impediment in appointment and performance
of duties by such person.”
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
15.
The High Court of Delhi in the case of Vikas
Nagar Vs. Union of India and others4 (Vikas Nagar) has
held at paragraph Nos.3 and 4 as under:
“3. In the present case, as has been noted in
our Order dated 03.10.2024, the criminal case has
arisen out of a matrimonial dispute between the
petitioner and his wife. The proceedings in the said
criminal case have been stayed by the High Court of
Judicature
at
Allahabad vide its
23.02.2024
referred
Order
hereinabove.
The
dated
petitioner
cannot be made to suffer a punishment when the
criminal case is yet to be adjudicated. We do not
need to emphasise that in the matters of public
employment,
the
opportunity
does
not
come
repeatedly and may never come for the petitioner
again. The petitioner has been successful in obtaining
the employment with the CISF based on his own
merit and qualification. In case, the petitioner is not
allowed to join, subject to the pendency of the
criminal
case,
the
petitioner
may
lose
this
opportunity for all times to come and this loss would
never be compensated. On the other hand, in case
he is eventually found guilty, the balance can be
struck by making his appointment subject to the
outcome of the criminal case and, in that event,
2024 SCC Online Del 8162
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
directing that he would be terminated from service
without any notice or following the rigours of an
inquiry.
4. We, therefore, dispose of this petition by
setting aside the impugned letter dated 03.09.2024,
issued by respondent no.2. The petitioner shall be
allowed to join the post of Constable DCPO in the
CISF subject to the outcome of the criminal case,
that is, Case No.6431/2023 arising out of the FIR
No.322/2023 dated
Police
Station
30.08.2023,
Nakhasa,
District
registered
Sambhal
at
(Uttar
Pradesh) under Sections 376 / 377 / 354 / 364 / 511
/ 323 / 504 / 506 / 452 of the Indian Penal Code,
1860, and pending before the Competent Court at
Sambhal.
In
case
the
petitioner
is
eventually
convicted in that case, the respondents shall be free
to terminate the services of the petitioner, without
the petitioner having any equity in his favour due to
this Order or his service rendered in the interim. We
further clarify that the petitioner shall not be entitled
for any service benefits for the service that is
rendered by him, in case of his conviction, except for
the pay that he has earned for that period.”
16.
The Delhi High Court said that the proceedings in
the said criminal case has been stayed by the appellate
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
court and gives a rider clause saying that eventually if it is
convicted in that case, the respondent shall be at liberty to
terminate
the
services
of
the
petitioner
without
the
petitioner having any equity in his favour due to this order
or the service rendered in the interim.
17.
From the decisions stated supra, the law is well
settled that pendency of a criminal case by itself cannot be
a disqualification of her appointment to government service.
Moreover, when the law holds that until the person is been
convicted in any criminal case continues to enjoy the
presumption of innocence. The Candidate cannot be denied
public employment merely on the basis of pendency of a
criminal case without conviction.
18.
In this case, inter-se matrimonial dispute is there
between the parties and not a case of moral turpitude,
dishonesty or any other relating to his employment or
service conditions. Having regard to the same, for the
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
foregoing reasons, the point frame for consideration is
answered and this Court pass the following:
ORDER
i.
The writ petition is allowed.
ii.
The
impugned
communication
dated
17.03.2023 passed by respondent No.2
withdrawing the petitioner's appointment
dated 02.11.2022 to the post of Assistant
Professor, Grade-I, Chemistry is hereby
quashed.
iii.
The withdrawal of appointment cannot be
constituted as valid, as the pendency of a
criminal case arising out of the matrimonial
dispute in the absence of any statutory
qualification
under
the
Institute
of
Technology Act, 1961 and Section 19 read
with Section C, clause 16(a) and (b) of the
first statute of IIT Dharwad 2017 cannot be
constituted a valid ground for withdrawal of
the appointment.
iv.
It is clarified that the criminal proceedings
pending against the petitioner being of a
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC-D:1686
WP No. 102329 of 2023
HC-KAR
personal and a matrimonial nature shall not
be
a
ground
to
disqualification
or
service
shall
nor
be
for
treated
as
a
discontinuous
in
they
prejudice
to
petitioner's service career.
v.
The petitioner by way of an interim order of
this Court dated 13.04.2023 has been
appointed. The respondent is directed to
continue the services of the petitioner as
the Assistant Professor Grade-I and he
would be entitled for all the benefits arising
therefrom.
Sd/JUSTICE K.S.HEMALEKHA
AT/EM
Ct:VH
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 28
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review