Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
PIL No.18/2019 with
MC (PIL) No.5/2022
Heard on: 21.11.2022
Date of Judgment: 24.11.2022
Shri Lawyerson War
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & ors
Jrop Singh Nongkhlaw & ors
Vs.
Lawyerson War
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
:
For the Respondents :
Ms. S. Alam, Adv with
Mr. S. Dey, Adv
Mr. S. Deb, Adv
Ms. C.B. Lalrinawmi, Adv
Mr. A. Kumar, Advocate General with
Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl.Sr.GA
Ms. S. Laloo, GA
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. A. Pradhan, Adv
Appearance:
For the Applicants
:
Mr. K. Paul, Sr.Adv with
Mr. S. Chanda, Adv
For the Respondent :
Mr Ms. S. Alam, Adv with
Mr. S. Dey, Adv
Mr. S. Deb, Adv
Ms. C.B. Lalrinawmi, Adv
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
Hon’ble, the Chief Justice:
At the outset it must be recorded that there has been a
considerable twist in the matter, in the sense that the perceived original
grievance bears little resemblance to the ultimate bone of contention.
2.
When this petition, filed in public interest, was received, the
Court was minded to entertain the same on the ground that a valuable
mineral and natural resource, which this idyllic State tucked away in one
corner of the vast country was endowed with, was sought to be willy-nilly
squandered without a care for tomorrow. The premise on which this
Court found an element of public interest in the matter was the manner in
which limestone was being permitted to be quarried in the State and the
resultant likelihood of the imminent depletion of its finite resources. The
fundamental premise remains unaltered though there has, undoubtedly,
been a twist in the tale.
3.
Keeping the basic grievance – of the rapid depletion of limestone
deposits in the State – in mind, the course that this petition has charted
over the last six months or so may be noticed from the orders passed
herein. The petition was received and progressed for nearly three years in
rather timid fashion till it appeared to spring to life with an order made
on April 5 this year. It must be acknowledged that for most of the
interregnum an invisible virus and the several lockdowns that it brought
in its wake disrupted Court activities as it, indeed, threw life across the
globe into disarray like never before.
4.
The order dated April 5, 2022 noticed that documents relied upon
by the petitioner revealed that an amendment had been brought about in
the Meghalaya Minor Minerals Concession Rules, 2016 on January 29,
2018 with what appeared to be a disingenuous design to facilitate illegal
quarrying and mining. In the backdrop of the wanton illegal mining of
coal that remained unchecked till orders of the National Green Tribunal
and the Supreme Court beginning 2016 came to be made, it was a serious
issue. Indeed, it was a matter that alarmed the Court, particularly since
around the same time it came to the notice of this Court that despite the
strict orders of the NGT and the Supreme Court pertaining to illegal coalmining, the State had done little to implement the same and there were
reports of tragic deaths caused by rathole-mining pouring in from several
parts of the State.
5.
To continue with the order dated April 5, 2022, the Court found
that a new definition was added to the Rules of 2016 by introducing, inter
alia, clause (u) to define the word “incidental”:
“(u) “incidental” in the context of extraction of minor minerals
means such an unintended extraction which arises out of nonPage 3 of 30
mining activities such as construction of roads or other major
infrastructural projects.”
6.
This Court observed in the relevant order that the definition was
not exhaustive and it only referred to certain activities like construction
of roads and other major infrastructural projects as falling within the
meaning of “incidental extraction” of minor minerals, but the definition
deliberately left it open to interpretation and application in other cases.
This Court observed that a person may dig deep in his ground to extract
some minor minerals and claim to have “incidentally” extracted the same
while preparing the ground for cultivation. To boot, the Court relied on
an official list that showed wanton plundering of limestone by
euphemistically referring to it as “incidental” extraction and the
Administration endorsing such activity.
7.
At the same time, the Court noticed that though the Rules
pertaining to transportation of minerals had not been altered, yet
“incidental challans” came to be issued for minor minerals that had been
“incidentally” extracted in terms of the definition of “incidental”
introduced as Rule 2(u) of the said Rules of 2016. This Court recorded
that the petitioner’s response to queries made under the Right to
Information Act, 2005 revealed that though Rule 2(u) pertaining to
“incidental” extraction of minor minerals was incorporated in 2018, it
was only by a notification of January 19, 2021 that Rule 26 of the said
Rules of 2016 was amended to incorporate sub-rule (4) pertaining to the
transportation of minor minerals “incidentally” extracted.
8.
A chart relied upon by the petitioner on the basis of information
obtained under the RTI Act enumerated more than hundred cases of large
amounts of minor minerals having been “incidentally” extracted in the
State. The order dated April 5, 2022 recorded three of the instances where
amounts as much as 99,061 MT, 42,907 MT and 34,621 cubic metre of
limestone, were said to have been “incidentally” extracted in course of
construction of a farmhouse, a residential pathway and paving the way to
a paddy field, respectively. The relevant order observed that there were
several such instances of large scale “incidental” extraction of limestone
without the relevant extraction being in course of any construction of any
road or of any infrastructural project. An apparent nexus between illegal
coal-mining and “incidental” extraction of limestone was also noticed in
a list issued by the Divisional Forest Officer of the Jaintia Hills Territorial
Division, Jowai, a region which has seen rampant illegal coal-mining that
prompted suo motu proceedings to be initiated by this Court.
9.
The order lamented that it was only the Forest Department of the
State which was entrusted with the matter of monitoring licences and
permits under the said Rules of 2016 without there being any separate
specialised authority in such regard. This Court assessed that tens of
crores of rupees in revenue may have been lost to the State, in the State
sponsoring the illegal extraction of minor minerals by tweaking the
definition provision and including “incidental” within its fold without
following it up by maintaining any check or balance as to how the
“incidentally” extracted limestone or minor mineral had been obtained or
was being transported or dealt with. A detailed report was called for.
10.
The time to receive the State’s report in terms of the order dated
April 5, 2022 was enlarged by an order of April 25, 2022 and the matter
was taken up in right earnest next on May 6, 2022.
11.
The relevant order recorded that the State had filed an action
taken report and that several amendments had been made to the Rules of
2016 to plug the loopholes that existed therein. The substantive part of
the rest of the order needs to be seen to appreciate how the matter may
have taken a slightly different trajectory thereafter:
“While it is appreciated that the State makes a clean breast of the
earlier mistakes in the said Rules of 2016, the petitioner maintains
that the illegal mining of limestone continues unabated even
though the State has no authority to grant any permission for any
limestone quarrying since limestone is a major mineral and, only
in the exceptional case when limestone is used in kilns for
manufacturing of lime as building material, would limestone be
regarded as a minor mineral. According to the petitioner, on the
basis of the permits or permissions issued or granted by the State,
influential persons are carrying on regular business in limestone
and selling the limestone to parties in Bangladesh or even to
cement manufacturers in Meghalaya and nearby States.
“Since the allegation of limestone being extracted and openly sold
with State permission has not been squarely levelled in the
original petition, it will be open to the petitioner to use a
supplementary affidavit to indicate the petitioner’s perception as
to the present position in such regard.
“In the meantime, whether or not the loopholes have been
plugged as submitted by the State, the State should ensure that no
extraction of limestone is permitted without obtaining appropriate
sanction under the Mines and Minerals (Development and
Regulation) Act, 1957.”
12.
After the matter meandered through several adjournments to
receive the petitioner’s supplementary affidavit and the State’s response
thereto, it came to be substantially heard on June 23, 2022 when the
petitioner produced a copy of a challan pertaining to limestone mining
that the petitioner claimed brought the irregularities in such regard to
light. By the order made on June 23, 2022, the petitioner was required to
disclose the relevant challan and the connected documents by way of an
affidavit without being obliged to indicate the source of obtaining the
challan. The State was called upon to confirm whether the copy
documents were authentic. The petitioner’s contention was also recorded
that challans of the kind produced in Court were being used by persons
to cite the same as a licence to export limestone to a neighbouring
country, though the licence issued was in respect of a minor mineral.
13.
The Court noticed that a licence for mining limestone as a minor
mineral may only be issued if the end-use of the product is as a building
material. A prima facie view was also expressed by the Court in the
following words:
“Surely, exporting the goods to another country will not amount
to the mineral being used for building material even if the same
were used for building material in the other country.”
14.
The order called for a further affidavit from the State to deal with
such aspect of the matter upon ascertaining whether any licence issued to
any person for mining limestone as a minor mineral was being misused
by exporting the mined mineral to any country.
15.
The State’s comprehensive affidavit in such regard came to be
filed on or about August 17, 2022. Such affidavit, inter alia, appended
copies of notifications issued by the Union on June 1, 1958, September
12, 1961, August 23, 1989 and February 10, 2015. In addition, the State
relied on a letter issued by it on July 18, 2022 to the Ministry of Mines,
Government of India and the response thereto of July 25, 2022. Following
the Union’s response of July 25, 2022, the State put a query to the
Directorate-General of Foreign Trade and received a response thereto on
August 11, 2022. In effect, the entire thrust of the matter moved from the
original grievance of “incidental” extraction of minor minerals to the
misuse of the minor mineral licence for limestone granted by the State by
the licensees not adhering to the end-use thereof. Not only did the Court
ensure that supplementary affidavits to bring the somewhat altered case
were on record, but also afforded the State full opportunity to deal with
the matter squarely, which the State did by filing the said affidavit on
August 17, 2022.
16.
Before returning to the State’s justification for issuing minor
mineral licences to persons exporting limestone, a further order of this
Court of September 7, 2022 and the effect of such order may first be seen.
17.
The order dated September 7, 2022 referred to the response by the
Union Ministry of Mines to the State’s query of July 18, 2022. The
second paragraph of the Union’s response of July 25, 2022 was quoted
thus in the relevant order:
“2. The matter has been examined in the Ministry. It is informed
that the Central Government in exercise of the powers conferred
under Section 3(e) of the MMDR Act has issued notifications
no.MII-159(18)-54-A-II dated 01.06.1958 and MII-169(40)/58
dated 12.09.1961 read with notification no.GSR786(E) dated
23.08.1989, vide which it was declared that “kankar and
limestone when used in kilns for manufacture of lime used as
building material” is a minor mineral.”
18.
The order of September 7, 2022 proceeded to record the
petitioner’s apprehension that limestone used for any purpose other than
for manufacturing lime to be used as a building material was illegal if a
minor mineral licence had been issued in such regard. The State made
no bones of the fact that a substantial part of the limestone mined in the
State pursuant to minor mineral licences was exported. The State
submitted that considerable revenue was earned by the State as a result.
19.
In the light of the issue which arose, the order dated September 7,
2022 went on to observe as follows:
“However, as observed in a previous order in the present
proceedings, when a mineral is exported, the end-use of such
mineral, as far as this country or the place where it is mined is
concerned, would be the export and not how the material is used
in the country of import. This is because neither this country nor
the State where the mineral originates will have any control as to
the use of the mineral once it is exported to the importing country.
The word “end-use” used in the relevant memorandum of July 25,
2022 must be seen to be end-use with reference to how the
mineral is dealt with within the territorial limits of this country.
“There may not be any difficulty in the matter since limestone
may still be mined, for export purpose, as a major mineral. The
State has only to be mindful of any minor mineral mining license
not being misused by the licensees to extract limestone for the
purpose of export thereof. If the end-use is export, the limestone
mined will be regarded as a major mineral and a completely
different license and control regime has to be adopted for such
purpose.
“Let the matter appear a fortnight hence for the State to respond
and make alternative arrangements, if deemed fit.”
20.
The matter was next taken up on November 1, 2022 when the
State submitted that it had challenged some of the orders passed in the
present proceedings before the Supreme Court, including the
interpretation given by this Court pertaining to the end-use of limestone.
Meanwhile, the petitioner complained that notwithstanding previous
orders in these proceedings, in effect, restraining minor mineral licensees
from exporting limestone to a neighbouring country, the State had
continued issuing minor mineral licences for such purpose in the
interregnum. The matter was directed to appear next on November 15,
2022.
21.
On such next appointed day, the matter was taken up and the State
produced a copy of an order dated November 11, 2022 passed by the
Supreme Court on petitions for special leave to appeal carried before it.
The relevant part of the Supreme Court order of November 11, 2022 as
extracted in the order of November 15, 2022 reads thus:
“In our considered view, it is not necessary for us to go into the
merits of the issues involved in these matters, as the main PIL No.
18 of 2019, is still pending adjudication before the High Court of
Meghalaya at Shillong.
“Keeping this fact in view, we deem it appropriate to direct that
the impugned Order dated 7-9-2022 passed by the High Court,
shall remain in abeyance and be not given effect to, till the main
case vis. PIL No. 18 of 2019 is decided by the High Court.
“Owing to the nature of controversy, we request the High Court
to decide the PIL at the earliest and preferably within a period of
three months, reckoned from the date of communication of a copy
of this Order.
22.
After noticing the Supreme Court order of November 11, 2022,
this Court’s order of November 15, 2022 referred to the circumstances in
which the order of September 7, 2022 came to be passed and the relevant
interpretation rendered. The Court also observed that there was no
prohibition on the State to act in accordance with law and ensure that
exporters of limestone obtained licence as a major mineral in accordance
with law. It was also recorded that several minor minerals licensees of
limestone had filed special leave petitions without applying before this
Court. At the same time, since the notifications issued by the Union
required interpretation, learned Deputy Solicitor-General of India was
requested to represent the Union at the final hearing fixed on November
21, 2022.
23.
At such final hearing on November 21, 2022, quite expectedly, an
application came through from one of the minor mineral licensees of
limestone to express such licensee’s point of view. Such licensee, the
applicant in Misc. Case No.5 of 2022, has been heard along with the
petitioner and the State though Counsel for the Union had not obtained
any instructions.
24.
According to the petitioner, the export of limestone cannot be
made if it has been quarried on the strength of a minor mineral licence as
the end-use of the mineral would not be in conformity with the prevailing
notification issued by the Union in such regard. The petitioner also relies
on judgments reported at (1975) 1 SCC 627 (Rukmani Bai Gupta v. State
Government of Madhya Pradesh) and (1976) 2 SCC 911 (Gorelal Dubey
v. State of Madhya Pradesh) to emphasise on what the expression “enduse” would mean in the context of limestone being mined under a minor
mineral licence.
25.
Lamentably, a hopeless case on behalf of the State has been
obstinately pursued without any element of reason justifying the State’s
conduct. Indeed, as has been appropriately pointed out on behalf of the
petitioner, the State’s own Rules of 2016 make it more difficult for the
State to justify the end-use of limestone for export when a minor mineral
licence is granted for its quarrying. The Rules of 2016, in such regard
refer to “Limestone of any grade” which is a higher case than the mere
use of “limestone” in the notifications issued by the Union.
26.
The State’s specious ground for allowing limestone to be
exported under minor mineral licences for quarrying thereof is that there
is no express bar to the export of the mineral in any of the notifications
issued by the Union. The State’s second line of argument is that under
Section 15 of the Act of 1957, the State has full authority over and in
respect of minor minerals. The State’s equally facetious third limb of
contention is that despite its detailed query of July 18, 2022 indicating
the steps taken by the State and the use of limestone quarried under minor
mineral licences issued by the State, a rather terse reply emanated from
the Union without so much as an observation that the State was wrong.
The final leg of the State’s absurd stand is in its reliance on a stray line in
a Supreme Court judgment that cannot be regarded as a part of the ratio
decidendi in the matter or even as an obiter dictum. Remarkably, the cat
slips out of the bag when the State submits that it grants minor mineral
licence for quarrying limestone at the rate of Rs.280/- or so per unit as
against the rate prescribed by the Union of about Rs.150/- or thereabouts
per unit as a major mineral. The State asserts that even the prescribed rate
for a major mineral would go to the State coffers, but only that it would
be a reduced revenue. The State also acknowledges that additional
considerations may come into play when it comes to granting a major
mineral licence for quarrying or mining limestone.
27.
It is here that the tragedy really lies that a State government, no
less, would subvert the law and act contrary to the constitutional scheme
of things to consciously do something not within its authority, only for
the purpose of augmenting its revenue. Even if the additional revenue
generated is regarded to be for the benefit of the State, the ends do not
justify the means.
28.
Now to return to the cases cited by the petitioner, to the extent
they are apposite in the present context. In the case of Rukmani Bai
Gupta, the distinction between minor minerals and major minerals in the
context of the Act of 1957 fell for consideration. At this stage, it may do
well to see Sections 3(e) and 15(1) of the Act of 1957:
3. Definitions.– In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,
–
(e) “minor minerals” means building stones, gravel, ordinary
clay, ordinary sand other than sand used for prescribed purposes,
and any other mineral which the Central Government may, by
notification in the Official Gazette, declare to be a minor mineral;
…
15. Power of State Governments to make rules in respect of
minor minerals.– (1) The State Government may, by notification
in the Official Gazette, make rules for regulating the grant of
quarry leases, mining leases or other mineral concessions in
respect of minor minerals and for purposes connected therewith.
(1A) …”
29.
By an amendment of 1986, sub-section (1A) has been
incorporated in Section 15 of the Act to prescribe, without prejudice to
the generality of the power conferred under sub-section (1), rules to be
made by State governments for certain matters. However, the remainder
of Section 15 of the 1957 Act apart from sub-section (1) thereof, may not
be relevant for the immediate discussion.
30.
The following passage from paragraph 8 of the judgment in
Rukmani Bai Gupta is instructive in the present assessment:
“8. … Formerly limestone used for burning for manufacture of
lime, whatever may be the uses to which such lime may be put,
whether as building material or for other purposes, was within the
definition of ‘minor mineral’, but after the amendment, it was
only limestone used for burning in kilns for manufacture of lime
used as building material that was covered by the definition of
minor mineral. When limestone is used for burning for
manufacture of lime for industrial or sophisticated purposes
otherwise than as building material, it would have to be of
superior quality and hence after the amendment, it was classified
as major mineral, leaving only limestone used for burning in kilns
for manufacture of lime used as building material to be regarded
as minor mineral. But in both cases, whether under the original
notification or the amended notification, limestone was
contemplated to be used for burning for manufacture of lime. The
only difference was that in the former, burning could be by any
means or process and lime manufactured could be for any purpose
including building material, while in the latter, burning could be
only in the kilns and for manufacture of lime used only as building
material and for no other purpose. …”
31.
The discussion above pertains to the amendment made in the
original notification of June 1, 1958 by the subsequent notification of
September 12, 1961 (erroneously referred to in the judgment as of
September 20, 1961). Both notifications are relied upon by the State in
its affidavit of August 17, 2022.
32.
As per the original notification of 1958, for limestone to be
regarded as a minor mineral, it had to qualify thus: “limestone used for
lime burning”. By the subsequent notification of 1961, it was specified
that “kankar and limestone used in kilns for manufacture of lime used as
building material” shall stand substituted in place of “kankar and
limestone used for lime burning” in the previous notification of 1958.
33.
As held by the Supreme Court in Rukmani Bai Gupta, “kankar
and limestone used for lime burning” was rather expansive and it was
whittled down in the 1961 notification and made subject to the twin
conditions that such kankar and limestone would be used in kilns and
only for manufacture of lime used as building material for the kankar and
limestone to be regarded as a minor mineral. These twin conditions
attached to limestone for it being regarded as a minor mineral have
remained unchanged. By a notification of 2015 “limekankar” has been
recognised as a minor mineral without any conditions attached. However,
the present discussion is confined only to limestone and not extended to
either kankar or limekankar, though the same rules as limestone would
govern kankar in it being licensed as a minor mineral.
34.
The same view as in Rukmani Bai Gupta was echoed by the
Supreme Court in Gorelal Dubey in the following words at paragraph 10
of the report:
“10. … After the 1961 notification only that type of limestone
would be a minor mineral which is capable of being used for
burning in kilns for producing that quality of lime which can
ordinarily and generally be used as a building material.”
35.
The petitioner has also relied on two other judgments reported at
1986 (Supp) SCC 20 (D.K. Trivedi and Sons v. State of Gujarat) and
(2008) 5 SCC 772 (S.S. and Co. v. Orissa Mining Corporation Ltd) which
are not found to be relevant in the present context.
36.
The State, on the other hand, founds its completely illegitimate
course of action on a solitary line in a judgment reported at (2012) 4 SCC
629 (Deepak Kumar v. State of Haryana). The matter pertained to notices
issued by the State of Haryana proposing to auction the extraction of,
inter alia, minor minerals in certain districts and quarrying of minor
minerals and riverbeds. At paragraph 19 of the report, the Court noticed
the definition of “minor minerals” in Section 3(e) of the Act of 1957 and
the clarification in respect of “ordinary sand” in Rule 70 of the Mineral
Concession Rules, 1960 framed under the Act of 1957. In observing how
minerals had been classified as major and minor minerals, the following
sentence finds place at paragraph 19 of the report:
“19. … It may thus be observed that minerals have been classified
into major and minor minerals based on their end use rather than
level of production, level of mechanisation, export and import,
etc. …”
37.
The State seeks to rely on such observation for it to imply that the
end-use rule in the notifications issued under Section 3(e) of the Act of
1957 would not govern the proposed export of the minor mineral.
38.
Clearly, such argument is completely flawed and liable to be
rejected without further consideration. For a start, observations in orders
of Court are not to be read as enactments or edicts on stone. It is only the
ratio decidendi which is of paramount importance as that reflects the core
decision that has been rendered and which operates as a precedent. Even
obiter dictum of the Supreme Court does not operate with the same force
though it, obviously, commands high respect and is of great persuasive
value; but obiter dictum may not be the law declared by the Supreme
Court within the meaning of Article 141 of the Constitution. At any rate,
high authorities dating back over a century and endorsed repeatedly by
the Supreme Court, instruct that it is only what has been specifically
decided in a particular case that will operate as a precedent and not what
may appear to have been incidentally decided.
39.
With respect, the relevant sentence in Deepak Kumar must be
seen in the right perspective. It appears to be a casual sentence; or else
the word “import” could never have found a place therein since, in the
context of what is defined to be a minor mineral under the 1957 Act, the
concept of import is wholly inapposite.
40.
The other judgment carried by the State is even more tenuous in
its relevance to the present discussion and the issues involved herein. In
the judgment reported at (2004) 10 SCC 201 (State of WB v. Kesoram
Industries Ltd), paragraph 139 from the majority opinion is placed for its
reference to Section 15 of the Act of 1957 and recognition of the distinct
areas of operation of Entry 54 of List I in the Seventh Schedule to the
Constitution and Entry 23 of List II thereof. However, much time need
not be wasted on such aspect, particularly since the discussion in the
matter pertained to whether cess could be levied on royalty and, at any
rate, the legal question involved has now been referred to a larger Bench
in the Supreme Court.
41.
Entry 54 in List I of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution
provides thus:
“54. Regulation of mines and mineral development to the extent
to which such regulation and development under the control of
the Union is declared by Parliament by law to be expedient in the
public interest.”
Entry 23 of List II of the Seventh Schedule is clear in its wording:
“23. Regulation of mines and mineral development subject to the
provisions of List I with respect to regulation and development
under the control of the Union.”
42.
Thus, the extent of State’s authority under Entry 23 of List II is
subject to the extent to which regulation of mines and mineral
development under the control of the Union is declared by Parliament by
law. Apart from the express provision in Entry 23 of List II making the
field of its operation subservient to the corresponding entry in List I, the
general rules as enunciated in Articles 245 and 254 of the Constitution
create a limited scope for the State in respect of minor minerals as defined
in the Act of 1957. Section 15(1) confers requisite authority on the States
to grant quarry leases, mining leases or other mineral concessions in
respect of minor minerals and for purposes connected therewith, as long
as the regulation by the States is confined to minor minerals as defined in
the statute or other minor minerals declared as such by the Central
government by a notification in the Union gazette. Nothing in the
constitutional scheme of things or in terms of the said Act of 1957
circumscribes the Union’s authority to declare a mineral to be a minor
mineral in certain circumstances, whether based on its end-use or other
considerations. Since the Union has exercised its constitutional authority
by a law in such regard made by the Parliament as the Act of 1957, the
State’s field of operation is confined to minor minerals as defined or as
notified, together with the attendant conditions attached thereto.
43.
It is an entirely different matter that the State grants a minor
mineral licence keeping the twin conditions in mind, but there is a minor
aberration by the licensee in the end-use. The State may then take the
licensee to task. It may also happen that the licensee does not conform,
quite regularly, to the end-use condition and the matter does not come to
the notice of the State. In either case, it would not be the State’s fault as
long as the State has granted the minor mineral licence with the stipulated
conditions.
44.
But what is happening here is that the State is granting a minor
mineral licence without imposing the twin conditions attached to the use
of the limestone for it to be regarded as a minor mineral. The State here
is openly canvassing the export of limestone by licensees granted minor
mineral licences. Whether it is for the State’s revenue or for any other
more noble consideration, it does not matter. The State’s authority is only
to grant a minor mineral licence subject to the end-use of mineral as
specified. In the State allowing export of limestone upon granting a minor
mineral licence therefor, the State is acting in excess of the authority
available to it under the constitutional scheme and the mechanism
envisaged by the Act of 1957 and the notifications issued under Section
3(e) thereof.
45.
The authority available to a State, no less, has to be exercised
rationally and reasonably. It is completely irrational and totally uncalled
for, for the State to grant minor mineral licence for mining or quarrying
limestone when fully conscious that the end-use is otherwise than for
manufacture of lime used as a building material. Indeed, there is no
insurmountable problem here, as emphasised in the order of September
7, 2022. If the purpose of quarrying or mining limestone is the export
thereof, a major mineral licence has to be obtained for the purpose,
subject to the attendant formalities in such regard. The State cannot
subvert the mechanism put in place by a law of Parliament by openly
allowing limestone to be mined or quarried under a minor mineral licence
for it to be ultimately exported.
46.
In the context of the end-use as indicated in the notifications
issued by the Union, the end-use has, per force, to be completed within
the territory of India. Limestone quarried or mined under a minor mineral
licence may be used for the manufacture of lime used for building
material in the same State or in a State other than where the mineral
originates. At any rate, to the extent feasible, both the State and the minor
mineral licensee are obliged to give effect to the end-use condition in
such regard. There may be some minor seepage for which neither the
licensee nor the licensor may be pulled up; but the process cannot be
subverted in the manner it has been.
47.
As a matter of fact, the State itself makes a distinction between
the use of minor minerals in industry and the use of minor minerals other
than in industry. The State’s Rules of 2016 have carved out the two
separate schedules in such regard. When the State is as conscious in
making a distinction between the use of minor minerals in industry and
otherwise than in industry, the State allowing limestone to be exported
when quarried or mined under a minor mineral licence is completely
unacceptable and in abject derogation of the scheme of things under the
Act of 1957 and the State’s obligation in terms of the Constitution to
adhere thereto.
48.
When an end-use, as in the present context, is specified, the end-
use must be verifiable. As in the principle of E&OE in accounting, minor
aberrations may be excepted, but what comes to light here is Statesponsored subversion and a kind of misadventure that does not behove
its status.
49.
None of the grounds pressed into service by the State to justify its
conduct holds any water. It is true that the notifications issued by the
Central government do not expressly prohibit export, but that is quite
besides the point. There may be times when a definition or a formal
mandate is couched in words that indicate a sense of exclusivity or,
conversely, a sense of not being exhaustive. The distinction can be
understood by comparing the notifications of 1958, 1961 and 1989 on the
one hand and the notification of 2015 on the other. The same matter has
been refined and amended from what it read in the 1958 notification to
what it was altered to in the 1961 notification and what now applies in
terms of the 1989 notification. All three notifications carved out a
distinction as to whether the same mineral would be regarded as a major
mineral or as a minor mineral based on the specific condition of end-use
indicated therein. On the other hand, the 2015 notification indicates
several minerals which would fall in the category of minor minerals,
irrespective of any other consideration.
50.
When an exception is carved out in a category and specified, such
exception has to be regarded as exhaustive and not merely indicative.
Limestone, as in the present case, would be a minor mineral only if used
in kilns for manufacture of lime used as a building material. That would
imply that in all other situations limestone would have to be regarded as
a major mineral. The moment limestone is mined for the purpose of its
export, that would have to be on the basis of limestone in such a situation
being regarded as a major mineral.
51.
As to the State’s perceived complete authority over and in respect
of minor minerals, the issue has already been addressed; just as the
discussion hereinabove has also dealt with the State’s reliance on a stray
line in a Supreme Court judgment.
52.
Apropos the relevant Union Ministry’s terse reply to the State’s
letter of July 18, 2022, it must be said that the second paragraph of the
response of July 25, 2022 has said it all. The State and the Union are
partners in governance. It would not augur well for the Union to point an
accusatory finger at a State once the Union indicates the legal position on
the issue. Implicit in the Union’s response to the State’s query was the
assertion that the State may not have been mindful of its limited scope of
authority in view of the matter pertaining to the regulation of minerals
having been enacted upon by the Parliament. Similarly, the reply issued
by the DGFT to the State’s query would not imply that there is no
restriction on the export of limestone. The DGFT made it clear that such
export would be governed by any law in operation in such regard.
53.
A further point has been taken by the State as to the locus standi
of the petitioner and his motive to carry the matter to Court. When faulty
or flawed administrative functioning is brought to the knowledge of a
constitutional Court, the petitioner is treated as a mere informant as the
Court takes up cudgels on behalf of the citizens to test the conduct of the
State or the Union in a matter where the Court perceives there is an
element of public interest. The informant may be a felon, but it must be
remembered that the petitioner’s conduct is not on trial as much is the
conduct of the Union or any State in a matter of public interest.
Accordingly, the petitioner’s status or conduct is irrelevant in the present
case, once the petitioner has brought to the knowledge of the Court a
matter of public interest and the Court has entertained the same.
54.
In the light of the State’s admitted conduct, the future course of
action by the State will have to meet a higher test than was ordinarily
required. When limestone is permitted to be quarried or mined under a
minor mineral licence in the State, the State is now required to keep a
strict vigil on the end-use thereof and ensure that no part of it is exported
in any manner or form.
55.
PIL No.18 of 2019 is disposed of by directing the State to not
allow the export of limestone that is mined or quarried by persons under
a minor mineral licence by obtaining regular end-use certificates from the
licensees, verifying the same and presenting annual reports in such regard
for cross-verification by the office of the Accountant-General under the
aegis of the Comptroller and Auditor-General of India. This process will
continue for the next 10 years unless interdicted by an express order of a
competent Court.
56.
For the State’s conduct in the issuance of minor mineral licence
for limestone used for export thereof, the State will pay damages assessed
at Rs.2 crore which will go towards the purchase of additional equipment
for cancer treatment at the specialised unit therefor installed at the Civil
Hospital, Shillong. Again, the Accountant-General will audit and verify
the purchase of equipment exclusively from the damages awarded and
not from funds that may otherwise be made available by the State to the
relevant unit. Such money has to be put in by the end of January, 2023.
57.
In view of the State’s affidavits indicating that the loopholes that
had arisen upon the introduction of Rule 2(u) in the Rules of 2016 have
been plugged, the State is directed to ensure that large scale limestone
“incidentally” extracted is not dealt with without reference to the State.
The State should indicate, by formulating a rule in such regard, specifying
a much lower threshold of, say, up to 50 MT of minor mineral being
“incidentally” extracted; but any quantum in excess thereof, even if it is
“incidentally” extracted, would have to be made over to the State for the
State to deal with the same in accordance with law.
58.
At the end of the day, the State is in the position of a trustee
protecting the natural resources of the State in the interest of its people
and for their benefit. The rule would apply more strictly in this State
almost completely governed by the Sixth Schedule to the Constitution
where the land and the resources under the land have been recognised to
be the property of the tribes and its tribal folk. The State has a duty to
ensure the preservation of a precious natural resource for future
generations rather than exhaust the entire deposits over one or two
Assembly terms.
59.
A line may be expended in disposing of the application filed by a
minor mineral licensee being MC (PIL) No.5 of 2022. It is laughable that
a genuine limestone mining leasee engaged in exporting the mineral
would support the State’s cause, as the applicant has purported to do,
though obtaining a minor mineral licence costs the licensee much more
than obtaining a major mineral licence for the same purpose.
60.
MC (PIL) No.5 of 2022 is dismissed with costs assessed at
Rs.10,000/- to be paid to the Meghalaya State Legal Services Authority
within a fortnight from date.
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
I agree.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
Meghalaya
24.11.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review