Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~2 & 3
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of Decision: July 01st , 2026
+
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & CM APPL. 19251/2014
AIRPORTS AUTHORITY
OF INDIA
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Digvijay Rai, Mr. Archit
Mishra & Mr. Yatinder
Chaudhary, Advs.
versus
LATA DEVI
Through:
+
W.P.(C) 9787/2015
LATA DEVI
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Anuj Aggarwal, Ms. Tanya
Rose, Mr. Shubham Bahl, Ms.
Kritika Matta, Mr. Nikhil
Pawar, Ms. Bhumika Kundra,
Mr. Lovekesh Chauhan, Ms.
Anjali Bansal & Mr. Pradeep
Kumar, Advs.
.....Petitioner
Mr. Anuj Aggarwal, Ms. Tanya
Rose, Mr. Shubham Bahl, Ms.
Kritika Matta, Mr. Nikhil
Pawar, Ms. Bhumika Kundra,
Mr. Lovekesh Chauhan, Ms.
Anjali Bansal & Mr. Pradeep
Kumar, Advs.
versus
THE AIRPORT DIRECTOR, AIRPORT AUTHORITY OF
INDIA (AAI)
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Digvijay Rai, Mr. Archit
Mishra & Mr. Yatinder
Chaudhary, Advs.
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
AMIT MAHAJAN, J. (Oral)
1.
The present cross petitions are filed assailing award dated
13.12.2013 (hereinafter ‘impugned award’) passed by the learned
Central Government Industrial Tribunal (hereinafter ‘Tribunal’) in ID
No. 79/2000 whereby the learned Tribunal set aside the order of
discontinuation of service and directed reinstatement without back
wages.
2.
Briefly stated, the Respondent/ Smt. Lata Devi was engaged by
the ex-contractor of the Petitioner/Airport Authority of India, namely,
M/s Office Care Services and was working as a Sweeper at the Cargo
Terminal, IGI Airport.
3.
Consequent to the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court
in Air India v. United Labour Union : (1997) 9 SCC 377, the
Respondent was taken under the care of the Petitioner with effect from
01.02.1997 pending detailed scrutiny regarding eligibility for
regularisation.
4.
During scrutiny, certain alleged discrepancies were found in the
documents furnished by the Respondent, regarding the name of her
husband. In the affidavit dated 14.02.1997 the Respondent had
mentioned her husband’s name as Sh. Shanti (Shashruthi) Dass,
however, the name of her husband was reflected as Sh. Khushi Ram in
her ration card and election ID card.
5.
Accordingly, the services of the Respondent were discontinued
vide order dated 13.07.1998 on the premise that she had contracted a
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
dual marriage in violation of the applicable service regulations i.e.
International Airports Authority of India (General Conditions of
Service Regulations) 1980 which specifically provided that no person
who had entered into or contracted a marriage with any person having
a spouse living or who having a spouse living, has entered into or
contracted marriage with any person shall be eligible for employment
in the services of Airports Authority of India (International Airports
Division).
6.
Aggrieved thereby, the Respondent raised an industrial dispute
before the Regional Labour Commissioner (Central). Upon failure of
the conciliation proceedings in the said matter, the same was referred
to the Learned Tribunal vide order dated 24.09.1999.
7.
The learned Tribunal vide the impugned award dated 13.12.2013
set aside the order of discontinuation of service and ordered
reinstatement of the Respondent without back wages. The relevant
observations of the learned Tribunal are reproduced herein below:
“I have heard the arguments of Ld. A/R for the parties and perused
the pleadings and evidence of parties including written arguments
of workman as well as principles laid down in cited rulings on behalf
of workman and relevant provisions of law and settled law on the
relevant points.
It is relevant to mention here that management prior to stage of
evidence raised objection in the instant ID and three other Ids
showing those to be not maintainable in the light of principle laid
down by Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Steel Authority of India
vs. National Union Water Front Workers Labour and Industrial
Cases 2001 page 3656 decided on 30.08.2001 which was heard,
decided and rejected by me Ld. Predecessor by detailed order on
15.2.2002.
It is also relevant to mention here that after oral arguments A/R for
the management as well as any person on behalf of management is
not turning up to participate in the proceedings of the instant case
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
with an ulterior motive to prolong the proceedings of the instant old
ID No. 79/2000 since 11.10.13 so that only ex-parte award could be
passed against management. That could be with inordinate delay.
Management has not filed reply to written arguments of workman.
It is necessary to mention here that workman Lata Devi who was
casual worker on daily rated wages discontinued from services on
13.07.1998 on which date principles laid down by their Lordship
of Hon'ble Supreme Court in case AIR INDIA STATUTORY
CORPORATION ETC. VS. UNITED LABOUR UNION & ORS
1996 (9) SCALE, MCD VS. PRAVEEN KUMAR JAIN (1999)
LAB IC 619 and NAR SINGH PAL VS. UNION OF INDIA &
ORS 2000 LAB. IC 1377 were applicable in the instant case.
Reference of the instant ID was made on 24.9.1999. On which date
principle laid down by their Lordship of Hon'ble Supreme Court in
aforesaid case was the settled law of Hon'ble Supreme Court on the
point and the principle laid down by their Lordship of Hon'ble
Supreme Court on in case of Steel Authority of India Ltd vs.
National Union Water Front Workers reported in Labour and
Industrial Cases 2001 page 3656 at page 3696 was not applicable.
Which overruled the aforesaid judgment is inapplicable in the
instant case because prior to it management itself has adopted the
aforesaid principle of aforesaid judgment of Hon'ble Supreme
Court and regularized the other co-employees. In the instant case
management has not regularized the workman Lata Devi but
discontinued her on the count of alleged dual marriage without any
proof by way of evidence or enquiry etc.
Hence order of management is illegal and unjustified is liable to
be set aside and Reference is liable to be decided in favour of
workman and against management. Which is accordingly decided
in favour of workman and against management.
Workman Lata Devi is liable to be reinstated but without back wages
in want of her pleadings and evidence of back wages.
She is accordingly reinstated without back wages and management
is accordingly directed to reinstate Lata Devi without back wages
after expiry of period limitation of available remedy.
Award is accordingly passed.”
8.
Aggrieved thereby, the present cross petitions have been filed.
Smt. Lata Devi (Petitioner in W.P (C) 9787/2015), is aggrieved to the
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
limited extent that back wages were not awarded to her.
9.
This Court by order dated 28.11.2014, stayed the operation of the
impugned award.
10.
The learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner submits that the
impugned award is perverse and liable to be set aside.
11.
He submits that the Respondent had been employed by the ex
contractor of the Petitioner and no direct employer-employee
relationship ever existed between the parties.
12.
He submits that the learned Tribunal has wrongly applied the
dictum of the judgment in Air India (supra) even though the same has
been overruled by the judgment in SAIL v. National Union Waterfront
Workers, (2001) 7 SCC 1.
13.
He further submits that the Respondent, during her cross
examination before the learned Tribunal admitted that she never gave
any application for employment with the Petitioner and that she was an
employee of the ex-contractor.
14.
He submits that the learned Tribunal failed to take note of
multiple discrepancies in the statement of the Respondent and other
witnesses regarding the allegations of dual marriage against the
Respondent.
15.
He submits that since no employer-employee relationship existed
between the parties, the claim petition was not maintainable and the
Respondent was not entitled to reinstatement much less back wages as
claimed by the Respondent in her cross petition.
16.
Per Contra, the learned counsel representing the Respondent
submits that in terms of the judgment in Air India (supra) the
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
Respondent would be entitled to be treated as an employee of the
Petitioner and thus the Petitioner ought to have followed the appropriate
procedure before passing the order of discontinuation of service. Thus,
he submits that the learned Tribunal rightly set aside the order of
discontinuation of service.
17.
He further submits that Writ Petition (C) No. 9787/2015 is
confined to challenge the denial of back wages by the learned Tribunal
to Smt. Lata Devi, despite the fact that she had specifically pleaded that
she had remained unemployed post her termination and faced financial
hardship.
18.
I have heard both the parties and perused the material placed on
record.
19.
At the outset, it is necessary to note that the scope of interference
under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India with an Award
passed by the Labour Court is limited. Interference is warranted only
where the Award suffers from patent illegality, perversity or an error
apparent on the face of the record. The present Petition does not invite
this Court to re-appreciate the evidence or disturb findings of fact but is
confined to examining the legality and propriety of the relief granted by
the Labour Court.
20.
Adverting to the merits of the present case, the Respondent was
admittedly engaged as a Sweeper at the Cargo Terminal, IGI Airport,
through the ex-contractor of the Petitioner.
21.
Notably, the Central Government issued notification dated
09.12.1976 exercising its powers under Section 10(1) of the Contract
Labour (Regulation and Abolition) Act, 1970 (‘CLRA Act’) prohibiting
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
employment of contract labour on and from 09.12.1976 for sweeping,
cleaning, dusting and watching of buildings owned or occupied by the
establishments in respect of which the appropriate government under
the said act is the Central Government. It further provided that the same
shall not be applicable to the outside cleaning and other maintenance
operations of multi-storied buildings where such cleaning or
maintenance operation cannot be carried out except with specialized
experiences. The Hon’ble Apex Court in Air India (supra), discussed
the above notification and held that although the CLRA Act contains
no explicit provision for absorbing contract labour after a prohibition
under Section 10(1), such workers cannot continue as contract labour
once the prohibition takes effect. A direct employer–employee
relationship arises between the workers and the principal employer, as
the Act was not intended to deprive them of their livelihood. The Court
further held that where contract labour is engaged or continued in
violation of the Act, the High Court, in exercise of its jurisdiction under
Article 226, can grant appropriate relief including absorption. In his
concurring opinion, Justice Majmudar reasoned that abolition of
contract labour eliminates the intermediary contractor, leaving a direct
relationship between the workers and the employer. He concluded that
Section 10 implicitly reflects the legislative intent that, upon abolition,
former contract workers become direct employees of the establishment.
22.
Admittedly, consequent to the judgment passed by the Hon’ble
Apex Court in Air India (supra), the Respondent was taken under the
care of the Petitioner with effect from 01.02.1997 pending detailed
scrutiny regarding eligibility for regularisation. Thereafter, after finding
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
certain discrepancies in the documents of the Respondent regarding the
name of her husband. The Petitioner discontinued the service of the
Respondent in the year 1998 alleging dual marriage against her.
23.
During the pendency of the industrial dispute, the above
judgment was overruled in 2001 by the Constitution Bench of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Steel Authority of India (supra) and the
same was made applicable prospectively.
24.
Though much emphasis has been laid by the Petitioner on the fact
the judgment in Air India (supra), stood overruled and the benefit of
the same could not have been extended to the Respondent, it emerges
from the record that admittedly, the Petitioner and it’s management had
already adopted and even implemented the decision passed in the above
judgment of Air India (supra) and regularized about 50-60
sweepers/contract labourers i.e. co-employees. Thus, it has been rightly
observed by the learned Tribunal that once the Petitioner had already
adopted the said decision and accorded the benefit of the same to other
similarly placed employees it cannot later claim the same to be
inapplicable in the present case.
25.
Having adopted and implemented the judgment in Air India
(supra) by extending its benefit to similarly situated contract labourers,
the Petitioner could not have arbitrarily denied the same benefit to the
Respondent without any justifiable basis. Consequently, the contention
of the Petitioner that no relationship of employer and employee existed
between the parties cannot be sustained. Applying the ratio laid down
in Air India (supra) to the facts of the present case, the Respondent,
being a contract labourer engaged in an activity prohibited under the
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
notification issued under Section 10(1) of the CLRA Act, was rightly
treated as having a direct relationship of employer and employee with
the Petitioner during the period when the said judgment held the field.
26.
This Court is also in agreement with the observations passed by
the learned Tribunal that the management, without any explanation as
to why the same benefit ought not to be extended to the Respondent,
did not regularize the Respondent and rather discontinued her services
alleging a dual marriage without any cogent evidence/proof or even
holding an enquiry. Once the Respondent was treated as a direct
employee pursuant to the implementation of Air India (supra), her
services could not have been discontinued without following the
procedure prescribed under the Industrial Disputes Act and without
adhering to the principles of natural justice, particularly when the
discontinuation was founded upon the allegation of a bigamous
marriage which could not have been proved without cogent evidence.
Thus, the view adopted by the learned Tribunal is a plausible view as
regards the wrongful termination/discontinuation of the services of the
Respondent.
27.
However, be that as it may, this Court cannot lose sight of the
fact that mere finding of wrongful termination/discontinuation does not
by itself grant a right of reinstatement or back wages to the aggrieved
employee.
28.
It is trite law that a finding of illegality in termination does not,
by itself, mandate reinstatement in every case. The Hon’ble Apex Court
has repeatedly held that reinstatement is not an automatic or mechanical
consequence of an order of termination being held illegal and that the
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
relief must be moulded having regard to the nature of employment,
length of service and the surrounding circumstances of the case. In
Allahabad Bank v. Krishan Pal Singh : (2021) 19 SCC 227, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that reinstatement with full back
wages is not automatic in every case where termination or dismissal is
found to be not in accordance with the procedure prescribed under law
and that the relief can be moulded depending upon the facts and
circumstances of the case. The relevant extract of the same is
reproduced hereinbelow:
“8. The directions issued by the High Court of Allahabad for
reinstatement were stayed by this Court on 23-8-2019 [Allahabad
Bank v. Krishan Pal Singh, 2019 SCC OnLine SC 2061] . During
the pendency of these proceedings, the respondent workman had
attained age of superannuation. Though, there was strong suspicion,
there was no acceptable evidence on record for dismissal of the
workman. However, as the workman has worked only for a period
of about six years and he has already attained the age of
superannuation, it is a fit case for modification of the relief granted
by the High Court. The reinstatement with full back wages is not
automatic in every case, where termination/dismissal is found to be
not in accordance with procedure prescribed under law.
Considering that the respondent was in effective service of the Bank
only for about six years and he is out of service since 1991, and in
the meantime, respondent had attained age of superannuation, we
deem it appropriate that ends of justice would be met by awarding
lump sum monetary compensation. We accordingly direct payment
of lump sum compensation of Rs 15 lakhs to the respondent, within
a period of eight weeks from today. Failing to pay the same within
the aforesaid period, the respondent is entitled for interest @ 6%
p.a., till payment.”
29.
Similarly, the Hon’ble Supreme Court In Jagbir Singh v.
Haryana State Agriculture Mktg. Board : (2009) 15 SCC 327 clarified
that reinstatement with back wages is not automatic, and in appropriate
cases, compensation may be granted instead depending on the facts and
circumstance, relevant paragraph has been reproduced hereinunder: Signature Not Verified
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
“7. It is true that the earlier view of this Court articulated in many
decisions reflected the legal position that if the termination of an
employee was found to be illegal, the relief of reinstatement with
full back wages would ordinarily follow. However, in recent past,
there has been a shift in the legal position and in a long line of
cases, this Court has consistently taken the view that relief by way
of reinstatement with back wages is not automatic and may be
wholly inappropriate in a given fact situation even though the
termination of an employee is in contravention of the prescribed
procedure. Compensation instead of reinstatement has been held
to meet the ends of justice.”
30.
Hence, it is well crystallised that where the facts so warrant, the
Court is empowered to award monetary compensation in lieu of
reinstatement, in such cases where reinstatement is not feasible, and
where such relief of compensation would better serve the ends of
justice.
31.
This Court though upholds the finding of the learned Tribunal
that the discontinuation of the Respondent's services was illegal and
unjustified, however, cannot lose sight of the fact that the Respondent's
services came to be discontinued in the year 1998 and almost three
decades have elapsed thereafter. The Petitioner has also brought to the
notice of this Court that, as per the medical examination conducted in
the year 1993, the Respondent was found approximately 45 years old,
thereby implying that she would have attained the age of
superannuation in the years 2007–08, much prior to the passing of the
impugned Award in the year 2013. Be that as it may, undisputedly the
Respondent has currently surpassed the age of superannuation and
cannot be granted reinstatement at this stage.
32.
Though it has been urged that the Respondent be granted back
wages, since she remained unemployed due to her discontinuation from
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
service, the same cannot be accepted. As noted above, mere finding of
illegality in the discontinuation of service does not, by itself, entitle a
workman to back wages. Admittedly, the Respondent did not render
any service during the intervening period and has also failed to place
any material on record to establish that she remained unemployed after
the discontinuation of her services. In the absence of any evidence
regarding the same, no direction for payment of back wages can be
issued.
33.
Accordingly, while affirming the finding of the learned Tribunal
on the issue of illegality of the Respondent's discontinuation from
service, this Court is of the considered view that the relief granted by
the learned Tribunal warrants modification.
34.
In the opinion of this Court, in the facts and circumstances of the
present case, ends of justice will be met if the Respondent is awarded a
lump-sum compensation of ₹5,00,000/- in lieu of reinstatement. The
said amount shall be paid by the Petitioner within a period of eight
weeks from the date of this order.
35.
Accordingly, the petitions are disposed of in the aforementioned
terms. Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed.
36.
A copy of this order be placed in both the matters.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J
JULY 1, 2026
“SS”
Signed By:HARMINDER
W.P.(C) 8300/2014 & W.P.(C) 9787/2015
KAUR
18:01:41
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review