Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/lanxess-belgium-n-v-vs-union-of-india-20260707/ · Printed 21 Nov 2026
Civil

Lanxess Belgium N. V. vs Union of India

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Gujarat High Court
Date
7 July 2026
Case No.
SCA 8794/2026
Result
Dismissed
Bench
Honourable Mr. Justice A.s. Supehia, Honourable Ms. Justice Vaibhavi D. Nanavati
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

33. Thus, we are not inclined to interfere with the impugned final findings recorded by respondent No.2 and the Notification in exercise of our extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, particularly in the absence of any gross violation of the principles of natural justice, any violation of C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 the statutory provisions governing the process of law, or any lack of jurisdiction. Hence, the writ petition fails and the same is dismissed. The petitioner may avail of the remedy of filing an appeal impugned before the findings CESTAT, as well challenging as the the impugned Notification. Sd/. (A.S.SUPEHIA, J) Sd/. (VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI,J) Bhavesh-[PPS]* - Mahesh-[PS]* *** Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.

Filed under

Constitution of India Article 226, Constitution of India

The sections, explained

The law this judgment cites

Opens the section on Law Maker (lawmaker.in), our sister site for law students.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 Reserved On : 01/07/2026 Pronounced On : 07/07/2026 IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO.8794 of 2026 FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA Sd/and HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI Sd/========================================================= Approved for Reporting Yes No a ========================================================= LANXESS BELGIUM N. V. Versus UNION OF INDIA & ORS. ========================================================= Appearance: MR. MIHIR JOSHI, SENIOR ADVOCATE, WITH TANAY VYAS WITH SHAREEN GUPTA WITH MRINAL BHATNAGAR for the Petitioner MR ANKIT SHAH FOR MR PRADIP D BHATE for Respondents No.1-2 MR SAURABH SOPARKAR, SENIOR ADVOCATE, WITH MR. RAJESH SHARMA WITH GARGI R VYAS WITH SALONI JAIN for Respondent No.3 ========================================================= CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA and HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI CAV JUDGMENT (PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. SUPEHIA) 1. In Article the present of writ petition Constitution of filed under India, the petitioner has prayed for quashing and setting aside by questioning the legality and validity, of the Final Findings dated 20.03.2026, bearing Case No.AD(OI)-49/2024 and Impugned Notification No.11/2026-Customs (ADD) dated 19.06.2026. C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 BRIEF FACTS : 2. The petitioner is a Company incorporated under the laws of Belgium and the European Union, having its registered office at Haven 1992, Ketenislaan, 9130 Kallo, Belgium. The petitioner is, inter alia, engaged in the manufacture of Sulphenamides Accelerators, which constitute an essential input in the manufacture of rubber products. 3. It is the petitioner's case that the manufacture of the product under consideration is governed by the manufacturing standards, qualitycontrol prescribed Europe. protocols by its and commercial group company Consequently, the policies situated product in under consideration exported by the petitioner conforms to stringent European quality standards, resulting in a comparatively higher export price to India than the price at which the corresponding product is supplied by respondent No.3. 4. Respondent No.3 filed an application before respondent No.2 under Rule of the Customs Tariff (Identification, Assessment and Collection of Anti-Dumping Duty on Dumped Articles and for C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 Determination of Injury) Rules, 1995 ("the AntiDumping Rules"), alleging that the product under consideration was being dumped into India. 5. It is the petitioner's grievance that, without undertaking the mandatory pre-initiation scrutiny contemplated under the Anti-Dumping Rules or satisfying itself as to the accuracy, adequacy and sufficiency furnished by respondent proceeded to of No.3, initiate the information respondent the anti-dumping investigation solely on the application submitted by respondent issuing the Initiation basis of the No.3 by Notification dated 31.12.2024. According to initiation of investigation undertaken without proper verification of assertions and supporting material factual the the No.2 petitioner, the was thus the furnished by respondent No.3. 6. Pursuant to the issuance of the Initiation Notification, 10.02.2025, product respondent determined under No.2, the by Notice final consideration by scope of the adopting the Product Control Number (PCN) methodology. dated C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 SUBMISSIONS ON 7. Learned BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER : Senior Advocate Mr.Mihir Joshi submitted that respondent No.2 failed to disclose the working, computation, methodology and basis adopted for determining the exporter-specific dumping margin underlying and injury margin applicable to the petitioner. 8. While referring to Rule of the Anti- Dumping Rules, it is submitted that Rule 16 of the Anti-Dumping Rules mandates respondent No.2 to disclose the essential facts under consideration before recording the final findings so as to afford the interested parties a real, effective and meaningful opportunity to defend their interests. It is contended that the failure to disclose the detailed computation and working of the dumping margin and injury margin deprived the petitioner of the opportunity to identify and point out factual, methodological and computational errors before the issuance of the final recommendation, thereby vitiating the entire decision-making process on of account violation of the principles of natural justice. 9. Learned Senior Advocate referred to the Landed Value of imports and has contended that it C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 is lower for the imports originating from the People's Republic of China as compared to those originating from the European Union. It was contended that, under Rule 11 of the Anti-Dumping Rules read with Annexure-I and Annexure-II thereto, the Injury Margin is determined as the difference between the Non-Injurious Price (NIP) and the Landed Value of namely: Injury Margin = the imported goods, Non-Injurious Price (NIP)-Landed Value. It was submitted that where the Non-Injurious Price remains constant or is uniformly determined for the domestic industry, a lower Landed mathematical Value must, consequence, as result an inevitable in a higher Injury Margin, whereas a higher Landed Value must necessarily result in a correspondingly lower Injury Margin. 10. Reference is made to the provision of Section 9A(1) of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (for short “the Act”) read with Rule 17(1)(b) of the AntiDumping Rules, and it is submitted that the antidumping duty cannot exceed the margin of dumping and, in consonance recognised framework, under the duty with the lesser the Indian recommended duty rule anti-dumping is ordinarily C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 restricted to the lower - (i) the dumping margin, and (ii) the injury margin. It is submitted that the impugned final findings are ex-facie contrary to the statutory framework governing anti-dumping investigations. determine Section the Respondent export No.2 has in accordance price 9A of the Act read with Annexure-I to the Anti-Dumping failed Clause Rules, to with of thereby vitiating the determination of the dumping margin and, consequently, the entire exercise culminating into the impugned final findings. 11. It was further submitted that Rule 5(3) of the Anti-Dumping Rules embodies a mandatory jurisdictional pre-condition requiring respondent No.2, before investigation, initiating to an examine anti-dumping the accuracy and adequacy of the material placed before it so as to satisfy evidence itself exists that sufficient regarding – (i) prima facie dumping, (ii) injury to the domestic industry, and (iii) the causal nexus between the two. According to the learned advocate, the failure to undertake such mandatory scrutiny renders the very initiation of the investigation without jurisdiction vitiates all the consequential proceedings. and C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 12. Learned advocate for the petitioner placed reliance on the following judgments of the Apex Court in the cases of – (i) Reliance Industries Ltd. vs. 180]; Designated (ii) Authority, Automotive [2006 Tyre (9) TMI Manufacturers Association vs. Designated Authority, [2011 (1) TMI 7], wherein it has been held that final findings issued in violation of the prescribed statutory methodology and principles of natural justice are liable to be set aside. 13. According to the learned Senior Advocate for the petitioner, such an anomalous and irreconcilable outcome could arise only if there exists a fundamental error in the computation of the Landed Value, the determination of the NonInjurious Price, the calculation of the Injury Margin, or the application of the lesser duty rule. Any such error, it was submitted, strikes at the very determination foundation and renders of the impugned the final findings legally unsustainable. 14. With regard to resorting to the alternative remedy under Section 9C of the Act, it is contended that it does not operate as a bar to the exercise of the extraordinary jurisdiction of C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution, particularly when the impugned final findings have been rendered in flagrant violation of the principles of natural justice and in complete disregard to the mandatory procedure prescribed under the Customs Tariff Act and the Anti-Dumping Rules. It was submitted that the present case squarely falls within the well-recognised exceptions to the rule of alternative remedy as enunciated by the Apex Court Whirlpool Corporation vs. in the case Registrar of of Trademarks, Mumbai & Ors., (1999) 8 S.C.C. 1, and reiterated in paragraph No.27 of Radha Krishna Industries vs. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2021) 6 S.C.C. 771. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS : 15. Opposing the present petition and foregoing submissions, learned Senior Advocate Mr.Soparkar appearing for respondent No.3 and learned Senior Standing Counsel Mr.Ankit Shah, at the outset, have submitted that the present petition may not be entertained in view of availability of an efficacious alternative remedy to the petitioner of filing Section 9C an of appeal the under Act. the In provisions support of of the submissions, reliance is placed on the decision C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 of the Supreme Court in the case of Nitco Tiles Ltd. vs. Gujarat Ceramic Floor Tiles Manufacturer Association and Ors., (2005) 12 S.C.C. 454 and in the case of Designated Authority and others vs. SanDisk International Limited and Ors., (2018) 13 S.C.C. 402. They have also submitted that one of the parties i.e. Automotive Tyre Manufacturers Association, has already approached the Customs, Excise and CESTAT Tribunal, New Delhi, challenging the impugned final findings and the Notification, and, thus, it is urged that any observations made by this Court in the present petition would have direct impact on the proceedings before the CESTAT, New Delhi. 16. It is contended that the petitioner, by alleging violation of the principle of natural justice, has sought to invoke the jurisdiction of this court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, whereas in fact, there is no violation of principle of natural justice as canvassed by the petitioner. Reference is made to the various observations made by the competent authority i.e. respondent No.2 in the impugned findings dated 20.03.2026 as well as the disclosure statement dated 12.03.2026. C/SCA/8794/2026 17. It CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 is contended that the respondents have only questioned the determination of the antidumping duty and the injury margin by alleging that the same is not appropriately arrived at looking to the domestic sales of the industry and volume of dumped imports. It is submitted that all these aspects can be considered by the appellate authorities and it is argued that this Court may not examine the magnitude of the injury margin, as determined by respondent No.2, after the same is determined by appreciating the submissions advanced by the all the stakeholders, including the petitioner and the respondents. ANALYSIS AND OPINION : 18. The issue, which falls for deliberation, is that whether in the facts the case, the be relegated to avail the remedy of filing an Section 9C the Act for impugned final petitioner can alternative efficacious appeal, under challenging the of of findings dated 20.03.2026, as well as the Notification No.11/ 2026 dated 19.06.2024 issued by respondent No.2 or not. 19. The provisions of Customs 9C of the Act reads as under :Page 10 of 21 C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 “9C. Appeal.— 1[(1) An appeal against the order of determination or review thereof shall lie to the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal constituted under section 129 of the Customs Act, 1962 (52 of 1962) (hereinafter referred to as the Appellate Tribunal), in respect of the existence, degree and effect of— (i) any subsidy or dumping in relation to import of any article; or (ii) import of any article into India in such increased quantities and under such condition so as to cause or threatening to cause serious injury to domestic industry requiring imposition of safeguard duty in relation to import of that article.] [(1A) An appeal under sub-section (1) shall be accompanied by a fee of fifteen thousand rupees. (1B) Every application made before the Appellate Tribunal,— (a) in an appeal under sub-section (1), for grant of stay or for rectification of mistake or for any other purpose; or (b) for restoration of an appeal or an application, shall be accompanied by a fee of five hundred rupees.] (2) Every appeal under this section shall be filed within ninety days of the date of order under appeal: Provided that the Appellate Tribunal may entertain any appeal after the expiry of the said period of ninety days, if it is satisfied that the appellant was prevented by sufficient cause from filing the appeal in time. (3) The Appellate Tribunal may, after giving the parties to the appeal, an opportunity of being heard, pass such orders thereon as it thinks fit, confirming, modifying or annulling the order appealed against. (4) The provisions of sub-sections (1), (2), (5) and (6) of section 129C of the Customs Act, 1962 C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 (52 of 1962) shall apply to the Appellate Tribunal in the discharge of its functions under this Act as they apply to it in the discharge of its functions under the Customs Act, 1962 (52 of 1962). (5) Every appeal under sub-section (1) shall be heard by a Special Bench constituted by the President of the Appellate Tribunal for hearing such appeals and such Bench shall consist of the President and not less than two members and shall include one judicial member and one technical member.]” 20. Thus, it is not in dispute that the petitioner is having an alternative efficacious remedy of impugned Excise filing final and an appeal, findings Service challenging before Tax the the Customs, Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT). Upon examination of the provision of Section 9C of the Act, it is manifest that there is nothing examining that the prevents legality and the CESTAT validity from of the disclosure statement and final findings and the Notification issued under Section 9A of the Act. However, we are settled legal also conscious precedent that the of the well- extraordinary powers of High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution cannot even alternative if an be eclipsed or efficacious available to the parties. restricted remedy is C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 21. The law in this regard is well-settled in the case of Whirlpool Corporation vs. Registrar of Trade Marks, Mumbai and Ors., (1998) 8 S.C.C. 1, and thereafter followed in series of the judgements. 22. Thus, it is a settled legal precedent that if there is gross violation of principles of natural justice governing or violation the jurisdiction, of statutory process of law, the High Court, provisions or while lack of exercising its extraordinary powers conferred under Article of the 226 Constitution can always interfere with such action even if there exists an alternative efficacious remedy. 23. The petitioner has emphasized on the blatant violation of principles of natural justice, by alleging that the mandatory disclosure under Rule 16 of the the Anti-Dumping Rules read with Rules 6, 7, 11 and 17 of the Anti-Dumping Rules are violated. margin It is also determined mathematically alleged by that respondent impossible, and the injury no.2 is respondent no.2 fell in error in determining the injury margin since there is inconsistency in comparing the landed value of imports and Non-Injurious Price C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 (NIP). The petitioner has attempted to build its case by comparing the erroneous export price and landed value, which is contrary to Rule 11 of the Anti-Dumping Rules. It is contended that the NIP remains constant across all exporting countries or is determined domestic enquiry, on a uniform lower basis landed for value the must invariably result in a higher injury margin and conversely, a higher landed value must result in a lower injury margin. It is alleged that the valuation adopted by respondent No.2 and the duty recommended in the statement of impugned findings are inconsistent since the country of lower value, landed value, has been recommended a lower duty, whereas a country with higher landed value has been recommended higher duty, when lower injury arithmetically it must have margin. it is alleged Thus, a that there is fundamental error, in the computation of landed value, or in the computation of NIP, or in the determination of injury margin, or in the application of lesser duty, which goes to the root of the determination. 24. Thus, the case of the petitioner is premised on the recommendation made in final findings, C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 determined on an incorrect or faulty determination. 25. As far as the allegations about adopting an erroneous and a flawed methodology is concerned, this Court cannot venture into the determination or the valuation, adopted by respondent No.2, in the anti-dumping investigation concerning imports of sulfenamides accelerators. The disclosure statement, which is produced on record, reveals that respondent No.2 has aspects considered all the submissions of all the the opposing No.38, in fact extensively, along with the stakeholders, including interested parties. In paragraph taking of the arguments while care advanced by the interested parties relating nonsharing of the import data, it is recorded that “the applicant submitted that intelligence to before the it relied has compute the authority, upon total has market volume and value of imports from all countries and the same has been made available to other interested parties”. So far as the transaction-wise data is concerned, which is procured by the authority, is confidential Government in of nature India. and The is not shared same has not by been C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 disclosed to any interested party, including the domestic industry. The authority has shared the information of volume and price of imports which is relevant under information the collected Anti-Dumping Rules, from Directorate the the General of Commercial Intelligence and Statistics (DGCI&S). It is further recorded that the interested parties have been provided enough of opportunity to defend information relevant their to the interest on the investigation and determination. 26. While referring to Rule 6 (7) and Rule 7 of the Anti-Dumping Rules, it is also recorded in paragraph No.39 available the that the authority non-confidential has version of made the information provided by various parties to all other interested parties as per Rule 6(7) of the Anti-Dumping Rules. 27. In paragraph No.40 of the disclosure statement, the authority has taken care about the submissions made by the domestic industry and the participating exporters confidentiality, production, sales on capacity, volumes, market concerning information capacity share, such as utilization, stocks, selling C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 price etc. It is further recorded that wherever information is for injury period, the same has been provided on an indexed basis. The authority has also sensitive maintained the information, as business-related confidential. After sharing all the data, as required under the AntiDumping Rules, respondent No.2 has determined the normal value, export price and dumping margin for the subject Rules, more countries as per the Anti-Dumping particularly Rule 9A(1)(c) of the Anti-Dumping Rules. 28. The normal value and export prices for the petitioner is also determined, as mentioned in paragraph No.52 to 61. 29. In paragraph No.63, the dumping margin has been determined, which has been doubted by the present petitioner. The designated authority while assessment of injury and causal link in paragraph has recorded the submissions of interested parties, and has accordingly recorded its findings. The determination of dumping margin on the extensive scrutiny of data has been shared among the interested parties. The High Court in a writ petition, incognita cannot venture into terra by doubting the methodology/valuation, C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 since the same falls within the domain of the designated subject. authority The who analysis is an expert or scrutiny in the on the confidential information is impermissible by the High Court, in wake of the fact interested parties have maintained the confidentiality. The aspect No.2 of the procedure adopted and the magnitude of injury margin, as paragraph No.119 cannot be determined below by respondent delved and examined by this Court, by High Court, while exercising its extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and the appropriate authority would be the Tribunal. 30. We shall now deal with the alleged breach of Rules 6, 7, 11 and 17 of the Anti-dumping Rules. Rule regulates investigation. the The violation of prescribes that, principles petitioner sub-rule (6) of “the designated governing has Rule alleged 6, which authority may allow an interested party or its representative to present the information relevant to the investigation orally, but such oral information shall be designated taken into authority.” consideration by the On of the scrutiny C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 disclosure statement, we find that the provisions of neither Rules 6(6), 7, 11 nor Rule 17 have been violated. The interested parties, including the petitioner, have been given sufficient opportunity of hearing. The disclosure statement mentions that all the relevant data and information have been shared with the interested parties, and if it is the case of the petitioner that the necessary information has not been shared, the same can be examined by the Tribunal, since we do not find that the petitioner has been exclusively denied the information. Similarly, we also do not find that there is any violation of Rule 7 relating to confidential information, as the designated confidentiality authority and has has maintained full maintained the confidentiality of the information on the request of the interested parties and has followed the provisions of Rule 7. Likewise, as regards Rule 11, which mentions the determination of injury, and Rule 17, which stipulates the limitation and recommendation of amount of duty after recording the reasons leading to conclusion are concerned, we find that the petitioner is questioning the methodology/ valuation adopted by respondent No.2, in determining the injury which cannot be C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 scrutinized by this Court unless it is in gross violation of Rules or principles of natural justice. 31. In case the petitioner is deprived of some information, it is always open to the petitioner to point out the same before the fact-finding authority i.e. the Tribunal. The Court cannot, in the writ petition, delve into such aspects. 32. There is an additional ground which prevents us from interfering with the Final Findings and the Notification, application impugned i.e. the the CESTAT, Findings dated before Final pendency of an Delhi. The 20.03.2026 are New challenged by the Automotive Tyre Manufacturers Association by filing an application being Diary No. 51523/2026 before the CESTAT. The petitioner can adopt the same course. 33. Thus, we are not inclined to interfere with the impugned final findings recorded by respondent No.2 and the Notification in exercise of our extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, particularly in the absence of any gross violation of the principles of natural justice, any violation of C/SCA/8794/2026 CAV JUDGMENT DATED: 07/07/2026 the statutory provisions governing the process of law, or any lack of jurisdiction. Hence, the writ petition fails and the same is dismissed. The petitioner may avail of the remedy of filing an appeal impugned before the findings CESTAT, as well challenging as the the impugned Notification. Sd/. (A.S.SUPEHIA, J) Sd/. (VAIBHAVI D. NANAVATI,J) Bhavesh-[PPS]* - Mahesh-[PS]* *** Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Gujarat HC judgments →